We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 4
PERSPECTIVES ON GLOBAL
GEO-POLITICAL CONFLICTS AND
IMPERATIVES FOR BUILDING
ANTIFRAGILE SUPPLY CHAINS
Rajesh Pandey
he Butterfly Effect in Chaos theory is highly
applicable in the context of global geopolitical
conflicts that have become inherent features of
the 2tst-century world order, as the effects of an
event in one comer of the world may affect/reflect
‘on another. Thus, calling for an understanding the
geopolitical landscape, which is paramount to
grasping the dynamics that shape global affairs.
Besides, with the advent of globalization of supply
chains, countries compete for strategic resources,
geopolitical sways, and economic dominance.
‘At the same time, historical alliances, territorial
disputes, and ideological differences contribute
to the complex interactions. Superpowers and
‘emerging economies play pivotal roles in shaping
the geopolitical order, influencing their immediate
regions and the entire world.
As these conflicts intensify and evolve, their
impact on global supply chains cannot possibly
be understated. Supply chains, the complex
and complicated networks that facilitate the
production and distribution of goods and services
worldwide, are highly vulnerable to disruptions
caused by geopolitical tensions. Businesses
operating in this dynamic environment must
navigate a complex web of challenges to ensure
the resilience and adaptability of their supply
chains. By understanding the perspectives on
global geopolitical conflicts and their implications,
stakeholders can better prepare for the
uncertainties ahead, fostering a more robust and
sustainable global economic system. This essay
explores the various perspectives on some of the
major global geopolitical conflicts and their far-
48 | DISHA 2023
reaching implications on supply chains.
BREXIT AND THE EUROPEAN UNION:
The United Kingdom's decision to leave the
European Union, commonly known as Brexit,
had significant implications for supply chains,
particularly in industries heavily integrated across
European borders. The uncertainty surrounding the
prolonged negotiationsand the eventual departure
led to disruptions in logistics, increased customs
check, and regulatory changes. Companies faced
challenges in adapting to new trade rules and had
to navigate a more complex and time-consuming
process for goods to move between the UK and
the EU and rest of the world. The automotive and
aerospace industries experienced disruptions
due to their intricate cross-border supply chains,
showcasing the vulnerability of industries to
geopolitical shifts.
US-CHINA TRADE Wai
US-China dangerous tango is something going
fon for years. The recent concoction was put on
the boiling cauldron and stoked by respective US
presidencies starting with Barrack Obama and later
Donald Trump and Joe Biden. The ongoing trade
tensions and technological cold war between the
United States and China arising from competition
and insecurities have had a profound impact on
global supply chains. The trade war, marked by
tariffs and counter-tariffs and complete blockages,
has disrupted established supply _ chains,
particularly in the technology and manufacturing
sectors. The Micro-chip (and generally semi
conductors) is the NEW Oil and is the tug of werbetween them among other things. Competing for
technological supremacy, these nations engage
in battles over intellectual property and control
over emerging technologies. Companies that
heavily rely on Chinese manufacturing facilities
faced increased production costs due to tariffs on
imported goods as well uncertainties for future
product development strategies. To adapt, some
businesses have shifted production to other
countries, leading to a restructuring of supply
chain networks. This trade war highlighted the
vulnerability of global supply chains to geopolitical
tensions, prompting companies to reassess their
strategies to ensure resilience and flexibility,
RUSSIA-UKRAINE CONFLICT:
This recent conflict has resulted in huge polarization
of nations on the global scale and has re-defined
the reference point forall the strategic geo-political
discussions from Second World War to Russia -
Ukraine war. The geopolitical tensions between
Russia and Ukraine have had ripple effects on the
global agricultural supply chain and European
energy costs. Ukraine is a major exporter of wheat
and other agricultural products. The annexation of
Crimea by Russia and the ongoing conflict in eastern
Ukraine have disrupted agricultural production and
transportation routes. As a result, global wheat
prices have been affected, impacting food and
livestock industries worldwide. Similarly, the rising
energy cost in Europe brought high inflation, raising
the costs across the supply chains impacting many
products and commodities. The conflict serves as a
stark reminder of how regional geopolitical tensions
can reverberate through the global supply chain,
affecting commodity prices and availabilty
NORTH KOREA NUCLEAR TENSION
The geopolitical tensions surrounding North Korea's
nuclear ambitions have affected supply chains in
the Asia-Pacific region. The unpredictable nature
of North Korea's actions has led to increased
ical risks, impacting businesses operating
in the region particularly in South Korea and Japan.
