Active Archipelagic Defense Strategy
Active Archipelagic Defense Strategy
S E C R E T 1
S E C R E T
PART I - INTRODUCTION
1.1.2. The Philippines in the past three years has experienced giant strides
in putting its maritime agenda in order. This was initially brought
about by the passage of the amendments to the Philippine
Baselines Law or Republic Act 9522. The law effectively set the
national policy of aligning our national boundaries consistent with
the UN Convention on the Law of Sea, eliminating strategic
ambiguities with respect to our maritime territories and jurisdiction.
The Philippine Supreme Court in denying petitions to nullify the law
further affirmed this.1
1
Prof. Merlin M. Magallona, et al. Vs. Eduardo Ermita, et al. GR Nos. 187167. 16 August 2011.
2 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
1.1.6. However, the experience with the past modernization effort should
guide the implementation of the amended law. The lessons are
more pronounced for the Philippine Navy due to the very long lead
time involved in acquiring the capital assets, developing the
manpower skills, and establishing the maintenance and life support
systems.
1.1.7. We should also be able to identify strategic risks both during asset
acquisition and transition periods to optimize public funds. Learning
lessons from other countries can help reduce the technical,
operational, and financial risks associated with the new acquisitions.
Furthermore, prudence dictates that support and sustainment
systems should be put in place in tandem with introduction into the
service of proposed acquisitions.
1.1.9.1. Address the current and future naval defense and maritime
security concerns of the Philippines;
2 Pertains
to Doctrine, Organization, Training, Materiel, Personnel, Leadership, Facility, and
Sustainment.
S E C R E T 3
S E C R E T
4 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
2.1.3. There are five (5) important international navigational routes criss-
crossing the Philippine archipelago. These are: (a) Luzon Strait-
Bashi Channel-Balintang Channel, and Babuyan Channel; (b)
Verde Island Passage-San Bernardino Strait; (c) Mindoro Strait-
Basilan Strait-Sibutu Passage; (d) Surigao Strait-Balabac Strait;
and (e) Balut Channel.7
3
Baviera, Aileen S. The Practice of National Security. Southeast Asian Affairs. 1998, pp. 215
4
Col. Eugenio Reyes. “Implications of the Exclusive Economic Zone on the Capability of the
Philippine Navy”NDCP : Manila, 1985 p. 141
5
Ibid., p. 142
6 Department of Environment and Natural Resources, United Nations Development Programme,
and Marine Environment and Resources Foundation Inc. “ArcDev: A Framework for Sustainable
Philippine Archipelagic Development. February 2004. p.14
7
Mary Ann Palma. The Philippines as an Archipelagic and Maritime Nation. RSIS Working Paper
No. 182. Singapore:2009. p. 7.
S E C R E T 5
S E C R E T
2.1.7. Southern Luzon and the Visayas offer relatively subdued sea
states and can be covered by small patrol boats and craft during
most of the year. The Mindanao-Sulu area can likewise be covered
by boats and craft.
2.1.8. During the southwest monsoon, the waters off Western Luzon and
Visayas could be very rough and require high endurance vessels.
Sulu Sea, which is an open area, offers moderate to rough sea
state conditions that requires an average-sized vessel.
2.1.9. On the other hand, the coastal waters and waterways are almost
protected from harsh weather conditions and in most cases, sea
state conditions ranging from 0 to 4 are being experienced. In this
respect, patrol boats and craft are ideal for deployment along these
waters.
2.2. Under the Defense Strategic Planning System (DSPS) Cycle 2015-2020,
there are six (6) "core security challenges” that are considered as very
urgent concerns with high impact on the Philippine‟s national sovereignty
and strategic posture. 8 These concerns would either require the
Department of National Defense and the Armed Forces to take on the lead
role or to share responsibility with other government agencies and offices
in addressing these challenges. The core security concerns are: territorial
integrity, maritime security, internal security, natural disasters, cyber
security, and global peace and security. 9
8
Strategic Assessment, Defense Strategic Planning System (DSPS) Planning Cycle 2015-2020
9
The peripheral or “non-core” security concerns include food, energy, and water; and proliferation
of weapons of mass destruction (WMD); and, chemical, biological, radiological, nuclear (CBRN)
explosives.
