Labour Law 1
Labour Law 1
LABOUR LAW I
Prepared as per the syllabus prescribed by Karnataka State Law University
(KSLU), Hubballi
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526 ,9972799641
Page 1
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given notes
Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
CONTENTS
PART-I
SYLLABUS:
UNIT-I Historical aspects Master and Slave Relationship, Trade Unionism in India and
UK Enactment of the Trade Unions Act,1926-
ILOConventionsrelatingtoTradeUnionsand relevant Constitutional provisions.
UNIT-3 Law relating to regulation of strikes and lockouts- Definition of strikes and
lockouts, Analysis with reference to Judicial Interpretations, Regulation U/Ss 22,
23, 10-A(4-A), and 10 (3), Illegal strikes and lockouts, penalties.-Regulation of
Job losses- concepts of Lay-off, Retrenchment, Closure and Transfer of
undertakings with reference to statutory definition and Judicial Interpretations
-Regulation of job losses with reference to the provisions of chapter V A and V B
of the ID Act, 1947 - Regulation of managerial prerogatives - Ss. 9A,llA, 33
and33Aof ID Act, 1947 -Certified Standing Orders - Meaning and Procedure for
Certification, Certifying officers- Powers and Functions, etc.
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526
Page 2
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given notes
Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
UNIT-5 The Payment of Wages Act, 1936 -Definitions — employed person, factory,
industrial and other establishment, wages, etc. - Deductions — Authorities -
Inspectors and Payment of Wages Authority.
The Factories Act, 1948 —Definitions -factory, manufacturing process, occupier,
worker, hazardous process, etc. -Provisions of the Factories Act relating to
health, safety and welfare of workers -Provisions relating to Hazardous process
-Provisions relating to working conditions of employment - Working Hours,
Weekly leave, Annual leave facility -Provisions relating to regulation of
employment of women, children and young persons.
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526 ,9972799641
Page 3
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given notes
Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
II PART-II -
NO. CONTENTS Page.No
I. Trade Unions Act, 1926 5-18
Historical aspects-Master and Slave Relationship, Trade Unionism in -
India and UK Enactment of the Trade Unions Act, 1926 -ILO -
Conventions relating to Trade Unions and relevant Constitutional
provisions.
-
A bird's eye view of the Act—Definitions-Trade Union, Trade -
Dispute, etc. Provisions relating to registration, withdrawal and -
cancellation of registration-Funds of Trade Union, Immunities, -
problems of Trade Union, Amalgamation of Trade Union -
Recognition of Trade Unions - Methods, need and efforts in this
-
regard, Collective Bargaining - Meaning, methods, status of
collective bargaining settlements, collective bargaining and
-
liberalization. -
II. Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 19-26
Historical Background and Introduction to the Industrial Disputes Act, -
1947 - Definitions - Industry, Workman, Industrial Dispute, -
Appropriate Government, etc., - Authorities/ Industrial Dispute
-
resolution machinery - Works Committee, Conciliation and Board of
Conciliation -Powers and Functions, Court of Inquiry, Grievance -
Settlement Authority, -
Voluntary Arbitration U/S 10-A, Compulsory Adjudication- -
Government's power of reference U/S- 10 - Critical analysis with -
reference to decided cases.
-
Compulsory Adjudication - Composition, Qualification, Jurisdiction,
powers of adjudication authorities, - Award and Settlement -
-
Definition, Period of operation, binding nature and Juridical Review -
of award. -
-
III. Law relating to regulation of strikes and lockouts- 28-36
Law relating to regulation of strikes and lockouts- Definition of -
strikes and lockouts, Analysis with reference to Judicial -
Interpretations, Regulation U/Ss 22, 23, 10-A(4-A), and10 (3), Illegal -
strikes and lockouts, penalties.-Regulation of Job losses- concepts of
-
Lay-off, Retrenchment, Closure and Transfer of undertakings with
-
reference to statutory definition and Judicial Interpretations –
Regulation of job losses with reference to the provisions of chapter
-
VA and VB of the ID Act, 1947 – Regulation of managerial -
prerogatives - Ss. 9A,llA, 33 and 33Aof ID Act, 1947 -Certified -
-
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526
Page 4
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given notes
Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526 ,9972799641
Page 5
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given notes
Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
IV PART IV Page.No
1 Bare Acts 58-73
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526
Page 6
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given notes
Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
UNIT-I
Historical aspects:
Master and Slave Relationship
Q. Explain Factors responsible for the old theory master and servant?
• A master and servant relationship is determined based upon the amount of control the
employer exercises over the 6 Page 12 service provided by the employee. A master will
be liable for acts of an employee committed while within the scope of employment.
