Midterms Reviewer
Midterms Reviewer
What is Taxation?
• State Power: The government's inherent right to collect contributions (taxes)
from its people.
• Process: The way the government levies and enforces tax collection.
• Cost Distribution: How the government allocates its expenses by
requiring contributions from those who benefit from its services.
Why Taxation?
• Government Funding: Governments need money to provide
essential services (defense, education, etc.). This need is the basis of
taxation.
• Basis of Taxation: There's a mutual support system where citizens
receive benefits (services) and provide funds (taxes).
• Benefit Presumed: Everyone benefits from government services, directly
or indirectly, so taxes are required, even if you don't use every service
directly.
Theories of Cost Allocation
• Benefit Received Theory: Pay more taxes if you benefit more from
government services.
• Ability to Pay Theory: Consider a taxpayer's financial capacity.
o Vertical Equity: Those with higher incomes pay a larger percentage
(or amount) of taxes.
o Horizontal Equity: People with similar financial situations should
pay similar taxes.
The Lifeblood Doctrine
• Taxes are Essential: Taxes are vital for the government to function.
• Implications:
o Taxes exist even without specific constitutional grants.
o Tax exemptions are interpreted narrowly (against the taxpayer).
o The government chooses what to tax.
o Courts generally don't interfere with tax collection.
o Income received in advance is taxable.
o Deductions may be limited.
Inherent Powers of the State
• Taxation: Power to collect contributions.
• Police Power: Power to enact laws for people’s well-being.
• Eminent Domain: Power to take private property for public use (with
compensation).
• Similarities: All are necessary for a government to function, inherent,
legislative, and impact private rights.
Scope of Taxation
• Comprehensive: Taxation is broad, plenary (complete), unlimited, and
supreme.
• Limitations: There are limits, both inherent and constitutionalLimitations of
Taxation
• Inherent Limitations:
o Territoriality: Taxes generally apply within the state's borders.
o International Comity: Respect for other nations (e.g., not taxing
foreign embassies).
o Public Purpose: Taxes must be used for the common good, not private
gain.
o Government Exemption: The government generally doesn't tax
itself.
o Non-Delegation: Taxing power is primarily held by the legislature
(Congress), with some exceptions (e.g., local governments).
• Constitutional Limitations: Many, including:
o Due process and equal protection.
o Uniformity and progressivity.
o Restrictions on imprisonment for debt, freedom of religion, and
non-impairment of contracts.
o Specific rules about tax exemptions.
Stages of Taxation
1. Levy or Imposition: Congress passes tax laws.
Congress (PH)
1. Senate – 24 members (nationwide vote)
2. House of Representatives – ~316 members (district + party-list)
Law-making process = 3 Readings (in both houses):
ART Bills =
• Appropriation
• Revenue
• Tariff
Start ONLY in the House of Representatives (Lower House)
Senate can amend, but cannot originate ART bills
2. Gross Estate
• Definition: The gross estate includes the value of all property owned by the
deceased at the time of their death, whether it is real property (like land
and buildings) or personal property (like money and personal belongings),
and whether it is tangible (physical items) or intangible (like stocks or
bonds).
• Nonresident Decedents: If the deceased was not a citizen of the
Philippines, only the part of their gross estate located in the Philippines is
taxable.
A. Components of Gross Estate
• Decedent's Interest:
• This refers to the interest (ownership rights) the deceased had in their
property at the time of death.
• Transfer in Contemplation of Death:
• This includes any property the deceased transferred (gave away) while
expecting to die soon, or that they intended to take effect after their
death. This also includes transfers where the deceased kept some
rights, such as:
1. The right to use or earn income from the property.
2. The right to decide who will receive the property or its
income, unless it was a bona fide sale (a genuine sale) for a
fair price.
• Revocable Transfer:
1. This refers to transfers made by the deceased that could be
changed or canceled by them before their death. This includes
situations where the deceased had the power to change the
terms of the transfer.
2. For this rule, the power to change or cancel a transfer is
considered to exist at the time of death, even if the change was
supposed to happen later. If the deceased had not given notice or
made the change before their death, it is treated as if they had
done so on the date of death.
• Property Passing Under General Power of Appointment:
• This includes property that the deceased could control through
a general power of appointment (the authority to decide who will
receive the property) exercised by them:
1. By a will (a legal document stating how to distribute property
after death), or
2. By a deed (a legal document for transferring property) made
with the intention of taking effect after death.
• Proceeds of Life Insurance:
• This refers to the money that the estate (the total assets of the
deceased) or designated beneficiaries receive from life insurance
policies taken out by the deceased, regardless of whether the
deceased could change the policy.
• Prior Interests:
• This applies to various transfers and interests, regardless of when they
were created, and includes the rules mentioned in the previous
sections.