10
Department of National Defense, Defense Planning Guidance: 2014-2019 (2012), p.6
6 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
2.3.2. The most compelling security concern is China. Its internal political
and economic dynamics; global developments; and the need for
resources to fuel its economy and feed its population are driving its
assertive posture in the West Philippine Sea. This is best expressed
by China‟s “nine-dash-line.” 11 Chinese posturing against the
Philippines in the last three (3) years includes: the harassment of a
seismic survey ship working for Forum Energy; the encroachment
over Bajo de Masinloc; and the blockade of Ayungin Shoal. While
the Philippines has gained international support in the WPS issue as
a result of its legal, diplomatic, and political efforts, it is undeniable
that there is a need for the AFP to develop its capability to credibly
back up the non-military efforts, adequately perform its mandate,
and ably ensure the country‟s sovereignty in the KIG. 12
S E C R E T 7
S E C R E T
15
ibid.
16
Office of the President of the Philippines, National Security Policy (2011),p. 21
17
Overview of the Concepts on Active Archipelagic Defense Strategy, p.1
18
Strategic Assessment, Defense Strategic Planning System (DSPS) Planning Cycle 2015-2020
19
Ibid. p. 6
8 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
20
Ibid. p. 7
21
AFP Strategic Intent, op.cit. p.12
22
National Security Policy, op.cit., pp.15-17
23Palma, ibid.
24
Ibid.
25
Kale Bantique Fajardo, Filipino Crosscurrents: Oceanographies of Seafaring, Masculinities, and
Globalization, University of Minnesota Press, 2011, p. 77.
26
Ibid.
S E C R E T 9
S E C R E T
27
Ibid.
28
DENR, UNDP, MERF Inc. Ibid.
29
Ibid.
30
Ibid. p.14. See also, Huerto, Dexter O. “Command and Control of Philippine Maritime Air
Surveillance”. Air Power Studies Center. 1998. p.21-22
31
Ibid.
32
DENR, UNDP, MERF Inc. loc.cit.p.14
10 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
S E C R E T 11
S E C R E T
Intentionally Blank
12 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
3.1. Culling altogether the materials from the Philippine Constitution of 1987
and policy issuances within the security sector and the Armed Forces of
the Philippines, the principal tasks required of the Philippine Navy are as
follows:
3.2. In terms of defending the territory and securing the strategic maritime
interests, the Philippine Defense Transformation White Paper considers
the following capabilities critical:
3.3.1 The AADS addresses the need to defend our territory and secure
our maritime interests pursuant to existing government policies and
taking into consideration the scenarios of greatest concerns as
articulated in the DSPS. Under normal peacetime conditions, the
Philippine Navy‟s focus will be on establishing a comprehensive
operating picture over our maritime areas of interest and supporting
S E C R E T 13
S E C R E T
our interagency partners enforce the law and order at sea. In times
of crisis in our maritime territory and affecting our jurisdiction thereof,
a tiered and calibrated response will be forthcoming against any
breach of the peace. The AADS is likewise premised on a Philippine
Navy working either in a joint environment ready to undertake the
unilateral defense of the Philippines or with our allies in a
multilateral cooperation regime. (Figure 1)
14 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
S E C R E T 15
S E C R E T
16 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
S E C R E T 17
S E C R E T
18 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
S E C R E T 19
S E C R E T
33Under Part VI Article 77.3 of UNCLOS, “the rights of the coastal State over the continental shelf
do not depend on occupation, effective or notional, or on any express proclamation.”
20 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
34 Such facilities should be benign enough so as not to complicate existing efforts towards the
adoption of a binding Code of Conduct in the South China Sea and prevent the same from
becoming valid military targets under the Geneva Convention on the Law of Armed Conflicts.
