Spoof Assessment For BAM7010-Report
Spoof Assessment For BAM7010-Report
Student Name
Student ID
Executive Summary
The chosen organisation here is Sainsbury’s Plc which is a UK-based supermarket company.
The report mainly investigates the strategic leadership issues within Sainsbury’s plc and
critically analyses the effectiveness of the organisational leadership styles and management
strategies, given the organisation’s strategic position. The report suggests that to make the
leadership and management framework of the organisation more effective and competent, the
leaders need to arrange formal meetings, training, and development for the managers so that
they can transform their leadership styles according to employees' preferences and
organisational needs to establish a comfortable and positive work culture
Page 1 of 21
Table of Contents
Introduction:...............................................................................................................................3
Conclusion/summary:..............................................................................................................10
Reference list:...........................................................................................................................11
Appendices:..............................................................................................................................14
Page 2 of 21
Introduction:
Background analysis of the organisation (position and performance):
The chosen organisation here is Sainsbury’s Plc which is a UK-based supermarket company.
It is a merchandise retailer organisation and it mainly runs via 2 main segments, namely
"Retail" and "Financial Services". The retail segment is engaged with retailing of food,
apparel/clothes, and general merchandise, and financial services include various financial
products such as credit cards, savings, loans and so on. Within the UK's retail sector,
Sainsbury tends to hold more than 16 percent of the total market share, right after TESCO
and ASDA, and it is the third largest supermarket in the United Kingdom market (Davies et
al., 2019). In 1922, the company was founded in London and as of now, the organisation has
been dominating the "UK retail industry" (Sainsbury's, 2022). The most significant strength
of the company is its global reputation, whereas one of its weaknesses is that it has some
leadership gaps from the managerial side, which further causes employees' dissatisfaction
(for a detailed SWOT analysis, refer to Appendix 1).
In the context of economic factors, Sainsbury's business performance gets affected. For
example, the rise in fuel prices tends to make it costlier in terms of transportation of goods
within and across the nation (Erdmann and Ponzoa, 2021). Thus, the supermarket businesses
like Sainsbury would have to account for “increased cost”.
This might manifest in terms of lower "profit margins" or "greater price tags" for the
customers, and in both cases, this would tend to decrease the total profitability (Bridger,
2022). In terms of social factors, Erdmann and Ponzoa (2021) note that the sociocultural
trends towards eating healthy also affect the business as it has to adapt to the demands of the
consumers for long-term success.
Page 3 of 21
Various recent technological advancements, such as the use of Big Data and AI principles,
have been enabling businesses to become more and more acquainted with their own
operations (Miller et al., 2019). Again, environmental factors also affect Sainsbury's business
position and performance as the supermarket chains are potentially responsible for huge
"carbon footprints", and due to the mounting environmental concerns, supermarkets like
Sainbury’s have to identify new ways to become more and more environment-friendly
(Miller et al., 2019). Furthermore, various legal ramifications of the “post-Brexit economy”
are another major factor that the brand must be prepared to encounter and it would be needed
to change many of its policies whilst running its outlets (al Habibi, 2019). (For further
information about the key external driving forces influencing Sainsbury’s performance, refer
to Appendix 2).
In order to adapt to these changing environments of the business successfully, the company
needs qualified leaders and managers. Aligning with the studies of Prince (2020), it can be
said that the increase in "Volatility, Uncertainty, Complexity, and Ambiguity (VUCA)"
makes it necessary for present-day businesses to seek for fresh and innovative leadership and
management approaches to ensure positive outcomes under the "changed circumstances" (al
Habibi, 2019). For example, to tackle the increasing deregulation within the service industry,
Sainsbury has to carry out a range of change activities such as effective scenario planning and
dealing with pandemic situations like COVID-19, increased automation, inventory stock
shocks, and so on. It tends to restructure its supply chains, deploy higher resource
concentration of resources, increase in-house operations and incorporate more delegations in
the value chain (Colley and Spyridonidis, 2022). (For more information about the way
Sainsbury’s Plc is managed and led in the VUCA environment, refer to “Appendix-3”).
