Laser Diode Efficiencies

Slope Efficiency

 Po  Po
slope    
 I  abovethreshold I  I th

Increase in optical output power

slope 
Increase in input current above threshold
 Laser Diode Efficiencies

External Quantum Efficiency

Number of output photons from the diode per unit second

EQE 
Number of injected electrons into the diode per unit second

Po / h ePo
EQE  
I /e Eg I
 Laser Diode Efficiencies

External Differential Quantum Efficiency

Increase in number of output photons from diode per unit second

 EDQE 
Increase in number of injected electrons into diode per unit second

Po / h e  e  Po
 EDQE   slope 
I / e h  E g  I  I th
 Laser Diode Efficiencies

Internal Quantum Efficiency

Number of photons generated internally per unit second

IDQE 
Number of injected electrons into diode per unit second

1/ r
IQE 
1 /  r  1 /  nr

tnr = Nonradiative recombination time

tr = Radiative recombination time

 Laser Diode Efficiencies

Internal Differential Quantum Efficiency

Increase in number of photons generated internally per unit second

 IDQE 
Increase in number of injected electrons into diode per unit second

If the current increases by DI above threshold, increase in the

injected electrons is DI/e

The increase in the number of photons generated internally is

then

hIDQE × DI/e
 Laser Diode Efficiencies

Extraction efficiency
=
(Loss from the exit cavity end)
/ (Total loss)

hEE = (1/2L)ln(1/R1) / at
 Laser Diode Efficiencies

Po = hEEhIDQEhu(I - Ith)/e
hslope = DPo/ D I = hEEhIDQEhu/e

hEDQE = (DPo/ hu) / (D I/e)

= (Po/ hu) / [(I - Ith)/e] = hEEhIDQE
 Laser Diode Efficiencies

Power Conversion Efficiency

Optical output power Po  Eg 
 PCE     EQE  
Electrical input power IV  eV 

Po  Eg 
PCE   EQE  
IV  eV 
 Laser Diode Efficiencies
Typical characteristics for a few selected red and violet commercial laser diodes. All LDs are
MQW structures and have FP cavities. Violet lasers are based on InGaN/GaN MQW, and red
LEDs use mainly AlGaInP/GaInP MQW.

LD Po l Ith I V q q// hslope hPCE

(mW) (nm) (mA) (mA) (V) (mW/mA) %
Red 500 670 400 700 2.4 21 10 1.0 30
Red 100 660 75 180 2.5 18 9 1.0 22
Red 50 660 60 115 2.3 17 10 0.90 19
Red 10 639 30 40 2.3 21 8 1.0 11
Violet 400 405 160 390 5.0 45 15 1.7 21
Violet 120 405 45 120 5.0 17 8 1.6 20
Violet 10 405 26 35 4.8 19 8.5 1.1 6.0
 Laser Diode Efficiencies

Typical values for the threshold current Ith, slope efficiency (hslope ) and power conversion efficiency
(hPCE) for 36 commercial red LDs with different optical output powers from 3 mW - 500 mW.
EXAMPLE: Laser diode efficiencies for a sky blue LD
Consider a 60 mW blue LD (Nichia SkyBlue NDS4113), emitting at a peak wavelength of 488 nm. The
threshold current is 30 mA. At a forward current of 100 mA and a voltage of 5.6 V, the output power is
60 mW. Find the slope efficiency, PCE, EQE and EDQE.

Solution
From the definition in Eq. (4.12.2),
hslope = Po / (I - Ith)
= (60 mW) / (100 - 30 mA) = 0.86 mW/mA-1
From Eq. (4.12.8), PCE is
hPCE = Po / IV
= (60 mW) / [(100 mA)(5.6 V)] = 0.11 or 11%
We can find the EQE from Eq. (4.12.3) but we need hu, which is hc/l. In eV,
hu (eV) = 1.24 / l (m m)
= 1.24 /0.488 = 2.54 eV
EQE is given by Eq. (4.12.3)
hEQE = (Po /hu) / (I /e )
= [(60×10-3)/(2.54×1.6×10-19)]/[(100×10-3) /(1.6×10-19)] =
0.24 or 24%
EXAMPLE: Laser diode efficiencies for a sky blue LD
Solution (continued)

