Risk 4 Question
Risk 4 Question
3. What techniques are commonly used to determine the loss amount in property insurance?
4. How does replacement cost less depreciation method work in determining actual cash value?
6. What are the three methods used by courts to determine actual cash value?
9. Explain replacement cost insurance and how it differs from other methods of determining indemnity.
10. Why is life insurance considered a valued policy and not a contract of indemnity?
14. How does legal liability create an insurable interest in property insurance?
16. Can life insurance be purchased on someone else's life without an insurable interest? If not, why?
17. How does the timing of insurable interest differ between property insurance and life insurance?
18. Why is the existence of insurable interest crucial at the time of loss in property insurance?
19. In what type of insurance must insurable interest be met only at the inception of the policy, not at
the time of loss?
20. Why is it important for beneficiaries in life insurance to have insurable interest at the inception of
the policy?
Answer
1. The fundamental purpose of the principle of indemnity in insurance contracts is to prevent the
insured from profiting from a loss and to reduce moral hazard.
2. The principle of indemnity prevents moral hazard in insurance by ensuring that the insured does not
stand to gain financially from a loss, thus discouraging intentional or reckless behavior that could lead to
claims.
3. Common techniques used to determine the loss amount in property insurance include actual cash
value, replacement cost less depreciation, fair market value, and the broad evidence rule.
4. The replacement cost less depreciation method works by calculating the current price of a new item
of like kind and quality (replacement cost) and then subtracting the decrease in market value due to
wear and tear, age, and economic obsolescence (depreciation).
5. Example of calculating actual cash value using depreciation: If a 5-year-old car with a useful life of 20
years suffers a total loss due to fire and has a replacement cost of $120,000, the depreciation would be
$30,000, resulting in an actual cash value of $90,000.
6. The three methods used by courts to determine actual cash value are replacement cost less
depreciation, fair market value, and the broad evidence rule.
7. Exceptions to the principle of indemnity in insurance contracts include valued insurance policies,
replacement cost insurance, and life insurance.
8. A valued insurance policy pays the face amount of the policy when a total loss occurs, and it is used
when determining the actual value of the property at the time of loss is difficult.
9. Replacement cost insurance pays for the replacement value of the loss without any deduction for
depreciation, providing full reimbursement for the insured's loss.
10. Life insurance is considered a valued policy because it pays the specified sum to the beneficiary at
the time of the insured's death, rather than reimbursing for actual losses.
11. The principle of insurable interest in insurance contracts states that the insured must be in a position
to lose financially or incur some other kind of harm if a loss occurs.
12. The purposes of insurable interest in insurance contracts include preventing gambling, reducing
moral hazard, and measuring the amount of the insured's loss in property insurance.
13. In property and liability insurance, insurable interest can be supported by ownership of property,
legal liability, secured creditors, or contractual rights.
14. Legal liability creates an insurable interest in property insurance when a person or entity has a
responsibility to safeguard or care for property that does not belong to them.
15. In life insurance, insurable interest must exist for anyone purchasing insurance on someone else's
life, typically satisfied by close ties of blood or marriage or a pecuniary interest.
16. Life insurance cannot be purchased on someone who is more remotely related or unrelated unless
the beneficiary would suffer a financial loss from the insured's death.
17. The timing of insurable interest differs between property insurance and life insurance, with property
insurance requiring it to exist at the time of loss, while life insurance requires it at the inception of the
policy.
18. The existence of insurable interest at the time of loss is crucial in property insurance because it
ensures that the insured has a financial stake in the property being insured.
19. Insurable interest must be met only at the inception of the policy, not at the time of loss, in life
insurance because life insurance is a valued policy that pays a specified sum to the beneficiary at the
time of death.
20. It is important for beneficiaries in life insurance to have insurable interest at the inception of the
policy to ensure that the policy is valid and that the beneficiary would suffer a financial loss from the
insured's death.
1. What is the principle of subrogation in insurance contracts, and what is its main purpose?
5. Describe the legal doctrines that support the principle of utmost good faith.
6. What are representations in insurance contracts, and how do they relate to the principle of utmost
good faith?
9. What is a warranty in insurance, and how does it impact the validity of a contract?
12. What conditions must be satisfied for multiple insurance policies to contribute to the same loss?
15. How does primary and excess insurance work in determining insurance payouts?
18. Why is the principle of contribution essential for upholding the principle of indemnity in insurance
contracts?
