HACCP Application & Implementation Training
HACCP Application & Implementation Training
Implementation Training
Trainer: Muhamad Alexander Hamid Ho Bin Ridzuan
Date : 26.02.2024
1
WHAT IS HACCP?
A system which identifies, evaluates and controls hazards which are
Hazard significant for food safety (Codex
1999) 。
Analysi HACCP IS
s • Is a technique / process
• Is a systematic approach for the assurance of food safety.
Critical • Is internationally accepted as an effective system for production of safe
food.
• Can be applied throughout the food chain from primary production to
final consumption.
Control
FarmersManufacturer Service Industry
Point
2
RELEVANT STANDARD
✔ MALAYSIAN STANDARD : MS 1480 : 2019
FOOD SAFETY ACCORDING TO HAZARD
ANALYSIS AND CRITICAL CONTROL POINT
(HACCP) SYSTEM (SECOND REVISION)
✔ Codex Alimentarius:
HACCP System and Guidelines for its
application. (Annex to CAC/RCP 1-1969,
Rev 3 (1997)
3
ORIGIN & DEVELOPMENT OF HACCP
• Developed by Pillsbury Company in USA in 1959 for NASA
space programme.
• In the 1980’s – HACCP was used for food inspection
programmes
• By 1992 – system has been improved and its benefits
recognised worldwide.
4
WHY DO WE BENEFITS OF
NEED HACCP ? HACCP
• It provides many benefits ⮚ Instils awareness in food safety.
• Legislation recommends it ⮚Sets a preventive system for
• Many customer require it as food safety assurance
one of the conditions of ⮚Increase confidence in
product safety
doing business
⮚ Reduces losses and wastage.
• It is a insurance against ⮚ Internationally recognized.
foodborne incidents and ⮚Meet requirements set by
disease. relevant regulatory authority.
5
FOODBORNE INCIDENTS
Can be caused by : Can be caused by:
1) Biologicals Hazards 1) Supply of poor quality raw materials
e.g : microorganisms and their toxins 2) Mishandling of raw materials
3) Change of formulation of product
2) Chemical Hazards
4) Change in processing of product
e.g. cleaning agents, chemical residue
5) Cross contamination
3) Physical Hazards 6) Inadequate maintenance
e.g. foreign objects such s metal and glass 7) Addition of wrong ingredient.
THE VICTIMS
• Consumer safety
• Product quality
• Shelf life product
• Yield / recovery
• Recall
• Management time
• Credibility
• Reputation
• Market share
• Financially Stability
How do you prevent foodborne disease ?
►Quality raw materials
►Awareness of all staff
►Personal health ( communicable disease control)
►Proper temperature control
►Proper segregation of raw uncooked from ready-to-eat
food
►Proper handling
►Correct equipment cleaning and sanitation
►Waste control
►Pest control
7
HACCP PRINCIPLES
Principle 1 : Identify hazards and preventive
measures
Principle 2 : Identify Critical Control Points (CCP)
Principle 3 : Establish Critical Limit (CL)
Principle 4 : Establish CCP monitoring requirements
Principle 5 : Establish corrective actions
Principle 6 : Establish verification procedures
Principle 7 : Establish records 8
HACCP TERMS
10
HACCP TERMS
Critical Control Point (CCP) Critical Limit (CL)
• Point, operational step • Measurable value which
or stage in the process separates acceptability
at which control can be from unacceptability.
applied and is essential
to prevent a significant
food safety hazard or
reduce it to an
acceptable level.
11
HACCP TERMS
Verification Validation
• Application of • Obtaining evidence that
methods, procedures, an element of the
HACCP plan is effective.
tests and other
evaluations, in
addition to
monitoring, to
determine
compliance with the
HACCP plan. 12
FOOD SAFETY HAZARDS
• Pathogeni • Mushrooms ,
Physica
• Plastic, glass
Chemica
Biologic
l
toxins and • Pesticides
al
other
l
mycotoxins • Sanitizers personnel
) items
• Lubricants
• Additives, • Insects
• Colorings… • Button
• Feathers, hair
• Rodent’s 13
Physical Hazards and Controls
Sources of Physical Hazards Prevention & Control
14
Chemical Hazards and Controls
Control Point Example Action / Procedure
Prior to receipt of raw materials, Raw materials assessment on
food ingredients and packaging specification before confirm
materials receipt.
