Chap I
Chap I
INTRODUCTION
The concept of the company has been there for quite a while. The highlights and attributes of
it have advanced over the timeframe as per the cultural changes that the nation has
experienced. The company has certain preferences over the type of systematic ownership and
association in view of the highlights like a constrained obligation, interminable progression
and so on. The present set up dealing with Company Law Administration, directly or indirectly,
at various stages and providing for various administrative authorities is as follows:
• The Central Government The Company Law Board
• National Advisory Committee on Accounting Standards
• Securities and Exchange Board of India
• Official Liquidator Advisory Committee Courts.
COMPANY MEANING
A company means an association of individual formed for some common purpose. But it is a
voluntary association of persons. It has capital divisible into parts, known as shares, an
artificial person created by a process of law and it has a perpetual succession and a common
seal.
DEFINITION
According to Prof. Lindley, company is defined as, “An association of many persons who
contribute money or money’s worth to a common stock, and employ it in some common trade
or business (i.e., for a common purpose), and who share the profit or loss (as the case may
be) arising therefore.
A company can be defined as an incorporated voluntary association of persons formed by law
for a definite purpose, as an artificial person with a separate legal existence.
CHARACTERISTICS OF A COMPANY
o
Membership: To form a private company, minimum two members are required, whereas a
public company can be formed if there are at least seven members. Further, the maximum
number of members in case of a private company can be 200 only, whereas there is no limit
on the maximum number of members in the case of a public company.
o Incorporated Association: It can be formed only by the operation of law. So, it must be
registered under the Company’s Act, which makes it an artificial legal person.
o Separate Legal Existence: It is distinct from its members and, any changes in the
membership of the company will not affect it. Hence, it can sue and be sued, come into a
contract and conduct business in its own name.
o Artificial person: Although a company is regarded as a person in the eyes of law, it cannot
enjoy the rights and duties, as are enjoyed by natural citizens.
o Perpetual Succession: It is formed with an intention that it is going to last forever,
irrespective of the changes in membership, insolvency/death/lunacy of any member.
Therefore, nothing can affect the life of the company, and it can only be dissolved by law.
o Common Seal: As a natural person, a company is not able to sign its documents and so for
this purpose a common seal acts as a tool to sign the official documents. In other words, the
common seal indicates the official signature of the company. The officer authorised to affix
the seal, has to sign the documents for and on behalf of the company.
o Limited liability: One of its most important features is the limited liability of the
shareholders. This means each shareholder is liable to the extent of the unpaid amount
on the shares held by him/her. In addition to this, in case of fully paid up shares, there is
no such liability.
o Share transfer: Shares of a public limited company are freely transferable by the
shareholders. As against, a private limited company has some restrictions on the transfer
of shares.
o Maintenance of Account books: A company has to prepare and keep books of accounts
and necessary documents, for each financial year, at their registered office or else they
have to pay the penalty if they fail to comply with the same.
o Audit of accounts: On the recommendation of the board of directors, the shareholders
appoint a chartered accountant, for auditing company’s account at periodic intervals.
• Adequacy of capital: Generally a Joint Stock Company has the opportunity to raise huge
capital than other types of business. If the company needs money it can sell its shares to
the public.
• Limited liability: The liability of a shareholder is limited to the face value of the shares he
holds. He has no further liability if he has paid the full value of the shares that he has
agreed to pay.
• Perpetual succession: Perpetual succession is another important advantage of joint Stock
Company. A joint-stock company survives, even if all members are willing to shut down
the company or if all members die in natural calamities.
• Transferability of shares: Shareholders have the right to sell the shares of a joint-stock
company to those who are interested to buy. This right to sell shares of joint Stock
Company gives scope to attract a large number of shareholders.
• Managerial efficiency: A company can secure the services of highly qualified persons who
are experts in different fields of business management. It is through the company that the
capital and business ability can be linked together for the benefit of both the individual
investor and the community as a whole.
• Tax relief: A company enjoys greater tax relief as compared to other forms of business
organizations. The company pays lower taxes on a higher income as it pays tax on a flat
rate. Moreover, a company gets some tax concessions, if it establishes operations in a
backward area. Some tax incentives are available for export promotion also.
• Advantages of large-scale business: Since a joint-stock company has huge capital and a
large number of shareholders; it can invest in large-scale production in order to meet the
requirements of people at large.
• Stability: Stability is none of the most important advantages of company Shareholders
death, retirement, or sale of stock do not lead to the dissolution of the business.
DISADVANTAGES OF JOINT STOCK COMPANY
Complexity information: There are a lot of legal requirements to start a company since a
company is created under the law, its formations a complex task.
Lack of control: The buying and selling of shares of a company is the only real control an
owner has. Since the number of shareholders is determined by the number of shares of a
company, control by the board of directors is difficult.
