Project (AutoRecovered)
Project (AutoRecovered)
Project Report on
Undertaken in
“Hindustan Unilever Limited”
By
Siddhi Prakash Shinde
1
DECLARATION
I the undersigned “Siddhi Prakash Shinde” hereby declare that the work
embodied in this project work titled “A preliminary study of the in-bound
Supply Chain dynamics at HUL (Surf Excel) with a focus on overhead
allocation and working capital performance (Ratio Analysis)” has been
prepared by me for the partial fulfilment of the requirement for the award of the
Master of Management Studies (MMS) degree, forms my own contribution
to the research work carried out under the mentorship of my mentor Dr.
Ashwini Mahadik and Prof. Mayuresh lonshute.
Whenever reference has been made to previous works of others, it has been
clearly indicated as such and included in the bibliography.
I, here by further declare that all information of this document has been
obtained and presented in accordance with academic rules and ethical conduct.
Signature of candidate
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
3
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
4
Contextual Background
With a customer base exceeding 700 million and a distribution network that
reaches every corner of the country, HUL's influence on the Indian consumer
landscape is profound. The company's ability to innovate and adapt to changing
consumer preferences and market dynamics has been key to its sustained
growth and leadership position in the FMCG industry. As it continues to evolve,
HUL remains dedicated to enhancing lives with products that not only meet
high standards of quality and efficacy but also uphold principles of social
responsibility and sustainability.
5
History
6
Chiplun Factory HUL
The Chiplun Factory of HUL is located in MIDC Lote Parshuram Tal. Khed,
Ratnagiri. It produces 2 lakh tonnes of products annually and employs around
400 people. The factory has 4 units: Unit 1 makes Surf excel, Unit 2 makes Rin
& Wheel, Unit 3 makes Vim, and Unit 4 produces Wheel powder.
In terms of their Home Care brands, they believe that having a clear purpose
and making high-quality products are crucial for success. For example, Surf
excel promotes the idea that "Dirt is good," encouraging people to care about
social and environmental issues. This year, Surf excel became the first Home
and Personal Care brand in India to reach a turnover of over US$1 billion.
Wheel also saw growth in its consumer base and performed well in the mass
detergents market. The internship began with a comprehensive overview of the
SAP integration within the plant's operations, allowing for a deeper
understanding of the inbound supply chain dynamics and providing a suitable
environment to apply concepts of Operations Management in a real-world.
Unit 1: Surf Excel This unit specializes in the production of Surf Excel powder.
Unit 2 Wheel: The Old bar unit focuses on manufacturing of Rin bar and Wheel
bar products. Unit 3 - Vim unit is responsible for the production of Vim bar.I
had an opportunity to witness the operations of vim bar plant. A short overview
of manufacturing of vim bar. The materials add on by sequence that is dolomite,
labsa, sodium silicate, soda then next step add colour green sulphate (solution),
AA Homopolymers(acusol), water mix for 90 sec, China clay, calcite in a dump
mix it till good consistence dough is formed. Then add Athena perfume by
adding all the ingredients and then cut according to the weight then it is packed
Unit 4 - Wheel Powder: The Wheel Powder unit is dedicated to the production
of Wheel Powder. HUL maintains warehouses and distribution centres
strategically located to store finished goods. Effective inventory management
ensures adequate stock levels while minimizing excess inventory and associated
costs.
7
COMPETITOR ANALYSIS:
At the heart of Dabur's success lies its commitment to Ayurveda, the ancient
Indian system of medicine. Dabur has leveraged Ayurvedic principles to
develop a wide range of products that cater to consumers' health and wellness
needs. From traditional formulations to modern innovations, Dabur's products
are known for their natural ingredients and efficacy.
8
Dabur’s product portfolio is extensive and includes well-known brands such as
Dabur Chyavanprash, Dabur Honey, Dabur Red Toothpaste, Dabur Amla Hair
Oil, and Dabur Lal Tail, among others. These products have become household
names in India and have earned the trust of millions of consumers over
generations. In addition to its focus on Ayurveda, Dabur has embraced
innovation and technology to stay ahead in the competitive FMCG market. The
company invests heavily in research and development to create products that
meet the evolving needs of consumers. It also employs state-of-the-art
manufacturing facilities and stringent quality control measures to ensure the
highest standards of safety and efficacy.
