anenye 10, Oidd Post Office Street ‘ yoo Ground Floor, Room No.20 Advocate Kotkata-700001 Bar assoctation room no.t8 49831999395 High Court, Calcutta Bmail:-auyonban1 1@gmail.com Date:-12,07.2023 TO, ”1.Ld Government Pleader, High Court, Calcutta 2. The State of West Bengal, service through the Secretary Department of — School Education, Government of West Bengal, having its office at Bikash Bhawan, 6% Floor, Salt Lake City, Kolkata - 700 091; 3. The West Bengal Board of Primary Education, service through the Secretary, of the Board, Acharya Prafulla Chandra Bhawan, DK-7/1, Sector-Il, Salt Lake City, Kolkata - 700 091; 4, The Principal Secretary School Education Department, Government of West Bengal, having his office at Bikash Bhawan, 6t Floor, Salt Lake City, Kolkata ~ 700 091; 5. The Commissioner of School Education, Government of West Bengal, having his office at Bikash Bhawan, 7% Floor, Bidhannagar, Kolkata — 700 091; 6. The Dis rict_ Inspector of Schools (P.E), Purba Medinipur, having his office at Tamluk, Purba Medinipur, PIN-721636 7. The Purba Medinipur District Primary School Council, service through the Chairman, having his office at SalgachiaBW Chamber : Liga n anenfe 10, Ole Post Office Street ‘ Yo Ground Floor, Room No.20 Advocate Kotkata-700001 Bar association room 10.18 49831999995 High Court, Calcutta Emailt-cuyonban1 Wagmail.com (Station Road), PIN- 721636 8. The Chairman, Purba Medinpur District Tamluk, Purba Medinipur, Primary School Council, having his office at Salgachia (Station Road), 7WGF+V66, Tamluk, Purba Medinipur, PIN-721636; 9. The Medical Officer of Contai S.D. Hospital, Government of West Bengal, office of the Superintendant, office at Darua Hospital Road, Darua, Contai,pin-721401; Re:- W.P.A No. 16201 OF 2023 Harekrishna Ranjit ..-Petitioner Versus STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS. \. Respondents sir, Please find enclosed herewith a copy of the above referred writ petition along with all annexures which will be used at the time of hearing of the instant matter before the Hon'ble Justice Abhijit Agcangopadhyay of the Hon'ble High Court on 44.07.2023 or any subsequent day thereafter. Please attend. ‘Thanking You. Your Truly, and Done. n Banerjee Advocate7112123, 113 ANE Case Status: Search by Case Number Calcutta High Court - Appellate side ‘ Appellate side Case Details (case Type WPA Filing Number 16276025 Filing Date: 07-07-2003 Registration Number 1620112023 Rogistration Date: 07-07-2023 ‘CNR Number : WBCHCA-032024-2023 Case Status First Hearing Dato [a3th July 2073, Next Hearing Date 213th July 2023, Stage of Case = NEW MOTION Coram 265724HON'BLE JUSTICE ABHIJIT GANGOPADHYAY Bench 7Single Bench State 7 West Bengal District TMEDINIPUR EAST Judie ‘MANDAMUS SECTION ~ Causelist Name Daily List Potitioner and Advocate 1) HAREKRISHNA RANT ‘Advocate: AYAN BANERJEE Respondent and Advocate 1) STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS. cere i Acts Under Acts) Under Section(@) om West Bengal Primary Education Act 1973 NA History of Case Hearing [Gause List type Tudge Business On Date [Hearing Date | Purpose of hearing [Dany List [FONGLE JUSTICE ABHILIT GANGOPADAYAY fisa7-2023 [NEW MOTION Orders ‘Order 7 fi Pies hi Number _| 2ués® Order Date Order Details | Category Details Category c GROUP A (WRIT MATTERS)( 1) } ‘Sub Category Education (6) i ‘Sub Sub Category PRIMARY EDUGATION (7) | ‘Sub Sub Sub Category 5 In Service Others 87 (9) 1 OBJECTION (Sette, [Scrutiny Date [Receipt Date] i lor-r-2023 |All Objections are Complied E hntpsifhesenvices.ecourts govinvecoutindishleasestease_no.php?stale cd=10édist cd=14court code=38slateNm=Calcuttak 1"DISTRICT: PURBA MEDINIPUR IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION APPELLATE SIDE W.P.A. No |b20| In the matter of: An application under Article 226 of the Constituticn of And In the matter of: Subject matter relating to Group: © , Head - (4? of the Classification List Cause titie Harekrishna Ranjit. Petitioner -Versus- State of West Bengal & Ors. Respondents. Advocate- >, Record mb Adwebate High Court, ola 7A, K.S. Roy Road, etendra Chamber’, 24 Floor Kolkata - 700001 Mobile-9831999395SHORT LIST OF DATES 21.02.2013 | Reply of the RTI application 22.03.2017 | The petitioner get disability certificate. 21.11.2020 | The petitioner final disability certificate. Pee ‘The petitioner get admit card ae 08.04.2013 | Letter to Chairman Purba Medinipur District Primary! School Council from the office of the District Magistrate and Collector, Purba Medinipur 22.08.2022 | Forwarding letter by court of Chief Commissioner for persons with Disabilities to Commissioner for Persons : with Disabilities 10.04.2023 | Petitioner made application under Right to Information Act, 2005.DISTRICT: PURBA MEDINIPUR IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA, CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION APPELLATE SIDE W.P.A. No. {620} of 2023 IN THE MATTER OF: - An application under Articie 226 of the Constitution of India; ~And- IN THE MATTER OF: - Harekrishna Ranjit. .. Petitioner -Versus- State of West Bengal & Ors. Respondents INDEX SL Particulars of documents Annexure | Pages No. : 1. | Writ Application Titel 2. [Photocopy of the disability certificate along) “PI” 7 \Y with the medical certificate for physically’ “ve handicapped person. H 19 3. | Copy of the application form along with {Pa ace admit card and the interview letter. 