Chaplains Guide Interactive PDF
Chaplains Guide Interactive PDF
HELPING
THOSE
STRUGGLING
WITH A
PORNOGRAPHY
HABIT:
An introduction to the brain science
of addiction, its negative effects, and
therapy models for change
This booklet is dedicated to my wife Kaylee
and our five children, Bridger, Beckham,
Benson, Anderson, and Roslyn.
HELPING
THOSE
STRUGGLING
WITH A
PORNOGRAPHY
HABIT:
1
Tapping into one of the most powerful
and desirable human impulses—the
reproductive urge—pornography has
the potential to lure individuals into its
use (Cline, 2001). In a 2016 nationwide
study, an estimated 70 percent of
men and 40 percent of women in the
United States have admitted to viewing
pornography within the past year
(Regnerus et al., 2016).
Although viewing pornography
does not always form into a habit, the
estimated number of users may indicate
that pornography is being used as a
maladaptive coping strategy, and that is
what this booklet aims to look at.
2
Although pornography is considered
potentially addictive (Hilton, Jr., 2013),
and brings with it a potential for
negative effects (Manning, 2006), there
is great hope in knowing that there is
effective treatment available that has
been shown to help individuals either
dramatically reduce or completely
eliminate pornography use from their
lives (Crosby and Twohig, 2016).
The purpose of this guidebook is to
give chaplains a greater understanding
of habitual pornography use, and also
more importantly, provide guidance
on how to assist those struggling with
a pornography habit find hope, with a
greater perspective and knowledge on
3
the subject.
While this guidebook by no means
aims to be comprehensive, the goal is
that it is used as a tool so that, along
with spiritual tools, success in recovery
can dramatically increase, along with its
associated benefits.
4
T HE BRAIN SCIENCE OF
ADDICTION:
For years, many people have simplified ad-
diction as a lack of personal control (Grubbs et
al., 2015). In the past 15 years, however, many
advances in neuroscience have demonstrated
that addiction is not merely a lack of self con-
trol, but instead a rather complicated matter
involving both brain pathways and emotional
regulation (ASAM.org).
5
6
H OW DOES ADDICTION
WORK?
Two important aspects of addiction
are emotional dysregulation and neural
adaptations (re-wiring of brain pathways; see
Koob, 2019). This may explain why addiction
is so prevalent in our society.
With easy access to so many pleasure
producing substances, people today often
do not learn how to regulate their emotions
in a healthy manner, and instead turn to
pleasurable substances or behaviors to
temporarily “cope” with their emotions rather
than addressing them healthily (Chamberlain
and Steurer, 2011).
7
E MOTIONAL DYSREGULATION
-Mark Chamberlain and Geoff Steurer, Love You, Hate the Porn:
Healing a Relationship Damaged by Virtual Infidelity
8
W hy do people put addiction
before other things?
As mentioned, there are certain substances
or behaviors that can produce stimulation
and pleasure beyond what is found in average,
everyday life. These substances or behaviors
can become very hard to resist once they
have been used habitually as a way to cope, as
other forms of coping which do not create as
powerful of an immediate reward to not seem
as desirable (Hilton, Jr., 2013).
9
This chemical messenger is also known as
a neurotransmitter (Nistico and Scapagnini,
2012).
10
N EURAL ADAPTATIONS
11
It is these neuroadaptations (neural
adaptations) in the brain pathways that
researchers have theorized to potentially be the
cause of the negative emotional states associated
with the discontinuation of an ingrained habit,
creating a vulnerability to future relapse as one
may wish to extinguish unpleasant emotional,
physical and psychological symptoms through
the behavior (Solinas et al., 2019).
12
P ORNOGRAPHY’S
NEGATIVE EFFECTS
Negative Effect #1: It Teaches Objectification
13
Negative Effect #3: It Impacts Marriage and
Family
14
T HERAPY MODELS FOR
RECOVERY
Thousands of scientific studies have been
dedicated specifically to the topic of addiction.
While a majority of them are focused on the
issue of substance abuse, many of the same
brain mechanisms activated during the
consumption of drugs of abuse are activated
upon the consumption of pornographic
material.