9
ROLE AND ACTIVITES PERFORMED DURING THE INTERNSHIP IN
HUL
Worked as a Summer Finance Intern for a period 45 days, and the work
activities done are the following:
I also went in VIM Bar plant & I analysed the procedure of making vim
bar of different grams.
Remaining……
10
OBJECTIVES:
To understand the basic operations of Surf Excel plant of HUL and relate
it to the Cost Management processes adopted in the factory.
11
SUMMARY OF THE ACTIVITIES PERFORMED DURING THE
INTERNSHIP:
In-bound supply chain drivers at HUL:
A supply chain transforms raw materials and components into a finished
product that's delivered to a customer. It is made up of a complex network of
organizations and activities, such as raw materials suppliers, manufacturers,
distributors, retailers and the customer.
12
- Analysing market demand, sales trends, and historical data to create accurate
forecasts.
- Determining production levels, inventory requirements, and distribution
plans based on the forecasts.
2. Procurement:
- Sourcing raw materials, packaging materials, and other necessary inputs
from a network of suppliers.
- Maintaining relationships with suppliers focusing on quality, cost, and
sustainability.
- Creating Material Requirement Planning (MRP) based Bill of Material
(BOM) every Saturday to determine materials needed for production and
schedule procurement.
13
4. Manufacturing:
- Operating multiple manufacturing facilities to transform raw materials into
finished goods.
- Optimizing production processes for efficiency, quality control, and
regulatory compliance.
- Four plants in HUL Chiplun Detergent factory.
a. Unit 1 - Surf Excel: This unit specializes in the production of Surf Excel
powder.
b. Unit 2 - Wheel: The Old bar unit focuses on manufacturing of Rin bar and
Wheel bar products.
c. Unit 3 - Vim unit is responsible for the production of Vim bar. I had an
opportunity to witness the operations of vim bar plant. A short overview of
manufacturing of vim bar. The materials add on by sequence that is dolomite,
labsa, sodium silicate, soda then next step add colour green sulphate (solution),
AA Homopolymers(acusol), water mix for 90 sec, China clay, calcite in a dump
mix it till good consistence dough is formed. Then add Athena perfume by
adding all the ingredients it is cut according to the weight then it is packed.
d. Unit 4 - Wheel Powder: The Wheel Powder unit is dedicated to the
production of Wheel Powder.
14
(a)Demand Posting: The despatch team at HUL receives demand requests from
retailers and Distribution Point Owners (DPOs). These demands are posted in
the SAP system, which reflects the requirements in the Chiplun factory.
(b)Allocation of Vehicles:
Based on the demand posted in the system, the despatch team, allocates
appropriate vehicle for transportation. Factors such as vehicle capacity, delivery
locations, and route optimization are taken into consideration during the
allocation process.
(c) Loading Team:
Once the vehicles are allocated, the dock shipping team and forklift operators
come into action. They load the products on to the trucks, ensuring proper
handling and secure packaging to prevent any damage during transit.
(d)delivery to DPOs and Retailers: The loaded trucks are now ready to deliver
the goods to the designated DPOs and retailers. The logistics team ensures that
the trucks are dispatched according to the planned routes and schedules.
15
partners may include freight forwarders, carriers, and third-party logistics
providers. HUL maintains strong coordination with these partners to ensure
smooth and efficient transportation operations.
(e) Delivery Confirmation and Documentation: Once the trucks reach their
destination, the goods are unloaded and delivered to the respective DPOs and
retailers. The delivery confirmation is recorded, and necessary
documentation such as delivery receipts and invoices are completed.
Conversion cost:
Conversion costs are what it takes to turn raw materials into finished goods,
including labour and overhead. Unlike prime costs, which cover only labor and
materials, conversion costs also include overhead expenses. In production, there
are three main costs: materials, labour, and overhead. Materials are the actual
stuff used, labour is the workers' cost directly tied to production, and overhead
includes other expenses like rent and utilities. Conversion costs specifically
focus on labour and overhead required for production.
16
1. Raw Material Packing Material Cost: This encompasses adding up the
expenses of all raw materials used in production, including packaging materials
like bales, sacks, and boxes.
(b)Utility Costs: Expenses related to utilities like electricity, water, and gas
necessary for manufacturing.
3.Total Cost: This is the sum of the raw material packing material cost and the
make cost. Adding these two costs together provides the overall expense
incurred in production.
