Audit Report Inditrade
Audit Report Inditrade
Name of Auditor :
Audit start Date :
Audit End Date :
Audit Period :
Branch start Date :
Age of the branch on Audit Date :
3
4
5
7
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
Major Observations Summary
Name of Audited Branch :
Name of the BM :
Name of RM :
Name of SH/ZM/DM :
State/Region Name :
No of staff :
Newly DB customer
Center visit Customer visit in the field
visit-01
Newly DB customer
Center visit Customer visit in the field
visit-01
Newly DB customer
Center visit Customer visit in the field
visit-01
Newly DB customer
Center visit Customer visit in the field
visit-01
Newly DB customer
Center visit Customer visit in the field
visit-01
Newly DB customer
Center visit Customer visit in the field
visit-01
Newly DB customer
Center visit Customer visit in the field
visit-01
Live Collection
Collections Live Collection Visit
Analysis_04
Live Collection
Collections Live Collection Visit
Analysis_04
Live Collection
Collections Live Collection Visit
Analysis_04
Live Collection
Collections Live Collection Visit
Analysis_04
Live Collection
Collections Live Collection Visit
Analysis_04
Live Collection
Collections Live Collection Visit
Analysis_04
Physical Cash
Cash Management Physical Cash Management at Branch
Verification_10
House-keeping_12 Admin & Others Housekeeping and fire safety norms at branches
Branch Score
Process Controls
a. Whether laid down CGT/GRT process been followed by the branch from sourcing to
disbursement of loan
whether customers and field executives follow collection discipline during center
meetings
f. Whether customer loan pass card and sanction letter has been issued to the customer
or not
f. Whether field executive sign the loan pass card and center register
a. Customer KYC details captured correctly,
b. Correct contact number captured ,
c. All necessary documents related to member insurance and her nominee shall be filled
in properly
Whether customer's correct mobile number updated into the system(can check during
customer visit)
a. Whether Customer lives in own house or rental (as per policy 60% should have own
house and only 40% rental)
b. Whether customer house distance from Center is within 500 meters
a)Confirmation meetings shall be conducted prior to the disbursements by BM/FE.
BM/BOE should ensure verifying the mobile numbers of customers during the
confirmatory meeting. And also customers LD should be dropped, in case the provided
mobile number does not belong either to the customer or to her family members. And
ack.is obtained from continuing members.
Branch Manager should verify the original KYC documents of applicants prior to
disbursements.
a. Time discipline of FE & Members; whether all members present; seating pattern;
center handling skills of the FE; FE discipline-(wearing ID card, carrying DL, phone fully
charged etc.).
b. Loan Pass card entry-whether the same is regular; responding to customers' queries by
FE;
a. Report under this point if collections meeting attendance falls below 75%.
B. Two collection meeting with less than 50% customer attendance in the meeting -
BM/RM should visit that center on priority.
Whether Disbursement happened within prescribed timeline of 15 days from the day of
CB Check
Check the Availability of customer correct income and expense calculation details in
software
Check whether FOIR has not exceeded 50% of the household income (Current EMIs from
all loans + proposed EMI)
member should have loan from maximum five regulated entities (including proposed
loan from Indi trade)
The indebtedness or total loan outstanding should not exceed INR175000 including
proposed Indi trade Loan (this includes all loans from Indi trade).
The delinquency on all existing loans should be <90 DPD during last two years and loan
overdue amount should not be more than INR5000 with other MFI/NBFC or any other
regulated entity
OD/PAR/small balances review shall be done on a daily basis at the Branch.
- PAR % shall not be more than the specified limit, i.e., 0.25%
- Report under this point if overdue is >0.25% <= 0.35%
- Report under this point if overdue is >0.35%
First emi OD account and relevant follow-up.
Following things to be checked: Time discipline of FE & Members; whether all members
present; seating pattern; House Verification; inter-action with customers by BM;
customer handling skills, Verification skills; Whether GRT was effective and serves the
purpose of customer selection; customer homogeneity; any gaps / adverse/negative/
observations etc.
a. Total Collections shall match with the cash deposit made in the branch.
In case of variance b/w actual cash submitted and total collected, cash should not be
accepted from FE. Same to be obtained once the FE provides approval from BM.
Whether, the cash is deposited with bank branches by FE, ensure to obtain
acknowledgement issued by said branch. The same should be scan and share with HO
F&A team on the same day.
Cash balance shall not exceed the insurance limit in any case.
Checklist & Claim forms should be complete w.r.t all the fields provided, including
necessary signatures.
Each line manager must completes his/her field verification process as laid down in the
process.
Pre-closure or any fore closure of loan should happen in the branch as detailed in the
process and policy
Daily physical verification of cash is done by the branch operation executive and any
excess/ shortage of cash shall be reported to the Branch Head and RM on daily basis.
BM should submit half yearly confirmation on status of IT and other asset issued to
branch to HO Admin.