• Since the Industrial Revolution, the law and practice of capital-labour relationship which
is the most important aspect of master and servant relationship have undergone a great
evolution and for the proper understanding of the significance and development of
industrial Jurisprudence, a resume of this evolution is very essential.
• The Nature of Master and Servant Relationship:
• A servant is one who works for another individual, known as the master, with or without
pay. The master and servant relationship only arises when the tasks are performed by the
servant under the direction and control of the master and are subject to the master's
knowledge and consent
• Advocate S. R. Samant observed that: “The words master and servant are suggestive of
the ideas of domination and submission hidden behind them. According to the settled law
of master and servant, the master holds authority over the servant and the servant owes
obeyance to the master. The strong is never wrong and the weak must ever be meek is the
maxim of the master and servant law. The master and the servant are truly the ruler and
the ruled”.
Q. Growth of Trade Unionism in India and UK.
• Trade Unionism in lndia and UK:
• Introduction:
• The law relating to labour and employment in India is primarily known under the broad
category of “Industrial Law”. Labour law seeks to regulate the relations between an
employer or a class of employers and their employees.The commence of industry and its
growth is not a venture of the employer alone; yet it involves the hard work and tough
grind of each and every stakeholder of the industry including the laborers, supervisors,
managers and entrepreneurs.
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526
Page 7
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given notes
Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526
Page 8
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given notes
Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526
Page 9
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given notes
Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526
Page 10
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given notes
Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526
Page 11
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given notes
Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
• Section 17 of the Trade Unions Act of 1926 exempts registered trade union officers
from prosecution for criminal conspiracy.
• A registered trade union is granted immunity under the Trade Union Act of 1926.
This immunity is only applicable to legal agreements made by a trade union’s
members for the stimulation of legitimate objects of a trade union, so it is only
partially available. One right given to registered trade unions to help them settle
trade disputes is the right to call for a strike and try to get their members to join. All
acts that give rise to civil lawsuits are considered illegal acts.
• Problems of Trade Union:
1. Multiplicity of unions: A number of unions exist in one industrial unit.
2. Absence of union structure: The structure of the trade union may be a craft
union, industrial union or the general union.
3. Limited membership: A trade union cannot become strong unless it can enroll
large number of workers as its members.
4. Scarcity of finances: The main problem faced by trade unions in India is the
paucity of financial resources.
5. Small size: On account of the limited membership, the size of the unions in India
is very small.
6. Lack of unity: The major weakness of the trade union movement in India is the
lack of unity among the various unions existing in India at present.
7. Lack of trained workers: The workers in India are uneducated and untrained.
The politicians, who are least concerned with the welfare of the workers, become their
leaders.
8. Political dominance: It is very unfortunate for the workers that all trade unions
in India are being controlled by political parties.
9. Hostile attitude of employers:The employers have their own unions to oppose
the working class.
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526
Page 12
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given notes
Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
• Recognition by Management:
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526
Page 13
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given notes
Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
UNIT-II
Industry
PYQ
1. Define "Industry" with the help of decided cases.
Definition of Industry:
• Section 2(j) defines industry, industry" means any business, trade, undertaking,
manufacture or calling of employers and includes any calling, service, employment,
handicraft, or industrial occupation or avocation of workmen.
• In Bangalore Water Supply v. A. Rajappa, a seven Judges' Bench of the Supreme Court
exhaustively considered the scope of industry and laid down the following test which
has practically reiterated the test laid down in Hospital Mazdoor Sabha case.
• Triple Test:
• Where there is:
(i)Systematic activity,
(ii)Organised by cooperation between employer and employee (the
direct and substantial element is chimerical),
(iii) for the production and/or distribution of goods and services
calculated to satisfy human wants and wishes, prima facie, there is an
"industry" in that enterprise. This is known as tripple test.
• Dominant nature test: hether there is complex of activities, the test would be the
predominant nature of services and integrated nature of departments.
• The exceptions to industry are- • Casual activities (because they are not systematic).
• Whether Municipal corporation can be regarded as an industry:
Supreme Court gave the judgement as the municipal corporation is an industry. The
court also held that the Departments of the Municipal Corporation which perform
welfare activities fall within the definition of industry under Section 2(j) of the Act. For
example: (i) Sewerage Department (ii) Public Works Department (iii)Education
Department (iv)Water works Department etc.