Similarly, hEDQE is given by Eq. (4.12.4b) above threshold,

hEDQE = (D Po /hu) / (D I /e )  (Po /hu) / [( I - Ith )/e )]

= [(60×10-3)/(2.54×1.6×10-19)] / [(100×10-3-30×10-3)/1.6×10-19)]

= 0.34 or 34%

The EDQE is higher than the EQE because most injected electrons above Ith are
used in stimulated recombinations. EQE gauges the total conversion efficiency from
all the injected electrons brought by the current to coherent output photons. But, a
portion of the current is used in pumping the gain medium.
EXAMPLE: Laser diode efficiencies
Consider an InGaAs FP semiconductor laser diode that emits CW radiation at 1310 nm. The cavity
length (L) is 200 mm. The internal loss coefficient as = 20 cm-1, R1 = R3  0.33 (cleaved ends). Assume
that internal differential quantum efficiency, IDQE, is close to 1. The threshold current is 5 mA. What is
the output power Po at I = 20 mA? The forward voltage is about 1.3 V. What is the EDQE and
conversion efficiency?
Solution
From the definition of IDQE in Eq. (4.12.6), the number of internal coherent
photons generated per second above threshold is hIDQE(I - Ith)/e. Thus,

Internal optical power generated = hu ×hIDQE(I - Ith)/e

The extraction efficiency hEE then couples a portion of this optical power into the
output radiation. The output power Po is then hEE × hu ×hIDQE(I - Ith)/e. Thus,

Po = hEEhIDQEhu(I - Ith)/e Output power vs current (4.12.9)

The slope efficiency from Eq.(4.12.2) is

hslope = D Po / D I = hEEhIDQE(hu/e ) Slope efficiency (4.12.10)
EXAMPLE .3: Laser diode efficiencies
Solution (continued)

Further, from the definition of EDQE and Eq.(4.12.9) is

hEDQE = (D Po / hu) / (DI /e) = (Po / hu) / [(I - Ith)/e] = hEEhIDQE

External differential quantum efficiency (4.12.11)

We can now calculate the quantities needed. The total loss coefficient is

at = as + (1/2L) ln (1 / R1R2)

=2000 + (2×200×10-6)-1 ln(0.33×0.33)-1 = 7543 m-1

The extraction efficiency is

hEE = (1/2L)ln (1/R1) / at = (2×200×10-6)-1 ln(1/0.33) / (7543) =

0.37 or 37%
EXAMPLE: Laser diode efficiencies
Solution (continued)

Thus, using I = 20 mA in Eq. (4.12.9),

Po = (0.37)(1)[(6.62×10-34)(3×108)/(1310×10-9)][(0.02 - 0.005) / (1.6×10-19)] =

5.2 mW

The slope efficiency from Eq. (4.12.10) is

hslope = DPo / DI = (5.2 mW - 0) / (20 mA - 5 mA) = 0.35 mW mA-1

The EDQE from Eq. (4.12.11) is

hEDQE = hEEhIDQE = 0.37 or 37%

The power conversion efficiency hPCE = Po / IV

= 5.2 mW / (20 mA × 1.3 V)
= 0.20 or 20%
Laser Diode
Equation

A highly simplified and idealized description of a

semiconductor laser diode for deriving the LD
equation. (a) The heterostructure laser diode structure.
(b) The current I injects electrons in the conduction
band, and these electrons recombine radiatively with
the holes in the active region. (c) The coherent
radiation intensity across the device; only a fraction G
is within the active region where there is optical gain.
(d) Injected electron concentration n and coherent
radiation output power Po vs. diode current I. The
current represents the pump rate.
 Laser Diode Equation

I n
  CnNph
eLWd τ r
Radiative lifetime
Rate of electron injection by current I
= Rate of spontaneous emissions
+ Rate of stimulated emissions

