PTJ 99 9 1242
PTJ 99 9 1242
T
he First and Second Physical Therapy Summits on Global Health (2007 and 2011) S. Gylfadóttir, PT, MSc, Physical Ther-
paved the way for the Third Summit (2015), the focus of this Perspective article, apy, Reykjalundur Rehabilitation Cen-
and its findings related to establishing minimal accreditable health competency ter, Mosfellsbaer, Iceland, Europe.
standards in the profession. These standards relate to health promotion and disease A. Jones, PT, PhD, Discipline of Phys-
prevention with special reference to noncommunicable diseases (NCDs). NCDs were a iotherapy, Faculty of Health Sciences,
priority given they are leading causes of morbidity, disability, and premature death The University of Sydney; and De-
partment of Rehabilitation Sciences,
worldwide and increasingly so in low- and middle-income countries.
The Hong Kong Polytechnic University,
Hong Kong, Asia Western Pacific.
The prime focus of the 3 summits was on the role of physical therapists in reducing the
S.K. Veluswamy, PT, PhD, Department
knowledge translation gap between evidence supporting healthy lifestyle choices and
of Physiotherapy, Ramaiah Medical Col-
the practices of health professionals, including physical therapists, to promote healthy lege and Hospitals, Bangalore, India,
lifestyles with targeted examination/assessment of every patient’s and client’s health and Asia Western Pacific.
lifestyle behaviors and targeted interventions, including health education and exercise
The gap between the unequivocal evidence regarding the relationship between lifestyle
and NCDs and lack of systematic intervention to address this gap in health services has
been referred to as the “ultimate knowledge translation gap.”3 An international
benchmarking study of physical therapist curriculum content related to health promotion
and NCD prevention supports this contention,4 first documented by Rea and colleagues.5
Given that education is a primary focus of standard practice, physical therapists are
uniquely positioned to assume a leadership role in knowledge translation related to
NCDs and their risk factors, and the minimization of these.
health policy levels and pave the way for other health continuously and seamlessly support sustained healthy
professional groups.8 The study reported by Ketkar and lifestyles in patients and clients.
colleagues9 is an example of physical therapists assuming
a leadership role and spearheading a health promotion The social and economic costs of lifestyle behaviors are
and NCD prevention initiative in the workplace, a health well recognized by governments. One seminal study
service setting for employees, as a basis for informing examined lifestyle behaviors of registrants with the
institutional health policy. Using established screening and National Health Service in the United Kingdom over 1
evaluation methods for NCDs, the investigators year. Based on a sophisticated economic analysis, the
documented poor dietary practices, suboptimal blood investigators reported that the greatest contributors to
pressures, and physical inactivity as leading modifiable health care costs in descending order of economic impact
risk factors in the cohort, a cohort that might be inclined were diet, smoking, being overweight, alcohol
to be more mindful of their lifestyle practices and status. consumption, and physical inactivity.13 Further, recent
The data provided a basis for targeted health education evidence supports that these costs can be mitigated with
Table 1.
