Integrated Project Final Report - Group 11
Integrated Project Final Report - Group 11
Group Project By
GROUP 11
HARIKA BESTHA RAMANABOYENA 13018160
JOHN MATHEW CYRIL JAMES 13889928
RAJASEKARNA
SAITEJA GOLI 14176511
RANJITH RAJENDRAN JOTHILAKSHMI 13926740
1
APPENDIX
1.1 Introduction 3
1.2 Site location 4
1.3 Project Dimensions 5
2.1 Environmental Impact 5
2.2 UXO Report 7
2.3 SWOT ANALYSIS 8
3 EVALUATION OF METHODS 11
3.1 FULL REFURBISHMENT - NHS 11
3.2 PESTEL ANALYSIS FOR NHS 12
3.3 FLOOR PLANS FOR NHS 14
3.4 PARTIAL DEMOLITION AND REFURBISHMENT - 17
STUDENT
ACCOMIDATION
3.5 PESTEL ANALYSIS FOR STUDENT ACCOMIDATION 17
3.6 FLOOR PLANS FOR STUDENT ACCOMIDATION 19
3.7 FULL DEMOLITION – CAR SHOWROOM 21
3.8 PESTEL ANALYSIS FOR CAR SHOWROOM 21
3.9 FLOOR PLANS FOR CAR SHOW ROOM 22
4 BCIS CALCULATIONS 24
4.1 OPTION 1 – NHS 24
4.2 OPTION 2 – STUDENT ACCOMIDATION 26
4.3 OPTION 3 – CAR SHOW ROOM 30
4.4 REVENUE GENERATION FOR THREE OPTIONS 31
5 CONCLUSION 33
2
1.1 INTRODUCTION
The team created numerous development proposals and trimmed them to three specific
recommendations for developing the site. This concept will be carefully and selectively
assessed for quality and cost-effectiveness using SWOT and PESTLE analysis, as well as
providing a client-beneficial cost and revenue analysis. The recommendations of team
members include the entire demolition of the existing structure and the construction of a new,
modern building, the partial demolition and remodeling of the building, and securing the
existing structure with simple refurbishment.
3
1.2 SITE LOCATION
IKEA is located in the city Centre of Coventry's Post Town. The building is situated
in city Centre, Coventry on a street that runs north to south. Many shops, restaurants, theatres,
parks and businesses are located on a street with convenient access to public transportation at
this location. Since the 2007, when the constructionof commercial buildings in city Centre, the
value of real estate in that region has growndramatically. The neighboring train station is about
12 minutes away on foot from cityCentre, adding to the building's advantage.
Site Corporation Street is situated in Coventry's Post Town, the city's Centre. The
structure is located on a north-south roadway in Coventry's city Centre. There are a lot of
stores, theatres, parks, eateries, and other enterprises situated on a street here that has easy
access to public transportation. The value of real estate in that area has increased significantly
since the 2007s, when work on commercial buildings on Corporation Street started. One
other benefit of the building is that it is only a 12- minute walk from Corporation Street to the
nearby train station.
4
(figure 2 : Site Live Image)
The building is located at the coordinates, 52.4073 °N, 1.5167 °W, at 2 Croft Road,
Coventry (CV1 3AZ). The building located on Corporation Street in Coventry was originally
constructed as an IKEA store. However, in the summer of 2020, IKEA made the
unprecedented decision to close this particular city centre store. Subsequently, they sold the
property to a third-party buyer, marking the first instance of a major IKEA branch closure in
the UK.
5
➢ Profitability is impacted by subpar material accounting. Low profitability is
the result of material theft caused by improper material storage on the job site.
Materials stored improperly on the site might cause damage or destruction,
which lowers profitability.
➢ Some studies claim that up to 50% of climate change is caused by
construction. It also affects air, water, and noise pollution, as well as landfills.
