CH 14 Company Law
CH 14 Company Law
event
company
Bankruptcy Voluntaryordered I . Winding I. ActAsper ) MODES ceases
exist. to
or for
creditors there tSec. Dissolution
Winding grounds
Winding members paymentdebts(u) MEANING
lite
leading insolvency or Windingup of
liquidation
up of
wants is the
a 2 OF
14
winding or
defaultspecified of (944), of
toCode, corporate up company up WINDING isthcompany.
e
its to resolution the
liabilities, and of to of OF
under by under company.
last
company
endclose2016 winding WINDING
up by Tribunal
hasdown the under may the stage The
Insolvency
person
occurred company where of company to bemeansv up UP
Insolvency in isItaprocess meansa
Sec.under proCess
NCLT, th e
220 as (.e. UP
thethere and 271 swinding process
distribution (ii) process
of
or under the and and C
period
for company) its
is situations and Sec. and winding
H
Bankruptcy results which
some no operational petition 270Bankruptcy upunder
of
bringing WINDINGUP A
default of Sec.
of
winding up an
other its
59 ariseitself the
involves PT
duration filed ofsurplus,
up. in
by of makes Code, Companies applicable. Code,
as
this
reason the wherecreditors On end E
dissolution (i))
the under ,2016 Act dissolution
Insolvency
has (i.e. realisation the R.
company
voluntarily. liquidation an 2016 if
.the any,
expired application or Sec. Act ,amongst
operations
financial :272: Companies of
where on company.
company of
orand and or t he assetS,
is the and
that for
company th e CIRP debtsthere
of
WINDING
or Registrar friendly as (SEC. Under
where on
remedies justimmediately it interests follows: be shall is is
misconduct
in be for default
up of
initiated of
is arise
Insolvency UP
just filingwound fraudulent have under resolved wound Rs.
Winding
it and and relations
or 270) where crore
1 in
isare and wi th been this any of be pay
consideredequitable management the up as &
equitable
not preceding connection up; in other with that Bankruptcy
the conducted
and Act, sovereignty by per Voluntary
windingup
under
up
efficacious the Tribunal the
basis Registrar unlawful person
the foreign company Sec.
just that of Tribunal provisionsthe of Code
is five its authorised in 59
and
enough. granted consecutivethe therewith
its a States, and under
of
affairs
purpose
fraudulent be IBC
equitable company financial is integrity wound 221
of public Sec.
Fol only and have or the by
UNITV:DIVIDENDS. AUDIT AND WINDINGUn
222 CH. 14:WINDING UP
223
(1) Where the sub-stratum of the company is
Cofee Co. (1882), the mainobject for
which
the gone:company
In re le)
personauthorised bythe
any Central Government in that behalf; or
An order shall be made within ninety days from the date of company liquidator shall make the periodical reports to the Tribunal.
the petition.
Before appointing a provisional liquidator under
shall give notice to the company and afford areasonable
pres ntaion s
clause (C), the
FinalreportshallbeesubmittedtotheTribunal
The
2. Rejection of
approve of the
resolution plan; or liquidation: or ximum
days to prepare memorandum resolution plan by
NCLT on technical
containing relevant information
3. The debtor resolution plan by NCLT,
submitted to it on 180 for formulating resolution plan grounds
(i.e, technical grounds; or Or
to theresolution
person
Company and NCLT finds themakes an
charge toapplication
be
plan and
NCLT to liquidate
Resolution plan approved
by 66%** of creditors at the
approve resolution
plan
4. AA does not
receive a genuine; and meeting of Committee of Or
Note: The entire process resolution plan within the specified time Creditors On application by
been under frame. adversely affected
depicted step wise in FigureInsolvency
14.2.
and
Bankruptcy Code, 2016 has Resolution plan approved
NCLT
shall pass
person
Or
order for
by AA AA does not receive
liquidation a resolution plan
Company shall be within the specified
restructured and revived time frame.
AND WINDING UD CH. 14:WINDING UP
UNITV:DIVIDENDS, AUDIT 229
228
14.2: Home VOLUNTARY WINDING
1. Explanation for*in the Diagram buyers not \es UP (UNDER SEC. 59 OF IBC) AND
orNote:
not lessthan10% oftotal number of allottees, whichever is less,
to NCLT in case of
default. ,are
thaN AS PER
PROCESS
REGULATIONS, 2017 W.E.F. APRIL 2017
INSOLVENCY AND
make an application 14,2:66%(value of l0% SSUED
BY BANKRUPTCY BOARD OF INDIA
in the Diagram
2, Explanation for**creditors) by lBC Code (Second
the fcAmendment
reditors) )
ass
for 75% (value of
w.re.f. 6/6/2018.