‘Companies face uncertainties related to the stability
of transportation routes and the potential for
increased military tensions. These uncertainties can
50 | DISHA 2023
disrupt supply chains, affecting industries ranging
from electronics to automotive, as companies
reassess their manufacturing and distribution
strategies in the face of geopolitical instability.
COVID-19 PANDEMIC:
While not a geopolitical conflict in the traditional
sense, the global response to the COVID-19 pandemic
has demonstrated how external shocks can disrupt
supply chains. The pandemic, which originated
in Wuhan, China, led to widespread lockdowns,
travel restrictions, and disruptions in manufacturing.
The geopolitical dimension emerged as countries
implemented export restrictions on medical supplies
and equipment. This highlighted the vulnerability
‘of supply chains to unexpected events, prompting
companies to rethink their strategies and emphasize
resilience and agility in the face of unforeseen
geopolitical and global health challenges. Even
countries are forced to think about their dependence
for the critical pharma and medical inputs from the
rival nations and how to de-risk the same.
‘SOUTH CHINA SEA DISPUTE
The territorial disputes in the South China Sea
have created tensions among several Southeast
Asian countries and China. The region is a crucial
maritime route for global trade (an estimated $3.4
trillion worth of trade goods, which is around 1/31d
of global trade), and the geopolitical uncertainties
have implications for shipping and logistics.
‘Companies relying on these routes for transporting
goods face risks related to potential disruptions,
increased insurance costs, and the need for
alternative transportation strategies. The South
China Sea dispute underscores how geopolitical
tensions in strategic waterways can impact the
reliability and efficiency of global supply chains.
INDIA-CHINA BORDER TENSIONS,
The border disputes between India and China in
the Himalayan region have had implications for
supply chains, especially in the technology and
manufacturing sectors. The tensions led to calls
for economic boycotts and heightened scrutiny
of business ties between the two countries.
‘Companies relying on manufacturing facilities inthe region faced disruptions, and the geopolitical
uncertainties prompted some to reconsider their
supply chain strategies. Many Indian organizations
localized the component sourcing to India as the
local government's push for localization and the
ever-increasing rivalry.
ARAB SPRING / JASMINE REVOLUTION
The pro-democracy protests in the middle east
and north Africa shook the established autocratic
regimes and systems. The current and crosscurrents
experienced by different nations traversing the
transition to the democratic structures added
to the already muddled world experiencing the
onslaught of disturbances with after-shocks being
felt til this day. These Oil producing nations
adversely affected the Crude availabilty and
consequent economic disruptions.
ISRAEL ~ HAMAS (PALESTINE/ARAB)
CONFLICT
‘The unfolding of the ongoing terrible conflict in the
Middle East is taking huge tolls on people's life and
properties in Gaza Strip. Mega destruction is on the
show. This has potential to escalate beyond Israel
and Palestine-Gaza too, as it is again dividing the
world powers. fthis spreads, the jolt on the supply
chains will be huge and will be felt widely across
geographies and businesses as it is very close to
the important international trading routes.
As is evident from the above analysis, the
Geopolitical conflicts often manifest in the form of
supply and other economic disruptions, trade wars
and protectionist measures. Nations purposely
resort to tariffs, trade barriers, and sanctions to
protect domestic industries or exert leverage over
fal nations. These actions disrupt established
supply chains, leading to increased costs, delayed
deliveries, and uncertainties for businesses.
Similarly, certain important regions become focal
points of geopolitical conflicts, posing significant
threats to the stability of supply chains by
disrupting the transportation of goods, disrupting
energy supplies and escalate overall uncertainty.
‘Companies are forced to adapt their strategies to
navigate the changing trade landscape.
52 | DISHA 2023
Besides, many more risks, which are lurking in the
background and are waiting for their critical mass
to explode and engulf the region / globe in its fire
‘One cannot miss the Climate Impact on the supply
chains. its repercussions are in fact already getting
felt/experienced by many fires, storms, floods,
weather conditions, diseases and productivity
losses. The technological uncertainties arising
from the Semi-conductor / Chip war, Resources
for EV Batteries, sharing of technologies to handle
climate change etc. will have huge implications for
the supply chain stability and risks. The question
mark on the reserve currency status of US Dollar
is another global headache. Whereas with the rise
cof multi-polar world with regional as well as global
blocks/groupings is giving rise to multiple trading
currencies but stil there is no one currency which
can be alternative to US Dollar. The European
Euro, Chinese Yuan or Japanese Yen still are not
the match. With US Sovereign ratings getting
downgrades by Rating Agencies, the strength of
Dollar is getting negatively impacted and creating
uncertainties in the trade. This too, if this scenario
persists, will have potentially big impact on supply
chains going forward.
