Challenges and Opportunities For Community Based Ecotourism Development in Ethiopia
Challenges and Opportunities For Community Based Ecotourism Development in Ethiopia
net/publication/328450903
CITATIONS READS
18 7,401
1 author:
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Challenges and Opportunities for Community Based Ecotourism Development in Ethiopia View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Sewnet Tesfaye Lema on 23 October 2018.
Sewnet Tesfaye
Department of Tourism Management
Madda Walabu University
Ethiopia
sewtes15@gmail.com
Abstract
Ecotourism is defined as responsible travel to natural areas that conserves the environment and improves
the well-being of local people. Community-based ecotourism (CBE), on the other hand, is a very specific
form of ecotourism which is used to describe ecotourism ventures that are characterized by high
environmental considerations, increased control and involvement of the local residents, as well as
significant benefits accruing for the host community. Ethiopia, due to its magnificent natural and cultural
tourism resources, has a huge potential to become one of the sought after ecotourism destinations in the
world. There are some promising community based ecotourism initiatives in different parts of the country
such as Adaba -Dodola, Semen Mountains National Park, Wonchi Crater Lake and Adwa. The objective of
this review paper was to examine the challenges and opportunities for Community Based Ecotourism
development in Ethiopia. By its methodological approach, this review is considered to be a narrative review
since the reviewer summarized the findings of empirical research which were conducted in different parts
of Ethiopia, and a total of 13 research findings were reviewed. The findings from these studies revealed a
poor ecotourism infrastructure and facilities (trekking pass, parking facilities, all weather roads, camping
sites, clean water, electricity and health and other facilities), conflicts of interest over resource usage and a
severe lack of trained manpower as being the major hindering factors for community based ecotourism
development in Ethiopia to flourish. Moreover, the results from the review also identified the presence of
an abundant variety of ecotourism resources, good proximity to honeypot areas and enabling policy
environments, as the major prospects for community based ecotourism development in Ethiopia to take
root.
Keywords: challenges, opportunities, community based ecotourism, Ethiopia.
Introduction
The International Ecotourism Society (2010) has described Ecotourism as responsible travel to
natural areas that protect the environment and enhance the welfare of local communities.
Moreover, the World Conservation Union (IUCN) defined the term ecotourism in 1996 as an
environmentally accountable travel and visitation to natural places, to experience and admire
nature (and any related cultural features, both ancient and contemporary) which encourage
conservation, and which invariably also have a minimal visitor impact and provide for beneficially
active socio-economic involvement of local peoples, leading to their regional sustainability
enhancement.
Community-based ecotourism (CBE), on the other hand, is a very specific form of ecotourism
which implies that the community has substantial control of, and involvement in, the ecotourism
project and the majority of the benefits remain in the community. It has thus emerged as a valuable
African Journal of Hospitality, Tourism and Leisure, Volume 6 (3) - (2017) ISSN: 2223-814X
Copyright: © 2017 AJHTL - Open Access- Online @ http//: www.ajhtl.com
tool for poverty alleviation, wildlife conservation and the delivery of responsible and sustainable
tourism offerings (Denman, 2001). Ecotourism has become the fastest growing sector of the
tourism industry growing three times faster than the industry as a whole (TIES, 2008 as cited in
Ambelu, 2011).
Ethiopia is a country which is endowed with the vast array of ecotourism resources including
cultural, historical, and archaeological and natural resources which are ideal for the development
of sustainable ecotourism ventures. Ethiopia’s wildlife is one of the richest and most diversified in
Africa with several of its protected areas and wetlands. Out of the total wildlife resources, more
than 320 mammals (39 endemic), 918 birds (19 endemic), 240 reptiles (16 endemic), 71
amphibians (30 endemic) and 172 fishes (38 endemic) species are recorded in Ethiopia
(Vreugdenhil et al., 2012; Amare, 2015b).The country also has a wide variety of wildlife habitats
ranging from alpine moor lands, to lowland savannahs with extensive wetlands. Having evolved
in relative ecological isolation from the rest of the African mainland, Ethiopia contains
approximately 40% of all land above 2,500m in altitude (EWCA, 1996).