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526
Page 14
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given notes
Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
:
• purpose of giving medical , medical education
• production or distribution of goods ,etc
• Hospital run by the Government as a part of its function is not an industry.
• all hospitals fulfilling the test laid down in Bangalore Water Supply case will be
industry.
• Whether University and Educational Institutions are industries?
• University of Delhi v. Ram Nath, In 1961, University of Delhi Case arose where a
driver of Miranda House was discharged from service which led to dispute.
• University claimed that it is not industry and the Court agreed. The Court held that
education is imparted by teachers who are not workmen. The intention of legislature
was not be include educational institutions within industry to extend benefits to the
drivers and others who are not core service providers.
• Is Government Department an industry?
• In State of Rajasthan v. Ganeshi lal, It was held that the Law Department of
Government could not be considered as an industry.
• Whether Club is an industry? In Cricket Club of India v. Bombay Labour Union :
It was held that the club was a self service institution and not an industry and it was
wrong to equate the catering facilities provided by the club to its members or their
guests (members paying for that), with a hotel. The catering facility also was in the
nature of self service by the club to its members. This case has now been overruled.
• Definition of Workman:
• Definitions of workman. an employee who performs manual or industrial labor.
synonyms: working man, working person, workingman.
Appropriate government :
• Introduction:
• Section 10, a powerful provision that empowers the government to intervene and
resolve conflicts through conciliation or adjudication, was incorporated into the
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. Section 10 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 deals with
the procedure for the reference of disputes to the appropriate authority for adjudication.
• Section 2(a), tells who will be the appropriate government under this Act:
• Central Government will be the appropriate government where:
• any industrial establishment is under the control of the central government or carried
on by the central government; or,
• Railway Industry, banking and insurance company, a major port and mine and oil field.
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526
Page 15
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given notes
Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
• The authorities have been divided into adjudicatory and non-adjudicatory bodies.
1. Works Committee.
2. Conciliation Officers.
3. Boards of Conciliation.
4. Court of Inquiry.
1. Works Committee.
section 3 of the act ,It is to try to settle the dispute in the first instance through the process
of mediation in the initial stage of the dispute. The works committee also time to time
comments upon the matters in dispute.
2. Conciliation Officers.
The appropriate Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, appoint such
number of persons as it thinks fit to be conciliation officers, charged with the duty of
mediating in and promotion the settlement of Industrial disputes.
3. Boards of Conciliation.
Under section 5 ,The appropriate Government may, as occasion arises by notification in the
Official Gazette constitute a Board of Conciliation for promoting the settlement of an
industrial dispute.
4. Court of Inquiry.
section 6 of the act , The appropriate Government may as occasion arises by notification in
the Official Gazette, constitute a Court of Inquiry for enquiring into any matter appearing
to be connected with or relevant to an industrial dispute
• powers and functions of Board of Conciliation:
i. promote and facilitate the settlement .
ii. investigate and inquire. iii. settle the dispute through
negotiation and compromise. iv. create a peaceful and cooperative
working environment
v. fair and amicable settlement.
vi. If the parties cannot resolve their differences through conciliation, the dispute may
be referred to a government-appointed arbitrator or tribunal for a final dec ision.
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526
Page 16
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given notes
Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
UNIT-III
‘
• Introduction:
• In the case Management of Kairbetta v/sRajamanickam And Others on 24
March, 1960, Hon'ble Supreme Court of India court has observed as follows:
Just as a strike is a weapon available to the employees for enforcing their industrial
demands, a lockout is a weapon available to the employer to persuade by a coercive
process the employees to see his point of view and to accept his demands. In the
struggle between capital and labour, the weapon of strike is available to labour and
is often used by it, so is the weapon of lockout available to the employer and can be
used by him.
• The use of both the weapons by the respective parties Must, however, be subject to
the relevant provisions of the I D Act. Chapter V which deals with strikes and
lockouts clearly brings out the antithesis between the two weapons and the
limitations subject to which both of them must be exercised.
• Case law: Patiala Cement Company ltd v/s Workman 1955,
• It was held tht there is no limit for the period of strike. It can be for any short period
or any long period. Cessation of work for half an hour was also held to be a strike.
Strike
• Meaning and definition:
• According to section 2(q) of Industrial Disputes Act 1947,
• "a strike is "a cessation of work by a body of persons employed in an industry acting
in combination; or a concerted refusal of any number of persons who are or have
been so employed to continue to work or to accept employment; or a refusal under
a common understanding of any number of such persons to continue to work or to
accept employment".
