Chapter 5 - Documentary Credit
Chapter 5 - Documentary Credit
COURSE OBJECTIVES
After study this chapter, you will be able to: Understand the application of documentary credit. Understand the commonly used documentary credit and forms of payment in international trade. Explain various documents required for preparing documentary credit. Explain discrepancies and how to resolve it. Various financing of LC from an Islamic Bank.
RECAP
Documentary Collection
A procedure in which a bank in the importers country acts on behalf of an exporter for collecting and remitting payment for a shipment. In other words, Documentary Collection is a procedure for collecting and remitting payment for a shipment How to claim goods shipped?
3
RECAP
Documentary Collection:
1. Documentary Against Payment (DAP)
Suitable for Exporter
A payment undertaking given by a bank to the seller and is issued on behalf of the applicant i.e. the buyer.
Exporter Importer
DOCUMENTARY CREDIT
Also known as Letter of Credit (LC). A payment term generally used for international sales transactions. It is basically a mechanism, which allows importers/buyers to offer secure terms of payment to exporters/sellers in which a bank (or more than one bank) gets involved.
S.W.I.F.T
Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunication The majority of international interbank messages use the SWIFT network. SWIFT transports financial messages in a highly secure way, but does not hold accounts for its members and does not perform any form of clearing or settlement.
10
9.
11
11.
12.
13.
15.
16. 17.
Expiry Date/Place of Credit The credit needs to have an expiry date for the presentation of documents or else it may cause some problems. Time for Presentation of Documents needs to stipulate the expiry date for presentation of documents for payment, acceptance or negotiation. If no such date the documents must be presented not later than 21 days under Article 43(a), UCP Whether Partial Shipment allowed means buyer needs to have his goods in one shipment or more shipments. Whether Transhipment is Allowed means under Article 23(b), UCP 500 as unloading and reloading from one vessel to another during the course of ocean carriage from the port of loading to the port of discharge stipulated in the credit 13
14
15
Disadvantages to seller: In the case of revocable LC, it may be amended or cancelled at any time without his prior consent If there are discrepancies, he may face delays in receiving his payment There is always the remote chance of the issuing bank becoming insolvent The seller needs to have some knowledge of the working of documentary credit.
16
17
18
19
BUYER/ APPLICANT
2. Application of L/C
ISSUING BANK
21
BUYER/ APPLICANT
10. Docs. Released to applicant
11. Applicant Makes payment
ISSUING BANK
22
23
The terms stated by BCL are: Sight LC or cash payment to be remitted to its bank in Brazil, Brazil National Bank (BNB). Goods will be shipped C&F (Port Klang, Malaysia) Insurance to be arranged by buyer (CSB) The terms stated by CSB are: Goods to be authenticated by the Brazil Gemstone Institute, stating that they are natural semi-precious stones and crystals mined/produced in Brazil. Goods must arrive Port Klang Malaysia by December 15 2003
24
STEP ACTION OR ACTIVITY TAKEN 1 CSB decided to import 1 containers of crystals and semi-precious stones from BCL. Upon checking with MITI, it was confirmed that no special permit required. CSB went to its bank, Maybank Islamic Bhd (MIB) (CSB has a trade line facility with MIB of RM500,000). CSB applied for sight LC for US$80,000 (RM304,000), to be addressed/forwarded to BNB in Brazil and favouring the beneficiary Brazil Corporation Ltd. Shipment terms C&F Port Klang. Latest shipment date : November 15 2003 (as goods must reach Port Klang on or before Dec. 15 2003 so to allow for 1 months journey)
CSB (importer)
25
STEP TAKEN 3
ACTION OR ACTIVITY
MIB checked CSBs account. Still has RM400,000 available trade line. Processed CSBs LC application. Couriered the original copy of the LC to BNB in Brazil. At CSBs request, confirmed a forward exchange rate for US$80,000 for CSBs account. Give duplicate copy to CSB. Went to insurance company to arrange for insurance policy (marine cargo policy) for the shipment of goods.
CSB (importer)
BNB received LC. Notified BCL. BCL intended to BNB (exporters negotiate the LC, and make all arrangements to bank) ship the goods.
26
STEP TAKEN 6
ACTION OR ACTIVITY
ACTION PERFORMED BY
BCL made arrangements to ship the goods. BCL Produced the shipping documents to BNB. BNB processed the claims by BCL. After it has ascertained that the various conditions stipulated in LC and terms of the importer have been duly met by BCL, it paid US$80,000 into BCLs account.
