Lift-Drag-Boundary Layer Problems
Lift-Drag-Boundary Layer Problems
Sources: Brevoort and Joyner 10, Lindsey 6, Morrison 16, Roberson et al. 17, Rouse 12, and Scher and
Gale 18.
To find the drag force on an object, find or estimate the coefficient of drag and then apply the drag force
equation. This approach is illustrated by Example 11.2.
What is the drag of a 12 mm sphere that drops at a rate of 8 cm/s in oil (µ = 10-1 N · s/m2, S = 0.85)?
Problem Definition
Situation:
Properties:
Plan
1. Calculate the Reynolds number.
2. Find the coefficient of drag using Fig. 11.8.
4 of 8 1/15/2009 1:08 AM
Drag of Axisymmetric and 3D Bodies http://edugen.wiley.com/edugen/courses/crs2436/crowe9771/crowe9771...
Solution
1. Reynolds number
Figure 11.9 Horizontal forces acting on car that is moving at a steady speed.
The driving force (FDrive) is the frictional force between the driving wheels and the road. The drag force is the
resistance of the air on the car. The rolling resistance is the frictional force that occurs when an object such as a
ball or tire rolls. It is related to the deformation and types of the materials that are in contact. For example, a
rubber tire on asphalt will have a larger rolling resistance than a steel train wheel on a steel rail. The rolling
resistance is calculated using
(11.10)
The power required to move the car shown in Fig. 11.9 at a constant speed is given by Eq. 7.2a
5 of 8 1/15/2009 1:08 AM
Terminal velocity http://edugen.wiley.com/edugen/courses/crs2436/crowe9771/crowe9771...
To find terminal velocity, balance the forces acting on the object, and then solve the resulting equation. In
general this process is iterative as illustrated by Example 11.4.
Problem Definition
Properties: Water (20°C), Table A.5, ν = 1 × 10-6 m2/s, ρ = 998 kg/m3, and γ = 9790 N/m3.
Plan
This problem requires an iterative solution because the terminal velocity equation is implicit.
Solution
1. Force equilibrium
1 of 3 1/15/2009 1:09 AM
Terminal velocity http://edugen.wiley.com/edugen/courses/crs2436/crowe9771/crowe9771...
· Solve for V0
3. Iteration 1
4. Iterative solution
· As shown, use a spread sheet program to build a table. The first row shows the results of
iteration 1.
2 of 3 1/15/2009 1:09 AM
Terminal velocity http://edugen.wiley.com/edugen/courses/crs2436/crowe9771/crowe9771...
· The terminal velocity from iteration 1 V0 = 0.413 m/s is used as the initial velocity for
iteration 2.
· The iteration process is repeated until the terminal velocity reaches a constant value of
V0 = 0.44 m/s. Notice that convergence is reached in two iterations.
Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. All rights reserved.
3 of 3 1/15/2009 1:09 AM
Lift and Drag on Airfoils http://edugen.wiley.com/edugen/courses/crs2436/crowe9771/crowe9771...
A graph showing CL and CD versus α is given in Fig. 11.24. Note in this graph that CD is separated into the
induced-drag coefficient CDi and the form drag coefficient CD0.
Figure 11.24 Coefficients of lift and drag for a wing with an aspect ratio of 5. [After Prandtl 23.]
Problem Definition
Situation:
Find:
7 of 9 1/15/2009 1:11 AM
Lift and Drag on Airfoils http://edugen.wiley.com/edugen/courses/crs2436/crowe9771/crowe9771...
Assumptions:
Plan
1. Find the lift by applying force equilibrium.
2. Calculate the coefficient of lift using Eq. (11.20).
3. Find the angle of attack α from Fig. 11.23.
4. Read the maximum angle of attack from Fig. 11.23, and then calculate the correspoding stall
speed using the lift force equation (11.17).
Solution
Review
Notice that the stall speed (119 km/h) is less than the takeoff speed (140 km/h).
8 of 9 1/15/2009 1:11 AM
102 CHAPTER 11. DRAG AND LIFT
Problem 11.2
Air with a speed of 30 m/s and a density of 1.25 kg/m3 ßows normal to a rec-
tangular sign of dimension 5.5 m by 7.5 m. Find the force of the air on the sign.
Solution
&!!2
$$ = "$ %"
2 ³ ´¡ ¢
¡ ¢ 1#25 kg/m3 302 m2 's2
2
= "$ 5#5 × 7#5 m
2
= "$ (23#2 kN)
The coe!cient of drag from Table 11.1 with (') = 7#5'5#5 ! 1#0 is 1.18. Thus
Problem 11.4
For a bicycle racer who races on the road, a typical speed is 40 kph, the coe!-
cient of drag is about 0.88, and the frontal area is about 0.36 m2 # Determine the
power required to overcome wind drag when there is (a) no headwind and (b) a
headwind of 15 kph.
