User's Guide To Spray Nozzles - 2013 - Lo-Res-Sequential
User's Guide To Spray Nozzles - 2013 - Lo-Res-Sequential
A USERS GUIDE TO
SPRAY NOZZLES
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
SECTION ONE
The Costly Consequences Of
Spraying Too Much or Too Little. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
SECTION TWO
Spray Nozzle Fundamentals. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
SECTION THREE
Know Your Nozzle Types . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
SECTION FOUR
Selecting The Right Spray Nozzle. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
SECTION FIVE
Consult The Experts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40
SECTION SIX
Making Maintenance A Priority. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42
SECTION SEVEN
Sprayer Calibration
Ensures Optimal Performance. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 6
SECTION EIGHT
Future Trends in
Spraying and Nozzle Technology. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 52
A Users Guide to Spray Nozzles
INTRODUCTION
poor choice in
spray nozzles,
Your success
SECTION
ONE
THE
COSTLY
CONSEQUENCES
OF
SPR AYING TOO MUCH OR TOO LIT TLE
Making sure you have the proper spray nozzles for your applica-
tion and that they are performing properly are two things that every user should
practice to maximize performance and profitability. The spray nozzles you
select will determine:
The amount of chemical applied to an area
The uniformity of the application
The coverage of the chemical on the target surface
The amount of potential drift
Using the wrong spray nozzle or a spray nozzle that isnt performing properly
can result in over or under application. Over application can be wasteful and
costly; under application can result in a reduction in performance or the need for
re-application.
The use of a rate controller can certainly help ensure the proper amount is
sprayed. You can also make minor adjustments to sprayer pressure or speed to
apply the correct amount of chemical. However, the proper application volume
doesnt necessarily mean maximum effectiveness.
For example, if you are using the wrong nozzle or if the nozzle is worn by as
little as 10%, the spray pattern may not be uniform across the boom and you
will not get the spray coverage you expect. Coverage may be streaky and some
areas may receive more or less chemical than intended, resulting in the need to
re-apply the product.
No matter the root cause, over and under application both have high price
tags thousands of dollars, and in some cases, tens of thousands of dollars.
The full cost of these losses will likewise depend on your operation and the plant
protection products you use. See the example below.
Problems like this can be avoided by making sure youve selected the proper
spray nozzles for your application and that they are in good working order. If you
think there is a nozzle that may better meet your needs, or you suspect that your
nozzles are worn, do not hesitate to replace them. The cost of replacing nozzles
is minor compared to the effects of poor spraying. In fact, youll recoup the cost
of the nozzles almost immediately by applying the proper amount of chemical in
just a few acres.
$2,700
$27,000
$54,000
SECTION
TWO
S P R AY N O Z Z L E F U N D A M E N TA L S
Spray Patterns
There are many types of nozzles and spray patterns available; your best choice
will depend on the application. Three of the most common types are:
Flat fan
Cone spray
Streaming nozzles
Flat Fan
The flat fan spray nozzle forms a narrow, elliptical, inverted V pattern commonly
referred to as a tapered spray (FIGURE 1). Deposition is heaviest at the center
of the pattern and dissipates toward the outer edge. A uniform distribution
pattern across the boom is achieved when the boom height and nozzle spacing
are optimized for proper spray pattern overlap of adjacent nozzles. Variations of
the flat fan include:
E
xtended range flat fan for broadcast spraying; designed to operate
with a wider range of spray pressures (FIGURE 1).
S
ymmetric or asymmetric twin flat fan for broadcast spraying; flow
is divided between two orifices pointed forward and backward; can
provide improved coverage and canopy penetration (FIGURE 2).
F
looding for broadcast spraying; wide angle flat pattern using larger
droplets (FIGURE 3).
E
ven spray for band spraying; non-tapered spray patterns provide
even coverage without overlapping (FIGURE 4).
A
dditionally, all of the above nozzle types may be offered in a
traditional single orifice design, pre-orifice design or air induction
design. More to come on this in the next section.