19. How does the concept of contribution apply in cases where multiple insurance policies cover the
same loss?
20. What are the implications of contribution for insurers and policyholders in insurance contracts?
Answer
1. The principle of subrogation in insurance contracts refers to the substitution of the insurer in place of
the insured for the purpose of claiming indemnity from a third party for a loss covered by insurance. Its
main purpose is to prevent the insured from collecting twice for the same loss, to hold the negligent
person responsible for the loss, and to help keep insurance rates down.
3. The principle of utmost good faith in insurance contracts imposes a higher degree of honesty on both
parties to the contract. It requires the applicant for insurance to make full and fair disclosure of the risk
to the insurer, ensuring that any information known to one party is also known to the other.
4. Key aspects of utmost good faith in insurance include full disclosure of risk by the applicant, honesty
in representations and disclosures, and the obligation of both parties not to attempt to deceive or
withhold material information from each other.
5. The legal doctrines that support the principle of utmost good faith include representations,
concealments, warranties, and mistakes.
6. Representations in insurance contracts are statements made by the insured on the insurance
application to determine insurability and premium rates, aligning with the principle of utmost good
faith.
7. Misrepresentations can affect an insurance contract if they are material, relied upon by the insurer,
and false. If the insured intentionally fails to disclose material facts, the insurer may have grounds to
avoid coverage.
8. Concealment in insurance contracts refers to the intentional failure of the applicant to reveal material
facts to the insurer, potentially leading to voiding of the contract if the insured knew the facts were
important and intended to defraud the insurer.
9. A warranty in insurance is a promise made by the insured in the contract, and any breach of warranty,
even if immaterial, can void the contract.
10. Express warranties are stated in the insurance contract, while implied warranties are not found in
the contract but are assumed by the parties.
11. The purpose of the principle of contribution in insurance is to prevent the insured from profiting
from multiple insurance policies and to support the principle of indemnity.
12. Multiple insurance policies can contribute to the same loss if they relate to the same subject matter,
cover the same interest of the insured, cover the same peril, and are in force at the time of loss.
13. The pro-rata liability clause in insurance contribution means that each policy pays a portion of the
loss proportional to its amount over the total amount of all policies for the loss.
14. Contribution by equal shares in insurance means that each company pays an equal amount until the
loss is covered or the policy limit is reached, with remaining insurers making equal payments for any
uncovered loss.
15. Primary and excess insurance work by having the primary insurer pay first, and the excess insurer
pays only after the primary policy limits are exhausted.
16. In a scenario with primary and excess insurance, if a liability risk exceeds the primary policy limit, the
excess insurer becomes payable for the remaining amount up to its limit.
17. The concept of contribution prevents the insured from profiting from multiple insurance policies by
ensuring that each policy pays its fair share of the loss, thus avoiding overcompensation for the insured.
18. The principle of contribution is essential for upholding the principle of indemnity in insurance
contracts by ensuring that the insured is indemnified for the actual amount of the loss without receiving
double compensation.
19. Contribution applies in cases where multiple insurance policies cover the same loss by distributing
the responsibility for paying the loss among the insurers involved.
20. The implications of contribution for insurers and policyholders in insurance contracts include
ensuring fairness in compensation, preventing overpayment for losses, and promoting financial stability
in the insurance industry.
1. What is the doctrine of proximate cause in insurance, and how does it relate to the principle of cause
and effect?
2. Explain the principle of proximate cause and its application in determining insurance coverage.
3. How does the selection of proximate cause impact the determination of insurance coverage?
4. What is the significance of distinguishing between insured, excepted, and uninsured perils in
insurance contracts?
5. Describe a scenario where the selection of proximate cause might be challenging in determining
insurance coverage.
6. In the scenario provided, how much will each insurance company pay to Ato Abebe, and why?
7. How does the principle of indemnity apply to Ato Abebe's situation with multiple insurance policies?
8. What amount can Ato Abebe claim in total, and how is it calculated based on the contributions from
each insurance company?
9. Why is it not possible for Ato Abebe to claim compensation from both the insurance companies and
the wrongdoer, Ato Kebede?
10. Why is an understanding of the legal interpretation of insurance contracts important for a risk
manager?
11. What functions do insurance contracts serve, and why is it essential for both parties to understand
their rights and responsibilities?