Page 4 of 21
Leadership and management issues
The research by Prince (2020) suggests that most of the managers of Sainsbury are
“autocratic”, but the staff prefer the participative style (Hassan et al., 2020). Thus, it can be
said that there is somewhat a gap between the existing overall management and leadership
style and the overall preferences of the employees. Moreover, male managers are more
autocratic in nature than female ones. Erdmann and Ponzoa (2021) further suggest that with
autocratic leadership, short-term outcomes can be earned, but it will fail to gain long-term
outcomes. However, it is worth mentioning that "Justin King", the former CEO of the
company, is considered to be a great leader as he followed a democratic leadership style
(DuBrin, 2007). (for more information, refer to Appendix 4). Justin King, throughout his
career, always encouraged managers to refer to the employees as “colleagues” rather than
“Staff” (Gill, 2007). Also, the current CEO Simon Roberts is also a very experienced
commercial leader who follows a transformational leadership style.
As per Justin King, any organisational change is not possible without the proper and adequate
contribution of the other employees and hence during any big change, such as supply chain
restructuring, work culture change, and so on, the decisions have been taken in collaboration
with the other managerial staff (Thompson and Doherty, 2010). Moreover, the current CEO
of Sainsbury's Plc, Simon Roberts, is a very optimistic and resilient leader and tends to make
it quite easy for people to follow him. He tends to create positive energy within the team
members. He is known to be a transformational leader (refer to appendix 4 for more info). He
has revamped Shop floor structures and rebuilt the operational model of the business. He
believes in remaining approachable and undertakes "collaborative management styles". He is
highly pragmatic and adopts a "common sense approach" for making decisions.
Here, the advantages and disadvantages of the leadership styles of the two most popular and
phenomenal leaders of Sainsbury are discussed:
Again, considering the Behavioural theory (refer to Appendix-4), it can be said that Simon
Robert learned many skills like ardent technical skills, conceptual skills and human skills
(Stoner and Stoner, 2013). Technical skills help him to remain aware of the various
technological processes and techniques within businesses and human skills enable him to be
effectively interactive and enhance his communication skills (Tushman and Anderson, 2004).
Again, with good conceptual skills, he is able to come up with effective ideas for running the
organisation in a smooth manner. Thus, it can be seen Simon Roberts has both in-born
attributes and learned skills and hence he is partially a made, and partially a born leader.
It should be noted that some of the most daunting future challenges of Sainsbury include
“workers’ stress” and “supply chain challenges” (Wright and Taylor, 1994). To tackle these
challenges, effective risk management and stress management initiatives are necessary.
Hence, the leaders of the company need to call for potential "cost-saving programs", "logistic
operations", as well as "strong supplier relationships" and “employee engagement programs”.
Apart from that, to meet the present-day and future challenges, a supply chain restructuring is
required with a potential change management approach. It needs effective leadership and
change management skills to implement the changes successfully and to meet the future
challenges of the VUCA environment (Kim et al., 2021). In addition, Prince (2020) suggests
that most of the managers of Sainsbury are "autocratic", but the staff prefer the participative
style, which introduces a gap between the existing overall management and leadership style
and the overall preferences of the employees.
Thus, a change in the overall leadership and management style is required. Thus, the current
CEO, Simon Robert, can provide training to the existing managers on how to modify and
transform their leadership and management styles (Ali et al., 2021). Training and
development programs can help motivating employees and make ready for facing future
challenges and thus positively contributes to succession planning. They can consider the
"Lewin's change model" (refer to Appendix 5) for changing the management structure of the
organisation. However, it is not to be forgotten that the main limitation involved with
Lewin’s change model is the “insecurity amongst the managers” as they often get stressed
and tensed regarding their performances when a new change is introduced and thus the
Page 7 of 21
leaders may face resistance to change (Xiang et al., 2022). Since the managers were used to
work with autocratic leadership styles, they may worry about whether or not they can
successfully work with democratic leadership style causing “resistance to change”. Thus, to
overcome the resistance to change, the managers should be allowed enough time to get used
to their new leadership styles and the new organizational settings through effective training
programs, job-shadowing and so on.
