Wjarr 2022 1339
Wjarr 2022 1339
Publication history: Received on 01 November 2022; revised on 12 December 2022; accepted on 14 December 2022
Abstract
Background: The pharmaceutical metal detector is a device to detect metal as well as non-metal contaminants of large
size in the pharmaceutical dosage form. The detection of unwanted metal (contaminant) is important to produce a high
quality of the dosage form.
Main body: Pharmaceutical dosage forms are highly sensitive to the environment to which they are surrounded. It is
challenging to keep a product in its original form throughout its shelf life. These metals find entry in the pharmaceutical
formulation during various phases of manufacturing while passing through pipelines, sieves, conveyors, wires, buds,
error in mixing processes, through raw materials. The Food and Drug Administration Hazard Evaluation board has given
that the length of 0.3 inches to 1 inch of metal is considered unacceptable. The article highlights source of the metal
contamination in pharmaceutical formulation types of detectors used, FDA standard for the metal detector, the need for
a metal detector with its ideal properties, effect, hazards of ingesting metal fragments through medicines, working
principle, uses, separation of metal contamination, test for the metal detector go about when metal is detected.
Monitoring of system in a metal detector at the Critical control points some case studies involve reputed pharmaceutical
manufacturers, which were forced to recall the batches for metal fragments detected in finished product.
Conclusion: The pharmaceutical companies are bounded to produce quality safe products. One adulteration may cause
recalls of products, cost loss of millions of dollar or total disruption of business as well. The selection of suitable metal
detector is much needed. As the metal detector inclusively controls the contamination maintains a tough control on the
quality of products.
Keywords: Metal detector; Metal contamination; Quality; Safety; Hazards; Ferrous non-ferrous; Recall
1. Introduction
Metal detector is a device, used to detect traces of magnetic or conductive metal present in pharmaceutical formulation.
In pharmaceutical preparations there are many metals that are categorized as useful metals. These include Sodium,
Potassium, and Magnesium. Sodium and potassium are alkali metals that occur in body that play role in homeostasis.
Magnesium is alkali earth metal found in bones, soft tissue, skeletal muscles and plays important role in some metabolic
signaling pathway [1]. Every metal is toxic in high concentration. On the other hand, the term heavy metal refers to
metallic elements that have a relatively high density and are toxic or poisonous at low concentrations. Examples of
heavy metals include mercury (Hg), cadmium (Cd), arsenic (As), chromium (Cr), thallium (Tl), and lead (Pb) [2].
Corresponding author: Ishita Sharma
Copyright © 2022 Author(s) retain the copyright of this article. This article is published under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Liscense 4.0.
World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2022, 16(03), 482–489
The occurrence of unwanted metal where it is not needed is considered contamination. FDA (Food and Drug
Administration) demands testing of finished product by metal detectors for consumer's safety. Metals as contamination
are important to detect with high accuracy and reliability. This is significant to ensure product safety. As per GMP (Good
Manufacturing Practices) standards the final food pharmaceutical products must always be free from metal
contaminations. Mostly the metal detectors are used by the US State Department of Agriculture (USDA), US Food Drug
Administration (USFDA), Hazard Analysis Critical Control Point (HACCP) Certifications in India, other countries [3].
HACCP is a management system in which food safety is addressed through the analysis and control of biological,
chemical, and physical hazards from raw material production, procurement and handling, to manufacturing,
distribution and consumption of the finished product [4].
Metal contamination can be found in food products or pharmaceutical products due to the presence of metallic
components (like- pins, wires, buds, punches, eroded or co-eroded metallic parts, etc.) as stainless steel, ferrous or non-
ferrous materials. Deducting these metal components is very important.
483
World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2022, 16(03), 482–489
2.2.3. Miscellaneous:
Advance metal detector: X-ray detector etc. [8].
