ERJSH Volume 52 Issue 3 Pages 164-171
ERJSH Volume 52 Issue 3 Pages 164-171
Abstract: Blade slots are known to reduce the noise and improve flow behavior and steadiness in centrifugal fans. The present work
considers an unsteady Computational Fluid Dynamic (CFD) study to investigate the effectiveness of slot location and width on the
performance and flow field inside the centrifugal fan blade passages. The computer program, Fluent 19, is used and the 3D fan model
is validated by comparing its results with those of earlier researchers. The aim of the present study is to find the best slot location and
appropriate slot width at that location. The flow pattern is then analyzed and simulated with no slot and with a slot at six different
radial locations; namely S1, S2, S3, S4, S5, and S6 with fixed slot width W of 2.5 mm. The computationally generated characteristics
of unsteady flow demonstrated that although cut slots at all locations on the fan blade from the hub to the shroud has a negative
influence on the centrifugal fan efficiency as well as the static pressure rise compared with the fan without slot, the slots added at S3
i.e. near the midpoint of the blade span gives the highest fan efficiency and largest increase in static pressure. Slots at S3 suppress
secondary flow at the blade passages and push it to the blade tip. Additionally, streamlines and velocity distributions in impeller
passages and over the blade surfaces (pressure and suction sides) validated the slots' benefits. Computations width different slot
width; namely 1.5 mm, 3.5 mm, and 5 mm are carried out to find the best slot location and width at the best slot location S3. At the
optimal efficiency point, the calculated performance of the employed fan with slot location S3 and 2.5 mm width, showed a 2.7 %
increase of efficiency and 1.5% increase in static pressure rise as compared to fans with slot at S1 with same width of 2.5 mm.
However, it showed a positive impact on the boundary layer buildup and flow separation over the blade suction side for the impeller
studied .
Keywords: Suction Slots, Secondary flow, Centrifugal Fan Performance, CFD, Simulation.
NOMENCLATURE
Symbols Description SI units Symbols Description
u Fluctuated velocity m/s Abbreviations
Time averaged velocity m/s BEP Best Efficiency Point
Ui
Cm Moment Coefficient - CFD Computational Fluid
Dynamics
Ds Slot pitch Diameter mm MRF Moving Reference Frame
2 2
k Turbulent kinetic energy m /s SST Shear Stress Transport
Greek SIMPLE Semi-Implicit Method for
Pressure Linked Equations
3
Instantaneous value of density kg/m
2 3
ɛ Turbulent energy dissipation rate m /s
-1
ω Rotational Speed S
ᴓ Flow coefficient = Q/ωD³ -
η Static Efficiency -
ᴪ pressure coefficient = ΔP/ρω²D² -
the blade tip and the fluid particles in the boundary layer
1. Introduction experience a negative velocity and the flow may be
In centrifugal fans, the recirculation zones occurring reversed. At the point of the separation one streamline
between the blade passages contribute to some losses. The intersects the wall at a definite angle as shown in Fig. 1, and
moving fluid with low velocity in the boundary layer the point of separation itself is determined by the condition
doesnot remain in the thin layer which sticks to the that the velocity gradient normal to the blade surface
impeller’s blade surfaces. The boundary layer will increase vanishes there.
