Module 3 Indian Contract Act (Special Contract)
Module 3 Indian Contract Act (Special Contract)
1. Law of Indemnity
2. Law of Guarantee
3. Law of Bailment
4. Law of Pledge
5. Law of Agency
Q1. EXPLAIN CONTRACT OF INDEMNITY
I] MEANING:
as a contract
by which one party promises to save the other
from the loss caused to him
either by the conduct of the promiser or any other person
Indemnifier Indemnity-holder
I] MEANING:
as a contract
to perform the promise or discharge the liability
of third person
in case of his default.
B
A
Creditor
Principal Debtor
C
Surety
The term “Guarantee” is a promise to pay a debt owed by a third person in case the
latter does not pay.
One who accepts One who grants the One who gives guarantee of
the debt/loan debt/loan debt on behalf of Principal
debtor to the Creditor
1. The Liability of Principal Debtor is PRIMARY and the liability of Surety is SECONDARY.
3. In case of default, the Creditor has the right to file suit either only against the Surety or
against both (but the suit cannot be filed solely against the Principal Debtor)
In the continuing guarantee, the liability of surety continues, until the guarantee is
withdrawn/revoked.
3. BY DISCHARGE OF SURETY:
If the principal debtor is discharged (released) from his liability, then the surety’s
liability also ends.
Q4. EXPLAIN HOW SURETY IS DISCHARGED FROM ITS LIABILITIES UNDER LAW OF
GUARANTEE
I] MEANING:
The term discharge means “to release” or “to free”
The primary liability is of the Principal debtor and the secondary liability is of the
Surety.
The liability of surety is co-extensive with that of principal debtor
If any variance (changes) is made without the knowledge and consent of the surety,
between the Principal Debtor and the Creditor, then the surety is discharged from the
transaction subsequent to the variances.
The liability of surety is co-extensive with that of principal debtor. Thus if the Creditor
discharges the Principal Debtor from his liability, then automatically the surety is
discharged.
If the Creditor compounds (settlement) with the Principal debtor, may be accepts a
lessor amount of loan or gives more time, and then the surety is discharged, unless the
surety assents to such compounding.
If the creditor uses the security provided by the Principal Debtor, then the surety is
discharged to the extent of value of security.
Ex. A took loan from B for an amount of Rs.1 lac and provided a jewelry box worth 1 lac
as a “security” and C acted as a surety for A. Now if B, on failure to repay the loan by A,
sells of the jewelry, the C (surety) is discharged.
7. BY MISREPRESENTATION [SECTION 142]
When the creditor misrepresents the surety regarding any material facts, then the
guarantee is INVALID and therefore the surety is discharged.
When the creditor obtains guarantee by concealing (hiding) or keeping silent over the
material facts, then the guarantee is INVALID and therefore the surety is discharged.
If the surety was promised that there shall be co-surety then the creditor will not act
upon until such co-surety joins, otherwise the guarantee is INVALID and therefore the
surety is discharged.
When the agreement is made by the Creditor with a 3rd person to allot/give some time
to the Principal Debtor, and not actually with the Principal Debtor, THEN the surety is not
discharged.
Mere forbearance (patience) to sue the Principal Debtor by the Creditor does not
discharge the surety.
Ex. B owes C a debt guaranteed by A. The debt has become due and payable. C does not sue
B for a year after the debt has become payable. A is not discharged from his liability.
Out of many co-sureties, if the Creditor releases one of them, then the other sureties are
not discharge from their responsibility.
Ex. Ex. X, Y, Z are co-surety to B. Now, B releases X. Y and Z are still liable for their part of
liability.
Q5. EXPLAIN THE RIGHTS AND LIABILITIES OF A SURETY
I] MEANING:
A Surety provides “Guarantee” i.e. a promise to pay a debt owed by a third person
in case the latter does not pay.
On default by the Principal Debtor and on payment of his obligation there are
certain rights enjoyed by Surety.