Higher
Pressure
Lower
Pressure
AT 15 PSI / 1 bar
PRESSURE
FIGURE 1:
Extended range flat fan
spray pattern
FIGURE 3:
Wide angle flat fan
spray pattern
AT 60 PSI / 4 bar
PRESSURE
FIGURE 2:
Symmetric twin flat fan spray pattern
FIGURE 4:
Even spray pattern
Cone Sprays
Cone sprays come in two basic variations - hollow cone and full cone. The
hollow cone spray nozzle forms a ring-shaped pattern, finely atomized spray
and can be operated at high pressures. These unique characteristics make
hollow cone nozzles well suited for air blast applications as well as specialty
and directed spray applications. Hollow cone nozzles may be offered in a singlepiece tip design or a two-piece disc and core design. Air induction hollow cone
nozzles are a recent development that produces a spray pattern like a traditional
cone spray, but with much coarser droplets to reduce drift. (FIGURE 5 & 6).
The full cone spray nozzle creates a full, circular spray pattern. Full cones
typically produce coarser droplets and are offered in larger capacities than
hollow cone nozzles. These nozzles are typically used for directed spraying and
other specialty applications. Full cone nozzles may be offered in a single-piece
tip design or a two-piece disc and core design (FIGURE 7).
FIGURE 5:
Hollow Cone Spray Pattern
FIGURE 6:
Air Induction Hollow Cone
Spray Pattern
FIGURE 7:
Full Cone Spray Pattern
Streaming Nozzles
Solid stream or broadcast streaming nozzles are offered in a variety of
configurations and are commonly used for liquid fertilizer application. The
solid stream spray pattern reduces foliar coverage to minimize leaf burn while
projecting the liquid more directly to the soil surface where it can be absorbed by
the root system. More to come on these nozzles in the next section
The charts to the right provide information on the theoretical spray coverage of
the included spray angle at various spray heights. These values are based on the
assumption that the spray angle remains the same throughout the entire spray
distance. In actual practice, this does not happen due to the effects of gravity
(FIGURE 8).
Always keep in mind that spray coverage will vary based on operating pressure,
spray height and nozzle spacing. Follow the manufacturers recommendations to
achieve uniform coverage.
Optimum spray heights can be found in the table on the next page (FIGURE 9).
These heights are based on laboratory testing and provide the overlap required
to obtain uniform distribution. In many cases, typical height adjustments are
based on 1:1 nozzle spacing to height ratio. For example, 110 flat spray nozzles
spaced 20/50 cm apart are commonly set 20/50 cm above the target.
Included Spray
Angle
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
55
60
65
73
80
85
90
95
100
110
120
130
140
150
Included Spray
Angle
2.6
3.5
4.4
5.4
6.3
7.3
8.3
9.3
10.3
11.5
12.7
14.8
16.8
18.3
20.0
21.8
23.8
28.5
34.6
42.9
54.8
74.5
20 cm
30 cm
3.2
4.2
5.3
6.4
7.6
8.7
9.9
11.2
12.5
13.8
15.3
17.8
20.2
22.0
24.0
26.2
28.6
34.3
41.6
51.5
65.7
89.5
3.9
5.3
6.6
8.1
9.5
10.9
12.4
14.0
15.6
17.3
19.2
22.0
25.2
27.5
30.0
32.8
35.8
42.8
52.0
64.4
82.2
4.7
6.4
8.0
9.7
11.3
13.1
14.9
16.8
18.7
20.6
22.9
27.0
30.3
33.0
36.0
40.3
43.0
51.4
62.4
77.3
98.6
6.3
8.5
10.6
12.8
15.5
17.5
19.9
22.4
25.0
27.7
30.5
36.0
40.3
44.0
48.0
52.4
57.2
68.5
83.2
103
7.9
10.6
13.3
16.1
18.9
21.8
24.8
28.0
31.2
34.6
38.2
44.0
50.4
55.4
60.0
65.5
71.6
85.6
104
9.5
12.7
15.9
19.3
22.7
26.2
29.8
33.6
37.5
41.6
45.8
53.0
60.4
66.4
72.0
78.6
85.9
103
80 cm
90 cm
Disc Core
50 cm
60 cm
70 cm
FIGURE 8:
Theoretical Coverage
The most commonly used spray angle for various nozzle types are listed below.
Tapered flat fan nozzles are most often available with 80 or 110 spray angles
E
ven flat fan nozzles are commonly available with 40, 65, 80, or 95
spray angles
Flooding (wide angle) nozzles typically produce a 120 spray angle
Hollow cone nozzles are commonly available with 65 or 80 spray angles
The trend in broadcast flat fan spray tip design is toward wider spray
angles. This is why you will see most new generation tips offered in 110
or wider spray angles only. The advantages of wider spray angles include
increased overlap for better spray distribution and the ability to run booms
closer to the target surface to reduce drift potential.