Aligning with the suggestions of Miller et al. (2019), it can be said that with a happy and
dedicated workforce, any critical problem can be solved. In the case of Sainsbury's Plc, by
changing the management structure from autocratic to participative, the employees can be
encouraged to take part in the decision-making processes and collaborative initiatives can be
taken to further restructure their supply chains to meet future external challenges (El Sayad,
2022). Moreover, to build a high performing team and to understand the different phases
undergone by the employees while working together, and to manage their stress and conflicts
accordingly, the leaders and managers can consider “Tuckman’s model of team building”
which entail 5 stages namely, “Forming, Storming, Norming, Performing, and Adjourning”.
At Sainsbury’s plc, Simon, through this model can focus on the way his employees tackle
tasks from the “initial formation” through the completion of the task. Furthermore, to ensure
effective talent management, the leaders should employ advanced recruitment and screening
techniques such as Skills Testing, Asynchronous Video Interviews, Applicant Tracking
Systems and online research and also should deploy effective performance management
systems such as “Balanced Scorecard Method”, “Management By Objectives (MBO)”, and
so on (El Sayad, 2022).
With this method of team building, the team would be able to develop abilities, maturity,
relationships, as the leadership styles are changed by the leader (Miller et al., 2019). Each
stage of the team development process can be understood and in the storming stage, the most
stress and conflicts take place, and hence proper steps must be initiated by leaders to tackle
this (El Sayad, 2022). Employee engagement programs, regular meetings, appropriate
allocations of task and allowing effective communication amongst the staff would contribute
to stress management and conflict management.
Moreover, to develop better negotiation techniques, and to deal with different challenges and
conflicts, the employees can collaborate with future leaders and managers in the network
renewal process, acquisition of new systems technologies, processing and partnering and
Page 8 of 21
development of people culture (Vedhathiri, 2020). Collaboration and equal participation,
encouraged by a democratic or participative leadership style, would enable brainstorming of
ideas, splitting of workloads and also will foster innovation and creativity and hence would
improve and strengthen their negotiation skills. These are some of the important requisites to
meet the future challenges of the VUCA environment (Jones, 2022).
It is also important for Simon Roberts to remember that no single leadership style would be
enough to tackle the present day VUCA challenges and hence considering “contingency
theory” and “situational theory” of leadership (refer to appendix-7), it can be said that various
variables within a particular situation tend to decide the suitable leadership for that situation.
Therefore, Simon, along with his managers should always try to correspond their leadership
styles asper the need of the situations by evaluation different variables like types of tasks,
natures of the followers and so on. Therefore, aligning with the discipline of “Business
Process Management”, it can be said that the leaders and the managers need to combine
various methods such as discover, analyse, model, evaluate, enhance, optimise, and automate
the business processes for smooth and successful operation.
However, most male managers tend to practise autocratic leadership, which is opposed by the
employees and hence creates a gap between the expectations of the employees and the reality
(Jones and Comfort, 2021). Therefore, the lesson learnt here is that to make the leadership
and management framework of the organisation more effective and competent, the leaders
need to arrange formal meetings, training, and development for the managers so that they can
transform their leadership styles according to employees' preferences and organisational
needs to establish a comfortable and positive work culture (Paul, 2020). By practising
Page 9 of 21
democratic or transformational leadership, effective collaboration, brainstorming, innovation
and creativity can be fostered, which are required to address the future challenges of the
company (Roberts, 2018). However, it is also learnt that in the VUCA environment, no
particular leadership can be sticked to and there is a need to correspond leadership styles and
approaches according to need and nature of the situation.
Conclusion/summary:
The report has entailed a brief evaluation of a chosen organisation, that is, Sainsbury’s PLC
and its performance and position have been thoroughly evaluated within the relevant
industry. The report has also identified a range of key drivers that would impact the firm in
the future and will discuss the issues of leadership along with a critical evaluation of how the
company had been managed and led. It can be concluded that the leadership and management
style of Sainsbury's organisation, though considered to be competent but has flaws due to the
management teams. However, through proper training, communication and change
management, the gaps can be met and the organisation would become more competent to
meet future challenges.
Page 10 of 21
Reference list:
Adair, J., 2007. How to grow leaders: the seven key principles of effective leadership
development, London: Kogan Page.