4. Cost per Tonne: To find the cost per tonne, divide the total cost by the total
quantity produced in tonnes. This calculation helps assess the average cost of
each unit produced.
By carefully evaluating these elements, businesses can gain insights into their
production expenses, aiding in pricing strategies and cost management
decisions.
17
29,00,00,000.00 15,00,00,000.00 6,00,00,000.00 50,00,00,000.00
Non-management 52,500.00
Travel 33,500.00 16,000.00 3,000.00
Motor Vehicle
Expenses 3,27,000.00 1,52,000.00 26,000.00 5,05,000.00
Total Travel 4,27,500.00 2,00,000.00 35,000.00 6,62,500.00
18
Power, Light, Water
etc. 97,500.00 45,000.00 7,500.00 1,50,000.00
TPM/UQCSRM/CSR - - - -
4000.00
12000.00 9000.00
TOTAL TONNE 25,000.00
19
(The above figures are assumed numbers and not the financials of HUL,
the percentages are given by the finance executive at HUL as per the
company’s ratio)
20
1. Cost per Tonne Analysis: Product costing helps calculate how much it costs
to make one tonne of a product. This helps management pinpoint where they're
spending the most and find ways to cut costs. It's useful for comparing costs
between different parts of the production process or different products.
Shortage of funds for working capital has caused many businesses to fail and
in many cases, has retarded their growth. Lack of efficient and effective
utilization of working capital leads to earn low rate of return on capital
employed or even compels to sustain losses .
The need for skilled working capital management has thus become greater in
recent years. A firm invests a part of its permanent capital in fixed assets and
keeps a part of it for working capital i.e., for meeting the day-to-day
21
requirements. We will hardly find a firm which does not require any amount
of working capital for its normal operations.
The requirement of working capital varies from firm to firm depending upon
the nature of business, production policy, market conditions, seasonality of
operations, conditions of supply etc. Working capital to a company is like
the blood to human body. It is the most vital ingredient of a business.
1.Fixed Assets: Assets like property, machinery, and equipment used for long-term
operations.
2.Long-term Investments: Holdings like stocks or bonds expected to provide
returns beyond a year.
22
3.Permanent Working Capital: Minimum capital needed for continual operation.
4.Equity Capital: Funds raised by selling ownership shares.
5.Long-term Debt: Borrowed funds with repayment schedules over a year.
6.Retained Earnings: Profits reinvested into the company.
7.Intangible Assets: Assets lacking physical form but holding long-term value.
9.Accrued Expenses: Expenses incurred but not yet paid, such as wages, utilities, or
taxes.
Missed sales opportunities: Not having enough cash in hand will lead to
inability to exploit such opportunities.
Idle funds: Shareholder receives less return if the funds are not utilized
23
Excessive inventory: Higher working capital could also mean money
blocked in unsold inventory. Companies with excessive inventory also
need to bear high storage costs, which results in unnecessary expenditure
and decreased profits.
Just like inadequate working capital, excessive working capital also leads to
decreased profits. So, we need to maintain balanced working capital.
FINANCIAL RATIO ANALYSIS
24
decisions.
The decrease in the Gross Margin has had an impact on HUL's Net Profit
Ratio which decreased from 16.84% in 2023 to 16.72% in 2024 but in
2022 the betnet profit will be higher that is 17.09. Since the decrease has
not been substantial a further analyse for the reasons behind this decline
was not warranted.
25
company has no reported interest-bearing long-term debt. The reduction
in the non-current liabilities can partially explain the likely reasons for
the increase in the ROCE.
HUL's EPS has increased from 2022 in 37.53% to 42.40 in 2023 to 43.05
in 2024. Despite a decrease in the Net Profit margin as highlighted
earlier, the companies’ absolute value of its Net profits has gone up. With
no change in the Shares outstanding (that is no dilution in reported EPS)
the EPS has increased. This rise signifies that the company has generated
higher earnings for each outstanding share. It indicates positive growth
and can be seen as a favourable indicator for existing shareholders and
potential investors (with better PE Multiples and a consequent impact on
the market price). A detailed analysis of this is beyond the scope of this
Report.
DABUR
Profitability Ratios: HUL 2024 2024
1.Gross Profit Ratio: Gross profit *100 21.65% 12.40%
Net Revenue
The Gross Profit Ratio of HUL is significantly higher than Dabur. This
suggests that HUL has a higher ability to generate profit from its core
operations in comparison to DABUR. HUL may have better cost
management, pricing strategies, or a more favourable product mix.
