Module 3
Module 3
Registrar & Transfer Agents: A registrar and transfer agent (RTA) acts
as a mediator or agent between investors and mutual fund houses.
Fund Manager: A fund manager is a person who oversees the
activities of the mutual fund. In other words, the fund manager is
responsible for implementing a fund's investment strategy and
managing its trading activities. They also manage analysts, conduct
research, and make investment decisions.
Fund Accountant: A fund accountant is responsible the day-to-day
aspects of accounting for one or more assigned mutual funds. They
also prepare Net Assets Values, yields, distributions, and other fund
accounting outputs for sub- sequent review.
History of Mutual Funds in India
Phase 1 (1964-1987) – Establishment
Phase 2 (1987-1993) – Launch of Public Sector Mutual Funds
Phase 3 (1993-2003) – Launch of Private Sector Mutual Funds
Phase 4 (2003-2014) – Consolidation and slowdown
Phase 5 (since 2014) – Rejuvenation and consistent growth
MAJOR FUND HOUSES IN INDIA
Axis AMC
Aditya Birla SunLife AMC
Franklin Templeton Asset Management (India)
HDFC AMC
Invesco Asset Management (India)
Kotak Mahindra AMC
LIC Mutual Fund AMC
Motilal Oswal AMC
Nippon Life India Asset Management
SBI Funds AMC
UTI AMC
(Please note the list is not exhaustive)
MUTUAL FUND SCHEMES
There is a wide range of mutual fund structures for different investor goals.
Mutual funds can be broadly classified based on the following criteria:
• Organisation Structure -Open ended, Close ended, Interval
• Portfolio management strategy - Active or Passive
• Investment Objective - Growth, Income, Liquidity
• Underlying Portfolio - Equity, Debt, Hybrid, Money market instruments,
Multi Asset
• Sector specific funds – Real Estate, Hospital, FMCG
• Thematic/solution oriented -Tax saving, Retirement benefit, Child welfare,
Arbitrage
• Exchange Traded Funds
• Fund of funds
NET ASSET VALUE
• Net Asset value or NAV refers to the value of each unit of the scheme.
NAV is one of the most important concept to understand in a mutual
fund.
• All subscriptions into the fund and all redemptions out of the fund are
based on the NAV of the units on the date of
subscription/redemption.
• The fund houses are directed to publish the NAV of each fund on a
daily basis.
• These NAVs are made available on the respective websites of the
AMCs as well as on the AMFI website.
How is NAV calculated?
• This is calculated as follows:
NAV = Unit holders' Funds in the Scheme (Net Assets) /No. of outstanding
Units
For example, if unit-holders' funds in the scheme are taken as Rs 365 crore and
the number of outstanding units are 42 crore, then the NAV will be:
Rs 365 crore / 42 crore = Rs. 8.69 per unit
This calculation shows that:
• The higher the interest, dividend and capital gains earned by the
scheme, the higher would be the NAV.
• The higher the appreciation in the investment portfolio, the higher
would be the NAV
• The lower the expenses, the higher would be the NAV.
The summation of these three parameters gives us the profitability
metric as being equal to:
(A) Interest income
(B) + Dividend income
(C) +Realized capital gains
(D) + Valuation gains
(E) - Realized capital losses
(F) -Valuation losses
(G) -Scheme expenses
Part 3 : Mutual Funds and
Financial Planning Essentials
Chapter 2 : Criteria for
selection of Mutual Funds
INTRODUCTION
• In the earlier chapter, we understood a few concepts of mutual funds,
various schemes of mutual funds, advantages and disadvantages of mutual
funds and the concept of Net Asset Value (NAV)
• While the industry of mutual funds is vast expanding with a variety of new
scheme offerings, it is important to understand how these returns of
mutual funds are tracked.
• When fund manager creates portfolio of stocks/debt instruments, they
need to evaluate the fund performance. But, what are these fund
performance metrics?
• Mutual fund schemes invest in the market for the benefit of Unit-holders.
How well did a scheme perform? An approach to assess the performance is
to pre-define a comparable -- a benchmark - against which the scheme can
be compared.
Six levels of Risk for Mutual Fund Schemes
• Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), being the capital market regulator, has
issued a circular in October 2020 advising the Mutual Fund industry intermediaries on
the use of Risk-o-meter.
• SEBI, based on the recommendation of Mutual Fund Advisory Committee (MPAC), has
reviewed the guidelines for product labelling in mutual funds and decided that the Risk
level of a scheme be depicted by "Risk-o-meter“
• Risk-o-meter has following six levels of risk for mutual fund schemes:
i. Low Risk
ii. Low to Moderate Risk
iii. Moderate Risk
iv. Moderately High Risk
v. High Risk and
vi. Very High Risk
MUTUAL FUND RETURNS
Drivers of Returns and Risk in a Scheme
• The portfolio is the main driver of returns in a mutual fund scheme.
• The asset class in which the fund invests, the segment sectors of the
market in which the fund will focus on, the styles adopted to select
securities for the portfolio and the strategies adopted to manage the
portfolio will all determine the risk and return in a mutual fund
scheme.