Health Competency Definitions
Health Health promotion aims to enhance health through public policy, healthy social and The Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion. First
promotion physical environments, healthy lifestyle practices, and personal resilience. “Making International Conference on Health Promotion,
the healthy choice the easy choice” is part of the health promotion movement. Ottawa, November 21, 198626
(http://www.who.int/healthpromotion/conferen
that the HIC has been systematically adopted by any of Therapy Summit on Global Health reflected on
WCPT’s member organizations. We based this observation evidence-based health examination/assessment tools and
on direct questions to the Summit participants about their health behavior change
familiarity with the tool and their knowledge of their or strategies/interventions/approaches across the WCPT
others’ use of it clinically. regions and establishing health competency standards
across regions.21
Based on these lines of reasoning and evidence, the
Summit team initiated a global forum to review the status Health Competency Standards: Principles
of health promotion and NCD prevention within the
profession and tools related to health competencies, and Recommendations
including use of the HIC, and how these could be more Three overarching principles underlying health
effectively profiled and operationalized to facilitate their competencies in physical therapist practice emerged: (1)
uptake into practice. This would be a singular their theoretical and practice foundations; (2) the construct
achievement not only for the physical therapist profession of health-focused practice; and (3) that health promotion
but as an example to other health professions. and NCD prevention need to be shared competencies
across health professionals. Recommendations for health
competencies include minimum standards for
The Physical Therapy Summits on Global examination/assessment tools to inform health promotion
Health and NCD prevention interventions, and for behavior
An outcome of the First Physical Therapy Summit on change interventions. Interventions broadly focused on
Global Health was that physical therapists are the leading, counseling for smoking cessation, healthy nutrition,
established, largely nonpharmacological health maintaining a healthy weight, reduced sitting and being
professionals, and they have a primary role in addressing physically active, optimal sleep, and manageable stress.
global health priorities, specifically, the lifestyle-related Part of the intervention competencies was knowing, based
NCDs.19 No doubt exists that for prevention and on the examination/assessment, when to refer the patient
management of the chronic stages of the NCDs, or client to another established health
nonpharmacological interventions (health education and professional.
physical activity and structured exercise) are the
interventions of choice as noted in clinical practice Principle: Incorporate Into Physical Therapist
guidelines related to the prevention and management of Education and Practice the Theoretical and
NCDs. Outcomes of the Second Physical Therapy Summit Practical Foundations of Health Competencies
on Global Health were global regional action plans that A theoretical and practice foundation reflected in the
focused on health and NCD prevention in every patient established specialty of behavioral medicine served as a
and client.20 These were developed by regional working foundation to guide and inform lifestyle-related behavior
groups in a World Café dialogue format and published. change competency standards within established physical
Based on the 2 previous summits, the Third Physical therapist practice. Behavioral medicine is defined by the
International Society for Behavioral Medicine as “an would occur throughout the entire episode of physical
interdisciplinary field dealing with the integration of therapist services. To effectively adopt this framework, the
psychosocial, behavioral, and biomedical knowledge of process depends on the health professional’s self-efficacy
relevance for health in health protection and health to effect lifestyle-related behavior change in patients and
promotion, diagnosis, treatment, and rehabilitation.”22 An clients, that is, to enhance their self-efficacy to effect such
offshoot of behavioral medicine is lifestyle medicine, change and know when to refer to other professionals.
which singularly focuses on the knowledge, skills, and Previous work supports the fact that physical therapists
competencies needed to protect and promote health.23 value health protection and health promotion practice, yet
The American College of Preventive Medicine and key they report a lack of confidence in their capacity to effect
stakeholders propose having an important role in ensuring such change.31–34 Evidence of barriers toward health
lifestyle medicine practices and programs are based on behavior change have been supported by Abaraogu and
proven and effective methods of preventing and colleagues.35–37 Dean and colleagues29 recently published
controlling disease.24 Clinical practice guidelines for an example of how 1 entry-to-practice physical therapist
Principle: Incorporate Into Physical Therapist Lifestyle behavior changes most importantly need to
include smoking cessation; a healthy anti-inflammatory
Education and Practice Health-Focused Practice
diet (ie, plant-based diets such as the Mediterranean
Health-focused physical therapist practice can be defined
diet38,39 rather than the standard Western diet40 [also
as health promotion and NCD prevention practices that
referred to as the American diet]); reduced or non-harmful
target a patient’s or client’s overall health and well-being
alcohol consumption; healthy body weight; less sedentary
consistent with the WHO’s definition of health.19,25 Such
behavior; regular physical activity and exercise; better
practice is underpinned by the WCPT-supported
quality sleep; and less unmanageable stress, anxiety, and
International Classification of Functioning, Disability, and
depressive symptoms. The standard Western diet has been
Health1 and the definitions of health protection and health
reported to underlie the NCD pandemic in Western
promotion by The Ottawa Charter26 (Tab. 1). Health is
societies and other societies that are increasingly adopting
defined by the WHO as a complete state of physical,
this eating pattern.40 Lifestyle behaviors, like taking
social, and emotional well-being, not simply the absence
medications, can interact not only positively or negatively
of disease; and, health promotion is defined as “the
by possibly altering the pharmacodynamics of
process of enabling people to increase control over, and to
medications, but they may also augment the beneficial
improve, their health. To reach a state of complete
effects of each other, additively or multiplicatively.