Spray Pressure
Nozzle flow rate varies with spraying pressure. In general, the relationship
between flow rate in gallons per minute (GPM) or liters per minute (l/min) and
pressure in PSI or bar is shown at the right (FIGURE 10).
10
(in)
20"
30"
40"
30"
NR*
NR*
110
20
30"
NR*
120o
24"
30"
39"
80
(cm)
50 cm
75 cm
100 cm
80
75cm
NR*
NR*
110
50cm
75cm
NR*
120o
60cm
75cm
100cm
FIGURE 9:
Optimum spray heights
*Not recommended
GPM1
GPM2
l/min1
l/min2
PSI1
PSI2
bar1
bar2
FIGURE 10:
Relationship between flow rate (GPM or l/min) and pressure (PSI or bar)
11
12
XF
VF
Extremely
Fine
Very
Fine
Fine
Medium
VC
XC
UC
Coarse
Very
Coarse
Extremely
Coarse
Ultra
Coarse
FIGURE 11:
Droplet Size Classification
Laser Analyzer
13
14
15
SECTION THREE
KNOW
YOUR
NOZZLE
TYPES
Using AI nozzles:
Ideal for drift reduction while maintaining good coverage; when used
with the proper chemicals/additives, air bubbles are formed in the droplet
causing the droplets to shatter on impact, providing improved coverage.
B
e sure to use the proper operating pressures to achieve the proper
droplet size. Some AI nozzles require an operating pressure of
30 to 100 PSI (2 to 7 bar) to maximize performance. Many newer AI
nozzles have been designed to operate effectively at pressures as low
as 15 PSI (1 bar).
Most AI nozzles produce a wide angle flat fan or twin flat fan pattern.
AI
nozzles are typically used for broadcast spraying of post-emergence
systemic herbicides, fungicides and insecticides. In banded and
directed spraying, AI nozzles provide excellent performance in
application of pre-emergence herbicides, post-emergence systemic
herbicides, fungicides and insecticides.
A
symmetric twin spray nozzles are a more recent development that
features one spray pattern projected downward for canopy penetration
and one pattern projected horizontally for coverage at the top of the
crop canopy/seed head. These nozzles have proven to be particularly
effective for fungicide application and disease control in small grains.
16
C
arry a few spares. Even though cleaning these nozzles shouldnt
require tools, in-field cleaning isnt recommended because of the
number of small pieces. If in-field cleaning is necessary, keep a small
can of compressed air on board the sprayer.
17
18
19
20
21
Fertilizer Nozzles
Solid stream nozzles are offered in a variety of sizes offering anywhere from
1 to 7 or more individual streams. By utilizing individual liquid streams instead
of a fan spray, liquid fertilizer can be applied more directly to the soil surface
where it is needed. This minimizes foliar coverage in standing crop reducing
the chances of leaf burn and makes the likelihood spray drift extremely low.
Fertilizer streaming tips are not recommended for pesticide application.
22
D
ue to the more 3-dimensional nature of some streaming nozzles, be sure
to verify that the spray pattern formed by the tip is compatible with your
spray boom. Some manufacturers offer simple adapters that can be utilized
to adjust the orientation/position of the tip for optimum performance.
23
SECTION FOUR
SELEC TING THE RIGHT SPR AY NOZZLE
24
It may be tempting to overlook the role spray nozzles can have in the overall
success of your spraying season simply because they are a small, relatively lowcost component. However, a poor choice in spray nozzles or the use of underperforming nozzles, can lead to re-spraying or reduced performance two
problems no user should face.
Giving serious consideration to your spraying objectives and studying your options
shouldnt be shortchanged. Its a small time investment that will help maximize
your success. Start by reviewing your spraying requirements and be prepared to
have multiple nozzle sets on hand to meet your varying needs.
25
Do time constraints require you to spray under less than ideal conditions?
Selection of a nozzle
that reduces drift potential
requires an understanding
of droplet size.
27
Drift studies
Drift has become a topic of great interest in recent years and many studies
have been conducted to document drift potential of different types of nozzles at
varying operating pressures. However, drift studies can be difficult and costly to
conduct and there are several different methodologies in use. The methodology
influences the results so it is very important to understand these differences
if you are comparing drift data from different manufacturers or studies from
different research groups. Direct comparisons should not be made between:
Field studies They are costly and difficult to conduct, but the
data from these studies is considered the most reliable since actual
spraying conditions are tested.
Lab studies They use various collection devices and dye
concentrations. This technique uses various sophisticated
collection devices in a lab setting that replicates field spraying as
precisely as possible.
