Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

Module – 3

Introduction To Intellectual Property: Role of IP in the Economic and Cultural

Development of the Society, IP Governance, IP as a Global Indicator of Innovation, Origin of
IP History of IP in India. Major Amendments in IP Laws and Acts in India.

Patents: Conditions for Obtaining a Patent Protection, To Patent or Not to Patent an

Invention. Rights Associated with Patents. Enforcement of Patent Rights. Inventions Eligible
for Patenting. Non-Patentable Matters. Patent Infringements. Avoid Public Disclosure of an
Invention before Patenting.

Process of Patenting. Prior Art Search. Choice of Application to be Filed. Patent Application
Forms. Jurisdiction of Filing Patent Application. Publication. Pre-grant Opposition.
Examination. Grant of a Patent. Validity of Patent Protection. Post-grant Opposition.
Commercialization of a Patent. Need for a Patent Attorney/Agent. Can a Worldwide Patent
be Obtained. Do I Need First to File a Patent in India. Patent Related Forms. Fee Structure.
Types of Patent Applications. Commonly Used Terms in Patenting. National Bodies Dealing
with Patent Affairs. Utility Models.

Introduction
 Intellectual Property (IP) refers to creations of the mind, such as inventions,
literary and artistic works, designs, symbols, names, and images used in commerce.
 Intellectual Property is protected by law through patents, copyrights, trademarks,
and trade secrets, which enable individuals and organizations to earn recognition
or financial benefit from their inventions or creations.
 The main purpose of intellectual property laws is to encourage the creation of a
wide variety of intellectual goods while providing creators with the right to control
and benefit from their creations.
Primary categories of Intellectual Property:
1. Patents: Patents protect inventions or discoveries, granting the inventor exclusive
rights to use, make, sell, and import the patented invention for a limited period,
usually 20 years.
2. Copyright: Copyright protects original works of authorship, such as literary,
artistic, and musical works. This includes books, paintings, music, films, and
software. The creator of the work has exclusive rights to reproduce, distribute,
perform, and display the work. Copyright protection is generally granted for the
creator's lifetime plus a certain number of years.
3. Trademarks: Trademarks protect symbols, names, and slogans used to identify
and distinguish goods and services in the marketplace. The purpose is to prevent
consumer confusion and to ensure that consumers can rely on the quality and
source of products or services associated with a particular mark.
4. Trade Secrets: Trade secrets protect confidential business information, such as
manufacturing processes, formulas, and business strategies. Unlike patents,

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 1

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

trademarks, or copyrights, trade secrets are not publicly disclosed, and protection
lasts as long as the information remains secret.
5. Industrial Design Rights: Industrial design rights protect the visual design of
objects, such as the shape, surface, or ornamentation of a product. This is
particularly relevant in fields like product design and manufacturing.
6. Geographical Indications: Geographical indications protect the names of
products associated with a particular place and have characteristics or qualities
attributable to that place. This includes products like Champagne, Parmesan
cheese, and Darjeeling tea.

Role of IP in the Economic and Cultural

Intellectual Property (IP) plays a crucial role in both the economic and cultural aspects of
societies.
Economic Role of IP:
1. Encouraging Innovation and Creativity: IP rights, such as patents and copyrights,
provide creators and inventors with the incentive to invest time, effort, and
resources into developing new ideas, products, and artistic works. Knowing they
can protect and profit from their creations encourages ongoing innovation and
creativity.
2. Fostering Economic Growth: A strong IP system stimulates economic growth by
fostering innovation. New technologies, inventions, and creative works contribute
to the growth of industries, create job opportunities, and enhance overall
productivity.
3. Attracting Investment and Entrepreneurship: Investors are more likely to
support projects and businesses that are protected by IP rights. Knowing that their
investments are safeguarded by patents or other IP protections, entrepreneurs are
encouraged to bring new products and services to the market.
4. Facilitating Technology Transfer: IP rights enable the licensing and transfer of
technologies, allowing companies to share innovations and expertise. This helps in
the dissemination of knowledge and promotes collaboration between entities, both
nationally and internationally.
5. Promoting Fair Competition: Trademarks and patents ensure fair competition by
preventing unauthorized use of established brands and inventions. This protection
encourages companies to invest in building brand value and developing new
technologies, confident that their efforts will not be easily exploited by competitors.

Cultural Role of IP:

1. Preserving Cultural Heritage: IP protections, such as geographical indications,
contribute to preserving and promoting cultural heritage. Certain products are
associated with specific regions, and IP laws help maintain the authenticity and
unique qualities of these products.
2. Supporting Artists and Creators: Copyright protection ensures that artists and

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 2

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

creators are rewarded for their work, encouraging the production of diverse and
meaningful cultural expressions. This, in turn, contributes to the richness and
diversity of a society's cultural landscape.
3. Cultural Exchange and Diversity: IP laws facilitate the exchange of cultural
products and ideas by providing a framework for the fair use of copyrighted works
and the licensing of creative content. This allows for the global dissemination of
cultural expressions while respecting the rights of creators.
4. Encouraging Traditional Knowledge Protection: IP laws, including unique
systems, can be used to protect traditional knowledge and expressions of
indigenous communities. This recognition helps preserve and respect the cultural
heritage of these communities.
5. Promoting Media and Entertainment: Copyright protection is especially relevant
in the media and entertainment industries. It ensures that creators, including
writers, filmmakers, and musicians, can benefit financially from their works,
leading to the continued production of cultural content.

IP Governance:
Intellectual Property (IP) governance in India involves the management, protection, and
enforcement of intellectual property rights within the legal and regulatory framework
established by the Indian government. Key aspects of IP governance in India:
1. Legal Framework:
 Patents: The Patents Act, 1970, governs the grant and enforcement of patents
in India. India also allows for the filing of international patent applications
under the Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT).
 Copyrights: The Copyright Act, 1957, protects literary, artistic, and musical
works. The law has been amended over the years to adapt to technological
changes, including digital advancements.
 Trademarks: The Trade Marks Act, 1999, governs the registration and
protection of trademarks in India. The country has also adopted the Nice
Classification for goods and services.
 Designs: The Designs Act, 2000, deals with the registration and protection of
industrial designs.
 Geographical Indications: The Geographical Indications of Goods
(Registration and Protection) Act, 1999, provides for the registration and
protection of geographical indications.
2. Regulatory Bodies:
 Controller General of Patents, Designs & Trade Marks (CGPDTM): This
office, under the Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade
(DPIIT), is responsible for granting and administering patents and trademarks.
 Copyright Office: The Copyright Office, under the Ministry of Education,
administers copyright registrations and related matters.
3. International Treaties and Agreements: India is a member of various
international treaties and agreements related to IP, including the Agreement on

