Aircraft Recovery Manual
Aircraft Recovery Manual
Signature:
_____________________________________
A revision of all content is conducted once every two years on the revision date. Changes to
content shall be recorded in the table below:
Revision
Date Chapter Changes Executed by
number
05/2020 15/05/2020 All AF.AA.40.502 "Manual for the AF
recovery of damaged aircraft
at Cologne Bonn Airport" replaces
all previous regulations in this
regard, in particular OHB B_311 of
26.02.2020.
22/10/2020 Div. Removal of the Recovery PO
Contract+fees, as there is a
separate document;
Formal adjustments by Ms
Damaschke so that the document
can be uploaded to the DAW.
19/01/2021 Div. Grammatical and orthographic AFK
improvements
Table of contents
List of tables………........................................................................................................... 6
List of illustrations......................................................................................................... 6
List of abbreviations........................................................................................................ 7
Preface............................................................................................................................ 8
3. Structural organisation.............................................................................................. 13
3.3.2. Trainings…................................................................................................ 20
4. Procedural organisation.............................................................................................. 23
4.3.4.Documentation of recovery…...........................................................................33
Annex…..............................................................................................................................34
List of tables
List of figures
List of abbreviations
a/c aircraft
ARTS Aircraft-Recovery-Transport-System
LuftVZO Luftverkehrs-Zulassungs-Ordnung
Preface
This manual of Flughafen Köln/Bonn GmbH (FKB) describes the basics of aircraft recovery operations
and is intended to provide information on the organisation, processes and documentation of an
aircraft recovery operation at Cologne Bonn Airport (CGN). Besides general topics, the contents are
largely limited to the procedures and available resources commonly used at CGN. The content of
this manual is therefore primarily aimed at those involved in the recovery of aircraft and airlines
that regularly fly to the airport or use it as an alternative airport.
All procedures and measures described below are based on the specifications and recommendations
of the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) and the European Aviation Safety Agency
(EASA). The rules of the Airport User Regulations (AUR) as well as the measures to be derived from
the Aerodrome Manual of the CGN continue to apply. All parties for whom this manual serves as
the basis of the recovery operation at CGN are responsible for the implementation of and
compliance with all regulations and safety provisions resulting herefrom. With the entry into
force of this manual, all internal FKB regulations in this regard cease to apply, in particular OHB
B_311 Recovery Organisation from 26/02/2016.
The term "recovery" in this manual refers to an aircraft that is unable to move by its own power
or by the normal use of a suitable aircraft tug on or adjacent to the movement area of the airport.
According to the ICAO Airport Service Manual (ASM), Part 5, there are three types of recovery:
"aircraft debogging“,
"aircraft recovery“
"aircraft salvage“.
The recovery of an aircraft can only be initiated after the Federal Aircraft Accident Investigation
Bureau (Bundesstelle für Flugunfalluntersuchung – BFU) and, in the case of personal injuries, the
police and the public prosecutor's office have released the damaged aircraft. If the recovery case
occurs after an accident involving an aircraft of the German Armed Forces, the „General
Flugsicherheit in der Bundeswehr“ (General Air Safety in the German Armed Forces) must also give
permission for the aircraft to be recovered. As the owner of a commercial airport, FKB is only
responsible for recoveries that take place on the airport's premises. Outside the external property
border, FKB is only involved if an airline issues a recovery order for the recovery of the damaged
aircraft that is not located on the airport property.
In addition, according to § 45 LuftVZO, FKB is obliged to keep the airport in an operationally safe
condition at all times, i. e. it must also ensure that the runway system is cleared of any immobile
aircraft (see also Chapter 4.5). If an aircraft remains unable to move at the airport, FKB may
remove it from the flight operation areas after clearance, even without a special order from the
aircraft holder, at the latter's expense, or commission competent third parties to remove it, as
far as this is necessary for the handling of air traffic. If no significant contractual obligations
have been violated or if life, body or health have been culpably injured, FKB shall only be liable
for damages if it has caused them intentionally or through serious negligence. Liability is also
limited to the predictable, typically occurring damage. This also applies if the aircraft operator
has instructed FKB to remove an immobile aircraft from the flight operation areas or to assist in
such removal.
