J Intermet 2012 11 022
J Intermet 2012 11 022
Intermetallics
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/intermet
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: The structural phase transition in half-Heusler e Heusler stannides ZrNiSneZrNi2Sn and HfNiSn
Received 16 August 2012 eHfNi2Sn was studied using XRD and EPM analyses, electrical and magnetic properties measurement.
Received in revised form The influence of the disordering and defects in crystal structure on the physical properties was analyzed.
12 November 2012
The performed electronic structure calculations are in good agreement with electrical and magnetic
Accepted 17 November 2012
Available online
behaviors and allowed to explain limited solubility in these phases.
Ó 2012 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords:
A. Intermetallics
B. Electrical resistance and other electrical
properties
B. Magnetic properties
E. Electronic structure
F. Diffraction
0966-9795/$ e see front matter Ó 2012 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.intermet.2012.11.022
46 V.V. Romaka et al. / Intermetallics 35 (2013) 45e52
interchanged. Comparing the variants of the calculation for package [23]. Rietveld refinement was performed using the Win-
different combinations of atomic arrangement at the sites of the PLOTR program package [24].
NNiSn unit cell with the experimental data, the authors of [13] The chemical compositions of the obtained samples with
came to the conclusion that the crystal structure of the NNiSn accuracy w0.5e0.3 at.% were examined by Scanning Electron
compound is disordered and the composition of the compound is Microscopy (SEM) using Zeiss Supra 55VP scanning electron
similar to that assumed in [12]. Considerable concentrations of microscope. Quantitative electron probe microanalysis (EPMA) of
defects in NNiSn compound cause it’s a priori doping and make this the phases was carried out by using an energy-dispersive X-ray
compound a heavily doped and highly compensated semi- analyzer with the pure elements as standards (an acceleration
conductor (HDHCS) [14,15]. voltage was 20 kV; K- and L-lines were used).
It is known that thermoelectric properties of half-Heusler inter- Measurements of the magnetic susceptibility were carried out at
metallics in many cases are strongly dependent on the microstruc- room temperature and fields up to 10 kOe using a conventional
ture, heat treatments, homogeneity domains, atomic disordering and Faraday method with the tetrathiocyanate Co(II) mercury salt,
partial occupancy of the vacancy sites. It is very important for the Me HgCo(CNS)4, as the susceptibility standard. The copper-constantan
NieSn (M ¼ Ti, Zr, Hf) systems characterized by coexistence of two thermocouple was used. The electrical resistivity and differential
similar phases, i.e. MNiSn with cubic MgAgAs-type (half-Heusler thermopower (pure copper as a reference material) were measured
phases) and MNi2Sn with cubic MCu2Al-type (Heusler phases) [16e in the 80e370 K temperature range using two-probe method.
18]. The lack of mutual solubility of the half-Heusler phases MNiSn Band structure calculations were carried out in the framework
and Heusler phases MNi2Sn with similar crystal structures is quite of DFT using Korringa-Kohn-Rostocker method with coherent
remarkable in all studied systems. The half-Heusler MNiSn structure potential approximation and local density functional (KKR-CPA-
may be obtained from MNi2Sn if one half of the Ni-atoms is removed, LDA) [25]. Parameterization of Moruzzi, Janak, Williams [26] and
which results the presence of the covalent bonds and semi- semi-relativistic treatment of the core shells were used. Number of
conductive properties of the MNiSn compounds. In the TieCoeSn k-points for Brillouin zone integration and energy points for density
system these two phases represent the edge members of the solid of states was equal to 1000 in both cases.
