Ge 006 - Ethics - Chapter - 2
Ge 006 - Ethics - Chapter - 2
CHAPTER 2: UTILITARIANISM
THE PRINCIPLE OF UTILITY
PRINCIPLE OF THE GREATEST NUMBER
JUSTICE AND MORAL RIGHT
UTILITARIANISM
LIMITATION OF UTILITARIANISM
- Assume a hospital has four people who lives depend upon receiving organ
transplant. A healthy person’s organs could be harvested to save four lives at
the expenses of one life.
TYPES OF UTILITARIANISM
There are basically two branches of utilitarianism. They both agree that the goal
of ethics is to maximize happiness. But they disagree on where that decision
should be applied;
1. Act Utilitarianism – argues that we should always choose our actions based
on what will cause the greatest amount of happiness.
2. Rule Utilitarianism – argues that we should figure out what sort of behavior
usually causes happiness, and turn it into a set of rules.
TWO FORMST UTILITARIANISM THINKERS
- Born on February 15, 1748. He was the teacher of James Mill, FATHER of
John Stuart Mill. He first wrote about the greatest happiness principle of
ethics.
- Born on May 20, 1806. He was the SON of James Stuart Mill, a student,
friend and disciple of Jeremy Bentham. He was known for his long essay
entitled “UTILITARIANISM” in 1861.
Principle of Utility
Jeremy Bentham begins by arguing that our actions are governed by two
“sovereign masters” - PLEASURE and PAIN – which are given to us by
nature to help us determine what is good or bad and what ought to be done
and not.
Having identified the tendency for pleasure and the avoidance of pain as the
principle of utility, Bentham equates happiness with pleasure.
Mill supports Bentham principle of utility. He reiterates moral good as
happiness and consequently, happiness as pleasure.
“Intended Pleasure” “Privation of Pleasure”
States that equating happiness with pleasure doesn't aim to describe the
utilitarianism moral agent alone and independently from others.
Utilitarianism cannot lead to a selfish act. It is neither about our pleasure
nor happiness alone. It cannot be all about us (ourselves).
- It is necessary for us to consider everyone’s happiness, including our
own as a standard by which we evaluate what is moral.
JUSTICE – Mill understand justice as a respect for directed toward society's pursuit for
the greatest happiness of the greatest number.
Examples;
- Rights serve general happiness, and are justified because they contribute to the
general good. This means that society is made happier if its citizens are able to
live their lives knowing that their interests are protected and that society, as a
whole, defends it.
- A right justifiable on utilitarian principles in as much as they produce an overall
happiness that is greater than the unhappiness resulting from their
implementation.