First Regional Centre of Expertise Confernce Held at Kenyatta Conference Centre Nairobi, Kenya
First Regional Centre of Expertise Confernce Held at Kenyatta Conference Centre Nairobi, Kenya
NAIROBI, KENYA.
BY
NAIROBI
i
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
TABLE OF CONTENTS
2.0 REMARKS.............................................................................................................................................. 1
3.0 PRESENTATION...................................................................................................................................... 5
ii
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
iii
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
1.0 INTRODUCTION
2.0 REMARKS
Ag. Director General, NEMA
The Director was pleased to launch the Education for Sustainable Development (ESD)
Implementation Strategy and the first national conference on RCEs on Education for sustainable
development in Kenya. The theme of the conference was “RCE – Turning a Green Leaf
towards Sustainability” which was meant to urge all stakeholders to reorient all their activities
towards the achievement of sustainable development. He reiterated that the United Nations
General Assembly in December 2002, adopted resolution 57/254 that designated the period
1
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
2005-2014 as the Decade for Education for Sustainable Development. UNESCO was tasked to
spearhead the global process and develop an international implementation scheme. In Kenya,
NEMA coordinated a multi-stakeholder team that developed the national ESD implementation
strategy with the technical help from UNESCO.
The ESD implementation strategy provides a dynamic concept that addresses awareness,
education and training to enhance understanding of sustainability. The goal is to integrate the
values inherent in sustainable development into all aspects of learning to encourage changes in
behavior that promotes a more sustainable, economically viable and just society for all. It aims
to provide opportunities for all to benefit from education, value acquisition, behavior change and
lifestyles that ensure a sustainable future.
He informed the conference that ESD has achieved tremendous achievements to include policy
formulation by different institutions, public awareness and advocacy, development of ESD
materials, sensitization meetings on ESD for twenty one ministries, training of senior officers in
different ministries, carried out national survey on primary schools on ESD carried out research
and innovations to address sustainability.
The RCE conference brought together stakeholders from eight regions so as to share their
experiences, innovations and information on how best to address the sustainable development
challenges.
He urged the participants to develop solutions that can work for their specific regions. Each
RCE should learn from others and partner strongly with government, private sector, civil society
organizations and media in the sphere of sustainable development. Participants were encouraged
to build networks beyond the conference and continue to share information, innovation, best
practices and develop common research concepts for RCEs even globally. NEMA will continue
playing its role of focal point for ESD implementation and RCE coordination for any future
follow up conferences and take stock of the progress RCE is making as the ESD decade
approaches its end.
The Minister speech was read by the Permanent Secretary, MEMR. The Minister was pleased to
launch the ESD implementation strategy and open the first National Conference on the Regional
Centres for Expertise on ESD. He reiterated the 1992 UN Conference on Environment and
2
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
Development (UNCED) which recognized education as an important tool for enhancing the
attainment of sustainable development.
Kenya as a member of the UN family is obligated to observe the decade on ESD. The ministry of
Environment and Mineral Resources through NEMA developed the ESD implementation
strategy which was adopted by the National Environment Council in April 2008. The medium
term plan of vision 2030 has captured ESD as a cross cutting issue which envisions the
formulation of an ESD Policy for Kenya and the reorientation of curricula at all levels to address
ESD concerns. The constitution of Kenya has elevated environmental matters in section 67. It
states that every person has a right to a clean and safe environment and has the right to have the
environment protected for the benefit of present and future generations.
The Ministry of Environment is implementing some flagship programs within the vision 2030.
Some of the projects include waste management system that will see the decommissioning of
Dandora dump site and the establishment of a sanitary landfill, carbon offset scheme,
compensation for environmental services and streamlining of exploration and mining. The
Ministry has achieved the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) guidelines, the climate change
strategy and the e-waste guidelines.
He informed the participants that 2010 state of environment report has flagged out a number of
challenging areas that need attention to include invasive and alien species, hazardous waste, bio-
piracy, climate change and biodiversity loss. Through NEMA, the ministry has recently
launched a toll free service number, I-Call, for disseminating environmental messages. The
Ministry also launched the environmental education and awareness campaign targeting school
across the country.
3
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
The Permanent Secretary (PS) Ministry of Environment and Mineral Resources –Mr. Ali
Mohammed Launch the Kenya ESD Implementation Strategy during the conference.
The Permanent Secretary distribute the ESD implementation strategy document to RCE
Coordinators
4
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
3.0 PRESENTATION
He mentioned that a school curriculum should achieve three broad educational aims which
include acquisition of knowledge, skills, abilities or capacities; development of competencies,
i.e. the ability to apply the knowledge and skills imparted by education to real-life situations;
development of key competencies, i.e. those that are essential in order to participate effectively
within society. (Eurydice, 2002)
Bearing this in mind, he said that it was pertinent to ask three key questions
• Can science and technology education be developed with a view to playing an active role
leading to true sustainable development?
• What effects are educational institutions and NGOs expected to have during the United
Nations Decade of Education for Sustainable Development so as to play a positive role in
promoting more appropriate science and technology education (especially for sustainable
development)?
• Can educational institutions (at primary, secondary and tertiary levels) and NGOs have
the vision, strength of direction and expertise to enhance greater self-empowerment and
guide the abandoning of inappropriate 20 th century (and often 19th century) science
education practices for more suitable practices that enhance meaningful sustainable
development and by so doing, use their power to enhance greater equity and fairness in
developing scientific literacy for all?
