10.1201 b12416 Previewpdf
10.1201 b12416 Previewpdf
Editors
Donald P.Albert
Wilbert M.Gesler
Barbara Levergood
The editors would like to express their appreciation to Lesa Strikland with Medical
Media, VA Medical Center (Durham, North Carolina), Department of Veterans
Affairs for her assistance in scanning figures and maps.
About the Authors
This book is an expression of the myriad ways in which the range of geospatial
methods and technologies can be applied to the analysis of issues related to human
and environmental health. Since the study and management of the many diverse
issues related to human health is one of the most important aspects of human
endeavor it is not surprising that it has been a fruitful area for application of geo-
spatial analysis tools. Contributions to this book run the gamut of these diverse
applications areas from more classical medical geography to the study of infectious
disease to environmental health. The tools used in these studies are also diverse–
ranging from GIS as a core and unifying technology to geo-spatial statistics and the
computer processing of remotely-sensed imagery.
This book should prove useful for practitioners and researchers in the health care
and allied fields as well as geographers, epidemiologists, demographers, and other
academic researchers. Today one sees a continual increase in the power and ease of
use of GIS, better integration and easier availability of related technologies, such as
remote sensing and global positioning systems and rapidly falling costs of platforms,
peripherals, and programs. Thus, one now sees an increasingly large cadre of users
of geo-spatial technology in all fields, including health related ones. The methods and
examples provided in this work are a starting point for this growing group of users
who will find the power of spatial analysis tools and the increasing availability of
data sources to enable them to obtain answers and to arrive at solutions to a host of
critical health care related issues. The tools and knowledge are readily available and
the skills can be developed by any dedicated user; therefore, what direction users of
GIS in health related fields choose to take this and related technologies is now
primarily limited by their imaginations.
Dr. Mark R.Leipnik, Ph.D.
Director GIS Laboratory,
Texas Research Institute for
Environmental Studies,
Assistant Professor,
Department of Geography and Geology,
Sam Houston State University
Huntsville, Texas
Contents
1. Introduction 1
D.P.Albert, W.M.Gesler, B.Levergood, R.A.Fellers, and J.P.Messina
2. How Spatial Analysis Can be Used in Medical Geography 10
W.M.Gesler and D.P.Albert
3. Geographic Information Systems: Medical Geography 38
D.P.Albert, W.M.Gesler, and P.S.Wittie
4. Geographic Information Systems in Health Services Research 55
D.P.Albert, W.M.Gesler, and R.D.Horner
5. GIS-Aided Environmental Research: Prospects and Pitfalls 77
R.A.Fellers
6. Infectious Disease and GIS 111
D.P.Albert
7. A Historical Perspective on the Development of Remotely Sensed Data as 128
Applied to Medical Geography
J.P.Messina and K.A.Crews-Meyer
8. The Integration of Remote Sensing and Medical Geography: Process and 147
Application
J.P.Messina and K.A.Crews-Meyer
9. Conclusions 177
D.P.Albert, W.M.Gesler, and B.Levergood
Master GIS/RS Bibliographic Resource Guide 178
D.P.Albert, B.Levergood, and C.M.Croner
Glossary 200
Subject Index 207
Geographical Index 218
Spatial Analysis, GIS,
and
Remote Sensing Applications
in the
Health Sciences
Chapter One
Introduction
Second, this chapter describes the annual output of the published research using a
basic diffusion model. The model describes stages in the rate of growth of phenomena
(i.e., output of research publications) over time. The progression is one that follows
from innovation, early majority, late majority, and laggard stages of the diffusion
process. Finally, this chapter outlines the organization of the volume; included also is
a brief abstract of each chapter.
DEFINITIONS
This volume limits its review of research to studies that have interfaced
geotechniques (spatial analysis, geographical information systems, and remote
sensing) with health and disease topics. Although two of the editors and several of
the contributing authors are medical geographers, studies summarized in this
volume emanate not only from medical geography, but also biostatistics,
environmental health, epidemiology, health services research, medical entomology,
public health, and other related disciplines.
Defining terms is problematic because complementary and contradictory definitions
often compete for supremacy or acceptance. Of the three geotechniques, the least
definable is GIS. One of the major critiques of GIS is the absence of a universally
accepted definition. Fortunately, the eclectic scope of this volume permits the editors
to accept the full definitional spectrum of GIS. One might view spatial analysis, GIS,
and remote sensing as converging rather than distinct techniques and technologies.