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 3

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS), the Patent

Cooperation Treaty (PCT), and the Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary
and Artistic Works.
4. Enforcement and Legal Remedies: IP rights are enforceable through legal
actions, including civil and criminal proceedings. The Intellectual Property
Appellate Board (IPAB) hears appeals against decisions of the CGPDTM.
5. IP Awareness and Education: Efforts are made to raise awareness about the
importance of intellectual property rights through education and outreach
programs. Training sessions, seminars, and workshops are conducted for
stakeholders.
6. Technology Transfer and Innovation: The government encourages technology
transfer and innovation through various schemes and initiatives. This includes
promoting research and development activities and supporting startups and
inventors.
7. Compulsory Licensing and Public Health: India has provisions for compulsory
licensing, allowing the government to grant licenses for the production of patented
products in certain situations, particularly for public health reasons.
8. Online IP Protection: Given the rise of online infringement, there are provisions
for the protection of intellectual property rights in the digital environment.
Measures are taken to address issues such as online piracy and counterfeiting.
9. Policy Reforms: India periodically reviews and updates its IP laws to align them
with global standards and address emerging challenges. The government engages
in consultations and discussions with stakeholders to ensure a balanced and
effective IP regime.

IP as a Global Indicator of Innovation

Intellectual Property (IP) is widely recognized as a global indicator of innovation, reflecting
the creativity, research, and development efforts across countries and industries. Various
forms of IP, such as patents, trademarks, copyrights, and trade secrets, serve as markers for
innovative activities. Following are how IP functions as a global indicator of innovation
1. Patents as Indicators:
 Quantity and Quality: The number of patent filings and the quality of patents
granted are often used to measure innovation. A high volume of patent
applications may suggest a strong emphasis on research and development
within a country or industry.
 Technological Advancement: Analysis of patent portfolios provides insights
into the technological trends and areas of specialization. Patents reveal the
novel solutions, inventions, and technologies that contribute to global
innovation.
2. Trademarks and Brands:
 Market Presence: Trademarks and brands indicate market presence and
consumer recognition. The registration and protection of trademarks are
indicative of investments in brand development, marketing, and product

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 4

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

differentiation.
 Innovation in Marketing: Innovative marketing strategies, packaging, and
branding contribute to a strong trademark portfolio, reflecting a company's
ability to stand out in the market.
3. Copyrights:
 Creative Industries: Copyrights protect literary, artistic, and musical works.
The presence of a robust copyright system indicates a thriving creative
industry, encompassing literature, music, film, software, and other artistic
expressions.
 Cultural and Creative Contributions: Countries with a strong copyright
framework often contribute significantly to global cultural and creative content.
4. Trade Secrets:
 Competitive Advantage: Companies invest in protecting trade secrets, such as
proprietary formulas or manufacturing processes. The presence of a trade
secret regime indicates an emphasis on maintaining a competitive edge through
undisclosed innovations.
5. Geographical Indications:
 Quality and Origin: The registration of geographical indications indicates a
focus on preserving and promoting unique products associated with specific
regions. This reflects both innovation in production processes and the
importance placed on preserving traditional knowledge.
6. Global IP Filings:
 International Collaboration: The filing of IP applications under international
treaties and agreements, such as the Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT) or the
Madrid System for trademarks, demonstrates a country's engagement in global
innovation and collaboration.
7. IP Intensity in Industries:
 Sectoral Analysis: IP data can be analyzed across industries to identify sectors
with high innovation intensity. For example, technology and pharmaceutical
sectors often have a significant concentration of patents.
8. IP Enforcement and Litigation:
 Protection of Rights: The level of IP enforcement and litigation can indicate
the importance placed on protecting intellectual property rights. A robust legal
framework for IP protection encourages innovation by providing creators with
the confidence that their rights will be upheld.
9. Startups and Innovation Ecosystem:
 Startup Activity: The growth of startups and innovation ecosystems within a
country is often reflected in the number of new patents, trademarks, and
copyrights filed by emerging companies.
10. Global Rankings:
 Innovation Indices: Global innovation indices often incorporate IP-related
metrics to assess a country's innovation performance. Organizations like the
World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) and the Global Innovation

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 5

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

Index (GII) consider IP indicators in their rankings.

Origin of IP History of IP in India

The history of Intellectual Property (IP) in India is marked by the evolution of legal
frameworks and policies to protect various forms of intellectual creations. Here is an
overview of the history of IP in India:
1. Pre-Independence Era: India did not have a comprehensive IP legal framework
during the colonial period. British rule did introduce some IP-related legislation,
such as the Patents and Designs Act of 1911 and the Trade Marks Act of 1940.
2. Post-Independence Period (1947 onwards): After gaining independence in
1947, India began to develop its own legal framework for IP protection.
3. 1950s and 1960s:
 The Patents Act of 1970, which replaced the Patents and Designs Act of 1911,
was a significant development. The new law aimed to promote a balance
between the interests of inventors and the public. It included provisions for
compulsory licensing to ensure that patented inventions were accessible and
affordable.
 The Trade and Merchandise Marks Act of 1958 governed trademarks, providing
protection for distinctive marks used in connection with goods.
 The Copyright Act of 1957 was enacted to protect literary, artistic, and musical
works. Over the years, amendments were made to adapt to changing
technological landscapes.
4. 1970s: The Designs Act of 2000 replaced the Designs Act of 1911 and provided a
modern legal framework for the protection of industrial designs.
5. 1990s: India initiated economic liberalization policies in the early 1990s, leading
to increased global integration. This period saw an emphasis on strengthening IP
laws to align with international standards.
6. TRIPS Agreement (1995): India became a signatory to the Agreement on Trade-
Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) as part of its commitment
to the World Trade Organization (WTO). TRIPS set international standards for IP
protection.
7. 2000s:
 India implemented several amendments to its IP laws to comply with TRIPS
requirements. The Patents (Amendment) Act of 2005 allowed for the patenting
of pharmaceutical products and brought about changes to the definition of
inventions.
 The Trademarks Act of 1999 replaced the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act of
1958, aligning trademark laws with international standards.
 The Copyright (Amendment) Act of 2012 introduced significant changes,
including addressing digital rights, updating provisions for performers' rights,
and aligning copyright laws with international treaties.
8. Geographical Indications: The Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration
and Protection) Act was enacted in 1999 to protect the names of goods originating

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 6

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

from specific regions.

9. Recent Developments: India has continued to refine and update its IP laws to
address emerging challenges and align with global standards. The government has
focused on enhancing IP enforcement, promoting innovation, and addressing
issues related to public health.
10. National IPR Policy (2016): In 2016, India announced its National Intellectual
Property Rights (IPR) Policy, emphasizing the importance of fostering innovation
and creativity while ensuring that IP laws do not stifle access to knowledge and
resources.

Major Amendments in IP Laws and Acts in India.