Upon receipt of these materials Certificate of analysis verify
During processing Formulation control, Production
control, Cleaning and sanitation
control
During storage Segregate from raw materials
storage. Proper label / ID.
During the use of sanitizers, Training the handling employee
cleaning agents, lubricants.
Prior to the shipment of finished goods. Verify chemicals content
15
Biological Hazards and Controls
Pathogens :-
Common Pathogenic Able to cause sickness / disease through:
Bacteria Carried by Food
Aeromonas hydrophila Intoxication ( TOXIN) Infection ( INVASION)
Bacillus cerues • Staphylococcus : infected food • Salmonella : chicken
handler • Shigella :
Campylobacter • Bacillus : cooked rice fecal
jejuni Clostridium • C. perfringens : meat produce, contaminatio
botulinum soil n
• E. coli : minced beef, chocolate • Campylobacter : chicken
Clostridium
perfringens Shorter incubation period : 1- Longer incubation period :
2 hours 6- 72 hours
Escherichia coli
Where do pathogen come
Listeria •from
Low??quality raw materials
monocytogenes • Poor personal hygiene
Salmonella species • Inadequate cooking
• Improper storage / holding temperature
Shigella
• Improper reheating
dysenteriae • Cross –contamination – improper
Staphylococcus segregation
1
aurues Vibro • Past use-by-time 6
FACTORS AFFECTING MICROBIAL GROWTH
• FOOD / NUTRIENTS
• ACIDITY
• TEMPERATURE
• TIME
• OXYGEN
• MOISTURE
• PRESERVATIVES
17
1. TEMPERATURE
• Grow ideally at body temperature (37.5’C). • Hot temperature (above 70’C) will kill
• Also grow at temperature higher or lower most bacteria.
than this temperature.
• Fridge temperature will slow bacteria Bacillus
growth Escherichia coli,
sterothermophilus
Archea e.g.
Salmonella Pyrolobus
Pseudomonas
fluorescens
18
2. TIME
• At an ideal temperature, bacteria will double in number every 20
minutes.
Under ideal condition
O’clock Bacteria
12.00 1
12.20 2
12.40 4
1.00 8
2.00 64
3.00 512
4.00 4096
5.00 32768
6.00 262144
7.00 2098152
19
3. MOISTURE
• Bacteria must receive their food in some kind of water solution.
• This solution is described as water activity (A w), which is the
amount of water available for growth of bacteria.
Aw = 𝑣𝑎𝑝𝑜𝑟 𝑝𝑟𝑒𝑠𝑠𝑢𝑟𝑒 𝑜𝑓 𝑓𝑜𝑜𝑑 Food Water Activity
𝑣𝑎𝑝𝑜𝑟 𝑝𝑟𝑒𝑠𝑠𝑢𝑟𝑒 𝑜𝑓 𝑤𝑎𝑡𝑒𝑟 Water 1.00
• Aw of water = 1.00 Fresh fruit 0.91 – 1.00
Bread 0.90 – 0.99
Water Activity Limit for
Microbiological Cheese 0.95 – 1.00
Growth Fresh meat 0.95 – 1.00
Group Minimal Aw Value Jam 0.75 – 0.80
Most bacteria 0.91 Honey 0.54 – 0.75
Most yeast 0.88 Chocolate candy 0.55 – 0.80
Moulds 0.82 Milk powder 0.20
Biscuit 0.10 20
4. ACIDITY
• Acidity or alkalinity of food is measured by pH.
• Acidic foods – vinegar, pickles, fruits and vegetables.
• Neutral food : pure distilled water.
• Most microorganism like to grow in near neutral
condition. Microorganisms & pH
Microorganisms pH
Salmonella 6.0 – 7.5
Staphylococcus aurues 6.8 – 7.5
E.Coli 6.0 – 8.0
Most bacteria 5.5 – 8.0
Yeast ( spoilage organisms) 4.0 – 6.5
Moulds ( spoilage organisms) 4.5 – 6.8
21
5.