The Metal contaminants are categories in three forms: ferrous, non-ferrous and stainless steel. The ferrous
contaminations such as chrome steel are both magnetic and are good electrical conductor that is why they can be
detected easily. Non-ferrous metals contaminants are non-magnetic generally excellent conductors and are relatively
easy to detect. Metals such as Aluminum, Brass, Lead, and Copper fall under Non-ferrous metal contaminants. Stainless
steel comes in different grades is usually non-magnetic, electrically poor conductor. Thus, they are difficult to detect by
ordinary means. The overall capability of the metal detector is the sensitivity ratio between ferrous and the most
complicated is to spot ranking of stainless steel [9]. Based on the type of formulation solid metal detector is used for
oral solid dosages like tablets, capsules while liquid metal detectors are used for solutions, suspensions, paste. The
advance metal detector includes an X-ray metal detector. It is an advanced type of metal detector. X-ray metal detector
detects not only metals but also plastic, glass other contaminants also verify package integrity dosing portions. Criteria
for selecting metal detectors must be based on the following points but will not be limited to these only. The key aspect
is the Sensitivity of the metal detector. Sensitivity is explained as the smallest sphere of a particular metal or non-metal
that the unit can detect as it passes through the metal detector. A metal detector used in pharmaceutical industries are
available in different sensitivity e.g.,0.15mm diameter ferrous, 0.2mm diameter non-ferrous and 0.3mm diameter for
stainless steel particles. The industries require sensitivity at the time of the “Qualification of Equipment” to be
considered as priority parameter. Quantification of equipment is initial verification of quality of instruments to fulfill
the specific need at the time of procurement. The Sensitivity of Metal can be affected by many factors such as type of
metal contamination shape of metal contamination [10]. Secondly, Metal detector capacity is usually denoted by
tablet/minutes. Thirdly, the accessibility to store data in metal detector (e.g.,100 product materials), the last availability
of auto validation option or any other requirement as per firm.
2.3. FDA standards for Metal detector metal detector with ideal properties
The FDA's Health Hazard Evaluation Board provides limit of metals fragments that are unacceptable in formulations.
Any metal impurity beyond 0.3 inch to 1 inch (7mm to 25mm) is considered unacceptable. Any foreign material found
in the formulation is considered unsafe or adulterated [11, 12].
In manufacturing units of tablets or capsules, there may be the chance of metal impurity either ferrous, non-ferrous, or
tramp metals. The presence of metal in dosage form impacts the quality of product as the metal piece may initiate any
other reaction, also their presence may damage other equipment and also is hazardous for the consumer. To overcome
such challenges metal detectors are frequently used. These metal detectors are designed to detect metal impurities
without disturbing the routine manufacturing process. For effective detection a metal detector must be designed to
ensure metal free product in cost effective manner. To serve this purpose the metal detector used in the pharmaceutical
industry must have few basic properties. It should be simple to use, reliable, sensitive, capable to detect magnetic non-
magnetic metal, compatible with other machines like compression machines in case of OSD (Oral Solid Dosage form),
efficient for online metal detection rejection. It should occupy minimum space as possible, easy to clean most
importantly it should record the date and time of operation [13].
484
World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2022, 16(03), 482–489
In liquids, metal detection is done prior to the capper induction sealer. This is because most metal detectors are unable
to perform the inspection after foil seal adheres to the bottle. Therefore, the inspection in liquids performed without
cap on the bottles to increases the possibility of metal as well as other contaminants entering the bottle accidently
during the inspection. The recent advancement in the technology permits an inspection with foil seal to be tested after
the induction sealer. Hence the process will make the product a complete metal-free product. The contaminants
detection is always affected by bottle size, foil thickness, and foil position [7].
485
World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2022, 16(03), 482–489
2.8. Test for the metal detector goabout’s when metal is detected in the medicines
Pharmaceutical Industry must make sure that equipment working accurately in different time interval, which is referred
to as verification. To follow this rule the Metal Detector should be tested to know whether it is working in agreed
sensitivity or not. In this test, metal balls of fixed diameter are encapsulated in non-metallic or plastic blocks passed
through the metal detector. These metal balls are ideally made with Ferrous (FE), Non-Ferrous (NFE), and Stainless
Steel (SS) [19]. If metal pieces are detected then pre-established corrective action procedures are followed which should
be firstly to hold on to the product or destroy the batch. Production should not begin without an operating metal
detector, to try avoiding the source of metal fragment, to ensure maintenance of metal detector in a regular period so
that its sensitivity remains accurate [11].