With all measures and processes, the safety of people always comes first. The principle of "Safety
First" applies. Furthermore, the prompt removal of the damaged aircraft and, due to the high value
of the aircraft, the avoidance of additional damage caused by the recovery operation are of central
importance. A recovery operation is typically considered to be terminated as soon as the aircraft
is removed from the accident site and safely placed at a temporary destination so that normal
operations can be resumed at the airport. Following the recovery incident, a detailed
documentation of the events, a final meeting and the preparation of the final report take place.
This manual and its structure as well as content are based on various laws and directives issued
by the authorities responsible for air traffic. These are mainly the following documents:
In addition, the following applicable documents are taken into account in the event of the recovery
of an aircraft:
In order to assess the severity of damage, a recovery case at FKB is initially categorised into
three classes according to its difficulty, after a first inspection has determined what damage
has occurred to the aircraft. The following table shows these classes and their definitions.
Furthermore, the recovery case that has occurred and the necessary recovery preparation can be
classified on the basis of aircraft classes (Aerodrome Reference Code) in accordance with the ICAO
specifications in Annex 14.
Code letter Wing span Outer main gear wheel Typical aeroplane
(ICAO) span
Dassault Falcon 10,
A < 15 m < 4,5 m Piper Malibu,
Learjet 55
Cessna 525,
B 15 – 24 m 4,5 – 6 m Dassault Falcon 2000,
Embraer ERJ-145, Bombardier
CRJ-200
Gulfstream V, Dash 7, ATR42-
C 24 – 36 m 6–9m 500, Saab 2000, B737, A320,
MD88, Fokker 100
A300/310,
D 36 – 52 m 9 – 14 m B757/767,
Tupolev 154
A330/340/350,
E 52 – 65 m 9 – 14 m B747-400, B777/787,
MD11
B747-8,
F 65 – 80 m 14 – 16 m A380, AN124,
AN225
Table 2: aircraft categories according to ICAO Annex 14
For the exact classification of the occurred recovery case, the connection between the difficulty
of the recovery case and the aircraft category according to ICAO is therefore presented in a
matrix. This can be used professionally by the recovery management on the basis of the existing
experience and competencies. In addition to the recovery preparation, the matrix is also
intended to support the documentation of the recovery.
Recovery category
A B C D E F
Easy (L)
Medium (M)
Severe
(S)/Scrapping
3 Structural organisation
The registered owner or proprietor of the aircraft is responsible for the recovery of damaged or
immobile aircraft. If the owner or proprietor is unable to carry out the recovery himself, he must
appoint a responsible agent to carry out the recovery. This can either be FKB as the airport operator
itself or a third party company that carries out the recovery on behalf of the airline.
The following illustrations show the currently valid organisational structures, as well as the
descriptions of the individual functions during a recovery at CGN.
Note: If the airline has contracted FKB for aircraft recovery, it may still support the recovery
with aircraft technicians or additional equipment if necessary. In these circumstances, the
airline recovery crew is involved in the recovery. Therefore, a transparent way of representing
the airline recovery crew and its leader in the organisation chart has been chosen. In addition,
the airlin might use different terminology for the airline recovery crew and specifically for the
airline recovery crew leader. The areas of responsibility nevertheless remain the same.
o Leads the execution of the recovery in accordance with the recovery concept
o Supervision of the practical execution of the recovery
o Provision of the recovery equipment
o Coordinates with the recovery leader regarding the implementation of the
recovery concept
o Coordination with the recovery crew leader of the airline, especially for all
technical work at the aircraft
o Responsible for the operational readiness, maintenance and upkeep of the FKB's
own recovery equipment
o Carrying out recovery exercises in cooperation with all parties involved
Note: If the airline carries out the recovery of the aircraft itself or commissions a third party
company to do so, FKB can still support the recovery with additional equipment and associated
personnel if necessary. Under these circumstances, the FKB recovery crew is involved in the
recovery. Therefore, a transparent representation of the FKB recovery crew and its leader has been
chosen in the organisational chart. In addition, the airline may use different terminology for the
its recovery crew and specifically for its recovery crew leader. The areas of responsibility
nevertheless remain the same. The tasks of the airline recovery leader and the airline recovery
crew leader can also be carried out by the same person.
The FKB recovery team is capable of recovering all types of aircraft up to and including the Boeing
747 family. Complete recovery is possible for all types of aircraft (if necessary, with the support
of third-party companies).