Agile Scrum Guide., 2018. Tuckman's Model of Team Dynamics. Available at:
https://agilescrumguide.com/blog/files/Use-Tuckmans-Model-of-Team-Dynamics.html
(Accessed: December 5, 2022).
al Habibi, B., 2019. HR practices of Marks & Spencer, Selfridges, Primark, and
Sainsbury’s (Doctoral dissertation, University of Science & Technology).
al Habibi, B., 2019. HR practices of Marks & Spencer, Selfridges, Primark, and
Sainsbury’s (Doctoral dissertation, University of Science & Technology).
Ali, H., 2010. What Factors Contribute to Efficient Management of The Supply Chain of
Supermarket Within UK Retailers? Case Study―Sainsbury Supermarket PLC Supply
Chain.
Bridger, E., 2022. Employee engagement: A practical introduction (Vol. 24). Kogan Page
Publishers.
Carmichael, J.L., Collins, C., Emsell, P. and Haydon, J., 2011. Leadership and
Management Development, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Colley, J. and Spyridonidis, D., 2022. Making Decisions in a Volatile, Uncertain World.
In Unprecedented Leadership (pp. 41-63). Palgrave Macmillan, Cham.
Davies, A., Dolega, L. and Arribas-Bel, D., 2019. Buy online collect in-store: exploring
grocery click&collect using a national case study. International Journal of Retail &
Distribution Management.
DuBrin, A.J., 2007. Leadership: research findings, practice, and skills (5th Edition). New
York. Houghton Mifflin.
Page 11 of 21
El Sayad, S., 2022. Delineation of UK Retail Sector: An Actor-Network Perspective.
Academic Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies, 11(2), pp.83-83.
Erdmann, A. and Ponzoa, J.M., 2021. Digital inbound marketing: Measuring the
economic performance of grocery e-commerce in Europe and the USA. Technological
forecasting and social change, 162, p.120373.
Gandolfi, F. and Stone, S., 2018. Leadership, leadership styles, and servant leadership.
Journal of Management Research, 18(4), pp.261-269.
Gill, R., 2011. Theory and Practice of Leadership, 2nd edition, London: Sage.
Hassan, M.R., 2020. Theses Report On Identification Of The Role of Buying Office in
Developing Garment Product Quality and Promotional Strategy (Doctoral dissertation,
Jahangirnagar University).
Jones, P. and Comfort, D., 2021. Leading Retailers in the UK and Modern Slavery
Statements. International Journal of Sales, Retailing and Marketing, 10(2), pp.18-26.
Jones, P. and Comfort, D., 2022. Modern slavery statements and the UK’s leading food
retailers. Geography, 107(2), pp.107-110.
Jones, P., Wynn, M. and Comfort, D., 2020. SDG 12, Sustainable consumption and the
UK’s leading retailers. RESPONSIBLE CONSUMPTION AND PRODUCTION, p.7.
Kim, S.H., Lan, H. and Dobson, P.W., 2021. Identifying price-leadership structures in
oligopoly. Oxford Economic Papers, 73(1), pp.350-370.
Miller, S.K., Anganuzzi, A., Butterworth, D.S., Davies, C.R., Donovan, G.P., Nickson,
A., Rademeyer, R.A. and Restrepo, V., 2019. Improving communication: the key to more
effective MSE processes. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 76(4),
pp.643-656.
Parker, J., 2020. Ethnic diversity enriching business leadership. The Parker Review.
Page 12 of 21
Powell, D., 2019. Schools, corporations, and the war on childhood obesity: How
corporate philanthropy shapes public health and education. Routledge.
Prince, S., 2020. A Participative Style for Managing Sainsbury's Performance. Research
Gate.
Pulker, C.E., Trapp, G.S., Scott, J.A. and Pollard, C.M., 2018. Global supermarkets’
corporate social responsibility commitments to public health: a content analysis.
Globalisation and health, 14(1), pp.1-20.
Sinclair, A., 2007. Leadership for the disillusioned, Crows Nest, NSW: Allen and Unwin.
Stoner, C.R. and Stoner, J.S., 2013. Building Leaders: Paving the Path for Emerging
Leaders, London: Routledge.
Thompson, J.E. and Doherty, C., 2010. Be a Better Leader: Teach Yourself
Series. London: Hodder and Staughton.
Tushman, M.L. and Anderson, P., 2004. Managing Strategic innovation and Change,
Oxford: OU Press.