• The underlying facts are different for each asset class.
MUTUAL FUND RETURNS
Measures of Returns
• The returns from an investment is calculated by comparing the cost
paid to acquire the asset (outflow) or the starting value of the
investment to what is earned from it (inflows) and computing the rate
of return.
• The inflows can be from periodic pay- outs such as interest from fixed
income securities and dividends from equity investments and gains or
losses from a change in the value of the investment.
• The calculation of return for a period will take both the income
earned and gains/loss into consideration, even if the gains/loss have
not been realized.
MUTUAL FUND RETURNS
Simple Return
((Later value-Initial value) x 100)/Initial Value
Example:
Suppose you invested in a scheme at a NAV of Rs. 15. Later,
you found that the NAV has grown to Rs. 20. How much is your
return?
Simple Return = ((20 - 15) * 100) / 15 = 33.33%
MUTUAL FUND RETURNS
Annualised Return
Annualization helps us compare the returns of two different time periods.
Annualized Return = Simple Return x 12/ Period of Simple return in months
Example:
Annualised returns:
Two investment options have indicated that their returns since inception as 9% and
4% respectively.
If the first investment was existence for 9 months and the second for 3 months, then
the two returns are obviously not comparable without using this method
Investment 1 ------------------ 9 percent * 12/9 =12% p.a
Investment 2------------------ 4 percent x 12/3 = 16% p.a.
SEBI Norms regarding Representation of
Returns by Mutual Funds in India
• Mutual funds are not permitted to promise any returns, unless it is an
assured returns scheme. Assured returns schemes call for a guarantor
who is named in the offer document.
• The guarantor will need to write out a cheque, if the scheme is
otherwise not able to pay the assured return.
• Advertisement Code and guidelines for disclosing performance
related information of mutual fund schemes are prescribed by SEBI.
Alpha
• The difference between a scheme's actual return and its optimal return is its
Alpha - a measure of the fund manager's performance. Alpha, therefore,
measures the performance of the investment in comparison to a suitable market
index.
• Positive alpha is indicative of out-performance by the fund manager; negative
alpha might indicate under-performance.
• Since the concept of Beta is more relevant for diversified equity schemes, Alpha
should ideally be evaluated only for such schemes.
• These quantitative measures are based on historical performance, which may or
may not be replicated.
• Such quantitative measures are useful pointers. However, blind belief in these
measures, without an understanding of the underlying factors, is dangerous.
While the calculations are arithmetic - they can be done by a novice; scheme
evaluation is an art- the job of an expert.
Beta
• Beta is based on the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM), which states that there are two
kinds of risk in investing in equities-systematic risk and non-systematic risk.
• Systematic risk is integral to investing in the market; it cannot be avoided. For example,
risks arising out of inflation, interest rates, political risks etc. This arises primarily from
macro-economic and political factors. This risk cannot be diversified away.
• Non-systematic risk is unique to a company; the non-systematic risk in an equity
portfolio can be minimized by diversification across companies. For example, risk arising
out of change in management, product obsolescence etc.
• Since non-systematic risk can be diversified away, investors need to be compensated only
for systematic risk, according to CAPM. This systematic risk is measured by its Beta
• Beta measures the fluctuation in periodic returns in a scheme, as compared to
fluctuation in periodic returns of a diversified stock index (representing the market) over
the same period.
• The diversified stock index, by definition, has a Beta of 1. Companies or schemes, whose
beta is more than 1, are seen as more risky than the market. Beta less than 1 is indicative
of a company or scheme that is less risky than the market.
QUANTITATIVE MEASURES OF FUND MANAGER
PERFORMANCE ABSOLUTE & RELATIVE RETURNS
• Using the concept of benchmarks, one can do relative comparison viz. how
did a scheme perform vis-à-vis its benchmark or peer group. Such
comparisons are called relative return comparisons.
• A credible benchmark should meet the following requirements:
It should be in sync with
(a) the investment objective of the scheme (i.e. the securities or variables
that go into the calculation of the benchmark should be representative of
the kind of portfolio implicit in the scheme's investment objective);
(b) asset allocation pattern; and
(c) investment strategy of the scheme.
QUANTITATIVE MEASURES OF FUND MANAGER
PERFORMANCE ABSOLUTE & RELATIVE RETURNS
If a comparison of relative returns indicates that a scheme earned a
higher return than the benchmark, then that would be indicative of
outperformance by the fund manager.
In the reverse case, the initial premise would be that the fund manager
under-performed. Such premises of outperformance or under-
performance need to be validated through deeper performance
reviews.
MCs and trustees are expected to conduct such periodic reviews of
relative returns, as per the SEBI Guidelines.
Risk-adjusted Returns
• A risk-adjusted return is a calculation of the profit or potential profit
from an investment that takes into account the degree of risk that
must be accepted in order to achieve it.
• It enables the investor to make comparison between the high-risk and
the low-risk return investment.