6
2.2 UXO REPORT
7
2.3 SWOT ANALYSIS
One kind of diagnostic tool used to find strategic planning early in a project is the
SWOT analysis. Both internal and external components of this study are utilized to
emphasize the opportunities and threats in the external dimension, as well as the strengths
and weaknesses in the interior dimension (internal positive and internal negative). In order to
streamline the building and investment processes, this analysis will help with risk assessment
as well as strengths and weaknesses analysis. (Zima, Krzysztof, 2020)
• It is a straightforward tool that can be • Due to the fact that the technique utilizes
used by any individual or group to individual data, it is regarded as a
identify and evaluate static choices. subjective study.
8
Figure 4 – Define of SWOT (source from google)
1 Restaurant 1 Option 1
2 Supermarket 2 Option 2
Co-working spaces/
Offices
3 3 Option 3
Student
4 accommodation 4 Option 4
7 NHS 7 Option 7
8 Gym 8 Option 8
9
By conducting a thorough examination of each alternative, the team
has settled on the most suitable concepts to implement in the existing structure. The
following table illustrates the advantages and disadvantages of adapting these strategies
to building
10
impression on Because of marketing
the customer and Environment price
ultimately drive impact
sales for surrounded
the brand area
Table 3: SWOT Analysis for selected options
3. EVALUATION OF METHODS:
Full Refurbishment refers that, the building is to make better, shine, or restore
anything to its former state. It a property is the process of making the suitable for occupants
once more. Now in full refurbishment, the structure selected as NHS, because the structure is
in good condition & surrounded by all facilities for medical emergency.
11
3.2 PESTEL ANALYSIS for FULL REFURBISHMENT
Political Factors
➢ The rising disparity between the demands on the NHS and its resources is
largely due to the care backlog. Funding for the NHS is not a theoretical or
abstract subject. Insufficient resources will have an impact on both quality and
accessibility.
Social Factors
12
Technical Factors
The total construction of five floors, the total build-up area is 28,230 sqm. The
Ground floor-area 916 sqm is OP, first floor-area 783 sqms, second floor-area is 8103 sqm,
third floor-area is 2137 sqm, fourth floor-area 22672 sqm, fifth floor-area 6775 sqm & sixth
floor-area 6986 sqm, Roof is 263 sqm. Each floor may have a different number of rooms
regarding to facilities in NHS. These floors are accessible via stairs, elevators based on the
patient conditions. Based up on the area the plans are executed.
Economical Factors
In 2022-2023, the UK's central government will have spent approximately £180 billion
on health care (including through the use of devolved administrations and central government
departments). This is equivalent to around 10% of your taxes, or the entire GDP (Gross
Domestic Product).
Legal Factors
➢ Patients (or family members) who are dissatisfied with the caliber of their care,
however, are turning to the legal system more often than not to get revenge.
➢ The UK has seen an increase in the care related lawsuits, and this pattern of increasing
numbers of lawsuits is nothing new to the NHS. The healthcare organization will
regrettably have to incur additional, significant costs as a result of having to finance
pricey legal defenses and settlement payments.
➢ It can be simpler for the body to deliver high quality health as a result of technological
advancements But if the NHS is to live up to rising expectations, it appears that it will
require a lot more funding.
13
Floor Plans for NHS
14
Second, Third and Fourth Floor plan
15
Fifth floor plan
16
3.4 PARTIAL DEMOLITION – STUDENT ACCOMIDATION
Socio-Political
➢ It will retain the structural performance and increases the usability of building
effectively.
➢ The existing building considering electrical and fire safety defaults and installation of
necessary safety services as well as to assure compliance with safety laws.
➢ Providing free Wi-Fi facilities over the entire accommodation
➢ It will be carried out to enhance a building's aesthetics, such as by modernizing the
exterior facade and interior decor.
➢ The accommodation best suites in place for the students
17
Economical Factors
➢ The investment costs depend on the capital required for the project refurbishment.
The income generated through the student accommodation will be future proof as
Coventry University is in high demand of students for its education.
➢ Using Lean project management will help to complete tasks more quickly when you
streamline personnel and procedures. Has ability to finish the project more quickly and
move on to the next one results in better productivity and allows to take on more jobs
with high return!