On payment by surety for the obligation of the Principal Debtor to the Creditor, the
Surety is subrogated to the position of a creditor.
Surety may now sue the Principal debtor, just like a Creditor had right to sue.
On payment by the surety for the obligation of the Principal Debtor to the Creditor,
the Surety is entitled to all the securities that the Principal debtor has given to the
Creditor.
Surety
Any loss incurred by the Surety on account of Principal Debtor, then Surety is entitled to
recover from the Principal Debtor whatever sum surety has rightfully
When 2 or more persons are co-sureties for the same debt jointly , whether under the
same or different contracts, with or without the knowledge of each other, then the co-
sureties are liable as between themselves, to pay each an equal share of the whole
debt.
Ex. A, B , C are joint sureties to D for a sum of Rs.30,000/- lent to E. Now E makes default in
payment. Here A, B, C are liable for a sum of Rs.10,000/- each
The liability of the surety is co-extensive with that of the Principal Debtor i.e. as long as
the Principal Debtor is liable the surety is liable. Once the Creditor releases the Principal
Debtor the liability of surety will automatically cease.
Q6. EXPLAIN CONTRACT OF BAILMENT
I] MEANING:
BAILOR BAILEE
GRATUITOUS NON-GRATUITOUS
BAILMENT BAILMENT Ex. I take care of my neighbor’s pet cat,
when my neighbor is out of town. I don’t
charge any amount for taking care. This
Bailment without Bailment for amounts to Gratuitous Bailment
consideration consideration
IV] ESSENTIALS OF BAILMENT:
1. Contract
In bailment, the goods are delivered from bailor to bailee for a temporary period.
Upon delivery there is a transfer of possession, not ownership.
Delivery can be actual or constructive.
I] MEANING OF BAILMENT
If the bailee, with the consent If the bailee, without the consent of
of bailor mixes the goods of bailor mixes the goods of bailor
bailor with his own goods with his own goods
It is the duty of the bailor to deliver the goods to the bailee and
thereby handing over the possession of the goods.
The bailor is bound to disclose to the bailee all faults in the goods
which might put the bailee into an extra-ordinary risk while using
the bailed goods.
Where the bailor was not entitled to make bailment or to give directions with
respect to the goods and if due to defect in bailor’s title, loss is sustained by the
bailee- the bailor is liable to pay the damages to the bailee.
Where the bailee is does any act for consideration (Gratuitous bailment) and the
bailor demands the goods back before the time period or before the purpose is
accomplished, then the bailee is entitled to be indemnified by the bailor, in case
of any loss suffered.
Q8. EXPLAIN THE RIGHTS, DUTIES & LIABILITIES OF BAILEE
I] MEANING OF BAILMENT
It is the duty of bailor to make the bailee aware as to any material defects in the
goods.
In case of bailor’s goods mixed with the bailee’s good with the
consent of the bailor, the bailee can claim proportionate share
in the mixed goods.
Due to defect in bailor’s title, if the bailee has suffered any losses then the bailee
has the right to claim damages for the same.
Under the contract of bailment, if the bailee has incurred any expenses with
respect to the bailed goods, then it shall be the rights of bailee to get it
recovered from the bailor.
6. To claim indemnity
Under the contract of bailment, if any loss has caused to the bailee with respect
to the bailed goods, then it shall be the rights of bailee to be indemnified from
the bailor.
Under the contract of bailment, it shall be the rights of bailee to claim for
remuneration under the contract of bailment and if the remuneration is not paid
then the bailee has the right to lien (retain/withhold) on the bailed goods.
III] BAILEE’S DUTIES
It is the duty of the bailee to take care of the bailed goods like a
prudent (ordinary) man.
The bailee should take reasonable degree of care like a person
does for his own goods.
It shall be the duty of the bailee not to make any wrongful use of goods.