Solution
* = $$ !'
&!!2
$$ = "$ %"
2 ³ ´³ ´
3 2 2 2
¡ ¢ 1#2 kg/m 11#1 m /s
= 0#88 0#36 m2
2
= 23#4 N
The power is
* = $$ !'
= (23#4 N) (11#1 m/s)
= 260 + (no headwind)
When there is a headwind, the drag force changes because the velocity term repre-
sents the speed of the wind relative to the cyclist. The wind speed is
µ ¶µ ¶
1000 m 1 hr
!wind = (15 kph)
1 km 3600 s
= 4#17 m/s
!! = !' + !wind
= (11#1 + 4#17) m/s
= 15#3 m/s
105
&!!2
$$ = "$ %"
2 ³ ´³ ´
¡ ¢ 1#2 kg/m3 15#32 m2 /s2
= 0#88 0#36 m2
2
= 44#5 N
* = $$ !'
= (44#5 N) (11#1 m/s)
= 494 W (with headwind)
Problem 11.5
During the preliminary design of a submarine, a designer assumes that the drag
force will be equal to the drag on a streamlined body that has a diameter of 1.5
m and a length of 8 m. The design speed is 10 m/s, the submarine will operate
in 10 ! C water (kinematic viscosity is , = 1#31 × 10!6 m2 's), and the sub will be
powered by an electric motor with an e!ciency of 90%. Determine the power that
will be consumed by the motor.
Solution
* = $$ !(
The power that will be consumed by the electric motor is increased because of the
e!ciency rating (-)#
$$ !(
* =
-
To Þnd drag force, the Reynolds number is needed.
!( .
Re =
,
(10 m/s) (1.5 m)
=
(1#31 × 10!6 m2 /s)
= 11#5 × 106
Fig. 11.11 hows the coe!cient of drag for a streamlined body with /'0 = 5. Since
the aspect ratio of the submarine is /'0 = 8'1#5 = 5#33, Fig. 11.11 provides a good
© 2018 Pearson Education, Inc., 330 Hudson Street, NY, NY 10013. All rights reserved. This material is protected under all copyright laws as they
currently exist. No portion of this material may be reproduced, in any form or by any means, without permission in writing from the publisher.
11–1. Determine the distance x = xcr over the flat plate to 4 ft!s
where the boundary layer for kerosene at T = 68°F begins
to transition from laminar to turbulent flow.
SOLUTION
We will consider the flow as steady, and the kerosene as incompressible. From the
table in Appendix A, rke = 1.58 slug>ft3 and vke = 25.4(10-6) ft2 >s for kerosene
at T = 68°F. The transition from laminar to turbulent boundary layers occurs at
critical Reynolds number of 1Rex2 cr = 51105 2.
Uxcr 14 ft>s2xcr
1Rex2 cr = ; 51105 2 =
vke 25.4110-6 2 ft2 >s
xcr = 3.175 ft Ans.
Ans:
xcr = 3.175 ft
929
11–2. The boundary layer for wind blowing over rough terrain 10 m!s
can be approximated by the equation u>U = 3y> 1y + 0.0224,
where y is in meters. If the free-stream velocity of the wind is
10 m>s, determine the velocity at y = 0.2 m and at y = 0.4 m
from the ground.
y
SOLUTION
We will consider the flow steady, and air as incompressible.
Here,
u y
=
U y + 0.02
y 10y
u = a bU = a b m>s
y + 0.02 y + 0.02
At y = 0.2 m,
1010.22
u "y = 0.2 m = c d m>s = 9.09 m>s Ans.
0.2 + 0.02
At y = 0.4 m,
1010.42
u "y = 0.4 m = c d m>s = 9.52 m>s Ans.
0.4 + 0.02
Ans:
u " y = 0.2 m = 9.09 m>s
u " y = 0.4 m = 9.52 m>s
930
11–3. Water at 60°F flows over the top surface of the plate. 2 ft
If the free-stream velocity is 1.5 ft>s, determine the boundary
layer disturbance thickness and momentum thickness at the
back end of the plate.
4 ft
1.5 ft!s
SOLUTION
The flow is steady, and the water is incompressible. The transition from
laminar to turbulent boundary layer occurs at the critical Reynolds number of
1Rex2 cr = 51105 2. From the table in Appendix A, vke = 12.2110-6 2 ft2 >s for water
at 60°F.
