Introduction To Risk and Insurance
Introduction To Risk and Insurance
To understand insurance and how it works, it is important to understand the concept of risk
and which types of risk are insurable.
Risk exists when there is uncertainty about the future. Both individuals and business
experience two kinds of risk: speculative risk and pure risk.Speculative risk involves three
possible outcomes: loss, gain or no change. Pure risk involves no possibility of gain; either a
loss occurs or no loss occurs. This possibility of financial loss without the possibility of gain
(pure risk) is the only kind of risk that can be insured.
Risk
Individuals are at risk due to potential financial losses that may result from unexpected
occurrences such as:
Death
Disability
Illness
Accident
Outliving one’s savings
Risk Management
This component is an accordion comprised of collapsible content panels containing display text. Select the item titles to toggle the visibility of these content panels.
Risk management is the process of identifying, assessing (or measuring) and dealing with the
exposures to risk. Once exposures to financial risk have been identified and their impact
measured, various methods (or tools) of risk management can be used to eliminate or reduce
the exposure to risk.
There are primarily four methods that can be used to eliminate or reduce exposure to
financial risk, and a decision with respect to the best method, or combination of methods, to
use must be made. The four methods include:
Risk avoidance
This method focuses on avoiding the risk altogether.
Controlling risk
Also known as risk prevention and reduction. This method focuses on reducing the chance
that a loss will occur (risk prevention) and/or reducing the magnitude of a loss if it does occur
(risk reduction).
Accepting risk
Also known as risk retention. This method retains or bears the risk internally, which is
commonly referred to as self-insuring against the risk.
Transferring risk
This method focuses on transferring the financial consequences of any loss to another party .
An insurance contract or policy is a written document that contains the terms of the
agreement between the insurance company (the insurer) and the owner of the policy. In
general terms, it is an enforceable contract under which the insurance company agrees to pay
a certain amount of money (called a benefit) when a specific loss occurs. In return, the
individual or business pays a specified amount of money called a premium.
Insurers can afford to be financially responsible for the financial risks of the individuals they
insure by using a concept known as risk pooling. With risk pooling, individuals who face the
uncertainty of a particular loss—for example, the loss of income because of a disability—
transfer this risk to an insurance company.
Insurers know that not everyone who is issued a disability income policy will suffer a disability.
In reality, only a small percentage of the individuals insured by this type of policy will actually
become disabled at some time during the period of insurance coverage. For example, a policy
may have 200 individuals paying premiums each month, but only a small percentage are
expected to ever go on disability. By collecting premiums from all individuals and businesses
that wish to transfer the financial risk of disability, insurers spread the cost of the few losses
that are expected to occur among all the insured persons. Insurance, then, provides
protection against the risk of financial loss by applying the principle of risk pooling. If the
financial losses that actually result from a given peril, such as disability, can be shared by
large numbers of people who are all subject to the risk of such losses and the probability of
loss is relatively small for each person, then the cost to each person will be relatively small.
The group insurance policy provides insured coverage for specific types of losses and pays
benefits to members of the insured group when they have an eligible loss.
Predictions of future losses are based on the concept that, although individual events such as
the disability or death of a particular person occur randomly, the observations of past events
can be used to determine the likelihood, or probability, that a given event will occur in the
future. A key concept that helps explain the accuracy of predictions about the probability of
an event occurring is the law of large numbers.
The law of large numbers states that, typically, the more times a particular event is observed,
the more likely it is that the observed results will approximate the “true” probability that the
event will occur.
There are five basic characteristics that define an insurable risk and form the foundation of
the business of insurance. A potential loss that does not have these characteristics generally
is not considered to be an insurable risk.
Note that these are standard characteristics. Some benefits do not exhibit all these
characteristics, for example, basic dental.
Basic dental
Basic dental insurance typically covers diagnostic and preventative services, such as oral
exams, x-rays, scaling and topical fluoride treatments, in addition to services triggered by an
unexpected event. The cost of dental services is generally predictable and there is lower risk
that dental services will result in a cost that is catastrophic in nature.