Double taxation: In the case of a company, there are two systems of tax payment. First,
on the basis of profit earned by the company. Second, on the basis of dividend earn by the
shareholders. So the shareholders suffer from double taxation.
Lack of secrecy: A company must provide each shareholder with an annual report. When
a large number of reports are issued, the reports become public. These reports present
data on sales volume, profit, total assets, and other financial matters. Public disclosure of
these data enables competitors and other outsiders to see the company’s financial
condition.
Lack of personal interest: In most corporations, except the small ones, management and
ownership are separate. This separation can result in a lack of personal interest in the
success of the company.
Credit limitations: Bank and financial institutions have to consider the fact of limited
liability of shareholders of a company. If a company fails, its creditors can look only to the
assets of the business to satisfy claims.
TYPES OF COMPANY
“Shareholders may shelter behind the principle of corporate veil, certain that their
obligation does not extend beyond the value of their shares,” according to the Cambridge
Dictionary. STATUTORY PROVISIONS RELATING TO LIFTING OF CORPORATE VEIL
a) Misstatement in Prospectus of the Company – Companies offer securities for sale by
publishing prospectuses. The prospectus produced u/s 26 provides essential notes about
the firm, like facts about shares and debentures, the names of directors, the company’s
principal goals and current activity. If someone attempts to provide misleading or untrue/
inaccurate representations in a prospectus of the Co., he is liable to the penalty,
imprisonment, or both stipulated u/s 26 (9), 34, and 35 of the Act, depending on the
circumstances.
b) Reduction of No. of members below the statutory minimum – If the minimum number
no. of members of a company falls below 2 (for private companies), or below 7 (for public
companies), the company can continue to operate for a period of 6 months while the
number is so reduced, and every person who is a member of the company during that
time, knowing that the minimum number of members has been reduced. If the grace
period of 6 months has expired, the corporation and its members will be held accountable
and can claim for the sum they earned during those 6 months, or the firm may be sued
severally.
c) Failure to refund application fees – According to Section 39 (3) of the Act, if the directors
of the company fail to repay the application money (without interest) within 120 days
when the Co. fails to allot shares, they will be jointly and severally accountable to pay back
the money along with interest of 6% p.a. from the date of expiry of 130 days.
d) Misperception of the name of the company – According to section 12, an officer of an
corporation which signs any bill of trade, hundi, promissory note, or check where the
name of the organisation is not referenced in the recommended way could be held
personally accountable to the holder of the bill of trade, hundi, etc. unless it is
appropriately paid by the company.
e) Fraudulent trading – Section 339 of the Companies Act, 2013 If, during the course of a
company’s winding-up, it seems that any business of the company was conducted with
the intension of defrauding the company’s creditors or any other persons, or for any illegal
purpose, the Tribunal, on the application of the Official Liquidator, the Company
Liquidator, or any creditor or contributory of the company believes it is appropriate, may
proclaim that any individual who is or has been a company’s director, manager, or officer,
or any individuals who were intentionally parties to the carrying on of the business in the
manner aforesaid will be responsible personally, with no limitation of liability, for all or all
of the company’s debts or other liabilities, as directed by the Tribunal. Every individual
having knowledge of that fraud shall be punished with imprisonment for period upto 2
years or fine of upto Rs. 50,000/-, or both.
f) For investing ownership of the company – According to Section 216 of the Act, the Central
Government may appoint Inspectors to examine and report on the company’s
membership in order to determine the real persons who are financially engaged in the
firm and who influence its policies. As a result, the Central Government might ignore the
corporate veil.
g) Inducing persons to invest funds in the company – According to Section 36 of the Act,
anyone who makes false, fraudulent, misleading, or inaccurate representations or
promises to another person or hides relevant material from another person in order to
induce him in doing any of the following:-
• An agreement to acquire, disposes of, subscribe to, or underwrite securities.
• An agreement to guarantee gains to any of the parties based on the return of
securities or on changes in the value of securities.
• An agreement to receive credit from any bank or financial organisation.
In certain cases, the corporate personality might be neglected in order to identify the
actual guilty party and hold him solely accountable.
h) To furnish false statements – Under Section 448 of the Act, if any person makes false or
untrue representations in any necessary return, report, certificate, financial statement,
prospectus, statement, or other document, or hides any relevant or material truth, he is
responsible u/s 447 of the Act. The corporate veil must be lifted in order to find the true
guilty individual who authorised such documents to be disclosed in the name of the firm.
i) Repeated defaults – According to Section 449 of the Act, if a company or an officer of a
company commits an offence shall be punished by fine or imprisonment and commits the
same offence within three years, the company and officer must pay twice the penalty in
addition to any custodial sentence imposed for such offence.
j) In case of Ultra-Virus Acts – Every company is required to operate in accordance with its
AoA, MoA, and the Companies Act, 2013. Any activity performed outside jurisdiction of
either is considered to be “ultra-virus” or inappropriate or beyond the certified scope.
