Market RiskPractice Question
Market RiskPractice Question
Title
Date
Lifetime Learning Building Success Towards
Globalization
DECISION MAKING
2
01/30/16
Calculation of Z- Score
AMOUNT
30
Term Loan
40
20
Bank Guarantee
10
Derivatives
Total Facilities
5
105mn
What is Risk?
Risk, in traditional terms, is viewed as a 'negative'.
"exposing to danger or hazard".
hazard
The Chinese symbols for risk give a much better description of risk:
The first symbol is the symbol for danger,
danger while the second is the
symbol for opportunity,
opportunity making risk a mix of danger and opportunity.
01/30/16
GLASS-STEAGALL ACT
This Act formed the cornerstone of the Banking
industry in the 20th Century.
This Act is also known as Banking Act of 1933.
The Act created the barriers between Commercial
Banking & Securities market industry.
This was enacted as at that time many blamed
the securities activities of the Banks as a major
reason for their collapse.
IMPACT OF GLASS-STEAGALL
ACT
The Act changed the landscape of Investment
Banking industry for the next 66 years.
The major commercial Banks closed down their
securities business.
This Act also led to the establishment of new
Securities firms.
The profitability of the Banks were severely impacted
as their most profitable business was closed
Many of the provisions were very harsh and led to a
situation where the growth of Banking industry was
significantly affected in the next two decades.
RISK MANAGEMENT
Risk
The word risk is derived from an Italian
word Risicare which means To Dare. In
this sense risk is a choice rather than fate.
Risk is uncertainty that an asset will earn an
expected rate of return, or that a loss may
occur.
Risk is volatility, where unexpected
changes; positive or negative are viewed
symmetrically.
The objective of risk management is not the
elimination of risk but to optimize it.
CREDIT RISK
MARKET RISK
LIQUIDITY RISK
OPERATIONAL RISK
LEGAL RISK
TECHNOLOGICAL RISK
REPUTATION RISK
OFF BALANCE SHEET RISK
CURRENCY RISK
DERIVATIVES RISK
COUNTRY RISKS
FORCE MAJURE RISK
REGULATORY RISK
24
01/30/16
Market risk
Market risk is caused due to changes in the
market variables having adverse impact on
earnings of a bank or on its capital.
Those variables are: interest rate, foreign
exchange, equity price, commodity price, and
liquidity.
Liquidity risk
Mismatching in maturities of banks assets and
liabilities cause banks to finance liquidity at
unfavorable cost or forced to liquidated assets at
unfavorable prices.
Banks with surplus liquidity may also suffer due
to idling of funds.
Key ratios; loan to deposit ratio, liquid assets to
total assets, liquid assets to total deposits, interbank-deposits to total deposits.
Country risk
Cross border lending and investment, when
counterparty is unable service and repay the debt.
Currency transfer risk; borrower is able to repay in
local currency but there is shortage in foreign
currency.
Political risk; restrictions imposed
Sovereign risk; government involved but inability
to take legal action.
Cross border risk; borrower being resident of a
country other than where the cross border assets
are booked and exposure to currencies other than
local currencies.
Operational risk
Caused due to deficient and fast changing
internal
process/systems/procedures;
nonconducive work environment; de-motivated
untrained and incompetent staff or from external
events.
Legal risk
Technology risk
Outsourcing
Group risk
Arises
when
a
bank
has
other
domestic/overseas subsidiaries dealing in
various activities such as merchant banks,
mutual funds, insurance may not doing
well and incurring losses and in turn may
effect their profitability.
Credit risk
The possibility of losses associated with diminution in the
credit quality of borrowers or counter parties.
DISCUSSION
risk
BUSINESS RISK
CASE STUDY-1
IDENTIFY THE KEY RISKS WITH THE
COMPANY.
ARABTEC
EMMAR PROPERTIES
EMMAR MALLS
DU
NAKHEEL
IDENTIFYING THE
FINANCIAL RISK
CASE STUDY-2
IDENTIFY THE KEY RISKS WITH THE
COMPANY.
LEVERAGE RATIOS
PROFITABILITY RATIOS
DSCR
TOL/TNW
This ratio is a critical measure of solvency of the
company.
It shows how many times your Networth (own
funds) is the Outsiders liabilities.
The ratio =
Total Outsiders Liability
--------------------------------Networth
The benchmark ratio in this regard is a maximum
of 3 times.
The benchmark can vary from Bank to Bank
depending on their risk appetite.
DSCR
This is one of the most important ratio in Project
Finance.