There are some encouraging community based ecotourism initiatives in Ethiopia such as Adaba
-Dodola, which is financially and technically supported by the German Agency of Technical
Cooperation or GTZ (now GIZ) on the northern slopes of the Bale Mountains in Oromia National
Regional State and a pilot ecotourism project on Semen Mountains National Park (Sisay,2004).
In addition, there are some Community Based Tourism initiatives in other parts of the country
such as Wonchi Crater Lake (in Ambo, Oromia Region), Adwa (Tigray region) and Mekit in north
Wollo (Amahara region). The Government of the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia has
initiated what is termed the Climate-Resilient Green Economy (CRGE) initiative to protect the
country from the adverse effects of climate change and to help build a green economy that will
help the country realize its ambition of reaching middle income status before 2025 (MoFED,
2013). Hence, Community Based Ecotourism could be one of the best choices to ensure a green
economy as well as to realize the second Growth and Transformation Plan (GTP).
As a result, it is rational to conduct a review on the various studies which have been conducted
in different corners of the country regarding challenges and opportunities of Community Based
Ecotourism Development. It is hoped that this will help provide a multifaceted input for policy
makers, the Ministry of Culture and tourism offices, Ngo’s, the Ministry of Finance and
Development, environmentalists and any other concerned bodies.
The reviewer has not come across with any paper related to the topic described, except a review
paper by Asfaw (2013) which investigated the contribution of ecotourism for livelihood
diversification and sustainable natural resource management from a purely eco-development
paradigm point of view. Hence, it was considered pertinent to conduct this research in order to fill
the gap in reviews, regarding the challenges and opportunities of Community Based Ecotourism
development in Ethiopia.
qualitative rather than a quantitative approach. Hence, the findings of the reviewed studies were
paraphrased, narrated and presented thematically.
The reviewed studies included both published and unpublished research works. The published
research articles were collected from the internet by entering the search terms and phrases such
as ‘Ecotourism in Ethiopia’’, ‘Challenges of Community based Ecotourism in Ethiopia’,
‘opportunities for ecotourism development in Ethiopia’’ into the Google search engine and other
sites of interest.
Only Full length and open access research articles were considered for the review. Consequently,
a total of six (6) published research articles were accessed from different journals such as the
Journal of Environmental Science and Water Resources, the American Journal of Human
Ecology, and the Journal of Hospitality and Management Tourism. Moreover, unpublished
research was also accessed from two renowned universities in the country i.e. Addis Ababa
University and the University of Gondar which had post graduate programs in Tourism during the
review period, and six(6) theses works with an academic rating of very good and above were
selected for this review. In addition, one unpublished research thesis was accessed from Madda
Walabu University Research and Publication Directorate Office. Hence, a total of 13 research
works were reviewed. The small amount is somewhat of a limitation in a narrative approach, but
the researcher is happy that important areas were covered.
The reviewed studies were conducted between 2011-2015 in different parts of Ethiopia and the
regional distribution of the reviewed studies indicated that six researches were conducted in
Amahara Regional State (Semen Mountains National Park in North Gondar, Borena Sayint
National Park in Wollo, Meket Woreda Wollo, Lake Zengena in Awi Zone, Choke mountains in
east and west Gojjam, Alatish National Park in north Gondar); Four researches were conducted
in Oromiya Regional State (Wonchi Crater Lake in Ambo, Bale mountains National Park in Bale,
Awash National park and Adaba –Dodola in East Arsi); one research was conducted in Addis
Ababa ,and the last one was conducted by taking Ethiopia on the whole, as a case.
Findings
In this section, the findings from reviewed studies regarding constraints and opportunities of
Community based ecotourism in Ethiopia are briefly discussed.
by communities where the trekking routes passed adjacent to their farming land. Ambelu further
stated that unless the resource ownership questions are solved through a series of hastily
arranged village meetings, discussion and negotiation, there is the ever-present risk that tourism
will not be adequately supported (or will be resisted) by the local communities who need it most.