486
World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2022, 16(03), 482–489
2.9. Monitoring of system in a metal detector at the critical control points (CCP)
The CCP is key variables affecting the pharmaceutical production process. The operational conditions within this range
are considered acceptable for operation as standards. Any deviation from this acceptable range will be indicative of
issues within the process. As critical control point of metal detector must be monitored frequently. These are monitored
for various purposes such as for internal error monitoring, audit trail, and user management. The internal error
monitoring program should be done by carry out an internal error search error analysis. The second one is Audit Trail
that shows us the record about who assessed the system with Date and Time. The Error messages warnings are also
recorded logged. If in case settings that influence the sensitivity of metal detector changes, it should be recorded in the
audit trail when carried out. The third one is the User management system that should also be monitored. Access
authorization should be designed according to system relevance. If any unauthorized person confirmed, a warning
message without restoring production safety in the CCP, then CCP should not be valid [20].
487
World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2022, 16(03), 482–489
3. Conclusion
The Global Market of Pharmaceutical Metal Detector is expected to be $1.6 billion by 2022 will grow exponentially. As
the metal detector inclusively controls the contamination maintains a tough control on the quality of products. It is
widely accepted by various regulatory authorities their use should be mandatory for Pharmaceutical Industry. The
pharmaceutical companies are bounded to produce quality safe products. One adulteration may cause recalls of
products, cost loss of millions of dollar or total disruption of business as well. The selection of suitable metal detector
may be hit trial process that should consider ease of use or operation, sensitivity most important audit ability. At the
same time, using a metal detector is not fully assured that the formulation is free from any metal pieces. In future,
advance metal detector, best metal detectors and reviews over top 5 metal detectors can be the good headings to cover
as these are unexplored areas.
Acknowledgments
The authors are thankful to MIT College of Pharmacy, Moradabad, Utter Pradesh, and India for providing the necessary
facilities to accomplish the work.
References
[1] Chellan. P andSadher P.J.(2015), “ The elements of life and medicine”, Phil. Trans. The royal society publishing,
373:20140182.http://dx.doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2014.0182
[2] Singh. R and et al., (2011), “Heavy metals and living system: an overview”, Indian Journal of pharmacology,
volume 43(3), page no.246-253
[3] Mal. D, Metal detector: Types uses in pharmaceutical industry,
http://www.pharmabiz.com/ArticleDetails.aspx?aid=75768andsid=21#:~:text=Metal%20detectors%20are%2
0used%20in,or%20corroded%20metallic%20parts%20etc. Published date 06.06.2013 , Pharmabiz.com,
Accessed on28.02.2021
[4] https://www.fda.gov/food/guidance-regulation-food-and-dietary-supplements/hazard-analysis-critical-
control-point-haccp accessed 19.1.2022
[5] Stellmack. M, Rhodes. K (2010), Metal contamination in Bio-pharmaceutical drugs,
https://www.contractpharma.com/issues/2010-10/view_features/metal-contamination-in-bio-
pharmaceutical-drugs/ Published date 10.08.10, Contract pharma, Accessed on28.02.21
[6] Pharmaceutical contamination: Types, causes prevention
https://lindstromgroup.com/in/article/pharmaceutical-contamination-types-causes--prevention/ Published
date 27.08.2020 Lindstrom group, Accessed on14.02.2021
488
World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2022, 16(03), 482–489
[7] Zarnick. K, "Helping keep pharmaceuticals safe: metal detection overview guidelines", White Paper PI.0101,
Thermo scientific, Page no. 1-4.
[8] Thomas. P, Testing your metal: Best Practice from PTI
https://www.pharmamanufacturing.com/articles/2010/058/ Published on 12.04.2010, Pharma
manufacturing, Accessed on27.04.2021
[9] "Safeline Metal Detection and X-ray inspection" Mettler Toledo, "Detecting more metal for increased br
protection" Page no. 1-4.