For the moment, however, note the following definitions of spatial analysis, GIS, and
remote sensing.
Geotechniques
Spatial Analysis: The study of the locations and shapes of geographic features
and the relationships between them (Earth Systems Research Institute, 1996).
Geographic Information Systems:…computer databases that store and
manipulate geographic data (Aronoff, 1989).
Remote Sensing:…imagery is acquired with a sensor other than (or in addition
to) a conventional camera through which a scene is recorded, such as by electronic
scanning, using radiation outside the normal visual range of the film and camera
–microwave, radar, infrared, ultraviolet, as well as multispectral, special
techniques are applied to process and interpret remote sensing imagery for the
purpose of producing conventional maps, thematic maps, resource surveys, etc.,
in the fields of agriculture, archaeology, forestry, geology, and others (Campbell,
1987, p. 3).
INTRODUCTION 3
Interfacing Disciplines
In recent years the use of geotechniques, especially GIS, has been diffusing into the
private and public sectors and across disciplines (e.g., city and regional planning,
transportation, government, and marketing). This is no less true for disciplines that
have health and/or disease as their foci. Some of the disciplines exploring the use of
GIS/RS include biostatistics, epidemiology, environmental health, health services
research, medical entomology, medical geography, and public health. Definitions of
these disciplines are presented below. Again, as with the definition of geographic
information systems, there exist complementary, contradictory, and competing
statements that define these disciplines. However, for the purposes of providing a
broad-based review of geomedical/ geotechnical applications, the definitions set out
below were deemed to be adequate. Each of these disciplines offers a distinct set of
knowledge, methods, and approaches; note, however, that there is a substantial
overlap among these sciences.
Together, the interface between geotechniques (spatial analysis, GIS, and remote
sensing) and some specific disciplines (biostatistics, epidemiology, environmental
health, health services research, medical entomology, medical geography, and public
health) sets our parameter limits. The intersection among the three geotechniques
4 SPATIAL ANALYSIS, GIS, AND REMOTE SENSING APPLICATIONS IN THE HEALTH SCIENCES
and seven disciplines produces a scope for this volume that is wide and inclusive
rather than narrow and exclusive.
themes operating within Chapter 5. First, each of the five infectious diseases
discussed (dracunculiasis, babesiosis, Lyme disease, LaCrosse encephalitis, and
malaria) is placed within the context of its geographic distribution and current
infection trends. Second, a comparison of variables, analyses, and conclusions across
studies is made to evaluate the divergence or convergence of research results.
Chapter 6 points to some of the problems and pitfalls of using geographic information
systems to examine environmental and public health issues. Chapter 7 uses the four
resolutions (spatial, temporal, radiometric, and spectral) of remote sensing to
analyze the contribution of satellite data in identifying and predicting risk areas for
such diseases as leishmaniasis, trypanosomiasis (sleeping sickness), shistosomiasis,
Rift Valley fever, malaria, hantavirus, Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever, Lyme
disease, and onchocerciasis (river blindness). Chapter 8 discusses the specific
processes of remote sensing and their ramifications for developing medical geography
applications.
geography and related disciplines. It documents a small but vibrant body of research
that was grappling with the introduction of GIS into the realms of health and
disease. While some scholars were optimistically urging use of this emerging
technology, others were advocating caution before jumping on the GIS bandwagon.
All the while, a handful of investigators began to develop and operationalize
applications of geographic information systems having specific foci on health and/or
disease. Such applications as emergency response, AIDS prevention, hospital service
areas, toxic air emissions, lead exposure, measles surveillance, radon risk, and
cancer clusters are highlighted.
Chapter 4, “Geography Information Systems in Health Services Research,”
outlines research contributions that explore physician locations, hospital service and
market areas, public health monitoring and surveillance programs, and emergency
response planning within the context of geographic information systems. Aronoff’s
(1989) classification of GIS functions into (1) maintenance and analysis of the spatial
data, (2) maintenance and analysis of the attribute data, (3) integrated analysis of
the spatial and attribute data, and (4) cartographic output formatting functions
provides a structure to evaluate the extent to which health services researchers have
utilized the full potential of GIS. The chapter also presents multiple definitions of
GIS and health services research, outlines some general concerns about geographic
information systems, and makes a general appraisal of the contribution of this
technology to the health of human populations.
Chapter 5, “GIS-Aided Environmental Research: Prospects and Pitfalls,” is a fairly
comprehensive review of the ways in which GIS can improve research into the
human-environment relationship, as well as the special problems investigators
encounter when they attempt to adapt this powerful analytic tool to such projects.
