SWOT Analysis
SWOT Analysis
SWOT
Analysis
Strengths
Well-established
and
growing
brand
recognition
Product
and
brand
consistency
Eco-friendly
practices,
for
Starbucks
is
concerned
with
conserving
energy,
water,
controlling
climate
change
and
recycling
Participates
in
community
service
(both
employees
and
customers)
Active
participant
of
Create
Jobs
for
USA,
STARBUCKS
(RED),
Starbucks
Foundation
and
Ethos
Water
Fund
Wide
variety
of
product
offerings
Offers
free
Wi-Fi
in
stores
and
a
comfortable
space
for
its
customers
Staff
(employee
benefits,
staff
represents
the
brand)
Innovative/Progressive
Strong
brand
image
associated
with
quality
coffee
and
excellent
customer
service
(The
Starbucks
Experience)
Ethical
values/Ethical
mission
statement
Rewards
and
recognition
Possesses
a
potential
for
new
and
innovative
store
operations
Has
retained
a
level
of
sound
financial
performance/profitable
An
international
brand
wit
more
than
5,500
stores
in
over
50
countries1
Weaknesses
Needs
more
of
a
wide
spread
customer
base
Prices
continually
rising,
thus
risking
the
loss
of
customers
Increasing
number
of
competitors
Size
of
stores:
stores
can
become
crowded
at
times
Political/religious
support
(may
not
reflect
with
those
of
its
customers)
Limited
products
at
different
locations
Organization
has
strong
presence
in
the
U.S.
with
more
than
of
their
cafes
located
in
the
home
market/lack
of
international
presence
Reputation
with
pressure
groups;
criticized
for
not
using
free
trade
products
Prices
high
as
opposed
to
rivals
such
as
Dunkin
Donuts
and
McDonalds
Product
recalls,
which
occur
rather
frequently
Rapid
decline
of
satisfactory
customer
service,
as
observed
from
comments
on
MyStarbucksIdea.com
Leaders
are
too
cross
functional
in
their
management
Not
available
to
all
target
segments
due
to
higher
prices
Not
enough
Drive-Thru
services
Starbucks
locations
are
scarce
in
suburban
areas
1
Starbucks.com.
Starbucks
corporation.
2011.
Feb
10,
2012
<http://www.starbucks.com/>.
1
Not enough bilingual employees Lack of coupons, deals and promotions2 Opportunities More products can emerge while adapting to other markets Creating a coffee house experience in global target markets Can focus on emerging economies Opportunity of third house experience Opportunity for strategic growth initiatives Holds the ability to be influenced by the opinions, thought and concerns its customers have on MyStarbucksIdea.com Can increase its knowledge in new technological advances to use in stores (espresso makers/to-go cups) With continued domestic expansion, it can reach domination of its segment More promotions/coupons/discounts3 Threats Relies on international trade for its coffee beans (Arabia, South America, etc.) Must comply with international governments for production and distribution Very competitive environment with leaders in the restaurant/food business Cultural values and routines may interfere/not adapt with the coffee house experience Has become a luxury brand; thus, it is a brand that can be consumed by every consumer on a daily basis Issues of negative publicity against the brand due to fair trade conflict with coffee bean farmers in Africa A younger domestic market is being alienated from the Starbucks brand due to cost Recession or downturn in the economy affects consumer spending Several activist groups maintain websites criticizing the companys fair trade policies, labor relations and environmental impact.4
2
"MBA Tutorials Starbucks SWOT Analysis." MBA Tutorials MBA Tutorials Accounting,
Economics,Finance, Management, Marketing,Strategic Management,human Resource Management,branding. MBA Tutorials. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://www.mbatutorials.com/marketing/swot-analysis-marketing/310-starbucks-swot-analysis.html>.
3
"Starbucks S.W.O.T." Business & Company Resource Center. Business & Company Resource Center. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://galenet.galegroup.com.emils.lib.colum.edu/servlet/BCRC?vrsn=unknown>.
4
"Starbucks Swot Analysis." Scribd. Scribd. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://www.scribd.com/doc/3972739/Starbucks-Swot-Analysis>.
Smoothies (Chocolate, Orange Mango, Strawberry) Baked Goods (Muffins, Doughnuts, Scones, Fritters, Loafs, Croissants, Cheese Danish, Cookies, Bars, Bagels, Brownies, Gingerbread, Pound Cake, Bread, Coffee Cake, Buns) Petites Dessert (Cake Pop, Whoopie Pie, Sweet Square, Mini Cupcake) Bistro Boxes (Cheese and Fruit, Chicken and Humus, Chicken Wraps, Protein- based Bites, Salumi and Cheese, Sesame Noodles, Tuna Salad) Breakfast (Sandwiches, Wraps, Oatmeal) Salads (Deluxe Fruit Blend) Sandwiches, Paninis and Wraps Ice Cream (Caramel Macchiato, Coffee, Java Chip Frapp, Mocha Frapp, Peppermint Mocha, Strawberries and Crme, Vanilla Bean) Yogurt Parfaits (Greek Yogurt Honey, Peach Raspberry, Strawberry and Blueberry) Equipment (Coffee Presses, Coffee Makers, Espresso Machines, Grinders, Teapots and Teakettles, Equipment Gift Sets) Drinkware (Cups and Mugs, Tumblers and Travel Mugs, Cold Beverage, Accessories, Winter Drinkware) Syrups and Sauces (Caramel, Pepermint, Hazelnut, etc.) Hot Cocoa Individual Pre-Packaged Mixes Music and Books (Tracks that are played in store) Apparel (Hoodies, T-shirts, Hats) Starbucks Card (Gift Card, Pre-pay, Manage, Reload, Rewards)
Starbucks products are enveloped in Starbucks ultimate goal of creating the coffee house experience or The Starbucks Experience. From the variety of coffee products to the ambience in each store, Starbucks takes all the right steps to deliver this experience to its customers, community, employees and shareholders.7
Manufacturer/Marketer
Peter D. Gibbons joined the Starbucks team as the Senior Vice President of Global Manufacturing Operations in 2007, and is now Executive Vice President of Global Supply Chain Operations. His duties are to operate and control the manufacturing, engineering, procurement, distribution, strategic planning, transportation, and inventory management of Starbucks stores worldwide. Gibbons works to maintain and enhance the ultimate experience that Starbucks believes in and makes sure that it continues to participate in environmentally safe procedures and local community volunteering. 7 Starbucks.com. Starbucks corporation. 2011. Feb 10, 2012 <http://www.starbucks.com/>. 4
Starbucks has five company-owned roasting plants in Nevada, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Washington and Netherlands. Starbucks also has 24 co-manufacturers in the U.S., Canada, Europe, Asia and Latin America. It also owns one tea processing plant in Portland, Oregon and in the U.S. Its approximate product deliveries are 2.7 million units per year.8 Supply Chain Management The supply chain management for Starbucks begins with the importation of its coffee beans from Latin America, Africa and Asia to the U.S. and Europe. The unroasted, or green, coffee beans are transported in ocean containers to the U.S. or Europe, and are then taken to six storage sites where they are roasted. Starbucks has five regional distribution centers in the U.S. Two are company-owned, and third-party logistic companies manage the remaining three. These distribution centers distribute not only coffee, but other Starbucks products as well. The roasted coffee beans are then taken here for distribution. Starbucks distribution centers are also located in Europe and Asia, all which are owned by third-party logistic companies. Apart from distribution centers, Starbucks also holds 48 central distribution centers worldwide: 33 in the U.S, seven in Asia/Pacific, five in Canada and three in Europe. Third-party logistics companies own forty-seven of these centers. Products are then distributed by truck from these central distribution centers, or from the larger distribution centers, to their local Starbucks stores.9
Starbucks
product
life
cycle
follows
a
similar
structure
as
the
general
product
life
cycle
process.