It shall be the duty of the bailee not to mix his own goods with the bailed goods.
Upon receipt of all remuneration, expenses, claims, it shall be the duty of the
bailee to return bailed goods to the bailor.
I] MEANING:
Bailment of goods
As a security for payment of a debt or performance of a promise
Is called pledge.
II] PARTIES: Ex. Mr. A took a loan of Rs.2 lac and pledged
his car against the loan as a “security” that
when Mr. A will pay the amount the car be
released.
PLEDGOR PLEDGEE
III] ESSENTIALS:
I] MEANING OF PLEDGE:
It is the right of pledgor to redeem (repay the debt) and take back his pledged goods,
even if the pledgor makes default to make the payment at the stipulated time. He can
still redeem the debt by paying some extra expenses.
The pledgor has the right to see that the pledgee, preserves the goods pledged and
maintains it like any ordinary person maintains its goods.
The pledgor enjoys all the rights and protection of an ordinary debtor.
1. Right of Retainer
The pledgee may retain (hold back) the goods pledged until the entire dues are paid.
The entire dues include the principal amount, interest, any expenses incurred etc.
When the pledgee lends some more money to the same pledgor, it will be presumed
that the right of retainer extends even on the subsequent advances.
Ex. A took a loan of Rs.50,000/- and pledged his car worth of Rs.2 lacs. A, later took further
loan of Rs.30,000/-. Now the pledgee can retain the pledged goods for total amount of
Rs.80,000/-
3. Right to extra ordinary expenses
If the pledgee has incurred some extra ordinary expenses for preservation of the
pledged goods then the pledgor shall reimburse the same to the pledgee.
I] MEANING:
The General Rule, “Only the true owner can pledge the goods”
However, exception states that in certain cases pledge “non-owners” would also be
considered as valid pledge.
In possession of
However, if for some reason after sale, the goods are with
goods AFTER sale
the SELLER and the seller pledges the goods, it would be a
valid pledge.
Can create a
Valid Pledge
I] MEANING:
“Qui facit per alium facit per se” he who does the act through another does it himself
Therefore, for all the acts of agent, the principal is liable. Principal
No consideration is required to create an agency [Section 185]
Agent
II] WHO CAN BECOME AN AGENT AND PRINCIPAL:
1. BY AGREEMENT
2. BY NECESSITY
4. BY RATIFICATION
1. SUB AGENT
2. SUBSTITUTE AGENT
When the agent names another person to act for the principal for a specific transaction, then
that is a Substitute agent.
For the acts of Substitute agent, the principal is responsible.
When a person untruly represents himself to the authorized agent of the other, and thereby
inducing the 3rd party to deal with him as an agent, is called Pretending Agent.
It is a false representation of authority on the 3rd party, of which the principal shall be unaware.
Thus, the 3rd party can file a suit against the pretending agent personally.
V] TERMINATION OF AGENCY
2. By operation of law
I] MEANING OF AGENCY
AGENT
POWER/AUTHORITY/RIGHTS DUTIES LIABILITIES
-to do all lawful things -not to delegate his authority -Liable for the acts of sub-agents
-to act prudently to protect -use discretion in selecting an -Liable to account for profits
-to appoint agent for the principal -conduct business as per the -For loss due to acting contrary to
-to renounce agency -to render proper accounts -For loss due to neglect/want of
skills
-to claim compensation for pre- -to communicate all facts to the -Liable for fraud
representative
-to retain sums received for the -to disclose material facts
principal
I] MEANING OF AGENCY
PRINCIPAL
POWER/AUTHORITY/RIGHTS DUTIES LIABILITIES
To ratify agent’s act To pay remuneration To pay remuneration
To disown agent’s act To pay for any expenses To pay for any expenses
To claim profit/loss due to acting To compensate the agent for To compensate the agent for
misrepresentation of agents
************************************************************************************************
Note: Distinguish between has to be studied from your respective textbooks