Unit 5 - Consumer's equilibrium and demand
Unit 5 - Consumer's equilibrium and demand
and Demand
“The identity of an individual is essentially a function of her choices, rather than the
discovery of an immutable attribute.” —Amartya Sen
“Every man lives by exchanging.” —Adam Smith
“Consumption is the sole end and purpose of all production” —Adam Smith
Unit 5: Consumer’s Equilibrium and Demand
Consumer’s equilibrium – meaning of utility, marginal utility, law of diminishing marginal
utility, conditions of consumer’s equilibrium using marginal utility analysis.
Indifference curve analysis of consumer’s equilibrium-the consumer’s budget (budget set
and budget line), preferences of the consumer (indifference curve, indifference map) and
conditions of consumer’s equilibrium.
Demand, market demand, determinants of demand, demand schedule, demand curve and
its slope, movement along and shifts in the demand curve; price elasticity of demand -
factors affecting price elasticity of demand; measurement of price elasticity of demand –
percentage-change method and total expenditure method.
Make a note:
Meaning:
The consumer occupies a pivotal place in the economic activity. He/ She is an economic agent who consumes
goods and services for satisfaction of his/her wants.
The satisfaction of the wants is the beginning and end of all economic activities. The objective of a consumer is
to get the maximum satisfaction from the expenditure incurred on various goods and services.
To study a consumer’s behaviour we assume that the consumer is rational and has to decide how to spend his/
her money on two different goods. This is problem of choice. Most naturally, a consumer will opt for the
combination of goods which gives him/her maximum satisfaction.
What will be this ‘best’ combination? This depends on the likes of the consumer and what the consumer can
afford to buy. The ‘likes’ of the consumer are also called ‘preferences’. And what the consumer can afford to
buy, depends on prices of the goods and the income of the consumer.
Make a note:
There are two different approaches to study consumer behaviour and equilibrium
Consumer’s
Behaviour
- It is the behaviour
in which the
consumer spends
his/ her limited
income on various
goods and services
in such a way that
he/she obtains
maximum
satisfaction
Make a note:
Utility
- The term ‘utility’ refers to the want satisfying power of a commodity. In other words,
amount of satisfaction, actual or expected, obtained from consuming goods and services
is called utility.
Characteristics : -
a) Utility depends upon urgency or intensity of want :- More intensity of want implies higher
utility (satisfaction) for a commodity. Ex - A pen gives more utility during examination than
during summer vacation.
b) Utility is subjective :- Satisfaction derived from a commodity will vary from person to
person. Ex. A hungry person will derive more satisfaction from chapatis than a person
who isn't hungry.
c) Utility is measurable :- There are two approaches for the measurement of utility -
Cardinal utility and Ordinal Utility.
d) Utility is not essentially useful :- Higher utility does not always mean greater usefulness.
Ex. Drugs or Alcohol may give utility to an addict but are not useful otherwise.
Make a note:
ORDINAL UTILITY
Economists - John Hicks and Roy Allen in 1934 first produced a paper which mentioned
ordinal utility.
In ordinal utility, the consumer only ranks choices in terms of preference but we do not
give exact numerical figures for utility. It measures utility in qualitative order like first
preference, second preference, third preference and so on. It is measured in ranks.
For example, we prefer a BMW car to a Nissan car, but we don’t say by how much.
It is argued this is more relevant in the real world. When deciding where to go for lunch,
we may just decide I prefer an Italian restaurant to Chinese. We don’t calculate the exact
levels of utility, hence, It is more practical and sensible.
This approach is used while examining the Indifference curve analysis to explain the
Consumer’s equilibrium.
Make a note:
CARDINAL UTILITY
The theory was given by Alfred Marshall. Cardinal Utility is the idea that
economic welfare can be directly observable and be given a value. It measures
utility in quantitative order like 1, 2, 3, 4…. Etc. The units of utility is called “utils”.
It is measured in absolute numbers.