N ph
 CnN ph Rate of coherent photon loss in the cavity
 ph = Rate of stimulated emissions

Photon cavity lifetime

 Laser Diode Equation

I th nth
 Threshold

eLWd τr
1
nth  Threshold

C ph

Substitute back into steady state rate equation

I

nth
 CnthN ph
 ph
eLWd τr N ph  ( I  I th )
eLWd
 Laser Diode Equation
 ph
N ph  ( I  I th )
eLWd
( 12 N ph )(Cavity Volume)(Ph oton energy)
Po  (1  R )
t

 hc 2 ph (1  R ) 
Po    ( I  I th )
 2enL 

 hc 2 ph (1  R ) 
Io    ( J  J th )
 2end 
Light intensity = Po / A
Threshold Gain

1  1 
g th   t   s  ln  
2 L  R1R2 

G= Fraction of the coherent optical

radiation within the active region

The gain g works on the radiation within the

cavity, which means that we must multiply g
with G to account for less than perfect optical
confinement
 Optical Gain Curve
(a)
(b)

(a) The density of states and energy distribution of electrons and holes in the conduction and
valence bands respectively at T > 0 in the SCL under forward bias such that EFn - EFp > Eg.
Holes in the VB are empty states. (b) Gain vs. photon energy (hu).
 Optical Gain Curve

Optical gain g vs. photon energy for an InGaAsP active layer (in a 1500 nm LD) as a function of injected
carrier concentration n from 1×1018 to 3×1018 cm-3. (The model described in Leuthold et al, J. Appl. Phys.,
87, 618, 2000 was used to find the gain spectra at different carrier concentrations.) (Data combined from J.
Singh, Electronic and Optoelectronic Properties of Semiconductor Structures, Cambridge University Press,
203, p390; N.K. Dutta, J. Appl. Phys., 51, 6095, 1980; J. Leuthold et al, J. Appl. Phys., 87, 618, 2000.)
 Optical Gain Curve

The dependence of the peak gain coefficient (maximum g) on the injected carrier concentration n for
GaAs (860 nm), In0.72Ga0.28As0.6P0.4 (1300 nm), and In0.60Ga0.40As0.85P0.15 (1500 nm) active layers. (Data
combined from J. Singh, Electronic and Optoelectronic Properties of Semiconductor Structures,
Cambridge University Press, 203, p390; N.K. Dutta, J. Appl. Phys., 51, 6095, 1980; J. Leuthold et al, J.
Appl. Phys., 87, 618, 2000.)
EXAMPLE: Threshold current and optical output power from a Fabry-Perot
(FP) heterostructure laser diode
Consider GaAs DH laser diode that lases at 860 nm. It has an active layer (cavity) length L of 250 mm.
The active layer thickness d is 0.15 mm and the width W is 5 mm. The refractive index is 3.6, and the
attenuation coefficient as inside the cavity is 103 m-1. The required threshold gain gth corresponds to a
threshold carrier concentration nth  2×1018 cm-3. The radiative lifetime tr in the active region can be
found (at least approximately) by using tr = 1/Bnth, where B is the direct recombination coefficient, and
assuming strong injection as will be the case for laser diodes [see Eq. (3.8.7) in Chapter 3]. For GaAs, B
 2×10-16 m3 s-1. What is the threshold current density and threshold current? Find the output optical
power at I = 1.5Ith, and the external slope efficiency hslope. How would G = 0.5 affect the calculations?