35
A term originally accepted in international maritime law to indicate the practice of “privateering”,
or the right in wartime of individual owners of ships to arm them in order to attack the merchant
ships of an enemy power when licensed to do so by a letter of marque. A form of guerre de course
was reinstated at the Hague Convention of 1907 when it was agreed among the signatories that
merchant ships of a belligerent power could be taken up for war service as armed merchant
cruisers. Source:
http://oxfordindex.oup.com/view/10.1093/oi/authority.20110803095911150
S E C R E T 21
S E C R E T
22 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
Figure 4. Hammer and Anvil Concept for the Defense of the Philippines
S E C R E T 23
S E C R E T
24 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
S E C R E T 25
S E C R E T
26 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
S E C R E T 27
S E C R E T
28 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
S E C R E T 29
S E C R E T
Intentionally Blank
30 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
4.1. Force Design. Under the AADS framework, the defense of the Philippine
archipelago will be undertaken through three naval areas or fronts, which
are analogous to a triangle. This triangle covers the country‟s North
Western, Eastern, and Southern Fronts. The apex of the triangle covers
the Bashi and Balintang Channel in the north, Balabac Strait in the
southwest, and the waters adjacent to Davao Oriental. The fronts were
organized based on the commonality of the operating geography and
security challenges present in these areas. (Figure 7)
S E C R E T 31
S E C R E T
4.1.3. The Southern Front secures the tri-border with Indonesia and
Malaysia and addresses the threat of international and domestic
terrorism. This shall comprise the combined area currently under
Naval Forces Eastern Mindanao and Naval Forces Western
Mindanao.
4.1.5. A separate Naval Maneuver Command with its own Flotilla and
Marine Brigade will be established and maintained for overseas and
combined operations. It shall be designed for capabilities such as
recovery of forces abroad, international peacekeeping operations,
non-combatant evacuation, protection of national flag carriers, and
combined naval exercises and operations.
4.2.2. Interoperable. Forces are tasked organized and readily linked for
naval, joint, interagency, and combined operations in addressing a
wide spectrum of contingencies and challenges; and,
4.2.3. Versatile Force. Forces are a mix surface, air, ground, and cyber
forces that can respond to a wide range of operations in a local,
national, or regional environment.
4.3.1. The C4ISTAR pertains to the command and control systems among
Maneuver Force, Static Forces, and Support/Sustainment Forces to
provide operational commanders and decision-makers at all levels
with the means to collect and exchange maritime information to
support planning and execution of naval and maritime operations.
32 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
are made up of the Fleet surface and air units, the Marine Corps,
SEAL Teams, and in recent times, cyber units.
4.3.4. The Sustainment and Support pertains to the shore-, sea-, and
ground mobility-based logistics systems that support the Maneuver
Forces, Static Forces, and C4ISTAR. Shore-based facilities
provide re-provisioning, morale and welfare services,
communications, and depot services, among others. These services
are made available through the various bases, stations, and
reservations dispersed throughout the archipelago. Sea-based
component includes the logistics support vessels, oilers, munitions
vessels, - which goes with the Fleet as underway replenishment
(UNREP) vessels or strategic and tactical lift vessels that provide
forwarding services in between shore facilities.
4.4. Force Package. In order for forces and its capabilities to be employed at
the operational area, it is necessary to provide structure to the force. The
Force Structure36 is dictated by doctrines and concepts that prescribe how
a force is to be employed given a scenario or contingency. Under the
AADS, the determination of the required force is dictated by the delivery of
a force package to address a certain contingency. From this strategic
intent, we can derive the force structure packages necessary to
accomplish the objectives of the AADS.
36
The composition of the Services in terms of the number of major combat and support units, and
their relationship to each other is known as the force structure. In broad terms, it may also mean
the composition and arrangement of personnel, equipment, organizational hierarchy and
command and control elements needed to meet an operational or functional objective of a force.