12. Explain the distinguishing features of insurance contracts, including their personal, unilateral,
conditional, aleatory, and adhesive nature.
13. What does it mean for an insurance contract to be a contract of utmost good faith, and how does it
affect the obligations of both parties?
14. Describe the concept of a contract of indemnity in property and liability insurance contracts.
15. What are the requirements for a valid insurance contract, according to the law of contracts?
16. Explain the elements commonly found in a valid insurance contract, including the application,
binders, policy forms, and endorsements.
17. What information does the application for insurance typically include, and why is it important?
19. What are the common provisions included in policy forms, and what information do they provide?
Answer
1. The doctrine of proximate cause in insurance refers to identifying the nearest cause leading to the
loss, which is the direct cause of a loss event. It is based on the principle of cause and effect, focusing on
the immediate cause that produces the result. This doctrine disregards remote or distant causes and
selects the immediate cause based on common sense standards. In insurance, coverage is provided only
for insured perils named in the policy, not for uninsured perils. Therefore, selecting the proximate cause
is crucial in determining whether the loss is covered by insurance.
2. The principle of proximate cause is applied in insurance to determine coverage by identifying the
immediate cause of the loss event. It focuses on the cause that is primary to the occurred event,
disregarding remote causes. This principle is essential in differentiating between insured perils covered
by the policy and uninsured perils not mentioned in the policy.
3. The selection of proximate cause impacts the determination of insurance coverage by identifying the
immediate cause of the loss event. This cause must be an insured peril named in the policy for the loss
to be covered by insurance. It helps differentiate between covered and uncovered losses, ensuring that
insurance compensation is provided only for insured perils.
4. Distinguishing between insured, excepted, and uninsured perils in insurance contracts is significant for
determining coverage. Insured perils are those specifically named in the policy for which coverage is
provided. Excepted perils are risks explicitly excluded from coverage. Uninsured perils are those not
mentioned in the policy and, therefore, not covered by insurance.
5. A scenario where the selection of proximate cause might be challenging in determining insurance
coverage could involve a loss event caused by multiple simultaneous events or sequential events. In
such cases, identifying the immediate cause that triggered the loss becomes complex, requiring careful
analysis to determine coverage under the policy.
6. Each insurance company will contribute to the loss based on the proportion insured by the
policyholder. In this scenario, Ato Abebe can claim the amount of loss, Birr 200,000, from both Ethiopian
Insurance Company (EIC) and Awash Insurance Company (AwIC). EIC will contribute 60% (Birr 120,000),
while AwIC will contribute 40% (Birr 80,000) to cover the loss.
7. The principle of indemnity applies to Ato Abebe's situation with multiple insurance policies by
ensuring that he is compensated for the actual amount of loss suffered, without profiting from the loss.
Therefore, Ato Abebe can claim compensation up to the total amount of the loss from both insurance
companies, but not more than the actual loss incurred.
8. Ato Abebe can claim a total of Birr 200,000, which is the amount of the loss, from both Ethiopian
Insurance Company (EIC) and Awash Insurance Company (AwIC). EIC will pay Birr 120,000 (60% of the
loss), while AwIC will pay Birr 80,000 (40% of the loss), based on their respective proportions insured.
9. Ato Abebe cannot claim compensation from both the insurance companies and the wrongdoer, Ato
Kebede, due to the principle of indemnity and subrogation. The principle of indemnity prevents the
insured from profiting from the loss, while subrogation allows the insurer to recover the amount paid
for the loss from the negligent third party.
10. Understanding the legal interpretation of insurance contracts is important for a risk manager for
several reasons. It helps in deciding whether to use insurance or other risk management tools,
understanding the insurer's promises under the contract, and knowing the rights and responsibilities of
both parties involved.
11. Insurance contracts serve various functions, including defining the risk to be transferred, stating the
conditions of the contract such as premiums and acts to be performed, and explaining the procedure for
filing loss claims. It is essential for both parties to understand their rights and responsibilities under the
contract to ensure compliance and effective risk management.
12. The distinguishing features of insurance contracts include their personal nature, unilateral nature,
conditional nature, aleatory nature, adhesive nature, and principle of utmost good faith. These features
shape the rights and obligations of the parties involved and influence the interpretation of the contract
by courts.
13. A contract of utmost good faith in insurance means that both parties are bound to disclose all
relevant facts to each other and cannot take advantage of the other party's lack of information. This
principle ensures transparency and fairness in insurance transactions.
