Proposed Machine Learning-Enabled Framework to

Predict Consumer Behavior in the Retail Sector

Abstract—Machine-learning frameworks provide a variety Retail consumer clustering is a powerful tool for
of tools, such as data preprocessing and model training utilities, understanding consumer behavior [4]. It involves grouping
to aid in the development of sophisticated machine-learning customers into clusters based on their purchasing habits or
models. Furthermore, they frequently include features such as
other characteristics [4]. This helps retailers better
automatic hyperparameter tuning to improve model
performance. Consumer behavior prediction is an important
understand their customers and identify trends in their
tool for retailers because it allows them to tailor their behavior [4]. Market basket analysis is another technique
marketing and product offerings to their customer’s needs and that helps retailers understand their customers by analyzing
preferences. Machine learning frameworks can be used to the items they purchase together [5]. Association rule
create predictive models that can assist retailers in mining is a method of extracting useful information from
understanding customer behavior and anticipating future large datasets by discovering relationships between variables
trends. These models can be used to identify potential customer [6]. Association post-processing is a technique used to refine
segments and target them with tailored campaigns. These and optimize the results of association rule mining, ensuring
models can also be used to create personalized product
that the most useful information is extracted [7]. The most
recommendations for customers as well as identify potential
cross-selling opportunities. The goal of this paper is to propose suitable machine learning technique to be applied as a post-
a machine-learning-enabled framework" for identifying trends processing technique is “Reinforcement Learning”.
in consumer behavior through the use of clustering and “Reinforcement Learning is a type of ML that focuses on
association rule mining techniques to gain insight into the data learning from rewards and punishments” [8].
and enable data-driven decision-making. The overall These techniques are all key components of the proposed
performance of the proposed framework will be determined by machine learning framework for predicting consumer
the accuracy and reliability of the predictive models used, as behavior in the retail sector. Clustering helps identify
well as the evaluation of the framework's predictions customer segments, market basket analysis can uncover
Keywords—Machine-Learning; Framework; Consumer
trends in purchasing behavior [9], and association rule
Behavior; Prediction. mining and post-processing can be used to uncover
relationships between products and customers [6]. By using
I. INTRODUCTION these techniques in combination, the framework can provide
The retail sector is a complex and ever-evolving market valuable insights into consumer behavior in the retail sector
that relies heavily on customer behavior [1]. The ability to that can be used to make more informed business decisions.
accurately predict consumer behavior is essential to any retail B. Contribution to the Retail Sector
business [1]. Machine learning (ML) offers a powerful set of
tools to gain insight into and facilitate data-driven decision- The proposed machine learning framework is expected to
making. This paper proposes a machine-learning framework make a significant contribution to the retail sector by
for accurately predicting consumer behavior in the retail providing retailers with actionable insights into consumer
sector. The proposed framework introduces two techniques behavior. By leveraging the power of ML, the framework
to achieve this goal: clustering and association mining [2]. will enable retailers to identify customer segments, uncover
trends in purchase behavior, and uncover relationships
The problem of how to accurately predict consumer between products and customers [10]. This will enable
behavior in the retail sector can be solved by leveraging the retailers to make more informed decisions and better
power of machine learning [3]. “The purpose of this paper is understand the needs of their customers. In addition, the
to propose a machine learning-enabled framework” to framework will provide retailers with the ability to quickly
identify trends in consumer behavior by using clustering and and accurately predict consumer behavior and respond to
association rule mining techniques to gain insight into the changes in the market [11]. This will allow retailers to stay
data and enable data-driven decision-making. ahead of their competition and remain competitive in the
ever-changing retail sector. Ultimately, the proposed
A. Background
framework is expected to significantly improve the
“Machine learning is a field of artificial intelligence that efficiency, effectiveness, sustainability, and profitability of
focuses on the development of computer programs that can retail operations.
learn and adapt from data” [3]. ML algorithms are used to
detect patterns in data and to make predictions about future II. METHODOLOGY
behavior. In the proposed framework, unsupervised ML is The methodological approach for the proposed machine
used to identify patterns in consumer behavior data and to learning-enabled framework involves an analysis,
make accurate predictions about future consumer behavior requirement, framework construction, and performance
[3]. ML algorithms such as clustering, association rule evaluation phases as shown in Figure 1 below.
mining, and market basket analysis, are used to gain insight
into consumer behavior, and the results of these algorithms
are used to drive more informed decisions.

