RFS - Unit 4 2024
RFS - Unit 4 2024
Market Risk,
Investment Risk &
Liquidity Risk
Contents
2
Contents
▪ Identification of Liquidity Risk: constituents of liquidity risk and how they can arise
within the contexts of credit, market, investment and operational risk. Measurement of
Liquidity Risk: funding liquidity risk analysis: liquidity gap analysis, stress testing,
expected future funding requirement. 3
Market
Risk
4
“ Market Risk is defined
as
“ the risk of loss arising
from changes in the
value of finanical
instrustments”
5
Introduction
❖ One of the major aims of many financial instruments is the generation of profits
through investment in global financial markets.
❖ Price uncertainty is the mechanism that allows profits or losses to be made and the risk
of loss associated with it is known as market risk.
❖ The factors affecting market risk are complex. For instance, when investing in a
company’s shares there are direct and indirect market risk factors to consider.
6
Direct and Indirect market risk
factors
7
Financial service
sector & Market risk?
8
Financial service sector & Market risk?
2 4 6
1
3
Currency Risk
▪ If the two positions were truly ‘equal and opposite’ then there
would be no risk in the combined position.
▪ Basis risk exists to the extent that the two positions do not exactly
mirror each other.
1
5
Interest Rate Risk
1
6
Commodity Price Risk
1
7
Commodity Price Risk
1
9
Boundary Issues
Boundary issues can arise between different types of market risk due to
the complexities and interconnections within financial markets.
Market risk refers to the potential for financial losses resulting from
adverse market movements.
Different types of market risk include:
▫ Interest Rate Risk
▫ Equity Price Risk/ Stock price risk
▫ Currency Exchange Rate Risk
▫ Commodity Price Risk
▫ Liquidity Risk
▫ Credit Risk/ default risk
▫ Systemic Risk
2
1
Boundary Issues
▪ For example:
▫ liquidity risk could be caused by a lack of supply or demand –
which also causes price level risk
▫ an increase in volatility risk will intensify price level risk for
investors wishing to buy or sell
▫ interest rate risk will indirectly affect the real economy and
therefore the markets.
Correlations
Risk Aggregation
Model Assumptions
Regulatory challenges
Portfolio management 2
3
Correlations: Market risks are often interconnected. For instance, a change in interest
rates can impact both equity and bond prices. These interdependencies can make it
challenging to isolate the effects of one specific type of risk.
Risk Aggregation: Financial institutions and investors need to aggregate their various
risks to assess their overall risk exposure accurately. However, different types of market
risk may have nonlinear effects when combined, making accurate risk assessment
complex.
Model Assumptions: Different types of market risks require different models for
measurement and analysis. Assumptions made in these models can influence the way
risks are quantified and managed, leading to potential discrepancies when risks
2
intersect. 4
Regulatory Challenges: Regulatory frameworks may classify and regulate different
types of risks separately. However, in reality, these risks can interact and amplify each
other's impact, which can pose challenges for regulatory authorities.
Scenario: In recent years, XYZ Corporation has expanded its operations globally, and it
is now exposed to various forms of market risk, including currency risk, interest rate risk,
and equity market risk. The management team is aware of the importance of effective risk
management to protect the company's financial stability and shareholder value. They have
appointed a dedicated risk management team to assess and mitigate market risk. 2
6
Questions
1.What is market risk, and why is it important for XYZ Corporation to manage it
effectively?
2. Identify and describe the specific types of market risk that XYZ Corporation is
exposed to.
3.What strategies can XYZ Corporation use to manage its currency risk effectively?
4.How can XYZ Corporation mitigate interest rate risk in its financial operations?
5. What steps can XYZ Corporation take to manage equity market risk in its
investment portfolio?
6.How can XYZ Corporation’s risk management team regularly monitor and assess
market risk exposure? 2
7
Market Risk Management
Techniques and their Application
High
Market risk
Hedging Diversification Frequency
limits
Trading
2
9
Hedging
3
0
Market Risk Limits / Stop Loss limit
3
1
3
2
Diversification
Ex
The sun cream factory does well when the summers are hot, while the
umbrella business does well on rainy days. Although the earnings of each
individual business can be volatile,
3
3
High Frequency Trading
○A type of algorithmic financial trading characterized by
○high speeds,
○high turnover rates, and
○high order-to-trade ratios
○that leverages high-frequency financial data and electronic trading
tools.
(1) narrower bid–ask spreads;
(2) increased market liquidity in normal times;
(3) improved price discovery; and
(4) significant volume on transparent, traditional exchanges.