The
product
life
cycle
for
Starbucks
proves
to
be
different,
for
certain
Starbucks
products
may
go
through
each
stage
at
differently,
and
these
stages
may
occur
over
various
lengths
of
time.
For
example,
the
Starbucks
product
life
cycle
of
a
summer
drink
like
the
Frappuccino
starts
its
introduction
stage
in
early
to
mid-spring.
Then,
the
Frappuccino
hits
its
growth
stage
from
the
beginning
to
late
summer,
as
consumers
opt
for
cold
beverages
in
the
hot
weather.
As
the
summer
begins
to
end,
the
product
reaches
the
maturity
stage
within
the
product
life
cycle.
The
decline
stage
of
the
Frappuccino
beverage
will
hit
during
late
fall
and
early
to
mid
spring.
The
demand
8
"Starbucks Newsroom: Executive Vice President, Global Supply Chain Operations." Starbucks
Newsroom: Home. Starbucks. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://news.starbucks.com/article_display.cfm?article_id=162>.
9
Cooke, James A. "From Bean to Cup: How Starbucks Transformed Its Supply Chain Procurement CSCMP's Supply Chain Quarterly." CSCMP's Supply Chain Quarterly Supply Chain Analysis, Insight & More. CSCMP. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://www.supplychainquarterly.com/topics/Procurement/scq201004starbucks/>.
for the product falls, and the consumption of hot beverages during the cold winter times rises.10
The
total
annual
sales
volume
for
the
Starbucks
Corporation
is
standardized
in
millions
of
USD.
The
corporations
fiscal
year
ends
in
October.11
Fiscal
Year
Total
Revenue
Gross
Profit
2011
$
11700.4
MM
$
3086.0
MM
2010
2009
2008
2007
$
10707.4
MM
$
9774.6
MM
$
10383.0
MM
$
9411.5
MM
Fiscal
Year
2011
2010
2009
2008
2007
$
2697.4
MM
$
2024.6
MM
$
1992.6
MM
$
2196.5
MM
The
sharp
decline
in
revenue
during
the
2009
fiscal
year
has
been
attributed
to
the
United
States
recession,
as
well
as
the
overall
weak
global
economy,
during
the
specific
time
period.
Starbucks
was
one
of
the
initial
corporations
to
recognize
the
recession
and
its
potential
negative,
long-term
effects
to
total
revenue
and
gross
profit.
Thus,
the
company
halted
plans
for
further
global
expansion
in
July
2008,
and
in
January
2009,
closed
507
of
its
retail
stores
in
the
United
States
and
64
retail
stores
abroad.
Starbucks
saw
it
best
to
concentrate
their
efforts
upon
a
fewer
number
of
stores,
thus
allowing
them
to
improve
within
the
areas
of
brewing
coffee
and
customer
service,
and
rediscovering
the
coffee-house
art
of
pouring
espresso.
In
the
second
quarter
of
the
2009
fiscal
year,
Starbucks
announced
a
77
percent
net
income
drop,
attributed
partially
to
an
8
percent
decline
in
revenue
from
stores
that
10
Starbucks.com.
Starbucks
corporation.
2011.
Feb
10,
2012
<http://www.starbucks.com/>.
11
"Starbucks Financials." Business & Company Resource Center. Business & Company Resource Center.
Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://invreports.galegroup.com.emils.lib.colum.edu/reuters/FinancialReport/FinancialReports.jsp?COUN TRY=US>.
Through the recession and decline in gross profit margin, Starbucks saw an opportunity to improve revenue: the introduction of a breakfast value meal. Customers were given the option to purchase a cup of coffee and one of Starbucks Artisan Sandwiches, a cup of Perfect Oatmeal, or a piece of coffee cake for $3.95. The company also simultaneously planned a multi-million dollar advertising campaign, focused on Starbucks ability to offer value without compromising quality, and lowered the cost of more basic specialty coffee beverages.12 Within the fiscal third quarter of 2009, the Starbucks Corporation (NASDAQ: SBUX) reported stronger results. The 8 percent decline of store sales in the second quarter had risen to 5 percent, and the reported net revenue of $2.4 billion was only 2 M lower than the reported results in the third quarter of 2008. In the press release surrounding the announcement of the results, Executive Vice President and CFO, Troy Alstead, explained the reasons for Starbucks financial improvement: Excellent execution throughout our organization contributed significantly to our performance this quarter. Our store partners have embraced the cost disciples and efficiency initiatives that are enabling us to expand our operating margin. In doing this, they have also delivered increased service speed, measurably improved customer service, customer satisfaction, and an overall enhanced Starbucks Experience.13
had been operational for at least a year. Further research found that 5 percent of that drop could be attributed to customers cutting back on transactions and the amount they spent per visit. Starbucks has long been characterized as a corporation to appeals to affluent professionals, while the lower end of the market is catered to by competitors such as McDonalds, which had begun selling specialty coffee beverages during the time period as well. In the search for a more economical way to find their morning coffee fix, many former Starbucks consumers had begun visiting foodservice industry giants Dunkin Donuts and McDonalds, or purchased in-home coffee brewers and espresso machines.