For example, if a Nissan car gives 5,000 units of utility, a BMW car would give
8,000 units OR Sam says that pizza gives him 60 utils of satisfaction whereas
burger gives only 40 utils.
It is less practical.
This approach is used while examining the utility analysis explain the
Consumer’s equilibrium.
● A consumer, in general, consumes many goods; but for simplicity, we shall consider the
consumer’s choice problem in a situation of a single good or where there are only two goods:-
Good X and Good Y.
● Any combination of the amount of the two goods will be called a consumption bundle or, in
short, a bundle.
● In general, we shall use the variable Qx to denote the quantity of Good X and Qy to denote
the quantity of Good Y. Qx and Qy can be positive or zero.
● (Qx, Qy) would mean the bundle consisting of Qx quantity of Good X and Qy quantity of Good
Y. For particular values of Qx and Qy, (Qx, Qy), would give us a particular bundle.
● For example, the bundle (5,10) means 5X + 10Y; the bundle (10, 5) means 10X + 5Y, whose
market prices are Px and Py respectively.
● In economics, it is assumed that the consumer chooses his consumption bundle on the basis
of his taste and preferences over the bundles in the budget set. It is generally assumed that
the consumer is a rational individual and he has well defined preferences over the set of all
possible bundles.
(CARDINAL UTILITY)
Make a note: Concepts of Utility
There are two types of utility - Total utility and Marginal utility
a) Total utility (TU) : It is defined as total psychological satisfaction, a consumer derives from
consumption of a certain amount of a commodity. Mathematically, TU is aggregation of
Marginal utility derived from consumption of different units of a commodity.
TUn = MU1 + MU2 + ……. + MUn
More of commodity X provides more total utility (TU) to the consumer. Thus, TU depends on
the quantity of the commodity X consumed. TU is the sum of the utilities from all the units
consumed.
For example:- if the 1st unit of commodity X gives the consumer a satisfaction of 12 units
and 2nd one gives 6 units, then, TU from 2 units of commodity X is 12 + 6 = 18 units.
If the 3rd unit of commodity X gives satisfaction of 4 units, then TU from 3 units of commodity
X will be 12 + 6 + 4 = 22 units.
Make a note:
b) Marginal utility (MU) : It is an addition made to total utility by consuming an additional unit of
the commodity or it is the additional utility derived from consumption of one more unit of the
given commodity.
MUn = TUn - TUn- 1 (when units consumed change in consecutive order, one by one)
OR
MUn = TUx (when units do not change in consecutive order)
Qx
So, MU is the utility derived from the last unit of a commodity consumed.
Example, when 3rd unit of commodity X is consumed, TU increases from 18 units to 22 units.
Therefore, MU of the 3rd unit of commodity X = TU3 – TU2 = 22 – 18 = 4 units.
Example - 2 units of commodity X gives the consumer 18 units of total utility and 4 units give him
24 units of total utility. So, MU = 6/2 = 3 units.
This simply means that TU derived from consuming n units of commodity X is the sum total of
marginal utility of first unit (Mu1), marginal utility of second unit (MU2), and so on, till the marginal
utility of the nth unit. So, basically we can say that TU = ⅀ MU
Hermann Heinrich Gossen
- was a Prussian economist who is often regarded as the first
to elaborate a general theory of marginal utility.
- The law of Marginal Diminishing utility is popularly known
as Gossen’s first law of consumption. This law states that
as the stock of goods for consumption increases, the utility
derived from it decreases.
The point
at which
Marginal
Utility of a
commodity
is Zero and
its Total
Utility is
maximum,
it is
referred as
Point of
Satiety.
Make a note
Graphical
presentation
of Law of
DMU
Make a note Relationship between TU and MU
1. As long as MU is positive, TU increases - When MU falls +vely, TU increases at a
diminishing rare. . In the example- units 1 to 5, TU increases from 10 to 30 utils and MU falls from
10 to 2 utils. [the area before point A (TU) and B(MU)]
2. When MU is zero, TU is maximum and constant - In the example, when MU is 0 at the
6th unit, TU is maximum and constant at 30 utils. This is called as the point of saturation [shown
by point A(TU) and B(MU)].