15
16
A couple of the models which have been
shown to demonstrate lasting, positive
changes in individuals include the therapy
models of Emotionally Focused Couples
Therapy (EFT), which sees addiction as an
attachment disorder and aims to repair the
attachment, and Acceptance Commitment
Therapy (ACT).
17
pleasure arises with social contact and strong
attachment bonds, which is . . . thought to
be mediated by [endogenous] opioids,” and
“being close to significant others leads to
feelings of comfort, security, and pleasure”
(Zellner et al., 2011).
18
safety and connection that ultimately satisfies
more than the substance or behavior alone
(Zellner et al., 2011).
19
According to Zitzman and Butler, there
is some evidence that pornography may
impact attachment security with habitual use.
Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT), on the
other hand, capitalizes on the concept and
power of secure attachment and attachment
repair, and is considered by various
professional therapists a “roadmap for the
path of couples’ healing.” EFT has even
been called by some the “most effective and
research-validated way to treat couples in
distress” (Chamberlain and Steurer, 2011).
20
The reason why this word fits so well in
the context of addiction is because of how
its definition correlates with the overarching
purpose of the EFT model—to help couples
establish a relationship based on “continuous
progression” and “development” in emotion-
ally-connecting interpersonal skills, which ul-
timately leads to a secure attachment.
HOW TO APPLY THE “ARC” PROCESS:
The first step in the Emotionally Focused
ARC process towards healing is learning to
become (A) more Aware of emotions, espe-
cially the emotions that are typically pushed
down for being petty, such as getting one’s
feelings hurt from a less-than-thoughtful
comment. “As we become more aware of our
emotions” says Dr. Mark Chamberlain, “we
gain an ability to choose how we want to act
in response to them” (Chamberlain and Steur-
er, 2011). And regaining the ability to choose
is a huge step forward in the recovery process.
21
of emotion it is and labeling it is a very
important tool for knowing how to talk
about it, to diffuse its distressing energy:
22
“Husband and wife [or trusted friend] can
help each other if he (or she) recognizes and
shares the deeper emotions that drive the
cravings for relief. This will help her (or him)
see that he’s (or she is) coming to her (or him)
long before the emotions become sexualized
in the form of seeking relief through por-
nography” (Chamberlain and Steurer, 2011).
23
WHY USE EFT?
24
ACT—Acceptance and Commitment
Therapy
In an article on the effectiveness of “mind-
fulness-based” approaches to therapy (such
as Acceptance and Commitment Therapy),
Julie Fraumeni-McBride states: “Mindful-
ness-based therapies for addiction have
emerged recently as validated forms of clin-
ical therapy comparable to and in certain
situations or cases superior to traditional
forms of therapy such as CBT,” adding later
that “mindfulness, more specifically accep-
tance and commitment therapy, may be the
optimal form of therapy in treating problem-
atic pornography use—use that may qual-
ify as addiction, which falls in the realm of
sex addiction” (Fraumeni-McBride, 2019).
25
reduction, and 24 (93%) had at least a 70%
reduction” (Crosby and Twohig, 2016). These
statistics are beyond what is considered suc-
cessful in a clinical trial, and it is possible that
these numbers may have caught the attention
of psychotherapists in the last several years.
.
THE BASIC MODEL OF ACT
In a 2006 review of ACT, researchers list
what they call the “Six core processes of ACT”
where the overall goal of ACT is increasing
“psychological flexibility” (Hayes et al., 2006).
26
(3) Being Present (ongoing non-judg-
mental contact with one’s own psychological
events, including thoughts, just as they oc-
cur);
27
ACT claims to be one of the most effective
treatments for addictions when compared
to other therapy models, especially among
highly religious populations (as mentioned in
Crosby and Twohig’s study on ACT for treating
problematic internet pornography use). This
is because “many religious systems define
certain sexual practices as permissible and
others as problematic,” hence the perceived
problematic practices can often lead to “guilt
and shame” (Grubbs et al., 2015).
28
Shame is labeled by Kenneth Adams and
Donald Robinson as one of the “three key
barriers” that “prevent addicts from breaking
the compulsive cycle,” and is defined by them
as “self-contempt, feelings of inadequacy,
and painful disapproval of the self (seeing
one’s self as “bad” rather than making poor
choices)” (Adams and Robinson, 2001).