its thickness substantially within the downstream path near
164
Engineering Research Journal (ERJ) S. A. Beskales et al Vol.52, No1 January 2023, pp:164-171
2. COMPUTAIONAL TECHNIQUE
2.1 Governing Equations
Researchers utilize CFD to collect information on fluid
flow issues and flow parameters such as pressure, velocity
in situations when experimental procedures cannot be
conducted. This can be achieved by solving the
fundamental equations such as conservation of mass and
Fig 1. Flow in boundary layer near separation [1]
momentum for incompressible turbulent flow [1]
This study's objective is to enhance the flow on the U i 0 (1)
suction side of the blade’s impeller by decreasing the size t x
i
of the recirculation zones. This can be done by cutting slot
in the blades of the impeller to control the flow passively in
order to delay flow separations. slot will move the flow (2)
from the pressure side of the blade to the suction side, they
are installed near the point of separation to control the
development of the boundary layer over the blade surface. 2.2 Shear Stress Transport (SST) K- ω Model
Many researchers have utilized CFD to investigate In the present study, the Shear Stress Transport (SST) k- ω
centrifugal fan performance. [2] studied numerically the model is implemented. The k- ω model consists of two
effect of the operating condition, such as the impeller speed, equations. The Wilcox k- ω model [12] is more stable than
on the centrifugal fan performance and flow characteristics. the k- ε model in the viscous sublayer close to the wall and
[3] analyzed both transient simulations and steady moving is one of the most well-known forms of k- ω. However, its
reference frame (MRF) simulations. [4] studied the effect of results are particularly sensitive to the free stream value of
blade angles on the velocity and pressure distribution inside ω in the free shear layer and adverse pressure gradient
the impeller passages using the CFD techniques. boundary layer flows. Consequently, the k- ε model is not
Furthermore, detailed information on the flow field through the most appropriate model for wake area applications. In
the fan may be collected, providing guidance for fan the wake areas, however, the k- ε model performs better,
impeller modification by cutting slots in the impeller according to Menter [13], the combination of the two
blades. [5] investigated the effect of a cut slot in the blower models is the optimum way to model the flow
blades, the results showed The magnitude of pressure characteristics along the wall and in the boundary layer's
variations decreases when slots are added to the impeller wake. Accordingly, the SST k-ω turbulence is believed to
blades and the fluid poured through the slots into the be the best acceptable model for predicting the flow
impeller passages re-energizes the separated flow. [6] characteristics. The first equation in the model defines the
Studied the effect of constant-diameter slots in a turbulent kinetic energy (k), while the second describes the
perpendicular direction to the blade surface on radial fan turbulent dissipation rate (ω).
impeller. The results revealed that the slots enhanced the
internal efficiency and overall pressure of the fan impeller
without volute casing. [7] analyzed unsteady numerical (3)
simulations the slot cuts near the impeller shroud and the
results showed that both the performance and flow field are
well improved by applying the blade surface slots with 3.6
% for the total pressure and of 2.6 % for the efficiency at (4)
the design mass flow rate. Single and twin slot
configuration were investigated by [8] at different locations 3. CFD PROGRAM VALIDATION
on the chord length from the blade root. The results showed 3.1 Geometric Model
that the optimum single slot size is 5 mm with 5.5 %
increase in the static pressure while the twin slot located at The aim of this section is to verify the reliability of the CFD
50% and 75% from the blade root with 3 mm slot size model such that it can be used with confidence for
enhance the static pressure by 7% compared with the base numerical simulation and decision making in the design and
blade model. [9] studied the effect of the slot on an airfoil, the modification of centrifugal impeller blades with
results confirmed the slot benefits in reducing the boundary different slot locations and widths. The predictions of the
layer separation and stall control over different incident utilized computer software, FLUENT 19, are validated and
angles. [10] used a passive control using an opening in the compared to the results produced by Schönwald et al. [14]
airfoil thougth which the flow passed and converted the using HP workstation (Intel Xeon E5-2680 V3 -2.5 GHz
spearation region into small vorticies. [11] used a slotted and 128 GRAM). The modeled centrifugal fan in the
blade on a centrifugal pump, which improved hydraulic present validation is with ten backward impeller blades. The
performance. whole fan’s design specifications and settings are provided
in Table 1 and Fig. 2.