Moreover, according to Eshetie (2012), locals display huge resentment towards the direct
competition of sheep with the wild life resources of the park. The direct competition of sheep with
the wild life of the park is leading to predation which in turn causes diseases, especially at Mehal
Sayint woreda. Eshetie stated that Festuca gilbertiana is a thin-leaved species which is in high
demand by the local communities because of its multipurpose functions, and it is used by locals
to make thatch, rope, mattresses and also serves as fodder. However, due to the current policy
of the park, the locals are prohibited from utilizing this grass which has created great resentment
among the local communities. Furthermore, Alemayehu (2011) in his study in Awash National
park also reported the existence of inter-ethnic conflict between the Kerreyu, Ittu and Afar
pastoralists over resource ownership rights of dry-season grazing lands and vital access to water
points, and conflict between the park scouts and the local Pastoralist is also a common
occurrence.
Basic ecotourism facilities such as accommodation, transportation, health services and other
support facilities are essential to enhance the satisfaction of eco tourists and to maximize the
length of stay of tourists to any area. However, the findings of this review indicated that most of
the ecotourism destinations in Ethiopia are devoid of these facilities and services. For instance,
Ketema (2015) stated that there is a dire absence of well-designed trekking passes, parking
facilities, camping sites and effective land use planning alongside the lake. Ketema has also
mentioned that there is a lack of transportation and comfortable roads, and there are no eco-
lodges andcatering facilities around the lake. Similarly, Eshetie (2012) also stated that a lack of
basic facilities such as electricity, an effective road network to and from Borena Sayint National
Park and health stations, are other major problems encountered. Bires (2014) in his study of Lake
Zegena in Amhara Regional state, revealed a shortage of sufficient potable water, a lack of
electricity, toilets and other important facilities that tourists require to make their trips memorable.
Furthermore, Berhanu (2015) has also reported that poor health and accommodation services,
very limited shopping, banking and postal services, the absence of all-weather roads, and no
telecommunication service in all kebeles of Quara wereda except Gelegu town, are all huge
problems requiring urgent support. Demeke and Verma (2014) and Alemayehu (2011) also
identified limited transportation and accommodation facilities as a challenge for CBET in their
study area. Alemayehu (2011) asserts that the community has an acute shortage of clean water
and local people who reside adjacent to the park are forced to use the irrigation canal for
themselves and for their livestock. Ayinalem (2013) also revealed that tourism infrastructure like
accommodation establishments, road transportation, and other destination facilities and services
are very poor and limited in number in his study areas.
Other Factors
Apart from the aforementioned major challenges, there are also other constraints which are
specific to diverse study areas. For instance, global warming, desertification, and the prevalence
of malaria are mentioned as major constraints for community based ecotourism development in
Alatish National Park, north west Ethiopia (Berhanu, 2015). Kassahun,et al.,(2015) have indicated
that problems encountered from non-ecotourism members are the greatest challenge in the
Adaba-Dodola community based ecotourism project. On the other hand, Asteray (2011) reported
that a number of issues are problematic, such as inter alia, the existence of a main road within
the boundary of the Semen Mountains National Park, human induced pressures such as human
settlement, overgrazing, and deforestation, and epidemic diseases of the flag species are the
most challenging issues for CBET in the park. Asteray stated a rabies virus and Foot and Mouth
Diseases (FMD) are threatening the lives of Ethiopian Wolves and the Walia Ibex respectively. A
rabies virus is transmitted from dog to Red foxes and FMD from goats and sheep to Walia Ibex,
which could have a long run negative impact on the park’s tourism. This would lead to a reduction
in the number of tourist arrivals for those keen to view the flagship species associated with the
park.
Ketema (2015) identified unfair benefit sharing, the inability of ecotourism to substitute traditional
agriculture, illegal land marketing, plantation of eucalyptus trees on the shore of Wonchi Lake,
and other institutional constraints as the primary challenges for community based ecotourism
development in Lake Wonchi crater and its surrounding areas. Gemechu (2014) in his study in
Addis Ababa revealed that the fast growing construction industry in city and its surroundings, the
dependence on forests for livelihood, the lack of clear budget and weak formal institutions to
organize ecotourism at sub-city level, the very low income of parks and poor economic benefits
for locals, low levels of awareness of the locals on environmental protection issues, weak
implementation of environmental protection law, deforestation, pollution and the presence of
Eucalyptus trees in Addis Ababa and its surrounding areas are all major constraints for CBET
development. Asfaw (2014) identified other issues such as the shortages of forage/fodder and
grazing land, soil fertility reduction, the absence of a buffer zone, the absence of off-farm activities,
and expensiveness of agricultural inputs as factors which hinder CBET development in Borena
Sayint National Park, north Wollo, Ethiopia. A lack of operative promotion and marketing
(Kassahun, et al., 2015; Berhanu, 2013), the elongated shape of the park (Eshetie, 2012;
Asfaw, 2014), the forced relocation of residents and the small size of the park (Eshetie,
2012), the demand for agricultural land (Asteray, 2012; Kassahun, et al., 2015; Asfaw,
2014) were all critical negative aspects which adversely affect community based
ecotourism development in different parts of Ethiopia.