Absolute Return
• Absolute return is simply whatever an asset or portfolio returned over
a certain period.
• Absolute performance is the return of the portfolio itself on a year-
over-year basis.
• Absolute return investing can beat average market returns with less
risk and volatility over time.
Relative Return
• Relative return is the return an asset achieves over a period of time compared to a benchmark.
The relative return is the difference between the asset's return and the return of the benchmark.
Relative return can also be known as alpha in the context of active portfolio management.
• Relative performance is the comparison of the returns of your portfolio to that of some
benchmark index.
• Relative return is important because it is a way to measure the performance of actively managed
funds, which should earn a return greater than the market. Specifically, the relative return is a
way to gauge a fund manager's performance.
Relative returns comparison is one approach towards evaluating the performance of the fund
manager of a scheme.
• A weakness of this approach is that it does not differentiate between two schemes that have
assumed different levels of risk in pursuit of the same investment objective.
• Therefore, although the two schemes share the benchmark, their risk levels are different.
• Evaluating performance, purely based on relative returns, may be unfair towards the fund
manager who has taken lower risk but generated the same return as a peer.
Measures of risk-adjusted returns
Sharpe ratio is a very commonly used measure of risk-adjusted
returns.
An investor can invest with the government and earn a risk-free rate of
return (Rf). T-Bill index is a good measure
Through investment in a scheme, a risk is taken, and a return is earned (Rs)
The difference between the two returns i.e. Rs - Rf is called risk premium.
It is like a premium that the investor has earned for the risk taken, as
compared to government's rid-free return This risk premium is to be
compared with the risk taken.
Sharpe Ratio uses Standard Deviation as a measure of risk It is calculated as:
Sharpe Ratio = (Rs – Rf) / Standard Deviation
Example: Let's say that the risk free return is 4.25% and the scheme has a
standard deviation of 0.35%. The return earned by the scheme is taken at
8%. Calculate the Sharpe Ratio.
Rf = 4.25
Rs = 8%
Standard Deviation = 0.35%
Sharpe Ratio = (Rs – Rf) / Standard Deviation
Sharpe Ratio = (8-4.25) / 0.35 = 10.71
Sharpe Ratio is effectively the risk premium generated by assuming per unit
of risk.
Higher the Sharpe Ratio, better the scheme is considered to be.
Sharpe Ratio comparisons can be undertaken only for comparable schemes.
or example, Sharpe Ratio of an equity scheme cannot be compared with the
Sharpe Ratio of Debt scheme.
Treynor Ratio
Like Sharpe Ratio, Treynor Ratio too is a risk premium per unit of risk.
Computation of risk premium is the same as was done for the Sharpe Ratio. However, for risk,
Treynor Ratio uses Beta.
Treynor Ratio = (Rs - Rf) / Beta
Example:
Let's say that the risk free return is 4.25% and the scheme has a Beta of 1.2. The return earned
by the scheme is taken at 7.5%. Calculate the Treynor Ratio.
Beta = 1.2
Rf =4.25%
Rs =7.5%
Treynor Ratio = (Rs - Rf) / Beta
Treynor Ratio = (7.5 - 4.25) / 1.2 = 2.71
Higher the Treynor Ratio, better the scheme is considered to be. Since the concept of Beta is
more relevant for diversified equity schemes, Treynor Ratio comparisons should ideally be
restricted to such schemes
Tracking Error
• The difference between an index fund's return and the market
return is the tracking error.
• Tracking error is a measure of the consistency of the out-performance
of the fund manager relative to the benchmark.
• It is not enough if the fund is able to generate a high excess return, it
must do so consistently.
• Tracking error is calculated as the standard deviation of the excess
returns generated by the fund.
• The tracking error has to be low for a consistently out- performing
fund.
Part 3 : Mutual Funds and
Financial Planning Essentials
Chapter 3 : Financial Planning,
Life Cycle and Personal Budget
Introduction
• In the earlier modules, we have learnt at length about the various
concepts of savings & investments, returns, investment vehicles, etc.
We have also touched based on the very basic of financial planning.
• In the chapter, we will try to learn some more about financial
planning, the steps involved, and the other aspects associated with
investments and sourcing of finances.
Steps Involved in Financial Planning
Process undertaken by financial advisors for their client’s financial
planning
1) Establish and define the client-planner relationship
2) Gather client data, including goals
3) Analyze and evaluate financial status
4) Develop and present financial planning recommendations
5) Implement the financial planning recommendations
6) Monitor the financial planning recommendations
Understanding Financial Life Cycle
The Ten Financial Stages of Life Experts have divided life into ten typical
financial stages. There are specific wealth building strategies for each
stage and financial ratios that mark the transition from one stage to the
next. The most unreliable indicator on the Financial Life Cycle is the age
range.
Understanding Financial Life Cycle
Life Stages Financial Stages
Stages
1&2 TODDLER AND • Parents teach – Accumulation (Piggy bank),
CHILDHOOD • Convertibility (spend some of our allowance to buy things)
• Relative Value (rupee and paisa)