Cash Flow Analysis
Cash Flow Analysis
7.0 OBJECTIVES
The objectives of this unit are to:
explain importance of cash flow statement for investors and other
stockholders;
compare the differences between cash flow statement with other financial
statements;
explain regulations relating to preparation of cash flows;
familiar with the methodology for preparation of cash flow statement
and different components of cash flow statement; and
comprehend how cash flow statement can be used in real life for different
decision making.
7.1 INTRODUCTION
The statement of cash flows, required by the Accounting Standard-3, is a major
development in accounting measurement and disclosure because of its relevance
to financial statement users. Cash Flow Statement is reasonably simple and easy
to understand. It is also difficult to fudge or manipulate the cash flow numbers
and hence often used as a way to test the real profitability of the firm. For
instance, if your company approaches a bank for a loan, your company will
82 normally highlight the profitability of your business as your strength. But the
bank
manager may not be sure how you arrived at the profit, particularly when we read Cash Flow
Analysis
lot of accounting related scams. Hence, the bank manager would like to examine
whether you have actually earned the profit or not. Cash Flow Statement will be
useful to examine whether the profits are realised and if so, to what percentage of
profit a firm has realised. In other words, a company that shows high level of
profit need not be liquid in cash. Suppliers of goods will also be interested to
examine the cash flow position of the company before supplying goods on credit.
Investor, who have no control on management, will also be interested in
examining the cash flow to supplement her/his analysis on profitability of the
business.
Activity 1
1) Before you read further, can you think about why profit reported in P&L
account might be misleading? Can you think about some examples of
how profit can be overstated?
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
2) If you have identified some examples, can you think about why companies
resort to do such things and also how you can find out if you are an outsider?
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
1) Harold Williams (the then chairman of the SEC) made the following
comments in a speech to the Financial Executives Research Foundation:
Banks lend cash to their clients, collect interest in cash, and require debt
repayment in cash. Nothing less, just cash. Financial statements,
however, usually are prepared on an accrual basis, not on a cash basis.
And projections? Same thing. Projected net income, not projected cash
income. Yet, cash repays loans. Therefore, we are compelled to shift
our focus if we truly wish to assess our client’s ability to pay interest and
repay debt. We must turn our attention to cash, working through the
roadblocks thrown up by accrual accounting, to properly evaluate the
creditworthiness of our client. (RMA Uniform Credit Analysis,
Philadelphia, Robert Morris Associates, 1982).
84
Activity 2 Cash Flow
Analysis
1) Pick up annual report of a company and show the Balance Sheet and Profit
and Loss account to your non-accounting friends. Ask them how comfortable
in reading the two statements and record their observation here.
...........................................................................................................................
...........................................................................................................................
...........................................................................................................................
...........................................................................................................................
2) Now, show the Cash Flow statements to them and ask them whether they are
able to understand anything better about the company. Record their statements
here.
...........................................................................................................................
...........................................................................................................................
...........................................................................................................................
...........................................................................................................................
3) Examine the above two and record your overall assessment whether there is
any improvement in their understanding.
...........................................................................................................................
...........................................................................................................................
...........................................................................................................................
...........................................................................................................................
Activity 3
1) Visit some of the web sites of large Indian companies, which have also
issued American Depository Receipts (ADR). From the web sites, download
the P&L account as per Indian Accounting Standards and also P&L account
drawn under US accounting standards (called US GAAP). Compare the two
statements and then briefly write your overall observations.
............................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................
2) Why do you feel that the two figures are different? List down some of the
dominant reasons.
............................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................ 87
Analysis of Financial
3) Now, you check the cash flow statement reported under two systems and list.
Statements
............................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................
The effect of cash purchases in computing cash from operations can be calculated
as follows:
Account Format
The cash flow statement can also be prepared in an account form starting with an
opening balance of cash on its debit side and ending with the closing balance of
cash on its credit side as shown below:
Account Form of
Cash Flow Account for the year ending.........
Rs. Rs.
To Opening Cash Balance ...... By Redumption of Preference Shares...
To Cash from Operations ...... By Redumption of Debentures ......
To Issue of Shares ...... By Repayment of Long term Loans ......
To Long term Loans ...... By Purchase of Fixed Assets ......
To Sale of Fixed Assets ...... By Payment of Tax ......
By Payment of Dividends ......
By Cash Balance (closing) ......