India has undergone several amendments to its Intellectual Property (IP) laws and acts over
the years to align with international standards, address emerging challenges, and promote
innovation. Here are some major amendments to key IP laws in India:
1. Patents Act, 1970:
 Patents (Amendment) Act, 2005:
 Significant amendment to comply with TRIPS obligations.
 Introduced product patent protection for pharmaceuticals.
 Strengthened provisions for exclusive marketing rights.
 Patents (Amendment) Rules, 2016:
 Focused on streamlining patent filing procedures and reducing timelines.
 Introduced provisions for expedited examination of patent applications.
 Patents (Amendment) Rules, 2019:
 Aimed at promoting startups and simplifying procedures for women and
small entities.
 Introduced reduced fees for filing and prosecuting patent applications by
startups.
2. Trade Marks Act, 1999:
 Trade Marks (Amendment) Act, 2010:
 Introduced provisions to align with the Nice Classification system.
 Addressed issues related to the protection of well-known trademarks.
 Streamlined the registration process.
 Trade Marks (Amendment) Rules, 2017:
 Introduced provisions related to the use of sound marks and the protection
of domain names.
 Addressed issues related to the international classification of goods and
services.
3. Copyright Act, 1957:
 Copyright (Amendment) Act, 1994:
 Introduced protection for software and databases.
 Extended the term of copyright protection for photographs.
 Copyright (Amendment) Act, 2012:
 Brought about significant changes to address digital rights, protect
Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 7
 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

performers' rights, and update provisions related to statutory licenses.

 Included provisions for technological protection measures.
4. Designs Act, 2000:
 Designs (Amendment) Rules, 2008:
 Introduced provisions for expedited examination of design applications.
 Focused on improving procedural aspects of design registration.
 Designs (Amendment) Rules, 2014:
 Introduced provisions for online filing of design applications.
 Streamlined procedures for the examination and registration of designs.
5. Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act, 1999:
Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) (Amendment)
Rules, 2019:
 Introduced provisions for the expedited processing of applications.
 Addressed issues related to the renewal of registration.
6. National IPR Policy, 2016:
 The National Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) Policy, released in 2016,
outlined a comprehensive approach to IP in India. While not an amendment
to existing laws, it emphasized key principles, including awareness and
enforcement, and aimed to create a conducive environment for innovation.

Patents: Conditions for Obtaining a Patent Protection

Obtaining a patent protection involves meeting certain conditions and following a specific
process. Patents are legal rights granted to inventors, giving them exclusive rights to their
inventions for a limited period. The conditions for obtaining a patent protection generally
include:
 Novelty: The invention must be new and not disclosed to the public before the
filing date of the patent application. This means that the invention should not have
been previously patented, published, publicly used, or otherwise made available to
the public.
 Non-obviousness: The invention must involve an inventive step or non-obvious
advancement over existing technology. It should not be an obvious combination of
existing elements or methods.
 Usefulness: The invention must have a practical utility. It should be capable of
being used or applied in some industry.
 Subject Matter Eligibility: Not all types of inventions are eligible for patent
protection. In some jurisdictions, laws may exclude certain subject matters like
abstract ideas, laws of nature, or natural phenomena from patentability.
 Enablement and Sufficient Disclosure: The patent application must provide
enough information (enablement) to allow someone skilled in the field to make and
use the invention based on the description in the application.
 Patentable Subject Matter: The invention should fall within the categories of
patentable subject matter, which typically include processes, machines,
manufactures, compositions of matter, and certain types of improvements.

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 8

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

 Timely Filing: Patents are time-sensitive, and there are deadlines for filing
applications. In many jurisdictions, the first inventor to file a patent application is
granted the patent rights. Therefore, timely filing is crucial.
 Patent Search: It is advisable to conduct a thorough patent search to ensure that
the invention is novel and not already covered by existing patents.
 Proper Application: A complete and properly drafted patent application must be
filed with the relevant patent office. This includes detailed descriptions, claims
defining the scope of the invention, and any necessary drawings.
 Examination Process: The patent application undergoes an examination process
by the patent office, during which examiners review the application to ensure it
meets the patentability criteria.

To Patent or Not to Patent an Invention

Deciding whether to patent an invention involves careful consideration of various factors.
Here are some key points to help you decide whether patenting is the right choice for your
invention:
 Market Potential: Consider the market potential of your invention. If you believe
your invention has a significant market value and the potential for commercial
success, securing a patent can provide a competitive advantage by excluding others
from making, using, or selling the invention.
 Competitive Landscape: Assess the competitive landscape in your industry. If
your invention is unique and not easily replicable, a patent may be more valuable.
However, if the market is crowded with similar innovations, the exclusivity granted
by a patent may have a limited impact.
 Costs: Obtaining and maintaining a patent can be a costly process. Factor in the
costs of preparing and filing a patent application, as well as ongoing maintenance
fees. Evaluate whether the potential benefits of patent protection justify the
associated expenses.
 Duration of Protection: Patents provide limited-term protection, typically 20
years from the filing date. Consider whether the potential benefits during this
period outweigh the costs and whether the invention's value will persist over time.
 Enforcement Capability: Obtaining a patent doesn't automatically protect your
invention; you may need to enforce your rights through legal action. Consider
whether you have the resources and willingness to enforce the patent if
infringement occurs.
 Disclosure Concerns: Applying for a patent requires disclosing detailed
information about your invention in the patent application. If you're concerned
about revealing trade secrets or proprietary information, you may need to weigh
the benefits of patent protection against the risk of disclosure.
 Business Strategy: Your overall business strategy should guide your decision.
Some companies use patents as a defensive strategy to deter competitors, while
others leverage patents as part of a licensing or revenue-generating strategy.
 Industry Standards: In some industries, patents are considered essential for

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 9

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

competitiveness, while in others, they may be less crucial. Assess the norms and
expectations within your industry regarding patent protection.
 Alternative Forms of Protection: Explore alternative forms of protection, such
as trade secrets, trademarks, or a first-mover advantage. Depending on the nature
of your invention, these options may provide adequate protection without the costs
and disclosure associated with patents.
 Legal Advice: Seek advice from a patent attorney or intellectual property
professional. They can help you assess the patentability of your invention, navigate
the application process, and provide guidance based on your specific
circumstances.