165
Engineering Research Journal (ERJ) S. A. Beskales et al Vol.52, No1 January 2023, pp:164-171
TABLE 1 The design parameters for the centrifugal fan.[14] in greater numerical model stability [15]. Figure 4 shows
Item Dimension the mesh used for inlet pipe (A) , impeller (B) and volute
Angle of cover plate 11 ° casing(C) using polyhedral elements.The leakage flow
Blade inlet angle 31 ° through the clearance between the impeller and inlet pipe
Blade outlet angle 41 ° (fig 4. D) has a great impact on the performance of the
Curvature of the cover plate 45 mm centrifugal fan. consequently, in the present validation, the
Curvature of the inlet nozzle 45 mm
Clearance 3 mm
gap dimensions mentioned in Table.1 is considered in
Clearance width 13 mm present CFD simulations.
Casing width 315 mm
Curvature of the blade 383 mm
Blade number 10
Diameter of the inlet duct 400 mm
Diameter of impeller outlet 722 mm
Diameter of impeller inlet 318 mm
Blade inlet width 33 mm
Blade outlet width 93 mm
166
Engineering Research Journal (ERJ) S. A. Beskales et al Vol.52, No1 January 2023, pp:164-171
convergence histories of other solution variables like field across the critical areas of the centrifugal fan, it is
pressure outlet, pressure inlet and coefficient of moment necessary to construct the smallest elements around the
(Cm) are also monitored to decide whether a reasonable blades, such as the leading and trailing edges, etc. In this
solution is reached or not. unsteady graphs are divided into section a mesh convergence test is carried out to assure that
three convergence stages; each stage represents a complete the CFD validation results is in a good agreement with the
revolution of the impeller. Stage 1 shows the transition experimental results by Schönwald et al. [14]. In the present
from the steady to the unsteady calculations represented in work, we used six different points starting from the coarse
dramatically change in the output value followed by some mesh (point 1) to the fine mesh (point 6). Figure 6 shows
fluctuation to flow time at 0.04 seconds. Prior to the second the effect of the number of cells on the Static pressure rise
stage, the flow statistic is initialized and calculations are between the inlet and outlet of the fan (fig.6 A) and
done for the second impeller revolution to time 0.08 impeller torque (fig.6 B) for one of the cases of the
seconds. The final stage from 0.08 to 0.12 is carried out to validation study at flow coefficient of 0.027. The figures
insure that the output variables are unchanged. show that the results are almost independent of mesh
elements number for all values of number of elements equal
3.5 MESH SENSITIVITY STUDY or above 3.4 million.
Mesh size is one of the most influential elements in the
outcomes of numerical simulations. To explore the flow
Fig 4. Convergence history graphs at [ N=1500 RPM and Φ =0.027]: (A) Residuals graph for mass flow rate, velocity components, turbulence kinetic
energy (K) and dissipation rate (ω), (B) outlet pressure, (C) Coefficient of moment CM and (D) Inlet pressure
Fig 5. Eeffect of mesh elements number on the static pressure rise coefficient (A) and impeller torque (B) at flow coefficient 0.027
167
Engineering Research Journal (ERJ) S. A. Beskales et al Vol.52, No1 January 2023, pp:164-171
168
Engineering Research Journal (ERJ) S. A. Beskales et al Vol.52, No1 January 2023, pp:164-171
Configurations S0 S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6
Ds/DImpeller - 0.5 0.6 0.65 0.7 0.8 0.9
Ds - 361 433.2 469.8 505.4 577.6 649.8
Width - 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5
Fig 12. Streamlines comparisons colored by velocity magnitudes at flow coefficient 0.0321 between Datum Blades (S0) and slotted blades at six
different locations
169
Engineering Research Journal (ERJ) S. A. Beskales et al Vol.52, No1 January 2023, pp:164-171
Fig 13. A close view of velocity streamlines comparisons in the blade passages at flow coefficient 0.0321 between the datum blade (S0) and slotted
blades at six different locations
Fig 14. Fan blades with slot configuration S3 and different slot widths
170
Engineering Research Journal (ERJ) S. A. Beskales et al Vol.52, No1 January 2023, pp:164-171
171