26
HUL has a higher Net Profit Ratio compared to Dabur. This indicates that
HUL is more efficient in generating profit after considering all expenses
and taxes, in relation to its net sales. HUL's higher net profit margin
suggests better cost control or higher revenue generation in comparison to
Dabur.
HUL's Current Ratio has increased from 1.34 in 2022 to 1.38 in 2023 to
1.64 in 2024. This indicates a slight improvement in the company's ability
to cover its short-term liabilities with its current assets.
HUL's Quick Ratio has increased from 1.033 in 2023 to 1.329 in 2024 but
in 2022 it decreases 0.982. A clear reflection of the company’s overall
liquidity improvement as shown in Current Ratio analysis). This indicates
27
a slight improvement in the company's ability to cover its short-term
liabilities with its quick assets, excluding inventory.
The Current Ratio of both HUL and Dabur are below 1, marginally
higher for HUL Theoretically it has a better ability to cover its short-term
liabilities with its current assets. A higher CR or that matter a lower CR
may not be cause for any Liquidity anxieties for both the companies.
The Cash Ratio of Dabur is significantly higher than that of HUL. The
maintenance of cash balances could reflect on the company’s aggressive
or conservative policies of cash balances. Excessive cash may have signs
of better liquidity but lower profitability as the cash balances do not
generate any returns unless invested judiciously. Theoretically a higher
cash ratio suggests better immediate liquidity and the ability to meet
immediate obligations without relying on other assets.
Activity Ratios:
Working Capital Formula HUL HUL HUL
31st March 31st March 31st March
2024 2023 2022
1.Receivable Turnover Sales 20.6526 21.6249 26.4974
Receivables
2.Receivable Days 365 17.673 16.879 13.775
Receivables Turn Over
28
A higher ratio is generally favourable, as it implies faster and efficient
utilization of the asset. In this case, the receivable turnover decreased
from 2022 to 2024, suggesting a slight decrease in the efficiency of
receivables collection. Two factors contributing to this are apparent, one
sale has decreased by 0.97% in 2024, however the decreases in the trade
receivables has been 45%. The combined effect has lowered the
turnover ratio in 2024.
The receivable days ratio represents the average number of days it takes
for the company to collect its accounts receivable. For HUL the lowering
of the Turnover ratio has increased the Receivable days. In this case, the
receivable days increased from 2022 is 13.77 days to 2023 is 16.87 Days
& 2024 is 17.67 days indicating higher receivable days in 2024.
The inventory days ratio represents the average number of days it takes
for the company to sell its inventory. As a consequence of a higher
inventory turnover the inventory days decreased from say 43.45 Days in
2024 & 43.51 Days 2023 but in 2022 the inventory day will higher
51.58, a lower number indicates a shorter period and thus suggests more
efficient inventory turnover.
Inventory period+
8.Cash Conversion Accounts Receivable -52.13 -49.476 -63.316
29
The payables turnover ratio shows how quickly the company pays its
suppliers. A higher ratio suggests faster payment. In this case, the
payables turnover increased from 2.8x in 2022 & 3.3x in 2023, indicating
a slight improvement in the speed of paying suppliers
The operating cycle represents the average time it takes for the company
to convert its inventory into cash through sales. It is calculated by adding
the inventory days and the receivable days. In this case, the operating
cycle increased from 68 Days in 2024 & 60 Days in 2023 and 2022 is 65,
indicating a slight improvement in the efficiency of the company's
operating cycle.
The cash conversion cycle is the time it takes for the company to convert
its investments in inventory and accounts receivable into cash. It is
calculated by subtracting the payable days from the operating cycle. A
negative value indicates that the company receives cash from customers
before it needs to pay its suppliers. Using trade credit to supplement the
working capital needs of the company. In this case, the cash conversion
cycle moved from negative 52 Days in 2024 & a negative 49 Days
2023&63 negative Days in 2022 , largely on account of the quicker
payment to the trade creditors.
1.Receivable
Sales
Turnover 20.6526 10.1619
Receivables
2.Receivable Days 365 17.6755 35.9184
Receivables Turn Over
30
5.Payables Turnover Purchases
Payables
1.Receivable Turnover:
The receivable turnover ratio indicates how quickly the companies collect their
accounts receivable. A higher ratio is generally favourable, as it implies faster
collection. In this case, HUL has a higher receivable turnover of 20.65 x as
compared to Dabur of 10.16 x, indicating that HUL churns its receivables more
quickly as compared to Dabur.