OXYGEN
Aerobic Bacteria Anaerobic bacteria
Need oxygen Does not need oxygen
Gram – negative roods, Gram- positive rods
cocci Gram – positive rods,
cocci
Most pathogenic bacteira Clostridium botulinum
6. PRESERVATIVES
Natural preservatives Chemical preservatives
Salt and sugar Sodium nitrite, benzoic acid
Function: Water –binding capacity Function: Inhibit microbial (bacteria,
yeast and mould) to grow.
22
HOWTO IMPLEMENT A
HACCP PLAN ?
1. Based on the application of 7 key
principles
2. Key elements :
• common sense;
• knowledge of product and process ;
• understanding of HACCP
23
HACCP PLAN
HACCP Plan shall mean a document prepared in
accordance with the principles of HACCP to ensure
control of hazards which are significant for food safety in
the segment of the food chain under consideration
24
Logic Sequence for Application of HACCP System
Get
Construct
Management Set
Commitment,
Assemble HACCP Identify Flow
Diagram On site
Food Safety Describe
Team Intended Confirmation
Policy and Scope Product
Use of Flow
of Objective
Diagram
P6:
P7: Review HACCP
Determine
Documentation & Plan
verification
records keeping
procedures
25
Prerequisites of HACCP System
Establishment
1) Management 2) Product
Responsibility Description
3) Intended use(s)
of product and 4) Process
potential flow
consumers’ abuse diagram
26
1) Management
Responsibility
Management
Define and document Food Safety Policy
and Food Safety Objectives
Appoint HACCP coordinator / team leader
Hazard Evaluation
• Determines which potential hazards must be addressed in HACCP plan.
• Based on the severity and likely occurrence of each hazards
• Severity - the seriousness' of the consequences of exposure to
the hazards
• Risk : The likely occurrence of the hazard based on experience,
technical literature, epidemiological data, etc. 36
Hazard Matrix Table (ECO-QA-
AP21) Likelihood Hazard Column
Severity Decision
Matrix Value Color
A B C D E
Essential control
1 1 2 4 7 11 1~6 Pink measure
Is a CCP
2 3 5 8 12 16
Advised control
3 6 9 13 17 20 7 ~ 10 Yellow
measure Is a OPRP
4 10 14 18 21 23
11 ~ 25 Green Practice GMP / PRP
5 15 19 22 24 25
38
Principle 2 : Determination of CCPs
Critical Control Point :
A step at which control can be applied and is essential to
prevent, eliminate or reduce to an acceptable level a food
safety hazard.
↓
Yes No
Are you or the consumer going to
Q2
process this hazard out of Sensitive raw
Go to Q3
product? material control is a
CCP
↓
Yes No
Is there a cross-contamination risk
Q3 to the facilities or to other products Sensitive raw material
which will not be controlled? Not CCP
control is a CCP
40
PROCESS STEP CCP DECISION TREE
Yes No
Are there preventive measure(s) for the
Q1 Q1.1 Is control necessary Modify step, process
identified hazard? Go to Q2
at this step for safety? or product
↓ ↓
↓ No Yes
↓ Not a CCP ® Proceed*
No Yes
Is the step specifically designed to eliminate or
Q2 CCP
reduce Go to Q3
the likely occurrence of a hazard to an acceptance Need Control
level?
↓
Would contamination occur at unacceptable level(s) Yes No
Q3
or increase to unacceptable level? Go to Q4 Not a CCP ® Proceed*
↓
Yes No
Will a subsequent process step eliminate or reduce
Q4 CCP 41
the hazard to an acceptable level? Not a CCP ® Stop
Principle 3: Determination of Critical Limit
Critical Limit
• Is the tolerance range within the limit.
• If the critical limits are exceeded, the CCP is out of
control – potential hazard.
• Each CCP must have a CL in order to determinate the CCP
is
IN or OUT of control.
• A CCP may have one or more CL.
• A CL is used to distinguish between safe and unsafe
operations at critical CCP – it defines the “Boundaries of 42
Rule of thumb for Determination
Measurement
of Critical Limits for Each CCP : Particle size
Measurement
(P3) : Chemical
concentratio
n
Chemical Hazards:
Non-intended
Physical
chemical Hazards
CL Shall be: adulteration
:
✔ Specified for each
, intentionally
added chemicals
but added beyond
Foreign
acceptable limit, matter
CCP Food allergen
✔ Measurable Biological
Hazards:
✔ Scientifically Food
validated pathogens Measurement:
and virus Bacterial count
43
Establishing Operational Limit (OL)
OL:
• Criteria that are MORE STRINGENT than critical limit
(CL) and that are used by an operator to reduce the risk of a
deviation.