(Balancing figure)
92
Cash Flow
7.6 REGULATIONS RELATING TO CASH Analysis
FLOW STATEMENT
Accounting standards in India are formulated by the Accounting Standards Board
(ASB) of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI). Though
International Accounting Standard Committee has revised the International
Accounting Standard-7 (IAS-7) in 1992 and switched over to cash flow statement,
Accounting Standard-3 (AS-3) of ASB, which is equivalent to earlier IAS-7, was not
revised till 1997. In 1997, ASB of ICAI revised the AS-3 in line with revised IAS-7
and issued an accounting standard on reporting cash flow information (see AS-3 full
text given in http://www.icai.org.). However, this standard was not been made
mandatory immediately in 1997. However, AS-3 was made mandatory for the
accounting period starting on or after 1st April 2001 for the following enterprises:
Since ASB of ICAI took a long time for the introduction of cash flow statement,
the SEBI had formed a group consisting of representatives of SEBI, the Stock
Exchanges, ICAI to frame the norms for incorporating Cash Flow Statement in the
Annual Reports of listed companies. The group has recommended cash flow
statement to be supplied by listed companies. SEBI, following the
recommendation of the group, has instructed the Governing Board of all the Stock
Exchanges to amend the Clause 32 of the Listing Agreement as follows:
“The company will supply a copy of the complete and full Balance Sheet, Profit
and Loss Account and the Directors Report to each shareholder and upon
application to any member of the exchange. The company will also give a Cash
Flow Statement along with Balance Sheet and Profit and Loss Account. The
Cash Flow Statement will be prepared in accordance with the Annexure
attached hereto”.
Cash Flow Statement, as a requirement in the Listing Agreement, has been made
effective for the accounts prepared by the companies and listed entities from the
financial year 1994-95. Cash Flow Statement, as a requirement of the Listing
Agreement, has been made effective for the accounts prepared by the companies
listed in stock exchanges from the financial year 1994-95.
Activity 4
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
93
Analysis of Financial
2) Download the cash flow statement of a company (visit the web site) for two
Statements
years and read the statement carefully. Write your observation whether the
benefits stated in the AS-3 is actually true.
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
B. Cash flow from investing activities B. Cash flow from investment activities
Purchase of fixed assets Sale of fixed Purchase of fixed assets
assets Acquisition of companies Purchase Proceeds from sale of fixed assets Investment in
of investments Sale of investments Interest subsidiaries Investment in trade investment
Received Dividend Received Loans and Advances Taken/(returned) Current
Net cash used in investing activities investments made Interest/Dividend Received
Net cash used in investing activities
C. Cash flows from financing activity Proceeds from C. Cash flows from financing activity Proceeds from
issue of share capital Proceeds from long-term issue of share capital Proceeds from long-term
borrowings(net) Repayment of financial lease liabilities borrowings Repayment of Loans
Dividend paid Dividend paid
Net Cash used in financing activities Net Cash used in financing activities
Net Increase in cash & cash equivalents Net Increase in cash & cash equivalents
Direct Method
Under Direct method, the difference between cash receipts from customers and
cash paid to suppliers and other operating expenses represents ‘‘cash generated
from operations’’. Both cash receipts from customers and cash paid to suppliers
and operating expenses can be calculated as follows:
Cash receipts from customers :
Cash sales during the year xxx
Credit sales during the year xxx
Add : Sundry debtors at the beginning ... xxx
" Bills receivable at the beginning ... xxx 95
Analysis of Financial
Statements Less : Sundry debtors at the xxx
end ... xxx xxx
" Bills
Cash receipts from thereceivable
Customersat the xxx
Cash paid to Suppliers and employees
Cost of goods sold xxx
Operating expenses xxx xxx
Add : Sundry creditors at the beginning ...
Bills Payable at the beginning ...
Outstanding expenses at the beginning ...
Stock at the end ...
Prepaid expenses at the end ... xxx
xxx
Less: Sundry Creditors at the end ...
Bills Payable at the end ...
Stock at the beginning ...
Prepaid expenses at the beginning ... xxx
Cash paid to Suppliers and employees xxx
Under direct method all non-cash transactions such as depreciation, goodwill,
preliminary expenses, discount on shares and/or debentures etc. and loss or profit
on sale of assets and investments are to be ignored as these are non-cash
transactions. Similarly, non-operating income such as income from interest and
dividends are not to be considered.
The cash flows associated with extraordinary items like bad debts recovered,
insurance claim received, loss of stock by fire, earthquake etc., cash flows from
interest and dividends received and paid should be disclosed separately.
Cash flow from operating activities is computed under the following heads using
a set of equation listed against each.
Infosys Technologies
Cash Flow Summary Ltd . 2001-02 2000-01 1999-00
Cash and Cash Equivalents at Beginning of the year 577.74 508.37 416.66
Net Cash from Operating Activities 834.22 560.49 259.41
Net Cash Used In Investing Activities --280.23 --451.3 --146.2
Net Cash Used In Financing Activities --104.77 --39.82 --21.54
Net Inc/(Dec) In Cash And Cash 449.22 69.37 91.71
Cash And Cash Equivalents At End of the year 1,026.96 577.74 508.37
Cash Flow From Operating Activities 2002-03 2001-02 2000-01
Net Profit Before tax & Extraordinary Items 943.39 696.03 325.65
Adjustment For Depreciation 160.65 112.89 53.23
Interest(Net) --51.23 --38.47 0
Dividend Received 0 0 0
P/L on Sales of Assets --0.09 --0.09 0
P/L on Sales of Invests 0 0 0
Prov. & W/O(NET) 0 15.29 0
P/L In Forex --13.26 --20.17 0
Others --139.96 --85.18 --36.71
Op. Profit Before Working Capital Changes 899.5 680.3 342.17
Adjustment For
Trade & other Receivables --34.36 --166.2 --58.3
Inventories 0 0 0
Trade Payables --5.16 60.93 42.65
Loan & Advances --39.02 --34.72 --41.5
Direct Taxes Paid 0 0 --35.54
Cash Flow Before Extraordinary Items 820.96 540.32 249.48
Extraordinary Items
Gain on Forex Exchange Transaction 13.26 20.17 9.93 99
Net Cash Flow From Operating Activities 834.22 560.49 259.41
Analysis of Financial The first part of the table shows the summary of Cash Flows of Infosys
Statements Technologies Ltd. and the second part lists detail working of Net Cash
Flow Operating Activities. Infosys has generated Rs. 834.22 cr. during the year
2001-02 through its operation against Rs. 560.49 cr. during the previous year.
How this is comparable with the net profit figure? It is comparable for this
company since during the year 2001-02, the company reported a net profit value
of Rs. 807.96 cr. But it need not be true for other companies where the net profit
and cash from operating activities may show substantial difference. For instance,
Pentamedia Graphics Ltd. has reported a net profit of Rs. 98.75 cr. for the year
ending March 2002 whereas for the same period, its cash flow from operating
activities is a negative value of Rs. 360.88 cr. There could be several reasons for
such wide difference between the reported book profit and cash flow from
operating activities.
In the Infosys Cash Flow Statement, the first part of the adjustment is related to
removing non-cash expenses and income and the second part of adjustment is
related to impact of changes in current assets and liabilities. In the third part, cash
arising out of extraordinary items is shown separately since the profit figure of the
first line excludes such extraordinary items. In terms of relative importance, the part
one adjustments are high value. While this may be true for companies like software
where working capital is not high, the second component may be large for
manufacturing companies. For instance, the cash flow statements of Cipla Ltd. for
the year ending 2002 shows an adjustment factor of Rs. 1.25 cr. (negative) for non-
cash items against Rs. 183.13 cr. (negative) for working capital items. The
adjustments relating to extra-ordinary items is not a regular feature and in the
Cipla’s case, it has not shown any value in the last three years. An analysis of
component of the three operating items shows further insight on where the cash is
drained. A year-to-year comparison also shows how much of additional amount is
being pumped in each of these items. While such an analysis is possible with
balance sheets figures alone, an analysis on cash basis is much simpler and straight
forward without any accounting principles and policies related issues.
Increasingly, users of financial statement rely on cash flow statement for this
reason.
Activity 5
1) Collect Cash Flow from Operations of few companies and examine how is
related to Profit reported in P&L account?
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
2) Compare the each components of cash flow from operating activity over the
period and record your observations here.
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................
100
..........................................................................................................................
Cash Flow
7.9 CASH FLOW FROM INVESTING Analysis
Illustration 2 Using the P and L account and Balance Sheet given below, prepare
Cash Flow Statement both under direct and indirect method.
Profit and Loss Account for the year ended 31st March, 2005
(Rs. in thousands)
Year 2004-05 Year 2003-04
Sale 111780 98050
s 390 220
Other 41954 39010
Income 16178 12500
Cost of Goods 54038 46760
Sold
21615 18704
Selling and Administrative 101
32423 28056
Expenses
Analysis of Financial
(b) Balance Sheet as on 31st March, 2005
Statements
(Rs. in thousands)
Liabilities and Shareholder Equity As on 31-3-05 As on
Equity Share Capital Retained 180000
Earnings Current Liabilities Accounts 134045
Payable Income Tax Payable
Dividend Payable 3526
21615
----
Total Liabilities 339186
Assets
Fixed Assets 393000 (370000) Less:
Depreciation 92400 (90000) Current Assets 300600
Cash
Accounts Receivable: 20064 6380
Less: Provision - (972) Inventory : Raw
Materials 19092
Finished Good 516
Investments 598
12000
Total Assets 339186
Solution
Cash Flow Statement Under Direct Method (Rs. in thousands)
Illustration 3
Prepare a Cash Flow Statement from the following information under both Direct
method and Indirect method:
Balance Sheet as on 31.12.2005
(Rs. in 000)
Liabilities 2005 2004 (Rs.) (Rs.) Assets 2005 2004 (Rs.) (Rs.)
Profit and loss account for the period ending Dec. 31, 2005
(Rs. in 000)
Rs. Rs.
To Cost of Sales 52,000 By Sales 61,300
Cash flow statement is very useful to the financial management. It is used as a tool for
financial analysis for short term planning.
The preparation of cash flow statement has several uses. The more important uses
are as follows:
1) Changes in cash balance between two points of time and the contributing factors
for such change are clearly revealed.
2) The cash flow statement explains the reasons for:
i) the presence of very low cash balance inspite of huge operating profits: or
ii) the presence of a higher cash balance inspite of a very low level of profits
3) Projected cash fow statements help the management in short-term planning and
several other ways like:
i) Determination of additional cash requirements during a given period
and making timely arrangements
ii) Identification of the size of surplus and the time for which such
surplus funds are likely to be available
iii) Judging the ability of the firm to repay/redeem debentures/preferences
shares.
iv) Examining the possibility of maintaining/increasing dividends
v) Assessing the capability of finance, replacement of fixed assets
vi) Assessing the capacity of the firm to finace expansion.
vii) More efficient and effective management of cash flows.
iii) Rs. 10,000 were written off for Goodwill during the year.
iv) Bonds of Rs. 12,000 were paid during the course of the year. You are required
to prepare a Cash Flow Statement.
(Ans. Cash from Operations Rs. 28600, Sources Rs. 36,600,
Applications 39,000)
110
Cash Flow
9) From the following Balance Sheets of Alfa Ltd., prepare Cash Flow Statement Analysis
under both the methods:
Liabilities 2004 2005 Assets 2004 2005
Note: Machinery costing Rs. 40,000 (accunulated depreciation Rs. 10,000) was sold
for Rs. 35,000
(Ans. : Cash from Operation Rs. 55,000)
13) Extracts of Balance Sheets of Messers Beta Company Ltd. are given below:
Liabilities 31.12.03 31.12.04 Assets 31.12.03 31.12.04
Rs. Rs. Rs. Rs.
Additional information
The profits for the year ended 31.12.2004 amounted to Rs. 48,000 before charging
depreciation & taxation. During the year 500 share were issued at Rs. 20 each. Interim
dividend paid during the year Rs. 6,950. Prepare cash flow statement.
Additional Information:
i) Depreciation on Plant Rs.10,000
ii) Gain on Sale of Building Rs. 20,000
[Fund from Operation , Rs. 1,63,000, Cash from Operation Rs. 1,15,000 Cash
Inflow Rs. 2,80,000; Cash Outflow Rs. 2,62,000]
16) You are given the following Balance Sheets of International company Ltd., for
the years ending 31st December, 2002 and 2003.You are required to prepare a
Cash Flow Statement under i) Direct Method and ii) Indirect Method for the year
ended 31st December, 2003.
Equity Share Capital 4,00,000 6,00,000 Machinery (at cost) 2,00,000 2,60,000
Additional Information :
i) Dividend paid @ 8% on share capital during 2003.
ii) Investments costing Rs. 40,000 were sold in 2003 for Rs. 50,000.
iii) Machinery costing Rs. 18,000 on which Rs. 2,000 depreciation has been accumu-
lated , was sold for Rs. 12,000 in the year 2003.
Prepare Cash Flow Statement for the year 2003 as per AS -3
[ Ans. Net Increase in Cash and Cash Equivalent : Rs. 40,000]
18) On the basis of the information given in the Balance Sheet of ABC Ltd. prepare
a Cash Flow Statement
Liabilities 2003 2004 Assets 2003 2004
Note : These questions will help you to understand the unit better. Try to write
answers for them. But do not submit your answers to the University. These
are for your practice only.
115