A complete load or complete reload becomes necessary if an aircraft can no longer be made capable
of moving with the equipment available at CGN. FKB can only carry out this independently for ICAO
category A aircraft. For all other aircraft types up to Boeing 747, only partial loading (e.g. of a
main landing gear) can be carried out independently. In the event that an aircraft of ICAO category
B to F has to be loaded completely, there is a contract with Frankfurt/Main Airport for the joint
use of the Aircraft Recovery Transport System (ARTS-2/2x) (see Annex 7).
The primary task of the FKB recovery crew is to use/operate the recovery equipment of FKB. In the
event of mechanical or electronic repair or maintenance work on the aircraft, the airline must
send competent technicians to carry this out (see also chapter 4.5).
3.3.2 Trainings
For all recovery coordinators, recovery leaders, recovery crew leaders and the recovery crew, a
detailed practical training course, including work safety training, is held once a year. This goes
beyond the planning exercises ("tabletop exercises") recommended in ICAO ASM Part 5 for aircraft
recoveries at the respective airport. In addition to FKB, the German Armed Forces stationed at the
airport and the local THW are taking part in the recovery exercise. It is intended to integrate
other participating companies (such as airlines and refuelling services) in the recovery training.
In addition, the recovery coordinators, recovery leaders and recovery crew leaders are sent to annual
recovery seminars organised by the Arbeitsgemeinschaft deutscher Verkehrsflughäfen e. V. (ADV) in
order to expand their know-how regarding new recovery equipment and to exchange experiences with
recovery officers from other airports in German-speaking countries.
The entire training and examination concept for recovery operations at FKB can be viewed on
request.
The inventory of recovery equipment at FKB is - in relation to other airports of the same size -
above average. A list of all parts of the recovery equipment, including the respective number of
pieces, storage location, length, load-bearing capacity and colour, is kept and constantly updated.
The list of recovery equipment can be viewed on request.
In addition to its own equipment, there is also cooperation with the German Armed Forces based
at CGN and the local THW regarding the support of FKB with recovery equipment in the event of a
recovery. Furthermore, there is a contract with Frankfurt Airport which stipulates that FKB may
use the Aircraft Recovery Transport System (ARTS-2/2x) of the Frankfurt Airport operator under its
supervision (see Annex 7).
FKB's own equipment may only be operated by employees appointed by FKB. The operation of FKB's
own recovery equipment by other persons is therefore not permitted.
The FKB recovery crew leaders are responsible for the operational readiness, maintenance and
upkeep of FKB's own recovery equipment. In accordance with the manufacturer's specifications, all
components of the recovery equipment are regularly maintained. The maintenance status of the
recovery equipment is always documented. As soon as the expiry date specified by the manufacturer
is reached, the equipment is replaced.
Special maintenance instructions are found for the lifting bags. Initially they have to be
maintenanced every five years, later every two years and finally every year. As soon as the lifting
bags have reached their 20th year of life, they are replaced by new ones. The tests of the lifting
bags are carried out externally by the manufacturers themselves in order to ensure the maximum
possible safety.
In the event of a recovery case, airlines must inform the BFU about the damaged aircraft as soon
as possible so that it can quickly authorise the recovery of the aircraft.
After the occurrence of a recovery case, the airline must also have made a decision within 30
minutes of the alert and communicated it to the FKB as to whether it will carry out the recovery
independently or commission the FKB or a third-party company to do so. If this does not happen
within the specified time interval, the FKB will exercise its right described in the foreword to
this manual, in the FBO and in the Aerodrome Manual, to remove the aircraft from the flight
operation areas after clearance even without a special order from the aircraft holder at the latter's
expense or to commission competent third parties with the removal, insofar as this is necessary
for the handling of air traffic.
In the course of the recovery operation, the recovery leaders provided by airlines must permanently
coordinate with the recovery coordinator appointed by FKB. Even in the event that FKB carries out
the recovery independently, a representative of the airline should always be on site. This can be
the aircraft operator of the damaged aircraft, the owner of the aircraft or a representative chosen
by him. In addition, the specific Aircraft Recovery Manual of the type of Aircraft involved in the
accident, as well as the load sheet for the flight involved in the accident, should be made available
to the recovery leader of the FKB.
In addition, each aircraft operator should establish a core team that is responsible for all possible
aircraft recovery cases. The recovery team of the FKB - in case the recovery is fully or partially
carried out by the FKB - deploys the recovery equipment specific to the aircraft, which is not the
property of the FKB and is ordered separately by the FKB, on the aircraft and operates it on the
instructions of the recovery crew leader of the FKB.