Rights Associated with Patents

When an inventor or applicant successfully obtains a patent, they are granted certain
exclusive rights over the invention for a limited period. The rights associated with patents
generally include:
 Exclusive Use: The patent owner has the exclusive right to make, use, sell, and
import the patented invention. This means that others are prohibited from
manufacturing, using, selling, or importing the patented invention without the
patent owner's permission.
 Monopoly Rights: Patents provide a limited monopoly for a specific period,
typically 20 years from the filing date of the patent application. During this time,
the patent holder has the sole right to exploit the invention commercially.
 Legal Protection: Patents grant the inventor legal protection for their invention,
allowing them to take legal action against anyone who infringes on their exclusive
rights. This can include seeking damages or an injunction to prevent further
infringement.
 Licensing Opportunities: Patent owners have the option to license their patented
technology to others, granting permission for third parties to use the invention in
exchange for licensing fees or royalties. Licensing can be a way to generate revenue
from the patented invention.
 Strategic Advantage: Patents can provide a strategic advantage in the
marketplace by creating barriers to entry for competitors. The exclusivity granted
by a patent may deter others from entering the market with similar inventions.
 Portfolio Building: Companies often build a portfolio of patents to strengthen
their position in the industry. A robust patent portfolio can enhance a company's
competitiveness and be used as a bargaining tool in negotiations or cross-licensing
agreements.
 Innovation Recognition: A patent is a recognition of the inventor's contribution
to innovation. It can enhance the inventor's reputation and credibility in the
industry.
 National and International Protection: Patents are typically granted by national
or regional patent offices, providing protection within the designated geographic
area. International patents, such as those obtained through the Patent Cooperation

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 10

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

Treaty (PCT), offer a way to seek protection in multiple countries through a

streamlined process.

Enforcement of Patent Rights

Enforcing patent rights involves taking legal action to prevent others from using, making,
selling, or importing the patented invention without the patent owner's permission. The
process of enforcing patent rights are as follows:
 Monitoring and Detection:
 Regularly monitor the market for potential infringement of your patented
invention.
 Use online tools, industry publications, and market research to identify possible
infringing activities.
 Cease and Desist Letter:
 Before resorting to legal action, patent owners often send a cease-and-desist
letter to the alleged infringer.
 The letter typically outlines the patent owner's rights, provides evidence of
infringement, and requests the infringing party to stop the infringing activities.
 Negotiation and Licensing:
 In some cases, negotiation may lead to a licensing agreement. The alleged
infringer may agree to pay licensing fees or royalties in exchange for the right
to use the patented technology.
 Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR):
 Alternative dispute resolution methods, such as mediation or arbitration, may
be considered as a way to resolve patent disputes without going to court.
 Filing a Lawsuit:
 If informal methods fail, the patent owner can file a lawsuit in a court with
jurisdiction over the matter.
 The lawsuit typically includes a complaint detailing the alleged infringement,
evidence of the patent owner's rights, and a request for remedies such as
injunctions, damages, and legal costs.
 Injunctions:
 A successful patent infringement lawsuit may result in the court issuing an
injunction, ordering the infringing party to stop their activities.
 Injunctions can be preliminary (temporary) or permanent, depending on the
circumstances.
 Damages:
 If infringement is proven, the court may award damages to the patent owner.
Damages can include compensatory damages, which aim to compensate the
patent owner for losses suffered due to the infringement.
 Defenses and Counterclaims:
 The alleged infringer may raise defenses, such as challenging the validity of the
patent or claiming non-infringement.
 Counterclaims may also be filed, alleging that the patent owner has engaged in

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 11

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

anticompetitive behavior or asserting that the patent is unenforceable.

 Appeals:
 Either party may appeal a court decision to a higher court, seeking a review of
the judgment.
 International Enforcement:
 For patents with international coverage, enforcement may involve legal action
in multiple jurisdictions or coordination with relevant authorities.

Inventions Eligible for Patenting

To be eligible for patenting, an invention must meet certain criteria set by patent laws. The
criteria may vary slightly among different jurisdictions, but generally, inventions must
satisfy the following requirements:
 Patentable Subject Matter: The invention must fall within the categories of
patentable subject matter defined by patent laws. Common categories include
processes, machines, manufactures, compositions of matter, and certain types of
improvements.
 Novelty: The invention must be new and not publicly disclosed or available before
the filing date of the patent application. Novelty means that the invention has not
been previously patented, published, publicly used, or otherwise disclosed.
 Non-Obviousness (Inventive Step): The invention must involve an inventive step
or non-obvious advancement over existing technology. It should not be an obvious
combination of existing elements or methods to a person skilled in the relevant
field.
 Usefulness (Industrial Applicability): The invention must have practical utility
or industrial applicability. It should be capable of being used or applied in some
industry or have a specific purpose.
 Enablement and Sufficient Disclosure:
 The patent application must provide enough information (enablement) to allow
someone skilled in the field to make and use the invention based on the
description in the application.
 The disclosure should be clear, complete, and enable a person skilled in the art
to replicate the invention without undue experimentation.
 Statutory Requirements: The invention must meet the statutory requirements
outlined in the patent laws of the relevant jurisdiction. These requirements may
include specific criteria for patentability and the filing of a proper patent
application.
 Non-Patentable Subject Matter Exclusions: Certain subject matters may be
excluded from patentability, such as abstract ideas, laws of nature, natural
phenomena, and some types of inventions deemed unethical or contrary to public
order.

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 12

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

Non-Patentable Matters.
While patent laws vary across jurisdictions, there are certain categories of inventions and
subject matters that are typically considered non-patentable. These exclusions are meant
to ensure that patents are granted for inventions that meet certain criteria and contribute
to technological progress. Some common examples of non-patentable matters include:
 Natural Phenomena: Laws of nature, natural phenomena, and naturally occurring
substances are generally not eligible for patent protection. For example, isolated
naturally occurring minerals or elements may not be patentable.
 Abstract Ideas and Theories: Abstract ideas, mathematical formulas, and purely
theoretical concepts are typically excluded from patentability. Patent protection
requires a practical application of these ideas.
 Methods of Medical Treatment: In many jurisdictions, methods of medical
treatment performed on the human body are often excluded from patentability.
However, certain medical devices or pharmaceutical compositions may still be
patentable.
 Scientific Principles: Purely scientific principles and discoveries, without a
practical application, are generally not eligible for patent protection. The
application of scientific principles to create a useful and practical invention is a key
requirement for patentability.
 Computer Programs and Algorithms: The patentability of computer programs
and algorithms varies, but in some jurisdictions, they may be excluded if they are
considered abstract or lack a technical effect. However, specific implementations
or applications of software may still be patentable.
 Literary, Artistic, and Aesthetic Creations: Literary works, artistic creations,
and aesthetic designs are generally protected by copyright or other intellectual
property rights rather than patents. Patents are intended for technical and
functional innovations.
 Inventions Against Public Policy or Morality: Inventions that are contrary to
public policy, morality, or public order may be deemed non-patentable. This can
include inventions with unethical or harmful applications.
 Plant Varieties and Animal Species: In some jurisdictions, plant varieties and
animal species are excluded from patentability. Instead, they may be eligible for
protection through plant variety rights or other forms of intellectual property.
 Diagnostic Methods: Some jurisdictions exclude the patentability of diagnostic
methods performed on the human or animal body. However, specific applications
or devices used in diagnostics may still be patentable.