He further mentioned that vision for the education sector in the Kenya Vision 2030 is ‘‘to have
globally competitive quality education, training and research for sustainable development’’.
Ensuring environmental sustainability is one of the goals of the United Nations Millennium
Development Goals (MDGs).
He mentioned that there is an urgent need for a number of major changes in the orientation and
development of science and technology education if it has to enhance and promote sustainable
development. Five paradigm shifts are put forward, each suggested as playing a key role in
enhancing science education for sustainable development.
• Ensuring the purpose of science education is scientific literacy (in terms of relevance,
practicality, values)
5
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
• Taking greater measures to enhance and sustain student motivation in and about science,
thus enabling science and technology education to play a role in education for sustainable
development. Science education is not and cannot be the same as science.
• Enacting more effective teacher preparation/professional development for science and
technology education and determining the role of the teachers geared to professional
development for sustainable development.
• Placing greater emphasis within student learning on an understanding of the Nature of
Science and Scientific Inquiry (Abd-El-Khalick, 2004: McComas, Almazroa & Clough,
1998; Lin and Chiu, 2004), noting their importance for the promotion of sustainable
development. Policy makers should consider what will encourage a better balance
between teaching science as established yet often irrelevant information for today’s world
and those features of science that are referred to as the Nature of Science and relate to
civil commons aspects of sustainable development.
• Recognize the crucial need for the setting up of effective partnerships. All stakeholders,
including local governments, non-governmental organizations, the industrial sector,
learned (science) societies, schools and community groups, need to participate in the
sustainable development efforts. Human resource development should focus the
development process to increase their knowledge, skills and understandings, and to
develop the attitudes needed to bring about the desired developmental change. More
efforts must therefore be undertaken to build a fair relationship between scientific and
traditional knowledge, to strengthen the capacity of communities to revitalize and
manage their own knowledge base, and to promote the integration of local knowledge,
values, traditions and practices, in sustainable development projects. National
partnerships are seen as crucial in meeting the need to ensure general support for moving
science education forward in promoting sustainable development which is seen as
essential for more responsible citizens, improved human rights, and developing a
universal culture of peace.
She mentioned that goal of the programme is to secure the ecological integrity & sustainability
of the Lake Victoria catchment for the benefit of its inhabitants & biological diversity. The
purpose is to empower catchment communities, schools and regional partners with knowledge,
motivation and abilities for sustainable use and management of natural resources. This is through
empowering of Civil Society Organizations through capacity building to ensure successful
Programme Implementation. The programme is funded by Sida and implemented in
collaboration between WWF ESARPO and WWF Sweden. The Implementing Partners in East
Africa are Kenya – Wildlife Clubs of Kenya; Uganda – Nature Uganda; Tanzania – WWF
Tanzania Country Office and Rwanda – start up activities collaborating with the government
through Rwanda Environment Management Authority and Ministry of Education.
6
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
• Working with 66 schools, and 7 primary Teacher Training Colleges in Kenya, Uganda
and Tanzania within the Lake Victoria Catchment.
• On average 95 % of targeted educators are able to coordinate and monitor ESD
programmes in model schools in Kenya and Uganda. In Tanzania 80 % have improved
monitoring & coordination of activities.
• Whole school approach has led to transformation of schools into green model schools
• LVCEEP’s capacity building in teacher training colleges has led to pre-service training of
teachers on ESD which will contribute to curriculum re-orientation towards ESD.
• Additional training on entrepreneurship and Education for Change Concept
• Mainstreaming of climate change adaptation in ESD workshops has led to increased
awareness schools and communities
• Teachers are now using Locally Relevant Themes (LORETS) to teach the school
curriculum.
• School inspectors have mainstreamed ESD in their schools assessment
• LVCEEP Schools have continued to engage in diverse greening initiatives to include tree
nurseries, woodlots, beehives, water harvesting, hand washing facilities for improved
sanitation, fish ponds and botanic gardens.
• To date 70 % of school children in Kenya & Tanzania are able to engage in
conservation activities. In Uganda 97% of ESD in schools has filtered to household
levels.
• LVCEEP Schools have received recognition during world events days and also won
awards.
• The schools have become demonstration centres and visitor centres transforming them to
centres of excellence.
• In Kenya and Tanzania 70 % of targeted communities are transferring EE /ESD learning
practices to their households. Uganda has had 97 % of this knowledge transfer to date
• In Kenya over 20,720 trees have been established in Target schools.
• In Tanzania over 3,500 seedlings planted in 3 schools have survived and doing well.
7
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
Riparian communities achieve capacity to conserve and sustainably manage natural resources
within selected sites of the Lake Victoria catchments and best practices spread in the wider area:
• On average 75 % of targeted riparian communities are engaged environmentally friendly
practices
• 75 % of targeted farmers are practicing sustainable agriculture within the catchment
area.
• 77.6 % of communities have developed a more holistic perception on environmental
management.
• Communities have been capacity built on soil conservation, organic farming and on
income generating activities that have led to poverty alleviation.
• 40,200 tree seedlings planted along riverine and shoreline of Mara River and Lake
Victoria respectively in Tanzania to mitigate Climate Change.
• In Kenya, eco-jiko adoption rates from Nandi Hills, Transmara & Homabay sites average
to 59 %.
• In Uganda there is 67% increase in income, sales & savings with households living on an
average of US$3 per day.
• 70% of communities in Kenya use clean drinking water due to rain water harvesting
• A regional ESD Day that will be celebrated annually in the East African countries was
launched in July 2010.
