H.D.F. Kitto (1897-1982),
The Greeks, rev. ed. (1957; rpt. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books, 1967), pp. 36-37 (footnote omitted):
In Greece one can lead an active life on much
less food than harsher climates make necessary; but there is
also the fact that the Greek — the Greek man — could and did
spend most of his leisure hours out of doors. That in itself
meant that he had more leisure; he did not need to work in
order to buy settees and coal. — After all, the reason why we
English have invented 'le confort anglais' is that we cannot be
comfortable and warm except indoors. The leisure which the
Athenian enjoyed is popularly attributed to the existence of
slavery. Slavery had something to do with it, but not so much
as the fact that three-quarters of the things which we slave for
the Greek simply did without.
So, spending out of doors the leisure which he earned largely
by doing without things which we find or think necessary, the
Greek, whether in town or village, was able to sharpen his wits
and improve his manners through constant intercourse with
his fellows. Few people have been so completely sociable.
Talk was the breath of life to the Greek — as indeed it still is,
though somewhat spoiled by a serious addiction to newspapers. What society but Athens could have produced a figure
like Socrates — a man who changed the current of human
thought without writing a word, without preaching a doctrine,
simply by talking in the streets of a city which he never left but
twice — for the battlefield? In what other society is one so little
conscious of a chasm between the educated and the uneducated,
between those with taste and the vulgar? The real education of
the Athenian, and of many another Greek, was given in the
places of assembly — in the hours of talk in market-place, colonnade or gymnasium, in the political assembly, in the theatre,
at the public recitals of Homer, and at the religious processions
and celebrations. For it was perhaps the greatest boon conferred upon Attica by her chmate that her big assemblies could
be held in the open air. However democratic the instincts of
the Athenian might be, Athenian democracy could not have
developed as it did — nor for that matter Athenian Drama — if
a roof and walls had been necessary. In our conditions of
shelter, privacy and admission-fees, the life of the well-to-do
must be potentially richer than the life of the poor, and only
six hundred can have direct access to the business of the
nation. In Athens all these things could be open to all because
they could be open to the air and the sun. To explain Athenian
culture simply as the product of the Athenian climate would
be foohsh, though not unfashionable; nevertheless it is demonstrable that in a different climate it could not have developed
as it did.
# posted by Michael Gilleland @ 4:39 AM