W
ind tunnel testing Uses water sensitive paper to collect and
observe drift. The use of wind tunnels and water sensitive paper is the
least accurate and clear guidelines for accuracy and repeatability do
not exist.
When evaluating drift data, it is important to read the entire test report. Some
companies can selectively extract information to make their spray nozzles look
better and/or make invalid comparisons across various nozzle types.
Wind Tunnel
for Drift Studies
28
29
General guidelines:
F
ine, Medium & Coarse Droplets Use for post-emergence contact
applications that require excellent coverage on leaf surfaces including
herbicides, fungicides and insecticides.
C
oarse & Very Coarse Droplets Use for contact and systemic
herbicides, insecticides, and fungicides.
V
ery Coarse, Extremely Coarse & Ultra Coarse Droplets Use for
systemic herbicides, pre-emergence surface applied herbicides and
when working in highly sensitive areas.
D
roplet size will vary based on pressure. In general, the smaller the
nozzle size and the greater the spray pressure, the smaller the droplets
and the greater proportion of driftable droplets.
A larger capacity nozzle will produce more coarse droplets.
S
pray for the situation at hand. Crop conditions, pest conditions, and
weather conditions can dramatically impact the performance of the
applied product.
ALWAYS consult the chemical label for the manufacturers application
and droplet size recommendations before applying.
30
GPA (solution)
Conversion Factor
GPA (water)
l/ha (solution)
Conversion Factor
l/ha (water)
FIGURE 12:
Density conversion formulas
Pounds
per Gallon
Kilograms
per Liter
Conversion
Factor
7.0 lb/gal
0.84 kg/l
0.92
8.0 lb/gal
0.96 kg/l
0.98
8.34 lb/gal
1.00 kg/l
(water)
1.00
9.0 lb/gal
1.08 kg/l
1.04
10.0 lb/gal
1.20 kg/l
1.10
10.65 lb/gal
1.28 kg/l
(28% Nitrogen)
1.13
11.0 lb/gal
1.32 kg/l
1.15
12.0 lb/gal
1.44 kg/l
1.20
14.0 lb/gal
1.68 kg/l
1.30
FIGURE 13:
Density conversion tables
31
32
33
34
Size How many spray nozzles does the manufacturer produce annually? How
much manufacturing space is dedicated to spray nozzle production? These are
often good indicators of quality. Manufacturers producing low quality nozzles
wont have the same level of demand as those producing superior products.
Commitment Is the manufacturer actively involved in the international spray
community? Does it participate in conferences and technical committees? Does
it conduct research and share the findings with the industry to advance spray
technology? All of these items indicate a long-term commitment to the industry
and the environment both of which provide value to you.
35
Herbicides
Soil Incorporated
Pre-Emergence
Systemic
Excellent
Good
Good
Good
Very Good
Very Good
Very Good
Very Good
Good
Excellent
Excellent
Excellent
Low Pressure
Air Induction Flat Spray
Air Induction
Twin Flat Spray
Extended Range
Flat Spray
Excellent
Excellent
36
Post-Emergence
Contact
Good
Good
Excellent
Excellent
Very Good
Very Good
Good
Excellent
Excellent
Excellent
Air Induction
Flat Spray
Very Good
Fungicides
Insecticides
Drift Management
Contact
Systemic
Contact
Systemic
Excellent
Good
Excellent
Good
Good
Very Good
Very Good
Very Good
Very Good
Very Good
Good
Excellent
Good
Excellent
Excellent
Excellent
Excellent
Excellent
Excellent
Excellent
Excellent
Excellent
Excellent
Excellent
Very Good
Good
Excellent
Good
Excellent
Excellent
Very Good
Very Good
Very Good
37
Herbicides
Pre-Emergence
Banding
Directed Spraying
Excellent
Good
Excellent
Good
Very Good
Good
Excellent
Good
Excellent
Good
Good
Very Good
Air Induction
Hollow Cone
Mechanical
Air Assisted
Systemic
38
Post-Emergence
Contact
Good
Excellent
Excellent
Good
Excellent
Excellent
Good
Fungicides
Insecticides
Contact
Systemic
Contact
Systemic
Good
Excellent
Good
Excellent
Very Good
Good
Very Good
Good
Excellent
Excellent
Good
Excellent
Good
Excellent
Good
Good
Good
Good
Very Good
Good
Very Good
Excellent
Excellent
Good
Excellent
Excellent
Good
Excellent
Good
Excellent
Excellent
Good
Excellent
Good
Air Induction
Hollow Cone Spray
39
SECTION
C O N S U LT
T H E
FIVE
E X P E R T S
a tremendous amount of
actionable information. Its goal is to educate you and guide you through the spray
nozzle selection process so you make the best decision possible. However, the
process is complex because there are so many variables. It is recommended you
consult with spray nozzle experts for assistance during the selection process to
validate your decision.