• The LVBC gave it official recognition during this year’s event in July 8, 2011 in
Mwanza.
• Awards were put in place;
Best farming communities
Best Eco-friendly Income Generating Activities for communities
• National Community Exchange Visits carried out. In Uganda – upstream – downstream
visits between Masaka and Kyenjojo Communities, Kenya – Nandi & Homabay; &
Transmara; Tanzania – Mara Region
• Regional Exchange Visits done communities in Tanzania visited Kenya; previously
Uganda communities visited Tanzania
8
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
• ESD Methodology Book – demystifies ESD and provides hands on ESD activities for
educators
• An ESD Toolkit for Schools in the Mara River Basin developed for use in Kenya and
Tanzania.
• A LVCEEP Programme Profile
Output 4: Networking
A practical partnership building mechanism for EE / ESD delivery within & among key
stakeholders developed
• Regional Advisory Committee – top most advisory organ for the programme
• Capacity building of Project Executants and Core Team
• Regional Network on Education for Sustainable Development for East Africa formed
during workshop held on October 2010 in Dar es Salaam. 2nd Meeting held in October
2011 in Kampala. WWF to provide secretariat until sustainability is achieved.
• Upstream – Downstream networks – Uganda we have community conservation networks
& organic farms community networks.
• Networking with other stakeholders helped communities market their goods.
Lessons Learnt
She mentioned introduction of ESD villages in Kenya will lead to social transformation and
exemplary communities of practice in ESD. While Community Conservation Banks in Tanzania
will lead to promoting a culture of saving and investing and contribute to poverty alleviation.
She further mentioned that partnerships with the Private sector e.g. the Transmara community
has led to steady income and has empowered the Maasai women who package and sell the
honey; Construction of granaries in Uganda has led to increased food security among
communities; Growing of alternative food crops like sorghum, cassava and millet in Musoma
will help the communities cope and adapt to climate change.
• Networks provide a way forward for sustaining development interventions once a donor
or development partner is not present.
• Ground level networks can be sustained by the actors if they are involved in sustainable
activities.
• National and regional networks - currently national nodes of ESD Networks in East
Africa hosted by government agencies – for sustainability.
• EAC Network for ESD Practitioners to be hosted by the East African Community –
WWF currently providing secretariat.
The programme is looking forward to working with schools to promote food security, improved
health and sanitation, Promote Sustainable Cities, celebrate Earth Hour 2012 in four cities in the
region– Nairobi, Entebbe, Mwanza and Kigali – Energy and Climate Change ,Support ESD
Policy work with National Curriculum Centres in the East African Countries, Regional ESD
Policy Workshop 2012 – East Africa Community Countries, South – South Exchange
Programme, Support ESD Network for Eastern African to achieve sustainability and Exploring
Climate Change work opportunities with communities using ESD as a strategy
She mentioned that the vision of the RCE is to ensure that Mau complex ecosystem retains its
ecological functions and sustainably provide goods and services to support livelihoods and
contribute to regional and global environmental benefits’. The mission is to ‘Facilitate a
platform for knowledge management within Mau complex for informed decision making’
The RCE has set up various Strategies to address the challenges. The immediate actions were
suggested include:
1. Raise levels of environmental awareness among the population
2. Promote marketing regional products
3. Raise production in agriculture and livestock to promote household food security
4. Address issues on climate change through appropriate climate change mitigation and
adaptation measures at household, community and regional level
5. Promote sustainable waste management in urban and rural areas
6. Promote conflict resolution / peace education in the region
10
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
RCE PWANI
RCE Pwani was established to address local sustainable development challenges in the coastal
region. The RCE is coordinated by Pwani University College. He mentioned that the principal
appointed a committee of ten officers to coordinate the programme.
He mentioned that the thematic areas include
1. Land ownership / tenure and governance
2. Environment and ecosystem management
3. Climate change and disaster management
4. Agriculture and food security
5. Health, drug and substance abuse
6. Poverty unemployment,
He mentioned that so far the RCE has set up the RCE management committee, developed a draft
policy for Pwani University, strengthened environmental club in the university, and established
an operational network in Kilifi County with the stakeholders. He further mentioned that the
RCE has undertaken various cleanup activities and tree planting and held sensitization meetings
with the university management.
He said that some of the proposed activities include sensitization workshops, initiate university/
stakeholder joint research project, to implement project proposals and register RCE with the
United Nations University (UNU).
He mentioned that the main issues of concern for the RCE are as follows:
Insufficient Environmental Awareness,
Environmental degradation,
Waste management,
Unsustainable agriculture,
Unaffordable and unsustainable energy resources,
Poor health,
Insecurity and violence,
Poor governance and corruption.
Lack of entrepreneurial skills,
11
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
The main goal is to advance public awareness, education, training and capacity building to
achieve sustainable development. While the key objectives are;
1. To promote understanding and awareness of ESD
2. To enhance stakeholder participation
3. To train trainers in ESD
4. To develop context-specific ESD materials and tools
5. To disseminate best practices in the region
6. To improve the livelihood of poor families
7. To promote sustainable rural and urban development.
He concluded by mentioning that the RCE has proposed several activities which include
1. Consultation with stakeholder members February 2012
2. Consultation with stakeholder members April 2012
3. RCE Registration- May 2012
4. Regular consultation, review and recruitment of membership
She mentioned that so far the RCE Nyanza have been able to develop botanical garden
1. Wetland restoration
2. Tree planting
3. Beekeeping
4. Mat making
5. The action plan is to establish a regional steering committee
6. Advocacy
7. Research and innovation
8. She mentioned that they are looking forward to the registration of Nyanza RC E
12
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
He shared his innovation on the energy sector and his plan to resolve the high energy costs in the slums
by availing cheaper affordable technologies / alternatives
He mentioned that some of the achievements of the short-term objectives – networks, gaps identification
and research areas, increased awareness about environmental degradation, increased students enthusiasm
and participation in environmental conservation efforts, disseminated research findings at Annual
Research Conferences and other fora in communities and improved health and sanitation practices, child
health care and nutrition.