physical, mental and social well-being, an individual or
group must be able to identify and realize aspirations, to
A component of teamwork to which physical therapists
satisfy needs, and to change or cope with the
aspire is the notion of cross-referral. For coordinated
environment.” The WHO has long advocated for lifestyle
seamless health care, physical therapists, like other health
behavior change given the evidence supporting its
professionals, need to identify what is within their scope
long-term health benefit.27 Further, in its Global Strategy
of practice-given health competencies and what is not.
on Diet, Physical Activity, and Health,28 the WHO
They need competencies to judge when to refer patients
promoted and provided support for educating health
to other health professionals, both for physical and mental
professionals about healthy nutrition and physical activity,
health issues.
either within existing programs or in dedicated
workshops, as an essential component of the curricula for
Health-based studies are needed to elucidate these
entry-level health professions’ education and postgraduate
relationships so that the invasive practices of physicians
professional development.29
and surgeons can be better integrated with noninvasive
practices, such as those of physical therapists (the largest
Principle: Incorporate Into Physical Therapist established noninvasive health professional group). Over
Education and Practice That Health Competencies time, as the benefits of a healthy lifestyle take effect for
Need to Be Shared Across Health Professionals the patient and client, health professionals can better
An example of an algorithm for interprofessional titrate invasive and noninvasive interventions and
collaborative practice in health protection and promotion procedures to the patient’s or client’s needs. By so doing,
practice appears in an article by Dean and colleagues,30 drug usage can be reduced and surgery avoided or
and it is designed to ensure that such practice is replaced with less invasive or noninvasive interventions.
expedient, seamless, and cost-effective. The process is
reflexive, that is, the examination/assessment, initiation, Recommendations for Standards for Health
intervention, and reinforcement are done by the physical Competencies
therapist or initiated by the therapist and with referral to We recommend that the minimum standards for health
another health professional. Then, ongoing evaluation competencies that emerged from the Third Physical
Therapy Summit on Global Health be adopted into Integral to health protection and health promotion
globally endorsed accreditation standards for physical practices are interprofessional practices and cross-referral
therapist practice. Further, these competencies should be to appropriate health practitioners. In summary, a
recommended for adoption by all established health psychosocial perspective to physical therapist practice was
professions to ensure that seamless attention to the viewed as a foundation requirement based on the
patient’s or client’s needs is consistent across health principles encompassed in the established specialty of
service providers, and that due priority is given by health behavioral medicine.22
professionals to reduce the risk of patients and clients
falling through the cracks in terms of overall health and
NCD risk factors. Broad categories of lifestyle behavior Recommendation: Health and Lifestyle Behavior
change appear in Table 2, and more specific details are on Examination/Assessment Tools Be Core Physical
a dedicated website.41 Therapist Competencies
Core competencies related to health and lifestyle behavior
Table 2.