3
4
Market Risk Management - Features
▪ ownership of the firm’s market risk management policy
▪ proactive management involvement in market risk issues
▪ defined escalation procedures to deal with rising levels of trading loss, and market risk
limit breaches
▪ independent validation of market pricing and adequacy of VaR models
▪ ensuring that VaR is not used alone, but is combined with stress testing and scenario
analysis
▪ independent daily monitoring of risk utilisation through the daily production of profit
and loss (P&L)
▪ accounts and review of front-office closing prices (independent means a separately
accountable function reporting directly to senior management).e market risk in a
company-wide context. 3
5
Concepts used in risk
measurement and control
Measures of Central Tendancy
Measures of Dispersion
3
7
3
8
Variance and Standard Deviation
Let us assume we have the following annual returns for an investment: 13%,
11%, 2%, 6%, 5%, 8%, 7%, 9%, 7%, and 6%.
4
1
Understanding the Terminology
4
2
Risk Measurement and Control
Concepts
4
3
4
4
Value-at-Risk (VaR)
Approach
▪ Value-at-Risk (VaR) is a widely used measure the maximum loss that can
occur with a specified confidence over a specified period.
▪ Because there is uncertainty about how much could be lost over the
specified time horizon, the VaR measure includes the level of confidence
that the specified loss will not be exceeded.
▪ It will then monitor them to ensure that traders or fund managers do not
exceed them.
▪ Where they are exceeded, escalation will take place to the head of trading,
the relevant desk head or a risk committee
4
7
Advantages of using VaR
▪ it provides a statistical probability of potential loss
▪ it can be readily understood by non-risk managers
▪ it translates all risks in a portfolio into a common standard, allowing a
comparison of risks between asset classes and, hence, the
quantification of firm-wide, cross-product exposures.
▪ Back testing is the practice of comparing the actual daily trading exposure to the
previously predicted VaR figure.
▪ It is a test of reliability of the VaR methodology and ensures that the approach is of
sufficient quality.
5
1
The steps are as follows:
1. Identify the risk factors that affect the returns of the portfolio, such as:
• individual stock prices, individual stock volatilities, the correlations between the
stocks (described above).
2. Select a sample of actual historic risk factor changes over a given period of time – say,
the last 500 trading days.
3. Systematically apply each of those daily changes to the current value of each risk
factor, revaluing the current portfolio as many times as the number of days in the
historical sample.
4. List out all the resulting portfolio values, ordered by value and, assuming the required
VaR is at the 95% confidence level, identify the value that represents the fifth percentile
of the distribution in the left-hand tail.
5
2
Advantages and Disadvantages
▪ The main disadvantage is that it assumes that history will repeat itself, which is clearly
often not the case.
5
3
Parametric (‘Analytical’) Approach
This approach assumes that portfolio returns are normally distributed, and uses the
standard deviation (volatility) of the returns to ‘plot the graph’ and hence derive the VaR
figure at the required confidence level.
5
5
Monte Carlo Simulation
5
6
Scenario and Stress Testing
▪ Scenario analysis and stress testing should, be conducted on an institution-wide basis,
taking into account the effects of unusual changes in market and non-market risk
factors. Such factors include prices, volatilities, market liquidity, historical correlations
and assumptions in stressed market conditions, and the institution’s vulnerability to
worst-case scenarios such as the default of a large counterparty.
▪ Scenario analysis and stress testing would enable the board and senior management to
better assess the potential impact of various market-related changes on the institution’s
earnings and capital position. The board and senior management should regularly
review the results of scenario analyses and stress testing, including the major
assumptions that underpin them. The results should be considered during the
establishment and review of policies and limits.
5
7
Investment
Risk
▪ The credit and market risks are managed for the benefit of the firm’s owners
and clients.
▪ Many of these clients are investors whose funds are managed by the firm,
and providing the ‘right’ level of return to these investors as ‘investment
risk’.
▪ Investment is the decision to forgo the use of current resources, in the belief
that they can instead be used to create future benefits which are greater than
their current value.
5
9
Measurement of Investment
Returns
Basic Concepts and the Measurement of Investment Returns
Basic concepts and measurement of investment
related returns
Nominal returns
Real returns
Total returns
6
4
Real Returns
The real return is the return the investment provides an investor after stripping out the
effects of inflation.
If inflation is running at say 8%, then in real terms the value of the cash in a 12% bank
account is actually growing by just 4% a year.
If the nominal rate of return is 12% pa and the annual rate of inflation is 8% pa, the real rate
of return is the return earned after allowing for the return needed just to keep pace with
inflation.
6
5
Total Returns
▪ Total returns mean the returns on an investment both from its income
production, and any capital gains (or losses) it generates.
