Scribd
Upload
61 views56 pages

Approach To A Failed Bankart's Surgery

This document discusses failed shoulder instability surgery. It provides data on recurrence rates for open and arthroscopic Bankart repairs ranging from 10-35%. It identifies risk factors for recurrence including age under 20, number of pre-op dislocations, bone loss, and technical errors in the surgery. For recurrent instability after failed Bankart repair, it recommends evaluating for missed pathology, addressing capsular laxity, and considering revision repair or a Latarjet procedure if there is significant bone loss of greater than 25%. It provides outcomes data on revision surgeries and Latarjet procedures, with lower recurrence rates reported for the Latarjet.

Uploaded by

chandan noel
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PPTX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
61 views56 pages

Approach To A Failed Bankart's Surgery

This document discusses failed shoulder instability surgery. It provides data on recurrence rates for open and arthroscopic Bankart repairs ranging from 10-35%. It identifies risk factors for recurrence including age under 20, number of pre-op dislocations, bone loss, and technical errors in the surgery. For recurrent instability after failed Bankart repair, it recommends evaluating for missed pathology, addressing capsular laxity, and considering revision repair or a Latarjet procedure if there is significant bone loss of greater than 25%. It provides outcomes data on revision surgeries and Latarjet procedures, with lower recurrence rates reported for the Latarjet.

Uploaded by

chandan noel
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PPTX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 56

APPROACH TO

A FAILED
INSTABILITYS
URGERY

DR.V.CHANDAN NOEL
MOHTADI
JBJS -2014

LEVEL -1

OPEN – 11%

ARTHROSCOPIC – 23%
OJSM
-2017

BURKHART-10.8%
KIM-10%
BOILEAU-14.8%
LAFOSSE- 18%
IMHOFF-14.2%

CASTAGNA-23%
VAN DER LINDE- 35%
FLINKILLA-20%
OPEN A’SCOPY

<2005 10.7% 16.8%

>2005 10.8% 14.2%


WHAT IS FAILURE …..???

1.INSTABILITY

2.PERSISTENT PAIN
3.MOTION LOSS
4.N/A RETURN TO WORK
5.OA CHANGES
CAUSES COMBINATION

1.INTRINSIC FACTORS

2.INACCURATE DIAGNOSIS

3.TECHNICAL ERRORS
KANDZIORA
INTRINSIC FACTORS – NON
ET AL ANATOMICAL
INJURY TO SURGERY TIME >6 MO’S

AGE RATE OF NUMBER OF RATE OF


RECURRENCE DISLOCATIONS RECURRENCE
20 years 25 %
21–30 years 20 % 1-2 11.1%
31–40 years 7.1 % 3-4 17.8%
6-10 43%
41 years 0%
11-20 43.4%
>20 55.5%
COLLISION GROUP- 29%
VS
NON-COLLISION-6%
KSSTA
2012

1. AGE <20-33% VS >20-11.8%


2. GENDER MALES-15% VS FEMALES-8.7%
3. HIGHER PRE-OP DISLOCATIONS RISK FOR RECURRENCE
4. COLLISION/CONTACT SPORTS VS OTHERS (15% VS 11%)- NO DIFFEREN
5. LEVEL OF SPORTS ( 29% VS 11.5%)
6. LIGAMENTOUS LAXITY
ANATOMICAL
>250MM3

VOLUME OF THE HILL SACHS- LENGTH X DEPTH X HEIGHT

633MM 3

VS
233MM 3
LIGAMENTOUS
LAXITY… 18.9% VS 4.9%

3 TIMES RISK
ALPSA HIGHER
12.5%
RISK OF
FAILURE Vs
6.5%
ERRORS IN TECHNIQUE

– INFERIOR CAPSULELAXITY IS NOT ADDRESSED


– POOR RE-TENSIONING
– POOR ANCHOR PLACEMENT
– TOO FEW ANCHORS
– POOR KNOTS
– STICH PATTERN
– BONY BANKART (NOT INCORPORATING IN REPAIR)
– HILL SACHS NOT ADDRESSED
– SHORTER IMMOBILIZATION
TECHNICAL ERRORS
SICOT 2016
37% 61% 11%

REPAIR OF INFERIOR LABRUM CRITICAL TO JOINT


VOLUME REDUCTION
LEVEL II
KSSTA-2012

– LESS THAN 3 ANCHORS , HIGHER RECURRENCE


– INADEQUATE RE-TENSIONING OF THE INFERIOR CAPSULE
– MOST REPAIRS LACKED ANCHORS AFTER 4’O CLOCK.
ERRORS IN DIAGNOSIS

– PAN-LABRAL TEARS
– BONE LOSS
– ALPSA
– HAGL’S
– CAPSULAR TEARING
– SLAP
– CUFF PATHOLOGY
• 55% BONY BANKART’S MISSED OR NOT
INCORPORATED IN REPAIR
• 22% LAX CAPSULE NOT DIAGNOSED PRE-OP, MISSED
• 5% HUMERAL SIDED LESIONS
EVALUATION
HISTORY
– TRAUMATIC OR A TRAUMATIC
– NUMBER OF DISLOCATIONS
– NIGHT INSTABILITY
– SPORTS
– PREVIOUS OP RECORDS / IMAGES ( MISSED
PATHOLOGIES)
– INFECTIONS, HARDWARE
EXAMINATIONS