Starbucks retail sales mix is approximately 61% coffee beverages, 16% food items, 15% whole-bean coffees, and 8% coffee-related products and equipment. The product sales volume differs from store to store, commonly depending on the size and location of each individual outlet. Larger locations carry a greater variety of whole coffee beans, 12 Flynn, Laurie J. "Starbucks Reports 77% Earnings Decline - NYTimes.com." The New York Times Breaking News, World News & Multimedia. The New York Times, 16 Feb. 2012. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/30/business/30sbux.html>. 13 "Starbucks Newsroom: Starbucks Posts Strong Third Quarter Fiscal 2009 Results." Starbucks Newsroom: Home. Starbucks. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://news.starbucks.com/article_display.cfm?article_id=249>.
gourmet food items, teas, coffee mugs, coffee grinders, coffee-making equipment, filters, storage containers, and other accessories. Smaller stores retail location sales are typically limited to coffee beverages, and a small variety of whole-bean coffees.14
$
Sales
Volume
and
Share
of
Total
$
Sales
for
Key
Items
within
the
Product
Line
(2011)15
Product
Line
Coffee
Beverages
Food
Items
Whole-Bean
Coffees
Products/Equipment
14
"Coffee Shop Industry - A Strategic Analysis." Grin. Katz Graduate School of Business. Web.
16 Feb. 2012. <http://www.grin.com/en/e-book/111348/coffee-shop-industry-a-strategic-analysis>.
Financials." Business & Company Resource Center. Business & Company Resource Center. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://invreports.galegroup.com.emils.lib.colum.edu/reuters/FinancialReport/FinancialReports.jsp?COUN TRY=US>.
15
"Starbucks
Largest Coffee Shops Worldwide, 2009 Companies are ranked by units. Seattle's Best is a subsidiary of Starbucks and is present in 400 Borders Books and soon in more than 7,000 Burger King stores. u Starbucks 11,000.00 Coffee Bean and Tea Leaf 750.00 Caribou Coffee 511.00 Peet's Coffee 192.00 Seattle's Best 160.00 Tim Horton's 160.00 Coffee Beanery 131.00 Tully's 100.00 Top Quick-Service Restaurant Chains, 2009 Firms are ranked by sales in billions of dollars. $ McDonald's 31.00 Subway 10.00 Burger King 9.00 Wendy's 8.38 Starbucks 8.34 Taco Bell 6.80 Dunkin' Donuts 5.70 Pizza Hut 5.00 KFC 4.90 Sonic 3.83 Arby's 3.22 Chick-fil-A 3.21 Jack in the Box 3.07
Top Coffee Makers, 2010 Companies are ranked based on sales at supermarkets, drug stores and mass merchandisers (excluding Wal-Mart) for the 52 weeks ended August 8, 2010. ($ mil.) Share $ % J.M. Smucker Co. 898.50 17.69 Kraft Foods Inc. 497.30 9.79 Starbucks Coffee Co. 224.70 4.42 Massimo Zanetti Beverage USA 87.20 1.72 Eight O'Clock Coffee Co. 66.70 1.31 Peet's Coffee and Tea Inc. 60.20 1.19 Rowland Coffee Roasters 45.50 0.90 New England Tea and Coffee Co. Inc. 35.20 0.69 Community Coffee Co. Inc. 33.40 0.66 Private label 237.70 4.68 Other 2,892.10 56.95 16
16
"Starbucks Market Share." Business & Company Resource Center. Business & Company Resource
Center. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://galenet.galegroup.com.emils.lib.colum.edu/servlet/BCRC?vrsn=unknown>.
10
including over 1,200 in Canada, 700 in the United Kingdom, and 54 in Russia.
In order for any marketing efforts to succeed, it is important to have a logo that encompasses the brands business identity. The newest Starbucks logo has dropped its name; it is simple, clean, and evokes confidence. Last year, Starbucks celebrated its 40th anniversary. Over the past 40 years, the brand has become the worlds leading purveyor of the highest quality coffee, as put by Starbucks chairman and CEO, Howard Shultz. In 2011, Starbucks evolved the design of the logo: It embraces and respects the Starbucks heritage and at the same time, it evolves and feels more suitable for the future, Shultz explained. At its core, it is the exact same essence of the Starbucks experience and allows to customers to think beyond coffee. The Starbucks logo has changed three different times over its forty years in business, each marking a historical achievement for the brand.17 Starbucks marketing efforts have focused on local rather than nationwide marketing. Starbucks positions each store individually according to the specific location they are in. Starbucks is as aware of the local community, thus making each retail location specific and unique to each neighborhood they are located in. Starbucks Marketing Strategic Ideas o Perfect cup of coffee - placing emphasis on product quality o Third Place - focusing on creating the third place for everyone to go between home and work o Customer satisfaction - it is important for customers experience the uniqueness of the coffee experience o Creating a Starbucks community - creating a community around the brand, locally and globally o Smart partnerships - a way to grow business is to partner smart o Innovations - creative and innovative ideas to add to their product line and services (for example, Starbucks was first to offer free Wi-Fi within its stores)
17
Allison,
Melissa.
Starbucks
takes
unique
approach
to
marketing.
Seattle
Times.
Oct
12,
2006.
The
Seattle
Times
Company.
Feb
8,
2012
<http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/businesstechnology/2003300353_events12.html>
11
o Brand Marketing" - word of mouth focus, letting the high quality of their products speak for themselves.18
18
Allison,
Melissa.
Starbucks
takes
unique
approach
to
marketing.
Seattle
Times.