2g 4. | Copy of the intimation letter. Pe 28° 5. [Photocopy of the said letter dated 218) “P-4™ TOO” February, 2013 along with the list of panel. { 6. | Photocopy of the complaint dated 228d ] “p-5 | 3) August, 2013. { 7. | Copy of the RTI application along with track “P.6" ( % report dated 10% April, 2023. PATH seb aed 1s espe 2e LETT ile GiLIST OF DATES 21.02.2013 Reply of the RTI application 22.03.2017 | The petitioner get disability certificate 21.11.2020 The petitioner final disability certificate ‘The petitioner get admit card 08.04.2013 [Leiter to Chairman Purba Medinipur District Primary i School Council from the office of the District | Magistrate and Collector, Purba Medinipur 22.08.2022 | Forwarding letter by court of Chief Commissioner for persons with Disabilities to Commissioner for Persons : with Disabilities 10.04.2023 _| Petitioner made application under Right to Information * Act, 2005, |i ul W. Vv. ML LAW POINTS INVOLVED Whether the Respondent Authority made il! providing the information sougnt in the RTI application dated 10% April, 2023 to the petitioner and this is a massive illegalities done by the authorities which shows tt authorities are trying suppress the actual truth of selection process of primary teacher, 2009 to the petitioner? Whether the respondent council made illegalities by not providing any opportunity to the petitioner in primary teacher by saying a typographical mistake has happened in the preparation of list for appointment in primary teacher selec process 2009 as your petitioner came to know from the rep! 21 February, 2013 of the previous RTT application? Whether the act of the respondent council js illegal as why the respondent council provided the panel list of PC-Eye category to the petitioner in the reply of the RTI application by not disclosing the detail marks of the candidates in the merit list as your petitioner information sought in the RT! application? Whether the petitioner has ever right to see and inspect his OMR sheet and the OMR sheets along with subject paper and question paper and the marks of the other appointed candidates for swiping out the illegalities and also knowing the truth as per eye of law? Whether the commission cannot deny the right of the petitioner as an primary teacher by not providing a proper clarification as per the appointment proceedings by which the other appointees has been appointed in the said post? Whether the petitioner has every right to know the truth as per law?DISTRICT: PURBA ss BR | IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUT CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION APPELLATE SIDE, w.P.a.NO.[620| oF 2023 In the Matter of An application under Article 226 of the Constitution of India; And In the Matter of Harekrishna Ranjit, son of Jagneswar Ranjit, residing at Negua, Egra-I, Purba Medinipur West Bengal, PIN- 721448; .. Petitioner - VERSUS- 1 The State West Bengal, service through the Secretary Department of School Education Government of West Bengal, having its office at Bikash Bhawa 6 Floor, Salt Lake City, Kolkgara - 700091;2 The West Bengai Boarc Primary Education, service through the Secretary, of the Boa Acharya Prafulla Chandra Bhawan, DK-7/1, Sector-l, Salt Lake City, Kolkata — 700 091; 3, The Principal Secretary Schoot Education Department, Government of West Bengal, hay his office at Bikash Bhawan, 6° Floor, Salt Lake City, Kolkata ~ 7 091; 4 The. Commissioner of Schooi Education, Government of Wes! Bengal, having his office at Bikash Bhawan, 7% Floor, Bidhannagar. Kolkata - 700 091, 5. The District Inspector of Schools [P.E), Purba Medinipur. having his office at Tamiuk, Purba Medinipur, PIN- 721636; 6 The Purba Medinipur Dis! Primary School Council,To through the Chairman, having iis office at Salgachia (Station Roadi Tamiuk, Purba Medinipur, P!N- 721636 7. The Chairman, Purba Medinpur District Primary School Coun having his office at Salgachia (Station Road), «= 7WGF+V65 Tamluk, Purba Medinipur, PIN- 721636; 8. The Medical Officer of Contai be 8.0. Hospital, Government of West Amy Bengal, office of the & | ORRUA Hopital Road, Dever Superintendant, office aycontain; ane Respondents The Hon'ble T.S. Sivagnanam, Chief Justice and His Companion Justices of this Hon’ble Court. SHEWETH: 1. Your petitioner is a law abiding and bonafide citizens of | The humble petition on behalf of the Writ Petitioner above named most respectfullyand residing at the address mentioned in the cause title hereinal 2. The respondents are all the ‘State Authorities’ and/or its agencies and/or instrumentalities, coming under the scope, purview and ambit of Article 12 of the Constitution of India. The acts, actions, conducts and inactions on the part of the respondents are subject to judicial scrutiny and review. The respondents are, therefore amenable to the writ jurisdiction of this Hon'ble Court 3. The petitioner has been affected, aggrieved by the act and/or decision of the respondent commission, its men and/or agents for tie arbitrary selection process adopted by the Respondent Authority and the relief prayed for by the petitioner against the respondents herein would affect the petitioner. The act of the Respondent Authority has resulted in an infringement of right of relief to exist in the petitioner against the respondents, its men and agents as your petitioner 1s more qualified for the primary teacher than other appointed candidates, The petitioner herein is a physically handicapped person with 100% visual impairment and appeared in the selection process held by the Respondent Authorities on 17% June, 2012 and ai appearing in the said examination the petitioner’s name appeared in the call list published by the Purba Medinipur District Primary Schoo Council on 19.10.2012 in the panel for PC_ Ear category, but one o! sudden the petitioner came to know that the name which appeared in the final cail list was a typographical error and for this he was unable to join in the said post for primary teacher. Knowing