13
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
SESSIONS REPORTS
A SUMMARY REPORT ON CLIMATE CHANGE
Climate change has direct effects on the physical infrastructure of a city. Its network of
buildings, drainage and energy systems-which in turn impact the welfare and livelihoods of its
residents. It’s impacts disrupt transportation systems through weaker conditions that have
immediate impacts on travel and damages that house lasting service interruptions. By their very
nature, cities are centres of high demand for energy and related recourses. Climate change is
likely to impact both energy demand and supply. The combination of urban population growth,
changing local weather conditions urban heat-island impacts and economic growth has the
14
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
potentials to substantially increase demand for energy. Climate change will also affect energy
generation and distribution for instance, electricity transmission infrastructure may become
increasingly vulnerable to damage and interference as storms and flooding become more
frequent and intense.
Mitigating climate change is becoming an important issue in relation to urban infrastructure, but
one that reputes for attention with other pressures for energy security and affordability and the
provision of basic services. Nevertheless, NEMA and other government, private and civil society
actors have undertaken a range of scheme in order to reduce Green House Gas emissions through
the refurbishment and development of urban infrastructure systems.
The following papers were presented during this workshop
1. Climate Change Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies in Coastal Region, by Dr.
Mwakumanya Ali, Pwani University College.
The presenter gave an account of the climate change as a major global concern and the major
contributing factors both anthropogenic and natural factors. He also gave a board perspective of
the problems associated with climate change effects from a broad Kenyan perspective and why
the coastal region is highly vulnerable to these effects due to its location and high dependence on
natural resource for socio-economic development.
It was reported that there is need to come up with climate change adaptive strategies which are
appropriate for the coastal region, such strategies should integrate both formal and informal
knowledge. ESD should also be integrated into the climate change mitigation measures.
The presenter elaborated on issues concerning the model biogas project by highlighting on cost
estimation, specification, establishment period which was stated to be 2 years and lifespan which
was approximated to be 35 years. It was emphasized that this project was ideal as solid waste
management is today a major concern for many municipal councils.
In conclusion it was observed that this biogas project was an ideal technology to deal with urban
waste through turning it into green energy, mitigating climate change effects and improving
general environmental status.
15
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
fabric dye, ink and herbicide. But Juglone has been synthesized in a lab through use of light and
solvent. It was recommended that this process is environmentally friendly.
To overcome this challenge NEMA through the Department of Planning and Research has
developed an Implementation Action Plan on Research Agenda on priority thematic research
areas based on the mid term plan as well as major global environmental concerns. In conclusion
16
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
it was observed that there is need to incorporate RCEs in the agenda and focus on action research
to drive the country development plans.
The concept of the lifelong education or learning to learn is otherwise referred as human or
sustainable education is timely for development in developing and developed societies. The
paper addressed components of education, training and teaching and its relevance in
development. Global concepts relating to planning for sustainability as well as sub-systems,
characteristics and indicators covered include curriculum development, control measures and
quality concerns are components of relevance. The paper recommended all stakeholders in
education to consider development and humanity now and the future in sustainable education.
2. The Place of Technology Supported Learning for ESD in the Kenyan Education
System
The education system in Kenya has made institutions in the country promote developmental
education at the expense of the environment. The system has given very little emphasis on ESD
in the curriculum in practice. One of education’s chief roles is to prepare future workers and
citizens to deal with the challenges of their times.
Knowledge work—the kind of work that most people need in the coming decades-can be done
anywhere by anyone who has the expertise through a cell phone, a laptop, and Internet
connection. But to have expert knowledge workers, every country needs an education system
that produces them. Kenya as a country needs to re-examine herself and prioritize her needs with
a view to opting for an educational paradigm which not only develops the potential of the
citizens but also maximize on the use of their potential in addressing and meeting the national
needs.
17
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
The paper advocated for the promotion of Education for sustainability through technology in the
21st century learning in the Kenyans educational system and institutions.
3. An investigation into effects of drought on school attendance among primary school
pupils in Pokot North District by Sarah Chepleting, Moi University.
Efforts have been made in developing countries in the struggle to achieve the millennium
development goals. The first goal “to eradicate extreme hunger and poverty” is possible through
education and training. While the rest of the world has made significant progress towards
poverty alleviation, Africa, in particular Sub-Saharan Africa continues to lag behind. Hunger is
the most extreme manifestation of the multi-dimensional phenomenon of poverty, and the
eradication of hunger is therefore instrumental to the eradication of other dimensions of poverty.
The paper assessed the drought conditions around schools in Pokot North District and to
determine effects of drought on school attendance among primary school children in North Pokot
District. The findings revealed that the there are long periods of dry spell leading to scarcity of
water, food and pasture for livestock in the district. Consequently, during these periods most
pupils miss school to assist their parents look for food by mining small amounts of gold and to
look for pasture and water for their livestock. The sales from gold mining were used to buy food.