BNB processed the claims by BCL. Paid the BNB US$80,000 to BCLs account, then made arrangements to courier the shipping documents (including bill of lading) to MIB and claim US$80,000 from MIB.
27
STEP TAKEN 8
ACTION OR ACTIVITY
ACTION PERFORMED BY
MIB received the shipping documents from MIB BNB. Notified CSB and arranged to debit CSBs account and remit US$80,000 to BNB. CSB requested MIB to release the shipping documents. After confirming with CSB that it was satisfied with the documents received and that CSB was ready to take delivery of the goods, it processed CSBs application for a Trust Receipt of 90 days to accommodate CSBs temporary financing period because the US$80,000 has to be remitted to BNB to honour the LC arrangement. After CSBs TR of 90 days had been approved/processed, MIB remitted US$80,000 to BNB in Brazil.
The ship, SS Majesty, arrived Port Klang safely on December 10, 2003.
28
STEP TAKEN 10
ACTION OR ACTIVITY
CSB took the shipping documents. Went to Port Klang to declare the goods to Customs Dept in Port Klang and took delivery of the goods for its showrooms and sales outlets.
11
The 90-day TR matured on March 16, 2004. CSB CSB paid for it on Feb 20 2004 well before the maturity date. By doing so it saved a little on interest payable. MIB liquidated the TR account of CSB so that MIB CSB has again to date an available line of RM304,000 to use for other future imports/purchase.
12
29
FORMS OF DOCUMENTARY CREDIT/LETTER OF CREDIT There are two forms of documentary credit, namely: Revocable credit Irrevocable credit Article 6 of the UCP 550 provides that a credit should indicate clearly whether it revocable or irrevocable, and if there is no such indication, then the credit shall be deemed to be irrevocable.
30
31
Term (acceptance) Documentary Credit also known as acceptance credit. It calls for a tenor BE such as 30 days, 60 days, 80days, 90 days etc.) drawn by the beneficiary on the issuing bank, or the advising/confirming bank as stipulated in the credit. BE may be drawn for certain period and beneficiary will be able to secure payment on the maturity date. He may discount it prior to the maturity date if he needs financing.
34
RECAP
Documentary Credit = Letter of Credit (LC) Advantages and Disadvantages of LC to Seller/Exporter and Buyer/Importer Revocable LC Irrevocable LC Confirmed Irrevocable LC
35
RECAP
You must know :
What is LC? Advantages and Disadvantages of LC to:
Seller/Exporter Buyer/Importer
36
RECAP
Definition of LC A Letter of Credit is an instrument issued by a bank on behalf of the importer promising to pay the exporter upon presentation of the relevant prescribed documents
37
Letter of Credit = a document Who apply for LC? Issuing Bank? Advising Bank/Negotiating Bank? Beneficiary?
38
39
RED CLAUSE LC
LC is issued with special clause written in red, authorizing advising bank to make an advance to beneficiary according to stated terms and conditions. An example : This is a red clause credit authorizing the advising bank to advance up to 80% of this credit amount to the beneficiary to utilize it for goods to be supplied/shipped. Issuing bank is required to have a credit line with advising bank prior to its issuance. It is issued against applicant indemnity to indemnify the advance made. The bank provides the advance is not required to ascertain the end use of such advance. The suggested concept for this under shariah is Al-Mudharabah principle and known as Al Mudharabah LC.
40
STANDBY LC (SLC)
A form of guarantee payment. SLC secures payment to the beneficiary if there is nonperformance of the contract terms by another party. SLC backs up the beneficiary (seller/exporter) when there is any default by the buyer/importer. Assurance of payment to beneficiary for performance under contract against documents called for under the credit. For example, performance guarantee, repayment of loan, services rendered or for goods shipped. Standby LC is governed by UCP No. 400 while conventional guarantee is governed by the common law of the country where guarantee is issued. Concept under shariah may in used is Al-Kafalah, known as Al Kafalah LC.
41
REVOLVING LC
LC amount is renewed or reinstate automatically under stated condition. LC may revolve in relation to time or credit value. Example : This credit is a cumulative credit for RM10,000 available every month for 6 months period. In January, credit was drawn for RM10,000 i.e. the credit was fully negotiated/paid for RM10,000. In February the available amount is RM10 000. However in March it is negotiated for RM5,000. In April, the available balance is RM15 000. It can be cumulative or non-cumulative in nature. A revolving credit may be revocable or irrevocable.
