AFE Report
AFE Report
Akshesh Patel
Carleton id: 101244369
uOttawa ID: - 300273741
Abstract
Expansive soil is a problem soil that damages civil engineering structures all around
the world. Foundation problems are frequently caused by expansive soil, also known
as shrink-swell soil. Expansive foundation soils will "heave," causing a building or
other structure to elevate during periods of excessive precipitation. Expansive soil
will "collapse" during periods of decreased soil moisture, which can result in building
settlement. Damage can be severe in any case. Expansive soil can also cause
lateral movement by exerting pressure on the vertical face of a foundation,
basement, or retaining wall.
These soils, which are typically found in arid and semiarid locations and contain a lot
of clay minerals, are mostly found in arid and semiarid places. Large parts of the
southwest and western United States, including Oklahoma, Texas, Colorado,
Nevada, California, Utah, and others, have expansive soils. Large parts of India and
Australia (also referred to as black cotton soils), South America, Africa, and the
Middle East also have these soils (Bowels, 1988; Kalantari, 1991; Murphy, 2010).
During both dry and wet seasons, it's not straightforward to spot the expansive soils
on the field. During dry seasons, the maximum width of these types of soil can reach
over 20 meters, while during wet seasons, they become extremely sticky and difficult
to travel. The existence of surface cracks in expansive soil deposits also indicates
the potential for swelling soils to expand. In the laboratory, a variety of classification
approaches are employed to identify expansive soils. There is currently no uniform
classification system; different approaches are utilized in different parts of the United
States. Typical ways include using Atterberg limits and/or clay size % to categorize a
soil's expansion potential as low, medium, high, or extremely high. Soils classed as
CL or CH in the USCS, as well as A-6 or A-7 in the AASHTO classification systems,
might be considered expansive in general (Kalantari, 1991; U.S. Department of
Transportation, 2006).
Moisture-induced volume changes can cause problems for foundations built on
expansive soils. The volume changes that occur are a consequence of a variety of
variables, including the soil qualities, the moisture condition (suction) at the time of
construction, the degree of change in moisture condition, its variation over time and
space, and the structure's shape and stiffness. Moisture change causes volume
change beneath the structure, which occurs in unsaturated soils above the
groundwater table. For residential buildings, where there is a propensity to utilize
more empirically based solutions, the behaviour of unsaturated soils is frequently not
properly and/or appropriately evaluated.
Literature review
Types of foundations for structures in expansive soil areas can be classified as:
Shallow foundation
1. Individual footing or isolated footing
2. Combined footing
3. Strip foundation
4. Raft or mat foundation
Deep Foundation
1. Pile foundation
2. Drilled shafts or Caissons
3. Cofferdams
Suitability of foundation
Spread Footing: The base of a Spread Footings foundation is wider than that of a
standard load-bearing wall. When the bearing soil layer is within 3 m (10 feet) of the
ground surface, these footings are used. The weight must be supported by the soil
bearing capacity of the structure across the structure's base area These foundations
should not be utilized on soils where there is a risk of groundwater flowing over the
bearing layer and causing Scour. When expansive strata are thin enough to locate
the footing in a no expansive stratum below which differential movement is
insignificant, shallow footings can be used. Because of the narrow width of the
footings, placing significant loads on them may not be helpful in mitigating high swell
pressures. Unless the expanding soil layer is thin, the stress placed on the soil is
very low below a depth of about twice the footing width and contributes nothing to
offset the swell pressure.
Combined footing: A combination of footings Supports two columns, one of which
is so near to the other that its separate footings would overlap. At the property line,
one column is placed. The centroid of the footing and the C.G. of the column load
should be the same.
It is supplied on the following terms: When the soil's bearing ability is reduced,
additional space under individual footing is required.
Strip footing:
Strip footing is appropriate when the soil has less swelling pressure due to its
expansive nature. When the soil swells, the sand grains will move up to relieve the
strain. These foundations are often utilized to support medium loads. Strip
foundations can be utilized in a variety of sub-soils, however, they are best suited to
soils with a high carrying capacity. They're especially well-suited to light structural
loads, such as those seen in many low-to-medium-rise household structures, where
mass concrete strip foundations can be utilized. Reinforced concrete may be
necessary for other circumstances.
Pile Foundation:
A Pile foundation is a type of deep foundation which is used to transfer heavy loads
from the structure to a hard rock stratum much deep below the ground level. Pile
foundations are used to transfer heavy loads of structures through columns to hard
soil strata which is much below ground level and where shallow foundations such as
spread footings and mat footings cannot be used. This type of foundation is also
used to prevent the uplift of the structure due to lateral loads such as earthquakes
and wind forces. The pile foundations resist the loads from the structure by skin
friction and by end bearing. The use of Pile foundations also prevents settlements of
foundations.
Deep foundations, such as concrete piers for significant structures that must be
bottomed below a perched water table to have acceptable bearing capacity, may
result in heave of parched expanding subsoils when moisture seeps down the pier.