➢ Nonetheless, since 2007, there have been 102,000 more students residing in private
residence halls than there were in 2007. During the financial crisis, investors have
consistently poured money into this sector, even while other investment categories
have slowed down. Private sector investment is expected to have increased from £350
million in 2009 to £2.1 billion in 2013.
Technical factors
➢ The first-floor area 4050 sqm, second-floor area 3860 sqm, and third-floor area 4990
sqm, remaining left floors 4th,5th &6th floors are in demolishing stage. Each floor may
have a different number of rooms. These floors are accessible via stairs, elevators or a
combination of both.
➢ The student accommodation typically comprises of Standard, En-suite and studio
rooms. Different categorized rooms are standard rooms, En-suite rooms and studio
rooms. It also offers amenities such as laundry facilities, study lounges, or fitness
rooms to provide a comfortable and convenient livingenvironment for students.
➢ The ground floor of the building consists of car parking, common lounge and staff
working room.
➢ To optimize energy consumption or functioning ventilation, heating systems, air
conditioning, electrical, or other mechanical components will be installed.
➢ The project sustainable design ideas will be taken into consideration like recycling of
materials, utilizing natural light, and placing in renewable energy sources.
18
Legal Factors
The belief in personal importance, individual variations such as age and socioeconomic position, a
range of cognitive biases, an increase in commitment and sunk results, and prior experiences are all
significant determinants
19
First and Second Floor plan
20
3.5 Full Demolition – Car Showroom
➢ People from emerging and stable economic zones are getting richer every day.
As a result, their purchasing power is also increasing. It explains why there is
a growing need for automobiles.
➢ Communities' customs and cultures have an impact on the auto business as
well. For instance, the number of car owners may be lower
21
in nations with well-connected bus systems. Developed nations also tend to
have one or more cars in their possession.
➢ There is more rivalry for customers' business and more options available in an
area with many dealerships, so that's where they will search further. Dealers and
customers benefit from it.
➢ It has been demonstrated that removing vehicles from city centres, or at least
restricting their access, makes urban areas safe places for cycling and walking
while drastically lowering air and noise pollution, which has raised concerns
about the climate catastrophe.
➢ You also feel more independent because you don't need to rely on anyone else
to go about. In addition, they are typically more comfortable than public
transportation. The temperature is under your control, amongother things.
TECHNICAL FACTORS
The construction is total of new & designed as total construction area is 14,400 sqm,
from the ground floor to floor the total area is in Typical floor. The rooms are category to
staff rooms – service manager, technical support, non- technical support team, reception,
conference room, Lounge, Car display, canteen, Toilets, car wash, parts shop, car handover.
22
First floor Plan
23
BCIS CALCULATION
4.1 Option 1 : Full Refurbishment (NHS)
24
( Average Price Analysis for NHS Source - Own - BCIS website )
History Calculation :
Title : Internal floor area for the building cost including prelims
Date : Apr-2016
BuildingCost:
£75326983
Cost/m2 : 3283
TPI : 376
LI: 129
25
By considering all other required value from the above figures , we are about tocalculate the
adjusted cost.
= £ 2626
= 2626 * 28230
= £ 74,31,980
Hence the final Budget for the full refurbishment of this project NHS is £ 74,131,980
(StudentAccommodation)
26
27
(Graphical Analysis for Student accommodation Source : Own – BCIS Website )
History Calculation :
Location :
Date : 17-may-2019
Cost/m2 : 3283
TPI : 376
LI: 129
By considering all other required value from the above figures , we are about tocalculate the
adjusted cost.
28
Adjusted Cost = 2329* (388*100) / (356*92 )
= £ 2759
= 2759 * 12900
= £ 3,55,91,100
Hence the final Budget for the Partial demolition and refurbishment of this projectstudent
accommodation is £ 35,591,100
31
( Average Price analysis Source – own – BCIS website )
History Calculation :
creative arts
Dealership
Cost/m2 : 801
TPI : 292
32
LI: 98
By considering all other required value from the above figures , we are about tocalculate the
adjusted cost.
= £ 1086
= £ 10,42,56,00
Hence the final Budget for the full demolition of this project Car showroom is
£ 10,425,600
33
STUDENT ACCOMIDATION – Partial ➢ It usually discover a greater yield
Demolition percentage and a longer period of
time with student housing.