Insurable Groups
There are four main types of insurable groups in the marketplace that buy group life and
health insurance products:
1. Single-employer group
2. Multi-employer group
3. Association group
4. Creditor group.
Single-employer groups are the most common type of group covered by insurance
companies. These groups are also referred to as employee-employer groups and are
considered desirable from a risk perspective.
Single-Employer Group
A single-employer group covers the employees of one employer and is usually defined as a
company (whether incorporated, a partnership, or a sole proprietorship). Government
organizations and government-sponsored agencies, such as school boards and social work
agencies, are also considered to be employer groups.
A single-employer group is not always only one company. It can be made up of two or more
companies, such as a group of affiliated companies or a parent company and its subsidiaries.
However, for insurance purposes, the operation of these companies must be centralized at
some level so that all matters and decisions made concerning the group benefits plan are
handled by only one manager or department.
Multi-Employer Group
A multi-employer group generally covers members who work for more than one employer and
who are typically members of a single union in a particular industry and/or area, and where
employer contributions are determined in accordance with one or more collective bargaining
agreements.
The plan arrangement for such a group is referred to as a multi-employer plan (MEP). A trust
structure is commonly used to hold plan assets for MEPs. This arrangement permits delivery
of benefits to large groups of employees with different employers. One or more trustees, often
with equal representation from labour and management, have a fiduciary responsibility for
the trust assets. The trust “sponsors” the plan to provide coverage for members and
determine benefit levels and other aspects of plan design.
Association Group
There are two types of association groups eligible for group insurance:
In order to be eligible for group insurance, the association must have been formed for reasons
other than obtaining group insurance .
Creditor Group
Money-lending institutions contract with insurers to provide protection from debt losses due
to the death, disability and, sometimes, the unemployment of their borrowers. The borrowers
are covered in a group referred to as a creditor group. Any benefits payable under the terms
of the group insurance contract are paid to the financial institution as repayment of the
outstanding amount of the borrower’s loan. The borrower pays premiums for the insurance.
Lesson:2
Types of Group Insurance
In this lesson, you will learn to:
Reinsurance
Reinsurance is insurance that one insurer (known as the ceding company) purchases from
another insurer (known as the reinsurer) to transfer risks on insurance policies that the ceding
company issued. To cede insurance business means to obtain reinsurance on that business by
transferring all or part of the risk to a reinsurer.
A reinsurer also sometimes cedes risks to yet another reinsurer in a transaction known as
a retrocession. The reinsurance company that accepts the risk in a retrocession is known as
a retrocessionaire.
Reinsurance: Maria
The Omega Life Insurance Company has established a retention limit
of $750,000. Omega recently issued a $1,500,000 policy to Maria.
Omega has entered into a reinsurance agreement with the Epsilon
Reinsurance Company. Under the terms of the reinsurance
agreement, when Omega issues a life insurance policy with a face
amount that exceeds its retention limit, the amount in excess of the
retention limit is automatically ceded to Epsilon. Epsilon also has a
retention limit. Its limit is $500,000.
As a result of the reinsurance agreement, $750,000 of the coverage
Omega issued Maria will be ceded to Epsilon. Epsilon in turn will
cede $250,000 to a retrocessionaire. If Maria dies while the policy is
in effect, Omega will pay the policy benefit of $1,500,000. Epsilon
will reimburse Omega for $750,000 of the policy benefit payable.
The retrocessionaire will reimburse Epsilon for $250,000 of the policy
benefit payable.
When an insurer agrees to provide a group with insurance coverage, the insurer issues an
insurance policy (also known as a group benefits policy). The group benefits policy is a written
document that contains the terms of the agreement between the insurer and the owner of the
policy. The policy is a legally enforceable contract under which the insurer agrees to pay a
certain amount of money—known as the policy benefit, or the policy proceeds—when a
specific loss occurs, provided that the insurer has received a specified amount of money,
called the premium.
1. Advisors
An advisor is an individual or company that provides advice to group benefits plan sponsors.
There are several types of advisors.
1. Consultant: provides expert business, professional or technical advice and acts for
and represents the plan sponsor in dealings with the insurer
2. Agent: acts for or represents the plan sponsor in dealing with the insurer and
generally represents only one insurer (referred to as a “captive agent”)
3. Broker: acts for or represents the plan sponsor in dealings with the insurer. Unlike
an agent, a broker is self-employed or independent from all insurers and can sell
products from a number of insurance companies.