solution TiCo2xSn [19], where the electrical conductivity changes
from semiconducting to metallic type. 3. Results and discussion
Doping of the basic ternary compounds of the MgAgAs structure
type, in particular, TiNiSn, ZrNiSn, HfNiSn, allows to considerably 3.1. Composition and crystal structure of ZrNi1þxSn and HfNi1þxSn
improve the power factor values. In the case of substitution of the solid solutions
crystallographic sites in MNiSn structure by other elements the
studying of disordering phenomena and defect formation in crystal In our work we performed the detailed X-ray and EPM analyses
structure is very important. In Ref. [20] it was showed that TiNiSn of the synthesized samples in both ZrNiSneZrNi2Sn and HfNiSne
stannide has defect structure induced by vacancies in crystallo- HfNi2Sn composition range. The Heusler structure may be
graphic positions which can play a role of acceptor impurities. In conventionally presented as a cubic closest packed Sn atomic cell
[21] the structural disorder in ZrNiSn was found e Zr position where the octahedral voids are occupied by Zr(Hf) atoms and the
appeared to be mixed occupied by 99%Zr and 1%Ni atoms giving the tetrahedral voids are occupied by Ni atoms (Fig. 1).
final composition (Zr0.99Ni0.01)NiSn. According to the EPM analysis (Fig. 2) the ZrNiSn compound is
In work [22] the authors significantly improve the thermoelec- characterized by homogeneity region up to ZrNi1.3Sn composition.
tric properties of bulk nanostructured half-Heusler alloys. The SEM images show that starting from ZrNi1.3Sn sample small
authors showed that in half-Heusler MNiSn alloy that contain both amount of the second phase with composition close to ZrNi2Sn
Zr and Hf the solubility of additional Ni atoms was absent. Instead compound appears (Fig. 3). The boundaries between these phases
of this nanoparticle of full-Heusler phase was obtained. are blurred, however with increasing of Ni content they become
In the present contribution we performed a detailed study of the more contrast. All samples with composition between ZrNi1.3Sn
structural phase transition in half-Heusler e Heusler intermetallics and ZrNi1.65Sn consist of two phases e half-Heusler and Heusler.
MNiSneMNi2Sn (M ¼ Zr, Hf) and the composition influence on the Starting from ZrNi1.65Sn composition and up to ZrNi2Sn the samples
physical properties of the corresponding samples. were single-phase and limited the homogeneity region of ZrNi2Sn
compound. Thus, the final composition of these two phases could
2. Experimental be described as ZrNi1þxSn (0 x 0.3) for half-Heusler phase with
MgAgAs structure and ZrNi1þxSn (0.65 x 1.0) for Heusler phase
In our work samples between ZrNiSneZrNi2Sn and HfNiSne with MnCu2Al structure. The results of EPM analysis of the samples
HfNi2Sn compounds were prepared by a direct arc melting of the with Hf showed similar to Zr results (Fig. 4), however several
constituent elements (zirconium, purity of 99.99 wt.%; hafnium, features were found. The SEM image (Fig. 5) of pure HfNiSn stan-
purity of 99.99 wt.%; nickel, purity of 99.99 wt.%; tin, purity of nide showed several grains with gradient of gray colors (different
99.999 wt.%) under high purity Ti-gettered argon atmosphere on
a water-cooled copper crucible. The alloys were annealed at 1073 K
in the evacuated quartz tubes for 720 h, and subsequently
quenched in ice water.
X-ray phase analysis of the samples was carried out using the
powder patterns obtained on Guinier-Huber image plate system
(CuKa1 radiation) and DRON-4.0 (FeKa radiation) diffractometers.
The data for the crystal structure refinements were collected at
room temperature using STOE STADI P powder diffractometer
(CuKa1 radiation, curved germanium (1 1 1) monochromator) and
Guinier-Huber image plate system (CuKa1 radiation, germanium
monochromator). Lattice parameters were calculated by least- Fig. 1. Structural relationship between half-Heusler ZrNiSn (MgAgAs-type) and
squares fits to indexed 2q-values using the WinCSD program Heusler ZrNi2Sn (MnCu2Al-type).
V.V. Romaka et al. / Intermetallics 35 (2013) 45e52 47
Fig. 3. SEM pictures of the ZrNi1þxSn alloys: (a) 1. ZrNiSn; (b) 3. ZrNi1.01Sn; (c) 5. ZrNi1.03Sn; (d) 7. ZrNi1.08Sn; (e) 11. ZrNi1.3SneZrNi1.3Sn (gray light phase) and traces of ZrNi1.65Sn
(gray dark phase); (f) 13. ZrNi1.5SneZrNi1.3Sn (gray light phase) and ZrNi1.65Sn (gray dark phase).