Since xcr 7 L = 4 ft, the boundary layer is laminar over the entire length of the
plate. At the end of the plate, x = L = 4 ft. The Reynolds number at this point is
Ux 11.5 ft>s2(4 ft)
Rex = = = 4.9181105 2
v 12.2110 - 6 2 ft2 >s
Then the boundary layer disturbance thickness at the end of the plate can be
determined.
5.0x 5.014 ft2 12 in.
d = = 5
= 10.02852 ft2a b = 0.342 in. Ans.
2Rex 4.918110 2 1 ft
And the momentum thickness of the boundary layer can be determined.
Ans:
d = 0.342 in.
Θ = 0.0454 in.
931
SOLUTION
The air is considered to be incompressible. The flow is steady. From Appendix A,
r = 0.00237 slug>ft2 and n = 0.158 ( 10-3 ) ft2 >s. The transition from a laminar
boundary layer occurs at a critical Reynolds number of ( Rex ) cr = 5 ( 105 ) .
Uxcr
( Rex) cr =
n
( 6 ft>s ) x cr
5 ( 105 ) =
0.158 ( 10-3 ) ft2 >s
xcr = 13.17 ft
Since xcr 7 L = 12 ft, the boundary layer for the entire length of the signboard is
laminar. Here, the Reynolds number at x = L = 12 ft is
UL ( 6 ft>s ) (12 ft)
ReL = = = 4.557 ( 105 )
n 0.158 ( 10-3 ) ft2 >s
Then,
0.664brU 2L 0.664(6 ft) ( 0.00237 slug>ft3 )( 6 ft>s ) 2(12 ft)
FD = =
2Re L 24.557 ( 105 )
= 0.00604 lb Ans.
Ans:
FD = 0.00604 lb
933
SOLUTION
The flow is steady and the oil is incompressible. The Reynolds number at x = 0.75 m is
Ux U10.75 m2
Rex = = = 18.751103 2U
no 40110-6 2 m2 >s
Using the laminar disturbance thickness gives
5.0x 5.010.75 m2
d = ; 0.01 m =
2Rex 218.751103 2U
U = 7.50 m>s Ans.
3 5 5
In this case, Rex = 18.75110 217.502 = 1.41110 2 6 5110 2. Therefore, at x = 0.75 m,
the flow is indeed laminar.
Ans:
U = 7.50 m>s
934
SOLUTION
The flow is steady and the oil is incompressible. The transition from laminar to
turbulent boundary layer occurs at the critical Reynolds number of 1Rex2 cr = 51105 2.
Here, xcr = L = 3 m.
Uxcr U max 13 m2
1Rex2 cr = ; 51105 2 =
no 40110-6 2 m2 >s
U max = 6.67 m>s Ans.
Ans:
Umax = 6.67 m>s
935
6 m!s
11–10. A fluid has laminar flow and passes over the flat
plate. If the disturbance thickness of the boundary layer at a
distance of x = 0.5 m from the plate’s edge is 10 mm,
determine the disturbance thickness at a distance of x = 1 m.
10 mm
SOLUTION
The fluid is considered to be incompressible. The flow is steady.
The Reynolds number at x = 0.5 m and 1 m can be determined using
Ux U(0.5 m) 0.5U
Rex " x = 0.5 m = = =
n n n
and
Ux U(1 m) U
Rex " x = 1 m = = =
n n n
U
Thus, at x = 1 m, Rex = = 125 000. Then,
n
5.0x 5.0(1 m)
d = = = 0.01414 m = 14.1 mm Ans.
2Rex 2125 000
Ans:
d = 14.1 mm
938
11–15. Air at a temperature of 60°F flows at 1.2 ft>s over 1.2 ft!s
the plate. Determine the distance x where the disturbance
thickness of the boundary layer becomes 0.75 in.
3 in.
SOLUTION
We will consider the flow steady and air as incompressible. From the table in
Appendix A, va = 0.158110-3 2 ft2 >s for air at T = 60°F. Thus, the Reynolds number
in terms of x is
Ux 11.2 ft>s2x
Rex = = = 7.59491103 2x
va 0.158110-3 2 ft2 >s
We will assume that the boundary layer is laminar. With the requirement
0.75
d = ft = 0.0625 ft,
12
5.0 5.0x
d = x; 0.0625 ft =
2Rex 27.59491103 2x
x = 1.1867 ft = 1.19 ft Ans.
Ans:
x = 1.19 ft
943
SOLUTION
The air is considered to be incompressible. The flow is steady.