Penalties may be imposed if the company’s operations are found to be illegal. Directors
and other officers of a corporation will be personally liable for all acts performed on its
behalf if they are ultra-virus the corporation.
k) In case where companies internationally avoiding legal obligations – Wherever it is
discovered that an incorporated company is attempting to escape legal responsibilities, or
that the incorporation of a company is being exploited to avoid the force of law, the courts
have the right to reject the business’s legal identity and continue as if it never existed.
Liabilities might be imposed on the people involved.
JUDICIAL GROUNDS OF LIFTING OF CORPORATE VEIL
a) Sham Company (Fraud): It comes as no surprise that no company can conduct fraud on
its own. To conduct such crimes, there must be a human agent engaged with it. As a result,
measures can be made to avoid future fraudulent practices.
b) The courts also have the authority to remove the corporate veil if they believe the
businesses are a hoax or a “Sham”. Companies like these are only cloaks, and their
characteristics may be overlooked in order to find the true offender.
c) Invocation of the Principal of agency: The principle of corporate veil may be disregarded
when it is necessary to identify the principle and agent in connection with an
inappropriate activity undertaken by the agency.
d) Against Public Policy: When a company’s actions are in violation of public policy or the
public interest, courts have the authority to pierce the veil and hold those who are
personally accountable. The right basis for piercing the corporate personality is to
safeguard public policy.
e) Determining the True (enemy) Character of the Company / Avoid Welfare Legislation:
Where the goal of forming a business is to solely make profits. A corporation will not
intentionally try to do good for society. It may, although, choose to inflict harm instead.
f) Tax Evasion (Protection of Revenue): It is the responsibility of every earner to pay their
fair share of taxes. In the perspective of the law, a corporation is no different from a
person. Anyone who tries to escape this responsibility in an illegal manner is considered
to be committing an offence.
g) Negligent Activities: Every corporate entity establishes a distinction between holding and
subsidiary companies. Under Indian company law, holding companies are the ones that
have a say in the constitution of the Board of Directors or own more than half of the entire
share capital of a subsidiary company. For instance, Tata Sons is the holding company,
with Tata Motors, TCS, and Tata Steel as subsidiaries
DISTINCTION BETWEEN PRIVATE COMPANY AND PUBLIC COMPANY
Minimum number
2 7
of members
Minimum number
2 3
of directors
Articles of It must frame its own articles of It can frame its own articles of
Association association. association or adopt Table F.
The company can allot shares, The company cannot allot shares
Minimum amount
without obtaining minimum unless the minimum subscription
of allotment
subscription. stated in the prospectus is obtained.
Definition of CSR As per rule 2(d) of the CSR Rules as amended “Corporate Social
Responsibility” means the activities undertaken by a company in pursuance of its statutory
obligation laid down in section 135 of the Act in accordance with the provisions contained in
CSR Rules.
Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) implies a concept, whereby companies decide
voluntarily to contribute to a better society and a cleaner environment – a concept, whereby
the companies integrate social and other useful concerns in their business operations for the
betterment of their stakeholders and society in general in a voluntary way.
Basically, “Corporate Social Responsibility” means and includes but is not limited to:
• Projects or programs relating to activities specified in Schedule VII to The Act.
• Projects or programs relating to those activities which are undertaken by the Board of
directors of a company in ensuring the recommendation of the CSR Committee of the
Board as per declared CSR Policy of the Company along with the conditions that such
policy will cover subjects specified in Schedule VII of the Act. CSR Applicability in India
• Every company
• Its holding company
• Its subsidiary company
• Foreign company
Having in the preceding financial year:
• Net worth > 500 crore
• Turnover > 1000 crore
• Net profit > 5 crore
Eradicating poverty, hunger and malnutrition, promoting health care which includes
sanitation and preventive health care, contribution to the Swach Bharat Kosh set-up
1
by the Central Government for the promotion of sanitation and making available safe
drinking water.
Improving gender equality, setting up homes and hostels for women and orphans,
setting up old age homes, day care centres and such other facilities for senior citizens
3
and measures for reducing inequalities faced by socially and economically backward
groups.
Protection of national heritage, art and culture including restoration of buildings and
5 sites of historical importance and works of art; setting up public libraries; promotion
and development of traditional arts and handicrafts.
Measures for the benefit of armed forces veterans, war widows and their
6 dependents, Central Armed Police Forces (CAPF) and Central Para Military Forces
(CPMF) veterans, and their dependents including widows.
Training to stimulate rural sports, nationally recognized sports, Paralympic sports and
7
Olympic sports.
Contribution to the Prime Minister’s National Relief Fund, Contribution to the Prime
Minister’s National Relief Fund (PM-CARES) or any other fund set up by the Central
8
Government for socio-economic development providing relief and welfare of the
Scheduled Castes, the Scheduled and backward classes, minorities and women.