Issuer risk
Equity risk
Commodity risk
Property risk
Liquidity risk
6
8
Key Features and Relevance of
Other Asset Classes to Investment
Risk
1. Private Equity
2. Venture Capital
3. Property
4. Responsible investment
a) Environmental concerns
b) Social concerns
c) Corporate governance concerns
7
8
Private Equity
▪ Private equity fund managers often take an active role in the management of
the companies they invest in, through having a majority shareholding and/or a
seat on the board.
▪ They look to add value for their investors by transforming the way the
investee company is managed, and may aim to make their money by floating
the company on the market after a few years, once its performance has been
improved. 7
9
Venture Capital
8
0
Venture Capital
▪ Venture capital investments offer three main advantages for a portfolio of
otherwise ‘standard’ investments:
8
2
Responsible investment
▫ Environmental concerns
▫ Social concerns
▫ Corporate governance concerns
8
3
Correlation of Performance
between Asset Classes
Asset Allocation
▪ Asset correlations change over time, and the discipline of ‘asset allocation’
is the macro equivalent of diversifying a portfolio to reduce its risk.
▪ Before deciding which stocks to pick, a decision must first have been made
on which asset-mix to choose.
▪ Asset allocation involves considering the big picture first by assessing the
prospects for each of the main asset classes within each of the world’s
major investment regions against the backdrop of the world economic,
political and social environment.
8
5
Tracking Error
8
6
Methods used to Mitigate
Investment Portfolio Risk
1. Systematic and Non-Systematic Risk
2. Optimisation and Diversification
3. Portfolio Hedging
4. Short Selling
5. Risk Transfer
8
8
Monitoring, Management
& Reporting
There are four main areas where a portfolio will benefit from monitoring, management and
reporting:
1. Peer review with other fund managers in the same firm – this will help to ensure that, for
example, managers are abiding by ‘house view’ rules and not taking ‘unusual’ risks.
2. Risk review with independent risk managers in the firm – this ensures that the investment
process is transparent and duly challenged.
3. Monitoring for mandate compliance – systems are commonly used to perform pre- and post
trade compliance checking, for example, ensuring that forbidden stocks are not invested in.
4. Performance attribution reporting – this enables the fund manager, and the investors, to
better understand which elements within the portfolio are contributing to its returns. Typically,
the contribution to overall performance could come from:
• asset allocation
• stock selection
• currency exchange rate impact.
9
0
LIQUIDITY
RISK
Identification of Liquidity Risk
9
2
1. Maturity ladder
9
3
9
4
9
5
2. Actual and Contractual Cash
Receipts
▪ It is not possible to estimate with certainty the cash flows from all instruments.
▪ However, some types of financial instruments, such as derivatives, have a very
broad range of possible contractual outcomes.
▪ In these cases, statistical modelling techniques are used to provide ranges of cash
flow likelihoods.
▪ Even when cash flows can be properly estimated, the existence of credit risk
means that the cash may not materialise on the due date – or at all.
▪ The business may not wish to hold the instrument until maturity.
▪ Even without credit issues occurring, the way that the business uses financial
instruments will often result in the actual cash flows being significantly different
from the contractually stated position.
9
6
3. Asset Liquidity Risk
▪ The term ‘funding liquidity’ usually refers to the way in which a firm
obtains liquidity from the liability side of its balance sheet.
▪ So the term ‘funding liquidity risk’ refers to the likelihood that the
bank’s funding will not be available when required.
9
8
Measurement of Liquidity Risk
Measurement of Liquidity Risk
Measurement of Liquidity Risk
1
0
0
Liquidity Gap Analysis
▪ Modern banks rely on a number of sources for their funding. For example,
retail depositors, larger wholesale depositors and the money markets.
▪ Negative net future cash flows over a given time period represent a major
source of liquidity risk.
▪ Before a liquidity gap analysis can be performed, a technique called cash
matching is used to understand a firm’s or portfolio’s liquidity risk, by 10
examining all net future cash flows. 0
▪ A firm or portfolio is cash matched if:
• every future cash inflow is balanced with an offsetting cash outflow
on the same date, and
• every future cash outflow is balanced with an offsetting cash inflow
on the same date.
1
0
2
Measurement of Liquidity Risk
1
0
3
Uses and Limitations of the Key Measures of
Asset Liquidity Risk
1
0
4
Managing Liquidity Risk
▪ Liquidity Limits
▪ Counterparty Credit Limits
▪ Scenario Analysis
▪ Liquidity at Risk
▪ Diversification
▪ Behavioural Analysis
▪ Funding Methods
1
0
5
Market Dislocation
▪ central banks lose the use of interest rates as their main economic
lever. Interest rates can only go as low as zero and once this point is 1
reached, the economy risks entering into deflation. 0
7