A. Insurer(s)
The insurer is the party to the insurance contract who promises to pay losses or benefits
2. Plan Member
A plan member is any employee or member (or former employee) who is eligible to be
insured for any benefit under a group insurance arrangement. Sole proprietors or partners
in a partnership are also eligible to be plan members even though they are not employees.
A. Dependent
A dependent is generally the spouse or child of an individual covered under a group insurance
plan. Eligible dependents are defined in the policy and obtain coverage if designated by the
plan member. For example, a plan member’s spouse and children can be covered under a
dental, extended health care, dependent life and optional accidental death and
dismemberment (AD&D) policy. In addition, a member’s dependents may be covered under
an optional life policy.
B. Beneficiary
A beneficiary is a person designated by a plan member, or by the terms of a group benefits
plan, who is or may become entitled to a benefit under the plan. For example, a basic group
life plan requires that the plan member designate a beneficiary to receive the proceeds of any
death benefit payable under the terms of the plan. The concept of beneficiary is only
applicable to death benefits.
Mason has several options available. He can select a captive agent, or he can select a
broker or consultant. If he chooses a broker or consultant, that individual can
represent multiple insurers to “shop the market” for the best possible terms and cost
from multiple insurers; if he chooses an agent, the agent will represent only one
insurer.
Group Benefits Program and Group Benefits
Plan Defined
Group benefits are generally provided by plan sponsors in a package—a combination of
several different types of individual benefits (e.g., life insurance, health care and dental
insurance). The terms package and program are used interchangeably to describe the overall
collection of benefits provided by a plan sponsor.
Plan is another frequently used term, often used interchangeably with program or
package. Plan is also used to describe an individual benefit (e.g., a dental plan and a life
insurance plan are two components of the plan sponsor's group benefits program).
For the purpose of this course, the term program is used to describe the overall collection of
benefits provided and plan is used to describe an individual benefit.
Basic life
Optional life
Dependent life
Basic AD&D
Optional AD&D
Retiree life
Salary continuance
Sick leave
Weekly indemnity/short-term disability (WI/STD)
Long-term disability (LTD)
Hospital
Prescription drugs
Vision
Private duty nursing
Paramedical practitioners
Out-of-province/out-of-country
Basic
Major restorative
Orthodontic
Ancillary benefits
Employee assistance
Health care spending accounts
Wellness
Critical illness
Life Insurance
Life insurance benefits that an employer might offer include:
Basic Life Insurance
Basic life insurance provides a benefit in the event of an employee’s death while employed
by the employer. It is typically provided to all active full-time employees, and premiums are
usually paid by the employer.
Optional Life Insurance
Optional life insurance is a voluntary benefit that is supplementary to the basic life
insurance benefit (i.e., members can purchase additional life insurance benefits to
supplement the basic coverage). Premiums are paid by the employee/member and
coverage may be extended to the employee’s/member’s spouse.
Dependent Life Insurance
Dependent life insurance provides a modest lump-sum amount in the event of the deaths
of the employee’s/member’s eligible dependents. Generally, the benefit provides
protection of $5,000 to $25,000 in respect of the spouse and a lesser amount of $2,500 to
$12,500 in respect of each eligible child. The premium is typically paid by the employer.
The amount of income replacement benefit typically ranges from 55% to 70% of the
employee’s predisability earnings, and a maximum amount of benefit applies. Benefits are
paid on a weekly basis. The premium for WI/STD may either be paid by the employer or the
employee but is rarely based on a shared-cost arrangement.
Apply Your Knowledge
STD Insurance: Interior Dezine
Interior Dezine Inc. wishes to protect its employees from income loss during a period
of short-term disability. The company-paid WI/STD benefit achieves that purpose by
paying employees 60% of their regular predisability earnings for up to 17 weeks.
Benefit payments begin the fourth day following the last day worked by the employee.
If the employee is disabled due to an accident or is hospitalized, the three-day waiting
period is waived. The WI/STD plan covers only active, full-time employees.
