Presstressed Concrete Design - 092508
Presstressed Concrete Design - 092508
Pre-stressing is the application of an initial load on the structure so as to enable the structure to
counteract the stresses arising during its service period.
The idea of pre-stressed concrete has been around since the latter decades of the 19 th century, but
its use was limited by the quality of the materials at the time. It took until the 1920’s and 30’s for
its materials development to progress to a level where pre-stressed concrete could be used with
confidence. Freyssinet in France, Magnel in Belgium and Hoyer in Germany were the principle
developers.
The idea of pre-stressing has been applied to many other forms as wooden barrels and bicycle
wheel. In these cases, the heated metal is made to just fit an object. When the metal cools it
contracts inducing pre-stress into the object.
The concept of pre-stressed concrete is also not new. In 1886, a patent was granted for tightening
steel tie rods in concrete blocks. This is analogous to modern day segmental constructions. Early
attempts were not very successful due to low strength of steel at that time. Since we cannot pre-
stress at high stress level, the pre-stress losses due to creep and shrinkage of concrete quickly
reduce the effectiveness of pre-stressing.
Basic example:
The classic everyday example of pre-stressing is this: A row of books can be lifted by squeezing
the ends together.
The structural explanation is that the row of books has zero tensile capacity. Therefore, the
‘beam’ of books cannot even carry its self-weight. To overcome this, we provide an external
initial stress (the pre-stress) which compresses the books together. Now they can only separate if
Concrete:
In an ordinary concrete beam the tensile stress at the bottom are taken by standard steel
reinforcements.
But we still get cracking which is due to both bending and shear.
Since PSC uses the whole concrete section, the second moment of area is bigger and the section
is stiffer.
The larger second moment of area greatly reduces deflections for a given section size
The smaller section size reduces self-weight. Hence a given section can span further with pre-
stressed concrete that it can with ordinary reinforced concrete.
iv. Durability
Since the entire section remains in compression, no cracking of concrete can occur and hence
there is little penetration of the cover. This greatly improves the long term durability of structures
Disadvantages:
Concrete itself is a composite material. The basic ingredients of the concrete mix are water,
Portland cement and aggregates (rock and sand).
Ordinary Portland cement- based concrete is used but strength usually greater than
50N/mm2.
A high early strength is required to enable quicker application of pre-stress.
A larger elastic modulus is needed to reduce the shortening of the member.
A mix that reduces creep of the concrete to minimize losses of pre-stress.
Defects in concrete:
a. Shrinkage: Associated with the loss of moisture from gel particles of the paste.
b. Creep: Time dependent increase in deformation due to sustained loading can occur in
all types of loading-compression, tension and torsion. The earlier the age at which
loading is applied larger the creep. Creep is higher in wet conditions than in dry
conditions.
The steel used for pre-stressing has a normal yield strength of between 1550 to 1800 N/mm2. The
different forms the steel may take are:
Pre-tensioning:
This is the most common form for precast sections. In stage 1, the wires or strands are stressed;
in stage 2, the concrete is cast around the stressed wires/ strands; and in stage 3, the pre-stress is
transferred from the external anchorages to the concrete once it has sufficient strength. This
method produces a good bond between the tendon and concrete, which both protects the tendon
from corrosion and allows for direct transfer of tension.
The reinforcing steel in the bottom part of the beam, which will be subjected to tensile forces
when in service, is placed in tension prior to the concrete being poured around it. Once the
concrete has hardened, the tension on the reinforcing steel is released, placing a built in
compressive force on the concrete.
Post-tensioning:
In this method, the concrete has already set but has ducts cast into it. The strands/ tendons are fed
through the ducts (stage 1), then tensioned (stage 2) and then anchored to the concrete (stage 3).
i. Axially loaded member: Axial force vis-à-vis axial pre-stress forces illustrated in
post–tensioned (bearing plate) and in pre-tensioning (bond). The pre-stressing force is
applied at the centroid axis of the member.