Asset records with correctly tagged details, movement of excess/ shortage of assets is
being maintained
Same should be taken each employee issued IT asset.
All the listed concern areas are properly attended and taken care
Check whether closing stock of third party products is matched with the register and
product are stored in a diligent manner and condition
Check whether all sales of the audit period matching with the loan disbursement report
Check whether branch not having any products more then 3 month old
100%
sanction loans to customer who has done defaults in b. Reputation of the company might got affected
past may hamper portfolio quality
c. Sourcing in areas with higher incidences of customer Impact on loan portfolio quality with new loans disbursed without
defaults or affected by the ring leader or commission following-up of JLG norms of group formation resulted in to defaults.
agents.
In the absence of adequate training to customers there Impact on loan portfolio quality with new loans disbursed without
are risk of mis-selling of loan products to the customers. following-up of JLG norms of group formation resulted in to defaults.
Disbursement rejection due to in-correct bank details. Delayed disbursement of loan to customers.
In case %age rental customers more than own house Customer not attending regular meetings. Loan loss due to customer
customers, there shall be risk of migration of customers. migration.
Process non compliance w.r.t customer education and customer
Disbursements made without confirmation meetings
acceptance of rules of behavior on meetings/collection meeting
being conducted
attendance, repayment discipline, etc.
Non verification of original KYCs during the LD process
LD to wrong customer or ineiligible customers.
a. Collection procedures not followed as per the a. Excess amount remitted by the customer towards repayment not
guidelines recorded
GRT not done as per guidelines resulting in wrong loan a. Results in wrong loan recommendation * KYC non compliant of the
recommendation customer not completed during GRT process
Holding of cash beyond the Insurance Limit at the Chances of mis-use /loss of cash
branch.
Tracker for Insurance claims are not maintained at the Customer dissatisfaction, reputation loss due to delay in claim processing
Branch.
Pre/fore closure of loans been done in the field Missing of field controls by line managers
Pre/fore closure of loans in the field could lead to in- Customer loan closure of loan with in the field either excess or short
correct clousres of loans. amount.
Giving products without disbursing the loans Financial loss to the company
Warranty may be over and product may be absolute Financial loss to the company
Risk Classification Risk Type
Medium
High
High
High Operational Risk - Disbursement
Test Based 0 3
Test Based 0 3
Test Based 0 3
Test Based 0 3
Test Based 0 3
Test Based 0 4
Test Based 0 4
Test Based 0 3
Test Based 0 4
Test Based 0 3
Test Based 0 4
Test Based 0 3
Test Based 0 4
Test Based 0 4
Test Based 0 4
Test Based 0 4
Test Based 0 3
Test Based 0 3
Test Based 0 3
Test Based 0 3
Test Based 0 3
Test Based 0 4
Test Based 0 4
Test Based 0 4
Test Based 0 4
Test Based 0 4
Test Based 0 4
Test Based 0 4
Test Based 0 4
Test Based 0 4
Test Based 0 4
Test Based 0 4
Test Based 0 3
Analytical 0 4
Analytical 0 3
Analytical 0 4
Analytical 0 4
Analytical 0 4
Analytical 0 4
Analytical 0 3
Analytical 0 2
Analytical 0 2
Analytical 0 3
Analytical 0 3
Analytical 0 3
Analytical 0 3
Observation severity
For sample tests,
final Score
P=Pass No observation, H:- High Severity, M=
Medium Severity, L= Low severity observation
P 3
P 3
P 3
P 3
P 3
P 4
P 4
P 3
P 4
P 3
P 4
P 3
P 4
P 4
P 4
P 4
P 3
P 3
P 3
P 3
P 3
P 4
P 4
P 4
P 4
P 4
P 4
P 4
P 4
P 4
P 4
P 4
P 3
P 4
P 3
P 4
P 4
P 4
P 4
P 3
P 2
P 2
P 3
P 3
P 3
P 3
Audit Observations Root Cause
Evidences
Evidence required Details of
Auditee accpeted and Evidences
to close the action/closure(to be
Recommendation Accpetance & endorse by the accpeted by Audit
observations(to be given by the audittee)
Response line/reporting HO
given by auditor) with proofs
manager
Final Comments
of Head of Audit
H
M
L
P
Branch Staff Details - As on 07 Mar
Customer
Check
understanding on Who came to check
Customer whether FE Whether FE met Whether customer
insurance and verify/pass the Whether BM came to
understandin reaches on the customer's and her residence
coverage and center.(there should check customer house
g on Interest time for husband during photo taken by the
premium paid, be two visit one by FE and pass the group
rate sourcing field visit or not. FE and BM
whether husband and another by BM)
meeting
covered or not.