The pier and bell diameters can be chosen to provide high column loads and bearing
pressures on the soil beneath the footing, balance soil-swell pressures, and reduce
deep foundation heave (despite moisture seepage beneath the footing). The column
loads can be raised for a given structural weight by expanding the span between
footings and decreasing the size of the footings. An additional benefit of extending
the span distance between footings is that the structural member will rotate less
angularly for the same amount of vertical movement. As a result, the amount of
disruption in the structure is reduced. To simplify construction, reduce contractor
equipment on the job site, and save money, pier diameter variations should be kept
to a minimum in the foundation.
Medium to high compressibility and plasticity, as well as high shrinkage and swelling
qualities, describe black cotton soil. Because of this, black cotton soil is also known
as expansive soil, and its geotechnical features must be researched before any
construction can be built on top of it. The presence of montmorillonite, which is
characterized by substantial volume changes from wet to dry seasons and vice
versa, dominates the mineralogy of this soil. In the laboratory, the physical and
geotechnical qualities of the soil samples were investigated. Grain size analysis,
specific gravity, Atterberg’s limits, standard proctor compaction, consolidation, and a
direct shear test were all performed. The collected results were compared to the
Standard codes. Empirical models established in this work with the use of regression
analysis can help site engineers better understand the parameters involved in
describing the features of black cotton soil with medium plasticity and its usage as a
construction material in roads and foundations.
• Immediate settlement (Se) is the portion of the total settlement (S) that is meant to
happen when loading is applied:
𝐇
𝐒𝐜 = 𝐦𝐯 ∆𝛔𝐝𝐳
𝟎
𝐂𝛂𝐇 𝐭𝟐
𝐒𝐬 = 𝐥𝐨𝐠
𝟏 + 𝐞𝐏 𝐭𝟏
The settlement for suitable foundations is determined, and we may select the
appropriate foundation in black cotton soil based on this.The most essential feature
of the soil is that when it is dry, it shrinks and becomes as hard as stone, with a very
high bearing capacity. When the soil is wet, however, it expands, softens, and loses
its bearing capacity. It expands to 20 percent to 30 percent of its original volume and
applies pressure as a result of its expansive nature. The upward pressure exerted
gets so great that the foundation begins to lift upwards. The foundation's reverse
pressure generates fissures in the wall above. The fissures are thin at the bottom
and widen as they progress up the mountain. As a result, research into the types and
suitability of foundations for expansive soils, as well as foundation comparisons, is
required.
Conclusion:
Black Cotton Soil is a bad foundation material for construction due to its
unusual features. Black cotton soils are also low in strength and experience a
lot of volume variations, making it difficult to use them in building. As a result,
laboratory test reports are needed to determine soil type prior to construction,
and the results are compared to the Standards Code.
The foundation should be built or dug to a sufficient depth to safeguard the
structure from structural damage caused by soil swelling or shrinking.
Furthermore, the foundation must convey loads to the earth without
generating settlements or other moments large enough to impair or destroy
the structure or limit its overall usefulness, necessitating research into the
many forms of foundations.
Before deciding on a construction project, it's a good idea to research the
suitability of each form of foundation.
A comparison of foundations should be used to make the final foundation
choice.
Factors affecting for Heave: Because of the multiple elements that determine
the amount and rate of in situ swell, accurate heave estimates are extremely
difficult to come by.
Pore water composition, clay mineralogy, clay mineral quantity, and cation
type and concentration.
Organization. Geometry, specific surface area, bonding, platelet arrangement,
fissures and slickensides, dry density, and permeability are all factors that
must be considered.
Attitude and stratigraphy Expansive layer dip and strike, expansive stratum
thickness, stable stratum depth above expansive soil, bedding, and
stratification
Previous environment and climate, seasonal depths effect, initial desiccation
degree, vegetation coverage, and stress history
Rainfall, watering, leaking water lines, drainage pattern, ponding, depth to and
character of the water table, amount of covered area, and hydrogenases all
affect water availability after construction.
Structure and overburden pressures are referred to as surcharge pressures.
Time - The initial availability of water and the amount of time it took for it to
become available in diverse regions.
Temperature - As the temperature rises, moisture will migrate to colder
locations.
References
Vinayak Kaushal, "Geotechnical investigation of black cotton soil"- published
in Research gate in 2015.
“Department of the Army USA, Technical Manual TM 5-818-7, Foundations in
Expansive Soils, 1 September 1983.”
B.A.Mir, Deptt of Civil Engineering, National Institute of Technology, in 50TH
INDIAN GEOTECHNICAL CONFERENCE. in 2015.
Soil mechanics and foundations by A.R.Arora.