such factpetitioner filed one RTI application dated 3" January 2013 Chairman, District Primary School Council seeking informatie. regarding the score and how many candidates were being appointed in the primary teacher post as per the recruitment 2009 of District Primary School Council Purba Medinipur and after getting reply from the Respondent Authority, your petitioner came to know the petitioner came to know that he got lowest score than the lower score obtained candidate which is 21.08 and also came to know the name was appeared in the list was clerical mistake. Upon knowing the fact the petitioner informed the same fact to the Court of Chief Commissioner for Persons with Disabilities informing the same fact for non appointment of as a primary teacher as per the recruitment 2009 published by the Purba Medinipur District Primary School Council On 10 April, 2023 the petitioner filed another RTI application under Right to Information Act, 2005 for certain quarries but the Respondent Authorities unable to provide the information according to the petitioner Finding no other way the petitioner is filing this instant writ application with a hope to get a proper adjudication from this Hon'ble High Court. 4. Your petitioner states that your petitioner is a blind and physically handicapped person with 100% vision impaired and got certificate from the Government of West Bengal Contai Sub-divisionai Hospital at the time of certification of his disability Photocopy of the disability c ficate along with the medical Ycertificate for physically handicapped person are annexed anc collectively marked as Annexure-P/ 1. 5. Your petitioner states that your petitioner appeared in selection process for the post of primary teacher on 17% June, 2012 held by the Purba Medinipur District Primary School Council holding enrolment No. 600504 and qualified in the jew call amination and got an int from the said council which was hi on 8% September, 20 around 10.00 am at the Tamralipta Mahavidyalaya, Tamluk, Purba Medinipur. Copy of the application form along with admit card and the interview letter are annexed and collectively marked as Annexure-P/2. 6. Your petitioner states that one intimation he got from the set council on 19% October, 2012 on around 5.04 pm where wt has been stated that all testimonials and certificates of the petitioners should be submitted before the council within 1* November, 2012 to 17% November, 2012 on working days for further verifications and on such date the petitioner submitted all the documents as per the requirements of the council. Copy of the intimation letter is annexed herewith and marked as Annexure-P/3 7 Your petitioner states that after verification of all the testimonials and all the certificates by the Respondent Authorities.the petitioner waited till 21% December, 2012 knowing that others were getting appointment in the said post of primary teacher. The petitioner visited at the office of the District Primary School Council Purba Medinipur and got information due to some clerical mistake the petitioners did not get any call from the council. 8. The petitioner states that despite of getting any information your petitioner file one RTI application before the Chairman, Purbu Medinipur District Primary School Council seeking some information regarding the academic score, how many seats were reserved for disabled persons and the details (marks in subjective academic score, marks in OMR total in written marks in Viva-voce marks in co- curriculum activities and rank) of the appointed candidates by Purba Medinipur District Primary School Council. 9. Your petitioner states that upon receiving the said RTI letter from the petitioner the Chairman of the said Council replied that the score of the petitioner is much lower than the lowest score of the empanelled candidates as the petitioner obtained 21.08 marks where the lowest core of the panel PC-EYE category is 22.092 and the said council also disclosed, it happened due to the clerical mistake in percentage of marks without additional subject in Madhvam Pariksha of the said candidate of the petitioner was entered as 78,75 instead of 68.75. For that academic sore was recorded as © S though actually it would be 08.25 in the case of the petitioner. it has also disclosed by the said council that initially the name of the Aepetitioner has been empanelled but after verification of the academic records the mistake was noticed and corrected in due course taking academic score as 8.25 and gradually it was found by the council that the total score of the petitioner is lower than the lowest score of the panel and the name of the petitioner was excluded from the panel. Photocopy of the said letter dated 21% February, 2013 alone with the list of panel are annexed and collectively marked os Annexure-P/4. 10. Your petitioner states that after getting such information from the Chairman of the Council the petitioner went into depression and with no other option left the petitioner informed the said fact to the Court of Chief Commission for person with disabilities by disclosing the entire fact of illegalities done by the Respondent Authority on 3 February, 2013. The complaint was being forwarded to Commissiunes for Person with Disabilities from the Court of Chief Commission for the person with disabilities on 2294 August, 2013, but after that the petitioner did not pay any relief neither get any suggestion or help from the Commissioner of Person with Disabilities. Photocopy of the complaint dated 22" August, 2013 is annexed herewith and marked as Annexure-P/5. 