The premium for LTD insurance can be paid by the employer or the employee or both;
however, in practice, premiums are rarely on a shared-cost arrangement. The tax status of
any benefit received under the policy depends on which party has made the premium
payments. If any part of the premiums has been paid by the employer, the benefits are
taxable; however, if the entire premium has been paid by the employee, benefits are
nontaxable.
Dental Insurance
Dental insurance provides employees with reimbursement for the expenses incurred for basic,
major restorative and orthodontic services. The coverage is typically extended to include
reimbursement for expenses incurred by the employee’s eligible dependents. Benefits are
generally reimbursed at a higher level of coinsurance for services with the lowest cost and
highest frequency, such as basic services, than for the less frequent, higher priced services
such as major restorative care and orthodontia. Cost-sharing arrangements for dental
insurance are the same as those available for health care insurance. The plan may have a
deductible and/or coinsurance, and premiums may be paid by either the employer or the
employee or on a shared-cost basis.
CI insurance is intended to cover additional medical expenses or activities that support the
employee dealing with a critical illness; however, it can be used by the employee as he or she
wishes. It may be used to pay for experimental treatments (or other medical costs not
covered by provincial/territorial health plans or other private insurance plans) and lifestyle or
mobility changes resulting from the illness.
CI coverage can be offered under a basic or enhanced group plan. The basic plan typically
covers four to six illnesses, including strokes and heart attacks. If offered on a mandatory
basis, premiums are often 100% employer paid. An enhanced plan covers a more
comprehensive list of life-threatening conditions, including coronary artery bypass surgery,
kidney failure and multiple sclerosis.
Coverage is typically offered on a voluntary basis, with employees paying 100% of the
premiums. If offered as a mandatory benefit, the premiums are typically 100% employer paid
but can also be on a shared-cost basis.
LESSON-3
The parties to a master group insurance contract are the insurance company (insurer) and the
group policyholder. The group policyholder is the person or organization that enters into the
group insurance contract—known as the plan sponsor. The plan sponsor decides what types
of group insurance coverage to purchase for the group members, negotiates the terms of the
group insurance contract with the insurer and purchases the group insurance coverage.
The master group insurance contract is also referred to as the master contract or, more
typically, the group policy. A typical policy period is one year. In some cases, premium rates
may be guaranteed for longer than one year; however, policies typically renew once a year on
the anniversary date of the policy.
The plan sponsor receives a copy of the group policy. There is no requirement to provide the
individual plan members with a copy of the policy; however, they must be provided with a
certificate of insurance. Many policyholders describe the coverage in a benefit booklet. In
such cases, the benefit booklet contains the information that would be included in a
certificate, and the booklet serves as the group insurance certificate.
Policyholder vs. Policyowner
The term policyholder is used rather than the term policyowner (used in individual insurance
policies) because the group policyholder (plan sponsor) does not have the same ownership
rights in the group insurance policy that a policyowner has in an individual insurance policy
(e.g., when an individual buys life insurance for himself or herself). Instead, some of these
rights are granted to the insured group members.
For example, each group member insured under a group life insurance policy has the right to
name the beneficiary who will receive the benefits payable upon that group member’s death.
In contrast, an individual life insurance policy grants that right to the policyowner, rather than
to the insured.
As the policyowner, only Alice has the right to change the beneficiary under
either of these two individual policies.
Adam is also covered under the basic life insurance plan with his new
employer. Under this plan, Adam chooses his own beneficiary because his
employer is a policyholder rather than a policyowner.
Be provided with accurate information so that they can adequately assess the risks
involved, assess the validity of claims for benefits and set the premium rates
appropriately
Inspect group policyholders’ payroll (and other) records to assess the eligibility of
employees
Adjudicate (i.e., process) claims as per the terms of their contracts
Underwrite and decline business
Decline to renew policies
Sell all of, or a part of, their book of group clients to another insurer. A book refers to
a section or portfolio of policies.