This basically tests whether the internal
funding from the business is adequate to
meet the loan repayment obligations to the
Bank
Debt Service Coverage ratio, tests the ability of a
company to service the
Principal repayment
Interest servicing
DSCR
Cash Accruals
This refers to the Cash profits generated in the
business.
The Net Income (PAT) in the Financial statements
is after adjusting for non cash expenses like
depreciation.
Due to this the Reported Profits could differ from
the Cash Profits.
Cash Accruals = PAT+ Depreciation
EBITDA
(Earnings before Interest Tax, Depreciation &
Amortization)
The objective of this ratio is to calculate the
operating profits made by the company from the
core business operations.
The ratio calculates the operating profit margin
on the
Net sales made.
EBITDA
------------- X 100
sales of the Core Operating Performance of the
This isNet
an indicator
.company
5 Cs of CREDIT RISK
5CS
Character
Capacity
Capital
Collateral
Conditions
Selective monitoring.
Ensuring quality.
Migration of credit. Higher to lower
Management of credit risk.
Identification of safe and risky
areas.
Z- score Model
Z - score
Z= 1.2 X1+1.4 X2+ 3.3X3+ 0.6 X4+ 0.999 X5
Z- score model
1.
(Altman) Z-score
if (Z< 1.81) the firm will default. If Z (1.81:2.675),
the firm will either default or not. If (Z> 2.675),
the firm will not default.
CASE STUDY-2
Z-SCORING FRAMEWORK
PART-II
BASEL-II INSIGHTS
ON CREDIT RISK MANAGEMENT
the banks were categorized into risk buckets with risk weights ranging
from 0% to 150%.
Particulars
Cash in hand, Balance with banks, Investment in
government securities etc
Money at call and short notices, Investment under
government guaranteed securities, Advances to
staff members etc
Claim guaranteed by DICGC/ECGE
Advance to public against Housing Finance
Advances to corporates, claim on PSUs, SME
and Retail exposure etc.
Advances under consumer credit
Advances covered under Commercial real estate
Risk We ight
0%
20%
50%
75%
100%
125%
150%
credit risk.
Based on 1988 accord, central banks initiated various actions for the
banks like classification of assets, provision norms, classification of
asset class etc.
Approaches
risk
to
measure
Standardized approach
Internal ratings based (IRB) approach
Foundation
Advanced
Approaches to measure Operational risk
Basic Indicator Approach
The Standardised Approach
Advanced Measurement Approach
Approaches to measure Market risk
Standardised method
Internal Model
Credit
ADVANCED
INTERNAL RATING
BASED
APPROACH
FOUNDATION
INTERNAL
RATING BASED
APPROACH
DISCUSSION
Why do all Banks run behind top rated
corporates to offer them loans at low rates
?
Why is very higher rate charged on
customers with average or weak financials
?
Why Residential Mortgage is a preferred
business for all UAE Banks ?
Credit Risk
Sr.
No.
1
Instruments
Credit
Conversion
Factor (% )
100
50
20
CORE OF BASEL II
CALCULATION OF CAPITAL CHARGE
Credit Facility
Amount
50
TERM LOAN
40
LETTER OF CREDIT
30
BANK GUARANTEE
30
FORWARD CT/DERIVATIVE
LIMIT (CEL)
20
CAPITAL CHARGE
Facility
1. FBWC
50
2. TL-1
40
3 LC (Docum)
30
4 BG
30
5 CEL
20
Risk
Risk
Capital Charge
Weight Weighted (H = G * 12%)
(%) (F) Exposure
BBB (G = D*E*F)
Total
TRY THE SAME FOR COMPANIES WHICH ARE UNRATED & RATED AAA
TYPE OF ASSET
RISK WEIGHT
CORPORATE EXPOSURES
75%
Residential Mortgage
Retail Exposures
Probability of Default
(PD)
It measures the likelihood that
the borrower will default over a
given time-horizon.
Exposure at Default
(EAD)
It measures the amount of the
facility that is likely to be drawn
if a default occurs .
Exposure at Default
(EAD)
Maturity
(M)
It measures the remaining
exposure.
Determines framework for comparing different exposures.
Principal & outstanding balance
Opening Date of Loan
Contractual date of Maturity of Loan
Contractual and Discount Rate of Interest
Freq. of int. payment per annum
Tenor/Maturity (Years)
Time Period
Cash
Present Value of
in years
flow
Cash Flow
(A)
(B)
(c)
1
900
825.69
2
900
757.51
3
10900
8416.80
Total ------------------------>
10000.00
27591.11
Economic Maturity =
10000.00
10000
01/01/2003
31/12/2006
9.00%
1
3
(A) x (c)
825.69
1515.02
25250.40
27591.11
= 2.76