11. Your petitioner states that without getting any fruitful resuilt. the petitioner posted his grievances in a social network and one Mr Ayan Banerjec, Advocate contacted with the petitioner and suggestedhim to file a FIR before the Egra Police Station, Purba Medinipur per the suggestion of Mr. Banerjee, Advocate your petitioner lodged a complaint on 8 May 2023 before the Egra Police Station through registered post with A/D. 12. Your petitioner states that your petitioner has informed the entire fact of such illegalities happened with the petitioner bv the Council to the High Court authority by a written letter 13. The petitioner states that the issue which was actually the basis of the instant writ application is to get relief from illegalities which has done by the respondent commission by not disclosing the actual fact of the appointment of the petitioner in the post of primary teacher rather providing a fake statement of “typographical mistake”. The etitioner has ever right to know the entire marks of the appointed candidates as the petitioner neard that some of the candidates «nu got lower marks in Madhyamik Examination, but got chance in the primary teacher selection process 2009. 14. Your petitioner states that rather getting help being a physical disable person he has a way only moving the writ petition before this Hon'ble Court where the petitioner can his agitation and a get a proper adjudication against the illegalities committed by the commissioners by not disclosing the detailed merit list in respect of marks percentage of the appointed candidates and your petitioner is in belief that he will get chance if the proper investigation conductedby the authorities, 18. Your petitioner states that your petitioner filed another RTI application under the act of 2005 on 10.04.2023 seeking information as follows: a) e) As per the Notification of primary teacher recruitment par 2009 (whose written examination was held on 17% June, 20!2 conducted by Purba Medinipur District Primary School Council} How many teachers were recruited by Purba Medinipur District Primary School Council? Mention the number of appointment of each category ---UR, SC, St, OBC PWD and others. From which month after the declaration of primary teacher recruitment panel 2009 in 2012 was the issuing of appoinunent letters started? Provide detailed information of all appointed primary teachers of physically challenged categories, who were recruited by Purba Medinipur District Primary School Council as per the recruitment panel 2009 conducted in 2012, mentioning name date of bi ‘h, enrollment number, written examination score academic score, interview mark, score of extra curricular activities, name and address of the schoo! appointed. Copy of the RTI application along with track report dated 10% April, 2023 is annexed herewith and marked as Annexure-P/6.16. Your petitioner states that your petitioner will get appoinumen if the authorities view the complaint of the petitioner and investigate the matter the petitioner will definitely get a chance tw get appointment as a primary teacher. 17. The act of the respondent council in preparing the panels bu not disclosing the detailed marks of the candidates who has heer appointed and/or non-appointed is illegal, arbitrary, mala fice, unreasonably, discriminatory and constitutes violation of guarantees enshrined in Article 14,19 (1G) and 21 of the Constitution of India. 18, Being aggrieved by and/or dissatisfied with the inaction on the part of the Respondent Authorities, your petitioner begs to move the instant writ application under Article 226 of the Constitution of India before Your Lordship on the grounds following amongst other: GROUNDS 1, FOR THAT the Respondent Authority made illegalities by not providing the information sought in the RTI application dated 10% April, 2023 to the petitioner and this is a massive illegalities done by the authorities which shows that the authorities are trying suppress the actual truth of selection process of primary teacher, 2009 to the petitioner; Ul, FOR THAT the respondent council made illegalities by not providing any opportunity to the petitioner in primary teacher,i. Nv. VI. 19. by saying a typographical mistake has happened in the preparation of list for appointment in primary teacher selection process 2009 as your petitioner came to know from the repiy 21 February, 2015 of the previous RTI application; FOR THAT the act of the respondent council is iliegal as w the respondent council provided the panel list of PC category to the petitioner in the reply of the RT application i> not disclosing the detail marks of the candidates in the merit list as your petitioner information sought in the RTI application; FOR THAT the petitioner has ever right to see and inspect his OMR sheet and the OMR sheets along with subject paper and question paper and the marks of the other appointed candidates for swiping out the illegalities and also knowing the truth as per eye of law; FOR THAT the commission cannot deny the right of the petitioner as an primary teacher by not providing a proper clarification as per the appointment proceedings by which the other appointees has been appointed in the said post. FOR THAT the petitioner has every right to know the truth per law; ‘There is no other alternative, speedy and/or efficacious remedy and the relief as sought for herein, if granted would be adequate andcomplete to your petitioner. Alternative remedy, even if any, would not be @ bar given that violation of fundamental rights are involved in the instant writ petition. 20. Unless, therefore, the orders as prayed for herein is made your petitioner would suffer irreparable loss and injury as recruitment and selection are squarely related to their livelihood 21. Your petitioner have not moved any other applications before this Hon'ble Court or before any other appropriate forum on the seif same cause of action. 