3. When MU is negative, TU decreases - In the example, when MU becomes negative at 7th,
8th and 9th units - ie, -2,-4,-6; TU decreases. It implies that beyond 6th unit, further consumption
gives disutility. [area after point A(TU) and B(MU)]
4. Total utility is summation of MU - TU = ⅀MU and also, MU can be derived from TU -
MU = TUn - TUn-1
5. MU curve is the slope of TU curve - MU = ΔTU
ΔQ
Make a note
Ex. if 1 rupee can buy 100 g of sugar and 500 g of rice and if the total utility from
these goods is 4 utils,
Then, 1 rupee = 4 utils
Make a note
In other words,
Condition 1 -
Satisfaction MUx = Sacrifice Px at 3 units
Condition 2 -
Total gain (2 + 1 + 0) falls after this level as
MUx < Px.
Make a note
1. Suppose, burgers sell for Rs 10 each. Mr. X has already eaten 5 burgers. His
marginal utility of one rupee is 5. Should he consume more or stop? Given than
MUx = 50 utils.
Solution
1. Suppose, burgers sell for Rs 10 each. Mr. X has already eaten 5 burgers. Given
than MUx = 50 utils. 1 re = 1 util
Solution: 50 rs … 50 rs = 50 utils
2. Given below is the utility schedule of a consumer for commodity X. The price of the
commodity is Rs 6 per unit. How many units should the consumer purchase to
maximise his satisfaction. Given that Re. 1 = 1 util. Give reasons for your answer.
Solution
1. MU of good X = MU of good Y
OR
MUx = MUY = MUM
Px PY
A consumer consumes only two goods X and Y. The marginal rate of substitution is 1,
prices
of X and Y are `Rs 3 and ` Rs 4 per unit respectively. Is the consumer in equilibrium?
What will be further reaction of the consumer? Give reason.
A consumer consumes only two goods X and Y. The marginal utilities of X and Y are 4
and 3 respectively. Price of X and price of Y is `Rs 3 per unit. Is consumer in
equilibrium? What will be further reaction of the consumer? Give reasons.
A consumer consumes only two goods X and Y. The marginal utilities of X and of Y is 3.
Prices of X and Y are Rs 2 and Rs 1 respectively. Is consumer in equilibrium? What will
be further reaction of the consumer? Give reasons.
A consumer consumes only two goods X and Y both priced at `Rs 3 per unit. If the consumer
chooses a combination of these two goods with Marginal Rate of Substitution equal to 3, is
the consumer in equilibrium? Give reasons. What will a rational consumer do in this
situation? Explain.
A consumer consumes only two goods X and Y whose prices are Rs 4 and Rs 5 per unit
respectively. If the consumer chooses a combination of the two goods with marginal utility
of X equal to 5 and that of Y equal to 4, is the consumer in equilibrium? Give reasons. What
will a rational consumer do in this situation? Use utility analysis.
A consumer consumes only two goods, each priced at Rupee one per unit. If the consumer
chooses a combination of the two goods with Marginal Rate of Substitution equal to 2, is
the consumer in equilibrium? Give reasons. Explain what will a rational consumer do in this
situation.
A consumer consumes only two goods X and Y whose prices are Rs 2 and Rs 1 per unit
respectively. If the consumer chooses a combination of the two goods with marginal utility
of X being 4 and that of Y also being 4, is the consumer in equilibrium? Give reasons.
Explain what will a rational consumer do in this situation. Use Marginal Utility Analysis.
CONSUMER BEHAVIOUR
THROUGH
ORDINAL UTILITY ANALYSIS
Consumption Bundle :
It is a combination of the quantities of two goods. This is also called
bundle of two goods e.g (x1, x2) which denotes that this bundle has
x1 amount of good 1 and x2 amount of good 2. Similarly, (34,40)
would mean 34 units of good 1 and 40 units of good 2.