S E C R E T 33
S E C R E T
34 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
37
Flotilla refers to the aggregation of surface and sub-surface assets assigned to a Naval
Command for deployment and employment. Flotillas differ in size and combination as this is
dictated both by geographical considerations and force package requirements.
38
From the Offshore Combat and Littoral Combat Force
S E C R E T 35
S E C R E T
Oct-Nov: cut
across the AOR
Naval Coast is Mild tropical SW Monsoon: 2-3 Military:
Southern generally rocky climate. Wind Insurgency
w/ numerous predominantly NW Monsoon: 3-5 and terrorism
Command coral formation. northward
Constabulary
Most islands Wet Season: : smuggling,
and islets are Nov-Jan IUU fishing,
vegetated w/ illegal
mangroves Dry Season: migration
April -Nov
36 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
S E C R E T 37
S E C R E T
38 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
S E C R E T 39
S E C R E T
4.4.3.1. Naval Commands can also employ the Marine Brigade as its
principal static force. The three (3) battalions can be deployed
at the Forward Operating Bases, while supported by sealift
vessels. It is designed for island defense and the protection of
critical infrastructure. Attached to the brigade are naval and
marine reservists trained for island defense, irregular warfare,
and combat intelligence. The brigade may also be provided
with coastal missile systems and air defense systems to
establish local sea denial and control over adjacent waters.
4.4.3.2. From a joint perspective, the Marine Brigade can operate with
the coastal batteries of the Philippine Army and Ground-Based
Anti-Air Systems of the Philippine Air Force. Specifically, the
long-range defensive layer of anti-ship missile systems will be
employed for sea denial operations in key locations covered by
Naval Northern Command, while the early warning systems
and ground-based anti-air batteries provides force protection. If
the Philippine Army no longer pursues the coastal defense role,
a Coastal Defense Battalion may be established.
40 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
S E C R E T 41
S E C R E T
4.4.4.2. Philippine Marine Corps shall exercise administrative control over all
Marine Brigades and Battalions. It consists of infantry, armor, artillery,
and special-operations capable units with appropriate Combat
Support and Combat Service Support Brigades.
39
Naval Operating Base is a shore establishment located in a strategic area which comprises all
naval activities capable of providing direct services to the operating forces and prompt and
sustained Fleet-Marine Operation. Three (3) NOBs will be established, namely: NOB Ulugan,
NOB Margosatubig, and NOB Subic.
42 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
4.5. Employing the Force. After the identification of the required force
structure packages, the next step is to organize the force from a strategic,
operational, and tactical perspective.
4.5.1. At the strategic level, the force structure provides appropriate naval
units and capabilities in support of the Joint Combatant
Commands42. Command and control over all Fleet and Marine units
are integrated at the Headquarters Philippine Navy. The Type
Commands – Philippine Fleet and the Philippine Marine Corps –
exercise administrative control over their respective units and assets.
40
Forward Operating Bases are permanently protected shore establishment in strategic coastal
areas with limited shore facilities for naval activities, including embarkation/disembarkation
facilities for Fleet-Marine forces in support to operations.
41
Naval Support Facility is shore establishment which comprises other support activities, primarily
for Officer and Enlisted Personnel housing and secondary and/or tertiary services in support to NB,
NOB, FOB and Training Bases. This facility shall include all other PN base used jointly or
exclusively by the Fleet and/or Marine forces.
42
Unified Commands under the current AFP organization.
S E C R E T 43
S E C R E T
4.5.2. At the operational level, the force employers are the three (3) Naval
Commands and the Naval Maneuver Command. They exercise the
operational command and control functions for assigned Fleet and
Marine units. They have the capability to task organize fleet and
marine assets and units to address contingencies within their AOR.
4.5.3. The force structure following the levels of command and control is
shown in Table 2.