2. Receivable Days:
The receivable days ratio represents the average number of days it takes for the
companies to collect their accounts receivable. A lower number indicates
quicker collection. As a consequence of a higher turnover ratio for HUL, it has a
lower receivable days 17.67 Days compared to Dabur’s 35.91 Days, indicating
that HUL collects its receivables relatively more quickly.
3. Inventory Turnover:
The inventory turnover ratio measures how efficiently the companies manage
their inventory. A higher ratio suggests better inventory management. In this
case, HUL has a higher inventory turnover 15.86 x compared to Dabur’s 2.78x,
indicating that HUL marginally manages its inventory more efficiently.
4. Inventory Days:
The inventory days ratio represents the average number of days it takes for the
companies to sell their inventory. A lower number suggests faster turnover. In
this case, Dabur has lower inventory days 76 Days compared to HUL’s 43,
indicating that Dabur has a slightly lower holding period for inventory.
5. Payables Turnover:
31
The payables turnover ratio shows how quickly the companies pay their
suppliers. A higher ratio suggests faster payment. In this case, HUL has a higher
payables turnover compared to Dabur, indicating that HUL pays its suppliers
more quickly.
6. Payable Days:
The payable days ratio represents the average number of days it takes for the
companies to pay their payables. A higher number suggests slower payment. In
this case, HUL has a lower payable day’s ratio compared to Dabur, indicating
that HUL pays its payables more quickly.
7. Operating Cycle:
The operating cycle represents the average time it takes for the companies to
convert their inventory into cash through sales. It is calculated by adding the
inventory days and the receivable days. In this case, both companies have a
similar operating cycle, with a slightly longer operating cycle for Dabur.
The cash conversion period is the time it takes for the companies to convert
their investments in inventory and accounts receivable into cash. It is calculated
by subtracting the payable days from the operating cycle. A negative value
indicates that the companies receive cash from customers before they need to
pay their suppliers. In this case, both companies have negative cash conversion
periods, but HUL has a higher cash conversion period compared to Dabur
32
4.Interest Coverage 42.69
Ratio EBIT 130.49 120.78
Finance Cost
HUL has a consistent Debt to Equity Ratio of 0.430 for 31st March 2022 &
2023 and 31st March 2024 is 0.738. The ratio suggests a moderate level of
leverage, with a significant portion of the company's assets financed by
equity.
HUL's Debt Ratio has decreased by 0.007 to 2022 to 2023. The marginal
decrease indicates that the company relies less on debt to finance its assets.
A lower Debt Ratio suggests a lower financial risk and a greater reliance on
equity for financing.
HUL's Equity Ratio has increased this in the 2022 is 0.920 to 2023 is 0.927
to 2024 is 0.992. This indicates that a larger portion of the company's assets
is funded by equity. A higher Equity Ratio suggests a stronger financial
position and a lower dependency on debt financing.
HUL's Interest Coverage Ratio has improved from 130.49 in 2023 to 42.69
in 2024. This indicates that the company's EBIT is sufficient to cover its
interest expenses comfortably. A higher Interest Coverage Ratio signifies a
better ability to fulfil interest obligations.
33
Ratio
Finance Cost
HUL has a lower Debt to Equity Ratio compared to Dabur. HUL's lower
ratio suggests a relatively lower reliance on debt for financing its
operations, whereas Dabur has a higher ratio indicating a higher
proportion of debt in its capital structure.
HUL has lower Debt Ratio than Dabur. HUL’s lower ratio indicates a
lower reliance on debt financing in its capital structure compared to
Dabur.
HUL has a higher Equity Ratio compared to Dabur. The Equity Ratio
represents the proportion of a company’s assets that are financed by
equity. HUL’s higher ratio indicates a higher reliance on equity financing
and a lower reliance on debt Financing compared to Dabur.
HUL has a higher Interest Coverage Ratio than Dabur. HUL’s higher
ratio indicates a stronger ability to fulfil its interest obligations compared
to Dabur.
34
NEED IDENTIFICATION:
Based on the Ratio Analysis done focusing on the working capital issues a need
for further investigation on the relationship between the profitability and
liquidity of company.