Refuse to deal with a specific advisor and refuse to quote on any specific group
Deal only in those locations (provinces or countries) allowed by law and where
proper services can be provided
Change underwriting procedures, reserve formulas, interest credit formulas,
retention formulas, underwriting guidelines and benefit wording (with the signature
of the insurance company's president or chief executive officer on the contract
and/or amendment page)
Change standard commission scales on future business
Change service procedures, service staff and service locations
Change internal administrative procedures
Invest monies in their pools as the insurers see fit (and as permitted by law)
Decline coverage for any amount over the nonmedical maximum coverages if the
employee cannot pass medical underwriting approval
Cancel benefits for employees who are not actively at work, for example, during a
strike
Increase or decrease premium rates at any time, subject to any guarantees that may
have been provided to a group policyholder.
Rights of Policyholders
In general, policyholders (plan sponsors) that are parties to group insurance contracts have
the right to:
Determine the design of the benefits plan within the parameters of what the insurer
is prepared to underwrite
Determine which benefits are to be included, if this meets underwriting approval
Determine the funding method to be used, if this meets underwriting approval
Determine the premium sharing between the employer and the employees
Cancel the policy at any time and not replace it, unless specific employment
contracts, union or employee association agreements say otherwise
Change insurers at any time, as long as no employee loses group life or disability
insurance coverage
Change the premium-sharing arrangement with the employees at any time
Change the agent of record at any time. The agent of record is the individual or
company that is designated to represent the insured in purchasing, servicing and
maintaining an insurance policy. Smaller policyholders using a captive agent (i.e., an
insurance agent who only works for one insurance company) may be able to change
only to another agent of record within that insurer if they wish to retain their policy
with that specific insurer. All others can change at any time to whomever they wish.
Collect and remit the employee share of the premium
Expect that the insurer will deliver the services and pay the claims as per the terms
of the policy, including any changes to the contract and anything promised verbally
or specified in writing by the insurance company representatives
Cancel or stop paying premiums for benefits when employees are not actively at
work, such as during a strike, except where required by law
Receive and keep refunds of premium without refunding to employees their
share. Refunds may be accomplished in the form of a premium holiday, where
employees remain insured but are not required to contribute to premiums for a
specified period, or by investing the refund in other areas that directly benefit
employees.
Apply Your Knowledge
Rights of Policyholders: Mason
Mason, president of the Sweet Apple Company and plan sponsor
(policyholder) has been having financial challenges lately. He has
reviewed all aspects of Sweet Apple’s expenses and determines he must
do something to reduce costs. He could either reduce the company's
costs of the group insurance plan by having employees pay 50% of the
premium, or he could revise the plan to reduce the level of benefits
available to employees. He has not made a decision yet but is relieved to
know that he has the right to do either under the terms of the group
insurance contract.
Expect notification of any change to benefit wording within a reasonable time period
and, preferably, before a change takes place
Be provided with copies of a current employee booklet
Expect the employer to make proper deductions and to remit the premiums in a
timely manner so as not to jeopardize the policy or the claims payments
Change their own revocable beneficiaries of a life insurance benefit at any time. In
Quebec, a spouse as beneficiary is irrevocable, unless explicitly indicated as
revocable.
Expect the employer to look after their best interests in terms of setting up coverage
and handling the funding of the benefits in a judicious manner
Expect the employer to enroll employees on time so as not to cause a delay in the
employee or dependent coverage or the possible declination of that coverage
Expect the employer to submit timely eligibility information (e.g., enrollment of new
employees, salary changes, etc.)
Expect privacy and confidentiality of all personal information and all information that
pertains to their claims or the claims of their dependents. No information that is
attributable to or identifiable with a specific employee can be released without the
employee's or the dependent spouse's written permission.
Decline coverage, unless the policy’s administration is set up by the employer as a
condition of employment. A refusal card or some other form of waiver must be
signed and dated by the employee and submitted to the insurer.
Rights of Advisors
In general, advisors appointed by the policyholder as the agent of record have the right to:
Participate in the analysis of group insurance quotes as requested by the
policyholder
Request and inspect the overall premiums, claims and premium rate history for each
benefit of the policy
Request, inspect and clarify employee data required by insurers to provide
competitive and accurate quotes
Request from the insurer, on behalf of the policyholder, clarification of the terms and
conditions of the group contract
Request assistance from an insurer (via the group office) in reevaluating a particular
claim if permission has been granted by the policyholder and the plan member
Assist the policyholder in the group insurance administrative functions as requested
by the policyholder and as allowed by the insurer and by law
Request employee and dependent information on behalf of the insurer. Once
requested, the information can be sent directly to the insurer by the policyholder.