22. That under the facts and circumstances of the case any furthe notice of demanding justice would be an empty formality. 23. That the office of the Respondent Authorities are lying outside the ordinary original jurisdiction of this Hon'ble Court and therefore the instant writ petition is being marked and instituted under the Appellate Side jurisdiction of this Hon'ble Court. 24, That this application is made bonafide and in the interes justice, Under the — facts. and circumstances your petitioner humbly prays your Lordships would be graciously pleased to issue;aj Leave be granted to the petitioner dispensing compliance of the formalities conte: under Ruie 26 of the Rules of tne High Court at Calcutta Relauny to Applications under Arucie 226 of the Constitution; b) Issue a writ offor in the nature of mandamus, commanding the respondes and/or their men, servants to provide the proper information as x secking in the RTI application dated 10% April, 2023 from the Chairman, Purba Medinipur District Primary School Council; e) Issue a writ offor in the nature of mandamus commanding the respondents and/or their men, agents and servants to show cause the reply dated 21% February, 2013 of ma RTI application filed by1s petitioner will not be accepted eye of iaw without providing the proper clarification or appointment as a priman teacher of the petitioner as per the selection process of 2009; d} Issue a writ offor in the nature of mandamus commanding the respondent no.S and 7 and/or their sen agents and servants to pr original OMR sheet of the petitioner along with appointed candidates who has been appointed in primary teacher as per the selection process of 2009 along with ti question paper and marks shee: to clarify the legitimacy ol appointed candidates as per the eye of law; e} Issue a writ offor in nature of mandamus. commanding the responden16 and/or their men, agents and servants to give appointment: 79 sue av of certiorari directing the respondents to transmit the entire original records of the present matter herein before this Hon'ble High Court at Calcutta so that conscionable justice may be administered by quashing the same; g) Rule Nisi in terms of prayer and (b) to [e) above to make rule absolute; h) To Pass stich other and/or further orders and/or directions as this Hon'ble Court may deen fit and proper; And for this act of action your Petitioner, as in duty bound shall ever pray,dy, 1, Harekrishna Ranjit, son (| “by faith -Hindu, by occupation -unemployed, residing at Negua, § <2 I, Purba Medinipur, West Bengal, PIN- 721448, do hereby sol \affirm and say as follows: - ) ky.) That I am the petitioner in the instant writ applicatiornwnc~bam / ~ "well acquainted with the facts and circumstances of the case and ! am competent enough to affirm this affidavit. 2. ‘That the statement made in paragraphs {-!S //6,(7,— are Ola true to my knowledge, those made in paragraphs 48,6, {OI are matter of record which I verily believe to be true and rest are my humble submissions before this Hon’ble Court Hxaiahne oo Prepared in my office The deponent ig knoyn tome ) P> ped pike $ = Advocats Clerk to: Solemnly affigmedBefbre me on this the pe Gay of July, 2023 PS, fer 06:09 Cs ‘Commissioner of att gt yeliate 1. I certify that all annexure ardlieg BI rhea wltoper oe aSI.No. 92 ne Aonesure Pid OSFITAL i EMINIPUR, SERTIRCATE PHE / 292 (HAD / vi-8i/-2002 (Pt 4), et-8th flay 2003} iis coed eat, 1. He/ She is a physica! Hsneih aicabical mening ee, IZ tee adlailty epoca eee Uy i otaceateae Stas tation ee Crbernt tts mis aoe ete Berea et aig Soest of vein theca itis hcl Le 4, He / She being montaily challenged person witht a .Q. OF cassuerene category of Mild / Moderate / Severe / Profound. 5. The assessment has been made as pi 16-18/97-N1. Dt, 18.02,2002 6. He/She can [ cannot travet without assistance of an escort. 7. He! She may be provided with which will increase his/her mobility and functional independence. instruction, issued by the Govt. o pecial romarks if any . Sign. LT! of candidate &PERE NER that we have carefully eae Age, vis frie) nelentification Marl ie Addecss ONL Side boar. oe today 2h MN Gere found that, He/She is apped for the MiafMan diaability is/are sppranmately OS erg Siguatuce j LT] of the!Candidate ATTESTED, Lote! few (Sree) se Corsa! Sigastu:a ct the Me ay ee 6D. HOspr! AL Contai, MidisrsreL LY WEST BENGAL BC eye waY PRIMARY EDUCATION APPLICATION FORM & INFORMATION BROCHURE FOR THES IDATES APPEARING IN S. TION TEST 2009 , FOR APPOINTMENT TO THE POST OF ASSISTANT TEACHERS IN GOVERNMENT SPONSORED/AIDED PRIMARY/JUMIOR BASIC SCHOOLS UNDER DISTRICT PREMARY SCHOOL COUNCILS-~-\ GENERAL INFORMATION ee ick sates Wlanselfee reel f hae be 92 1.0K. 201009 the Apt ne eandtdate 9 $ulfills all the eligibility conditions nv laid damn in the advertixement putatished « the tally Newspapers. to avnid rejection of the Application Form, Academie qualifications abr ai after submission of the Applicativ« Form shall not be entertained, ~ ORM ty Criteria tor the candies 21 Citizenship: Appticnn must be a citizen of tudia, 2.2 Age Restriction? Nas completed the age of 18 years aod hax net completed the ure of $0 year a ve) D105 2080, Peaviled that the maximum age limit of the candidates, whose names have heen spemserett iy ie employtaeat exchanges lay cute of the reqisition mnie hy the respective Comes azar sacancies potrfiet during Mar perenl bul could not be comudered tor the reasons He of the recautiinent hy the Councils due 1a pendency af court caves wath respect to such wec sium: shall be relaxed for stich peniod by whiel suelt teeruitment process