From Appendix A, r = 1.247 kg>m3 for air at T = 10° C . Here,
km 1000 m 1h
U = a80 ba ba b = 22.22 m>s .
h 1 km 3600 s
U2 ( 22.2 m>s )2
FD = CDAp r = 1.12 ( 10.5 m2 )( 1.247 kg>m3 ) c d
2 2
= 3620.92 N
Thus, the power needed to overcome the drag is
#
W = FD # V = (3620.92 N)( 22.2 m>s ) = 80.46 ( 103 ) W
= 80.5 kW Ans.
Ans:
#
W = 80.5 kW
992
SOLUTION
The air is considered to be incompressible. The flow is steady.
From Appendix A, r = 1.247 kg>m3 for air at T = 10°C . Here,
km 1000 m 1h
U = a60 ba ba b = 16.67 m>s .
h 1 km 3600 s
U2 ( 16.667 m>s )2
FD = CDAP r = 0.86 ( 10.5 m2 )( 1.247 kg>m3 ) c d
2 2
= 1564 N
Thus, the power needed to overcome the drag is
#
W = FD # V = (1564 N) ( 16.667 m>s ) = 26.07 ( 103 ) W
= 26.1 kW Ans.
Ans:
#
W = 26.1 kW
993
SOLUTION
The air is considered to be incompressible. The relative flow is steady.
Since the parachutist descends with a constant terminal velocity, the acceleration is
zero. Referring to the free-body diagram shown in Fig. a,
+ c ΣFy = may; FD - 90(9.81) N = 90(0) FD = 882.9 N
From Appendix A, r = 1.202 kg>m3 for air at T = 20°C . Here, the projected area
of the parachute perpendicular to the air stream is AP = p(2 m)2 = 4p m2.
U2
FD = CDAP r
2
U2
882.9 N = 1.36 ( 4p m2 )( 1.202 kg>m3 )a b
2
U = 9.27 m>s Ans.
FD
a= 0
90(9.81) N
(a)
Ans:
U = 9.27 m>s
995
SOLUTION
The air is considered to be incompressible. The relative flow is steady.
Since the parachutist descends with a constant terminal velocity, the acceleration is
zero. Referring to the free-body diagram shown in Fig. a,
+ c ΣFy = may; FD - 90(9.81) N = 90(0) FD = 882.9 N
From Appendix A, r = 1.202 kg>m3 for air at T = 20°C . Here, the projected area
d 2 pd 2
of the parachute perpendicular to the air stream is AP = p a b = .
2 4
U2
FD = CDAP r
2
pd 2 ( 10 m>s )
2
882.9 N = 1.36 a b ( 1.202 kg>m3 ) c d
4 2
d = 3.71 m Ans.
FD
a= 0
90(9.81) N
(a)
Ans:
d = 3.71 m
996
SOLUTION
The air is considered to be incompressible. The relative flow is steady.
From Appendix A, r = 1.202 kg>m3 for air at T = 20°C. Here,
km 1000 m 1h
U = a160 ba ba b = 44.44 m>s.
h 1 km 3600 s
U2 ( 44.44 m>s )
2
FD = CDAP r = 0.28 ( 2.5 m2 )( 1.202 kg>m3 ) £ §
2 2
= 831.01 N
Referring to the free-body diagram shown in Fig. a,
+
S ΣFx = max; F - 831.01 N = 0 F = 831.01 N
Subsequently, the power that must be supplied by the engine to produce this drive
force is
#
W = F # U = (831.01 N) ( 44.44 m>s ) = 36.93 ( 103 ) W
= 36.9 kW Ans.
a= 0
W
x
FD = 831.01 N
F
N
(a)
Ans:
#
W = 36.9 kW
998
SOLUTION
The air is considered to be incompressible. The relative flow is steady.
From Appendix A, r = 1.007 kg>m3 and n = 17.26 ( 10-6 ) m2 >s for air at an altitude
km 1000 m 1h
of 2 km. Here, U = a12 ba ba b = 3.333 m>s. Thus, the Reynolds
h 1 km 3600 s
number is
UD ( 3.333 m>s ) (5 m)
Re = = = 9.656 ( 105 )
n 17.26 ( 10-6 ) m2 >s
Entering this Re into the graph for a sphere, CD ≅ 0.16 (approx.). Here,
5m 2
AP = p a b = 6.25p m2.
2
U2 ( 3.333 m>s )2
FD = CDAP r 0.16 ( 6.25p m2 )( 1.007 kg>m3 ) c d
2 2
= 17.6 N Ans.
Ans:
FD = 17.6 N
999
SOLUTION FD = 0.1746 N
U2 ( 20 m>s ) 2
FD = CDApr = 0.5 3 0.46225 ( 10-3 ) p m2 4( 1.202 kg>m3 ) J R
2 2
= 0.1746 N
Ans:
a = -13.7 m>s2
1020