Oct
12,
2006.
The
Seattle
Times
Company.
Feb
8,
2012
<http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/businesstechnology/2003300353_events12.html>
19
Morrison,
Maureen.
Starbucks
Hits
No.
3
Despite
Limited
Ad
Spending.
AdAge.
May
02,
2011.
Crain
Communications.
Feb
10,
2012
<http://adage.com/results?
endeca=1&searchprop=AdAgeAll&return=endeca&search_offset=0&search_order_b
y=score&search_phrase=starbucks+ad+budget>
20
Morrison,
Maureen.
Starbucks
Hits
No.
3
Despite
Limited
Ad
Spending.
AdAge.
May
02,
2011.
Crain
Communications.
Feb
10,
2012
<http://adage.com/results?
endeca=1&searchprop=AdAgeAll&return=endeca&search_offset=0&search_order_b
y=score&search_phrase=starbucks+ad+budget>
12
Social
media
has
proven
to
be
a
major
advertising
avenue
for
Starbucks.
Local
advertising
has
also
proven
to
be
a
major
advertising
avenue
and
has
been
much
more
successful
for
Starbucks
than
mass
national
campaigns.
In
the
present
day,
viral
marketing
allows
advertising
dollars
to
more
specifically
target
individuals
rather
than
the
masses.
There
are
two
recent
viral
campaigns
that
Starbucks
launched
for
the
holiday
season
and
Valentines
Day:
they
both
combine
a
unique
Starbucks
experience
with
modern
day
technology.
In
both
campaigns,
the
customer
scans
the
picture
on
the
cup
and
in
turn
can
receive
personalized
messages
and
information
about
the
brand.
For
example,
the
Starbucks
Cup
Magic
app
for
Valentines
Day
incorporates
the
latest
in
augmented
reality
technology
to
offer
an
animated
visual
experience.
Customers
can
download
the
app
by
scanning
a
picture
on
their
Starbucks
cup
to
create
their
own
personalized
augmented
reality
valentine
to
send
to
others.
There
is
an
option
to
also
send
a
personalized
valentine
with
a
Starbucks
Card
eGift.21
Target Audience
Starbucks has 25 million visitors in its stores each week, with this number steadily increasing every year. The average consumers are middle to upper class business associates and college students. Consumers are either single or married, and have a tendency for a greater amount of disposable income. Starbucks determined that most of its targeted customers consider themselves relatively technology savvy via the computer, thus the companys marketing focus on social media. Most Starbucks retail stores are located in big cities and shopping malls, or areas where populations of middle to upper class individuals are dense.
It has been found that 60% of Americans have scaled back on specialty coffee purchases in the past six months due to the overwhelming state of the economy. Those who have scaled back the most since the beginning of the year, according to the online survey of 500 Americans conducted between Jan. 14 and 15, are consumers 45 to 54. This statistic was followed by consumers who are 35 to 44 (37.5%) years of age, and finally by those aged 25 to 34 (33.3%). As might be expected, those who had trimmed the expense the most were in the lower of the survey's income brackets (48.6% earned
May 02, 2011. Crain Communications. Feb 10, 2012 <http://adage.com/results? endeca=1&searchprop=AdAgeAll&return=endeca&search_offset=0&search_order_b y=score&search_phrase=starbucks+ad+budget>
13
between $20,000 and $39,000, and 33.6% earned below $20,000; the latter presumably included college students).22
Media Consumption
Starbucks has historically avoided television advertisements, and instead utilizes newspapers and websites for increasing brand awareness. As Starbucks grew into one of the world's best-known brands, it has rarely been advertised on television. Starbucks was successful in this lack of mass television advertisements due to various strategic marketing tactics, such as social media. On Apr. 30 the company unveiled a new slogan, "It's Not Just Coffee. It's Starbucks," and kicked off a coffee-focused newspaper ad campaign in papers including The New York Times (NYT), warning against down-market imitators like McDonald's. "Beware of Cheaper Coffee. It Comes with a Price", reads one ad that ran on the back page of the Times' Sunday Business section. The campaign also includes a YouTube video, with Schultz asking Starbucks baristas what they think of the other print ads in the new ad campaign, like one that reads "This Is What Coffee Tastes Like When You Pour Your Heart into It." The Seattle-based chain also maintains a Facebook page and various other social media outlets.23
Psychographic Information
Consumers want to be able to taste many types of high quality coffee variations. It is vitally important that more popular coffee products are available to consumers, while other variations are introduced on an occasional basis. Starbucks also meets the needs of not only in-store consumers, but in-home coffee consumers as well by offering brewing equipment and coffee accessories. In addition to meeting those beverage needs of consumers, sometimes there is the need to have an assortment of small foods that are quick to consume and easy to carry. Changes in the social and economic structure of the country are resulting in higher levels of disposable income and a greater interest in Starbuck products and merchandise. At the same time, other coffee shops are trying to tap in on the fad created by Starbucks.24
22 "Ad Age." Advertising Agency & Marketing Industry News - Advertising Age. Ad Age, 31 Jan. 2012. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://adage.com/results?endeca=1>. 23 "Ad Age." Advertising Agency & Marketing Industry News - Advertising Age. Ad Age, 31 Jan. 2012. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://adage.com/results?endeca=1>. 24 "Ad Age." Advertising Agency & Marketing Industry News - Advertising Age. Ad Age, 31 Jan. 2012. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://adage.com/results?endeca=1>. 14
Category/Competition
Size
of
the
Category
and
Segments
including
a
5- Year
Growth
History
The
coffee
shop
industry
in
the
United
States
includes
20,000
stores
with
combined
annual
revenue
of
about
$11
billion.
Major
companies
include
Starbucks,
Dunkin
Donuts,
Coffee
Bean,
Caribou,
Tea
Leaf,
and
Diedrich
(Gloria
Jeans).
The
coffee
shop
industry
is
highly
concentrated
at
the
top
and
fragmented
towards
the
bottom,
meaning
that
the
top
50
companies
have
over
70
percent
of
the
industrys
sales.
Coffee
consumption
is
highest
in
the
Northeastern
portion
of
the
United
States,
where
over
60
percent
of
the
population
consumed
coffee
daily
in
2005,
according
to
the
National
Coffee
Association
(NCA).