48 V.V. Romaka et al. / Intermetallics 35 (2013) 45e52
Fig. 5. SEM pictures of the HfNi1þxSn alloys: (a) 1. HfNiSn; (b) 6. HfNi1.60SneHfNi1.3Sn (gray light phase) and HfNi1.70Sn (gray dark phase).
Table 1
X-ray powder diffraction data for ZrNi1þxSn (0 x 1) stannides.
Table 2
X-ray powder diffraction data for HfNi1þxSn (0 x 1) stannides.
Fig. 6. Temperature dependencies of electrical resistivity (left) and differential thermopower (right) of the ZrNi1þxSn alloys.
r
E1 ðx ¼ 0Þ ¼ 97:61 meV from percolation level, and E1a ðx ¼ 0Þ ¼ defects of donor nature are formed, and their concentration
83:8 meV determines amplitude modulation of continuous energy increase with increasing of Ni concentration. In this case, doping of
bands of n-ZrNiSn. n-type semiconductor by donor impurity should drift Fermi level
r
Doping of ZrNiSn by lowest concentration of Ni atoms leads to toward conduction band. The activation energy E1 from Fermi level
sharp decrease of resistivity, for example, at 80 K from r to percolation level in ZrNi1þxSn decrease up to y ¼ 0.08. Moreover,
(x ¼ 0) ¼ 4751.1 mU m to r (x ¼ 0.01) ¼ 231.0 mU m and r such doping should lead to decreasing of semiconductor compen-
(x ¼ 0.10) ¼ 62.8 mU m. Such behavior of r(x) shows that structural sation degree and as a result decreasing of amplitude modulation
r r
Fig. 7. Experimental and calculated values of activation energy ðE1 Þ from Fermi level to percolation level of conduction band (left) and hopping of electrons ðE3 Þ on energy states
close to Fermi level (right) of ZrNi1þxSn solid solition.
50 V.V. Romaka et al. / Intermetallics 35 (2013) 45e52
Fig. 9. DOS profile of ZrNi1þxSn solid solution e Ni goes into vacant 4d crystallographic site (left) of ZrNiSn (SG F-43m); vacancies created in Ni-filled 8c site of ZrNi2Sn (SG Fm-3m)
(right).
V.V. Romaka et al. / Intermetallics 35 (2013) 45e52 51
3.3. Band structure calculations gradually filled with Ni to obtain full-filled Heusler phase; (2) the Ni
(8c) site in Heusler phase was gradually filled with vacancies to
Despite similarity in crystal structure, half-Heusler and Heusler obtain hypothetical half-Heusler phase which could be described
phases differ due to the absence of the center of symmetry in half- by formula M(Ni0.5Ni0.5)Sn (M ¼ Zr, Hf). The calculations showed
Heusler phases. Such feature should significantly affect the elec- that in the first case discontinuous change of DOS profile is
tronic structure and chemical bonding of possible solid solutions observed (Fig. 9a), while in the second case e no significant
between half-Heusler and Heusler phases. To verify this assump- changes in band structure were found (Fig. 9b). It means that in
tion, the electronic structure calculations were performed in two half-Heusler phase the occupancy of Ni (4c) site doesn’t change. The
ways e (1) the empty (4d) sites in half-Heusler phase were energy-gap has nonlinear change and completely disappears near
Fig. 12. Distribution of the total and partial DOS of ZrNi1þxSn solid solution.
52 V.V. Romaka et al. / Intermetallics 35 (2013) 45e52
the MNi1.4Sn composition. The density of states at Fermi level magnetic properties of ZrNi1þxSn solid solution. The Ni doping of
dramatically increases after the energy gap disappears (Fig. 10). ZrNiSn and HfNiSn allows tuning up to 10% the thermoelectric
From the chemical point of view the filling of empty sites with Ni power factor.
generates additional d-states in the valence band right inside the
energy gap between valence s- and p-states of Sn
Acknowledgment
(region 5 O 7 eV) and gradually delocalizes them. In such way
the covalent bonding between Ni in 4c and Sn becomes weaker
The work was supported by the Ministry of Education and
(Fig. 11). Further increasing of Ni atoms concentration up to
Science, Youth and Sport of Ukraine (grant No. 0111U001088) and
MNi1.3Sn splits Sn p-states and after this point the structure no
Lviv Polytechnic National University (grant No. 1720).