lave been kept pencag, Upper age hmit is relaxale hy $ years for SC & ST Candidates of West Bengal, $ yeues tur Gt Candidates of West Bengal and upto 48 years for Persons with Disabilities (PDE The limit as relaxabile by 3 years tore than the period af his‘er service in the Armed Furcer ie ss Ex-Servicemten. Academic Regiirement: Possess the pass certificate in the Schoo! Final Madhyaritk 1 Gren or erstwhile Higher Secondary (Xt Class) Examination, under the West Bengal Board of Secondary Education or its egpiiv ti n, Provided that the Government shall have pewer tu decide the equivalence of the qualification referred to above and its decision thereon stall he Saat fer removal ef doubs it is hereby daviared thai no extsa masks shall be given for fi qualification at the tite of selection of an Assistant Teacher. fon & Relavabtlitys Necessary reservation and relaxability in age and fees are appltcabie 2 A Reser under: ta) Physically Challenged Candidates with disabilities specified under West Bengal Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Foll Participation) Rules, 1999 1c. having physical disabifities of 40% and above are eligible for reservation as applicah {b) Ex-Servicemen are those who have put not less than 6 months continuous service in anny (whether as a Combatuat or as a Non-Combatant) in the Armed Forces of the Union fe) No claim for being a member af SC/STOBCPC/ECIES will be entertained af the Application Form. (dj) SC/ST'OBC Candidate not belonging to the State of West Bengal shall be treated as Cieneral Candidate, ak 4. Application Procedure: 4,1, Submission of Application Form: The Application Farm not i the prescribed format we snvomptere or unsigned or not received through the Designated Bank Branches or the Primary Schoo! ( from where it has been procured or received after the last date shall 1 centerttined and shall be surnmarily rejected, The Application Form duly fitled in by the candidate is to be submitied 19 she respective Bank Branch or the Primary School Couneit from where it has been procured. Tae last dates forsubmission of filled in Application Form are 27.10.2009 and 03.11.2009 (upto the working y be hours of the concemed! Branch) and as notified by the Primary School Council, as the ease The pontinn of the Application Form marked “Candidate's Copy” must be retained by the canditare, No Application Form will be received through other agencies apart fron the designated Bs Branch and the respective Primary School Council from where it has been procures ay th may be.‘Le Issue of Adniit Cards: From the inert list prepared on Foal Madhyustink ot cestwlule Higher Secondary (Xf Ch ce seorpete! 4 Canty soll be aust < Xs. 40% in cat for Scheiluted Caste, Scheduled Habe. hwoldeng HPL, Cards, Kor other candidates die amount ta be dey ¢ the applicant's Examination Centre, Date and FH ark atnained 18 the Seat yninshon os agains eps and © the basix of mark yer equwalent F eo Heated candies pened rerity, A val ind ae “amid opographs an “ ‘isnmtedetet Ces ‘eh ies oned Aaievrted/ soiled dAdbinit Cards ill 10 appear in the Selection Test, 2009, Candidates muss retain thetr Admit Cards carefully in @ secured place. Mae No duplicate Admit Card will be iseved after the Sefectian Test a in ven canthdate will bs autornatically ean Se ace ‘of cocruilme wired by the Appropriate Autiionsh Adasit Card are not mistilateds eat not be allowed Neato ent for quired: appropriate dlactuments in original dari tultingent of eligibility and ollyer enteria as andl wher Centre of Examination: The allotment of Examination Cen : the vorvemed Primary Schoo! Council and the same shall be intimated by the Councils in due time, No rogues! for change of examination centre Procedure for Conduct of Examinations 3.1 The Examination Hall will be opened 1$ minutes before the commencement of the « are to take their seats immediately aflce the opening of examination ball 7.2 After occupying their seats they must write their names, Roll umber, index number at the appropriate places on OMR Sheet and Answer Sheet, 7.3. Candidates must bring with them (1) Admit Curd, (2) Blue/Black Ball Point Pen. TA Candidates must show their Admit Cards for admission into the examination half. A cas who does not possess the Admit Card shall not be admitted into the examination hull 7.5 A seat indicating the index number will be allocated to each candidate who must find out the samme anid occupy their alloted seats accordingly. 7.6 if a candidate writes hisher name or puts any special mark at any place in the OMR Sheet or Answer Sheet, except in the space provided for such purpose which may disclose in any wits, identity of the candidate, he/she will render himselitherself Viable to disqualification 7.7, Candidates are not allowed to cary any written/printed or textual materials, bits of paper or any other materials except those listed above inside the examination hall. Cellular Phones/Pagers/Electronic Watches with facilities of Calculator, Calculators, Log Tables, Slide Rules are not sllowed in the examination hall. Possession of such devicesfitems during the examination will lead to cancellation of the exaniination for such candidate besides same, will be completely i to the short-listed vwill be emertained nidutades vest. Candidarey izing of the 7.8 No candidate under any circumstances, without the special permission of the Centre. Jnvigilator concerned, will icave hiséhet seat or examination hall until is over. Candidate should not leave the hall without handing over Sheet to the Invigilitor concemed. Charg I the duration of examination the OMR Sheet and Anse 7.9 Candidates should maintain silenee in the examination hall. Any conversation in the examination hall shall be deemed as misbel ‘doping unfair means ot indulging misbehavior hisher candida ‘Ifa candidene is found impersonating, hiner candidature wil es veld 5 concerned examlace will be handed aver t0 the police, Pe canceled onright anu the disturbance or gesticilatian havior. If a candidate $s foes’ ture Will be rejected, 2¢ Evaluation and Declaration of Results: Pree i SA Question Patterns jn the OMR Sheets i.e. VART-1 there will be 20 Multiple Choice aon {MQ type, avth Four opttens ineluding singlecortedt answer) camryiny. 