42
BACK-TO-BACK LC (BBLC)
It involves two LC, the first LC is known as the Master LC or Prime LC and the second is known as Back-to-Back LC or Secondary LC. Those two LC are separate LC. Normally when a seller is a middleman. The applicant of back-to-back LC is the middleman. The middleman is the original beneficiary. Therefore, back-to-back LC depends very much on the standing of the middleman in order to secure the back-to-back LC.
43
ABC Sdn. Bhd., a middleman, sells keropok to Muthu Ltd in India. And Muthu Ltd. in India will apply LC to pay ABC Sdn. Bhd. in Malaysia, who is the original beneficiary of the LC. ABC Sdn. Bhd. gets supply from people in Terengganu. Then ABC Sdn. Bhd. apply a back-to-back credit to secure supply from Trengganu.
44
BACK-TO-BACK LC
Applicant 1st LC (importer) Issuing Bank Advising/ Confirming Bank 1st Beneficiary
(middleman)
Issuing Bank
45
TRANSFERABLE LC (TLC)
This type of credit is covered under Article 48 of the UCP No. 500, which states A transferable LC is a LC under which the beneficiary (first beneficiary - exporter) may request the authorized bank to pay in whole or in part to one or more other parties (i.e. second beneficiaries). Transferable LC can therefore be of assistance to seller with limited resources because payment is guaranteed.
46
TRANSFERABLE LC
The letter of credit can be transferred only once unless otherwise stated in the credit. Middleman will request buyer to issue a transferable credit. 1st beneficiary will request the credit to be transferred to the 2nd beneficiary in part or fully with a lower amount. 1st beneficiary will substitute/replace for documents presented by the 2nd beneficiary.
47
TRANSFERABLE LC
The transfer may be effected only if the letter of credit is designated as a transferable LC. Credit may be transferred within the ambit/scope of the original credit terms and conditions except it may be reduced or slashed the following:- the amount of the credit - any unit price stated therein - the expiry date - the last date for presentation of documents - the period for shipment - the percentage of insurance coverage May be issued under Al-Hiwalah principle.
48
TRANSFERABLE LC
Shipped goods
Contract Signed
Instruct changes
Issuing Bank
GREEN LC
This LC authorizes bank to make advance payment to the beneficiary against security of a standby credit. It is a pre-financing made against the presentation of invoice and delivery order in the name of a bank. Not a popular form of credit. Suggested concept to be applied for this credit is Al-Murabahah, known as Al Murabahah LC.
50
standard
51
52
PRESENTATION OF DOCUMENTS AND RESOLVING DISCREPANCIES Presentation of Documents - Beneficiary has a duty to ensure all documents drawn are in complete conformity with credit. This is evidenced in the case of Equitable Trust Co. of New York vs. Dawson Partners Ltd. -To ensure documents are consistent.
53
54
55
AMENDMENT OF CREDIT Duties of Applicant to give instruction for amendment must be written form duty to check copy of credit send to ensure conformity with sale contract to ensure amendment must be acceptable to issuing bank, otherwise may be refused by the bank 56
AMENDMENT OF CREDIT
Duties of Beneficiary to determine the acceptability of the amendment to advice non-acceptable of amendment immediately not to partially accept amendment as it not effective e.g. amendment in quantity and price from 100 units @ RM100 to 150 units @ RM90. Only accept the increase of quantity but reject the decrease in price.
57
1. 2.
3.
58
PROCEDURE FOR ESTABLISHING A LC cont 7. The place of shipment, destination and latest shipment date.
8. The terms of shipment, for example whether f.o.b or c.i.f. etc. 9. Detail of documents required in evidence of the transaction against which payment will be made.
60
61
62
63
64
7.
8.
It is drawn on a standard format (as prescribed by BNM); pink for purchase and certain sales green for certain sales only The maturity date of a BA should not fall on a Sunday or a public holiday. BA may be presented for payment on the next working day in KL. Discount the BA; MP = FV x 365 365 + (r + t) MP = market price or proceeds after discount FV = face value or maturity value of a BA R = rate of discount T = number of days remaining to maturity
65
LC - MURABAHAH
Cost plus deferred lump sum sale AlMurabahah contract allows the commodity exchange to be delivered immediately and the price is paid in lump sum at a later date. Essentials (tenets) Seller Buyer Commodity Price Offer and Acceptance (Ijab / qabul)
67
THE PRINCIPLES
THE SELLER MUST REVEAL THE COST OF THE MERCHANDIZE. THE SELLING PRICE MUST BE AGREED BY BOTH PARTIES. THE CONTRACT CAN BE REVOKED IF THERE IS ANY DISPUTE ON THE SELLING PRICE DULY QUOTED BY THE SELLER.
