Table of Responses

Lines Reviewer Comments/Suggest Answer

1-3 The Title is too long. I would suggest to shorten the Thank you for your review. We have agreed to accept
length by removing the words remote sensing and GIS the suggestions and feedback for improving the
technology and being replaced by “spatial”. manuscript.
33 Previously you mentioned Tangkahan National Park, Thank you for your review. Tangkahan Ecotourism is
then later on you said Tangkahan Village in Central an ecotourism destination located within Gunung
Kalimantan. Please check again the accuracy of this Leuser National Park. Therefore, we mentioned
information. To my knowledge, Tangkahan is not a Gunung Leuser National Park and Tangkahan
national park although it is located within (and Ecotourism in North Sumatra, which were already
adjacent) to Leuser National Park. Also for Tangkahan included in the text. Regarding Tangkahan Village,
Village, I think it should be Tangkahen. we made an error in writing, as it should refer to
ecotourism located in Tangkahen Village in Central
Kalimantan. Thus, we have corrected it based on
your suggestion.
85 What is AHP? Please add the abbreviation for this. Thank you for your review. AHP stands for
Analytical Hierarchy Process and has already been
added to the manuscript.
84-88 Not all readers are familiar with the context of study Thank you for your review. We have added detailed
area of studies cited here. Thus, I would suggest to add information about the locations of previous studies
the country where this study was conducted. we used.
113-116 Are some part of Ujungalang Village located in Thank you for your review. No part of Desa
Nusakambangan Island? If so, please add this Ujungalang is located on Nusakambangan Island.
information, it not please leave it.
133 What is open land you referring to here? It might be Thank you for your review. The open land referred to
useful to add few words in brackets to clarify this. in our study is unused vacant land.
182 Previously in the Introduction you said about AHP. Thank you for your review. This study does not use
Did you used AHP in Data Analysis? If so, please the AHP method for weighting; instead, the
explain how you used this methods. weighting is done using the ranking method proposed
by Selamat (2015).
184 What GIS software you used here? ArcGIS, QGIS? Thank you for your review. All spatial analysis and
data processing in our study were performed using
ArcGIS 10.8 software. We have added this
information to the manuscript.
200-202 I assumed that some of the spatial data are in the form Thank you for your review. The raster data used in
of raster. If so, please clarify what is the resolution of this study includes DEM (slope and elevation),
each raster data. MODIS (temperature), and Google Earth (land use).
These datasets have been extracted in a consistent
raster data format with the WGS 1984 Zone 49S
projection system and a 30-meter pixel resolution.
We have added this information to Table 1.
265-266 What do you mean of 45 species being certified? What Thank you for your review. Based on information
certification are you referring to? from Pertamina's website
(https://www.pertamina.com/id/news-room/news-
release/kolak-sekancil-wisata-mangrove-terlengkap-
di-indonesia), the diversity of mangroves in Segara
Anakan is described as stated. However, there is no
further information on this matter. Therefore, to
avoid misinformation, we have removed the related
sentence.
237-339 The explanation in the main text is related to Thank you for your review. We have corrected the
information presented in Figure 3. But not all factors references to the figures in the manuscript.
explained in the main text are annotated to the figure.
For example, for land use, there is no explanation
 which figure number it referring to. Please add each
factor in the main text the figure number it referring to,
for example land use is annotated to Figure 3A and so
on.
358 Please add note at the bottom of the table for each code Thank you for your review. We have added more
provided in the coloumn, for example rj. information about the abbreviations used in the
manuscript.
385-387 In the figure legend, it is not common to order medium Thank you for your review. We have corrected the
class first then followed by high and low. I would order of the ecotourism potential index categories on
suggest to put the high class in the first order. the corresponding map.

We accept all suggestions for writing improvements

in the form of sentence modifications.
We have also revised the ecotourism potential index
categories (Table 7).