Solution
The reflectances at the each end are the same (we assume no other thin film
coating on the ends of the cavity) so that R = (n-1)2/ (n+1)2 = 0.32. The total
attenuation coefficient at and hence the threshold gain gth, assuming G = 1 in Eq.
(4.13.9), is
1  1 
g th   t  (10 cm 1 )  = 55.6 cm4-1 ln  
(2  250  10 cm )  (0.32)( 0.32) 
From Figure 4.48(b), at this gain of 56 cm-1, nth  2×1018 cm-3. This is the threshold
carrier concentration that gives the right gain under ideal optical confinement,
with G = 1.
EXAMPLE: Threshold current and optical output power from a Fabry-Perot (FP)
heterostructure laser diode
Solution (continued)

The radiative lifetime tr = 1/Bnth = 1/[2×10-16 m3 s-1)( (2×1024 m-3)] = 2.5 ns

Since J = I/WL, the threshold current density from Eq. (4.13.4) is

nth ed (2 10 24 m 3 )(1.6 10 19 C)(0.15 10 6 m)
J
= th 
τr (2.5 10 9 s)

= 1.9×107 A m-2 or 1.9 kA cm-2 or 19 A mm-2.

The threshold current itself is,
Ith = (WL)Jth = (5×10-6 m) (250×10-6 m)(1.9×107 A m-2) =
0.024 A or 24 mA
The photon cavity lifetime depends on at, and is given by
tph = n/(cat) = 3.6 / [(3×108 m s-1)(5.56×103 m-1)]
= 2.16 ps
The laser diode output power is
 hc  ph (1  R ) 
2 34
(6.626  10 )( 3  10 ) ( 2.16  1012 )(1  0.32)
8 2
Po   ( I  I th )  ( I  I th )
 2enL 
19 9 6
2(1.6  10 )( 3.6 )(860  10 )( 250  10 )
EXAMPLE: Threshold current and optical output power from a Fabry-Perot (FP)
heterostructure laser diode
Solution (continued)

That is Po = (0.35 W A-1)(I – Ith ) = (0.35 mW mA-1)(I – 24 mA)

When I = 1.5Ith = 36 mA,
Po = (0.35 mW mA-1)(36 mA-24 mA) = 4.2 mW
The slope efficiency is the slope of the Po vs. I characteristic above Ith,
Po  hc  ph (1  R ) 
2

slope    -1
I =0.35 nL mA
2emW 

We can now repeat the problem say for G = 0.5, which would give Ggth = at, so that
gth = 55.6 cm-1 / 0.5 = 111 cm-1. From Figure 4.48 (b), at this gain of 111 cm-1, nth 
2.5×1018 cm-3. The new radiative lifetime,
tr = 1/Bnth = 1/[2.0×10-16 m3 s-1)(2.5×1024 m-3)] = 2.0 ns
The corresponding threshold current density is
Jth = nthed/tr = (2.5×1024 m-3)(1.6×10-19 C)(0.15×10-6 m)/(2.0×10-9 s)
= 30 A mm-2
and the corresponding threshold current Ith is 37.5 mA
EXAMPLE: Threshold current and optical output power from a Fabry-Perot (FP)
heterostructure laser diode
Solution (continued)

There are several important notes to this problem

• First, the threshold concentration nth  2×1018 cm-3 was obtained graphically from Figure
4.48 (b) by using the gth value we need.

• Second is that, at best, the calculations represent rough values since we also need to
know how the mode spreads into the cladding where there is no gain but absorption and, in
addition, what fraction of the current is lost to nonradiative recombination processes. We
can increase as to account for absorption in the cladding, which would result in a higher
gth, larger nth and greater Ith. If tnr is the nonradiative lifetime, we can replace tr by an
 1   r1   nr
1

effective recombination time t such that , which means that the threshold current
will again be larger. We would also need to reduce the optical output power since some of
the injected electrons are now used in nonradiative transitions.

• Third, is the low slope efficiency compared with commercial LDs. hslope depends on tph,
the photon cavity lifetime, which can be greatly improved by using better reflectors at the
cavity ends, e.g. ,by using thin film coating on the crystal facets to increase R.
 Distributed Bragg Reflector (DBR) LDs

(a) The basic principle of the Distributed Bragg Reflection (DBR) laser. (b)
Partially reflected waves at the corrugations can only constitute a reflected
wave when the wavelength satisfies the Bragg condition. Reflected waves A
and B interfere constructively when q(lB/n) = 2L. (c) Typical output
spectrum. SMSR is the side mode suppression ratio.
 Distributed Feedback (DFB) LDs

LEFT: Distributed feedback (DFB) laser structure. The mode field diameter is
normally larger than the active layer thickness and the radiation spreads into the
guiding layer.