Categories of Health Behavior Change Tools in the Tool Kit of the Centre of Excellence in Health Competencies for Health
Professionals: Examination/Assessment and Interventions/Strategies41,a
Life satisfaction
Participation in life
Self-report measures
Objective measures
Mental health: well-being (states of anxiety, stress, and depressive symptoms) Assessment/evaluation/strategies
use clinically. The Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion. is at least at the contemplative stage of readiness to change
First International Conference on Health Promotion, a behavior, then the 5 “A”s, endorsed by the WHO, can be
Ottawa, November 21, 198626 (http://www.who.int/health initiated, namely, ask, advise, assess, assist, arrange.51
promotion/conferences/previous/ottawa/en/) However, if the patient or client is not expressing
readiness to change a targeted behavior, that is, the
precontemplative stage, then the 5 “R”s can be initiated,
Recommendation: Health Protection, Health namely, relevance, risks, rewards, roadblocks, repetition.52
Promotion, and NCD Prevention Interventions Be
Core Physical Therapist Competencies
Core competencies related to lifestyle behavior change Recommendation: Behavior Change Theories and
interventions appear in Table 2 and more specifically in Models Underpin Core Health Promotion and
the eAppendix. After the examination/assessment of the NCD Prevention Competencies in Physical
various lifestyle-related characteristics and personal Therapist Practice
attributes, the patient’s or client’s readiness to change each Multiple behavior change theories and models have been
lifestyle-related behavior is established based on the advanced and underpin behavioral medicine, the elements
transtheoretical model.50 Stages of change include of which can be used by physical therapists to effectively
precontemplative, contemplative, preparation, action, promote health behavior change in their patients and
maintenance, and potential relapse. If the patient or client clients. These include social learning theory,53 the
transtheoretical model,50 the health promotion model,54 individual to effect health behavior change through
the health belief model,55 theory of planned behavior,56 knowledge and skill set.53 Comparable to other accredited
and goal-setting principles. Practical behavioral physical therapist competencies deemed best practice by
approaches useful as a component of professional bodies, these competencies need to be taught
examination/assessment and intervention include progressively and integrated across semesters and years in
cognitive behavior therapy,57 behavior modification or the academic program. This is assured through various
operant conditioning,58 mindfulness and meditation,59 and multimodal formats, for example, the theoretical
motivational interviewing.60 foundations followed by clinical practice of the
competencies, initially in the classroom and then clinically
Practitioner as well as patient and client self-efficacy under supervision.
warrants special attention given it has been a
long-standing construct in health service delivery and Clinical reasoning related to lifestyle behavior change has
forms the basis of many patient and client been documented as a unique competency by Elvén and
self-management approaches. Self-efficacy has become a colleagues.62 These investigators published a clinical
central construct in health promotion and NCD prevention reasoning model for health behavior change with special
education. For patients and clients to develop self-efficacy, reference to physical therapists increasing physical activity
health professionals need self-efficacy in assessing the in their patients and clients. The model, informed both by
need for health promotion/NCD prevention education in established theory and evidence, elucidates a process
their patients and clients, in selecting and providing the algorithm for examining/assessing patients and clients,
appropriate intervention(s) with targeted and tailored and potential tools for effecting person-centered
health promotion recommendations and advice, and in management. The model is reflexive, that is, response
evaluation of their effects. This process is comparable to driven, to maximize health behavior change outcomes and
examination/assessment and prescription of interventions their sustainability.
that constitute established physical therapist practices. In a
special report to the American Heart Association with Based on the extant literature, health professionals need
respect to the need to examine translational applications to serve as health role models as well as advocates. With
of dietary recommendations to maximize long-term respect to health service delivery, physicians who practice
adherence, Van Horn and colleagues61 described several healthy lifestyles have been reported to be not only more
methods, yet they acknowledged this was an area of likely to address health promotion with their patients and
knowledge deficit for practitioners. clients63,64 but also viewed as more credible by patients.65
Consistent with this body of knowledge, we support the
Originally, Bandura conceptualized self-efficacy largely as principle of The Patient Promise66 initiative that provides a
the function of 2 factors: (1) the importance to the person public forum for health professions to pledge to both live
of the behavior to change and (2) the confidence of that a healthy lifestyle and support this in their patients. The
Figure 2.