• When OL deviates, it only needs process adjustment (an
action taken by the firm to bring the process back within
operational limits.
44
Principle 4:
Establish CCP Monitoring Program
Monitoring is defined as:
• Conducting a planned sequence of observations or measurements to
assess whether or not a CCP is under control and production an accurate
thereof for future use in The 5 keys of
record monitoring:
verification.
Monitoring procedure shall comprise the ❖ WHAT?
❖HOW?
following:- ❖WHERE?
a) What is being monitored ❖WHEN?
❖WHO?
b) Monitoring method
c) Monitoring frequency; and
d) Personnel responsible for monitoring and evaluating the monitoring
result. 45
Principle 4:
Establish CCP Monitoring Program
Monitoring records:
- Data entered must be accurate and timely
- Free of error or omissions
- Free of whiteouts, erasures, blackouts, etc.
47
Principle 5: Establish Corrective Actions
Deviation :
- A failure to comply with a stated critical limit / operation
limit.
- Corrective actions must be developed for each CCP to
remedy an associated deviation and assure product safety.
- Corrective action “FIX” the deviation and assure
compliance with the HACCP plan is maintained.
- Purpose of corrective action:
❖Ensure CCP is brought back into control
❖Ensure products manufactured during CCP deviation
are handled according to procedure for NC products. 48
The HACCP plan shall describe the corrective actions to be taken
and assign the responsibility for taking each one.
❑Employees should be trained on the proper corrective actions to take
in response to deviations of the CCPs for which they are
responsible.
❑The first action that should be taken is to get control of / address
the affected product ( i.e place it on HOLD)
❑All corrective action must be thoroughly and accurately, recorded.
Management Calibration
Review
(MR)
52
Internal Audit
• Have planned intervals (Yearly)
• Internal auditors are qualified personnel
• Establish an audit programme / procedure
• The audits is to determine the HACCP system conforms to
the planned arrangement and it is effectively implemented
and updated.
• BRD / P21 Internal Audit
53
Management Review Present in manner that
enables top management
(MR)
Not more than 12 months to relate the information
MR shall include at least to stated objectives of
:- food safety management
system
• Follow up actions from previous
MR
• Analysis of result of verification activities including
internal audits, external audits and inspections
• Changing circumstances that can affect food safety
• Emergency situations, accidents and recall
• Reviewing result of system-updating activities
• Review of communication activities, including customer
54
feedback and complaints
Management Review (MR)
The outcome fro MR shall include decisions and actions related
to:-
✔ Assurance of food safety
✔ Effectiveness of the HACCP system
✔ Resource needs ; and
✔ Revisions of the organisation’s food safety policy and
related objectives.
Maintain MR records.
55
Principle 7 :
Documentation & Record
Records are kept for Active HACCP records include:
several Keeping
reasons:- ❖ Reason why CCPs were selected
❖ Reason why the critical limits have
• Evidence of product safety been selected.
• Regulatory compliance ❖ CCP monitoring records
• Tracing product ( traceability) ❖ CCP verification records
❖ Calibration records
• Review of procedures / ❖ Corrective action records
processes ❖ Overall HACCP plan
❖ Other records (example sample result)
57
HACCP Document Control
• Maintain a list of controlled copies of the HACCP plan
• Any proposed amendments to the HACCP plan must go through
a planned sequence for approval (SOP)
• A system of auditing needs to be in place to ensure that all copies of
the HACCP plan are updated when any amendments are made.
• Amended pages of the HACCP plan must be indicated in some
manner.
• Establish a filling system for the HACCP plan associated records
and supporting materials
✔ Accessible to plant and External Auditor personnel
✔ Provide adequate security
58
Hazard Analysis Worksheet for RM
59
Hazard Analysis Worksheet for RM
60
Hazard Analysis Worksheet for PM
61
Hazard Analysis Worksheet for PM
62
Hazard Analysis Worksheet for process
step
63
Hazard Analysis Worksheet for process
step
64
HACCP Plan
Summary
65
7 HACCP Principles can be summarized
in HACCP Plan Summary
BRD/ HM09
P2
P1
P3 P5 P6 P7
P4
66
PROBLEMS FACED IN
IMPLEMNETING HACCP SYSTEM
• Lack of knowledge and understanding about
HACCP.