This need was strengthened based on the emphasis the officials at HUL made
while interacting with them on the importance of the management of working
capital, essentially inventory. The location of the internship was at Chiplun
Factory which is one among the Home care production unit of HUL, hence the
emphasis was more on managing Inventory and Cash. At the same time
controlling costs was also a conscious exercise being carried out. This effort
emphasised the relationship between and the need to balance between liquidity
and profitability.
Before delving into the core investigation of the relationship it was considered
appropriate to look at an additional third competitor, namely P&G, along with
HUL and Dabur.
35
the more money it needs to keep in reserve, which can eat into profits.
RESEARCH HYPOTHESIS
Hypothesis I
36
Null (H0): There is no significant relationship between Profitability attributed to
the Gross Profit of a company and its Liquidity reflected in its Current Ratio.
INTERPRETATION:
The following the corresponding interpretation have emerged during the course
of the internship and the analysis leading to the finalization of the Report.
How dispatch works and its key performance like on time delivery,
order accuracy, truck utilization.
37
Implementing SAP facilitates real-time monitoring and
management of the supply chain, enabling the organization to
respond swiftly to changes and maintain a competitive edge.
FINDINGS:
38
RECOMMENDATION:
CONCLUSION:
39
Additionally, while adjusting to the work environment, i have gained insights
into the challenges and opportunities it presents. This experience has fostered
personal growth and equipped me with valuable skills that can be applied in
future professional endeavours.
Lastly, based on our observations and analysis during the project, we can
suggest measures to improve working capital management for the company.
These measures may include optimizing inventory levels, implementing
efficient cash flow management practices, and exploring potential cost-saving
opportunities. By adopting these suggestions, the company can enhance its
overall financial health and improve its ability to meet short-term obligations
while maximizing profitability.
Overall, this project has been instrumental in bridging the gap between
theoretical knowledge and practical application. It has provided a valuable
learning experience, enabling us to understand the intricacies of in-bound
supply chain logistics, cost management, workplace dynamics, personal growth,
and working capital management.
40
REFRENCES
https://www.hul.co.in/
toaz.info-the-ceo-factory-pr_039008df3d3de35781de07c69b3733a2.pdf
https://www.moneycontrol.com/
https://www.screener.in/
41
BALANCE SHEET OF Mar-24 Mar-23 Mar-22
HINDUSTAN
UNILEVER (in Rs. Cr.)
SHAREHOLDER'S
FUNDS
NON-CURRENT
LIABILITIES
CURRENT LIABILITIES
42
TOTAL CAPITAL AND 77,076.00 71,825.00 69,737.00
LIABILITIES
ASSETS
NON-CURRENT
ASSETS
Other Assets 0 0 0
CURRENT ASSETS
CIF VALUE OF
IMPORTS
Raw Materials 0 0 0
43
Trade/Other Goods 0 0 0
Capital Goods 0 0 0
EXPENDITURE IN
FOREIGN EXCHANGE
REMITTANCES IN
FOREIGN
CURRENCIES FOR
DIVIDENDS
Dividend Remittance In -- -- --
Foreign Currency
EARNINGS IN FOREIGN
EXCHANGE
BONUS DETAILS
NON-CURRENT
INVESTMENTS
Non-Current Investments -- -- --
Quoted Market Value
Non-Current Investments 1 1 2
Unquoted Book Value
CURRENT
INVESTMENTS
44
KEY FINANCIAL
RATIOS OF HINDUSTAN Mar-24 Mar-23 Mar-22
UNILEVER (in Rs. Cr.)
45
PER SHARE RATIOS
Book Value
[ExclRevalReserve]/Shar 216.91 213.71 207.49
e (Rs.)
Book Value
[InclRevalReserve]/Share 216.91 213.71 207.49
(Rs.)
Dividend / Share(Rs.) 42 39 34
Revenue from
257.31 251.68 217.84
Operations/Share (Rs.)
PROFITABILITY RATIOS
46
Return on Capital
21.74 21.99 20.19
Employed (%)
LIQUIDITY RATIOS
VALUATION RATIOS
EV/Net Operating
8.7 10.09 9.33
Revenue (X)
MarketCap/Net Operating
8.82 10.17 9.41
Revenue (X)
47
Retention Ratios (%) 7.07 15.08 14.73
48
49
50