Loan Disbursement Related Field Collection Related
Who came
to collect
the
Loan amount If amount credited Does FE in form
Amount credited into instalment Whether executive
credited in own into husband's the customers in
other members Fornightly/monthly (Check comes on time (first
account /husband account, check for case he/she
account, if yes with Installement paid whether ask for the collection
account/others undertaking from getting late for
whose approval customer date/time)
(specify) customer the meeting.
knows the
name of the
FE)
Whether customer
whether FE wears the loan pass card and
company I Card while sanction letter has
comes for the collection been isuued to the
customer or not
C. Audit Observations/File & Loan Document Verification
Sample passed
N.A
Sample failed
TOTAL
ERROR %
Details of Customer Personal Details/KYC Verification and Bank Account Details
Deviation
Customer name Customer's
approval taken for Address on KYC
matches with Whether customer CB residence -
change in name of matches with
name updated in check done or not (Owned/Rented
customer (Y/N), if that with system
System and KYC )
any
Whether customer
Whether co- Customer bank
Customer DOB photograph (live)
applicant details account details
matches with and KYC details are Date of CB
captured matches matches with
that with DOB in captured are from Check
with that of KYC details on bank
KYC document original and not from
details passbook.
photocopy.
#DIV/0!
C. Loan Document s
Date of
Names of the
Branch Name Center meeting No. disbursemen
Customers
t
Collection Date and Whether Insurance
Insurance Premium Customer
time are correctly premium detail for life
correctly mentioned signautre taken
mentioned on loan insurance and HOSPI
on sanction loan onthe sanction
pass card and cash mentioned in the
card (Y/N) letter
sanction letter sanction letter
Sample passed
N.A
Sample failed
TOTAL
ERROR % 0.00% 18.18% 0.00%
Whether Third Party
DPN & (Light Loan) loan Availability of
Availability of Availability of
Agreement application letter/DPN BM/FE
Customer BM/FE Signature
properly signed and sanction letter duly Signature on
signature on on Loan
and taken from signed by the customer Loan
Documents Document
the customer and branch executive Document
found in the documents.
S.No. Branch Name Center Name Customer Name Loan A/c No OD/PAR Bucket
whether
repayment whether repayment
Total OD Customer available for Last repayment schedule/loan schedule/loan card filled
Amount feedback during visit date/month card issued to regularly by the FE post
the customer collection of EMI
Visit of Line
Whether FE regular for manager Reason of OD - as told by Audit Observations
collection meeting (BM/RM/DM)since the customer
OD
Live CGT/GRT Visit
Centre Date of
FE Name BM Name Area/Village Name
Name/No. CGT/GRT
Demand for the given day Total Collection for the day
Amount
S.No. Branch Name Collection Date Amount
As per
Accounts Amount Accounts As per Alchemy-
Microsure -
Amt
Amt
r System
Demand/Colelction Analysis of Day Book & System Collection
Total Collection for the day
Diff Difference
Difference in Diffenrence in Cash updted in
Microsure- Reson For differences Day book-System
Accounts Amounts Day Book
Alchemy Cash
y Book & System Collection Analysis of Denomination & Day Book Register Total Cash in Hand
Opening Balance
Cash updated in Difference
Reason of Differences Reason of Differences (Closing cash of
Denomination Register Denomination-Day Book
previous day)
Cash Balance Kept
Total Cash in Hand Details of Cash Deposit at Bank
by the Branch
Fore-closure/Pre-closure of Accounts - Verify 20 % of total preclosed accounts for audit period or 5 which ever is high
Date of pre- Whether pre-closure happened in Pre-closure amount as per
Pre-closure amount
closure branch day book
2000 0 0 0
500 0 0 0
200 0 0 0
100 0 0 0
50 0 0 0
20 0 0 0
10 0 0 0
Coins 0 0 0
0 0 0
Petty Cash
2000 0 0 0
500 0 0 0
200 0 0 0
100 0 0 0
50 0 0 0
20 0 0 0
10 0 0 0
Coins 0 0 0
0 0 0
Audit
Difference
Observation
0
0
0
0
NA
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
No cash in
0
branch
0
0
0
0
Observations on Systems/equipments and System Use certificate
Physical
Sl. No. Particulars of Asset Make Book Quantity
Quantity
If Asset not
Present condition of the
Difference working, any
Difference equipments/systems
Noted steps taken
(working or not working)
by the branch
Audit observation
Housekeeping & Firesafety
Sl. No. Concern areas
Display of "No-smoking" in Notice Board
and other prominent places inside the
1
branch
12 NBFC-MFI Registration.
Notices required to be displayed as per
MFIN directives
a. Copy of certificate of Incorporation
under Company’s Act
13
b. Contact details of Regional offices
of RBI
c. List of fees charged for our
services.
Y
N
Total
Error %age
Audit Observation
Y
Opening Balance of Product received by
Product received Product Transfer to another
Audit Month Product Name/Code TPP at the beginning the branch from
from another branch Branch
of the month vendor/Boon Box
Balance Product
Product received Product returned
Product Transfer to No.of Product sold by available with
Closing from customer with back to vendor for
Boon Box the branch branch on th day
service issue servicing
of checking
Audit Obseervations