Budget set :
It refers to all consumption bundles that a consumer can buy using
her/his money (income) at the prevailing market price. Budget set
depends on two factors:
a) Consumer’s income and b) Price of good 1 and good 2.
So, at the given prices, the Budget set includes all those
Consumption bundles that cost less than or equal to a consumer’s
income.
Indifference Map and Monotonic Preferences
Slope of Indifference Curve ( Marginal Rate of Substitution (MRS)
MRS = Δ Loss
Δ Gain
1.An Indifference Curve Slopes downwards 2. An Indifference curve is convex to the point of origin
So, at the given prices, the Budget set includes all those
Consumption bundles that cost less than or equal to a consumer’s
income.
Px.Qx + Py.Qy ≤ M
Consumer Budget constraint :
It refers to a situation when expenditure on two goods by the
consumer has to be limited based on his/ her income.
For example -
If P1 = Rs 4 and P2 = Rs 2 and M = Rs 20, then the following bundles are not
affordable by the consumer.
(i) (0,14) = (4 x 0 + 2 x 14) ≠ 20
(ii) (1,20)
iii) (2,34)
If P1 = Rs 4 and P2 = Rs 2 and M = Rs 20,
Px. Qx + Py. Qy = 20
( 1, 1) (2, 5)
(1, 5)
Budget line/ Price line :
It represents the different bundles that the consumer can purchase.
Expenditure =
Graphical presentation -
Budget line
a) Attainable combinations
All points on AF as well as within
it are called attainable
combinations
b) Non-attainable combinations
All points on the outside AF are
called unattainable combinations
Changes in Budget line/ Price line :
a) Change in Income
(b) Demand always means effective demand i.e., demand for a commodity or
the desire to own a commodity should always be backed by purchasing power
and willingness to spend.
a) Price demand
b) Income demand
c) Cross demand
d) Derived demand
e) Direct demand
f) Joint demand
g) Composite demand
Determinants of Individual demand
15 (b) 150
When Px↓ - Dx ↑
Contraction in Demand for Goods
When the quantity demanded falls due to the rise in price, it is called contraction of demand.
20 100
25 70
When Px↑ - Dx ↓
Increase in demand - Rightward
Shift
(i) Change in price of substitute goods; (ii) Change in price of complementary goods;
Px Dx
20 100
20 150
When Px(same) - Dx
Decrease in Demand for Goods
Decrease in Demand refers to a fall in the demand of a commodity caused due to any factor other than
the own price of the commodity. In this case, demand falls at the same price. It leads to a leftward shift
in the demand curve.
Px Dx
20 100
20 70
When Px(same) - Dx
Income effect
- Income effect refers to the change in the demand for a Normal/ Inferior good
as a result of a change in the income of a consumer.
When Consumer consumes Normal good before Income (Y) changed
= no impact
When Consumer consumes Normal good before Income (Y) changed
= no impact
When Consumer consumes Inferior good before Income (Y) changed
(i) (ii)
1. Given that demand function is Qd = 100 - 5P,
Solution =
b) 15 units = 8.5
c) 0 units = 10
Elasticity of demand refers to
percentage change in demand
of a commodity due to
percentage change in any of
the factors affecting demand of
that commodity.
2. Income of the Consumers. If the income level of consumers is high, the elasticity of
demand is less. It is because change in the price will not affect the quantity demanded
by a greater proportion. But in low income groups, the elasticity of demand is high.
3. Luxuries versus Necessities. The price elasticity of demand is likely to be low for
necessities and high for luxuries. A necessity is a good or service that the consumer
must have such as food (bread, milk) and medicines. Luxuries are goods that are
enjoyable but not essential. Example: eating in a 5-Star hotel. If the price of necessities
rise, then demand will not fall by a greater proportion because their purchase cannot be
delayed. That is why, the price elasticity of demand in case of necessity is low.
