Risk & Return
Risk & Return
3
Average Rate of Return
• The average rate of return is the sum of the
various one-period rates of return divided by
the number of period.
• Formula for the average rate of return is as
follows: 1 1 n
R = [ R1 R 2 R n ] Rt
n t =1 n
4
Risk of Rates of Return: Variance and Standard
Deviation
1 n 2
2
Variance
n 1 t 1
Rt R
5
Example
• The following table gives dividend and share price data for Hind Manufacturing
Company. You are required to calculate: (i) the annual rates of return, (ii) the
expected (average) rate of return, (iii) the variance, and (iv) the standard
deviation of returns.
Dividend Per Share Closing Share Price Expected Return OR Annual Rate of
Return
2.50 12.25 -
2.50 14.20 2.50 + (14.20 – 12.25) / 12.25 = 36.32
2.50 17.50 2.50 + (17.50-14.20) / 14.20= 40.84
3.00 16.75 3 + (16.75 – 17.50) / 17.50 = 12.86
3.00 18.45 3+ (18.45 – 16.75 ) / 16.75 = 28.05
3.25 22.25 3.25 + ( 22.25 – 18.45) / 18.45 = 38.21
3.50 23.50 3.50 + (23.50 – 22.25 ) / 22.25 =21.35
3.50 27.75 3.50 + (27.75 – 23.50 ) / 23.50 = 32.98
3.50 25.50 3.50 + (25.50-27.75) / 27.75 = 4.5
3.75 27.95 3.75 + ( 27.95 – 25.50 ) / 25.50 = 24.31
3.75 31.30 3.75 + ( 31.30 – 27.95 ) / 27.95 = 25.40
Average Rate of 264.81 / 10 = 26.481 %
Return
Year (Col.1) Annual Rate of Annual Return minus Square of Deviation
Return(Col.2) Average Return (Col.3) (Col.3)2
2004 36.32 36.32 - 26.48= 9.84 9.84*9.84= 96.83
2005 40.84 40.84 – 26 .48 = 14.36 14.36*14.36= 206.20
2006 12.86 12.86 – 26.48 = -13.62 -13.62 * -13.62 = 185.50
2007 28.06 28.06 – 26.48 = 1.58 1.58 * 1.58 = 2.5
2008 38.21 38.21 – 26.48 = 11.73 11.73*11.73 *137.59
2009 21.35 21.35 – 26.48 = -5.13 -5.13* -5.13 = 26.32
2010 32.98 32.98 – 26.48 = 6.49 6.49*6.49 = 42.25
2011 4.50 4.50 – 26.48 = -21.98 -21.98 * -21.98 = 483.12
2012 24.31 24.31 – 26.48 = -2.18 -2.18 * -2.18 = 4.71
2013 25.40 25.40 – 26.48 = -1.08 -1.08 * -1.08 = 1.16
Total = 1186.2
Variance = 1186.2 / (10-1) = 131.8
Standard Deviation = Square root of 131.8 =
11.48
Expected Return : Incorporating Probabilities in Estimates
• The expected rate of return [E (R)] is the sum of the product of each outcome
(return) and its associated probability:
Rates of Returns Under Various Economic Conditions
9
Example
• Star Computer System Limited has forecasted returns on its share
with the following probability distribution. Calculate the
expected return, variance and standard deviation of returns for
Star.
Return (X) Probability Return * (Return – Probability *
(P) Probability(( ERR)2 (Return –
P*X) ERR)2
-20 0.05 -20*0.05= -1 (-20-11 )2 = - -33*-33*0.05
33*-33 48.05
-10 0.05 -10*0.05= - (-10-11)2= - -21*-21*0.05
0.5 21*-21 22.05
-5 0.10 -5*0.10= - (-5-11)2 -16*-16*0.10
0.5 25.6
5 0.10 5*0.10= 0.5 (5-11)2 -6*-6*0.10 3.6
10 0.15 10*0.15= 1.5 (10-11)2 -1*-1*0.15
0.15
18 0.25 18*0.25= 4.5 (18-11)2 7*7*0.25
12.25
20 0.25 20*0.25= 5 (20-11)2 9*9*0.25 20.25
30 0.05 30*0.05= 1.5 (30-11)2 19*19*0.05
18.05
Mean or Average X= Variance 150 150
Average ERR 11%
Standard Square root 12.24%
Deviation of Variance =
Historical Risk Premium
• The 28-year average return on the stock market is higher by
about 15 per cent in comparison with the average return on 91-
day T-bills.