14. A contract of indemnity in property and liability insurance contracts means that the insured should
not financially benefit from the occurrence of the insured event. Instead, the insured should be
compensated for the actual amount of loss suffered, without making a profit.
15. According to the law of contracts, a valid insurance contract must satisfy certain conditions,
including serving a legal purpose, making a definite offer and acceptance, providing consideration,
involving legally competent parties, and not being contrary to public interest.
16. A valid insurance contract includes various documents and conditions, such as the application,
binders, policy forms, and endorsements. These documents outline the terms of the contract, including
coverage, premiums, conditions, and modifications.
17. The application for insurance typically includes information about the insured, the property or risk
being insured, the desired coverage, and other relevant details. It is important for assessing risk and
determining the terms of coverage.
18. Binders in insurance contracts are temporary documents that provide coverage for a limited period
until the policy is issued. They serve as evidence of insurance coverage during the underwriting process.
19. Policy forms in insurance contracts contain various provisions, including declarations, insuring
agreements, exclusions, conditions, and endorsements. These provisions outline the terms and coverage
provided by the policy.
20. Endorsements in insurance contracts are forms used to modify the terms of the policy. They may
add, remove, or alter coverage, conditions, or exclusions based on the insured's needs or changes in risk
factors.
2. Which technique is commonly used to determine the actual cash value of a loss in property
insurance?
B) Market speculation
A) To increase premiums
B) To encourage gambling
5. Which of the following constitutes an insurable interest in property and liability insurance?
A) Ownership of property
B) The beneficiary
7. What is the requirement for insurable interest in life insurance at the time of policy inception?
B) Life insurance
C) To promote gambling
10. Which of the following best describes the principle of indemnity in insurance contracts?
A) Lack of ownership
C) Secured creditors
D) Contractual disagreement
12. Which method is used to determine the fair market value of a property loss in insurance?
C) Market speculation
13. What does the broad evidence rule involve in determining actual cash value?
D) To ensure a valid and legal relationship between the insured and the subject matter
Multiple choice questions
A) Preventing the insured from collecting twice for the same loss
3. What does the principle of utmost good faith entail in insurance contracts?
4. Which of the following legal doctrines supports the principle of utmost good faith?
A) Subrogation
B) Concealment
C) Warranty
D) Contribution
B) Promissory warranties are made by the insurer, while affirmative warranties are made by the
insured.
C) Promissory warranties apply only at the inception of the policy, while affirmative warranties apply
throughout the policy term.
D) Promissory warranties relate to actions the insured agrees to undertake, while affirmative
warranties relate to factual statements attested by the insured.
8. Which type of contribution involves each insurance company paying an equal amount until the loss is
covered or policy limits are reached?
B) To prevent the insured from collecting twice for the same loss
C) To discourage subrogation
10. When does the excess insurer pay in primary and excess insurance arrangements?
11. What is the primary objective of the principle of subrogation in insurance contracts?
12. What is the key requirement for an insurance company to deny payment for concealment?
13. In primary and excess insurance arrangements, when does the excess insurer pay?
14. Which type of warranty applies only at the time the insurance contract is first put into effect?
A) Promissory warranty
B) Affirmative warranty
C) Implied warranty
D) Express warranty
2. Why is it necessary to differentiate between insured peril, excepted peril, and uninsured peril in
insurance contracts?
3. Which legal doctrine states "cause proximate non remote spectator" in relation to insurance
contracts?
C) Principle of Subrogation
D) Principle of Indemnity
B) Because the insured has fulfilled their promise by paying the premium
B) The insurer can refuse to perform if the insured does not satisfy certain conditions
A) Aleatory contract
B) Personal contract
C) Unilateral contract
D) Conditional contract
8. What characteristic of insurance contracts allows courts to interpret ambiguous provisions in favor of
the insured?
A) Personal contract
B) Unilateral contract
C) Contract of adhesion
A) Contract of adhesion
C) Personal contract
D) Aleatory contract
10. Why are insurance contracts considered contracts of utmost good faith?
12. What is a requirement for a valid insurance contract according to the law of contracts?
13. What is the purpose of the declarations section in an insurance policy form?
A) To identify the insured and describe the property or life being insured
A) To set forth the facts and figures required by the insurance company
C) Because the insured usually does not participate in drafting the contract