Case 10
Case 10
The case-study method or the method of specific situations (from the English case
- case, situation) is a method of active problem-situational analysis based on
learning by solving specific problem situations (solving cases).- The case-study
method refers to non-game simulation active learning methods and is designed to
gain experience in the following areas:
identification, selection and problem solving;
working with information – understanding the meaning of the details described in
the situation; analyzing and synthesizing information and arguments; working with
assumptions and conclusions; evaluating alternatives; making decisions;
listening to and understanding other people, including group work skills.
The immediate goal of the case-study method is to analyze the situation – case
arising in a particular state of affairs through the joint efforts of students and
develop a practical solution; the end of the process is to evaluate the proposed
algorithms and choose the best one in the context of the problem.
The case itself is a written description of certain conditions from the life of an
organization, group of people or individuals, orienting students to formulate a
problem and search for solutions to it. A case is always a simulation of a life
situation, and working with a case allows you to consider a problem at a desk and
offer your own unique solution.
The case contains comprehensive information about: what is happening, who is
involved in it, when the result should be obtained, why all this is needed (i.e. the
purpose of the task), what resources (time, money, people, powers, etc.) can be
used? There is only no answer to the question: how to achieve the goal and get the
desired result? This is what the participant is invited to solve, who, like a
mathematical problem, must solve the case.
Case requirements
The case - example taken from real life is not just a true description of events, but a
single information complex that allows you to understand the situation. A good
case must meet the following conditions:
-meet a clearly defined goal of creation;
-have the appropriate difficulty level;
illustrate several aspects of economic life;
-don't become obsolete too quickly;
be relevant for today;
-illustrate typical situations;
-develop analytical thinking;
-provoke a discussion;
have multiple solutions.
Classification of cases
The basis is complexity:
illustrative educational situations - cases, the purpose of which is to teach the
algorithm of making the right decision in a certain situation by a certain practical
example; educational situations - cases with the formation of a problem, in which
the situation is described in a specific period of time, problems are identified and
clearly formulated; the purpose of such a case is to diagnose the situation and make
an independent decision on the specified problem;
educational situations are cases without forming a problem, which describe a more
complex situation than in the previous version, where the problem is not clearly
identified, but is presented in statistical data, assessments of public opinion,
authorities, etc.; the purpose of such a case is to independently identify the
problem, indicate alternative ways to solve it with an analysis of available
resources;
applied exercises that describe a specific situation, it is proposed to find ways out
of it; the purpose of such a case is to find ways to solve the problem.
Foundation - goals and objectives of the learning process:
training analysis and evaluation;
problem solving and decision making tutorials;
illustrating the problem, solution, or concept as a whole.
The basis is information saturation
a structured (highly structured) "case", in which a minimum amount of
additional information is given; when working with it, the student must apply a
certain model or formula; there is an optimal solution for problems of this type;
"small sketches" (short vignettes), containing, as a rule, from one to ten pages
of text and one or two pages of appendices; they introduce only key concepts and
when parsing them, the student must also rely on his own knowledge;
-large unstructured "cases" (long unstructured cases) with a volume of up to 50
pages are the most difficult of all types of educational tasks of this kind; they give
very detailed information, including completely unnecessary; the most necessary
information for analysis, on the contrary, may be missing; the student must
recognize such "tricks" and cope with them;
-groundbreaking "cases" (ground breaking cases), in the analysis of which
students are required not only to apply already acquired theoretical knowledge and
practical skills, but also to offer something new, while students and teachers act as
researchers.
The basis is the degree of exposure to sources:
practical cases that reflect absolutely real life situations (the main task of the
practical case is to reflect the life situation in detail and in detail. In fact, such a
case creates a practical, what is called a "working" model of the situation. At the
same time, the educational purpose of such a case can be reduced to training
students, consolidating knowledge, skills and behavioral skills (decision-making)
in this situation. Such cases should be as visual and detailed as possible. Their
main meaning boils down to the knowledge of life and the acquisition of the ability
to optimal activity);
training cases, the main task of which is training (the case with the dominance of
the training function reflects life not one to one: firstly, it reflects typical situations
that are most frequent in life, and which a specialist will have to face in the course
of his professional activity; secondly, in the training case, educational and
educational tasks are in the first place, which predetermines a significant element
of conditionality when reflecting life in it; the situation, problem and plot here are
not real, practical, but such as they may be in life);
-research cases focused on the implementation of research activities (the case
serves as a model for obtaining new knowledge about the situation and behavior in
it. Such a case is being built according to the principles of creating a research
model, therefore it is better to use it not as a method of teaching basic educational,
but as a method of professional development or professional retraining of
specialists.).
Sources of case formation
1. Artistic and journalistic literature, which can suggest ideas, and in some cases
determine the plot outline of cases in the humanities. The use of fiction and
journalism gives the case a culturological function, stimulates the moral
development of the student's personality.
2. The use of "local" material as a source of case formation. The most intense and
interesting discussion of cases about the activities of different companies occurs
when the company and its products have a certain personal significance for the
student. The case of Samsung goes best when there are students in the group who
have products developed by this company at home. The case of the development of
ski tourism in Demino is discussed with the greatest interest by fans of skiing…
3. The scientific nature and rigor of the case are given by statistical materials,
information about the state of the market, socio-economic characteristics of the
enterprise, etc.; at the same time, these materials can play the role of a direct tool
for diagnosing the situation, and can act as a material for calculating indicators that
are most essential for understanding the situation. Statistical materials are placed
either in the text of the case itself or in the appendix.
4. Sound materials for the case can be obtained by analyzing scientific articles,
monographs and scientific reports on a particular problem. The use of scientific
literature in the development of the case gives it greater rigor and correctness.
Scientific publications can perform two functions in the case-study method: the
first is that scientific publications and their fragments can act as components of
cases by including them in the fabric, and the second is that they can be included in
the list of literature necessary for understanding the case.
5. An inexhaustible source of material for case studies is the Internet with its
resources. This source is characterized by significant scale, flexibility and
efficiency.
Interviews
Documents
Archival records
Direct observations and encounters
Participant observation
Facts and statistics
Physical artifacts