• Transfers for Insufficient Consideration:
• If any transfer or trust is made for less than its fair value, only the
difference between the fair market value (the price it would sell for)
and what was received will be included in the gross estate.
• Capital of the Surviving Spouse:
• The assets of the surviving spouse (the husband or wife left behind) are
NOT included in the gross estate of the deceased.
These deductions are allowed only if the donor's tax (tax on gifts) or estate
tax was paid for the property received, and only if the value of the property is
included in the decedent's gross estate.
• Transfers for Public Use: This includes any bequests (gifts made in a will),
legacies, or transfers to the Government of the Republic of the
Philippines for public purposes.
• The Family Home: The current fair market value of the family home is
deducted, but if it exceeds Ten million pesos (₱10,000,000), the excess
amount is subject to estate tax.
• Amount Received by Heirs Under Republic Act No. 4917: Any amount
received by the heirs from the deceased’s employee due to the employee's
death under Republic Act No. 4917 is included in the gross estate.
7. Payment of Tax
A. Time of Payment
• The estate tax must be paid at the time the return is filed by
the executor (the person responsible for managing the
estate), administrator, or heirs.
B. Extension of Time
• If paying the estate tax on time would cause undue hardship (significant
difficulty), the Commissioner may allow an extension of:
• Up to five (5) years for estates settled through the courts.
• Up to two (2) years for estates settled outside of court
(extrajudicially).
• The amount due must be paid by the end of the extension period. During this
time, the Statute of Limitations (the legal time limit for tax assessments)
is paused. Extensions are not granted for cases involving negligence (failure
to take proper care) or fraud (deception). If an extension is granted, the
Commissioner may require the executor or administrator to provide
a bond (a financial guarantee) to ensure payment.
C. Payment by Installment
• If the estate does not have sufficient cash to pay the total estate tax, payments
can be made in installments over a period of two (2) years from the due
date without incurring penalties or interest.
D. Liability for Payment
• The estate tax must be paid by the executor or administrator before any
distribution of assets to beneficiaries (those who inherit from the estate).
Beneficiaries are also responsible for paying their share of the estate tax
based on their portion of the estate.
8. Discharge from Personal Liability
• If the executor or administrator requests a determination of the estate tax
amount and seeks a discharge (release) from personal liability,
the Commissioner must respond within one (1) year. Once the executor
pays the determined amount, they are released from personal liability for
any future tax deficiencies (shortfalls).
9. Definition of Deficiency
• Deficiency refers to the amount by which the tax owed exceeds what was
reported on the estate tax return. If no amount is reported, it refers to the
amount exceeding previously assessed taxes.
10. Payment Before Delivery
• Executors cannot distribute shares of the estate to beneficiaries until they
provide proof that the estate tax has been paid in full.
11. Duties of Certain Officers and Debtors
• Registers of Deeds (officials responsible for recording property
transactions) cannot register any property transfer or mortgage without proof
of tax payment. They must notify the Commissioner and other relevant
officials if they discover any unpaid taxes.
• Debtors (those who owe money) of the deceased cannot pay their debts to the
heirs or executor without proof of tax payment. However, they can pay the
executor if the debt is included in the estate inventory (the list of assets and
liabilities of the estate).
12. Restitution of Tax
• If new debts arise after the estate tax has been paid, and these debts are
settled by court order, the parties involved can request a refund of a portion
of the tax paid.
13. Payment of Tax Antecedent to the Transfer
• No shares, bonds, or rights can be transferred to new owners without proof of
tax payment. Banks may allow withdrawals from accounts of deceased
individuals, but these withdrawals are subject to a 6% withholding tax (a tax
deducted at the source before the money is paid out).
Donor Taxation Overview
1. General Overview of Donor’s Tax
o Imposition of Tax (Section 98)
• Donor’s Tax is a tax levied on the transfer of property by way of gift,
regardless of whether the donor is a resident or non-resident.
• Key Elements:
• The tax applies to any transfer of property by gift.
• The transfer can be direct or indirect (e.g., by trust or other arrangements).
• Property subject to the tax includes both real and personal property, whether
tangible or intangible.
Now, how much can you deduct from your Philippine tax?
You can only deduct a portion based on the ratio of foreign gifts to total gifts:
6. Valuation of Gifts
• Property Gifts: The fair market value (the price it would sell for) at the time
of the gift is used to calculate the tax. This means that if you give a car worth
$10,000, that amount is used to determine how much tax you owe.
• Real Property: The FMV of real property is determined using the provisions
of Section 88(B) (related to estate tax valuation).
• The FMV may be based on either the zonal value (as determined by the
Bureau of Internal Revenue) or the assessed value (as listed in the
property tax declarations).