Patent Infringements
Patent infringement occurs when someone uses, makes, sells, or imports a patented
invention without the permission of the patent owner. To establish patent infringement,
certain elements must typically be demonstrated, and legal proceedings may follow. Here
are key aspects related to patent infringements:

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 13

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

 Elements of Patent Infringement:

 Valid Patent: The patent being asserted must be valid and enforceable.
 Patented Claims: The alleged infringing activity must fall within the scope of
the claims of the asserted patent.
 Unauthorized Use: The accused party must be using, making, selling, or
importing a product or process that falls within the scope of the patented claims
without the patent owner's permission.
 Direct and Indirect Infringement:
 Direct Infringement: This occurs when someone engages in the unauthorized
use, making, selling, or importing of a patented invention.
 Indirect Infringement: This may involve actions such as inducing or
contributing to another party's infringement.
 Literal Infringement and Doctrine of Equivalents:
 Literal Infringement: Occurs when the accused product or process falls
literally within the scope of the patented claims.
 Doctrine of Equivalents: Allows for infringement to be found even if the
accused product or process does not literally infringe but is equivalent to the
patented invention.
 Defenses Against Infringement Claims:
 Invalidity: The accused party may assert that the patent is invalid due to
reasons such as lack of novelty, non-obviousness, or insufficient disclosure.
 Non-Infringement: The accused party may argue that its product or process
does not fall within the scope of the patented claims.
 Enforcement Measures:
 Cease and Desist Letters: Before initiating legal action, patent owners often
send cease and desist letters to alleged infringers, notifying them of the
infringement and requesting them to stop.
 Litigation: If a resolution is not reached, the patent owner may file a lawsuit
in a court with jurisdiction over the matter.
 Remedies for Patent Infringement:
 Injunctions: Courts may issue injunctions to stop the accused party from
further infringing activities.
 Damages: Patent owners may be awarded damages to compensate for
financial losses resulting from the infringement.
 Accounting of Profits: Courts may order the infringer to account for and
disgorge any profits earned from the infringement.
 International Considerations:
 Patent infringement cases may involve international aspects, especially if the
accused activities occur across multiple jurisdictions.
 Patent owners may need to enforce their rights in different countries based on
the granted patents.
 Challenges and Appeals: Both parties may present evidence, and the court will
make a determination. Either party may appeal the decision to a higher court.
Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 14
 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

Avoid Public Disclosure of an Invention before Patenting

Avoiding public disclosure of an invention before filing a patent application is crucial to
securing patent protection. Once an invention is publicly disclosed, it may jeopardize the
novelty requirement for patentability. Here are some key strategies to prevent public
disclosure:
 File a Provisional Patent Application: Consider filing a provisional patent
application before any public disclosure. A provisional application provides a filing
date and establishes a priority date for your invention. It allows you to use the
phrase "patent pending" and gives you time (usually 12 months in the United
States) to file a non-provisional patent application.
 Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs): If you need to discuss your invention with
others, such as potential collaborators, investors, or manufacturers, consider
having them sign a non-disclosure agreement. An NDA legally binds them to keep
the information confidential.
 Confidentiality within the Team: If you're working in a team, ensure that all team
members are aware of the importance of confidentiality. Limit access to
information about the invention to those who need it for development and filing.
 Internal Documentation: Document your invention internally using lab
notebooks, project reports, or other record-keeping methods. These documents
can serve as evidence of your invention's conception and development timeline.
 Avoid Public Presentations: Refrain from making public presentations or
disclosures about your invention, especially in forums like conferences, seminars,
or trade shows, where the information could become publicly accessible.
 Limit Public Disclosures on social media: Be cautious about discussing your
invention on public forums, blogs, or social media platforms. Even casual
discussions or postings can be considered public disclosure.
 Confidential Patent Searches: If you need to conduct a patent search, consider
using confidential or non-disclosure patent search services to avoid inadvertently
disclosing your invention to the public.
 Commercialization Discussions: Be mindful during discussions with potential
business partners or investors. While you may need to share some information to
attract interest, carefully control the level of detail disclosed and consider using
NDAs.
 Educate Employees: Train employees and collaborators on the importance of
maintaining confidentiality. Implement policies to safeguard sensitive information
within your organization.
 Prioritize Patent Filing: Once your invention is sufficiently developed and you've
determined its commercial potential, prioritize the filing of a patent application.
Prompt filing is essential to securing the earliest possible priority date.

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 15

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

Process of Patenting
The process of patenting involves several steps, from the conception of an invention to the
granting of a patent. Following are the steps involved:
 Conception of the Invention: The process begins with the conception of a new
and non-obvious invention. This is the moment when the idea is first developed and
takes a concrete form.
 Prior Art Search: Conduct a thorough search to identify existing inventions or
prior art that may be similar to the proposed invention. This step helps determine
the novelty of the invention and assess its patentability.
 Record Keeping and Documentation: Maintain detailed records of the
invention's development, including lab notebooks, drawings, and any experimental
results. This documentation can serve as evidence of the invention's conception
and development timeline.
 Assessment of Commercial Potential: Evaluate the commercial potential of the
invention, considering factors such as market demand, competition, and potential
licensing opportunities.
 Filing a Provisional Patent Application: Consider filing a provisional patent
application. While not examined by the patent office, a provisional application
establishes a priority date and provides a "patent pending" status. It also allows the
inventor one year to file a non-provisional application.
 Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs): If discussions about the invention are
necessary with potential collaborators, investors, or partners, use non-disclosure
agreements (NDAs) to protect the confidentiality of the information.
 Drafting a Non-Provisional Patent Application: Prepare and draft a non-
provisional patent application with the assistance of a patent attorney or agent.
This application includes a detailed description of the invention, claims defining the
scope of protection, and any necessary drawings.
 Patent Office Examination: Submit the non-provisional patent application to the
relevant patent office. The patent office will conduct an examination to determine
if the invention meets the criteria for patentability.
 Patent Office Actions and Responses: The patent office may issue office actions,
which are official communications regarding the application. Responses to these
actions, often prepared by a patent attorney, may involve amending claims or
providing arguments to address the examiner's concerns.
 Publication of the Application: The patent application is typically published 18
months after filing. However, the actual granting of the patent depends on the
examination process and any potential challenges.
 Opposition Period (Some Jurisdictions): In some jurisdictions, there may be a
period during which third parties can oppose the grant of the patent.
 Grant of the Patent: If the patent office is satisfied with the application and any
necessary amendments or arguments, it will grant the patent. The inventor is then
issued a patent certificate.

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 16

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

 Payment of Maintenance Fees: To keep the patent in force, periodic maintenance

fees must be paid to the patent office throughout the life of the patent.