20 Markee each quesbor Sill ery Mask and an PATEL? the ermniny. 10 Marks will ented fora garages rin Wwiieh isto be wrttes within the space provided in the Answer sect im the same meds 36 wc the candidate opted to teach (iter nd, 2 in Hie Application From). laewere are te be marked using bluctitack ball paint pew aniy-on the OMR Sheet and on the Ansiver Shect provided foe the purposes, Under no eiscumstanices the examinee should mutifate, son, fold or deface the OMI Shyet and the Answer-Sheet Phe questions will be set in Rengalf and English for Part -] and those are to be auswered exsher 14 Bengali ar in English There will he no negative marking. Spectmen af OMR Sheet (Fall Marks « 20) Part +1 Use BluevBiack Ball Point Pen to shade the right answer: Example: |. Who istneantharof Abe Tabol!) oRabindneail Tagore: CRarikim Chandra ¢> Sarat Chanda @Sukuiar Roy “SIRT CII at ns Go? oo aetEIE SIE OME OM OT oR TH 2. How many districts are there in W.B 2 © 18 © 17 © 20 © None of these fewer coe ATE? OWN Ow © ROR Specimen of Paragraph Writing (Full Marks -10) Part -2 Example: 1. What do we mean by environment ? i ae ftcen ence an Att t i L 4 8.2 Result: Depending upon the result of the evaluated OMR Sheet and answer sheet together with the marks obtained for Co-curricular activities in SI. No. 11 in the Application Form. the Pritnary School Council will intimate the short-listed eligible candidates regarding the date. time and venue for the interview/aptitude test, ling up of Application Form: Application Form should be filled up as illustrated in the enclosed specimen. IMPORTANT Candidates who are short-listed and selected for sting for the Written Examination willbe required to prove their claims regarding educations! qualifications, marks obtained in the qualifying examinations, date of birth and claim for reservation and relaxation of fees under any category before receiving their Admit Cards from the Counell. Such candidates should therefore carry originale of the concerned documents along with one attested copy of each such document at the time of receiving of Admit Card. Attestation of all documents required to be submitted must be done by the Head of recognized GovernmentiAided High/Higher Sccuddary SchoolsMadrasahs or Principal of Recusuted Colle or an Officer of equivalent Cadre of Colleye/University/Goverament,CODE - LIST eH CODE LIST-8 | Cope LIST B ; Dakshin Dinajpor [North 24-Parganss Kotkata South 24-Parganas Howrah fa Paschins Medinipur Bankura Ponulia onc f CANVASSING IN ANY FORM WILL DISQUALIFY THE CANDIDATURE, CLOSING DATE OF ISSUANCE OF APPLICATION FORM 18 23.10.2009 AND 29.10.2000 UPTO THE WORKING HOURS OF THE CONCERNED BANK BRANCHES OR AS NOTIFIED BY THE PRIVIGES SCHOOL COUNCIL AS THE CASE MAY BE. i CLOSING DATE OF SUBMISSION OF FILLED IN APPLICATION FORM 15 27,10.2009.,81) 03.41.2080 UPTO THE WORKING HOURS OF THE CONCERNED BANK BRANCHES OR AS NOTIFIED BY THE PRIMARY SCHOOL COUNCIL AS THE CASE MAY BF, 42S ponents Trey yt “ Appieation Forme, 1 XK RK KKN | Application Form Far Setectton Test 2008 For Recrultment of Aesiatont Teachers In the Government Sponaored! Aided Primery!dunlor Basic Schools ta The Diatriet ‘ease edhe ininconncaatty bare ingot Apoienton Form. Une Sloe 0 et et tony, Al eotumns should be Ned up with enly BLOCK LETTERS exchvdeag ihe signatures & $1 Ho 17 Lo casera : 1 Det cose peepee 2 Mem obwrectoctes 2 2 Coveao conKea BATA SaseiPrray Schoicaner 2 OMamGnte SY we oe tt sper scheacnng ctaticatn eave one bor vacant Deen fo mors) TARA CHARAN bas Tv ALARA TRA omeoteen 2 9 @ DL 4 BO Aspersenor DO MoM YY yy Ming sndiicate | * camgeys & 7 CodeUisid & Cougey? 5 2B Cooelaté Nome ct amentiter (35 pe Sto eaing cee, Mave dw Dor VACSTE A BAER PAD HORI oo LATE KAM ALA BAS TAL A PLA RA us a 10 Compete Posat Aadiens for Comrunicaten tere on be vacant batreon rats, : SON 1 Ru PAM ‘ moe Nos wisp! OL Breet KA L Ponte UT TAR & Pose sates BAK S H . oe UT TAR Swe WE ST BR owes 71 Leo 1 & cis Rents parson per Soars acovtyrecreening me oxtct ne State Level Games or Spon = Y “CANDIDATE'S COPY : eames A me cob be ce sty exrscatey LFarmtan | XXX XA XXX | Nome TAKAGHARAS bas TALAPATRA S Sdewer¢7e NiROPAY KUMAR Roy Vat -32/A/2,, Ravvaunagaa. : FOr Ureag Rannanaman rok bist. UFtAR Ria Pomecwazoiwe fe cungoyt 4 F Campo? & 2 ‘Signature of the Recenang Otices wih sea! & catem4 aK 12 Deas regaring thi ecaérdic qunificatoes of the Candidate [rare econ E Srey | tose umes ese | Sues se | ifingg Yftwwese |/Beng [eeng.6 epi igen i 919 [oecHse || Beng Bors Ga. feo Iii | |Certities tra tre raformaton phitn under in No, 4.5.8,7.8.9,, 19,11 and 12 are tye to the Dest of my knowlodge 14 (linedie sag ay (ODOC) | Spr Raware Bey (Designation of the Atiesing Authorty i = TimaobaarahsTalafoke| [Signature of the candidate ia Engith 15] Oeciraion- Ga bere delve Pa have Carel eo ha soci af | have Gecided to appear a wis Cestnct uncer Salecton Test, 2009, that all the statemiiem mage and iformation provided 1 Ihis application fon ate true and correct. In the event of any of tha informalentntatement boing fou7d to be false of incotrest or ary inebgtoaty being detects bator or ater rsiseiectoe/recritendation fs ade my