Maintenance engineers and aircraft technicians are an elementary part of the airline's aircraft
recovery team and should be available on site at all times. They analyse the aircraft damage,
prepare the necessary temporary repairs and can support the recovery team with technical and
expert knowledge in the recovery case. Even in the event of recovery by the FKB, contact with
maintenance engineers and aircraft technicians must be ensured and, if required, be available to
the recovery leader, as it may be necessary, for example, for the recovery to have engines or other
parts of the aircraft dismantled by the maintenance engineers and aircraft technicians.
For the occurrence of an aircraft recovery case, the airline should maintain a recovery process
document (referred to in ICAO ASM Part 5 as the "Aircraft Recovery Process Document"). This should
describe in detail all necessary steps from the first notice of the crashed Aircraft and contain
recommendations on how to proceed with the recovery operation. On this basis, the recovery
concept is developed by the recovery leader in charge.
4 Procedural organisation
4.1 Process flow chart
On the following pages, the process flow diagram shows the work steps and the decisions to
be made during a recovery of an aircraft. It is subdivided into the following processes:
"Aircraft accident", "Recovery of Aircraft 1" and "Recovery of Aircraft 2".
Aircraft accident D M I
1) Aircraft accident
2) Alerting AF
3) Operation AF
4) if necessary: suspension of
flight operations & convene
crisis unit
BFU needed?
yes
For performing, collaboration
and information from the
alerting until beginning of
6) alert BFU process of aircraft recovery,
see Emergency Response
Planning of FKB
no
7) release of aircraft by BFU
Aircraft recovery
no necessary?
yes
End
Aircraft recovery 1 D M I
yes
yes
no
yes
no
R-L
3) Recovery carried out by FKB
R-Coor
yes yes
no
R-L
5) Settlement recovery contract no R-Coor
airline
R-Coor,
6) Start of recovery preparation R-L R-Crew CEO/CFO,
R-CL
DTM,AF
Aircraft recovery 2 D M I
R-L AF
7) Site investigation
R-Coor R-CL
CEO/CFO,
DTM,
R-CL
11) Start of recovery R-Crew R-L AL,AF,SU,
DFS,airline,
R-Coor
R-CL Fuelling
12) Weight reduction R-Crew service
R-CL Crane
13) Lifting process R-Crew company
Heavy DFS
R-CL
15) Movement process transport
R-Crew
company DTM
R-CL
17) Recovery follow-up R-Crew airline
End
Note: On the right-hand side of the process flow diagram are always the performing (D),
collaborating (M) and informing (I) parties. The abbreviations used can be found in the list of
abbreviations in the recovery manual. A rectangle stands for a work step, a rhombus for a yes/no
decision that must be made by the person carrying out the work. The function designation (e.g.
recovery leader - R-L) applies irrespective of whether the individual roles (with the exception of
FKB recovery coordinator) are provided by FKB staff, airline staff or third-party contractors.
Description: Immediately after the accident of the aircraft, the airport fire brigade is alerted
and takes over the initial operation at the aircraft. At the same time, the Duty Traffic Manager
(DTM) must decide whether flight operations must be interrupted and whether the head of the
crisis unit must be contacted in this situation.
If the accident occurred during a flight phase (including take-off and landing) or if there was an
intention to fly (e.g. in the case of a taxiing movement), the BFU must be informed immediately
of the incident so that it can begin the investigation as quickly as possible and then allow the
aircraft to be removed. If the accident occurs, for example during a towing operation, BFU does
not have to be informed of the incident.
A decision must then be made as to whether recovery is necessary: if the aircraft is unable to
move under its own power or by the normal use of a suitable aircraft tug on or next to the movement
area of the airport, the actual recovery process is initiated.
First of all, the airline must decide within 30 minutes of the accident which company will carry
out the recovery, in consultation with the FKB recovery coordinator. Subsequently, it must be
considered whether further support such as recovery equipment or personnel (possibly by third-
party companies) is necessary and the recovery contracts must be concluded on this basis (see
Chapters 4.5 and 5.2).
The further procedure for the recovery process is described in chapter 5.3.
The airline is responsible for the recovery of damaged or immobilised aircraft. It internally
appoints a person responsible for the recovery. If the airline is not able to carry out the recovery
itself, it can issue a recovery order. This order can either be given to FKB or to an external third
party. This should always be done in a written form and signed by airline or its representative. In
the case of a recovery order placed by FKB, a template for a recovery contract is kept ready; this
is available on the intranet.
