Talk:Wikimedia Apps
Add topic
Archives
|
|---|
Edit quality in Android application
[edit]Several contributors, including myself and User:Jules*, don't understand the point of the ‘edit quality’ mention in the Android application.
The mw:Wikimedia Apps/Android FAQ states that edit quality is ‘based on how many of your edits were reverted’. Is this the only criterion used? If so, calling it ‘edit quality’ is presumptuous, not to say irresponsible, given that there should be so many criteria. What are the different levels of judgement: excellent, good, bad, horrible, etc. ? What does this mean for developers, bots, patrollers and administrators? Whatever the case, the consequences of such a statement could be quite serious.
It's clear that the choice to keep this mention in the application doesn't just concern the application developers or even a small team, but all Wikipedia contributors, whatever their language. So we think it's important that you answer our questions. (As my English isn't very good, could you answer me in basic English, or at least without figures of speech? Thank you in advance.) Abalg (talk) 13:37, 7 January 2025 (UTC)