Details of Corporate InsoBvency
Resolution
(CIRP) cases as on September 30, 2023 Process su bstiued hapterVofthe Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 deals with voluntary
of corporate persons. Sec..59(1) of code states that a corporate person
iguvidation,
s to liquidate itself
intends voluntarily and has not committed any default may
aitiatevoluntaryliguidation proceedings as per the conditions and procedural
who
Status asprescribed dby the Insolvency and
Admitted No. of Cases eguirements
Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI).
provisionsof Secs. 35 (powers and duties of liquidator) to 53
Closure bv Appeal/Review/Settled
7058 and Chapter VII (offences and (distribution
assets) of Chapter III
The,
Closure by withdrawal
1053 voluntary
of
penalties) shall apply to
vliquidation proceedings for corporate persons with such modifications
Resolution Plan Approved 947 be necessary.
may
Liquidation order passed 808 as
Wherethe affairs of corporatepersons have been completely wound up and its
Ongoing CIRP cases 2249 assetscompletely liquidated, the liquidator shall make an application to the AA
Source: The Quarterly Newsletter of Insolvency and
(1BBI), July-Sept. 2023. Vol. 28 Bankruptcy Board of2001India ie,NCLT
forthe dissolution of such corporate persons.
Case Law: Regulations Issued by IBBI w.e.f. 1st April, 2017 (amended upto
16.09.2022)
Monotrone Leasing Pvt Ltd. v. Pm Cold Storage Pvt Ltd.
NCLAT, (New Delhi Bench) comprising Justice
Venugopalan
Srivastava) heldthat it is the'determination of default'
debt' which is relevant for acceptance or rejection of'rather
(16/07/2020)Singh,
M, V. P.
than Alok
LCommencement of Liquidation
Initiation of Liquidation
Liquidation Process: Once the liquidation order is
process shall start. For the purposes of liquidation, the
claims under
passed by
"inability
Sec.
NCLT,
7 to
of 1BC.pay 1. Liquidation proceedings of acorporate person shall meet the following con
ditions, namely:
estate of Assets which will be
Debtor. The Liquidator shall called'
Liquidator liquidation
Liquidation Estate'in relationtot shall form an (a) Declaration of solvency: A declaration of solvency from majority of
constitute the
within 60days from liquidation
assets, value of claim is
'Stakeholders
commencement Corport aete'e
Consultation Commi
date. Liquidator takes charoe af
the directors of the company [under Sec. 59(3) of IBC] verified by an
affidavit stating that:
is made by the determined, creditors are paid off and finally () they havemade afulinquiry into the affairs ofthe corporate person
Corporate DebtorLiquidator to NCLT for
shall be dissolved fromdissolution. The AA shall order
the date of that order.
application
that the and they have formed an opinion that either the corporate person
order shall be forwarded to the The copy of the has no debt or that it will be able to pay its debts in full from the
within seven days of order. authority with which Corporate Debtoris registered proceeds of assets to be sold in the liquidation; and
(i) the corporate person is not beingliquidated to defraud any person;
(b) the declaration shall be accompanied with the following documents,
namely:
() audited financial statements and record of business operations of
the corporate person for the previous twoyears or for the period
since its incorporation, whichever is later;
*BBI is an independent body for the administration and governance of Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code,
2016. It was established on 1st October, 2016. Source: ibbi.govin
IINIT VDIVIDENDS, AUDIT AND WINDING UD CH. 14:WINDING UP 231
230
liquidator,
se
shallprepare
preliminaryReport;
and submit:
Report;
anhe
appointing corporatNeern
Status
Drofessional to act as the liquidator: or Annual.
Imeet1eventing:requiringnstoheney
2
u) Onexpiry ofperiod or o Minutes of
members of the companyoccurrence
in a general
ofan
|Reportin the manner specified under these Regulations.
adreoscoulmuteionntsofth.
