Midterm Exam in Oblicon
Midterm Exam in Oblicon
III.Case Analysis. Examine the given cases and answer the given questions. Answer in A-L-A-C Method.
A. D owes C ₱10, 000 with G as guarantor. On the due date of the obligation, T, a third person,
offered to pay the obligation of D. Can C legally refuse to accept the payment?
B. X obliged himself to deliver to Y a specific carabao on July 31. The carabao died on July 25. Y has
no proof that X was negligent. Is X liable to Y?
C. A contract to sell a parcel of land is entered into by A and B. In their written contract, the piece of
land includes the concrete barangay road in front of the parcel of land. Rule on the validity of the
contract.
D. S offered to sell his Honda motorcycle to T. Unbeknownst to T, the motorcycle’s machine brand is
RUSI. Nonetheless, T purchased the motorcycle. Upon inspection of T’s trusted mechanic, he
informed T that the motorcycle is not Honda. Is the sale valid?
E. X and Y entered into a valid contract. X filed for the enforceability of the contract to which the
court granted. During the enforcement of the contract, as requested by X, he then filed for
reformation subsequently. Will the reformation prosper?
F. Does a contract to sell a house and lot with all the furniture therein includes the refrigerator in the
garage?
G. X owes Y ₱10, 000 with Z as guarantor. Y owes Z ₱10, 000. Can compensation take place?
H. Mr. X coerced Y to sell his land by saying that if Y did not sell his land to him, Y and his family
might get into trouble. Because of that, Y sold his land to Mr. X. Is the sale valid?