The chapter catalogs the elements involved in human exposure from the toxicity of
the pollutant through the ways the pollutant can change as it travels through the
environment, to the final stage of manifesting in a diagnosable health effect. Two
major groups of human-environment studies are being performed: analyses of the
impact of existing hazards, and assessments of potential hazard from proposed
industrial or residential developments in the planning phase.
Public health professionals will want to use this chapter as an aid in determining
just how credible are their data, where they might go for additional data, and why
combining data collected at different scales is risky. Not all statistical techniques are
appropriate for studies such as these, either. Most of the commonly used techniques,
such as analysis of variance and linear regression, assume that the observations
were measured without error. These techniques are easily biased by characteristics
common in the study of disease in space, such as the ways that events affect their
surrounding areas and the ways that they influence future events in the same area.
Techniques which are better able to handle these conditions without producing
biased results are reviewed, such as mixed models, multilevel models, and structural
equation modeling. Hopefully, the reader will find helpful suggestions for getting
INTRODUCTION 7
better results from ecologic studies that involve data collected at different scales,
from the individual level to the aggregate.
Chapter 6, “Infectious Disease and GIS,” reviews applications of geographic
information systems that investigate spatial aspects of dracunculiasis (Guinea worm
disease), LaCrosse encephalitis, Lyme disease, and malaria. For each infectious
disease the text follows a sequence that includes a description of disease and its
transmission chain, the geographic distribution and recent statistics, and a review of
select research using geographic information systems. A cross-comparison of
conclusions suggests that a targeted approach is more effective than broad-based
approaches in eliminating or reducing vectors and corresponding rates of infection.
These studies show the benefit of incorporating elements of human and physical
geography into GIS databases used to combat vectored diseases.
Remote sensing is the process of collecting data about objects or landscape features
without coming into direct physical contact with them. The application of remotely
sensed data and image processing techniques can seem daunting and simply too
expensive to implement. Chapters 7 and 8 are intended to take the novice remote
sensing person through the entire process. Given the nature of this book, the focus is
on the medical geography application of remotely sensed data. Chapter 7 is really the
first part of a two-chapter sequence. It is intended that this chapter provide the
framework to enable the layperson to act as an informed reader of the body of
medical geography literature utilizing remotely sensed data. As such, it contains a
brief history of remote sensing and introduces the basic vocabulary. The development
of the technology of remote sensing parallels the use of the data within medical
geography and helps to predict the direction of the discipline within the context of
future applications.
Chapter 8 is a detailed look at the application of remotely sensed data within the
existing body of medical geography literature. Each of the authors’ use of the data is
presented contextually in order to best explain the various techniques and to
promote general comprehension, not only of the remote sensing vocabulary, but also
in order to inspire ideas about how the data may be used in alternative case studies.
Chapter 8 includes a number of technique-specific insets. These insets are designed
to be more in-depth evaluations and discussions of the various methods used by the
medical geography community when applying remotely sensed data. Chapter 8 also
contains an overview of basic remote sensing terminology.
Both chapters may be reviewed independently, but of course are best understood
within the context of the whole. These chapters intentionally differ from the existing
body of medical remote sensing literature that usually follows a disease-specific
formula in describing remote sensing applications. The approach used is application-
specific rather than disease-specific in order to promote a more general
understanding of the nature of the data and associated techniques applicable to a
variety of diseases and disease vectors.
8 SPATIAL ANALYSIS, GIS, AND REMOTE SENSING APPLICATIONS IN THE HEALTH SCIENCES
The chapters are interspersed with tables and figures that represent sample output
from numerous geomedical applications of spatial analysis, GIS, and remote sensing
applications. These tables and figures have been drawn from the original source
articles with publishers’ permissions. Instructors might use this volume as a source
of illustrations useful in demonstrating geomedical applications of spatial analysis,
GIS, and remote sensing.
This volume highlights geomedical applications of spatial analysis, geographic
information systems, and remote sensing. Our aim is to describe “what” rather than
“how.” Knowing what has been done provides one with a sense of the big picture (i.e.,
current usage of geomedical GIS/RS applications). Knowing what also positions one
to be able to springboard to extend existing applications or create new geomedical
applications of spatial analysis, GIS, and remote sensing. Those requiring knowing
how should consult the original source articles. To address how would require a
detailed and technical account of data requirements and manipulations, software and
hardware specifications, and the mathematics of geotechniques. This is beyond our
scope since it is not the intent of this volume. Our reviews of particular geomedical
applications highlight studies that build upon and extend one another. This seems a
more rational approach than forcing the contents and findings of numerous and often
redundant studies under a single subject heading (e.g., malaria, sleeping sickness,
onchoceriasis). However, a master GIS/RS bibliographic reference guide includes some
400 articles that have been listed by subject.