XXX-X-XXXX-XXXX-X/XX/$XX.00 ©20XX IEEE

 into clusters of similar points [15]. The K-mean algorithm
works by randomly assigning data points to clusters and then
iteratively moving the data points to the cluster that is closest
to its center [16]. This algorithm is used to identify
meaningful clusters in data that can be used to gain insights
Fig. 1. The Methodological Approach. into consumer behavior [13].
The analysis phase involves gathering and analyzing data “Additionally, Association rule mining with the frequent
related to customer behavior. This includes techniques such pattern (FP)-growth algorithm is used to discover association
as clustering and market basket analysis and can involve data rules by identifying relationships between items in the data”
from surveys, customer feedback, customer databases, sales [6]. This stage allows the machine learning algorithms to be
and marketing campaigns, and other resources [12]. The used in order to make predictions about customer behavior
requirement phase involves defining the objectives and [16]. Association rule mining is a technique used to identify
requirements of the framework, such as the types of insights relationships between data points by analyzing their co-
it should provide and the level or degree of accuracy of the occurrence. The FP-growth algorithm is an efficient and
predictions. The framework construction phase involves scalable algorithm used to mine frequent itemsets from large
designing and implementing the proposed machine learning datasets [6]. It works by constructing a frequent itemset tree
framework. This includes selecting the appropriate ML (FP-tree) which is used to identify frequent itemsets in the
algorithms and techniques, designing the data architecture, data. The algorithm then uses this tree to generate association
and building the framework. The performance evaluation rules that can be used to uncover relationships between
phase involves testing the framework and assessing its variables. The FP-growth algorithm is fast and scalable,
performance. This includes metrics such as accuracy, making it an ideal tool for association rule mining in the
precision, recall, and other measures of effectiveness. The retail sector [22].
results of the evaluation can then be used to refine and
optimize the framework [13]. The Post-processing stage is used to support the
understanding of the association rule results [6]. It involves
A. The Proposed Framework refining the predictions made by the machine learning
For the framework construction, we follow the spiral algorithms. This includes adjusting the predictions based on
model (iterative process) in cooperation with the retail sector. known customer behavior, using data from other sources,
The spiral model is an iterative process that can be used in such as customer surveys, or using a new machine learning
any framework construction [13]. This model involves technique such as reinforcement learning [17].
iteratively building, testing, and improving the framework Reinforcement Learning can be used to optimize the results
[13]. The process begins by defining the objectives and of association rule post-processing by learning from rewards
requirements of the framework. “This is followed by and punishments associated with specific rules [8]. This will
designing and implementing the framework, followed by enable the post-processing stage to identify the most relevant
testing and performance evaluation. Based on the results of and useful association rules, providing the framework with
the evaluation, the framework can be refined ad improved more accurate and actionable insights [18].
before the process is repeated”. This iterative process ensures
that the framework is continuously optimized, allowing the “In the context of the proposed framework, the most
framework to provide accurate and actionable insights [13]. suitable reinforcement learning technique to be applied to the
The framework and its stages are illustrated in Figure 2 association rules in predicting consumer behavior is the Q-
below. learning reinforcement learning algorithm [19]. The basic Q-
learning algorithm works by assigning a score (“Q-value”) to
each possible action taken by the agent, which is updated as
the agent interacts with its environment [19]. The “Q-value”
is updated based on the reward received from taking an
action and the expected future reward from taking the same
action. Over time, the “Q-value” for each action converges to
Fig. 2. The Framework and its Iterative Process
the optimal value, allowing the agent to make better
The preprocessing stage is necessary “to ensure that the decisions [19]. This approach can be used to identify the best
data is suitable for the machine learning algorithms” [14]. marketing or product offering strategies based on the reward
This stage involves cleaning the data, transforming it into a received from previous interactions with customers [19].
format suitable for the algorithms, and removing any outliers. The experiment and evaluation stage involves testing the
By transforming the data, it can be used in an efficient predictions made by the machine learning algorithms. This
manner [14]. includes using actual customer data to test the accuracy of
The predictive model stage of the framework is the the predictions and evaluating the results of the experiments.