4. Proportion of Total Expenditure Spent on the Product. Higher the cost of the good
relative to total income of the consumer, more will be the price elasticity of demand. If
the price of bread, ink, salt, match box, etc., which is relatively low, doubles it would
have almost no effect on the quantity demanded of them. On the other hand, if price of
car doubles then the quantity demanded will fall by a greater proportion showing high
price elasticity of demand.
5. Number of Uses of the Commodity. The more the number of uses a commodity can
be put to, the more elastic is the demand. If a commodity has few uses, it has an
inelastic demand. Examples: goods like milk, eggs and electricity can be put to many
different uses and hence, enjoy elastic demand, i.e., when prices are low, demand
increases by a greater proportion as the goods can now be put to less important uses
also.
6. Time Period. If the time period needed to find substitutes of the commodity is more,
the price elasticity of demand is more and vice versa. Example: flying by aeroplane has
inelastic demand as no substitutes are available in the short run.
Px Qd
10 20
10 30
10 40
Px Qd
10 30
20 30
30 30
Relatively Elastic Demand e>1
Px Qd
100 100
150 30
Px Qd
100 100
150 80
Px Qd
10 40
5 60
Ed = ( - )
=
4. If price of a commodity rises by 40% and its
demand falls by 80 %, Calculate the Price elasticity
of demand.
Ed =
= (-) 80 %
40%
= (-) 2% …. As we ignore the (-) sign,
Ed = 2%. The price elasticity of demand is Greater
than unitary elastic demand
5. Price of a good rises by 25% but there is no effect on
demand of the good due to this price rise. Calculate
price elasticity of demand.
b) We use formula -
Solution :
Old price (P) = 5, New price (P1) = 4,
Δ P = New price - Old price = - 1
P.e =
D (ignore the (-) sign while computing)
= 5 x 2__
10 (-1)
= (-1) or 1 (Unitary elastic demand)
12. Price of a good rises from Rs 10 to Rs 12
and its demand falls from 120 units to 100
units. Calculate P.eD
13. Calculate P.e , if a person spends Rs 500 at Rs 5
D
P.e =
D if, Δ Q = ????
(-1) = 10 x Δ Q_ Δ Q = New Q - Q
30 (-1)
Δ Q = ???? New Price = ? Rs
17. What will be the effect of 10% rise in price of a good on its
demand if price elasticity of demand is
P.e d =
D % change in Qd P.e d =
D % change in Qd P.e d =
D % change in Qd
% change in P % change in P % change in P
P.e =
D if, Δ P = ????
2 = 5 x 40_ Δ P = New P - P
100 ΔP
Δ P = ???? New Price = ? Rs
19. The demand for a good is 300 units at Rs 20, if price rises
by Rs 5 and demand falls, find the new demand if P.e is -3.
D
PEd =-3
P = 20, , Δ P = 5 Rs, ( note: price increase = demand decrease)
Q = 300, New Q = ? , so ΔQ=?
P.e =
D if, Δ Q = ????
-3 = 20 x Δ Q_ Δ Q = New Q - Q
300 -5
Δ Q = ???? New Quantity = ? units
20. The demand for a good at Rs 10 per unit is 40 units. Price
falls by Rs 2, if price elasticity of demand is -5, Calculate
demand after price falls.
PEd = -5
P = 10, , Δ P = 8 Rs ( note: price has fallen = demand will increase)
Q = 40, New Q = ? , so ΔQ=?
P.e =
D if, Δ Q = ????
2 = 20 x Δ Q_ Δ Q = New Q - Q
300 2
Δ Q = ???? New Quantity = ? units
21. Find elasticity of demand.
a) When price falls from Rs 10 to Rs 9, and demand rises from 9 to 10
units
b) When price falls from Rs 8 to Rs 6 and demand rises from 20 to 40
units.
P = 10, New P = 9 , so Δ P = (-1) P = 8, New P = 6 , so Δ P = (- 2)
Q = 9, New Q = 10, so Δ Q = 1 Q = 20, New Q = 40, so Δ Q = 20
P.e =
D P.e =
D
= 10 x 1__ = 8 x (-2)_
9 (-1) 20 20
= ?? = ??