Warkentin, S., Mais, L.A., Ranganath, K., Jansen, E. and Carnell, S., 2020. Controlling
and less controlling feeding practices are differentially associated with child food intake
and appetitive behaviors assessed in a school environment. Pediatric Obesity, 15(10),
p.e12714.
Wright, P.L. and Taylor, D.S., 1994. Improving Leadership Performance: Interpersonal
Skills for Effective Leadership. 2nd ed. Hemel Hempstead, Herts: Prentice-Hall.
Page 13 of 21
Xiang, C., Zhang, J., Li, F., Fei, H. and Ji, D., 2022. A semantic and syntactic enhanced
neural model for financial sentiment analysis. Information Processing & Management,
59(4), p.102943.
Yukl. G., 2013. Leadership in Organisations (Global Edition), NJ: Prentice Hall.
Page 14 of 21
Appendices:
Appendix-1: SWOT analysis of Sainsbury’s Plc”:
Strengths: Weaknesses
Opportunities: Threats
Political Due to Brexit effects, leaving the EU might make it quite challenging for
"Sainsbury's Supermarkets" to affordably import products from abroad
whilst an increment in the costs of the foreign items will likely be passed
on to the final customers. These moves depict that the company need to
put great effort into ensuring the consumers keep on spending as much as
possible so as to maximise profits.
Economic The rise in fuel prices tends to make it more costly in terms of
Page 15 of 21
transportation of goods within and across the nation. Also, the "higher
wage movement" is mounting across Britain and Sainsbury's is expected
to address these to retain the stakeholders.
Social The socio-cultural trends towards eating healthy as unhealthy junk foods
are no longer entertained by the public. This trend towards making diets
healthier is an important trend that affects the business of supermarkets
like Sainsbury's as it has to adapt to the demands of the consumers for
long-term success.
Uncertaint In order to deal with uncertain situations such as "supply chain disruptions,
y "Sainsbury took notice of the "costs of disruptions" and has been trying to
diversify its Supply Chains at the cost of expensive operations.
Complexity In the current complex environment, the firm has to manage a range of
unrelated variables in the industry where it has little control over. In
complex situations such as geostrategic competitions, increased
globalisation, and so on., Sainsbury tends to become more dependent on the
aspects that are under their control and undertake a holistic approach to
manage situations such as reducing costs, increasing operational time and so
on.
Ambiguity A situation where the company has very little understanding of the macro
factors and does not have adequate tools to manage them is called an
ambiguous situation and to tackle such a situation, such as the aftermath of
the Covid-19 breakout, Sainsbury acts according to the situation, the need of
the hour, predict and plan and against the odds.
Page 17 of 21
leadership brings change within social systems and individuals. This
leadership style tends to bring positive and valuable changes within
the followers with the end goal of turning the followers into
leaders.
Great man theory The Great man theory of leadership suggests that some "in-born"
and "innate" attributes and qualities make an individual a leader,
such as personality, physical attributes, intelligence Quotient, and
many others.
Behavioural theory As per the behavioural theory of leadership, the way leaders behave
and assume their traits can be imitated by others and it suggests that
the leaders are not innately successful but are made so on the basis
of “learnable behaviour”.
Situational theory As per this theory, leadership styles and approaches depend on the
situation and hence by assessing the variables of a situations like
severity of task, nature of workers, and so on, leaders must have to
change their leadership styles.
Page 18 of 21
Appendix-5: Change management model and its limitations/complexities:
Principle: It entails 3 stages, namely, unfreeze>change> refreeze. The first step is to get the
workers prepared for change and to make them aware of the upcoming change and the need
for behind it. The second stage is about making required changes and the last stage ensures
that everything is in place as per the new changes. At Sainsbury, In the first stage (unfreeze),
the current structure can be dismantled, and in the second stage (change), managers can be
trained, and a new management structure can be formed, entailing participative and
transformational leadership, and this structure can be locked by refreezing in the third stage.
Limitations: It is quite time consuming and takes long to settle down and since the changes
often occur in VUCA environment, the leader face resistance to change from the managers,
the reason being the worries and stress about their performances within the changed system.
Page 19 of 21
Appendix-6: Tuckman’s team building model
Page 20 of 21