Fnal
pany to be liquidated publicAnnouncementbythe Liquidator
of its duration, if any, voluntarily
as aresult 4
of
constitutionalexpiry percioomd
fixed by its
the occurrence of
any event in of the Liquidator shall make a public announcement in Form Aof Schedule I
documents provide that the respect of which the or on
. The
withinfive days from his appointment.
corporate
as the case may be, and
act as the liquidator: an person
appointing insolvency shall be
constidiustioolvnead, 2The
public.announcementshall:
call upon stakeholders to submit their claims as on the liquidation
Provided that the
corporate person owes any debt to
Creditors representing two-thirds in value of the
person shall approve (1.e. debt oftthe
profeanys ional (a) commencement
(b) provide
date: and
QUESTIONS
Q1. What is the diference between winding up and dissolution2
Q2. Explain the winding up of acompany. Discuss the grounds under which: a
can be wound up by the Tribunal. (DU, B.Com. 2019, 2022)
Q3. Explain the provisions relating to voluntary winding up of a company. comgaty
Q4. Explain DeclarationofSolvency'under voluntary winding up. Is it
the approvalof creditors in voluntary winding up of acompany? necessary dotin
to
Q5. Who may file apetition for winding up? Discuss the grounds under whi
whichh a
-Compaty
can be wound up by the NCLT. (DU,B.Com. 2023,Modified)
Q6. Explain winding up of a company on just andequitable' grounds.(DU.
Q7. Discuss the grounds and consequences of voluntary
winding up of a B.Com.2019
(DU,B.Com. (H) 2023)
Q8. Write anote on PPIRP.
company.
PRACTICAL PROBLEM
Q1 There are only two members of acompany. They
are
pany. Both ofthemare not on speaking terms. Can the also the directors of the Com.
ground? Give reasons. company be wound up onthis
(Hint: Yes, it is 'just and equitable' to order winding-up when
management). there is deadlockin
ANNEXURE 1: LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
S No. Term
1. AoA Articles of Association
Exercise
Visit :UNITIII
IRStatutory/MoAAoARIL.pdf list ReadExercise3:Access
Ltd. its
of website CompanyCompanyA A Cyamineon
various these can whether Suereise b) Ga 6 0
www.sebl.gov.in/
website-
SEBI
documents
clauses Mernorandumaccessed
bee.g., limited
attached
limited is Access : the
it
- bouquet and
ga/global/en/home.htmiAxerciseNITI out ndtCsINe:Find
Enlist Can Can Write
2 PAN DIN
a
FODB
benoteSPICe+ Visit
1
:
nd
what do on
doMCA nCIN
the
also
Memorandum by by
inand through guaranteeshares,
M/A ofAssociation
havefollowing
Schedule
or
E-book
IServices
and the
ofcompany
obtained
TAN
of of
through
on
(18/6/21)
Role
CRC.
of
Video
gallery
by
different
portal.ofany
companyb
digits
Whatyou
ANNEXURE
and
and ofnot try
Companies using indicate. by
main look a Association having discern
how to offered SPICe+?
also attempt
following
find
visiting 2:
239
contents at link & share
amendments Articles
throughobtained
be
Act, linkhttps://www.mca.gov.in/mcafoportal/
the
Make that t
is
PRACTICAL
https://www.ril.com/DownloadFiles/ Articles & https://www.mca.gov.in/content/ following link aCIN
capital, 2013 note
of do through
AGILE-PRO-S. has
A/A. of these from in 21
digits
Association
ofAssociation etc. your
questions
these
in
documents MCA SPICe+? notebook.
which
EXERCISES
documents. portal
of -
Reliance ofa are
differ
company alpha-numeric.
Preparea Industries depending
from
7. 6. 5. 4. 3. 1.
try:Letusaccessed
information Exercise: UNIT V Women
2. Identify 1. Board UNITCorrelate
Exercise: IV () (6) (5) BRLM/Lead
information From
(3) Promoter
Manager (2) (1) Go Go
filings Go
to 240
limited
Concept notCompany
company.
otherCompany
of
Such to AJA
restrictGovernment
capital.
share up (4) to to
private A
exceed public BID/1SSUE Minimum Price
BID/ISSUE Registrar the public
Directors of Red-herring
company of from above
return of the such the Prepare DirectorsSelect Band list issue
company for regarding from
suchcertain formed which type their to shown
subscriptioncompany right on any parameters closesopens
lot
size (with the
and holding their
controls website) a Documents
a has to of list its from issue there
threshold.
company whose
patronage for company: Rotation listed on on Floor document.
transfer b0ard.
only of
promotion
the limitcompany in top its
with select ANNEXURE
one for company
website Price filed
paid composition to Audit
bonus is securities. ofthe of
different provisions & any
based up of member. shares number is
Auditors
Firms. and and Cap
company
with 2:
capitalsports ROC/final PRACTICAL
not preparecollect Price)/Issue
on and years Find
of of less and studied
mutual and under Board prohibit
members than of and
Audit any from intormation a offer EXERCISES
turnover 51% list by note
Section of the Price
assistance, Directors invitation Firms.listed of you. documents
to of Annual th e down
does 8. 200, pai d company Independent
regarding
the
Reports filed
following
chosen with
Composition
(which Directors Roc,
by pieces
you can
and
th
241
242 ANNEXURE 2: PRACTICAL EXERCISES
Context
1. Members don't have any insurable interest in the property of
the company.
