06 - Repair of Exchanger Tubes
06 - Repair of Exchanger Tubes
One of the most overlooked best practices for plugging a tube is to vent the tube
beforehand. Tube venting is a process by which a small puncture is made inside of the
tube, releasing any pressure or chemicals that may be trapped inside. The term positive
venting refers to the intentional creation of a pierced hole to vent the tube. The hole
should be of sufficient size so that deposits cannot seal it while the heat exchanger is
still in service.
Source for text and image.. Elliott Tool Technologies
Tapered Plugs
Friction fit tapered plugs (Picture below) shall only be used in services that meet all of
the following conditions, unless an engineering evaluation is performed indicating the
acceptability of these plugs in other services..
Note.. Inspection of the expanded tube for tube thinning should be made to ensure that
installation of the plug does not further damage the tube leading to seal failure between
the plug and the tubes.
Tapered plugs that are installed where tubes are not pierced can present a
serious safety hazard. If the tube cannot be pierced, the tube should be pulled or
other measures should be taken to ensure personnel protection, such as welding
the plug to the tubesheet and draining all liquids from the tube being plugged.
Mechanical plugs
Mechanical plugs (Picture below) should be considered in situations where friction fit
tapered plugs are not appropriate for the pressure and/or temperature of service or other
mechanical/environmental conditions. These types of plugs have been used in services
of up to 483 bar (7.000 psi) and 595°C (1.100°F). Mechanical plugs are typically
installed by a pneumatic or hydraulic system. Other styles of plugs may be considered
for higher pressures.
Consideration shall also be given to the following..
A plug map should be developed to record the number and location of tubes that have
been plugged. Additionally, the number of tubes, cumulative number of tubes versus the
duration, should be charted. When the sharp turn in tube failure numbers occurs,
replacement of the tube bundle should be considered. See image below for example
chart.