longer exists. Moreover, the hybridization between these two
components changes dramatically from tetrahedral (non-centro-
symmetric) p orbitals of Sn overlap with dz2, dx2-y2 orbitals of Ni to References
cubic (centrosymmetric) e s and p orbitals of Sn overlap with all
[1] Aliev FG, Brandt NB, Kozyrkov VV, Moshchalkov VV, Skolozdra RV,
d orbitals of Ni (Fig. 12). So the continuous solid solution between Stadnyk YuV. Dielectrization of intermetallic vacancy system RNiSn (R ¼ Ti, Zr,
MNiSn and MNi2Sn phases is absent because different types of the Hf). Pis’ma Zh Eksp Teor Fiz 1987;45(11):535e7.
chemical bonds in both compounds e MNi2Sn are characterized by [2] Aliev FG, Belogorohov AI, Brandt NB, Kozyrkov VV, Skolozdra RV, Stadnyk YuV.
Optical properties of vacancy system MNiSn (M ¼ Ti, Zr, Hf). Pis’ma Zh Eksp
metallic type of the chemical bonds while MNiSn are preferably Teor Fiz 1988;47(3):151e3.
covalent compounds and that fact explains nonlinear change of [3] Kim S-W, Kimura Y, Mishima Y. High-temperature thermoelectric properties
lattice parameters between these two phases. From DOS profile of of TiNiSn-based half-Heusler compounds. Intermetallics 2007;15:349e56.
[4] Stadnyk Yu, Gorelenko Yu, Tkachuk A, Goryn A, Davydov V, Bodak O. Electric
ZrNi1þxSn and HfNi1þxSn solid solutions it is easy to find, that
transport and magnetic properties of TiCo1xNixSb solid solution. J Alloys
structural phase transition from MgAgAs to MnCu2Al happens near Compd 2001;329:37e41.
MNi1.65Sn composition and that is in a good agreement with the [5] Wang W, Fukuhara T, Maezava K. Preparation of Fe-doped semiconductor
bottom edge of the homogeneity region of Heusler phases deter- NiZrSn. J Alloys Compd 2010;500:211e4.
[6] Skolozdra RV. Stannides of transition metals and rare earths. L’viv, Svit; 1993.
mined from EPMA and XRD data. p. 200. [in Ukrainian].
To compare the results of electrical and magnetic properties [7] Ögut S, Rabe KM. Phys Rev B 1995;51(16):10443.
measurements with band structure calculations the appropriate [8] Uher C, Yang J, Hu S, Morelli DT, Meisner GP. Phys Rev B 1999;59(13):8615.
[9] Ahilan K, Bennett MC, Aronson MC, Anderson NE, Canfield PC. Phys Rev B
crystal structure model should be used. Taking into account the 2004;69:1492.
r
obtained values of activation energy E1 from Fermi level to perco- [10] Ishida S, Masaki T, Fujii S, Asano S. Physica B 1997;237e238:363.
lation level and the values of magnetic susceptibility (Fig. 8) the [11] Ferro R, Saccone A. Intermetallic chemistry. Amsterdam: Elsevier; 2008.
[12] Aliev FG, Skolozdra RV. In: Proceedings of the 5th All Union Conference on
final mechanism of doping MNiSn with Ni atoms was determined. crystalline intermetallic compounds. L’vov: L’vovs. Gos. Univ.; 1989. p. 10.
The disordered models of ZrNiSn with composition (Zr0.99Ni0.01) [13] Larson P, Mahanti SD, Kanatzidis MG. Phys Rev B 2000;62(19):12754.