Per
capita
consumption
is
highest
in
the
Midwestern
United
States,
where
coffee
drinkers
average
3.7
cups
a
day.
The
typical
and
most
committed
coffee
drinkers
are
25-45
years
old,
affluent,
educated
adults.
Specialty
coffee
appeals
to
a
diverse
adult
demographic,
including
college
students
and
young
adults.
Larger
companies
may
also
sell
coffee
beans
wholesale
to
commercial
customers,
such
as
grocery
stores
and
restaurants.
Sales
are
generally
seasonal,
with
a
peak
during
the
fourth
quarter,
largely
driven
by
the
winter
holiday
season.
In
addition,
poor
weather
can
affect
sales
by
decreasing
store
traffic.
In
terms
of
market
growth
rate,
the
coffee
shop
industry
grew
over
40%
between
2000
and
2005,
with
an
overall
70%
increase
in
the
number
of
coffee
shops
between
2000
and
2005.
However,
the
coffee
shop
industry
expansion
is
slowed,
compared
to
its
explosive
growth
in
the
1990s.
Since
the
market
has
slowed
from
record
highs
in
the
1990s,
companies
are
looking
to
expand
overseas
through
licensing
agreements.
Starbucks
is
the
single
largest
contributor
to
this
increase,
as
its
number
of
outlets
continues
to
increase
on
a
yearly
basis
worldwide.25
15
Starbucks
Starbucks,
the
worlds
number
one
coffee
retailer,
has
over
13,000
coffee
shops
in
more
than
35
countries.
Starbucks
retail
locations
offer
specialty
coffee
beverages,
gourmet
food
items,
coffee
beans,
teas,
and
a
variety
of
coffee
accessories.
Starbucks
owns
about
17,500
of
its
shops,
which
are
located
in
about
10
countries
(mostly
in
the
U.S.),
while
licensees
and
franchisees
operate
the
remaining
outlets.
A
majority
of
Starbucks
retail
sales
account
for
specialty
coffee
beverages
(61%),
along
with
food
items
(16%),
whole-bean
coffees
(15%),
and
coffee-related
products
and
equipment
(8%).
The
company
does
not
compete
on
price,
but
rather
on
the
complete
experience
customers
receive
while
visiting
the
coffee
shop.
Starbucks
works
to
create
a
connection
with
every
single
one
of
their
customers.
Starbucks
overall
goal
is
to
establish
its
brand
as
one
of
the
most
recognized
and
respected
ones
in
the
world.
Therefore
the
enterprise
plans
to
continue
the
rapid
expansion
of
its
retail
locations,
grow
its
specialty
operations,
and
to
selectively
pursue
other
opportunities
to
leverage
the
brand
through
the
introduction
of
new
products
and
the
development
of
new
channels
of
distribution.
In
continuance
with
its
history
of
partnerships,
Starbucks
and
Concord
Music
Group
announced
on
March
12th
of
this
year
the
formation
of
a
new
record
label
Hear
Music
which
will
distribute
recordings
at
Starbucks
locations.
This
partnership
is
another
step
in
Starbucks
entertainment
strategy
that
links
to
the
companys
focus
on
atmosphere
and
image.
Last
fall,
addressing
McDonalds
attempts
to
lure
customers
away,
Starbucks
announced
its
plans
to
offer
hot
breakfast
sandwiches
in
an
appeal
to
fans
of
the
Egg
McMuffin
and
establish
them
also
in
the
breakfast
and
afternoon
snack
segment.
McDonalds
McDonald's
is
the
leading
global
foodservice
retailer
with
more
than
30,000
local
restaurants,
serving
nearly
50
million
people
in
over
than
119
countries
each
day.
In
2006,
the
company
reached
a
record
high
of
$21.6
billion
in
revenues.
McDonald's
has
become
a
major
player
in
the
coffee
market,
and
holds
the
belief
that
the
major
reason
for
the
billion
cups
they
sell
annually
is
due
to
their
brewing
temperature
of
195-205F.
The
average
cost
of
a
cup
of
coffee
at
a
McDonald's
retail
location
is
$1.35.
Recent
strategic
changes
within
McDonalds
include
the
improvement
of
the
quality
of
its
coffee
through
the
launch
of
a
premium
roast
in
March
of
2006.
The
launch
has
allowed
McDonald's
to
compete
with
major
coffee
house
retailers
such
as
Starbucks
and
Caribou
Coffee.
Furthermore,
McDonalds
is
looking
into
day-parts
penetration
as
a
growth
strategy.
The
company
is
currently
the
market
leader
in
the
breakfast
segment,
but
is
looking
to
take
over
the
afternoon
segment
as
well
through
the
launch
of
specialty
coffee
beverages
in
March
of
2007.
The
move
towards
a
premium
roast
is
consistent
with
McDonald's
overall
strategic
shift
to
begin
offering
more
'upscale
food',
16
though the pricing strategy for espresso-based drinks still falls below Starbucks' prices. Though McDonald's has a pricing advantage, specialty drinks are served from push- button machines, unlike retailers such as Starbucks or Caribou Coffee, who explore the art of handcrafted beverages and upscale customer service. However, coffee competitors are increasingly threatened by McDonald's recent ability to increase its level of service and improve its stores through the slowing down of expansion and reallocation of funds.