The general rules of risk selection used by underwriters are known as underwriting guidelines.
The term underwriter can mean:
1. The insurer that receives the premiums and accepts responsibility for fulfilling the
policy contract
2. The insurer’s employee who decides whether or not the insurer should assume a
particular risk.
The employer must contribute at least some of the cost of the plan.
This indicate the employer’s commitment to operate the plan along sound principles and to
continue the plan for a number of years.
There must be a spread of risk.
There must be a sufficient number of employees in the group to reduce, as much as possible,
the chance of fluctuations in the amount of claims incurred (by application of the law of large
numbers). Insurers have requirements for the minimum number of employees who must be
enrolled (two or more) and require that these participation rates be met
Adverse selection is also known as “selection against the insurer”—as the insurer is the party
in a group insurance arrangement that requires protection against antiselection. This is a
primary reason that insurers need to carefully review applications to properly assess the
degree of risk the company will be assuming if it issues the policy.
The Delta Gamma Insurance Company reviews each of the triplets’ applications for
optional life insurance. The insurer determines that while Izetta and Isabelle are
acceptable risks, Irene has a greater-than-average likelihood of dying before either of
her sisters. Delta Gamma Insurance Company accepts Izetta and Isabelle for coverage
under the Charles Chocolate Co. group optional life plan but declines Irene’s
application due to unacceptable medical evidence of insurability. Acceptance of
Irene’s application would have resulted in adverse selection.
Underwriting Guidelines
Each insurer establishes its own underwriting guidelines; however, the group underwriter
considers specific characteristics of a group when evaluating whether the group is an
acceptable risk. These risk characteristics include:
Group Size
One of the underwriter’s goals is to determine the group’s predicted loss rate. The predicted
loss rate is a forecast of the expected claims experience—in broad terms, a comparison of:
The size of the group has a strong impact on the underwriter’s ability to predict the group’s
probable loss rate. In general, the larger the group, the more likely it is that the group will
experience a loss rate that approximates the predicted loss rate.
For very small groups, such as groups with fewer than 15 members, group underwriting
guidelines may require each individual member of the group to submit satisfactory evidence
of insurability. For a slightly larger group (between 15 and 50 members), the underwriter may
combine several groups that are of the same approximate size and are in the same business
sector. By considering the expected experience of a number of small groups, the underwriter
can expect the experience of those small groups, taken as a whole, to approximate the
experience of a single large group.
1. Replace those who leave the group and, consequently, to keep the group size stable
2. Keep the age distribution of the group stable.
If a group does not add young, new members for a number of years, then the increasing age
of the group’s original members would adversely affect the group’s age distribution, and the
group’s loss rate and premium rate would increase as a result. If young, new members are
continually joining the group, the age distribution of the group should remain more stable, as
should the expected loss rate.
The flow of new, young employees into the Andersen Metalworks Ltd. group life plan
has resulted in keeping the age distribution of the group stable. The Merlin Insurance
Company has been able to maintain the original premium rate for Andersen
Metalworks over the ten years. The significant increase in average age under the
Copenhagen Metalworks’ plan is an indicator that there has been an increase in the
expected loss rate under the policy. The insurer had to take the increased risk into
account and has increased Copenhagen’s premium rate over the ten-year period.
Benefits typically offered on a voluntary basis include optional life and optional AD&D
insurance. Some underwriters have minimum participation thresholds (e.g., 10% of the group
or ten insured members electing coverage), while others have no minimum participation
requirement.
Some underwriters will agree to offer core benefits such as LTD and dental insurance on a
voluntary basis. In these rare situations, participation requirements are generally higher, e.g.,
75% of the group.
The larger the group, the better the spread of risk, and the more consistent the average age
and health of the group will remain from year to year. This protects the insurer against loss
and adverse selection and protects the employer from large fluctuations in premium rates
from year to year. All other factors being equal, a larger group may also have less expensive
per capita insurance costs due to economies of scale.