“Market Prediction Engine”. It uses Unsupervised Learning This helps to ensure that the predictions from the machine
such as clustering and using K-mean (centroid-based learning algorithms are accurate, reliable, and useful [20].
clustering) algorithm to identify patterns in the data. The
proposed predictive model is based on unsupervised learning III. DISCUSSION OF THE FRAMEWORK
and association rules mining algorithms [20]. “Unsupervised The performance of our proposed framework will depend
learning is a type of machine learning that focuses on finding on the accuracy and reliability of the predictive models used
patterns in data without being given labeled data”. Clustering i.e. the accuracy of unsupervised learning and association
is a popular unsupervised learning technique that involves rule mining. The accuracy of our predictive models will be
grouping data points together based on their similarities. K- determined by the quality of the data used, the complexity of
mean is an algorithm that uses clustering to group data points the models, and the optimization of the model parameters
 [21]. “The reliability of the models will depend on the performance of the framework will depend on the accuracy
accuracy of the model predictions and the ability of the and reliability of the predictive models.
model to generalize to new data. The overall performance of In the future, the proposed framework could further
the framework can be evaluated by measuring the accuracy be optimized by exploring additional unsupervised and
and reliability of the predictive models and by assessing the supervised learning algorithms, such as neural networks and
insights gained from the framework” [22]. deep learning [28]. Additionally, the framework could be
Several consumer behaviors predicting machine learning- expanded to include additional data sources and predictive
based methods have been in development in the past decade. models to provide more comprehensive insights into
In 2012, Calvert & Brammer applied machine learning to consumer behavior. Finally, the framework could be tested
functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) data and used in a real-world setting to assess its effectiveness in
unbiased pattern recognition algorithms to pretest and predicting consumer behavior.
classify marketing communications, so as to predict
consumer acceptance of new brands, products, and REFERENCES
campaigns [23]. This work was primarily based on brain- [1] M. M. Mohammed, N. A. Mohamed, A. A. Adam,
imaging techniques while our proposed framework is not. In S. S. Ahmed, and F. A. Saeed, ‘Current Directions
2017, Khodabandehlou & Zivari Rahman compared and Future Research Priorities of Customer Data
supervised machine learning techniques that predict customer Analysis, Journal of Information Systems and
churn based on the analysis of customer behavior and found Informatics, vol. 2, no. 2, pp. 300–311, Sep. 2020,
artificial neural networks to be the most accurate [24]. This doi: 10.33557/journalist.v2i2.75.
study used supervised machine-learning techniques but our [2] S. B. Aher and L. M. R. J. Lobo, ‘Combination of machine
proposed framework uses unsupervised machine-learning learning algorithms for recommendation of courses in E-
techniques. Learning System based on historical data’, Knowl Based Syst,
vol. 51, pp. 1–14, Oct. 2013, doi: 10.1016/j.knosys.2013.04.015.
Valecha et al examined the relationship between [3] C. Gambella, B. Ghaddar, and J. Naoum-Sawaya, ‘Optimization
consumer behavior parameters and willingness to buy using a problems for machine learning: A survey’, Eur J Oper Res, vol.
“time-evolving random forest classifier algorithm [25]. They 290, no. 3, pp. 807–828, May 2021, doi:
showed that the random forest classifier predictions were 10.1016/j.ejor.2020.08.045.