P
σ = Stress = (N/mm2), Ac = Cros-section area of concrete = bh (mm2)
Ac
ii. The duct not coincident with the centroid axis by eccentricity ‘e’.
P P . e Ms
f= ± ±
Ac Z Z
A simply supported beam with section shown below spans 15 m and carries uniform distributed
loading (including self weight) of 50 kN/m. If the beam is pre-stressed with a force of 2000 kN
acting at an eccentricity of 400 mm below the centroid, determine the stress distribution at
midspan and at the supports. Assume Zb = Zt = 70.73x106 mm3 and Ac = 2.9x105 mm2.
Solution:
P P . e Ms
Stress at mid span is given by, f= ± ±
Ac Z Z
; ;
Consider the beam above sectioned at a third point from the left end support. The free body of
the concrete is as shown below:
In the case of a continuously curved tendon, there must be a distributed force applied to the
concrete to maintain the tendon in position.
Neglecting friction between the tendon and concrete, the force in tendon at either end of
the element Δs is T.
Example:
A simply supported beam of length l has a parabolic tendon profile with maximum eccentricity e
as shown below. Determine the upwards force on the beam exerted by the tendon and draw the
shear force and bending moment diagrams due to the prestess force, P. The equation of parabolic
tendon profile is y = 4ex(l – x)/l2.
For a reasonably flat curve 1/rps ~ d2y/dx2, viz. a parabolic curve is approximately the same as a
circular curve.
, the curvature
Thus, ω being the upward force on the concrete. Assuming ω to act vertically
Mmax = - P.e
Below are the prestress bending moment and shear force diagrams
Effect of friction on behavior of the prestress member is illustrated in the diagram below.
Initial elastic shortening of concrete which results in shortening of the steel tendon
Long – term changes in length due to creep and shrinkage.
i. Class 1 members are those in which the minimum stress under service load is zero, viz.
full prestressing.
η = Mo/Ms
Where: Mo is the bending moment at a section required to cause zero stress in concrete, and Ms is
the maximum bending moment due to service load.
i. Water/Cement ratio
ii. Compaction to minimize air and compressibility, and enhance bond between concrete
and pre-tensioned steel
iii. Curing to allow for as much hydration of cement as possible.
ftu = 0.59fcu1/2
The strength of OPC concrete varies with water-cement ratio as indicated in the graph below.
Creep is defined as time dependent deformation under constant load. Creep affects the longterm
deflections of prestressed concrete members and the loss of prestress force in prestresed concrete
members. The basic mechanism of creep is gradual loss of moistures causing contraction (in the
structure) of cement paste in the concrete.
The long-term (30-year) specific creep strain may be determined from the following relationship
where Φ is a creep coefficient obtainable from the figure below, and E ct is the modulus of
elasticity of concrete in the long-term.
Shrinkage is caused by evaporation of surplus water which has not been used to hydrate cement.
Shrinkage, thus, depends on environmental conditions. By the end of one year, 80% of long-
term shrinkage has taken place. The figures below illustrate various aspects of shrinkage.
Average shrinkage of concretes stored at 50-70% RH (Neville, 1977).
There are several different types of steel used for prestressing and stipulated in various British
Standards, as indicated below:
Wires vary in diameter from 3 to 7 mm with carbon content of 0.70 – 0.85%. The wires are
drawn from hot-rolled rods, which have been subsequently heated to 1000ºC and cooled to make
them suitable for drawing. Several drawing operations that are subsequently carried out to reduce
the diameter and increase the strength of the wire.
Wires for pretensioned concrete members sometimes have indentations or crimps to enhance
bond between concrete and steel.
The high strength is derived from a cold working process. Thus during storage and construction
the wires should not be exposed to heat arising from, say, welding. Prestressed concrete
members in buildings must be properly insulated from heat (fire).
