ZhuM PS2015 SundayAM Handout
ZhuM PS2015 SundayAM Handout
Email: moyee@scalpacupuncture.org
Abstract
A number of studies and meta-analyses indicate that there is no clear evidence that
acupuncture has additional value to post-stroke rehabilitation. This article outlines key
issues underlining the failure of the acupuncture treatments in previous studies: delay in
Introduction
The World Health Organization estimates that 15 million individuals suffer from
hypercholesterolemia and cardiac diseases are prevalent. Stroke is the third leading
including the use of Tissue Plasminogen Activator (tPA) and intracranial angioplasty.
However, these procedures are not indicated for or accessible to all stroke patients.
Despite receiving tPA in the recommended window, 58% of the patients still die or end
Typical post-stroke care in the USA starts with seven days of hospital stay, then one
treatment comes to an end, but the patient’s recovery is far from complete. In one
Can Acupuncture Really Benefit Stroke Recovery? 3
study3 on ischemic stroke survivors who were at least 65 years of age, the following
Many people have asked this question. Our answer is a definite “yes”. However,
recent western research and meta-analyses make the claim that there is no clear
evidence that acupuncture has additional value for post-stroke rehabilitation.4,5 Why is
there a discrepancy? Whose statement is true, ours or the researchers’ ? Both are valid.
What is more accurate is: acupuncture can significantly benefit stroke patients if it is
done right; otherwise it is of little value. Our own experience with stroke patients over
the years demonstrates that when applied correctly, acupuncture can shorten recovery
time to as little as two weeks and restore function to over 95% in some patients.
Case Reports
(1) In December 2010, a man in his fifties suffered an ischemic stroke. Three days after
the stroke onset, he presented himself at our clinic with slurred speech, right
was able to move his right upper extremity. The next day, less than 24 hours later,
he stood up and walked on his own. On his third day of treatment, he climbed the
(2) One night in 1992, Mr. Shen, president of an acupuncturist association in California,
suddenly dropped on the floor and became stuporous. A CT scan of his brain
revealed a big lesion in the left cortex and basal ganglia, due to hemorrhage of the
middle cerebral artery. Within seven hours, we started Zhu’s Scalp Acupuncture
treatment on him, and continued for 20 consecutive days. Two weeks later, he
started to talk. After three months, he was able to return full-time to his acupuncture
(3) In 1998, a 55 year-old man discharged himself from the Taipei Veterans General
Hospital of Taiwan despite his doctor’s advice. It was the 8th day after his stroke
when he arrived at our clinic in a wheelchair. His ischemic stroke left him paralyzed
on the right side. Twenty minutes after applying scalp acupuncture needles, he
stood up. An hour later, he took a few steps. After two weeks of daily acupuncture,
he started walking with a cane. He ultimately regained all his gross and fine
movements. Today he is living his life as a fully-recovered stroke patient and still
(4) In 2007, an MD referred his 58 year-old male patient to us. This patient had an
ischemic stroke and was bed-ridden for 20 days. On the first visit, he came in a
wheelchair but left our clinic walking down two flights of stairs without assistance.
After 10 daily Zhu’s Scalp Acupuncture treatments of three hours each, he returned
to work.
Can Acupuncture Really Benefit Stroke Recovery? 5
These four case histories are a small representative sample of the large number of
stroke cases we have treated. What is common in these patients is that all were treated
Discussion
How can we make acupuncture maximally beneficial for stroke patients? Below
I. Time is crucial
stage of stroke. Quite the contrary, acupuncture should intervene promptly, as early
as the first hour after onset. Every hour of delay can cause a difference in the
outcome. The best treatment windows are, in decreasing order of therapeutic value:
(1) the first three hours, (2) the first three days, (3) the first week, (4) the first month,
(5) the first three months, and (6) the first six months. Both ischemic and hemorrhagic
stroke can receive acupuncture treatment from the first day, but they differ in
operation details.
surrounding the core of the stroke. Usually about 72 hours after a stroke, cerebral
edema starts to form and it is very damaging. Although the mechanism is not well
understood, acupuncture triggers some changes in the brain that result in the
protection of brain cells from necrosis. Therefore it prevents or reduces edema and
Can Acupuncture Really Benefit Stroke Recovery? 6
consequently promises a better prognosis. The often dramatic results in our stroke
patients suggest that acupuncture could promote the reperfusion of the brain in a
very short time, perhaps through the activation of the collaterals or the dissolution of
fibrin around the clot. More research is needed to understand the mechanism.