4.5.4. The AADS Force Structure requires time to fully materialize. In the
medium-term period, changes in the current force structure will be
implemented including the decommissioning of lower level
capabilities and units. This transition process is summarized in
Annex C.
44 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
ANNEX A
S E C R E T 45
S E C R E T
5.3.1.2. C4ISTAR
46 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
S E C R E T 47
S E C R E T
48 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
S E C R E T 49
S E C R E T
50 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
ANNEX B
PN Medium Term Development Plan (2013-2017)
S E C R E T 51
S E C R E T
52 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
S E C R E T 53
S E C R E T
Intentionally Blank
54 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
ANNEX C
Policy References
1.1. The 1987 Constitution provides the overall framework for identifying
the defense needs of the Philippines. Under the Declaration of State
Principles and Policies, the Philippines “renounces war as an
instrument of national policy”. 43 This generally connotes that the AFP is
intended only as a defensive force. The constitutional goal of the AFP
is “to secure the sovereignty of the State and the integrity of the
national territory.”44 There are two parts to this constitutional fiat. One is
that the AFP must at all times uphold and protect the constitutional
order that allows the free exercise of the people of their rights and
responsibilities under the law. It must be capable of addressing both
internal and external challenges to the will of the Filipino people to
govern our country in the manner of their own choosing. The second
part of the constitutional instruction relates to the role of the AFP in
ensuring that every part of Philippine territory is free from foreign
aggression and shall be under the effective control of the government.
The national territory of the Philippines includes all the islands
comprising the archipelago including the waters connecting these
islands and all other territories in which the Philippines exercises
sovereignty and jurisdiction. The latter includes the territories of Sabah,
Kalayaan Island Group, and Bajo de Masinloc.
1.3. Executive Order 292, also known as the Administrative Code of 1987,
prescribes the function of the Philippine Navy to “organize, train, and
equip forces for prompt and sustained naval operations. The law also
enjoins the PN to enforce all maritime laws, rules, and regulations in
the Philippine maritime territories and jurisdictions.
43
Article 2, Section 2 of 1987 Philippine Constitution.
44
Article 2, Section 3 of 1987 Philippine Constitution.
S E C R E T 55
S E C R E T
1.4.1. Under the NSP‟s second overarching goal, four (4) objectives
were enumerated: to promote external harmonious relationships
with our neighbors and the world at large; to pursue regional
cooperation in various areas; to enhance our cooperative
security arrangements with allies and neighbors; and to develop
a defense capability to protect our sovereignty and strategic
maritime interests.
1.6. To implement the goals of the PDT White Paper, the Defense
Planning Guidance (DPG) 2014-2019 identified challenges to
territorial integrity and maritime security as the top defense and
security concern. Given the limited resources, defense planning and
resources shall focus on building Minimum Credible Defense
Posture (MCDP) through equipment acquisition, equipment
sustainment, and upgraded technical skills training and education of
personnel. Support to the National Coast Watch System, as a
mechanism for interagency cooperation, shall be given priority.