Properities of prestressing strand and bar are shown in the table below:
Relaxation of steel stress is similar to creep in concrete in that it is a time dependent deformation
under constant load. The amount of relaxation depends on time, temperature and the level of
stress. The standard measure of relaxation is its value after 1000 hrs at 20ºC. Two classes of
relaxation are stipulated in BS 5896, thus:
Relaxation of steel at 20ºC with initial stress 0.7fpu is indicated in the figure below.
When maintained at a constant strain, prestressing strand gradually loses its stress with time (like
guitar going out of tune). It is due to a realignment of the steel fibres and is the same
phenomenon as creep. Depending on the quality of the steel, relaxation loses can vary in the
range of 3% to 8%.
Typical stress-strain curves for prestressing steel are shown in the figure below.
2.8 Corrosion
As with steel reinforcing bars, prestressing steel must be protected from attack by moisture
permeating the surrounding concrete.
Limit state design entails identification of various factors that affect the suitability of a
structure to fulfill the purpose for which it is being designed and choosing the most critical
conditions as the basis of the design, while checking the others afterwards.
a. Characteristic load
wk = wm + 1.64σ ⇒ 1:20 (5%) chance of (any test result) being exceeded. The load distributions
is shown in the figure below.
b. Characteristic strength
Design load = wk .γf ; where γf – partial factor of safety for load. Partial factors of safety
for loads are shown in the first table below.
Design strength = fk/γm; where γm – partial factor of safety for strength. Partial factors of
safety for strength are shown in the second table below.
iii. Minimum load condition in case of composite comprising precast beam acting together
with an in-situ slab, bending moment Md (due to dead weight of beam and slab).
Most losses of prestress will have occurred and the prestress force has attained its minimum.
iv. Maximum bending moment, Ms, occur at service load and with minimum prestress force
Class 3: flexural tensile stresses, but surface crack widths not exceeding a maximum
value of (0.1 mm for members in aggressive environment and 0.2 mm for all other members).
The allowable Stresses for Class 1 and Class 2 Members are shown in the table below.
fci and fcu are characteristic strength of concrete at transfer and service load respectively.
The fire resistance of a structure or a portion of a structure is defined as that period for
which the structure must remain intact during a fire in order for occupants to escape, before
the structure collapses. For good fire resistance of all concrete members, attention must be
paid to detailing - reinforcement is required near member faces to prevent spalling.
Class 3 members can withstand very high temperatures better than Classes 1 and 2 members,
because their greater proportion of lower-strength normal reinforcing steel is less affected by
high temperatures. Concrete cover for fire resistance is indicated in the table below.
3.8 Fatigue
This should be considered for prestressed members subject to repeated loading, in the
following cases:
3.10 Vibrations
The loss of prestress occurs by short term or long term, refer to the table below:
QUESTION 01:
A pre-tensioned concrete beam, 100mm wide and 300mm deep is presstressed by wires carring
an initial force of 150 KN at an eccentricity of 50mm. The modulus of elasticity of steel and
concrete are 210 and 35 KN/mm2 respectively. Estimate the percentage loss of stress in steel due
to elastic deformation of concrete if the area of steel wires is 188mm2.
Solution:
SHRINKAGE
A concrete beam is pre- stressed by a cable carrying an initial pre stressing force of 300 KN. The
cross sectional area of the wires in the cable is 300mm2. Calculate the percentage loss of stress in
the cable only due to shrinkage of concrete using IS:1343 recommendations assuming the beam
to be (a) pre- tensioned and (b) post- tensioned. Assume Es = 210 KN/mm2 and age of concrete at
transfer = 8 days.
Solution:
EXAMPLE 3:
A concrete beam of rectangular section, 100mm wide and 300mm deep is prestressed by five
wires 7mm diameter located at an eccentricity of 50mm. the initial stress in the wires being
1200N/mm2. Estimate the loss of stress in steel due to creep of concrete using the ultimate creep
strain method and the creep coefficient method (IS:1343). Use the following data.
Es = 210KN/mm2, Ec = 35KN/mm2,
Solution: