Business Ethics Notes For Students 1
Business Ethics Notes For Students 1
Ethico-moral actions pertain to a set of actions engineered by the characters and expressed
through behavior.
Definitions
Ethics is a concept of right and wrong behavior defining for us when our actions are moral
and when immoral.
What is?
Values are our measures of importance, whereas ethics represent our judgments about
right and wrong. The close relationship between importance and right and wrong is a
powerful influence on our behavior and how we evaluate the behavior of others.
Morality:
Principles: Natural laws in the human dimension that are just as real, just as
unchanging, as laws such as gravity are in the physical dimension
They are the laws of the universe that pertain to human relationships and
organizations.
Examples of principles
Fairness
Equity
Justice
Integrity
Honesty
Trust
Excellence
Justice
Human potential
People who recognize basic principles move toward survival and stability on the one hand or
disintegration and destruction on the other.
Principles unlike values are objective and external. They operate in obedience to
natural laws, regardless of condition
Values are our measures of importance, whereas ethics represent our judgments about right
and wrong. The close relationship between importance and right and wrong is a powerful
influence on our behavior and how we evaluate the behavior of others.
Types of Ethics
PERSONAL ETHICS
SOCIAL ETHICS
RELIGIOUS ETHICS
PROFESSIONAL ETHICS
BUSINESS ETHICS
GLOBAL ETHICS
ENVIRONMENTAL ETHICS
These are the principles we try to instill in our children, and expect of one another without
needing to articulate the expectation or formalize it in any way.
Benevolence
Trustworthiness
Preventing harm
These principles are woven into the fabric of every civilized society and constitute the
roots of every family and institution that has endured and prospered.
• Most people want to maintain a clear conscience and would like to act ethically under
normal circumstances
• It is natural for people to ensure that their actions do not cause injury, whether
physical or mental to others.
Social ethics-standards that govern how members of a society are to deal with other
on issues such as fairness, justice, poverty, and the rights of the individual
Profession is a vocation or calling especially, one that involves a specific branch of advance
learning or branch of science, for example the profession of a doctor, lawyer, business
manager, etc
Professional Defined
A professional is one who is engaged in a specific activity as one’s paid occupation like a
salaried business manager who is paid for his specific skill in managing the affairs of the
business enterprise he is engaged in.
Impartiality: Objectivity
Confidentiality; trust
Global Ethics:
The concept of Global Ethics proposes that there exists a common base of universal values
Global justice
Environmental stewardship
Environmental ethics is the studies of moral relationship of human beings to, and
also the value and moral status of, the environment and its non-human contents
Business Ethics
Definitions:
A set of moral rules that govern how businesses operate, how business decisions are
made and how people are treated.
Business Ethics implies the good or bad, right or wrong behavior, in pursuing
business, determined on the basis of expected behavior approved by the society.
E.g. Charging reasonable prices, just and fair treatment to workers, earning a
legitimate profit, providing a good environment to employees, etc
Business ethics is the study of proper business policies and practices regarding
potentially controversial issues, such as corporate governance, insider trading,
bribery, discrimination, corporate social responsibility and fiduciary responsibilities.
Business ethics means to conduct business with a human touch in order to give
welfare to the society
Ethics deals with what is right or wrong. Business ethics is nothing but an application
of ethical judgments to business activitiesBusiness ethics is that set of principles or
reasons which should govern the conduct of business whether at the individual or
collective level
Ethics can be described as philosophy in action and business ethics is the application
of ethical principles in business
Business ethics is not just related to an individual but to the whole organization. Any
business, operating in a society, has a moral responsibility of contributing to society
in terms of welfare schemes and projects
Business ethics promotes good business by generating support both within and
outside the organization. It is not about morality but about the establishment of
transparent norms of relationship in an organization
Though all religions preach high ethical/moral standards, generally, they do not address all
the types of problems people face today. E.g. cybercrimes and environment related issues are
totally new in the context of most religions
A good legal system may incorporate many moral/ethical standards. But there are several
instances where law deviates from what is ethical. Legal systems many vary from society to
society depending upon the social, cultural and religious beliefs.
Ethics: a set of moral principles or values that governs the conduct of an individual or group.
- Rule of law and rule of ethics may demand the same response.
- Law may permit an act that is ethically wrong.
- Law may demand certain conduct, but person's ethical standards are contrary.
The English adage, “When in Rome do as the Romans do” leads to an unethical behavior.
Some cultures are ethical, but many others are not.
Ethics is prescriptive, offers reasons for how humans ought to act under such situations
Our ethical choices are based on our feelings. Most of us feel bad when we indulge in
something wrong. But many especially hardened criminals may feel good when they do
something bad
Values are almost always oversimplified, so cannot be applied uniformly. Values tend to be
under-defined, situational by nature and subject to flawed human reasoning thus by
themselves, they cannot assure true ethical conduct
1. Religion: One of the oldest fundamentals of ethical standards. All religions talks about the
nature of right and wrong in business and in life. Fundamentally, they all operate on the
principle of reciprocity towards ones fellow beings! all of them are in agreement on the
fundamental principles
2. Culture: The culture that an individual has to follow pertaining to certain guidelines
prevalent in the society to which he belongs to. The culture implies the rules, standard, values
that are transmitted from generations to generations.
3. Law/ Legal System: Laws are rules of conduct formulated by the legal system of the state
that guide human behavior in any society. They codify ethical expectations and keep
changing when new evil emerges. But laws cannot cover all ethical expectations in society.
A code of ethics/professional conduct outlines the ethical principles that govern decisions and
behavior at a company. They give general outlines of how employees should behave, specific
guidance for handling issues like harassment, conflicts of interest.
Code of ethics deals with a range of issues including, but not limited to, the following:
Bribery Corruption and Illegal Conduct – This refers to issues where there are
allegations that criminal conduct has occurred
Discrimination – This is to ensure that company policies and, to the extent necessary,
the law, is complied, and that people are treated fairly and equally regardless of age,
gender, race, marital status, sexual orientation or any other head of power set out in the
code of ethics or indeed in the relevant legislation that may apply in the jurisdictions where
the company may do business
Conflicts of Interest – This is where you declare any relationships or situations which
would impede your capacity to act properly on behalf of the company. For example,
does your brother work for a client company?
Acceptance of Gifts – The Code of Ethics sets out guidelines by which you can accept
gifts from people as an officer of the company. Usually gifts above a particular value
set out by the Code of Ethics must be declared.
Social Responsibility – This refers to the company policies and their desire to be good
corporate citizens in their country of origin and internationally
Protection of Assets – This usually refers to issues surrounding protection of the
intellectual property held by the company
Impartiality- a manager should look at and treat all aspects of an issue in a fair and
unprejudiced manner Responsiveness to both public and shareholders interest should
be paramount to Managers.
Honesty-A cardinal ethical value that a manager should possess is honesty. Managers
should be fair, just and sincere. They should not indulge in cheating or stealing and
should be free of deceit and untruthfulness
Code of Conduct
A code of conduct is a way for management to say what the culture of the
organization should be how employees should act and how they shouldn't act
Ethics and values should form the basis of code of conduct that ought to govern the
behavior of business managers. In the exercise of their duties and responsibilities,
managers should observe the following:
In many organizations, employees must meet standards of professional behavior as a
condition of employment. These standards help an organization create a respectful
working environment for everyone.
Organizations provide a code of conduct to explain which behaviors are and are not
permitted by employees. Employees can be required to acknowledge this code by
signing an agreement upon employment.
ETHICAL THEORIES
Ethical theories are the rules and principles that determine right and wrong for a given
situation.
They are meant to help us figure out what actions are right and wrong
General Principle:
Of all the things a person might do at any moment, the morally right action is the one
with the overall best consequences (Internet encyclopedia of philosophy)
Whether an act is right or wrong depends only on the results of that action.
• The more good an act produces, the better or more right that action is.
Types of consequentialists/teleological
“After assessing the best we can, the likely results for each action, not just in the short
term but in the long run as well, we are to choose the course of conduct that brings
about the greatest net happiness.” (Shaw, 2011)
Business Ethics
A person looks to an outside source or a central figure for ethical rules or commands.
- This maybe a book or a person.
- Critics argue that ethical fundamentalism does not permit people to determine right and wrong for
themselves.
- Utilitarianism-Utilitarianism- A person must choose the action or follow the rule that provides
the greatest good to society.
+ Origins in works of Bentham and Stuart
- It has been criticized because:
+ It is difficult to estimate the "good" that will result from different actions.
+ It is hard to apply.
+ it treats morality as an impersonal calculation
Freedom
Knowledge
Life
Pleasure
Political right
Corollaries
The more good consequences an act produces, the better or more right that is.
The general principle of utility does not provide a rule to decide on the moral worth of
an action in face of actual consequences and foreseen consequences. We should do
what we have most reason to believe will bring about the best consequences of the
known available alternatives.
Egoism-The correct moral action is the one that meets the self-interest of individuals.
gain.
It is the view that our fundamental moral obligation is to maximize pleasure or happiness.
2. Non-Consequentialist-Normative theory
Any ethical theory which bases its moral judgment not on the
agent’s character.
Types of non-consequentialists:
Main Corollaries
This moral universal reason is “the Good Will” (The power of rational moral choice)
The Good Will is good because it motivates us to act out of duty, not on inclination,
desire or personal interest/gain
The Good Will makes us act according to the moral law and in order to know it, it
must check if it conforms to the categorical imperative
Formula of Universal law: Act as if the maxim of your action were to secure through
your will a universal law of nature
Formula of Humanity: Act so that you treat humanity, whether in your own person
or that of another, always as an end and never as a means only
Question to ask, “Would we want everyone to make the same decision we did?” If the
answer is “no”, then we have made the wrong choice
For Kant, ethics is based on reason alone and not on human nature.
The core idea of his categorical imperative is that an action is right if and only if we
can will it to become a universal law of conduct.
NON-CONSEQUENTIALIST-DEONTOLOGICAL-ROSS
W.D. Ross-There is several prima facie duties that we can use to determine what
concretely we ought to do.
A prima facie duty is a duty that is obligatory other things being equal. I.e. unless it is
over ridden by another duty or duties.
When there is a prima facie duty to do something, there is a fairly moral reason in
favor of doing it.
Example of prima facie is the duty to keep promises unless stronger moral
considerations overrides, one ought to keep a promise made.
By contrast with prima facie duties, our actual/concrete duty is the duty we should
perform in the particular situation of choice. Whatever one’s actual duty is, one is
morally bound to perform it.
The Agent’s virtue: The central moral concept is that of the morally good character or
morally good disposition
Virtue ethics: morally correct actions are those undertaken by actors with virtuous
characters. Therefore the formation of character is the first step toward morally correct
behavior. (Crane and Matten 2010)
Virtue ethics highlight the role of the person or actor in the ethical decision making. They
argue that individuals with high moral character are more likely to make wise ethical choices.
To identify the virtues that make up the character of this ethical prototype
The virtuous person exhibits the joint excellence of reason and character. He/she not only
knows what the good thing to do is, he/she is also emotionally attached to it. These virtues
are also intimately connected.
Ethical relativism- morality is relative to the norms of one's culture. That is, whether
an action is right or wrong depends on the moral norms of the society in which it is
practiced. The same action may be morally right in one society but be morally wrong
in another. E.g. premarital sex
Right and wrong are determined by what one’s society says is right and wrong.
No criterion of right and wrong by which to judge other than that of a particular
society. What morality requires is relative to society. (Shaw, 2011). There are no
moral absolutes
If ethical relativism is correct, there can be no common framework for resolving moral
disputes or for reaching agreement on ethical matters among different members of different
societies
A person must decide what is ethical based on his or her own feelings as to what is right or wrong
Critics argue that actions widely regarded as unethical would be seen as ethical under this theory
depending on perpetrator’s viewpoint
It undermines any moral criticism of other societies as long as their actions conform
to their own standards
There is no such thing as ethical progress. Moralities can change, but they cannot get
better or worse.
“Postmodernists reject the idea that there are universal, transcultural standards, such
as the laws of logic or principles of inductive inference, for determining whether a
belief is true or false, rational or irrational, good or bad.”
With postmodern ethical system, the first point one must think of is a system that says
there is no unified approach to understanding what is and is not ethical.
What they think is right and wrong in a particular situation. (Crane and Matten 2010).
There is no way to say that anything is right or wrong.
Post Modern ethics emphasizes the following in terms of ethical reasoning and
analysis :
Analytical Approaches
Ethical analysis is a systematic approach to figuring out the right moral decision
in a particular situation. By analyzing the situation logically, in accordance with
your ethical code, you can figure out which options are both effective and moral.
Morality is relative -a system for helping humans stay happy and alive.
The fundamental task of ethics is not to discuss substantive moral questions and to
seek solutions for them, but to examine the meaning of moral terms such as “good”,
“duty” “right”, “ought” and to make them as clear and precise as possible.