RIGHT: There are left and right propagating waves, partial reflections from the
corrugation, and optical amplification within the cavity, which has both the active
layer and the guiding layer.
 Distributed Feedback (DFB) LDs

2B
m   B  ( m  1)
2nL

LEFT: Ideal lasing emission output has two primary peaks above and
below lB. RIGHT: Typical output spectrum from a DFB laser has a single
narrow peak with a dl typically very narrow, and much less than 0.1 nm
 Distributed Bragg Reflector (DBR) and Distributed
Feedback (DFB) LDs

Selected properties of DBR, DFB and external cavity (EC) laser diodes
Note: fm is 10-15 s; du and dl are spectral widths (FWHM). SMSR is the side
mode suppression ratio, TEC is a thermoelectric cooler

LD l0 du, dl SMSR Po I hslope Comment

(nm)   dB mW mA mA
 
DBRa 1063 2 MHz, 45 80 200 0.8 GaAs DBR LD for spectroscopy and metrology, includes
8 fm monitor current, TEC and thermistor.
DFBb 1063 2 MHz, 45 80 190 0.2 GaAs DFB LD for spectroscopy and metrology, includes
8 fm monitor current, TEC and thermistor
DFBc 1550 10 MHz, 45 40 300 0.3 Pigtailed to a fiber, includes monitor current, TEC and
0.08 pm thermistor. CW output for external modulation. For use in
long haul DWDM.
DFBd 1653 0.1 nm 35 5 30 0.23 Pigtailed to a single mode fiber, includes monitor current,
TEC and thermistor. Mainly for fiber optic sensing.

ECe 1550 50 kHz; 45 40 300 0.2 Pigtailed. Tunable over Du = 3 GHz. Mainly for
0.4 fm communications

a
Eagleyard, EYP-DBR-1080-00080-2000-TOC03-0000; bEagleyard, EYP-DFB-1083-00080-1500-TOC03-0000;
c
Furukawa-Fitel, FOL15DCWD; dInphenix, IPDFD1602; eCovega SFL1550S, marketed by Thorlabs.
Example: DFB LD wavelength
Consider a DFB laser that has a corrugation period L of 0.22 mm and a grating length of 400 mm. Suppose
that the effective refractive index of the medium is 3.5. Assuming a first order grating, calculate the Bragg
wavelength, the mode wavelengths and their separation.

Solution
The Bragg wavelength is

2n 2(0.mm.
22 μm)(3.5)
B  = 1.5400

q 1
and the symmetric mode wavelengths about lB are
B2 (1.5400 μm) 2
m  B  (m  1)  1.5400  (0  1)
2n L 2(3.5)(400 μm)
so that the m = 0 mode wavelengths are
l0 = 1.53915 or 1.54085 mm.
The two are separated by 0.0017 mm, or 1.7 nm. Due to a design asymmetry,
only one mode will appear in the output and for most practical purposes the mode
wavelength can be taken as lB. Note: The wavelength calculation was kept to five
decimal places because lm is very close to lB..
 External Cavity Laser Diodes (ECLD)

A simplified diagram of an external cavity diode laser (ECDL), which uses an angled
interference filter (IF) to select the wavelength lo (depends on the angle of the IF), and the
optical cavity has a GRIN lens with one end coated for full reflection back to the LD. The output
is taken from the left facet of the LD.
 External Cavity Laser Diodes (ECLD)

LEFT: A commercial external cavity diode laser, based on the principle shown on the right. (US Patent
6,556,599, Bookham Technology). The output is a single mode at 785 nm ( 1.5 pm) with a linewidth less
than 200 kHz, and coupled into a fiber. The output power is 35 mW, and the SMSR is 50 dB. (ECDL,
SWL-7513-P. Courtesy of Newport, USA)