Prior Art Search

The prior art search is a crucial step in the patenting process. It involves searching existing
patents, published patent applications, scientific literature, and other publicly available
information to assess the novelty and patentability of an invention. Following are the
considerations for the prior art search:
 Comprehensive Search: Conduct a comprehensive search to identify relevant
prior art. This includes patents, patent applications, academic journals, conference
papers, technical reports, and any publicly available information related to the
invention.
 Database Searches: Use patent databases (such as the USPTO, EPO, WIPO, or
national patent offices) and non-patent literature databases to perform thorough
searches. Professional patent search firms or patent attorneys can assist in
conducting comprehensive searches.
 Search Strategy: Develop a search strategy based on keywords, classification
codes, and relevant technical terms associated with the invention. Iterative
searches may be needed to refine the strategy.
 Evaluate Relevance: Evaluate the relevance of the identified prior art to the
invention. Determine how closely it matches the features and elements of the
proposed invention.
 Analyze Patentability: Analyze the results to assess the patentability of the
invention. Identify any existing patents or publications that may affect the novelty
or non-obviousness of the invention.

Choice of Application to be Filed:

 Provisional vs. Non-Provisional: Consider filing a provisional patent application
if the invention is not yet fully developed or if there is a need to secure an early
filing date. A provisional application provides a priority date but does not undergo
a substantive examination.
 Utility vs. Design: Determine whether the invention is primarily functional
(utility) or ornamental (design). File a utility patent application for functional
inventions, while design patent applications protect the ornamental appearance.
 PCT Applications: If seeking international protection, consider filing a Patent
Cooperation Treaty (PCT) application. A PCT application provides a centralized
filing option and delays the decision on which specific countries to pursue patent
protection.
 National or Regional Filings: Decide on the countries or regions where patent
protection is desired. After the PCT phase, file national or regional applications in
the selected jurisdictions.
 Claims Drafting: Draft the claims carefully, as they define the scope of protection.
Claims should be broad enough to cover variations of the invention but specific

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 17

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

enough to distinguish it from the prior art.

 Consider Budget and Strategy: Evaluate budget constraints and overall patenting
strategy. Filing and maintaining patents can be costly, so it's essential to prioritize
filings based on the commercial significance of the invention.
 Professional Assistance: Seek the guidance of a qualified patent attorney or
agent. They can assist in interpreting the results of the prior art search, advise on
the appropriate type of application, and help with the drafting and filing process.

Patent Application Forms

The specific forms required for filing a patent application depend on the jurisdiction in
which you are seeking patent protection. Each patent office has its own set of forms and
procedures. Below are general categories of patent application forms commonly used in
various jurisdictions:
 Provisional Patent Application: In many jurisdictions, a provisional patent
application is filed to establish an early filing date for the invention. The form may
include details about the inventors, a description of the invention, and any
accompanying drawings.
 Non-Provisional (Utility) Patent Application: The non-provisional patent
application is a formal application that undergoes examination by the patent office.
It typically includes forms for the application cover sheet, specification, claims,
drawings, and an oath or declaration. Some jurisdictions, like the United States, use
the USPTO forms for non-provisional applications.
 PCT (Patent Cooperation Treaty) Application: The PCT application is an
international application that allows applicants to seek patent protection in
multiple countries. PCT forms include the PCT Request, Demand for International
Preliminary Examination, and various other forms required throughout the PCT
process.
 National or Regional Phase Entry Forms: After the PCT phase, applicants must
enter the national or regional phase in specific countries or regions. Each country
or region will have its own forms for entering the national phase, and these forms
typically include information about the application, inventors, and other
procedural details.
 Design Patent Application: Design patent applications, which protect the
ornamental appearance of an invention, have specific forms for the application
cover sheet, drawings or photographs of the design, and other relevant
information.
 Assignment and Ownership Forms: In some cases, forms related to the
assignment of patent rights or changes in ownership may be required. These forms
document the transfer of rights from one party to another.
 Oath or Declaration Forms: Applicants are often required to submit an oath or
declaration affirming that they are the true inventors of the claimed invention. This
form may also include an acknowledgment of the duty of disclosure.
 Small Entity or Micro Entity Status Forms: Applicants who qualify for small

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 18

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

entity or micro entity status may need to submit additional forms to claim the
reduced fees associated with these statuses.
 Response to Office Actions: If the patent office issues an office action or an
examiner's report, the applicant may need to submit response forms addressing
the issues raised by the examiner.
 Information Disclosure Statement (IDS): An IDS form may be required if the
applicant becomes aware of prior art during the prosecution of the application. This
form discloses relevant prior art to the patent office.
It's important to note that the names and formats of forms can vary among different patent
offices. Patent applicants are encouraged to consult the specific guidelines and
requirements of the relevant patent office and seek professional assistance from a qualified
patent attorney or agent to ensure accurate and compliant submission of patent application
forms.

Jurisdiction of Filing Patent Application

The jurisdiction in which you file a patent application depends on your strategic goals, the
potential market for your invention, and your budget. Following are the considerations
when choosing the jurisdiction for filing a patent application:
 National Patent Offices: You can file a patent application directly with the
national patent office of a specific country. This is known as a national filing. Each
country has its own patent laws and procedures.
 Regional Patent Offices: Some regions have established patent offices that allow
applicants to file a single application covering multiple countries. For example, the
European Patent Office (EPO) grants patents that are effective in multiple European
countries.
 International Patent Cooperation: The Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT) allows
applicants to file an international patent application, streamlining the process for
seeking protection in multiple countries. The PCT provides an international search
and preliminary examination, but it does not result in a granted patent. After the
PCT phase, applicants must enter the national or regional phase in specific
countries.
 Paris Convention for Priority Rights: The Paris Convention allows applicants to
claim priority for their invention within 12 months of filing the first application in
one member country. This is beneficial when seeking protection in multiple
countries, as it allows the later-filed applications to be treated as if they were filed
on the same day as the first application.
 Consideration of Market Presence: File in jurisdictions where you plan to
manufacture, sell, or license your invention. Focusing on key markets is often more
cost-effective than filing in every possible country.
 Budget Constraints: Filing and maintaining patents can be costly. Consider your
budget and prioritize filings based on the commercial significance of the invention
and the potential return on investment.
 Industry Considerations: Certain industries may have specific considerations. For

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 19

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

example, pharmaceutical companies often file in countries where regulatory

approval is sought, and technology companies may prioritize filings in regions with
significant market potential.
 Enforcement Considerations: Consider the enforceability of patents in different
jurisdictions. Some countries may have more robust legal systems for enforcing
intellectual property rights, while others may present challenges.
 Language Considerations: Be aware of language requirements in different
jurisdictions. Some patent offices may require documents to be submitted in their
official language or may accept translations.
 Competitor Activity: Monitor competitor patent filings to understand where they
are seeking protection. This information can help inform your own filing strategy.