Dunkin Donuts
Dunkin Donuts is the worlds largest coffee and baked goods chain, serving over 3 million customers a day. In 2006, the company boasted revenues of approximately $4.7 billion, with more than 7,000 shops worldwide (5,300 in the U.S.). The company is continues to open 700-1000 additional retail locations annually. Dunkin Donuts has forged a strong identity as a coffee destination, and continues to grow its food/beverage offerings incrementally. The company sells about 500 million cups of coffee a year, for approximately $1.65 per cup. Approximately 57% of the chain's sales are found in the sale of beverages. Dunkin Donuts is currently pursuing the following key strategies: multi-branding concept development, Dunkin brand vitalization, product innovations, accelerated brand development, improved operational effectiveness and talent acquisition, and operates its retail locations in a franchise format, either through operating agreement, license agreement, or joint venture. In order to grow its presence within the coffee market, Dunkin' Donuts plans to widen its specialty coffee beverage options. A portion of this effort included signing an agreement with Procter & Gamble in March of 2007, thus launching Dunkin' Donuts packaged coffee beans at U.S. retailers, including grocery stores, mass merchandisers, and club stores. Dunkin' Donuts' current advertising strategy works to emphasize the company's ability to be a faster, cheaper, and more user-friendly alternative to coffee houses like Starbucks. In an effort to market itself as time effective, Dunkin' Donuts has recently installed espresso machines which are capable of brewing coffee in approximately 44 seconds. CEO Jon Luther sees an opportunity for the company within the specialty beverage market, especially among a consumer of a younger demographic, who enjoys specialty coffee beverages, yet is unable to afford brands such as Starbucks. The current goals of the brand to target this particular market are to focus on improving customer service and cross shop consistency in service, a goal that might prove to be rather challenging due to the company's franchise structure.
Caribou Coffee
Caribou Coffee was founded in 1993, with its headquarters currently located in Minneapolis, Minnesota. Today, it is the second largest specialty coffee company in the U.S. with 416 outlets (2005) in 18 states and the District of Columbia. In 2005, company 17
revenue
was
found
to
be
approximately
$198
million.
Caribou's
retail
locations
have
a
distinct
design
scheme,
featuring
mountain-lodge-style
decor
with
exposed
beam
ceilings,
leather
chairs,
and
fireplaces.
With
a
motto
relaying
"Life
is
short.
Stay
awake
for
it.",
Caribou
Coffee
has
successfully
competed
against
Starbucks
in
a
number
of
U.S.
states.
Caribou's
point
of
brand
strength
is
found
in
the
quality
and
freshness
of
their
products.
Caribou
coffee
products
are
packaged
immediately
after
roasting,
and
are
sold
no
more
than
21
days
after
roasting
or
no
more
than
seven
days
after
opening
the
package.
An
additional
point
of
brand
strength
might
be
found
in
Caribou's
unique
roast
of
coffee
in
a
warmer
store
atmosphere,
as
opposed
to
the
sleek,
urban
design
of
Starbucks
retail
locations.
Caribou
Coffee
is
currently
looking
to
expand
internationally,
specifically
with
its
sights
set
on
initial
expansion
in
the
Middle
East,
for
the
company
believes
that
this
area
has
a
small,
but
developing
market
for
American-branded
coffee
houses.
Additional
strategic
approaches
include
the
development
of
strategic
partnerships
with
retailers
such
as
Eatzi's,
or
building
stores
specifically
next
to
Bruegger's
Bagels,
Blockbuster
Video,
and
Border's
Books.
The
company
continues
to
sell
its
coffee
as
well
in
higher-end
grocery
stores,
and
is
served
exclusively
on
Frontier
and
Maxjet
airlines.
___
Though
it
has
been
recognized
that
no
specialty
coffee
retailer
has
approached
Starbucks
in
terms
of
its
success
on
a
global
scale,
the
coffee
shop
industry
has
become
increasingly
competitive.
While
many
affluent
American
consumers
remain
to
favor
Starbucks
coffee,
industry
experts
have
questioned
whether
or
not
the
companys
focus
on
the
art
of
the
in-store
experience
rather
than
its
product
portfolio
will
allow
for
long- term
success.
With
the
selection
of
coffee
beans
improving
elsewhere,
it
is
unclear
how
many
customers
will
continue
to
purchase
specialty
coffee
beverages
at
premium
prices
if
Starbucks
terms
of
in-store
experience
become
no
longer
unique.
It
has
been
predicted
that
the
specialty
coffee
beverage
consumers
view
on
the
price-value
equation
will
change
in
the
future.26
Brand/Product Names
Today, McDonald's is the world's leading global food service retailer with more than 33,000 locations serving nearly 68 million customers in 119 countries each day. McDonald's has become very popular by the variety of food selection they offer, as well as the fast service they provide. McDonald's food menu consists of burgers, sandwiches, chicken, salads, breakfast, snacks, desserts and beverages. McDonald's meat and chicken comes from USDA-inspected suppliers in the U.S., with a small
26
"Coffee Shop Industry - A Strategic Analysis." Grin. Katz Graduate School of Business. Web. 16 Feb.
2012. <http://www.grin.com/en/e-book/111348/coffee-shop-industry-a-strategic-analysis>.
18
percentage
of
their
beef
imported
from
USDA-
inspected
suppliers
in
Australia
and
New
Zealand.
27
McDonald's
recent
espresso
line
makes
up
about
15
percent
of
McDonald's
revenue.
McCafe
has
been
successful
due
to
their
low
cost
on
espresso
beverages
compared
to
other
espresso
shops.
At
McDonald's,
one
can
choose
between
several
gourmet
coffee
choices:
cappuccinos,
lattes,
and
iced
and
hot
mochas.
Their
McCafe
specialty
coffee
beans
are
imported
from
Brazil
and
from
the
mountains
of
Sumatra,
Guatemala,
and
Costa
Rica.
Their
Premium
Roast
coffee
beans
are
grown
in
Brazil
and
the
mountains
of
Colombia,
Guatemala,
and
Costa
Rica.28
Manufacturer/Marketer
McDonalds manufacturers include Gavina Gourmet Coffee, Lopez Foods (beef patties), Keystone Foods (chicken), and 100 Circle Farms (potatoes).29 McDonalds utilizes Omnicom Group (DDB Worldwide), Publicis Groupes Leo Burnett Worldwide for their marketing tactics.30
"McDonald's Products, Calories and Nutritional Information." All Things Food and Diet - FatSecret. Web. 1 Feb. 2012. <http://www.fatsecret.com/calories-nutrition/mcdonalds>.
27
Patton, Leslie. "McDonalds Second-Quarter Profit Gains 15% as McCafe Beverages Boost Sales Bloomberg." Bloomberg - Business & Financial News, Breaking News Headlines. Bloomberg, 22 July 2011. Web. 1 Feb. 2012. <http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-07-22/mcdonald-s-second-quarter-profitgains-15-as-mccafe-beverages-boost-sales.html>. 29
"Meet Our Suppliers :: McDonalds.com." Home :: McDonalds.com. McDonald's. Web. 18 Feb. 2012. <http://www.mcdonalds.com/us/en/food/food_quality/see_what_we_are_made_of/meet_our_suppliers.html >.