canddature/seiection a fable jo be cancelled and appropriate logata‘fon be intited against me exher by ine W.B Board of Primary Ecucaten, |or by the Government of West Bengali: by: beth Fai noketar dun Bal Signature of ne Ca z ‘—— otha candle) om Deana he Referee tooo Altres of re Retoree need {Tre Retro sol 289 te they 0 ante CAPT bates ah(a Father's /Husboa : VTAGNES WAR RAN Chaivinan bis rimry Setodl Covet+O Purba'Medinipur District Primary School Council Purba Medinipur Dist Admit Card %, renege RaaT Fenske 238 Erecanaantls gupee8 Sateger PS EVE “Vente hareny seisesidto cpanurin niles aanitnen of ruta Teooias 3008, dc ha Cra ef Wwaniaw you om asses ing toa tcening cocoa Cpgca! Wary Wt tte ef acon hy al a tam araiva (2 capes el pounpad uascoe ‘elegant on conse fog cane nine ay dvcato De barca bral bapa {Ak Soeur noel ann ty vee vrtate at yee Co of enarviede chjsgiies weaivaiont tor aga pteet, Font ozanalign which invicates Civ prool of mask aa monsins by the endeaste 8) SiGe iscs1 se eecnisins iea-eenvin cian Pasicaty hatonge cerficat a6 appicaboy i ta cor 1) Soveuersuter seurdg eucticet ary) as menboaad i a prespecten inlonealica Weooaary aia Sapdigata at tho iso olapotesioa form 2) Rapanui be 030 haa befor in carves ene, seviee Cais: casa02” Tea OAM Tate Be Tees [Pcs oftaarvinw Tsnnfois Moevkdyalay, Tain Pusba Medniper seks fn) Dawn a roues2 9 a cana by de Goa! ae ‘SickinPeot Tie Baas Dnclatten The Rlemaion is bry Gap. beans. see ceneate pba ara seca tainet emoaesintn irsortolon becine und aavidanacd daca tive to rw, To aso ee Sivan st nigutara cob sauigtonty esob/ a espana ory et Esha roi saie mes Armvexune-P( Purba Medinipur Distric. Primary School Counc!> Office ofthe = A pyrexire — ely ipur District Primary School Council Purba Medi Solgechhia (Station Rood) Taniluk, Purba Medinipur Memo Xion 3 sont The Chairman, urba Medinipur District nary Schoo! Counc! P,Q. Tamiuk, Dist. Purba Medinipur To: SiiHarerishnia at 5/0 Jogneswar Ranjit, Vill. Wutiber, P.O, Negua, ®.S. Egra, Dist, Purba fiwedinpur, Bin 721453 . Subs: Thenformation related to RT! Act 200! Retix His letter dated 03.01.2013 tn réferencd to shove, the following information is being stated hare under? Q..No. & itis informed that the candidate, Sri Herekrishna Ranjit’$/O Jagnesw2 800504} obtained the following scare in Primary Teachers Recruis } Academic Scare on i. {Excluding Additional Subject) ii)» Score in written test iv). "Score in Viva Voce Grand Tota The lowest score of panel (PC-EYE category) is 22.092 As the said candidate-obtains 22.08 which is lower than, the lowest scorv of the panel for the said cateyery, the appointment letter was not issued in favour of Sri Harekrishna-Ranjit having Enrolment No. 600504 It ls also lnformed ‘that due 10. clerical’ mistake! percentage of marks without additional subject we ‘Madhyaunik Pariskhia of the seid condidate wus. entered a6 78,75 instead of 68.75. For that ecadentic s:.1 «was recorded as 09.45 though actually it would: be 08.25. lythe mame of the said candidate i, empanelied. ‘But efter verification of acadernic records the mistake was noticed and course taking academic score 9s 08.25. Alter correction itis found that the total scowe o islowerthan tie lowest score of the panel, Accordingly, the namie of the ean she par id candiiave ate tes bu . No. 2: “Total 118 seats were reserved for PC Category for the Primary Teachers Recruitmenc -2 Q. No.3? Will be sent story. !tis for his kind information. " Ce Chairman 2 21 ¢Byrbo Mediniper Distriee Primary Schoat Sour Oe edArrrexwre- DA } RUGTSS FST SgERT TReST Court of Chief Commissioner for Person: Brits wa Ministry of Social Justice & Empowerment Banann ard &urr/ Department of Disability Affairs Case NoATH AS51213 Doted 22.08.204 Dispatch No.1 To fice of the Ce for Persons wilh Disadi 45, Ganesh Chandra Avenue. Kolkata - 709 013 Subject: Compisint dated 03.02.2013 received from Shirl Harekrishaa Ranjit, & person with 100% visual impairment regarding non-issuance of appointnienit Ie for appointment to the post of Prisiary Teacher ond Iil-treatment by the staf of Poorva Medinipur Distriel Primirary Teacher Recruits Madam, {) recaived trom Enel "by. Chief Cornmisatene! Copy ts 7 Shri Harekrishna Ranjit, You ate informed that in mattars cetating to S: Vilage-Huliber Governments end their _—_undectakings. 2.0. Negur. Commissioner for Persons wilh Disedises of toe Distriot - Purba Medinipur concernes Stale is the appropnale authcniy Ye. WAS. - 721448 are, therefore advised 10 pursue wath =: OP of Commissions: for persons. wiih Government of esl SSH tis sae 9 a sks, ag fReeh-rigbor / Serojini House. 5154 The / Fae 28386 aoe. (Plosce quciw bw abovu fleleate nuenbar at hniae cos eagcrdereYou are here Home>> Track Consignment Track Consignment * Indicates a required field. * Consignment Number RW6301161051N Event Details For : RW630116105IN Current Status : ttem Delivered [To: m (Addressee) Date Time Office 4990412023 18:40:48 | Tamluk HO (Beat Numbers4} Home About Us Forms Register Quick het Event lem Delivered [To: m (Addressee) } Recruitments Holidays Feedback Right To Information Tenders India Related sites Website Policies, Contact Us Employee Corner Sitemap Help External Links ee 9a) patil ets govint National Voters Service Portal India Code ‘owin! felt Hon aotal tackinalrackconclanment aspxsoe DISTRICT: PURBA ME IN THE HIGH COURT A? Cz CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT SD LAT P.A, Nof@20| of 2023 THE MATTER OF: - under Article 226 Petitioner -Versvs. ‘The State of Wes: Bengai & Ors Respondents WRIT Advocate-on-Record Ayan Banerjee Advecate High Court, Caloutta TA, KS. Roy Road, Vetendra Chamber’, 2nd Fivor Kolkata - 760001 Mobile-O83 1999395