Publication. Pre-grant Opposition. Examination. Grant of a Patent. Validity of Patent

Protection. Post-grant Opposition. Commercialization of a Patent

The life cycle of a patent involves several stages, from the initial filing of the application to
the potential commercialization of the patented invention. Here's an overview of the key
stages in the life of a patent:
 Filing a Patent Application:
 Invention and Documentation: The process begins with the conception of
an invention. Detailed records and documentation are maintained to support
the patent application.
 Provisional or Non-Provisional Filing: The inventor may file a provisional
patent application for an early filing date or directly file a non-provisional
(utility) patent application, which undergoes examination.
 Publication:
 Publication of Patent Application: After filing, the patent application is
typically published after a certain period (e.g., 18 months) unless the
applicant requests non-publication. Publication makes the details of the
invention publicly available.
 Pre-Grant Opposition:
 Opposition Period: In some jurisdictions, third parties may have an
opportunity to oppose the grant of a patent after publication but before its
official grant. This is known as pre-grant opposition.
 Grounds for Opposition: Opposition may be based on claims of lack of
novelty, inventive step, or other statutory requirements.
 Examination:
 Patent Office Examination: The patent office conducts a substantive
examination of the patent application to assess whether the invention meets
the criteria for patentability, including novelty, non-obviousness, and utility.
 Office Actions and Responses: The patent office may issue office actions,
and the applicant responds by amending claims, providing arguments, or
addressing any concerns raised by the examiner.

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 20

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

 Grant of a Patent:
 Issuance of a Patent: If the patent office is satisfied with the examination
process, a patent is granted, and the inventor receives a patent certificate.
 Rights and Term: The patent provides exclusive rights to the inventor for a
limited term, usually 20 years from the filing date.
 Validity of Patent Protection:
 Presumption of Validity: A granted patent is presumed valid. However, its
validity can be challenged in legal proceedings.
 Enforcement and Litigation: The patent owner can enforce their rights
through legal action against infringers. Infringement lawsuits may involve
claims of patent invalidity as a defense.
 Post-Grant Opposition:
 Post-Grant Opposition or Review: Some jurisdictions allow post-grant
opposition or review, providing an opportunity for third parties to challenge
the validity of a granted patent after it has been issued.
 Patent Office Proceedings: The patent office may conduct proceedings to
reevaluate the patent's validity based on new evidence or arguments.
 Commercialization of a Patent:
 Licensing and Commercialization: Patent owners can license their
patented technology to others, granting permission for use in exchange for
fees or royalties.
 Manufacturing and Marketing: The patented invention can be
manufactured and marketed by the patent owner or licensed partners.
 Product Launch: The commercialization phase involves launching the
product or service associated with the patented invention into the market.
 Monitoring and Enforcement: The patent owner monitors the market for
potential infringement and may take legal action against infringers.

Need for a Patent Attorney/Agent

Engaging a patent attorney or patent agent is highly advisable when dealing with the
patenting process. Here are several reasons why their expertise is crucial:
 Legal Expertise: Patent attorneys and agents have specialized legal knowledge in
patent law. They are well-versed in the intricacies of the patent system, including
the statutory requirements, rules, and procedures.
 Drafting and Prosecution: They are skilled in drafting patent applications,
including the preparation of detailed specifications, claims, and drawings.
Additionally, they handle the prosecution of patent applications, responding to
office actions, and interacting with patent examiners.
 Patentability Assessment: Patent professionals can assess the patentability of an
invention by conducting thorough prior art searches and analyzing the results to
determine the novelty and non-obviousness of the invention.
 Strategic Advice: They provide strategic advice on the scope of patent protection,
helping inventors understand the potential limitations and strengths of their patent

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 21

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

rights.
 Navigating Legal Requirements: Patent attorneys navigate the legal
requirements of different jurisdictions, ensuring that patent applications comply
with the specific rules and regulations of each patent office.
 Risk Mitigation: They help identify potential risks and challenges during the
patenting process, such as prior art issues, and develop strategies to mitigate these
risks.
 Communication with Patent Offices: Patent attorneys and agents communicate
with patent offices on behalf of inventors, addressing questions, responding to
office actions, and advocating for the issuance of a patent.
 Patent Portfolio Management: For companies or inventors with multiple
inventions, patent professionals assist in managing a portfolio of patents. This
involves strategic decisions on filing, maintenance, and potential enforcement.
 Enforcement and Litigation: In case of patent infringement or legal disputes,
patent attorneys are equipped to handle enforcement actions and litigation. They
can represent clients in court and negotiate settlements.
 Confidentiality and Non-Disclosure: Patent attorneys are bound by professional
ethics and legal obligations to maintain client confidentiality. This is crucial when
dealing with sensitive information about inventions.
 Training and Qualifications: Patent attorneys typically have legal qualifications
and may have technical backgrounds in fields such as engineering or science. Patent
agents may have technical qualifications and are registered to practice before
patent offices.
 Updates on Patent Law: Patent professionals stay informed about changes in
patent laws and regulations, ensuring that they provide up-to-date advice and
services.

Can a Worldwide Patent be Obtained

There is no such thing as a "worldwide patent" that provides global protection for an
invention in a single filing. However, there are international mechanisms and treaties that
facilitate the process of obtaining patent protection in multiple countries. Two primary
routes for seeking international patent protection are the Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT)
and the Paris Convention.
 Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT):
 The PCT is an international treaty that simplifies the process of filing patent
applications in multiple countries. It does not grant a "worldwide patent" but
provides a streamlined mechanism for filing an international patent
application.
 International Phase: After filing a PCT application, the invention undergoes
an international search and, optionally, a preliminary examination. The PCT
application designates the countries where the applicant may later seek
national or regional patent protection.
 National Phase: At the end of the international phase (usually 30 or 31

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 22

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

months from the priority date), the applicant enters the national phase by
filing individual patent applications in the chosen countries. Each national or
regional application is subject to examination by the respective patent offices.
 Paris Convention for Priority Rights:
 The Paris Convention allows applicants to claim priority based on their first
filing in one member country. This priority right can be exercised within 12
months to file subsequent applications in other member countries.
 An applicant can file a first application in one country, and within 12 months,
file additional applications in other member countries, claiming the benefit
of the earlier filing date. This is known as the right of priority.

 It's important to note that while these international mechanisms streamline the
process of obtaining patents in multiple jurisdictions, each national or regional
application is treated independently and subject to the laws and requirements of
the respective patent office. Additionally, the granted patent rights are enforceable
only within the jurisdiction of each individual country.
 Furthermore, the term "worldwide patent" can be misleading, as patent laws are
territorial. Obtaining patent protection in every country can be expensive and may
not be necessary, depending on the commercial goals of the inventor or applicant.
Companies and inventors often strategically select countries where they see
significant market potential or where potential infringers may operate.
 Consulting with a qualified patent attorney or agent is crucial when considering
international patent protection. They can provide guidance on the most effective
strategy for protecting your invention based on factors such as market presence,
budget constraints, and the nature of the invention.