Developers frequently promise 8–
10% NET returns for a maximum of
5 years; Higher yields. Rent for
students is usually substantially
higher than for other renters, and
they have greater access to the
property. Year-over-year yields for
well-managed shared studenthousing
can reach 20%. Possibility of future
price growth, particularly if it is sold
as a going concern.
➢ Aim for a profit of at least 10% after
all costs and taxes, while the precise
number may depend on your
circumstances. 10% is a decent goal,
but depending on theproperty and the
rental market, you could be able to
make more.
➢ Investing in student property in the
UK in 2023 offers several
compelling advantages. A resilient
and growing market, consistentrental
income, higher rental yields,
potential for capital appreciation, tax
benefits, and portfolio diversification
make it an attractive option for
investors
34
lucrative auto dealership groups as
listed in the auto Dealer Top 100, the
company's average revenue for the
first half of 2022 was 8.9% from
new car sales and8.1% from used car
sales. These percentages are more
representative of the industry as a
whole.
5 CONCLUSION
➢ Based on the BCIS & survey regarding the project location.
➢ Our Group members/ my Team selected the option 2 "PARTIAL DEMOLISION - STUDENT
ACCOMIDATION"
➢ Very near location to university & have so many feasibility options for the students
➢ f based on the construction, the materials are recycled and used in construction
➢ Risk management & waste management both are balanced to supported the growth of building
➢ As a general rule of thumb, client should strive for at least 60% profit after all costs and taxes,
though the exact number will depend on your particular circumstances. Although 40% is a
reasonable goal, the property and the rental market may allow you to earn more.
➢ Unprecedented Demand for Student Housing: 1,489,110 students nationwide are in need of student
housing at this time.
➢ Student have the chance to grow more independent, particularly if they decide to move away from
home to pursue their studies. Common experiences include living away from home, handling their
own finances, and striking a balance between school and student accommodation
➢ Reduce of using public or private transportation for attending classes, so automatically the student
finance is safe
➢ The steady rental revenue provided by student housing is one of the key benefits of investing in it.
Since most student leases are signed for the duration of the academic year, landlords may be sure
they will get a consistent revenue for the term of the lease.
➢ As per the findings of a report published by Knight Frank, the average occupancy rate of purpose-
built student accommodation in the UK during the 2021-2022 academic year was 92%. This
indicates the stability of rental income and suggests that the UK student market is valued at
approximately £72 billion.
35
REFERENCES
1. Health funding data analysis. (n.d.). The British Medical Association Is the Trade
Union and Professional Body for Doctors in the UK. Retrieved November 26,
2023, from https://www.bma.org.uk/advice-and-support/nhs- delivery-and-
workforce/funding/health-funding-data-analysis
2. Arrowsmith, D. (n.d.). COVENTRY URBAN DESIGN GUIDANCE. Gov.uk.
Retrieved November 26, 2023, from
https://www.coventry.gov.uk/downloads/file/19150/coventry_urban_design_
guidance
3. Health funding data analysis. (n.d.). The British Medical Association Is the Trade
Union and Professional Body for Doctors in the UK. Retrieved November 26,
2023, from https://www.bma.org.uk/advice-and-support/nhs- delivery-and-
workforce/funding/health-funding-data-analysis
4. Ishak, N., Ibrahim, F. A., & Azizan, M. A. (2018). Analysis of factors influencing
building refurbishment project performance. E3S Web of Conferences, 34, 01013.
https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/20183401013
5. premjit. (2022, May 2). 4 steps for refurbishment & building renovation. Civilera.