12
Example
• The following are the returns during five years on a market portfolio
of shares and ‘AAA’ corporate bonds. You are require to calculate (i)
the realized risk premium of shares over the ‘AAA’ bonds in each
year; and (ii) the average risk premium of shares over ‘AAA’ bonds
during the period. Can the realized premium be negative? Why?
Solution
• The calculations for the premium in each year and the average
premium are shown below. The average premium is 4.7 percent.
• The realized premium can be negative as the share prices in practice
show wide swings. However, over a long period of time the premium
would be positive, as shares are more risky than bonds.
Expected Risk and Preference
• A risk-averse investor will choose among investments with
the equal rates of return, the investment with lowest
standard deviation and among investments with equal risk
she would prefer the one with higher return.
15
Risk preferences
16
Normal Distribution and Standard Deviation
17
Normal distribution
18
Properties of a Normal Distribution
19
Probability of Expected Returns
• The normal probability table, can be used to determine the
area under the normal curve for various standard deviations.
• The distribution tabulated is a normal distribution with mean
zero and standard deviation of 1. Such a distribution is known
as a standard normal distribution.
• Any normal distribution can be standardised and hence the
table of normal probabilities will serve for any normal
distribution. The formula to standardise is:
S = R - E(R)
s
20
Normal distribution
21
Properties of a Normal Distribution
22
Probability of Expected Returns
• The normal probability table, can be used to determine the
area under the normal curve for various standard deviations.
• The distribution tabulated is a normal distribution with mean
zero and standard deviation of 1. Such a distribution is known
as a standard normal distribution.
• Any normal distribution can be standardised and hence the
table of normal probabilities will serve for any normal
distribution. The formula to standardise is:
S = R - E(R)
s
23
Example
• An asset has an expected return of 29.32 per cent and the standard
deviation of the possible returns is 13.52 per cent.
• To find the probability that the return of the asset will be zero or less,
we can divide the difference between zero and the expected value of
the return by standard deviation of possible net present value as
follows:
• S= 0 - 29.32
= – 2.17
13.52
• The probability of being less than 2.17 standard deviations from the
expected value, according to the normal probability distribution table is
0.015. This means that there is 0.015 or 1.5% probability that the return
of the asset will be zero or less.
24
Portfolio Return and Risk
INTRODUCTION
• A portfolio is a bundle or a combination of individual assets or
securities.
• Portfolio theory provides a normative approach to investors to
make decisions to invest their wealth in assets or securities
under risk.
• The return of a portfolio is equal to the weighted average of
the returns of individual assets (or securities)
• Extend the portfolio theory to derive a framework for valuing
risky assets. This framework is referred to as the capital asset
pricing model (CAPM).
• An alternative model for the valuation of risky assets is the
arbitrage pricing theory (APT).
26
PORTFOLIO RETURN: TWO-ASSET CASE
27
Example
• 5000 in X Stock (Return = 10%, Risk = 8%)
• 5000 in Y Stock (return = 8%, Risk = 4% )
• Weight age Risk
• Portfolio Return = W1R1 + W2R2 =
10%*0.5 + 8%*0.5 = 5+4 = 9%
• Portfolio Risk = 0.5*8 + 0.5*4 = 6%
• No, the portfolio risk of a diversified portfolio is less
than the weighted average of individual risk of the
securities.
Expected Rate of Return: Example
Suppose there is an opportunity of investing your wealth either in
asset X or asset Y. The possible outcomes of two assets in
different states of economy are as follows:
Possible Outcomes of two Assets, X and Y
Return (%)
State of Economy Probability X Y
A 0.10 –8 14
B 0.20 10 –4
C 0.40 8 6
D 0.20 5 15
E 0.10 –4 20
The expected rate of return of X is the sum of the product of outcomes and their respective
probability. That is:
E ( Rx ) = (- 8´ 0.1) + (10 ´ 0.2) + (8´ 0.4) + (5 ´ 0.2)
+ (- 4 ´ 0.1) = 5%
Similarly, the expected rate of return of Y is:
E ( Ry ) = (14 ´ 0.1) + (- 4 ´ 0.2) + (6 ´ 0.4) + (15´ 0.2)
+ (20 ´ 0.1) = 8%
Deviation from Product of
State of Expected Deviation &
Economy Probability Returns Returns Probability
X Y X Y
A 0.1 –8 14 – 13 6 – 7.8
B 0.2 10 –4 5 – 12 – 12.0
C 0.4 8 6 3 –2 – 2.4
D 0.2 5 15 0 7 0.0
E 0.1 –4 20 –9 12 – 10.8
E(RX) E(RY) Covar = –33.0
=5 =8
30
Stat Probability X returns Y returns Deviatio Risk of X Deviati Risk of Product of
e n X (Ri – on Y (Ri Y Deviations
ERR-X) – ERR Y) (X & Y) &
probabilitie
s
- 33.0 - 33.0
Corxy = = = - 0.746
5.80 ´ 7.63 44.25
32
Example
PORTFOLIO RISK: TWO-ASSET CASE
34
Measuring Portfolio Risk for Two Assets
35
Correlation
36
Correlation
• The value of correlation, called the correlation
coefficient, could be positive, negative or zero.
