00 - Judicial Branch Unit Guide
00 - Judicial Branch Unit Guide
Plus:
Daily lesson plans are included for every day of the
school year! They’re all available at
StudentsofHistory.com!
Essential Questions
a) Which Supreme Court decisions have become landmark cases in U.S.
history? Content Page
Supreme Court
District Court
Court of appeals
/ appellate
court
Precedent
Writ of
Certiorari
Majority opinion
Dissenting
opinion
Judicial review
Concurrent
Jurisdiction
Timeline of Major Court Decisions & Actions
Directions: Place the following events on the timeline and draw images or symbols for at least four of them.
• The number of justices is increased to 10, the most • The Judiciary Act of 1789 is adopted, dividing the • The Supreme Court makes their infamous ruling on
ever in US History nation into 13 judicial districts and three circuits, and Plessy v. Ferguson
set the number of Supreme Court justices at 6
• The first Supreme Court is assembled • Fletcher v. Peck becomes the first time the Supreme
• The Supreme Court rules to uphold prohibition Court rules a state law unconstitutional
• The Supreme Court rules on Brown v. Board of
Education • The Supreme Court rules on Roe v. Wade • The number of justices is set to 9, the most recent
change to the number of justices.
• The Supreme Court rules on Miranda v. Arizona, • West v. Barnes is the first U.S. Supreme Court Case
leading to the creation of the Miranda Warning
1780 1800 1820 1840 1860 1880 1900 1920 1940 1960 1980 2000 2020
Which Supreme Court decision do you think was most controversial? Explain.
Supreme Court People & Roles to Know
Directions: First, research the role and importance of the Chief Justice, and then find information about the current
Chief Justice. Then, research the eight associate justices and record their information below. In the notes section, look
for details about important rulings or opinions, judicial philosophy, etc.
Nominated by:
Notable rulings:
Year: ___________
(Case Name)
Case Context:
Case Context:
Case Ruling:
Issue being reviewed:
Parties who are not satisfied with the decision of a U.S. Circuit Court of
Appeal (or, in rare cases, of a U.S. District Court), or a state supreme court
How does the Supreme Court get cases? How can petition the U.S. Supreme Court to hear their case. This is mainly done
do they decide which cases to hear? by a legal procedure known as a Petition for a Writ of Certiorari.
The court has discretion to decide whether to accept such cases. The court
accepts about 100-150 of some 7,000 cases it is asked to hear for argument
per year. The cases typically fit within general criteria for oral arguments.
Four justices must agree to hear the case. While primarily an appellate
court, the court does have original jurisdiction over cases involving
ambassadors and two or more states.
In your own words, explain Taft’s above belief about the Supreme Court.
“Presidents come and go, but the
Supreme Court goes on forever”
-William Howard Taft
“There are some singers that know exactly when to go, and others What are the benefits and drawbacks of justices receiving
hang on much too long and that is the same, that is the same with lifetime appointments to the Supreme Court?
judges. My own view, and I’ve said this many times, is as long as
I can do the work full steam, I will stay on the Court. But when I
feel myself slipping, when I slow down in my ability to write
opinions with fair dispatch, when I forget the names of cases that
I once could recite at the drop of a hat, I will know.”
- Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg. 9/16/2013
Judicial Philosophies
Since the Constitution was drafted, there has always been debate What is the difference between a “strict” versus
about how to interpret it, even amongst judges. “broad” construction of the Constitution?
“As a member of this Court I am not justified in writing my opinions into the Constitution, no matter how deeply I
may cherish them.”
- Justice Felix Frankfurter
“The ultimate question must be, what do the words of the text mean for our time? For the genius of the
Constitution rests not in any static meaning it might have had in a world that is dead and gone, but in the
adaptability of its great principles to cope with current problems and current needs”
- Justice William J. Brennan
Based on the quote above, how would you describe the judicial Based on the quote above, how would you describe the
philosophy of Justice Frankfurter? judicial philosophy of Justice Brennan?
Visual Literacy
Directions: Use the included images and captions to answer each question.
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg laid in state in the Capital Statuary Hall, 2021
Supreme Court The highest judicial court in the United States, Pictures for each
District Court Federal courts where the first trials are held, and lawsuits begin
Court of
A court that reviews decisions made by lower courts when one
appeals/appellate
party of the case appeals the decision
court
Concurrent
Powers shared by the state and federal government
Jurisdiction
Presidential Timeline
Directions: Place the following events on the timeline and draw images or symbols for at least four of them.
• The number of justices is increased to 10, the most ever • The Judiciary Act of 1789 is adopted, dividing the nation • The Supreme Court makes their infamous ruling on
in US History into 13 judicial districts and three circuits, and set the Plessy v. Ferguson
number of Supreme Court justices at 6
• The first Supreme Court is assembled • Fletcher v. Peck becomes the first time the Supreme
• The Supreme Court rules to uphold prohibition Court rules a state law unconstitutional
• The Supreme Court rules on Brown v. Board of
Education • The Supreme Court rules on Roe v. Wade • The number of justices is set to 9, the most recent change
to the number of justices.