Based on the findings, it was recommended that the government should dig boreholes and water
points in the District to facilitate irrigation of quick maturing food crops and provision of relief
food (3 meals) should done throughout the year to schools to sustain these children in school.
Education is the process of imparting intellectual, moral, social skills and values to learners for a
particular purpose. Human security and economic prosperity depend on the ability of a country
to educate and prepare its people to thrive in a rapidly changing world. Education for
sustainability aims to tackle the underlying causes of unsustainable trends with a focus on
systematic change by building capacity to re-orient the way we think, behave, live and work.
Creating a sustainable community requires that individuals and organizations have the
knowledge, skills, values, capacity and motivation to respond to the complex sustainability
issues they encounter in their personal and working lives.
The goal of the Decade for Education for Sustainable Development is to integrate the values
inherent in sustainable development in all aspects of learning to encourage changes in behaviour
that promote a more sustainable, economically viable and just society for all. School as a
community offers the perfect environment to empower learners through mutual interaction and
participation with teachers. Learning about sustainable development should be introduced at an
early age to help young people understand the needs and rights of present and future generations,
and to consider the best ways to tackle interrelated challenges.
18
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
The Kenya primary and secondary curriculum is designed in a spiral way building from simple
to complex concepts. The content takes cognizance of the social, cultural, geographical and
environmental challenges and disparities faced by learners in the various regions and thus,
provides a holistic framework for concepts on the three spheres of sustainable development:-
social, environmental and economic- to be developed. Nevertheless, the teaching methodology in
most Kenyan schools is largely teacher-centred and theoretical thus limiting the learners’
participation. This contributes to making education fall far short of what is required to impact
skills, knowledge and values that recognize the importance of sustainable development.
The paper based its argument on the constructivist theory of curriculum that schools emphasis
too much on rote learning and not on real understanding and thinking. For learning to be
meaningful, there must be opportunity for the learners to take some responsibility of the learning
process and make decisions and judgment on circumstances they find themselves in. Learners
should be facilitated to construct their own knowledge based on what they already know and to
use that knowledge in purposeful activities requiring decision making, problem solving and
judgment. In this regard, teaching and learning processes need to be re-oriented to facilitate
learners’ acquisition of knowledge, skills and values through active participation and self-
directed activities to enhance their capacity for contributing to social, economic and
environmental sustainability.
5. Basic & Higher Education Policy Implications For Sustainability In Kenya: Current
Hurdles And Opportunities For The Future By Dr Otieno Mary A., Kenyatta
University.
The role of education for sustainable development (ESD) is to help people develop the attitudes,
skills, and knowledge to make informed decisions for the benefit of themselves and others, now
and for the future, and to act upon those decisions. While many nations around the world have
embraced the need for education to achieve sustainability, only limited progress has been made
on any level. This lack of progress stems from many sources with the main one being a lack of
policy framework to support the mainstreaming of ESD in both basic and higher education
curriculum (university). The paper examined current basic and higher education policies in place,
and how they are an impediment for sustainability including possible future hurdles this poses
for ESD. The vision for the education sector for 2030 is “to have globally competitive quality
education, training and research for sustainable development”. To achieve this vision, four
strategic areas, namely, access, quality, equity, science, technology and innovation have been
identified for support based on their impacts on the economic, social and political pillars (Kenya
vision 2030, final report, 2007). However, the challenge is the sustainability strategy which
failed to be identified. By addressing education policies as critical impediments in the planning
stage, Kenya specifically can prevent or reduce delays or derailment of ESD efforts and,
ultimately, the attainment of sustainability. The national study involved basic and higher
education stakeholders as government, private sector, civil society, learning institutions and the
international community among others, who participated in providing their opinion.
19
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
The paper noted that at the moment, unfortunately, education policy in Kenya is not clearly
defined and does not optimally support holistic learning. The paper concluded that learning for
sustainable development constitutes a trigger for innovations in education and should therefore
be supported. Kenya like any other developing country faces a fundamental decision in
addressing an ESD strategy. She must decide on a method of implementation whether to create
another "add on" subject, (e.g., Sustainable Development, Environmental Education, or
Population Education) or to reorient entire education programs and practices to address
sustainable development. This is best done through clear policy frameworks In this regard
sustainable development education is an ideal vehicle for interdisciplinary learning and can be
used to bring relevance, depth, challenge and breadth to learning. Embedding sustainability
themes within the curriculum, and in the life of the school, develops our children and young
people as global citizens and equips them with skills, values and attributes for learning, life and
work
Provision of tertiary education has been recommended as a long term intervention to address
challenges associated with natural resources management and environmental conservation. A
number of countries have invested on natural resources policies, frameworks, research and
provision of professional education with evaluation and monitoring of the interventions showing
mixed results. The Kenyan government has shown commitment of environmental conservation
by passing of the Environment Management and Coordination Act (EMCA), 1999 and has gone
on in providing financial supports to government Ministries and other agencies involved in
natural resources management. Elsewhere public and private institutions continue to invest
resources on personnel, goods and studies to ensure compliance on environmental requirements.
Albeit all the efforts the country, firms and individuals have put on environmental issues, a
consensus is being reached that our environment continue to deteriorate.