• The correlation coefficient always ranges
between –1.0 and +1.0.
• A correlation coefficient of +1.0 implies a
perfectly positive correlation while a
correlation coefficient of –1.0 indicates a
perfectly negative correlation.
37
Variance and Standard Deviation of a
Two-Asset Portfolio
38
Portfolio Risk Depends on
Correlation between Assets
39
Example
• An investor holds two equity shares x and y in equal proportion with the
following risk and return characteristics. The returns of these securities
have a positive correlation of 0.6. You are required to calculate the
portfolio return and risk. Further, suppose the investor wants to reduce
the portfolio risk (σp) to 15 per cent. How much should the correlation
coefficient be to bring the portfolio risk to the desired level?
Part 1
Portfolio Return = 0.5 * 24 + 0.5 * 19 = 12+9.5 = 21.5%
43
Example
Portfolio Return and Risk for Different
Correlation Coefficients
P o rtfo lio R isk , p (% )
P or tfolio C o rre la tio n
W e ig ht Re tur n (% ) +1.00 -1.00 0.00 0.50 -0.25
Lo g ro w Ra p id ex Rp p p p p p
1.00 0.00 12.00 16.00 16.00 16.00 16.00 16.00
0.90 0.10 12.60 16.80 12.00 14.60 15.74 13.99
0.80 0.20 13.20 17.60 8.00 13.67 15.76 12.50
0.70 0.30 13.80 18.40 4.00 13.31 16.06 11.70
0.60 0.40 14.40 19.20 0.00 13.58 16.63 11.76
0.50 0.50 15.00 20.00 4.00 14.42 17.44 12.65
0.40 0.60 15.60 20.80 8.00 15.76 18.45 14.22
0.30 0.70 16.20 21.60 12.00 17.47 19.64 16.28
0.20 0.80 16.80 22.40 16.00 19.46 20.98 18.66
0.10 0.90 17.40 23.20 20.00 21.66 22.44 21.26
0.00 1.00 18.00 24.00 24.00 24.00 24.00 24.00
Minimum V ar ianc e P or tfolio
wL 1.00 0.60 0.692 0.857 0.656
wR 0.00 0.40 0.308 0.143 0.344
2
256 0.00 177.23 246.86 135.00
(% ) 16 0.00 13.31 15.71 11.62
45
Perfect Positive Correlation
46
There is no advantage of diversification when the returns of securities
have perfect positive correlation.
47
Perfect Negative Correlation
• In this the portfolio return increases and the
portfolio risk declines.
• It results in risk-less portfolio.
• The correlation is -1.0.
48
49
Limits to diversification
Since any probable correlation of securities Logrow and Rapidex will range
between – 1.0 and + 1.0, the triangle in the above figure specifies the limits to
diversification. The risk-return curves for any correlations within the limits of – 1.0
and + 1.0, will fall within the triangle ABC.
50
Zero-variance portfolio
51
Zero Correlation
52
53
Positive Correlation
• In reality, returns of most assets have positive
but less than 1.0 correlation.
54
EFFICIENT PORTFOLIO AND MEAN-
VARIANCE CRITERION - MPT
55
Investment Opportunity Set:
Two-Asset Case
56
Investment opportunity sets given different
correlations
57
Mean-variance Criterion
58
Investment Opportunity Set:
The n-Asset Case
59
Efficient Portfolios of risky securities
An efficient portfolio
is one that has the
highest expected
returns for a given level
of risk. The efficient
frontier is the frontier
formed by the set of
efficient portfolios. All
other portfolios, which
lie outside the efficient
frontier, are inefficient
portfolios.
60
PORTFOLIO RISK: THE n-ASSET CASE
61
RISK DIVERSIFICATION:
SYSTEMATIC AND UNSYSTEMATIC RISK
62
Systematic Risk
• Systematic risk arises on account of the
economy-wide uncertainties and the tendency of
individual securities to move together with
changes in the market.