African Journal of Hospitality, Tourism and Leisure, Volume 6 (3) - (2017) ISSN: 2223-814X
Copyright: © 2017 AJHTL - Open Access- Online @ http//: www.ajhtl.com
However, all the findings of the aforementioned studies are in stark contradiction with the concept
of ecotourism which is defined as a travel to relatively undisturbed and uncontaminated remote
natural areas.
Policy Environments
It was also found that there are various policies in the country which support and create favorable
conditions for ecotourism development as such. For instance, Eshetie (2012) states that
ecotourism development is a priority in the Ethiopian Tourism Development Strategy and is also
important in Ethiopia’s Plan for Accelerated and Sustained Development to End Poverty
(PASDEP) which has laid some solid foundations by establishing relevant strategies and policies
to address issues on the wise use of natural resources and an integrated approach for achieving
rapid and sustainable growth to end poverty. In addition, the Federal and Regional Government
Policy and commitment’s towards Infrastructure Development (Eshetie,2012; Berhanu, 2013), the
Tourism Policy and the new Community Based Ecotourism guideline (Gemechu, 2014); the
Environmental Policy of Ethiopia (Ayinalem, 2013; Alemayehu, 2011), Ethiopia’s anti-natalist
population policy (Eshetie, 2012) and the Investment policy of Ethiopia in the travel and tourism
industry (Asfaw, 2014), are all stated as policy environments which could offer positive
opportunities for developing effective community based ecotourism in Ethiopia.
identified the existence of some community based initiatives in the Awash Falls Lodge, such as
the positive attitude towards community-based ecotourism, the presence of sugar plantations as
aspects which have created alternative sources of employment for locals and traditional
institutions. This would be in areas such as the Gada system of the Kerreyu Oromo, and the
Belaadas of the Afar, which present opportunities for community based ecotourism initiaitives.
Ayinalem (2013) mentioned in his study, that the area is unsuitable for agriculture, mainly due to
the fact that it is a water tower of the upper Nile basin, and with the existence of various Ngos and
conservation projects in place, this is an advantage for community based ecotourism development
in the Choke Mountains and its environs. Eshetie (2012) identified the relative peace and security
of the country, the expansion of telecommunication services, and globalization as an opportunity
for community based ecotourism development in his study area.
References
Alemayehu, D. (2011). Challenges and Opportunities for the Establishment of Community-
based Ecotourism in the Awash National Park Area, Unpublished thesis, Addis Ababa University.
Amhara National Regional State Bureau of Finance and Economic Development (ANRS BoFED)
(2009). Development indicators of the Amhara National Regional State of the year 2008. 6th
edition; Bahir Dar, Ethiopia.
EWCA (2013). A Traveler’s Guide to Bale Mountains National Park. Frankfurt Zoological Society
and the Bale Mountains National Park, Ethiopian Wildlife Conservation Authority (EWCA), Addis
Ababa.
Gedeon, K., Spawls, S., Yalden, D., Berhanu, L. & Siege, L. (2015). Ethiopian Wildlife
Conservation Authority (EWCA), Addis Ababa.
Shale, G. (2014). Planning for Sustainable Tourism: Challenges and Opportunities for
Ecotourism Development in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. American Journal of Human Ecology, 3 (2).
Vreugdenhil, D., Vreugdenhil, A.M., Tilahun, T., Shimelis, A. & Tefera, Z. (2012).Gap Analysis
of the Protected Areas System of Ethiopia, World Institute for Conservation and Environment,
USA.