Lockout
• Definition of Lockout
• Section 2(I) of The Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 defines a lockout as the
“temporary closure of a workplace, the suspension of work, or an employer’s refusal
to continue employing any number of workers during their period of employment.”
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526
Page 17
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given notes
Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526
Page 18
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given notes
Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
• Lay-off
• Meaning:
• Lay-off means temporarily keeping a workman without or away from work. The
question of keeping without work arises when employers are unable to provide
employment to the workman for the reason beyond his control such reason or situations
may be:
o Shortage of raw materials o
Economic recession o
Breakdown of machinery o
Accumulation of stocks o
Layoff
• Definition of Layoff:
• Section 2 (kkk) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 defines the term ‘Layoff’’ as the
inability, failure, or refusal of the employer to provide employment to a workman whose
name is mentioned in the muster roll of his industrial establishment and who is not
retrenched due to the lack of power, coal, raw materials, accumulation of stocks,
breakdown of machinery or natural calamity for any other relevant reason.
• Essentials of Lay-off:
• There must be failure, refusal or inability on the part of the employer to give
employment to a workman.
• The failure, refusal or inability should be on account of shortage of coal, power or raw
materials or accumulation of stocks or breakdown of machinery, or natural calamity, or
any other connected reason.
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526
Page 19
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given notes
Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
The workman’s name should be on the muster rolls of the industrial establishment.
• The workman should not have been retrenched.
Case law: Central India spinning, weaving and manufacturing co.ltd Nagpur v/s state
industrial court 1959 Bombay HC The Bombay high court held that the key to the
definition is to be found in the world failure, refusal or inability of an employer these world
make it clear that employment has to be on account of a cause which is independent of any
action or inaction on the part of the workmen themselves.
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526
Page 20
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given notes
Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
UNIT-IV
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526
Page 21
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given notes
Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526
Page 22
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given notes
Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
UNIT-V
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp text to 95915 73526
Page 23
(g) Any place where work is being done on the
construction, development, or maintenance of
buildings, roads, bridges, or canals, or on operations
related to navigation, irrigation, or water supply, or
on the generation, transmission, and distribution of
electricity or any other form of power;
(h) any other establishment or type of establishments
that the Central Government or a State Government
may specify by publication in the Official Gazette,
having regard to the nature of the establishment, the
necessity for protection of persons employed within,
and other relevant circumstances.
Wages
• Wages have been defined under Section 2(iv) of the Payment
of Wages Act, 1936. “Wages” refers to all remuneration
(whether paid in the category of wage entitlements or
otherwise) represented in cash or qualified to be presented
in finances that would be due for payment to a worker in
respect of his occupation or work performed in such
employment.
• Also, wages include payments if the express or implied
terms of employment are satisfied, and include:
o Amount payable under the terms of
employment o Amount payable under any
award, settlement, or court order o Paid as
overtime labor or for vacations / leave period
• Manufacturing process:
• The manufacturing process definition is specified under Section
2(k). The term
“manufacturing process” refers to any process for:
• Generating, altering, repairing, ornamenting, finishing,
packing, oiling, washing, cleaning, demolishing, or otherwise
treating or adapting any article or;
• A substance in preparation for use, sale, transportation,
delivery, or disposal or; • Producing, transforming, or
transmitting energy or;
• Creating type for printing, letterpress printing, lithography,
bookbinding, or any other similar process or;
• Constructing, reconstructing, repairing, refitting, finishing, or
breaking up ships or vessels, etc. (as defined by the 1976
Amendment Act);
• Preserving or storing any item in cold storage.
For more information Please visit “Namma kanoonu” youtube channel & whatsapp
text to 95915 73526
Page 25
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given
notes Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp
text to 95915 73526 ,9972799641
Page 26
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given
note Call to "Namma kanoonu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
Sections Particulars
Chapter I Preliminary
2 Definitions
3 Appointment of Registrars
4
Mode of registration
5
8 Registration
9 Certificate of registration
10 Cancellation of registration
11 Appeal
12 Registered office
Chapter III
Rights And Liabilities Of Registered Trade Unions
19 Enforceability of agreements
For more information Please visit “Namma kanoonu” youtube channel & whatsapp
text to 95915 73526
Page 27
"To understand the notes given below, to watch all the videos on the given
notes Call to "Namma kanunu Academy" (95915 73526,9972799641)"
23 Change of name
27 Dissolution
28 Returns
Chapter IV
Regulations
30 Publication of regulations
33 Cognizance of offences
For more information Please visit “Nammakanunu” youtube channel & whatsapp
text to 95915 73526 ,9972799641
Page 28