A number of reasons have been raised on why even with all the efforts natural resources
management in Kenya is worsening with no scientific prove of the allegations. Although
environmental issues awareness is high among Kenyan population of all works government
workers, private sector actors and at individual levels, paucity of technical capacity to address
sustainable development has been reported as a major constraint. While the government and
individuals are spending a significant amount of money in sponsoring and/or pursuing
professional training on environment sciences, the impact of such investment are yet to be seen.
Queries have been raised on sufficiency of institutions to train on natural resources management,
levels of training available and accessible to Kenyans, approach of training (theoretical or
practical), training orientations and institution prospects on the graduates and professional
training. The paper attempted to respond to queries raised on efficiency and efficacy of our
tertiary level professional training on sustainable management of natural resources in Kenya. The
findings of the survey undertaken by Elixir Service Masters Ltd. in collaboration with Natural
Resources Management Group (composed of experts in natural resources from various
20
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
21
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
There is a growing recognition that centralized forest regimes which exclude local knowledge
and customary practices have not achieved sustainable forest management. The shift from
traditional to contemporary policy and governance systems has caused problems. This includes
lack of consultation with the local people and hence the policies fail to address the local
challenges comprehensively.
Now there is a new evolving international understanding on forest management requiring the
recognition of local people’s interest, their rights and access to forest resources so as to
contribute to their livelihoods. This has been supported by wider moves to reform national
policies leading to a shift in forest management practices in Kenya. Consequently, much of the
public especially in rural areas of Western Kenya have little interest in using environmental
resources.
22
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
3. “Promoting a More Sustainable, Economically Viable and Just Society for All” by
Wachira, James Maina, Moi University, Eldoret, Kenya.
In taking stock of the achievements NEMA is making in the implementation of Education for
Sustainable Development (ESD) in Kenya, this paper participates in sharing some insights on
how indigenous knowledge (would) enhance(s) innovations that our societies need in ‘promoting
a more sustainable, economically viable and just society for all.’ Specifically, the insights
discussed in this paper draw from some Samburu Oral Poetry. The community makes use of oral
poetry, first, as an archive of preserving values that sustain the continuity of the community and
also that ensure the sustainability of its physical environment. In addition, the poetry serves as a
resource for instructing the community on its role in ensuring the sustainability of the physical
environment. Using some selected praise oral poems the community performs to animals
(collected among the Samburu of) the paper illustrates how the community constitutes a model
complete with content, a methodology for disseminating the value of sustaining the environment
to an audience that practices them values. An analysis of such poetry reveals that the community
makes effort to conserve plants like the acacia and animals like ostriches and elephants due to the
role they play in the survival of the Samburu. The poetry serves as an site of the community
representing its awareness of first, the flora and fauna found in its environment and second, the
relevance of conserving the environment.
The paper considered the need to treat this poetry as a resource that needs to be integrated in
other modes designed and intended for aiding in the attainment of a more sustainable and
economically viable society. The oral poems used for the development of this paper were
collected between August, 2009 and October, 2009 at Wamba Division, Samburu County as part
of a research that has been going on since August 2008. The research was has been investigating
the place of Samburu animal praise oral poetry as a way of making sense of the Samburu
cosmos. The paper
accomplished its end by
paying attention to how the
Samburu structure this
poetry during its
performance it as a
discourse as well as the
features of its diction that
Mikhail Bakhtin labels as
discourse in art. To
conceptualise the structure
of this poetry, John Carlos
Rowe’s definition of a
structure was applied while
Foucault’s rules regarding
the production (read
performance of the poetry)
of discourse aid our
23
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
discussion on the performance of this poetry. The paper recommended that more studies on how
various communities employ(ed) such poetry (read resources) would provide information on
what communities have and/or lack in terms of means and approaches in participating in
Education for Sustainable Development.
“If the global agenda is to be probably addressed, a true partnership between civil societies and
the united nations agencies is not an option, it’s a necessity” Koffi Annan.
Accountability/participation occupies a central place in Development thinking and practice.
United Nations agencies, Government, funding Institutions, Donors and civil societies including
NGOs have all arrived at a near consensus that transformation, Holistic and inclusive
development can't be sustainable and long lasting unless community participation is made central
to the rehabilitation process. According to Cohen and Uphoff 1977, community participation
includes people's involvement in decision making processes, in implementing programmes, their
sharing in benefits of development programmes and their involvement in efforts to evaluate such
programmes. Community participation has been a constant theme in development dialogues
world wide, more recently about inclusive society through innovative participation and bottom-
up approach. Community Based Rehabilitation (CBR) is a strategy in the community
Development for rehabilitation, equalization of opportunities and social inclusion of all persons
with disabilities. According to WHO, CBR focuses on enhancing the quality of life of persons
with disabilities and their families, meeting their basic needs and ensuring inclusive
andparticipation.CBR is a multi-sector approach with five major components including Health,
Education, livelihood, social and empowerment.CBR was developed in 1980 to enable disabled
persons access to rehabilitation in their own community using local resources. “Villages are the
backbone of India” Mahatma Gandhi. Rural appraisal techniques are methods and approaches for
learning about rural life and conditions from, with and by rural people. Empowers the
community to plan, act, monitor and evaluate. The community is capable of collecting accurate
information, order, analyze it and start a process of development if given opportunity.