[10] Raju. A, Metal detectors hold the key for safety in Pharma sector
http://pharmabiz.com/ArticleDetails.aspx?aid=115585andsid=21 Published date 14.02.2019, Pharmabiz.com,
Accessed on23.04.2021
[11] https://www.fda.gov/media/80342/download, Accessed on14.02.21
[12] Bowling. S, FDA metal detection Stards, https://t2conline.com/fda-metal-detection-stards/Published on
23.10.2017, Time square chronicles, Accessed on14.02.2021
[13] Abernethy D.R et al.,( 2010), “Metal Impurities in Food and Drugs”, Pharmaceutical Reserch, Volume 23, 750-755.
[14] Frane. J, What happen if I swallow a very small piece of metal?,https://www.quora.com/What-happens-if-I-
swallow-a-very-small-piece-of-metal Answered on 12.04.2019, Accessed on28.02.2021
[15] Reese.C.A, What happen if I swallow a very small piece of metal?, https://www.quora.com/What-happens-if-I-
swallow-a-very-small-piece-of-metal Answered on 12.02.2019, Accessed on28.02.2021
[16] Tablet Metal detector https://www.prismpharmamachinery.com/metal-detactor.html, Prism Pharma
machinery, Accessed on14.02.2021
[17] "Requirement, Technology application recommendations Metal Detection in production lines",
https://www.geass.com/wp-content/uploads/filebase/minebea-intec/metal_detector/Rilievo-dei-metalli-
nelle-linee-di-produzione-Minebea-Intec_en.pdfSartorius Intec- A minebea group company, page no. 1-32
[18] "Requirement, Technology application recommendations Metal Detection in production lines",
https://www.geass.com/wp-content/uploads/filebase/minebea-intec/metal_detector/Rilievo-dei-metalli-
nelle-linee-di-produzione-Minebea-Intec_en.pdfSartorius Intec- A minebea group company, page no. 1-32
[19] How to test a metal detector https://www.pharmaceuticalonline.com/doc/how-to-test-a-metal-detector-0001,
Accessed on02.03.2021
[20] "Requirement, Technology application recommendations Metal Detection in production lines",
https://www.geass.com/wp-content/uploads/filebase/minebea-intec/metal_detector/Rilievo-dei-metalli-
nelle-linee-di-produzione-Minebea-Intec_en.pdfSartorius Intec- A minebea group company, page no. 1-32
[21] Lupin recall over 18,000 bottles of antibiotic drug in US
https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/companies/lupin-recalls-over-18000-bottles-of-antibiotic-drug-in-
us/article27955724.ece/amp/ Published on 16.06.2019,The hindu Business line, Accessed on25.04.2021
[22] Lupin recalls over 18000 bottles of antibiotics drug in the US
https://www.livemint.com/companies/news/lupin-recalls-over-18-000-bottles-of-antibiotic-drug-in-the-us-
1560662580896.html, Published on 16.06.2019, Mint ePaper, Accessed on25.04.2021
[23] Patel. R.B, Patel M.R, Patel.B.G, Detection of metal contamination: an overview,
http://www.pharmabiz.com/PrintArticle.aspx?aid=63358andsid=0 Published on 09.06.2011, Pharmabiz.com,
Accessed on 25.02.21
[24] Singer. N, J. andJ.Unit issue recall of Rolaids,
https://www.nytimes.com/2010/12/10/business/10recall.html#:~:text=A%20unit%20of%20Johnson%20%
26%20Johnson,wood%20particles%20in%20the%20products published on 09.12.2010, the new work time,
business, Accessed on26.02.21
[25] Tylenol contamination the drug recall epidemic, https://www.elementum.com/chain-reaction/tylenol-
contamination--the-drug-recall-epidemic published on 23.03.2015, Elementum, Accessed on26.02.2021
[26] Drucker. R, Voluntary recall: Infants' Mylicon Gas Relief Dye Free Nonstaining Drops,
https://www.jwatch.org/pa200811190000001/2008/11/19/voluntary-recall-infants-mylicon-gas-relief-dye,
published on 19.11.2008, NEJM Journal watch, Accessed on26.02.2021
[27] Stabilishment injection report L.Perigo Company, Allegan, MI. 49010, FEI 1811666, EI start 11/Nov/2006 EI end
12/Dec/2006, Page no. 1- 84
489