Rehabilitation, like acupuncture, should also start as soon as vital signs are
stable. This is particularly important for aphasia and dysphagia. Our experience
shows that if speech therapy does not begin within the first month, speech recovery
will be almost impossible or very limited. Again, ischemic and hemorrhagic strokes
call for different types of rehabilitation exercises during the acute phase.
Which acupuncture protocol is better for treating strokes? For many years Zhu
had used conventional body acupuncture to treat strokes but was not satisfied
with the results. So in the 1970’s he started to explore scalp acupuncture and
developed Zhu’s Scalp Acupuncture. Often people are amazed at the outcome.
For neurological conditions such as strokes, scalp acupuncture is by far the most
effective.
the qi. The technique and amount of manipulation vary with the type of stroke,
• It is not uncommon that the paralyzed side of the body feels colder to touch.
When this happens, the classical technique “Setting Mountain on FIre” often
warming the Yang and promoting Qi”, as these are called in Chinese medicine,
certainly will benefit the patient’s recovery. It should be noted, however, that
• During recovery stage, one can use stronger stimulation both on the scalp and
body.
• A comatose stroke patient whose vital signs are stable needs stronger
stimulation.
confidence to heal, helping the patient to relax, teaching the patient how to talk
and to move. All these things, which we call “Daoyin,”7 should be organically
(b) A stroke patient with facial palsy is instructed to open/close his/her affected
(c) A stroke patient with paralytic lower limb is instructed to stand and walk with
support.
(d) A stroke patient with paralytic upper limb is instructed to push and pull on
they differ.
(a) Our approach is proactive. We help a patient sit before he can sit on his own.
We make the first attempt to stand when the patient cannot even imagine or
regain his lost function instead of waiting for the first sign of the function to
(b) When doing Daoyin, we give the patient only minimal assistance while taking
adequate precaution and safety measures. The more active efforts from the
patient, the better the treatment results. By the same token, we discourage
ankle-foot orthoses (AFO) and not causing any harm to the patient. Orthoses
rob the patient’s opportunity to exert effort on his/her own, resulting in muscle
paralyzed side instead of the good side brings better outcome in the end.
changes in the brain. Hence, to achieve speedy functional recovery after a stroke,
treatments (needling and Daoyin combined) must be adequate especially in the first
three months. A daily three to six hours of focused and active Daoyin engagement
is the most desirable. We recommend multiple short sessions to avoid fatigue. The
average two to six hours a week that most stroke patients currently receive in out-
hemorrhage.
(c) Body postures: Spasticity does not set in immediately after a stroke and it can
Always keep the patient’s head, body, and limbs in normal physiological
positions, especially the joints - neck, elbow, wrist, fingers, ankle and feet.
(d) Dementia and Parkinsonism: These are common after-effects that manifest
after a long period of inactivity as the brain atrophies.8,9 Because they are not
always apparent immediately after a stroke, they are often neglected in the
Conclusion
correctly. Results are most remarkable in the acute stage. First, treatment must begin
this manner a stroke patient will achieve a faster and more complete recovery.
Can Acupuncture Really Benefit Stroke Recovery? 11
By sharing our experience, we hope that acupuncture treatments for stroke can
be optimized and that future research on this topic can yield more meaningful results.
References
and Stroke Statistics – 2011 Update: A Report from the American Heart Association.
2. The National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke rt-PA Stroke Study
Group. Tissue plasminogen activator for acute ischemic stroke. E Engl J Med.
1995;333:1581-1587.
3. Kelly-Hayes M, Beiser A, Kase CS, Scaramucci A, D’Agostino RB, Wolf PA. The
influence of gender and age on disability following ischemic stroke: the Framingham
4. Sze FK, Wong E, Or K, Lau J, Woo J. Does acupuncture improve motor recovery
2619.
5. Sze FK, Wong E, Yi X, Woo J. Does acupuncture have additional value to standard
6. Siu M. A Speedy Stroke Recovery using Zhu’s Scalp Acupuncture. Available at:
Can Acupuncture Really Benefit Stroke Recovery? 12
7. The concept and practice of Daoyin were depicted in the Emperor’s Classic and
8. Handley A, Medcalf P, Hellier K, Dutta D. Movement Disorders after Stroke. Age and
Ageing. 2009;38(3):260-266.
9. Tatemichi TK, Desmond DW, Mayeux R, Paik M, Stern Y, Sano M, et al. Dementia
2016
28th Annual Pacific Symposium
October 26 - November 2, 2015
San Diego, CA
The annual Pacific Symposium is
an opportunity to experience a
community of healers while learning
from innovators in the field.