Whatever a social group decides is right is right and whatever it decides is wrong is
wrong –
there is nothing "above" the group to which we can appeal in order to challenge those
standards.
BUSINESS ETHICAL THEORIES
No one theory can stand on its own. The theory that is presented by one school of thoughts is
not sufficient or practical enough in overcoming a multitude of moral problems which exist in
real life situation
In this arrangement, managers (including Board of Directors) act as agents for shareholders.
The core concept is that the ultimate objective of a company is to maximize wealth for
shareholders.
The only qualification on the rule to make as much money as possible is “conformity to the
basic rules of the society, both those embodied in law and those embodied in ethical custom.”
This relationship binds managers not to spend the available resources on any activity without
the authorization from their owners, regardless of any societal benefit that could be accrued
by doing so. This obviously implies that a business can have no social responsibility.
Managers have no option but to follow the dictates of their masters.
Milton Friedman asserts that “there is one and only social responsibility of business-to use its
resource and engage in the activities designed to increase its profits so long as it stays within
the rules of the game, which is to stay engaged in open and free competition without
deception or fraud.
The theory does not give the managers the opportunity to ignore ethical constraints in single-
minded pursuit of profits. The theory stresses that managers should purse profit only by all
legal non-deceptive means.
The stockholder theory is associated with a line of utilitarian argument that “One’s pursuit of
profit guided by one’s enlightened self-interest in a free market economy leads collectively to
the promotion of general interest as well.
Everyone by pursuing his/her own self interest promotes the interest of the society more
efficiently than when her/she really intends to promote it. As such it is unwarranted to expect
businesses to act directly to promote the common good
Therefore, there is no justification to make a claim that businesses “have any social
responsibilities other than to legally and honestly maximize profits of the firm.”
“Stockholders provide their capital to managers on condition that they use it in accordance to
their wishes. If the managers accept this capital and spend it on some social goals
unauthorized by the stockholders, does it not tantamount to a clear breach of the agreement?”
A stakeholder is any person/group which can affect/be affected by the actions of business.-
employees, customers, suppliers, creditors, competitors, wider community.
According to the stakeholder theory, a company must consider the interests of all
stakeholders when making business decisions. Consistent with stakeholder approach,
organizations are not only accountable to their shareholders but should also consider the
contrasting interest of all other stakeholders that can affect or be affected by the achievement
of organization‟s objective
Corporations should pursue wealth with a long run orientation that seeks sustainable growth
and profits based on responsible attention to the full range of stakeholders’ interest.
It focuses on generating stakeholder value, while having regard to the long term external
impact of the wealth generation.
Social contract theory is the view that persons' moral and/or political obligations are
dependent upon a contract or agreement among them to form the society in which
they live. It is a way for managers to take decisions in an ethical context.
Thus in addition to their profit maximization interest, organizations also display that
tendency to consider societal interest by taking on a massive responsibility for the
impact of their activities on employees, customers, suppliers, stakeholders and local
communities in which they operate not forgetting their environmental obligations as
well. The importance of considering societal prosperity is because it positively
impacts organizations prosperity.
The real objective behind this development of theories is to create companies, which
are sustainable and economically, ethically and socially responsible.
To give people the tools for dealing with moral complexities in business
To hold a company and its employees accountable for their actions as they affect
others. It keeps businesses and professionals mindful of the consequences of their
actions so that they can pursue success responsibly.
To manage behavior that cannot be covered by governmental laws. There are many
actions which, while they are legal, are also detrimental to certain groups such as
employees.
Having a code of ethics can encourage employees to stay honest and steer clear of
potentially illegal behavior.
It enhances the company's core values, beliefs and sets the right culture
To hold a company and its employees accountable for their actions as they affect
others. This includes both internal and external behavior. It keeps businesses and
professionals mindful of the consequences of their actions so that they can pursue
success responsibly.
To demonstrate behavior that is the current norm. Actions that were acceptable in the
past can become inappropriate in later years and vice versa.
To keep the business honest. While many unethical behaviors are not illegal, they can
often lead to unlawful acts. Having a code of ethics can encourage employees to stay
honest and steer clear of potentially illegal behavior.
Ensure that the power wielded by large corporations is used to good effect. As a
business expands, opportunities for corruption also grow.
With a good code of conduct, a company can work to repair possible damage caused
by its success and even work proactively to help others.
To provide a critique of the process of value formation in organizations and in the free
market economy
Assignment Questions
1.