– HYPERLAXITY ( GENERALIZED & SHOULDER)


– ROMS – STIFFNESS
– CUFF DYSFUNCTION ( SUB SCAPULARIS, SLAP-BICEPS)
– INSTABILITY IN MID RANGE
– APPREHENSION
– MDI
– NEUROLOGY- BRACHIAL PLEXUS
IMAGING
MANAGEMENT
REVISION BANKARTS REPAIR

– BANKARTS LESION (QUALITY…??)


– LAX CAPSULE (NOT ADDRESSED IN
PRIMARY SURGERY…??)
– NEGLIGIBLE BONE LOSS
– HILL SACHS< 25 % OF HEAD, ENGAGING
– SPORTING/ HYPERLAXITY/ ANCHORS
REOPERATIONS POORER OUTCOMES
– 56 REVISION
STABILIZATIONS
– 6 FAILURES (11%)
– ALL FAILURES HAD
POOR CAPSULOLABRAL
QUALITY
– BONE LOSS 15-20%
SCOI – HOSPITAL CORNER STICH
4 –SA
3- PLICATION
STICHES

– 18 patients with recurrent instability


– Bone loss >25% excluded
– Anterior capsulolabral repair + capsular plications
posteriorly
– Rotator interval closure sulcus in er
– 13/18 good results
– 3 recurrence of instability and 2- continued pain
• LEVEL 3
• PRIMARY VS REVISION (20 PATIENTS)
• NO REDISLOCATIONS
• POORER FUNCTIONAL OUTCOMES IN REVISION GROUP
2012

– MULTIDIRECTIONAL SHOULDER
INSTABILITY
– GREATER THAN 25% GLENOID
BONE LOSS
– A HILL SACHS LESION INVOLVING
MORE THAN ONE-THIRD OF THE
ARTICULAR SURFACE OF THE
HUMERAL HEAD.
– PATIENTS ELECTING TO CONTINUE
PURSUING CONTACT SPORTS
CONCLUSION
– ARTHROSCOPIC BANKARTS REPAIR HAVE SIGNIFICANT RECURRENCES
– SCOPY RECURRENCES FAIRLY SAFE TO ADDRESS WITH REVISION SCOPY
– PROVIDED EVALUATE THE PATIENT AS A WHOLE- SPORTING, AGE, LAXITY,BONE LOSS,
NUMBER OF DISLOCATIONS
– PLAN OF MANAGEMENT – BASED ON THE PROBLEMS AT HAND, ADDRESS LAXITY AND
ACCOMPANYING PATHOLOGIES
– CRITICAL BONE LOSS - 25%, SUB CRITICAL BONE LOSS….?????
– RETURN TO SPORT AFTER BANKART WITH A PINCH OF SALT
BONE LOSS > 25 % - LATARJET
3.3%
DISLOCATION FREQUENT
AFTER OPEN SURGERY VS
0.3%
CAUSES OF FAILURE IN
LATARJETS
– IMMEDIATE- WOUND RELATED COMPLICATIONS
– NEUROVASCULAR
– RECURRENCE OF INSTABILITY
– GRAFT NON UNION
– OSTEOLYSIS OF GRAFT
– GRAFT TOO MEDIAL-JOB NOT DONE..!!!
– TOO LATERAL – OSTEOARTHROSIS…JOB OVER DONE…!!!
RETURN TO
SPORT – 47%

5 PATIENTS WITH ARTHRITIS


3PROGRESSED BY ONE
GRADE
• 319 PATIENTS – 23 REVISION SURGERIES
• RECURRENCE 17%
• RECURRENCE IN REVISION CASES- 26% ( 1 DISLOCATION,5
SUBLUXATION)
• 95% SATISFIED
JBJS
2012

– 49 PATIENTS- 32(SINGLE), 12(DOUBLE),5 (TRIPLE)


– 2 (4.1%) ONLY SUBLUXATION, NO DISLOCATIONS
– 88% REPORTED GOOD RESULTS
• 34 PATIENTS
• 75% GOOD REULTS
• 85 % RETURN TO SPORTING
•
AJSM-2008

47 PATIENTS , NO
RECURRENCES AT 10
YRS FOLLOWUP.

You might also like

pFad - Phonifier reborn

Pfad - The Proxy pFad of © 2024 Garber Painting. All rights reserved.

Note: This service is not intended for secure transactions such as banking, social media, email, or purchasing. Use at your own risk. We assume no liability whatsoever for broken pages.


Alternative Proxies:

Alternative Proxy

pFad Proxy

pFad v3 Proxy

pFad v4 Proxy