Do I Need First to File a Patent in India

India follows the "first-to-file" system for patent applications, which means that the first
person or entity to file a patent application for a particular invention is generally given
priority over others who file later, regardless of who actually invented the technology first.
This is in contrast to some jurisdictions that follow the "first-to-invent" system, where the
date of invention is considered in case of a dispute.
Following key points to consider regarding the first-to-file system in India:
 Priority Date: The priority date is the filing date of the patent application. It
establishes the date from which the novelty and non-obviousness of the invention
are assessed. To secure an early priority date, it is advisable to file a patent
application as soon as the invention is developed and before any public disclosure.
 Risk of Losing Priority: Waiting to file a patent application may pose a risk of
losing priority to someone who files a similar application earlier. If another party
files a patent application for the same or a similar invention before you do, they
may be granted priority.
 Confidentiality and Non-Disclosure: To protect the novelty of your invention, it
is crucial to avoid public disclosure before filing a patent application. Public

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 23

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

disclosure can include publishing, presenting at conferences, or any other form of

communication that makes the invention accessible to the public.
 Provisional Applications: Filing a provisional patent application can be a strategic
option. A provisional application provides a filing date and allows the use of "patent
pending" status. It gives you time (usually 12 months) to further develop the
invention and file a non-provisional application while maintaining the priority date
of the provisional application.
 Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT): If you are considering filing patents in
multiple countries, you may use the Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT) to file an
international application. The PCT provides a centralized filing option, allowing you
to delay the decision on which specific countries to pursue patent protection.
 Consult with a Patent Attorney: Seeking advice from a qualified patent attorney
is highly recommended. They can assist in determining the appropriate timing for
filing, conducting a prior art search, drafting the application, and navigating the
patent application process in India.

Patent Related Forms

 Provisional Patent Application:
 Form 101: Application for Grant of Patent.
 Non-Provisional (Utility) Patent Application:
 Form 1: Application for Grant of Patent.
 Form 2: Provisional or Complete Specification.
 Form 3: Statement and Undertaking Regarding Foreign Applications.
 Form 5: Declaration as to Inventorship.
 PCT (Patent Cooperation Treaty) Application:
 PCT/RO/101: Request for International Search.
 PCT/IB/308: Demand for International Preliminary Examination.
 PCT/IB/373: Amendment under Article 34 (2) (b) and Rule 66.1.
 Design Patent Application:
 Form 4: Application for Registration of Design.
 Assignment and Ownership Forms:
 Form 17: Request for Entry in the Register and Notice of Opposition to Entries
in the Register.
 Form 16: Request for Postdating.
 Form 19: Application for Amendment of Patent.
 Oath or Declaration Forms:
 Form 26: Declaration as to Inventorship.
 Small Entity or Micro Entity Status Forms:
 Form 28: Declaration for Claiming "Small Entity" Status.
 Response to Office Actions:
 Form 7: Request for Hearing.

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 24

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

Fee Structure
The fee structure for patent applications varies based on factors such as the type of
application, the number of claims, and the applicant's status (individual, small entity, or
large entity). Common fees include:
 1. Filing Fees: Paid at the time of submitting the patent application.
 2. Examination Fees: Paid for conducting substantive examination.
 3. Publication Fees: Associated with the publication of the application.
 4. Renewal or Maintenance Fees: Paid periodically to keep the patent in force.

Types of Patent Applications

 Provisional Patent Application: Provides a filing date but does not undergo
substantive examination. Gives "patent pending" status.
 Non-Provisional (Utility) Patent Application: Subject to substantive
examination, leading to the potential grant of a patent.
 PCT (Patent Cooperation Treaty) Application: International application that
streamlines the process of seeking patent protection in multiple countries.
 Design Patent Application: Filed to protect the ornamental design or appearance
of an article.

Commonly Used Terms in Patenting

 Claims: Statements that define the scope of protection sought for an invention.
 Prior Art: Existing technology or information that is relevant to assessing the
novelty and non-obviousness of an invention.
 Examiner: A patent office official responsible for examining patent applications.
 Patentability: The criteria an invention must meet to qualify for patent protection.
 Infringement: Unauthorized use, making, selling, or importing of a patented
invention.
 Validity: The legal soundness and enforceability of a granted patent.
 Non-Obviousness: A requirement for patentability, indicating that an invention
must not be obvious to a person skilled in the relevant field.
 Novelty: A requirement for patentability, indicating that an invention must be new
and not part of the prior art.
 Abstract: A concise summary of the technical aspects of an invention.
 Prosecution: The process of interacting with the patent office during the
examination of a patent application.
 Office Action: An official communication from the patent office regarding the
status of a patent application.
 Grant: The formal issuance of a patent by the patent office.

National Bodies Dealing with Patent Affairs:

National bodies dealing with patent affairs play a crucial role in the administration and
regulation of patent systems within individual countries. These bodies are responsible for
receiving, examining, and granting patents, as well as maintaining patent databases and
facilitating the protection of intellectual property.

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 25

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

National Bodies Dealing with Patent Affairs:

 India:
 Indian Patent Office (IPO):
 Website: [IPO](https://www.ipindia.nic.in/)
 United States:
 United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO):
 Website: [USPTO](https://www.uspto.gov/)
 European Union:
 European Patent Office (EPO):
 Website: [EPO](https://www.epo.org/)
 China:
 State Intellectual Property Office of the People's Republic of China (SIPO):
 Website: [SIPO](http://english.sipo.gov.cn/)
 Japan:
 Japan Patent Office (JPO):
 Website: [JPO](https://www.jpo.go.jp/)
 United Kingdom:
 Intellectual Property Office (IPO):
 Website: [IPO](https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/intellectual-
property-office)
 Germany:
 German Patent and Trade Mark Office (DPMA):
 Website: [DPMA](https://www.dpma.de/english/)
 France:
 National Institute of Industrial Property (INPI):
 Website: [INPI](https://www.inpi.fr/en)

Utility Models:
A utility model is a form of intellectual property protection similar to a patent but typically
with a shorter term and less stringent requirements. Utility models are often available for
inventions that may not meet the inventive step (non-obviousness) threshold required for
patents. They provide a quicker and often less expensive route to protection. Here are some
countries that offer utility model protection:
 Germany:
 German Utility Model (Gebrauchsmuster): Administered by the German Patent
and Trade Mark Office (DPMA).
 Japan:
 Utility Model: Administered by the Japan Patent Office (JPO).
 China:
 Utility Model: Administered by the China National Intellectual Property
Administration (CNIPA).
 Spain:

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 26

 Research Methodology & Intellectual Property Rights

 Utility Model (Modelo de Utilidad): Administered by the Spanish Patent and

Trademark Office.
 Mexico:
 Utility Model (Modelo de Utilidad): Administered by the Mexican Institute of
Industrial Property (IMPI).
 Russia:
 Utility Model (Useful Model): Administered by the Federal Service for
Intellectual Property (Rospatent).

Compiled by Mr. Manjunath H S, Dept. of Civil Engineering, RIT, Hassan 27