Landmarkkludgmea
2. Doctrine of indoor
management
3. Promoter can make profit but no
secret profit
4. Remedies for mis-statement in
toan original allottee of shares
Prospectus are available only
Findout more
"Fundoo" is IEPFA's mascot for financial
(launched in October, 2022) awareness
Q2. a1. Durathour
ion:3
s
"All
questions
(c) (b) (a) "The(c) (b) (a)
(b) (a)
Stateth(ec) its Write "A
of"A
A company. Describe Explain a "The obligation
on Comment,
coveredAssociation. Explain
orandum of wilhe the fromAssociation.
containing Explain. producer the non-disclosure." company
applied company property companies
rightof a
these statement
the note
are
the losehis the citing in
Com. B.
as importance concept of (All
rescission six the for cannot company promoter on
per procedure
certain essential of a law
prescribed
syllabus
under right. retired names with a Act Small thequestions
company is
relating ofagainstbefore of
shares
justify must
steps Producer the
of Examine
of Company.not
is relevant a
different Semester ||Hons.
-
'memorandum six help a
against carry
be iscompany.
245 OR
to
thdirectors
e the of breach
a
a
to
formed.
be suitableof statement
Company. th e
OR
the case
person (CBCS)
the company?sharescompany property the laws. equal
NEP-2020.
alteration of taken
2018* -
of of contract profits altogethermarks)
were
Association' the on for State case
Also of with
company.
allotted. the on-line its made
of explain by the laws.
object basis members." regard Maximum
Marks:75
altering objectives by from
registration a
clause theof the Can Two of promoter,
to the
a
case prospectus
¤ its duties
company.
of directors
exercise Articles for Comment members"
where which
mem of and but
a
246 B.COM. HONS. (CBCS) -2018 SEMESTER-I)
Q.2
*All
Do holding any
exception
to meeting.' resolution
giving
by company company's
desires Act. removalap be
249 referenceofissue
statutory
taken duties."' company?
Companies the wound System.
what
have
tmay light
of regarding the regarding
process. their shares. a the regarding be
thenot with of a Depository
the validity of the may of
andmayExplain performing of there The validity 2013 up
in building special company Tribunal.
constitution prospectus 2013 transmission of 2013 Securities'. winding
or issue. Are the Mumbai.provisions Act,
means. of
him" Act, revoked.!to and the Act, Companies Law benefits
I| bonus
book in a for
SEMESTER fatal at ExamineCompanies which of
resolution
to Herring care audio-visual
Companies Company
NCLT
the not closed Management.
through
and
and be office relevant 'Dematerialization
the
Company'
knowbut and transfer
be
Director can the under OR the Explain
2019 issueloyalty cannot OR Delhi.
registered
company,
are Red OR
the meeting ordinary the ofthe of NCLT.
Auditor?
'National
in
OR to company through each. Newto circumstances
provisions petition
(CRCS) presumed importance
Producer thatindoor a right
of
of between
provisions
Women declared
of its
between
provisions
reference the depository?
duty at by
a doors between
HONS a examples on on a
ofdocuments the a Explain. agree?
vou meeting of has AGM an compulsorily
notice theof note notefile
of on once
difference Limitedwith the aof
Director.pointment
COM on is the doctrinesecurities
by Differentiate
owe Distinguish a can is
R note outsiderwithin the Directors the board's
note it? Explain.
Dividend Explain.
faulty suitable
its
hold Discuss
desire
are the a
What State
Write WriteWhoWhat
a Write
publicplace
the
Discuss Discuss
State
a
Write ABC
to
(b) (c) (a) (b) (c)
of 'A (c) (a)
o af (a) b)
(a) (al h) (c) (a) b)
0.5.
-
B.COM. (P) (CBCS) - 2019 SEMESTER - I| 251
oA Q3.
Q.5.
(al (c) (b) "Divdend(a) (h (a) (c) (b) (a)
exceptions? its
(b) (a) (b) ( a) (b) (a )
Explain director.
Write proxy.
(c)
directorship?
ExplainExplain. "A
(b)
Differentiate
office of
Under
plain Why itto
? Discuss issue "Memor
What ation.aof
Memorandum
AssociDefine ndum
explain
and th Explain
e
State faulty "sweat are and
rematerialized?What thison compulsorily
What pointment
auditors? of NCLT.by
What the does the the
is is are the note a the notice
what legal
Companies once statutory distinguish the rullaied rv. B.COM.
ground?
the meant t he equity
conditions
the
circumstances rules circumstances between of HONS.
process provision
on of provisions declared Association
by provisions "voting with the shares" procedure
alteration down (CBCS)
Discuss.