• The Supreme Court rules on Miranda v. Arizona, leading • West v. Barnes is the first U.S. Supreme Court Case
to the creation of the Miranda Warning
1780 1800 1820 1840 1860 1880 1900 1920 1940 1960 1980 2000 2020
Which Supreme Court decision do you think was most controversial? Explain.
Open to a variety of student responses, provided that students explain their reasoning.
Supreme Court Justices & Roles to Know
Directions: First, research the role and importance of the Chief Justice, and then find information about the current Chief
Justice. Then, research the eight associate justices and record their information below. In the notes section, look for details about
important rulings or opinions, judicial philosophy, etc. Updated December 2021.
Notes: Originalist in Constitutional interpretations, advocate Notes: Focuses legal decisions based on concern for
of natural law, considered one of the most conservative consequences, has criticizes originalism for lack of concern
members of court. of consequences.
Associate Justice: Samuel Alito Associate Justice: Sonia Sotomayor
Notes: Considered one of the most conservative justices in Notes: Concerned with the rights of defendants, calls for a
the Supreme Court, is a practical originalist reform of the criminal justice system, and has dissented on
issues of race, gender, and ethnic identities.
Associate Justice: Elena Kagan Associate Justice: Neil Gorsuch
Notes: Considered a liberal judge, but tends to be more Notes: Originalist in Constitutional interpretations, advocate
moderate, wrote opinion on case restricting permissible use of natural law.
of race in drawing congressional districts.
Associate Justice: Brett Kavanaugh Associate Justice: Amy Coney Barrett
Notes: Originalist in Constitutional interpretations, very Notes: Newest member of the Supreme Court, originalist in
conservative voting record. Constitutional interpretations
The Supreme Court & Judicial Review:
Directions: First, research Marbury v Madison to understand where the concept of Judicial Review comes from., and answer the questions below. Then, find a case that
has recently undergone Judicial Review and write the details of the case belo
Case Ruling: The case ended up examining the Judiciary Act of 1789, which Issue being reviewed:
was deemed as unconstitutional because it attempted to extend the courts
original Jurisdiction beyond Article 3, Section 2 of the Constitution. This
allowed the court to establish the principle of judicial review.
If there has been a decision, what was it?
The Supreme Court gets cases that are appealed to The court has discretion to decide whether to accept such cases. The
them from lower Federal courts or from State court accepts about 100-150 of some 7,000 cases it is asked to hear for
Supreme courts. The Supreme Court decides which argument per year. The cases typically fit within general criteria for
cases to hear based on if they fit into a set of oral arguments. Four justices must agree to hear the case. While
criteria, and if four justices agree that it would be a primarily an appellate court, the court does have original jurisdiction
good case. over cases involving ambassadors and two or more states.
In your own words, explain Taft’s above belief about the Supreme Court.
“Presidents come and go, but the
Taft believes that the Supreme Court stand the test of time because their rulings come to Supreme Court goes on forever”
influence entire generations, while presidents and their agendas rotate in and out of the -William Howard Taft
White House every four to eight years.
“There are some singers that know exactly when to go, and others What are the benefits and drawbacks of justices receiving
hang on much too long and that is the same, that is the same with lifetime appointments to the Supreme Court?
judges. My own view, and I’ve said this many times, is as long as
Open to various student responses. They could note how
I can do the work full steam, I will stay on the Court. But when I
feel myself slipping, when I slow down in my ability to write lifetime appointments are intended to keep justices
apolitical and not open to being swayed by public
opinions with fair dispatch, when I forget the names of cases that
I once could recite at the drop of a hat, I will know.” opinion. A negative could eb that they could be very old
and possibly out of touch with current values.
- Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg. 9/16/2013
Judicial Philosophies
Since the Constitution was drafted, there has always been debate What is the difference between a “strict” versus
about how to interpret it, even amongst judges. “broad” construction of the Constitution?
Others believe in “broad construction,” also known as a “living Broad Construction means that judges interpret the
constitution” philosophy. In this philosophy, people believe that Constitution as a living document that should be
Constitution should be interpreted as a living document that is more applied to modern situations.
flexible in its application to modern situations.
“As a member of this Court I am not justified in writing my opinions into the Constitution, no matter how deeply I
may cherish them.”
-Justice Felix Frankfurter
“The ultimate question must be, what do the words of the text mean for our time? For the genius of the
Constitution rests not in any static meaning it might have had in a world that is dead and gone, but in the
adaptability of its great principles to cope with current problems and current needs”
-Justice William J. Brennan
Based on the quote above, how would you describe the judicial Based on the quote above, how would you describe the
philosophy of Justice Frankfurter? judicial philosophy of Justice Brennan?
Based on this quote, Justice Frankfurter seems to be a believer of Based on this quote, Justice Brennan seems to be a
judicial restraint because he believes that his opinions should not believer in judicial activism because he believes that the
affect the Constitution at all. Constitution should be applied to current problems and
needs of the nation.
Visual Literacy
Directions: Use the included images and captions to answer each of question.
This check on power is important because it ensures that the other two
branches are allowed a say in reviewing who is places in the third
branch. That way, a president knows that their choice in justices is
being monitored and that they must hold up to the review of Congress.
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg laid in state in the Capital Statuary Hall, 2021
For the questions below, please examine the flow
chart to the left.