NiSn and HfNiSn with (Hf0.99Ni0.01)NiSn were used as initial. Filling [14] Shklovskii BI, Efros AL. Zh Eksp Teor Fiz 1971;61:816 [Sov Phys JETP 34,
435(1971)].
the empty 4d sites with Ni gradually decrease Ni concentration in [15] Shklovskii BI, Efros AL. Zh Eksp Teor Fiz 1972;62:1156 [Sov Phys JETP 35,
4a site of M (M ¼ Zr, Hf) down to (M0.995Ni0.005)Ni1.1Sn. For the 610(1972)].
calculations the linear dependence of Ni (4a) concentration against [16] Stadnyk YuV, Skolozdra RV. Isothermal section of the phase diagram of the
TieNieSn system at 770 L. Neorgan Mater 1991;27(10):2209e10.
Ni (4d) concentration between (M0.99Ni0.01)NiSn and (M0.995Ni0.005)
[17] Stadnyk YuV, Skolozdra RV. Phase composition of the ZreNieSn alloys at
Ni1.1Sn compositions was used. The obtained values of activation 800 S 50 at.% Sn, at 600 S >50 at.% Sn. Izv AN Russia, Metal 1994;1:164e7.
energy from Fermi level to conduction band (Fig. 7a) and density of [18] Stadnyk YuV, Romaka LP. Phase equilibria in the HfeNieSn ternary system
states at Fermi level (Fig. 8) are in a very good agreement with and crystal structure of the Hf2Ni2Sn compound. J Alloys Compd 2001;316:
169e71.
experimental data and prove the correctness of crystal structure [19] Stadnyk Yu, Romaka L, Horyn A, Tkachuk A, Gorelenko Yu, Rogl P. Isothermal
model. The Fermi level in all cases drifts near conduction band sections of the TieCoeSn and TieCoeSb systems. J Alloys Compd 2005;387:
keeping ZrNi1þxSn material as n-type semiconductor up to x ¼ 0.1. 251e5.
[20] Stadnyk Yu, Horyn A, Romaka VV, Gorelenko Yu, Romaka LP, Hlil EK, et al.
Crystal, electronic structure and electronic transport properties of the
4. Conclusions Ti1xVxNiSn (x ¼ 0e0.10) solid solution. J Solid State Chem 2010;183:
3023e8.
[21] Romaka VA, Fruchart D, Hlil EK, Gladyshevskii RE, Gignoux D, Romaka VV,
The homogeneity regions were found for ZrNiSn, ZrNi2Sn and et al. Features of n-ZrNiSn intermetallic semiconductor heavily doped with
HfNiSn, HfNi2Sn compounds and their composition could be the rare earth metals. Semiconductors 2010;44(3):293e302.
described by the following formulas ZrNi1þxSn (0 x 0.3) e [22] Makongo JPA, Misra DK, Zhou X, Pant A, Shabetai MR, Su X, et al. Simultaneous
large enhancements in thermopower and electrical conductivity of bulk
MgAgAs-type and 0.65 x 1.0 e MnCu2Al-type; HfNi1þxSn
nanostructured half-Heusler alloys. J Am Chem Soc 2011;133:18843e52.
(0 x 0.3) for half-Heusler phase and 0.7 x 1.0 for Heusler [23] Akselrud LG, Zavalii P Yu, Grin Yu N, Pecharski VK, Baumgartner B, Wölfel E.
phase. The crystal structure of HfNiSn appeared to be disordered e Use of the CSD program package for structure determination from powder
data. Mat Sci Forum 1993;133e136:335e40.
statistical mixture of Hf and Ni in 4a site and in a good agreement
[24] Rodriguez-Carvajal J. FULLPROF: a program for Rietveld refinement and
with previous investigation of ZrNiSn. The mechanism of doping pattern matching analysis. version 3.5d. Saclay, France: Laboratoire Léon
ZrNiSn with Ni atoms was determined e increasing of Ni concen- Brillouin (CEAeCNRS); 1998.
tration in 4d position decrease number of Ni atoms in statistical [25] Akai H. Fast Korringa-Kohn-Rostoker coherent potential approximation and
its application to FCC Ni-Fe systems. J Phys Condens Matter 1989;1:8045e63.
mixture (4a site). The results of modeled crystal and electronic [26] Moruzzi VL, Janak JF, Williams AR. Calculated electronic properties of metals.
structures are in a good agreement with the results of electrical and New York: Pergamon Press; 1978. p. 188.