• Lack of skilled personnel to look after the
system.
• Lack of confidence in HACCP.
• Lack of resource.
• Lack of facilities.
• Lack of funds.
• Lack of inter and intra sectoral coordination.
67
Operation of HACCP System
N Operation of HACCP Remark Documented Procedure
o
1. Records relating to Records shall be maintained BRD P01 Control of
the HACCP system Documents &
BRD P02 Control of Records
2. Control of non- • NC product shall be labelled BRD P16 Control of Nonconforming
conforming • It may be reworked, segregated Product
product or disposed
3. Traceability • Enables to identification of product BRD P20 Product Withdrawal
lots and their relation to batches of & Recall
RM, processing and delivery records
• Able to identify in-coming material
from the immediate suppliers and the
initial distribution route of FG.
• Traceability records shall be maintained
• Important to ensure an effective
and efficient recall system
68
Operation of HACCP System
N Operation of HACCP Remark Documented Procedure
o
4. Notification and recall • Shall be given the degree of detail BRD P19 Handling of Customer
regarding traceability in production Complaint
and post-delivery
• Ensure rapid identification and
removal of products from the market
in a timely manner.
• Recall shall be evaluated to ensure
effectiveness.
5. Control of measuring • Shall assess the validity of the BRD P07 Preventive Maintenance &
equipment and previous measurement result when the Calibration
methods equipment process environment is
found not to conform to requirement.
• Take action on the process
environment and any affected
product.
65
• Validate the software system is used in
monitoring and measuring.
Maintaining the HACCP System
• Maintain effective HACCP system through regularly
scheduled verification activities.
72
HACCP SYSTEM EVALAUTION
Potential hazards can be identified through:
▪ HACCP records, including flow diagram, deviations from
CLs and instrument calibration records.
▪ Product history including recall and market withdrawal information.
▪ Consumer / customer complaint trends
▪ Scientific literature articles
▪ Regulatory agency alerts
▪ Test result from sample monitoring
Type of Auditing
1. Compliance
Audit Getting ready for auditing:-
• GMP requirement are met
a. Adequacy
audit • Sanitation procedures in-place
b. On-site audit • HACCP Manual
c. Follow-up must be established
audit • HACCP system must
2. Surveillance be implemented
Audit • Internal verification is done
75
Accreditation of Big Red
Dot
❖HACCP certification under surveillance of
Kiwacert
❖Validity: 3 years
❖Surveillance audit: at least once a year by
Kiwacert
76
IMPORTANT
HACCP PLAN MUSTBE ON-GOING :
• In-place
• Up-dated
• Review on continuing suitability,
validation and effectiveness. 5 Important P’s
Premise
People
Process
Procedure(s
)
Product(s) 77
BRD CCPs
1. CCP 01a (Baking using OVN01 & OVN05)
2. CCP 01b (Baking using OVN03 & OVN04)
3. CCP 02 (Cooking)
4. CCP 03 (Metal Detecting)
5. CCP 04 (Packaging Sealing)
CCP 01a (Baking using OVN01 &
OVN05)
CCP 01a (Baking using OVN01 & OVN05)
– OL (Cakes and Cookies Baking Record)
CCP 01a (Baking using OVN01 & OVN05)
– OL (Mooncakes Baking Record)
CCP 01a (Baking using OVN01 & OVN05)
– CL (Baking Monitoring Record)
CCP 01b (Baking using OVN03 &
OVN04)
CCP 01b (Baking using OVN03 & OVN04)
– OL (Cakes & Cookies Baking Record)
CCP 01b (Baking using OVN03 & OVN04)
– CL (Baking Monitoring Record)
CCP 02 (Cooking)
CCP 02 (Cooking) – OL (Paste
Preparation and Cooking Record)
CCP 02 (Cooking) – CL (Paste
Preparation and Cooking Record)
CCP 03 (Metal Detecting)
CCP 03 (Metal Detecting) – CL (Packing QC
Inspection & Metal Detector Verification Record)
CCP 04 (Packaging Sealing)
CCP 04 (Packaging Sealing) – CL