https://www.civilera.com/post/4-steps-for-refurbishment-building- renovation
6. (N.d.). Cipd.co.uk. Retrieved November 26, 2023, from
https://www.cipd.co.uk/knowledge/strategy/organisational- development/pestle-
analysis
7. Six reasons to consider investing in student property in the UK in 2023. (2023,
June 9). Linkedin.com. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/six-reasons- consider-
investing-student-property-uk-2023-elavace/
36
8. Sustainable Refurbishment of Heritage Buildings, How BREEAM helps to deliver
(2014)- Kiruthiga Balson, Gavin Summerson and Andrew Thorne
9. Analysis of Factors Influencing Building Refurbishment Project Performance(2018)
Nurfadzillah Ishak1,* , Fazdliel Aswad Ibrahim2 , and Muhammad Azizi Azizan
https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/20183401013
10. D'Onofrio, L. (2019). Planning Committee Report.
11. Lowe, D. (2003). Economic Challenges of Sustainable Construction. The
Manchester Centre for Civil and Construction Engineering.
12. NHS total operating income in the UK 2019/20-2020/21. (n.d.). Statista. Retrieved
November 27, 2023, from
https://www.statista.com/statistics/1270007/nhs-total-operating-income-uk/
13. Buildings insurance. (n.d.). Directline.com. Retrieved November 27, 2023, from
https://www.directline.com/home-cover/buildings-
insurance?cmpid=43700076010356435/home/ppc/GOOGLE/building+insu
rance+calculator/kwd-
15923736/1006656/c/HOM_GEN_ALLON_LG_PPC+_Google+-
+Building+Insurance+-
+Core&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIyMnAypHkggMVv1tBAh3MBwyIEAAYASAAE
gLD4vD_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds
14. Bai, N., Wang, L., Wang, Q., Deng, J., Wang, Y., Lu, P., Huang, J., Li, G.,
Zhang, Y., Yang, J.and Xie, K., 2020. Graded intrafillable architecture- based
iontronic pressure sensor with ultra-broad-range high
sensitivity. Nature communications, 11(1), p.209. Retrived from:
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-019-14054-9 [Retrived on : 15
.11.23]
15. Banham, R. (2022). Architecture of the Well-tempered Environment. University
of Chicago Press . Retrieved from :https://books.google .com/
books?hl=en&lr=&id=g7R9EAAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PA
5&dq=architectural+and+structural+design&ots=DonMsCeNhm&
amp;sig=0UA6FrkM2TnV4v8ZemOREpS3XLg [Retrieved on:15/11/23]
16. Bonanomi, M. M., Hall, D. M., Staub-French, S., Tucker, A., & Talamo,
C. M. L. (2020). The impact of digital transformation on formal and informalorganizational
structures of large architecture and engineering
firms. Engineering, Construction and Architectura Management, 27(4),872-
892.
Retrived from https://re.public.polimi.it/bitstream/11311/1127697/4/11311-
1127697_Talamo.pdf
37
[Retrived on : 15 .11.23]
17. Caetano, I., Santos, L., & Leitão, A. (2020). Computational design in
architecture: Defining parametric, generative, and algorithmic
design. Frontiers of Architectural Research, 9(2), 287-300. Retrived from:
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2095263520300029 [Retrived on :
15.11.23]
18. Chaudhari, B. S., Zennaro, M., & Borkar, S. (2020). LPWAN
technologies: Emerging application characteristics, requirements, and design
considerations. Future Internet, 12(3), 46. Retrieved from:
https://www.mdpi.com/1999-5903/12/3/46 [Retrieved on:15/11/23]
19. Zhang, X., Ju, Z., Zhu, Y., Takeuchi, K. J., Takeuchi, E. S., Marschilok, A. C.,
& Yu, G. (2021). Multiscale understanding and architecture design of high
energy/power lithium‐ion battery electrodes. Advanced Energy Materials, 11(2),
2000808. Retrived from: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/am-
pdf/10.1002/aenm.202000808 [Retrived on: 15.11.23]
20. Wu, Y. N., Emer, J. S., & Sze, V. (2019, November). Accelergy: An architecture-
level energy estimation methodology for accelerator designs. In 2019 IEEE/ACM
International Conference on Computer-Aided Design (ICCAD) (pp. 1- 8). IEEE. Retrived
from: https://dspace.mit.edu/bitstream/handle/1721.1/122044/2019_iccad_accelergy_ilp
.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y [Retrived on : 15 .11.23]
38