[4] H. Rao, Z. Zeng, and A. Liu, ‘Research on personalized referral
more accurate than those of other machine learning service and big data mining for e-commerce with machine
algorithms [25]. Random forest classifiers are however learning’, in 2018 4th International Conference on Computer
difficult to interpret as the individual decision trees used in and Technology Applications (ICCTA), May 2018, pp. 35–38.
the model are usually invisible. Li et al used a “decision doi: 10.1109/CATA.2018.8398652.
tree, cluster analysis, and Naive Bayes algorithm to analyze [5] Y. A. Ünvan, ‘Market basket analysis with association rules’,
Commun Stat Theory Methods, vol. 50, no. 7, pp. 1615–1628,
customer characteristics and attributes with historical Apr. 2021, doi: 10.1080/03610926.2020.1716255.
purchase records”. They demonstrated that the prediction [6] M. A. Alyobi and A. A. Jamjoom, ‘A Visualization Framework
effect of the decision tree is better than clustering analysis for Post-Processing of Association Rule Mining. ’, International
and the Naive Bayesian algorithm [9]. However, decision Journal Transaction on Machine Learning and Data Mining,
trees are prone to overfitting and the creation of overly vol. 2020, no. 2, pp. 82–99, 2020.
[7] P. Berka and J. Rauch, ‘Meta-learning for Post-processing of
complex models which can lead to inaccurate predictions Association Rules’, 2010, pp. 251–262. doi: 10.1007/978-3-642-
when dealing with unseen data or when generalizing to new 15105-7_20.
data. Lee et al compared machine learning techniques for [8] A. Krajna, M. Brcic, T. Lipic, and J. Doncevic, ‘Explainability
predicting online consumer purchase behavior and found “the in reinforcement learning: perspective and position.’
eXtreme Gradient Boosting (XGBoost) model to be the most ArXiv:203.11547 [Cs], 2022.
[9] J. Li, S. Pan, L. Huang, and X. Zhu, ‘A Machine Learning Based
suitable for predicting purchase conversion of online Method for Customer Behavior Prediction’, Tehnicki vjesnik -
consumers” [26]. The “XGBoost model” is still insufficient Technical Gazette, vol. 26, no. 6, Nov. 2019, doi: 10.17559/TV-
for the entire retail sector since it is computationally 20190603165825.
expensive to train, can be difficult to interpret, and tends to [10] K. Kohara and T. Tsuda, ‘Creating Product Maps with Self-
become over-specialized to the training data. Tian et al based Organizing Maps for Purchase Decision Making. ’,
Transactions on Machine Learning and Data Mining, vol. 3, no.
their consumer behavior prediction model on “the recurrent 2, pp. 51–66, 2010.
Deep Neural Network (rDNN) model, which gave the best [11] I. Bose and R. K. Mahapatra, ‘Business data mining — a
prediction effect on consumer behavior, when compared to machine learning perspective’, Information & Management, vol.
other machine learning models” [27] . However, it lacks 39, no. 3, pp. 211–225, Dec. 2001, doi: 10.1016/S0378-
interpretability, is a "black-box" model, and is 7206(01)00091-X.
[12] H. J. Christanto and Y. A. Singgalen, ‘Sentiment Analysis of
computationally intensive and slow to train. Customer Feedback Reviews Towards Hotel’s Products and
Services in Labuan Bajo.’, Journal of Information Systems and
IV. CONCLUSION AND FUTURE WORK Informatics, vol. 4, no. 4, pp. 805–822, 2022.
This paper proposes a machine-learning framework [13] A. C. Gopal and L. Jacob, ‘Customer Behavior Analysis Using
Unsupervised Clustering and Profiling: A Machine Learning
for predicting consumer behavior in the retail sector. The Approach’, in 2022 2nd International Conference on Advance
framework is based on clustering, association rule mining, Computing and Innovative Technologies in Engineering
market basket analysis, and association post-processing. (ICACITE), Apr. 2022, pp. 2075–2078. doi:
Unsupervised learning (clustering and k-means) and 10.1109/ICACITE53722.2022.9823646.
[14] M. Vattulainen, ‘Preprocessing Optimization for Predictive
association mining (FP-growth) are proposed as predictive Classification: Baseline Results from Six Industry Cases. ’,
models to gain insight into consumer behavior and enable Transactions on Machine Learning and Data Mining, vol. 9, no.
data and information-driven decision-making. The expected 2, 2016.