Local resources
University and county extensions are always willing to help. Tap into their
personnel and request recent publications on spraying equipment. These
agencies have no manufacturer bias.
Third-party research
Broaden the scope of your knowledge. There are several respected
researchers in the field that publish technical data on a regular basis.
Ask your local university extension for additional information or consider
researching on the Internet. http://www.asabe.org has a variety of helpful
articles available.
40
Government sources
State agricultural departments as well national and international departments
shouldnt be overlooked. Below is a list of a few of the many additional
institutions who all have information to share.
The Spray Drift Task Force (http://www.agdrift.com/)
The Environmental Protection Agency (http://www.epa.gov/)
The United States Department of Agriculture (http://www.usda.gov/)
41
S E C T I O N S I X
MAKING MAINTENANCE A PRIORITY
42
FIGURE 14:
An inside look at nozzle orifice wear and damage.
New nozzle (top), worn nozzle (middle) and damaged nozzle (bottom).
43
If you feel your spray nozzles are wearing quickly, consider upgrading
to longer wearing materials.
P
rior to replacing spray nozzles due to wear, it is critical to keep them
in good working order. Variations in spray distribution, droplet size or
flow rate can reduce the effectiveness of the application.
It is important to clean clogged spray nozzles properly. Use a softbristled brush or compressed air for cleaning. Do not use metal objects
under any circumstances.
Use extreme care with softer tip materials such as plastic.
B
e sure to use adequate filtration and properly sized strainers
to minimize clogging.
44
FIGURE 15:
The Coefficient of Variation
45
SECTION SEVEN
S P R A Y E R
C A L I B R A T I O N
ENSURES OPTIMAL PERFORMANCE
but you
need to calibrate your sprayer. The time investment is well worth it as it can help
you avoid a re-spray.
46
Speed
MPH
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
8.5
9.0
100 ft
200 ft
300 ft
68
45
34
27
23
19
17
15
14
136
91
68
55
45
39
34
30
27
25
23
21
19
18
17
16
15
205
136
102
82
68
58
51
45
41
37
34
31
29
27
26
24
23
Speed
km/h
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
16
18
20
25
30
35
40
30 m
60 m
90 m
22
18
15
14
43
36
31
27
24
22
20
18
17
15
14
65
54
46
41
36
32
29
27
25
23
20
18
16
13
120 m
86
72
62
54
48
43
39
36
33
31
27
24
22
17
14
12
11
FIGURE 16:
Speeds
Speed (MPH) =
Speed (km/h) =
Distance (ft) x 60
Time (s) x 88
Distance (m) x 3.6
Time (s)
FIGURE 17:
Calculate Speeds
47
48
GPA x MPH x W
GPM =
5,940
l/min =
l/ha x km/h x W
60,000
49
50
FIGURE 19:
Formulas for Broadcast or Banding
51
SECTION EIGHT
F U T U R E T R E N D S I N S P R AY I N G
AND NOZZLE TECHNOLOGY
52
Category
Extremely Fine
Very Fine
Fine
Medium
Coarse
Very Coarse
Extremely Coarse
Ultra Coarse
Symbol
Color
Code
XF
VF
F
M
C
VC
XC
UC
FIGURE 20:
Droplet Size Categories
FIGURE 21:
Droplet Size Monitor
53
FIGURE 22:
Individual Tip Flow Meter
54
75%
ON
Duty Cycle
OFF
50%
ON
Duty Cycle
OFF
25%
ON
Duty Cycle
OFF
FIGURE 23:
PWM Duty Cycle
FIGURE 24:
PWM Equipped Nozzle Body
55
Mobile Apps
A wide range of mobile apps related to spraying are available today. Consult your
app store regularly to see what new, and often times free, tools are available.
56
Parting Thoughts.
As you can
LI-TJ178
All rights reserved. Full protection of law claimed
under Universal Copyright and Berne Conventions
and other applicable national and international laws.
Printed in USA. 2013, TeeJet Technologies.
www.teejet.com