29
Another way ACT is effective in the context
of healing from pornography addiction and
sexual compulsivity is where “high levels of
experiential avoidance” (avoiding or attempt-
ing to eliminate “unpleasant” events such as
boredom and loneliness with techniques such
as distraction) can be “related to increases in
sexual urges” (Wetterneck et al., 2012).
30
could “lead to an increase” rather than a de-
crease of these types of “inner experiences”
and “subsequent behaviors” (Crosby, 2011).
This is important to know as a pastoral coun-
selor, as sometimes the “traditional” methods
for overcoming bad habits are actually the last
thing you would want to do.
31
There is a difference between sexual arousal and sexual
behavior. Following James Crosby’s ACT model for pornography
addiction, “make sure the participant recognizes that they
have control over behavior, but not over the urges to view.”
32
to distinguish the difference between sexual
urges (arousal)—which are “a normal part of
being human”—and sexual behaviors, which
are consciously chosen and which they have
control of (Twohig and Crosby, 2010). This
is important as it allows the client to likely
reduce, or even eliminate, the shame they
experience when they encounter a desire
that is inherent in virtually all humans, if that
(shame) is what they have been experiencing.
33
Two Other Therapy Aids Backed by
Science:
#1: Exercise
Regarding the potential of exercise in helping
overcome an addiction, in his 2011 study
Christopher Olsen states:
34
He adds in the conclusion of his study that,
in addition to reducing “relapse to drugs of
abuse,” exercise also “reduces withdrawal
symptoms and relapse in abstinent smokers,”
and even mentions that “one drug recovery
program has seen success in participants that
train for and compete in a marathon as part of
the program.”
35
36
H ow to help those
struggling:
As mentioned in the introduction, this
guidebook was not meant to be a comprehen-
sive recovery manual for pornography or re-
lated addictions.
37
The key to recovery, then, is finding how
deep the roots go and taking care of the prob-
lem from the ground level up.
38
equately trained in them. The best way to use
this book, however, is to study it thoroughly to
gain a better understanding of addiction, to be
able to better understand those who approach
you, and listen to them with love.
39
“In reality, the pull of pornography
results ... from unmanaged
emotional and relationship pain.
Think of it as attempting to meet
healthy needs in unhealthy ways.”
-Mark Chamberlain and Geoff Steurer
40
R eferences
Adams, Kenneth M., and Donald W. Robinson. “Shame
Reduction, Affect Regulation, and Sexual Boundary
Development: Essential Building Blocks of Sexual Addiction
Treatment.” Sexual Addiction & Compulsivity 8, no. 1 (2001):
23-44.
41
Crosby, Jesse M., and Michael P. Twohig. “Acceptance and
Commitment Therapy for Problematic Internet Pornography
Use: A Randomized Trial.” Behavior Therapy 47, no. 3 (2016):
355-366.
42
Fraumeni-McBride, Julie. “Addiction and Mindfulness;
Pornography Addiction and Mindfulness-Based Therapy ACT.”
Sexual Addiction and Compulsivity 26, no. 1–2 (2019): 42-53.
43
Koob, George F. “Neurobiology of Opioid Addiction: Opponent
Process, Hyperkatifeia and Negative Reinforcement.” Biological
Psychiatry (2019): 1-10.
44
Owens, Eric W., Richard J. Behun, Jill C. Manning, and Rory C.
Reid. “The Impact of Internet Pornography on Adolescents: A
Review of the Research.” Sexual Addiction & Compulsivity 19,
no. 1-2 (2012): 99-122.
Van Der Kolk, Bessell. The Body Keeps the Score: Brain, Mind,
and Body in the Healing of Trauma. New York: Viking, 2014.
45
Wetterneck, Chad T., Angela J. Burgess, Mary B. Short, Angela
H. Smith, and Maritza E. Cervantes. “The Role of Sexual
Compulsivity, Impulsivity, and Experiential Avoidance in
Internet Pornography Use.” The Psychological Record 62, no. 1
(2012): 3-18.
46
47
48