[15] M. Song and S. Rajasekaran, ‘Fast Algorithms for Constant Artificial Intelligence and Information Technology (ICAIIT),
Approximation k-Means Clustering. ’, Transactions on Machine Mar. 2019, pp. 230–233. doi: 10.1109/ICAIIT.2019.8834571.
Learning and Data Mining, vol. 3, no. 2, 2010. [23] G. A. Calvert and M. J. Brammer, ‘Predicting Consumer
[16] D. M. R. M. Dissanayake and S. C. Premaratne, ‘Association Behavior: Using Novel Mind-Reading Approaches’, IEEE
Mining Approach for Customer Behavior Analytics.’ Pulse, vol. 3, no. 3, pp. 38–41, May 2012, doi:
International Journal of Computer Science Engineering, vol. 9, 10.1109/MPUL.2012.2189167.
no. 1, 2020. [24] S. Khodabandehlou and M. Zivari Rahman, ‘Comparison of
[17] C. Szepesvári, ‘Algorithms for Reinforcement Learning’, supervised machine learning techniques for customer churn
Synthesis Lectures on Artificial Intelligence and Machine prediction based on analysis of customer behavior’, Journal of
Learning, vol. 4, no. 1, pp. 1–103, Jan. 2010, doi: Systems and Information Technology, vol. 19, no. 1/2, pp. 65–
10.2200/S00268ED1V01Y201005AIM009. 93, Mar. 2017, doi: 10.1108/JSIT-10-2016-0061.
[18] Q. Yang, ‘Post-processing Data Mining Models for [25] H. Valecha, A. Varma, I. Khare, A. Sachdeva, and M. Goyal,
Actionability’, in Data Mining for Business Applications, ‘Prediction of Consumer Behaviour using Random Forest
Boston, MA: Springer US, pp. 11–30. doi: 10.1007/978-0-387- Algorithm’, in 2018 5th IEEE Uttar Pradesh Section
79420-4_2. International Conference on Electrical, Electronics and
[19] B. Jang, M. Kim, G. Harerimana, and J. W. Kim, ‘Q-Learning Computer Engineering (UPCON), Nov. 2018, pp. 1–6. doi:
Algorithms: A Comprehensive Classification and Applications, 10.1109/UPCON.2018.8597070.
IEEE Access, vol. 7, pp. 133653–133667, 2019, doi: [26] Lee Jungwon, Jung Okkyung, Lee Yunhye, Kim Ohsung, and
10.1109/ACCESS.2019.2941229. Park Cheol, ‘A Comparison and Interpretation of Machine
[20] A. Salamzadeh, P. Ebrahimi, M. Soleimani, and M. Fekete- Learning Algorithm for the Prediction of Online Purchase
Farkas, ‘Grocery Apps and Consumer Purchase Behavior: Conversion’, J. Theor. Appl. Electron. Commer. Res., vol. 16,
Application of Gaussian Mixture Model and Multi-Layer no. 5, pp. 1472–1491, 2021.
Perceptron Algorithm’, Journal of Risk and Financial [27] Y. Tian, Y. Lai, and C. Yang, ‘Research of Consumption
Management, vol. 15, no. 10, p. 424, Sep. 2022, doi: Behavior Prediction Based on Improved DNN’, Sci Program,
10.3390/jrfm15100424. vol. 2022, pp. 1–9, Jun. 2022, doi: 10.1155/2022/6819525.
[21] A. Martínez, C. Schmuck, S. Pereverzyev, C. Pirker, and M. [28] N. Ali Hakami and H. A. Hosni Mahmoud, ‘The Prediction of
Haltmeier, ‘A machine learning framework for customer Consumer Behavior from Social Media Activities’, Behavioral
purchase prediction in the non-contractual setting’, Eur J Oper Sciences, vol. 12, no. 8, p. 284, Aug. 2022, doi:
Res, vol. 281, no. 3, pp. 588–596, Mar. 2020, doi: 10.3390/bs12080284”.
10.1016/j.ejor.2018.04.034.
[22] Asniar and K. Surendro, ‘Predictive Analytics for Predicting
Customer Behavior’, in 2019 International Conference of