• This part of risk cannot be reduced through
diversification.
• It is also known as market risk.
• Investors are exposed to market risk even when
they hold well-diversified portfolios of securities.
63
Examples of Systematic Risk
64
Unsystematic Risk
• Unsystematic risk arises from the unique uncertainties
of individual securities.
• It is also called unique risk.
• These uncertainties are diversifiable if a large numbers
of securities are combined to form well-diversified
portfolios.
• Uncertainties of individual securities in a portfolio
cancel out each other.
• Unsystematic risk can be totally reduced through
diversification.
65
Examples of Unsystematic Risk
66
Total Risk
67
Systematic and unsystematic risk and
number of securities
68
COMBINING A RISK-FREE ASSET AND
A RISKY ASSET
69
A Risk-Free Asset and A Risky Asset: Example
RISK-RETURN ANALYSIS FOR A PORTFOLIO OF A RISKY AND A RISK-FREE SECURITIES
Weights (%) Expected Return, Rp Standard Deviation (p)
Risky security Risk-free security (%) (%)
120 – 20 17 7.2
100 0 15 6.0
80 20 13 4.8
60 40 11 3.6
40 60 9 2.4
20 80 7 1.2
0 100 5 0.0
20
D
E x p e c te d R e tu r n
17.5
C
15
B
12.5
10 A
7.5
5
2.5 Rf, risk-free rate
0
0 1.8 3.6 5.4 7.2 9
Standard Deviation
MULTIPLE RISKY ASSETS AND
A RISK-FREE ASSET
71
Risk-return relationship for portfolio of risky
and risk-free securities
We draw three lines from the risk-free rate (5%) to the three portfolios.
Each line shows the manner in which capital is allocated. This line is
called the capital allocation line.
Portfolio M is the optimum risky portfolio, which can be combined with
the risk-free asset.
The capital market line (CML) is an efficient set of risk-free and risky
securities, and it shows the risk-return trade-off in the market equilibrium.
72
Separation Theory
• According to the separation theory, the choice
of portfolio involves two separate steps.
• The first step involves the determination of
the optimum risky portfolio.
• The second step concerns with the investor’s
decision to form portfolio of the risk-free
asset and the optimum risky portfolio
depending on her risk preferences.
73
Slope of CML
74
Example
• Expected Return of Investor = 15
15 = 18 * Wm + 8 * (1- Wm)
Wm = 0.7
Portfolio Risk = Wm * Standard Deviation of Market
Portolio
= 0.7 * 6 = 4.2%
E(Rp) = Rf + (( RM – Rf) / (stand dev of M)) stand dev
of Portfolio
= 8% + ((18 – 8) / 6 ) 4.2 = 15%
CAPITAL ASSET PRICING MODEL (CAPM)
• The capital asset pricing model (CAPM) is a model that provides a
framework to determine the required rate of return on an asset
and indicates the relationship between return and risk of the asset.
• The required rate of return specified by CAPM helps in valuing an
asset.
• One can also compare the expected (estimated) rate of return on
an asset with its required rate of return and determine whether
the asset is fairly valued.
• Under CAPM, the security market line (SML) exemplifies the
relationship between an asset’s risk and its required rate of return.
76
Assumptions of CAPM
Market efficiency
Homogeneous expectations
Risk-free rate
77
Characteristics Line
78
Security Market Line (SML)
79
Security market line with normalize systematic risk
80
IMPLICATIONS AND RELEVANCE OF
CAPM
81
Implications
• Investors will always combine a risk-free asset with
a market portfolio of risky assets. They will invest
in risky assets in proportion to their market value.
83
THE ARBITRAGE PRICING THEORY (APT)
• The act of taking advantage of a price differential
between two or more markets is referred to as arbitrage.
• The Arbitrage Pricing Theory (APT) describes the method
of bring a mispriced asset in line with its expected price.
• An asset is considered mispriced if its current price is
different from the predicted price as per the model.
• The fundamental logic of APT is that investors always
indulge in arbitrage whenever they find differences in
the returns of assets with similar risk characteristics.
84
Concept of Return under APT
85
Concept of Risk under APT
86
Steps in Calculating
Expected Return under APT
87
Factors
Changes in
Industrial default
production premium
Changes in the
structure of
Inflation
interest rates rate
88
Risk premium
• Conceptually, it is the compensation, over and
above, the risk-free rate of return that
investors require for the risk contributed by
the factor.
89
Factor beta
• The beta of the factor is the sensitivity of the
asset’s return to the changes in the factor.
90