30
Chura, Hillary. "McDonald's Pulls Further Away from Mass Marketing." Advertising Age. Advertising Agency. Web. 18 Feb. 2012. <http://adage.com/article/news/mcdonald-s-pulls-mass-marketing/40403/>.
28
19
The chart above shows McDonald's sale by volume in billions of dollars. The chart shows years 2007-2011. The chart shows the growth rate in percent. 31
2006
0.71
2007
0.87
2008
0.43
2009
0.52
2010
1.24
The
chart
shown
above
is
McDonald's
earning/share
in
dollars
for
years
2006-2010.
The
Chart
above
also
show
the
percent
change
from
previous
year
in
percentages.
*
The
2000-2010
annual
growth
rate
percent
was
26.0.
Food
service
Industry
Category
Rank
(2010)
Company
Revenue
($Millions)
Rank
McDonald's
$
24,074.6
1
Yum
Brands
$
11,343.0
2
Starbucks
$
10,707.4
3
The
chart
show
above
is
the
Food
service
Industry
Category
Rank
(2010).
The
Chart
shows
the
companies,
revenue
($
millions)
and
Rank.
Ranking within Fortune 500 Companies (2010) Company Revenue ($Millions) Rank McDonald's $ 24,074.6 111 Yum Brands $ 11,343.0 214 Starbucks $ 10,707.4 229 The chart above is the Ranking within Fortune 500 companies (2010). The chart shows company, revenue($millions) and ranking within Fortune 500 companies (2010).32
31
"McDonalds Financials." Business & Company Resource Center. Business & Company Resource
Center. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://invreports.galegroup.com.emils.lib.colum.edu/reuters/FinancialReport/FinancialReports.jsp?COUN TRY=US>.
32 MarketWatch.
20
Demographics
McDonald's
age
group
demographics
include
6-12
year
olds,
who
are
considered
heavy
users;
16-24
are
considered
to
be
single
and
heavy
users;
24
and
older
are
considered
to
be
single
or
married,
and
are
light
to
medium
users.
Social
groups
demographics
include
students,
businessmen
and
women,
housewives,
entrepreneurs,
teenagers,
and
small
children.
McDonalds
demographic
information
regarding
location
includes
both
national
and
international
locations.
Race
demographics
includes
all
races
and
ethnicities,
as
well
as
gender
demographics,
which
include
both
male
and
female.
The McDonalds McCaf is a specialty coffee product with a different target market, as compared to Starbucks specialty coffee beverages. The particular target market for McDonalds specialty coffee beverages includes working individuals of a low to middle socioeconomic class. McDonalds promotes their McCafe beverages as a lower priced coffee beverage, yet one that still retains product quality.
The
McDonalds
McCafe
was
launched
upon
the
promotional
tool
of
Free
Coffee
Mondays,
which
was
a
prime
promotion
for
a
working
class
target
market.
Both,
Dunkin
Donuts
and
McCaf
are
looking
for
the
same
demographic
when
it
comes
to
customers.
The
Starbucks
consumer
is
considered
one
of
affluence,
is
typically
brand
loyal,
and
is
seeking
experience
rather
than
a
better
deal.
There
are
two
strategies
created
for
the
launch
of
McCaf:
one
targeted
to
leisurely
consumption
of
gourmet
coffee
drinks
such
as
mocha,
cappuccino
and
latte.
These
are
very
similar
to
Starbucks
ads
because
they
are
looking
to
join
that
category.
The
other
campaign
is
targeted
for
the
middle
class
working
American
that
is
seeking
a
quality
cup
of
coffee
at
a
reduced
price.
McDonalds
is
not
only
trying
to
get
the
attention
of
Starbucks
followers,
but
also
Dunkin
Donut
followers.
These
two
competitors
encompass
the
majority
of
the
market
segment
for
specialty
coffee
beverages.33
33
Morrison,
Maureen.
Starbucks
Hits
No.
3
Despite
Limited
Ad
Spending.
AdAge.
May
02,
2011.
Crain
Communications.
Feb
10,
2012
<http://adage.com/results?
endeca=1&searchprop=AdAgeAll&return=endeca&search_offset=0&search_order_b
y=score&search_phrase=starbucks+ad+budget>
21
In 2003, McDonalds was the 16th largest national advertiser in the United States, with advertising spending amounting to $1.37 billion (an increase of 2.4% since 2002). According to Advertising Age, U.S. sales were up $6 billion (up 11.4% since 2002), and worldwide sales were $17.1 billion (up 11.3% since 2002).34 In 2004, McDonalds began pulling away from the idea of mass marketing, believing that no single ad tells the entire story of a business, and instead moved to create an advertising strategy that uses multidimensional and multilayered media. After the implementation of this idea, McDonalds spent $577 million in measured media in 2003, according to TNS Media Intelligence/CMR.35
McCafe drinks are sold at a very low and affordable price, and thus allowing them a large amount of reoccurring customers. As well, many individuals buy their coffee with their breakfast that they get at McDonald's, leading to increase revenue. Adding an extra $2-$3 for a cup of coffee makes them less hesitant. McDonald's offers breakfast from early sunrise to approximately 10:30 a.m. Many people drink coffee with a breakfast meal, and it is thus an effective consumption pattern at McDonald's. On the other hand, Starbucks have less of a consumer consumption pattern due to their low variety of breakfast meals and high prices. They have less frequent repeat customers because it is viewed as a small luxury to get a beverage than a necessity.36
34
"McDonald's Corp. | AdAge Encyclopedia of Advertising - Advertising Age." Advertising Agency &
Marketing Industry News - Advertising Age. Advertising Agency. Web. 18 Feb. 2012. <http://adage.com/article/adage-encyclopedia/mcdonald-s-corp/98769/>.
35
Chura, Hillary. "McDonald's Pulls Further Away from Mass Marketing." Advertising Age. Advertising Agency. Web. 18 Feb. 2012. <http://adage.com/article/news/mcdonald-s-pulls-mass-marketing/40403/>.