This volume also includes a “Master GIS/RS Bibliographic Resource Guide,”
“Glossary,” and “Index.” The “Master GIS/RS Bibliographic Resource Guide” provides
over 400 references to geomedical applications. Represented within this bibliography
are citations from academic journals, trade publications, proceedings, and electronic
documents (i.e., World Wide Web). The bibliography has been arranged by subject for
the reader’s convenience.
This volume also includes a glossary of spatial analysis, GIS, and remote sensing
terminology. Here, terms from the text and other terms familiar to geoscientists are
defined. To assist in accessing information, we have included both a subject and
geographical index. We hope that combined, the appendix, bibliography, glossary,
and indices constitute valuable reference tools for tapping the full potential of this
resource guide as well as pointing to other outside sources.
A CAUTIONARY NOTE
The editors encourage readers to become grounded in the fundamental components
and dynamics of their subject (health care system or disease) prior to forging on with
geotechniques. It is important that one is knowledgeable about the basic sciences
and/or clinical findings of the particular subject under investigation. Therefore,
before diving headfirst into the realm of geomedical/technical application the
following sequence is recommended.
INTRODUCTION 9
• Know your subject. If you don’t know, find out. It is very difficult to develop a
sophisticated GIS application if you are not familiar with the health care
service or disease under question. So, depending on your subject, you might
want to become familiar with the organization, structure and dynamics of a
health management organization; the factors influencing the prevention and
transmission of diseases; the current spatial and temporal trends in disease
incidence; and even the clinical symptoms of a particular disease.
• Read sections of this volume that relate to the subject area in which you are
interested. If you need more information or more details, search the Master
GIS/RS Bibliography to locate articles on your topic. Going to the original
source often provides information as to the type of hardware, software, data,
and analyses that were used in a particular study.
• Evaluate whether some of the existing GIS/RS applications highlighted in the
text or referred to in the bibliography would be worth using or modifying for
your project or program needs. Perhaps you have ideas that might enhance
existing research. If your evaluation is affirmative, then...
• Explore the feasibility of developing your own GIS/RS capabilities (consult
Aronoff, 1989), collaborating with existing GIS/RS facilities within your
organization or system, or contracting out your project.
• Publish your results in official reports, newsletters, trade journals, and even
academic journals so that others can benefit from your experience.
REFERENCES
Aronoff, S.1989. Geographic Information Systems: A Management Perspective.Ottawa: WDL
Publications.
Campbell, J.B.1987. Introduction to Remote Sensing.New York: Guildford Press.
Dorland’s Illustrated Medical Dictionary,1985,26th ed. Philadelphia: W.B.Saunders Company.
Environmental Systems Research Institute. 1996. Introduction to ArcView GIS: Two-dayCourse
Notebook with Exercises and Training Data.Redlands, California: Environmental Systems Research,
Inc.
European Conference on Environment and Health. 1990. Environment and Health: TheEuropean
Charter and Commentary: First European Conference on Environment andHealth, Frankfurt, 7—8
December 1989.Copenhagen: World Health Organization, Regional Office for Europe.
Hunter, J.M.1974. The challenge of medical geography. In The Geography of Health andDisease: Papers
of the First Carolina Geographical Symposium,J.M.Hunter (Ed.), pp. 1—31. Chapel Hill: University of
North Carolina, Department of Geography.
Stedman, T.L.1982. Stedman’s Medical Dictionary, Illustrated,24th ed. Baltimore: Williams and
Wilkins.
White, K.L., J.Frenk, C.Ordonez, C.Paganini, and B.Starfield. 1992. Health ServicesResearch: An
Anthology.Washington, DC: Pan American Health Organization.
References
Cowen, D.J.1990. GIS versus CAD versus DBMS: What are the
differences? In Introductory Readings in Geographic
Information Systems,D.J.Peuquet and D.F.Marble (Eds.), pp.
52—61. London: Taylor & Francis.
Lee, W.T.1922. The Face of the Earth as Seen from the Air:
A Study in the Application ofAirplane Photography to
Geography.American Geographical Society Special Publication
No. 4. Washington, DC: Conde Nast Press.