All said and done, the globe is becoming
extremely chaotic and full of risks. Is it here to
stay and become permanent part of globalized
world or is it a transitory adaptation process
representing changed global power structure with
new determinants of dominance. Or optimistically,
it is @ process towards more egalitarian and
inclusive world community having multi-polarity,
representative and driven by international rules
or simply one chaos to another. Global supply
chains are highly interconnected and span across
multiple countries and continents. "Synchronicity
is thy name". Any disruption in one part of the
world can have cascading effects throughout the
entire chain. Geopolitical and all the other conflicts
introduce a myriad of challenges to the stability of
supply chains.
In the face of these challenges, businesses
are compelled to enhance the resilience and
adaptability of their supply chains. This involvesdiversifying sourcing strategies, creating additional
nodes / backups, redundancies (in fact, bigger the
market, larger the redundancies & backups), and
developing agile response mechanisms. Companies
must actively monitor geopolitical developments,
assess potential risks to their entire chain (with
high tech components, even the complete chain
is not fully known), and implement strategies to
adapt swiftly to changes in the global landscape.
Sustainable supply chain with less material resource
intensity, circular economy, digitization, renewable
energy use, operating with insights from big data will
add to the resilience planning. While rise in the digital
infrastructure is adding to the speed, real time critical
information flow, Consumer/market data analytics
and insights but it has also enhanced the associated
cyber security and network risks and amplified scope
for mega disruptions in the global operations.
Infact, NEAR, CLEAR & GEAR could be the acronym for
the adaptable supply chain strategy. NEAR represents
source as close as possible preferably Local, CLEAR
represents high level of awareness of the global
developments impacting supply chains and actions
and strategies needed to tackle them and finally GEAR
represents adaptation of the supply chain to the new
or emerging scenarios. Marrying Product Life cycle
stages to the supply chain strategies, shared digital
infrastructure, robust contract management, multi
currency trading mechanism will build robustness
and aid in avoiding disruptions. Local Design Houses,
Technology Hub and consumer research agencies
will keep the supply chains grounded and relevant.
This will ensure resilience and is largely preventive in
its approach and thrust. But this is not enough, we
need to go ahead and bring in creative paradigms to
ensure growth even in this challenging scenario, "Thy
name is Antifragility’
Antifragility is beyond resilience or robustness. The
resilient resists the shock and remains the same,
whereas the antifragile becomes better. The Lemnaean
Hydra, a seven headed water snake pursued by
Hercules in one of his 12 labours, which grew two,
heads to replace one that was cut off, is a fundamental
example cited for Antifragility. Another is the wind
extinguishes the candle and energises the fire. The
antifragile loves randomness and uncertainty and
has a singular property of helping us deal with the
unknowns. Traditional design of efficient supply chain
meant high speed and low cost with very low tolerance
for any change. Sheer high speed and low cost will
have to give way to Antifragility through creativity,
agility and adaptability. Routine strategizing suggests
building resilience to cope with sudden changes. But
those days are over, and the current and emerging
scenarios require antifragile mechanisms to cope with
the galore disruptions and chaos in the transitionary
economy and global trade. The antifragile properties
inject not only robustness but something innovatively
beyond robustness and as per NN Taleb’s construct
‘Gains from Chaos’. For instance, the MNC's proactive
extended contracts with local suppliers to mass
manufacture a part or system with technology transfer
‘or know-how built in advance, in case of supply
disruption or shock scenario, will not only overcome
the supply risk but may also result in cost reduction to
the customer OEM and enhanced royalty payment to
the MNC itself, a win-win supply alliance with robust,
aligned and trustworthy value constellation. Lot of
financial hedging tools can be used to overcome short
term survival risks for businesses. Antifragile concept is.
new and will take time, effort and creativity to develop
and adopt. But as is evident from the literature on the
concept, all the natural systems and successful man-
made systems, which have weathered the roughness
of time and stayed strong are un-intentionally built on
this concept.
To conclude, we must acknowledge that the global
disturbances are here to stay, and chaos and
adaptations will be more ofa rule than an exception.
It is also evident that predictability, certainty as
well as pre-emptory assumptions or the claim of a
knowledge of the future, are archaic myths, satisfied
only by the prophesies of the Oracle of Delphi. Unlike
the charming Hellenistic fables, managing a resilient
and antiragile Supply chains call for heightened
awareness, agility, creativity, technological deftness,
broader network collaboration and real teamwork to
successfully take the organizations through crucial
phases of growth and survival
5u | DISHA 2023