36 Coleman, Daryl, Connie Gao, and Heejae Kim. "McDonald's: Breaching the Luxury Coffee Market."
37
Coleman, Daryl, Connie Gao, and Heejae Kim. "McDonald's: Breaching the Luxury Coffee Market."
22
Bibliography
"Ad Age." Advertising Agency & Marketing Industry News - Advertising Age. Ad Age, 31 Jan. 2012. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://adage.com/results?endeca=1>..
Allison,
Melissa.
Starbucks
takes
unique
approach
to
marketing.
Seattle
Times.
Oct
12,
2006.
The
Seattle
Times
Company.
Feb
8,
2012
<http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/businesstechnology/2003300353_events12.html>
Celentano,
Manufacturing
<http://foodbeverage.about.com/od/Consumers/qt/Mcdonalds-Happy-Meals.htm>.
Chura, Hillary. "McDonald's Pulls Further Away from Mass Marketing." Advertising Age. Advertising Agency. Web. 18 Feb. 2012. <http://adage.com/article/news/mcdonald-s-pulls-massmarketing/40403/>.
"Coffee Shop Industry - A Strategic Analysis." Grin. Katz Graduate School of Business. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://www.grin.com/en/e-book/111348/coffee-shop-industry-a-strategic-analysis>.
Coleman, Daryl, Connie Gao, and Heejae Kim. "McDonald's: Breaching the Luxury Coffee Market."
Cooke, James A. "From Bean to Cup: How Starbucks Transformed Its Supply Chain Procurement CSCMP's Supply Chain Quarterly." CSCMP's Supply Chain Quarterly Supply Chain Analysis, Insight & More. CSCMP. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://www.supplychainquarterly.com/topics/Procurement/scq201004starbucks/ Flynn, Laurie J. "Starbucks Reports 77% Earnings Decline - NYTimes.com." The New York Times - Breaking News, World News & Multimedia. The New York Times, 16 Feb. 2012. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/30/business/30sbux.html>.
Hauks
Michelle,
Kembel
Brent,
Kembell
Shean,
Olsen
Luke,
Perry
Leonard
Catching
the
Starbucks
fever.
Academicmind.
April
2002.
Missouri
State
University.
Feb
10,
2012
MarketWatch. 2012. MarketWatch Inc.2 Feb. 2012<http://www.marketwatch.com>
"MBA Tutorials Starbucks SWOT Analysis." MBA Tutorials MBA Tutorials Accounting, Economics,Finance, Management, Marketing,Strategic Management,human Resource Management,branding. MBA Tutorials. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://www.mbatutorials.com/marketing/swot-analysis-marketing/310-starbucks-swot-analysis.html>. "McDonald's Corp. | AdAge Encyclopedia of Advertising - Advertising Age." Advertising Agency & Marketing Industry News - Advertising Age. Advertising Agency. Web. 18 Feb. 2012. <http://adage.com/article/adage-encyclopedia/mcdonald-s-corp/98769/>. "McDonalds Financials." Business & Company Resource Center. Business & Company Resource Center. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://invreports.galegroup.com.emils.lib.colum.edu/reuters/FinancialReport/FinancialReports.jsp?COUN TRY=US>.
"McDonald's Products, Calories and Nutritional Information." All Things Food and Diet FatSecret. Web. 1 Feb. 2012. <http://www.fatsecret.com/calories-nutrition/mcdonalds>.
23
"Meet Our Suppliers :: McDonalds.com." Home :: McDonalds.com. McDonald's. Web. 18 Feb. 2012. <http://www.mcdonalds.com/us/en/food/food_quality/see_what_we_are_made_of/meet_our_suppliers.html >. Morrison, Maureen. Starbucks Hits No. 3 Despite Limited Ad Spending. AdAge. May 02, 2011. Crain Communications. Feb 10, 2012 <http://adage.com/results?endeca=1&searchprop=AdAgeAll&return=endeca&search_offset=0&sear ch_order_by=score&search_phrase=starbucks+ad+budget> Patton, Leslie. "McDonalds Second-Quarter Profit Gains 15% as McCafe Beverages Boost Sales Bloomberg." Bloomberg - Business & Financial News, Breaking News Headlines. Bloomberg, 22 July 2011. Web. 1 Feb. 2012. <http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-07-22/mcdonald-s-second-quarter-profitgains-15-as-mccafe-beverages-boost-sales.html>. "Product Life Cycle." QuickMBA: Accounting, Business Law, Economics, Entrepreneurship, Finance, Management, Marketing, Operations, Statistics, Strategy. QuickMBA, 2010. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://www.quickmba.com/marketing/product/lifecycle/>. Starbucks.com. Starbucks corporation. 2011. Feb 10, 2012 <http://www.starbucks.com/>. "Starbucks Case Study." Starbucks Case Study. McGraw-Hill Companies. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://www.mhhe.com/business/management/thompson/11e/case/starbucks-2.html>. "Starbucks Financials." Business & Company Resource Center. Business & Company Resource Center. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://invreports.galegroup.com.emils.lib.colum.edu/reuters/FinancialReport/FinancialReports.jsp?COUN TRY=US>. "Starbucks Market Share." Business & Company Resource Center. Business & Company Resource Center. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://galenet.galegroup.com.emils.lib.colum.edu/servlet/BCRC?vrsn=unknown>. "Starbucks Newsroom: Executive Vice President, Global Supply Chain Operations. Starbucks Newsroom: Home. Starbucks. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://news.starbucks.com/article_display.cfm?article_id=162>. "Starbucks Newsroom: Starbucks Posts Strong Third Quarter Fiscal 2009 Results." Starbucks Newsroom: Home. Starbucks. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://news.starbucks.com/article_display.cfm?article_id=249>. "Starbucks Swot Analysis." Scribd. Scribd. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://www.scribd.com/doc/3972739/Starbucks-Swot-Analysis>. "Starbucks S.W.O.T." Business & Company Resource Center. Business & Company Resource Center. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. <http://galenet.galegroup.com.emils.lib.colum.edu/servlet/BCRC?vrsn=unknown>.
24