24
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
Pollution is basically degradation of environment where lot of harmful gases, liquids and solids
get produced from the various chemical reactions due to poor waste management and these toxic
gases, liquids and solids get released into environment. These toxic products seriously damage
the environment and cause serious health problems for the all animals, plants and human
beings.one example is like discharge of effluent from a Dairy plant into atmosphere without
treatment. First day this effluent only carries traces of milk, yogurts, butter fats, some minerals,
metals traces and few organic acids. Once it comes into contact with air born bacteria many
chemical reactions starts at same time and too many toxic products get produced like phenols,
formalins, alcohols, organic acids, and toxic gases. If this effluent get treated on first day the all
will get converted into harmless products and some use full products which be even sold.
However once it is discharged into environment without treatment it becomes a big pollutant.
Same is about solid waste like cow dung and other organic waste from kitchen etc. Once
managed well it can be converted into the organic manure which can be used to increase the food
production. If just thrown like that at Dandora dump site then after few days so many toxic
chemicals and gases get formed due to various chemical reactions that it becomes serious
environmental pollution.
This is one result of serious pollution and high COD in the lake waters due to poor waste
management. Good environment is very important for the healthy human life .however healthy
environment is not possible without correct waste management. All human activities generate the
waste. However this waste has to be managed before discharging into the atmosphere to avoid
serious environmental consequences. By mismanaging the waste we are getting closer to a
serious time bomb which may even wipe out whole human life on the earth like dinosaurs. Time
is now to wake up and to manage the waste to have the healthy environment for the healthy
tomorrow for the all of us. A one day visit to Lake Naivasha or lake Victoria will show you what
25
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
happens when untreated effluent is discharged into lakes and from there we can easily calculate
the quality fish we will catch from these lakes for our kitchens after 10 years from now if waste
will not be managed from today.
The chair reported that there were three presentations and the issues raised included
1. Building partnerships
2. Rehabilitation of Cherengani
3. Organo chlorine
They observed the need to develop RCE journal to present scientific information
Encourage alternative materials i.e recycled papers
Research on marketing systems to enhance livelihoods
26
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
Kenya is categorize as a mega diverse country alongside countries such as Indonesia, Brazil,
Congo, Madagascar and Tanzania. This has been attributed to its species richness, endemism and
ecosystem diversity.
Biodiversity refers to the total variety of life; it is classified into three categories to include
genetic diversity, specie diversity and ecosystem diversity. Biodiversity is the basis of ecosystem
health and of provision of ecosystem services which drives the socio-economic development.
However over the last 50 years changes in biodiversity due to human activities have been more
rapid than any other time in human history.
According to the UNEP Year book 2010, increasing pressure of Human population, over
exploitation, pollution and climate change has already pushed some ecosystems over critical
thresholds.
Other ecosystems are edging closer to threshold beyond which a return to stable conditions could
be difficult if not impossible. Due to these biodiversity changes sustainable conservation is of
world concern. For instance sustainable biodiversity conservation was a major topic of
discussion at the Rio earth Summit which called for partnership between all stakeholders
involved in its conservation.
This paper outlines how the members of the Biodiversity Thematic Working Group of the
RCEGN have been operating its activities and programmes either as individuals or in
partnership to promote the goals and objectives of RCE to achieve goals of United Nations
Decade for Education for Sustainable Development. The paper concludes by highlighting key
achievements made, challenges faced during implementation process and makes
recommendations on how to overcome the challenges in the future to promote efficient
achievement of the RCE aspirations for a sustainable future
The Cherangany Hills are recognized by Nature Kenya and Birdlife International as an Important
Bird Area. The hills occur on l 16’S, 3551 ‘E, in Rift Valley Province, spreads through six
constituencies namely; Marakwet west, Marakwet east, Keiyo north, Sigor, Kapenguria and
Cherangany. They cover an area of 95,600 ha on an altitude: 2,000 - 3,365 m above sea level. Of
this, around 60,500 ha is closed-canopy forest, the remainder being formations of bamboo, scrub,
rock, grassland, moorland or heath, with about 4,000 ha of cultivation and plantations (Blacken
1994i.j). Kapkanyar, Kapolet and Kiptaberr Forest Reserves together form a large western block
of forest, totaling about 20.000 ha. To the east, the Forest Reserves of Lelan, Embotut Kerrer,
Koisungur, Sogotio, Toropket, Chemurkoi, Kipkunurr, Cheboit, and Kapchemutwa are
fragmented and separated by extensive natural grasslands, scrub and farmland.
The Cherangany forests are recognized as one of the most important water towers for Kenya
together with Mt. Kenya, Aberdares, Mau complex, Elgon, and Nandi hills. The Forests are
27
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
critical water catchments, and sit astride the watershed between the Lake Victoria and Lake
Turkana basins. Streams to the west of the watershed feed the Nzoia River system, which flows
into Lake Victoria; streams to the east flow into the Kerio River system that feed to Lake
Turkana. Cherangany hills is the source of these rivers; Weiwei, Muruny, Arorr, Kerio and
Moiben.
The forests are highly responsible in keeping and sustaining local and national ecosystems,
climate and rain patterns. They support livelihoods of communities living around it in terms of
supplying herbal medicine, firewood, source of water for domestic use, fodder for livestock and
aesthetic beauty including creating a favourable atmosphere for human and animal habitats.
Cherangany is thus a forest of local and global significance for people and biodiversity.
The Cherangany forest is currently faced by both human induced and naturally occurring
problems namely; encroachment by farmers and livestock keepers, destruction from commercial
lumbering and charcoal burning, water springs destruction, biodiversity loss, poor agricultural
practices that cause pollution.