Soil mechanics and foundations by Dr.B.C.Punimia, Ashok Kumar Jain, Arun
Kumar Jain
G.Fulzele, V.R.Ghane, D.D.Parkhe, "Study of structures in black cotton soil"-
submitted to International Journal of Advances in Science Engineering and
Technology, ISSN: 2321-9009, Vol-4, Iss-4, Spl. Issue-2 Dec.-2016.
IS – 1904: 1986 – Design and construction of foundation in soils (General
requirements).
B.M.Das, Principles of foundation engineering.
Donaldson, G. W., "The Occurrence of Problems of Heave and the
Factors Affecting Its Nature," Proceedings, Second International
Research and Engineering Conference on Expansive Clay Soils,
18-20 Aug 1969» Texas A&M University, College Station, Tex.,
pp 25-36.
2. Holtz, W. G. and Gibbs, H. J., "Engineering Properties of Expansive
Clays," Proceedings, American Society of Civil Engineers, Vol 80,
Separate No. 516, Oct 195*+*
3. International Panel Review, "Status of the Art of Dealing with
World Problems on Expansive Clay Soils," Engineering Effects of
Moisture Changes in Soils; Concluding Proceedings, International
Research and Engineering Conference on Expansive Clay Soils, 1965*
pp 15-30.
McDowell, C., "The Relation of Laboratory Testing to Design for
Pavements and Structures on Expansive Soils," Quarterly, Colorado
School of Mines, Vol 5*+, No. Oct 19595 PP 127-153.
5. Woodward-Clyde & Associates, "A Review Paper on Expansive Clay
Soils," Vol 1, 1 9 6 7 » Los Angeles, Calif.
6. Jones, D. E., Jr., and Holtz, W. G., "Expansive Soils— The Hidden
Disaster," Civil Engineering, Vol ^3, No. 8, Aug 1973, pp ^9-51«
7. Holtz, W. G. , "Expansive Clays— Properties and Problems," Quarterly,
Colorado School of Mines, Vol 5^, No. U, Oct 1959, PP 89-125*
8. Engineering Foundation, "Expansive Soils," Newsletter, Feb 1968,
United Engineering Center.
9. DeBruijn, C. M. A., "The Mechanism of Heaving," Transactions, South
African Institution of Civil Engineers, Vol 5, Sep 1955, PP 273-278.
10. Hamilton, J. J., "Swelling and Shrinking Subsoils," Canadian Building
Digest 8U, Dec 1966, Ottawa, Canada.
11. Jennings, J. E. and Kerrich, J. E., "The Heaving of Buildings and
the Associated Economic Consequences, with Particular Reference to
the Orange Free State Goldfields," Civil Engineer in South Africa,
Vol U, No. 11, Nov 1962, pp 221-2U8.
https://trid.trb.org/view/121219
https://ascelibrary.org/doi/abs/10.1061/AJGEB6.0000059
https://ascelibrary.org/doi/abs/10.1061/40890(219)4
https://ascelibrary.org/doi/abs/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-
9364(1984)110:3(359)?casa_token=cZ8RL2-
KO0sAAAAA:JCs92afkSxXeDC4cXedjUbzWaupdsaICcrVIxsqb9jAbUT6ftjAPjf
Vely-LXHAxS-UvErLAtVJg
https://journals.co.za/doi/abs/10.10520/EJC24998
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/269195415_Evolution_of_Foundatio
n_Design_for_Expansive_Soils
Nelson, John & Overton, Daniel & Chao, Kuo Chieh. (2006). Evolution of
Foundation Design for Expansive Soils. 62-75. 10.1061/40890(219)4.
https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/A-Critical-Review-on-Foundations-in-
Expansive-Soils-Obulreddy-
Kumar/817060d88096fcc5c0158577a88f683a7d57c79a
DeBruijn, C. M. A., Jr., "Swelling Characteristics of a Transported
Soil Profile at Leeuhof Vereeniging (Transvaal)," Proceedings,
Fifth International Conference on Soil Mechanics and Foundation
Engineering, Paris, Vol 1, 1961, pp ^3 -^9 -
35- Kantey, B. A. and Donaldson, G. W., "Preliminary Report on Level
Observations at Leeuhof, Vereeniging," National Building Research
Institute Bulletin No. 9, Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial
Research Organization, Dec 1952, pp 7-2U.
36. Gizienski, S. F. and Lee, L. J., "Comparison of Laboratory Swell
Tests to Small Scale Field Tests," Engineering Effects of Moisture
Changes in Soils; Concluding Proceedings, International Research
and Engineering Conference on Expansive Clay Soils, 1965.
37- U. S. Army Engineer District, Fort Worth, CE, "Investigations for
Building Foundations in Expansive Clays," Vol 1, Apr 1968, Fort
Worth, Tex.
38. Carlson, C. A., "Apparatus and Tests for Determining Negative Pore
Water Pressure Characteristics of Desiccated Clays," Miscellaneous
Paper S-69-20, May 1969, U. S. Army Engineer Waterways Experiment
Station, CE, Vicksburg, Miss.