"inability Ac t provisions
meeting Right to
be Red in
relating allow cannot OR underProspectus
of regard OR
of under by
of Herring -
dematerialization electronic Companies a
Shares fulfilled t h e of is Royal 2022
to OR the OR
pay Companies to can director a beregarding
Companies charter a British SEMESTER-I|
which appointment be company to revoked."
debts"? and the
means." fatal is by
a
a Act Bonus buy of Bank
of Can Act, company regarding todeemed to Are reduction company inthe
the back buy Act?
shares? a ofvalidity Shares. and company." Turquand.
company 2013 to ofback there
Can may small have securities. in that Shelf object
regarding appointment shareholder's its any share
these be be of vacated shares?exceptions Prospectus.
proposes to
a Comment
clause What
wound would meeting." capital. 253
may the
the Ex are
be up ap up of of
B.COM. (P) (CBCS) -2022 SEMESTER -|1
255
OR
(a) How
can directors of a company be removed?
Explain provisions under the Companies Act, 2013 relating to Annual
B.(om. (P) (CBS) -2022* (b) General Meetings.
Semester -|l Distinguish between ordinary resolution and special resolution. Give
suitable example of each.
(h) Explain the meaning of dividend. What are the rules regarding
payment of dividends?
Duration:3 hours OR
(c) Define Producer (a) Explain the composition and powers of National Company Law
Q2. (a) Company and explain the objects for which it is Tribunal.
Discuss the statutory provisions formed (b) Write a note on:
(b) "A company cannot regarding'Reduction
justify breach of contract by
of Association". Comment. a
of Share Capital!
() Woman director
altering its Articles
(c) What do you mean by a (in) Alternate director
misleading prospectus? What are the effects of
misstatement ina prospectus? (c) Explain the provisions of the Companies Act, 2013 regarding "buy-back
of securities"
OR
(a) Explain Turquand's rule. Are there any
(b)
Differentiate between Right Shares andexceptions to it?
Bonus Shares.
(c) Distinguish
Q.3. (a) Write a notebetween Shelf prospectus and Red
on 'Sweat equity Herring prospectus.
(b) Can directors be shares.
appointed by the Board? If so, under what
*Allquestions covered are as
per syllabus
prescribed under NEP-2020.
situations?
254
(UGCF)- AUGUST 2023 SEMESTER -I|
B.COM.(HONS.)(U 257
(a)
Differentiate between Managing Director and Whole Time Director.
does the CompaniesSAct allow a company to buy-back its securi-
(b) *WhyDiscuss
Q1. (a) "The property of a company is the the conditions for buy-back.
on the statement with the property of its
help of the suitable case members"
ties?
.what is Dividend? Discuss the provisions relating to the payment of
(b) Write a note on Associate
(c) Whois a
Company.
lawS
p chapter is not in new syllabus, so the question was replaced during examination.
Q.3.
Q.2.
Q.
(x) (c) (b) 1.
(a) (2) (x) (c) (b) (a) (b) (a) (b) (a)
Define Shares?
BonusWhat What
spectus.State exception
Association? dumWhat
of promotes".
What
)
Explain
"Apromoter Discuss What form?
SPICeWhat What liftedorWhatcompany? Define
+ Actpierced?
What
are are in
prospectus. the is do do respect is is is is
the difference
the the you the you the a companya a
producer a
Com. B.
to "Corporate private
conditions procedure thismean stands binding mean use
important of
doctrine? ofsuch
What
between
for the
by in effects by company?
a 'doctrine 'Scompany. PICe
the
a
company? and
explain Semester||-
(P)
are to
be
rules
alteration
Elaborate doctrine
fiduciary Veil"?
(UGCF)
258 the OR OR of +' OR
fulfilled
relating 'shelf the Explain When What its
redients of form?
relationship Articles ultra salient
prospectus' constructive
by to the
of of
vires'?
What the under
or are
the August -
a the of provisions features.
company name are privileges
to forfeiture Association.
nstitute
and clause
towards Explain the what 2023
proposing 'red-herring notice? servicescircumstances
enjoyed
of of the its the of
a shares? a company Is effects.
ctus?
Memoran there offeredCompanie by
to such
issue
(6) (6) (6) (6) pro (6) (6) any (6) he (6) (6) (6) in (9 (9) is it
(9)
a
(9)