68
FEATURES OF LC - MURABAHAH
The customer informs the bank of his LC requirements and request the bank to purchase / import the goods. The customer indicates that he would be buying the goods from the bank on the negotiation of the credit under the concept of Al Murabahah. Bank appoints the applicant as its agent to purchase the goods. Bank establishes the credit and pays the proceeds to the negotiating bank utilizing its own fund. The bank then sells the goods to the customer at price comprising its COST and PROFIT MARGIN for settlement on a deferred term.
69
BENEFITS OF LC - MURABAHAH
Facilitate a convenience cash flow management of a business. To help in harmonizing credit sale and collection of debt and thus provide a reasonable aging of credit terms for business. As a prudent and reliable basis in the preparation for the projection of business. As a flexible financial instrument for the financing of working capital for a business. It can be securitized in the secondary market and thus convenience for liquidity management of the bank.
70
M.W.C.F. Purchase
1. Purchase order Supplier of goods Customer acting as an agent for the bank
2. Supply goods to k an customer b he ity t les tur tt Se ma 5. on 4. Bank sells goods on deferred payment basis BIMB
71
LC - MUSYARAKAH
DEFINITION : An arrangement of payment of a credit under an agreement of trustee joint venture profit sharing between the bank and the customer. ESSENTIALS: 1. SHARE HOLDING 2. CAPITAL 3. PROJECT 4. OFFER AND ACCEPTANCE
72
Features of LC - Musyarakah
Partners or shareholders are to negotiate on the terms of the AlMusyarakah financing. The customer places his capital sharing as deposit with the bank for his share of the cost of goods to be purchased / imported as per Al-Musyarakah Agreement. Bank as a party to the contract of Al-Musyarakah accepts the deposit under the principle of Al-Wadiah Yad Dhamanah. The bank establishes the LC and pays the proceeds to negotiating bank utilizing the customers deposit and its own shares of financing. The customer obtains the documents and take possession of the goods which will then be disposed. The bank and customer will then share the profit from the venture according to the terms in the agreement.
73
LC - MUDHARABAH
DEFINITION : It is a contract of trustee profit sharing between the capital provider and the entrepreneur. Another similar to this concept is Al-Qiradh, where under such contract the capital provider provides full capital (100%) for any project and to be managed by the entrepreneur without the interference of the capital provider. : 1. To overcome the wastage of expertise on the part of the entrepreneur. 2. To increase productivity. 3. To overcome a position of idle funds on the part of surplus unit. 4. To benefit the society as a whole.
Implication
74
Features of LC - Mudharabah
For the financing of permissible goods or projects. Capital must be in a specified monetary form determined at the point of offer and acceptance. The profit sharing ratio must be predetermined. No interference by the capital provider. In the event of loss, the capital provider/owner has to bear all the loss (purely business losses, not due to negligence). Al-Mudharabah contract can be revoked prior to the commencing and the utilization of fund for the project.
75
Characteristics of LC - Mudharabah
Capital is held under trust. Principle of guarantee is applied, if the lost incurred arises due to negligence of fraud. Both the capital owner and the entrepreneur are partners. Authority on the management of project is fully lies on the hand of the entrepreneur. In the case of Mudharabah Mutlaqah. Acts of entrepreneur is restricted to a particular project within a limited period.
76
77
LC WAKALAH (AGENCY)
IS AN ARRANGEMENT OF PAYMENT FOR A CREDIT UNDER AGENCY DEED ESSENTIALS: - Agent - Agent representative - Object of transaction - Offer and acceptance
78
FEATURES OF LC WAKALAH
THE APPLICANT WILL PLACE CASH FOR FULL AMOUNT TO CATER FOR PAYMENT OF THE IMPORTATION UNDER THE DOCUMENTARY CREDIT. THE CASH IS HELD AS MARGINAL DEPOSIT AGAINST THE LC BY THE ISSUING BANK UNDER THE CONCEPT OF AL-WADIAH YAD DHAMANAH THIS DEPOSIT IS THEN WILL BE LIQUIDATED FOR THE PAYMENT OF CLAIM UNDER THE DOCUMENTARY CREDIT
79
80