1.7. Accordingly, the AFP issued the AFP Strategic Intent, in support to the
National Military Strategy (NMS), the objectives of which are the
56 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
S E C R E T 57
S E C R E T
Intentionally Blank
58 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
ANNEX D
Table 5. Force Structure Transition Plan
Force Structure 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
HPN 1 1 1 1 1 1
Philippine Fleet 1 1 1 1 1 1
Patrol Force 1 0 0 0 0 0
Offshore Combat
Force 0 1 1 1 1 1
Frigate 2 2 3 5 5 5
Del Pilar Class 2 2 3 3 3 3
Combat Frigates 0 0 0 2 2 2
Corvette 0 0 1 1 1 1
OPV 12 12 10 9 8 7
Jacinto Class 3 3 3 3 3 3
PCE 6 6 4 4 4 4
DE/MSF 3 3 3 2 1 0
Assault Craft Force 1 0 0 0 0 0
Littoral Combat Force 0 1 1 1 1 1
Fast Attack Craft 59 53 50 45 40 40
PKM 6 6 5 4 4 4
78ft PG 22 22 22 22 22 22
82ft 2 2 1 1 0 0
Fast Patrol
Gunboats 0 0 0 0 0 4
DF 20 16 12 8 4 0
FACP 3 1 0 0 0 0
MPAC MK1 3 3 3 3 3 3
MPAC MK2 3 3 3 3 3 3
MPAC MK3 0 0 3 3 3 3
Coastal Patrol
Interdiction Craft 5 4 2 1 1 1
Aguinaldo Class 4 3 1 0 0 0
Cyclone Class 1 1 1 1 1 1
Service Force 1 0 0 0 0 0
Sealift Amphibious
Force 0 1 1 1 1 1
LST/LSV 4 4 4 4 4 4
SSV 0 0 1 2 2 2
LCU 5 5 6 6 6 6
Auxiliary/Transport
Vessel
Auxiliary Water 1 1 1 1 1 1
Auxiliary Fuel 1 1 0 0 0 0
Auxiliary Cargo 1 1 1 1 1 1
Coastal Fuel Tender 0 2 3 3 3 3
S E C R E T 59
S E C R E T
60 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
S E C R E T 61
S E C R E T
Intentionally Blank
62 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
ANNEX E
Definition of Terms
Amphibious operations are attacks launched from the sea by naval and
landing forces, embarked in ships and crafts involving a landing on a hostile
shore including the following stages: planning, embarkation, rehearsal,
movement and assault.
S E C R E T 63
S E C R E T
64 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
Gas and oil platform protection are activities taken to secure oil and gas
production, transport, and processing facilities located at sea, specifically oil
rigs, gas platforms, and pipelines.
Ground-based air defense systems are all measures which are terrestrial in
nature, designed to nullify or reduce the effectiveness of hostile air action.
45
US Joint Publication 1-02 p. 106
S E C R E T 65
S E C R E T
Internal Waters. Internal waters for the Philippines comprise the waters in
the mouths of rivers, bays and ports separately enclosed by baselines or
closing lines and delimited from the territorial sea and archipelagic
waters in accordance with the relevant provisions of UNCLOS. These waters
are subject to the sovereign jurisdiction of the Philippines.
Marine requirements are assets needed for the Marine Corps to satisfy the
CRs required for AADS. These requirements are deployable C3I, maneuver
forces, combat engineers, strategic artillery force, and combat service support
force.
66 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
Sealift operations refers to the use of cargo ships for the deployment of
military assets, such as weaponry, vehicles, military personnel, and supplies.
Surface and subsurface patrol are activities to gain knowledge of the enemy,
terrain, and operating environment using surface and subsurface assets.
Territorial Sea. The breadth of the territorial sea of the Philippines as may be
established by law shall not exceed 12 nautical miles, measured from
baselines as drawn in accordance with RA 9522. Ships of all States, whether
coastal or land-locked, enjoy the right of innocent passage through the
Philippine territorial sea. In the Philippine territorial sea, submarines and other
underwater vehicles are required to navigate on the surface and to show their
flag.
S E C R E T 67
S E C R E T
Intentionally Blank
68 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
ANNEX F
TEDDY G QUINZON
Commander, PN(GSC)
Director, ONSS
S E C R E T 69
S E C R E T
Intentionally Blank
70 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
ANNEX G
_________________________________
_______________________________
_____________________
(Originating Agency)
____________
(Date)
From: _______________________________________
(Originator)
To: Director, Office of Naval Strategic Studies
Comment/s:
Recommendation/s:
_____________________
(Signature)
S E C R E T 71
S E C R E T
Intentionally Blank
72 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
ANNEX H
Record of Observations
S E C R E T 73
S E C R E T
Intentionally Blank
74 S E C R E T
S E C R E T
ANNEX I
Summary of Changes
S E C R E T 75
S E C R E T
Intentionally Blank
76 S E C R E T