If it is necessary for the handling of commercial air traffic, the aircraft may also be removed from
the flight operation areas without a special order from the aircraft holder. This requires the
approval of the management or the DTM of FKB.
In the event of a recovery of an aircraft, FKB can request assistance from third parties, provided
it has been commissioned with the recovery by the airline. These include the THW and the German
Armed Forces, which participate in the annual recovery exercises. In addition, crane companies,
catering companies, civil engineering and road construction companies, heavy transport companies,
hazardous materials disposal companies, Maintenance, Repair and Overhaul (MRO) service providers
and other companies can be commissioned by FKB to assist in the recovery process.
The measures listed here for a recovery of an aircraft do not guarantee completeness. An
individually coordinated recovery concept must be drawn up for the respective recovery event.
The recovery leader has overall responsibility for the recovery process. During the course of the
recovery, routine situation meetings are to be held, in particular between the recovery leader, the
recovery coordinator and the recovery crew leader (from FKB, airline and third party companies), in
order to ensure a constant flow of information. The recovery leader is responsible for this. At these
meetings, the current status of the recovery should be shown, problems and difficulties reported
and solutions discussed. The results of the meetings should be included in the documentation of
the recovery.
In the following, the functionaries carrying out the individual tasks are named in analogy to the
process flow diagram in chapter 5.1. The information applies regardless of whether the individual
roles (with the exception of the FKB recovery coordinator) are performed by FKB staff, airline staff
or third-party contractors.
The recovery preparation starts after the occurrence of the recovery case, the evacuation of
passengers and crew, fire fighting and the alerting of the BFU, the police and the public
prosecutor's office. The recovery preparation starts as soon as airlines have communicated who
will carry out the recovery and usually have concluded the recovery contract.
The operational command is to be set up in the immediate vicinity of the operation site.
The planning of the required number of persons in the recovery crew is to be carried out,
including the organisation of the release from the actual activity of the employees.
The recovery team (especially the recovery crew leader) is to be instructed in the recovery
concept by the recovery leader.
The recovery crew shall be divided into appropriate groups and, if necessary, their respective
replacements shall be organised.
The supply and care of the recovery crew must be organised.
The recovery equipment and the communication equipment must be assembled or ordered from
other sources (e.g. third party companies).
The necessary technology, auxiliary materials and additional personnel in accordance with the
recovery concept must be rented or ordered.
The recovery is carried out by the recovery crew according to the previously prepared recovery
concept. The recovery leader is responsible for the overall execution of the recovery and the
associated work safety of all involved.
The recovery route must be prepared by removing obstacles, preparing the ground, levelling
the ground, cordoning off the recovery route and securing media routes.
The destination and the route are to be chosen in such a way that the transport process can
proceed as quickly as possible and without obstacles (if necessary, use the parking position
of an a/c).
The subsoil conditions (especially media routes) as well as the existence of sufficient free
spaces between all parts of the transport vehicle and the ground must be taken into account
during the movement process.
The a/c is moved using towing vehicles,
a) by towing with a push-back and securing vehicles or
b) by using slings on the landing gear. In any case, a brake vehicle must be used to
secure the truck against unintentional rolling.
Continuous, uninterrupted transport to the destination must be ensured.
The entire recovery operation must be documented in detail by the recovery leader or a responsible
person appointed by him. All measures taken to implement the recovery concept must be
documented chronologically.
Further components of the documentation of a recovery are the classification of the recovery case
in the recovery matrix, the resulting recovery concept, the number of persons involved in the
recovery, the recovery equipment used, meeting protocols (also of the final meeting), the detailed
description of the recovery procedure and the final report. In addition, the documentation must
include all damage to the aircraft, infrastructure and equipment that can only be recognised after
the recovery.
In addition, the essential work steps must be documented photographically. It should be ensured
that the documentation meets the requirements for sufficient preservation of evidence on the
condition of the a/c before the next work step. The recovery leader is also responsible for
appointing a person responsible for the photographic documentation.
All documentation material of the recovery of the aircraft is to be made available to the FKB
afterwards in the event that the airline (or a third party company commissioned by it) carries out
the recovery. Conversely, FKB also hands over its entire recovery documentation to the airline if
FKB recovers the aircraft.
Annex
Contact person for recovery of aircraft by FKB
If the FKB is commissioned to carry out the recovery, the on-call recovery leader
must be notified.
Contact persons
Contact person