Health Improvement Card (Source: World Health Professions Alliance, 2017, with permission).18
a work in progress, which like other scholarly endeavors, primarily nonpharmacological profession, needs to
warrants ongoing scrutiny and refinement. assume a leadership role in establishing minimum
accreditable health promotion and NCD prevention
Physical therapists could well be the first health competencies that could also be integrated into the
profession in the world to be truly committed to the practices of medicine and nursing and potentially
overall health and NCD prevention in every patient and dentistry and pharmacy. Such a position is highly
client, and to serve as leaders to other health professions. consistent with the profession’s commitment to best
They are uniquely and strategically well positioned to practice and the ethical standards of the WCPT.
assume a leadership role vis-à-vis health professionals’ Incorporating health competencies into standard practice
integrating lifestyle examination/assessment and would be a bold initiative, in that it would constitute a
interventions into their practices. We argue that the “first” within and across the leading established health
physical therapist profession, as the largest established, professions. Finally, this position is highly consistent and
aligned with the tenets of Hippocrates to which all health Data analysis: V. Mkumbuzi, K. Mostert, A. Söderlund, U.O. Abaraogu
professionals need to aspire: “first do no harm” and “the Project management: E. Dean, M. Skinner
function of protecting and developing health must rank Providing institutional liaisons: D. Shirley
even above that of restoring it when it is impaired.”67 Clerical/secretarial support: E. Dean
Consultation (including review of manuscript before submitting): E. Dean,
M. Skinner, H. Myezwa, V. Mkumbuzi, K. Mostert, D.C. Parra, D. Shirley,
With respect to the United States, Healthy People 2020 has
A. Söderlund, A. Dornelas de Andrade, U.O. Abaraogu, S. Bruno, D. Clark,
been a primary initiative to improve the health of the S. Gylfadóttir, A. Jones, S.K. Veluswamy, C. Lomi, M. Moffat, D. Morris,
population.68 It aspires to many of the same tenets as A-K. Stensdotter, W.P. Wong
those of the WHO’s documents over the years.69,70 Healthy
People 2020 constitutes a nationwide database. This Funding
database has provided an evidence base for public health
There are no funders to report.
planning in the country and development of health
behavior change initiatives across stakeholders. In Disclosures
47 Grundy SM, Pasternak R, Greenland P, Smith S, Jr, Fuster V. 59 Harvard Medical School. Positive Psychology. Boston, MA:
Assessment of cardiovascular risk by use of Harvard Medical School Press; 2011. Harvard Medical School
multiple-risk-factor assessment equations: a statement for Special Health Report.
healthcare professionals from the American Heart Association
and the American College of Cardiology. Circulation. 60 Rollnick S, Miller WL, Butler C. Motivational interviewing in
1999;100:1481–1492. health care: helping patients change behavior. New York, NY:
The Guilford Press; 2008.
48 Canadian Task Force on Preventive Health Care (CTFPHC),
Public Health Agency of Canada. CanRisk: are you at risk for 61 Van Horn L, Carson JA, Appel LJ et al. Recommended dietary
diabetes? https://canadiantaskforce.ca/wp-content/uploads/ pattern to achieve adherence to the American Heart
2016/05/2012-type-2-diabetes-canrisk-en.pdf. Published Association/American College of Cardiology (AHA/ACC)
2013. Accessed March 28, 2019. guidelines: a scientific statement from the American Heart
Association. Circulation. 2016;134:e505–e529.
49 Harvard School of Public Health. Healthy Heart Score.
62 Elvén M, Hochwälder J, Dean E, Söderlund A. A clinical
https://healthyheartscore.sph.harvard.edu/. Accessed June 8,
2019. reasoning model focused on clients’ behaviour change with
reference to physiotherapists: its multiphase development
50 DiClemente CC, Prochaska JO. Toward a comprehensive, and validation. Physiother Theory Pract. 2015;31:231–243.
transtheoretical model of change: stages of change and