The Upper Rift Valley RCE in collaboration with stakeholders will undertake the following
measures to address these problems. They include; create awareness on environmental
conservation to community through school pupils; encourage community ownership of the forest
ecosystem; identify and utilise existing indigenous knowledge in conservation; establish
functional tree nurseries and encourage farm forestry; participate in planting one million
seedlings; encourage formation of active community forest associations (CFA) and water
resource users associations (WRUA); form youth groups to watch illegal activity taking place in
the forest and introduce eco-friendly farming and soil conservation technology.
Based on the above stated activities, we have developed concept paper and look towards
identifying funding organizations to kick start the processes of rehabilitating and restoring the
Cherangany forest and water tower.
Due to population growth, in recent years, increased urbanization, climatic changes and
technological advancement, the capacity of infrastructure has been largely constrained, and there
is great pressure on construction and buildings materials. Alternatives to convection materials and
practices are the key to provision of sustainable eco-materials that are environmentally friendly,
durable easy to work with and will reduce effects of economic inflation, insufficient supplies-
cement(2009), variation of prices-timber(2011),droughts(2009),environmental
degradation(cements and tree cutting) and carbon emission-cements manufacturing for
convectional materials.
28
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
Waste plastics and polythenes and plastic materials, form one of the largest parts of the irritating
solid wastes in landfills. In Kenya, plastic waste is estimated to be about 150,000 tons per month
and currently only about 1200-1500 is recycled currently. In addition, this non-biodegradable
waste inhabit aerobic conditions in landfills, hence encourages release of methane gases, having a
green-house effect 21 times greater than carbon.
The aim of this paper is to show the applicability of eco-materials that may be used for low-cost
housing e.g. beams, trusses, joinery and civil Engineering projects, in road furniture, such as,
channels, bollards kerbs and Investigation of composite structures using concrete and recycled
plastic is feasible and sustainable. In this investigation are findings from a research undertaken to
determine the suitability of recycled polythenes and plastic material in the composite beams
concrete, metal straps and use of suitable additives. These poles were re-melted and remoulded
from waste plastics materials. Test were undertaken to determine the flexural strengths of
composite beams with plastic at different positions and compressive strength of cubes made
using a nominal concrete mix of compressive strength of 20N/mm.
The results indicated composite material higher flexural strength as compared, to the control
specimen (i.e. plain concrete samples). Their weights were also lower hence giving a remarkable
strength weight ratio. The deflections control measures was also recommended.
Generally the applicability and improvement that can be made on plastics and composite for low
cost houses was confirmed by the properties measured. Recycled plastics were also easy to work
with and low earners can prefer them for fast but durable constructions with wood work tools and
less resources and labour requirements. To improve on quality and quantity, better waste
management techniques, good code of practice and standard, regulations and policies
implementations are recommended from the government, environmental and construction
industries.
29
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
Q. What is the problem of not using or embracing new technology in our schools?
A. Teachers should embrace new methods and technologies for teaching in order to
effectively use the new technologies.
Q. How can i-Earn which is mainly used for school and teachers be used by other
stakeholders?
i-Earn is a new technology which should be embraced by all interested.
Q. Is there any way that the current ESD policy can be used to reorient curricula?
A. Different institutions have introduced ESD into their curriculum using the current policy
taking into consideration different aspects of the existing curricula.
Q. Are there other factors contributing to pupils not going to school apart from drought in
Pokot?
A. The other factors that contribute to pupils not attending school include early marriages,
circumcision rites, security and absenteeism from boarding schools due to shortage of
water.
30
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
Tosheka industries exhibits their baskets made Pure and cure Matters
from waste plastic bags
31
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
Nairobi International School’s showcase Dr. Isaack Misiko displays indigenous medicine
32
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
The Ag. Director General NEMA- Dr. Ayub Macharia gave the concluding remarks reiterating
that Kenya has made milestones and is ESD compliant. Environmental matters have been
elevated into the constitution of Kenya with ESD being entrenched through the bill of rights and
other sections. With its diversity, ESD through RCE has to incorporate the different ideas to
achieve its goal. RCEs have gone through storming and have now reached the norming stage,
where there is order with strategies having formulated on the way forward for RCE.
RCEs should engage NEMA to push forward their agenda. NEMA has developed a research
agenda which the universities can use to enhance RCEs in their institutions. In instances where
they have publications and journals, they can be supported. A communication strategy should be
formulated and embraced at the local level to enhance RCEs. There is need to strengthen RCEs
through mottos, songs, poems and other achievements. RCEs need to team up with NEMA to
integrate capacity and resources in order to achieve Education for Sustainable Development.
JKUAT has reoriented their curriculum towards ESD and its only waiting for senate’s approval.
NEMA is currently working with Pwani University College to embrace RCE. In future
conference, awards should be given to best ESD compliant institutions.
33
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
ANNEX 1: PROGRAMME
Monday, 14th November Tuesday, 15th November Wednesday, 16th November Thursday, 17th
(Day 0) (Day 1) (Day 2) November (Day 3)
Breakfast 8:30-9:00 Registration 8:30-9:00 -Recap of Day One Departures
3:40-4:00
- Implementing ESD and
Coordination of RCEs in
Institutions of Higher Education
(IHE) - The case of Rhodes
University-South Africa
4:00-4:30 Break 4:00-4:30 Break
4:30-5:00 4:30-5:30
- RCEs and Community Report to the Plenary and General Discussions
Engagement
35
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
37
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
38
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
40
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
41
Turning a Green leaf Towards Sustainability 2011
42